CNN

excuse me I mistakenly thought I was commenting on Peter Sparks remarks, and so I retract the statement above.

the neofascist always tried to shoot the messenger, congressman you should not have apologize for speaking the truth.

Just wanted to mention, I admire the CNN for its Freedom Of Speech on its website. Trying to write any Critical Israeli Policy Comment on the German Newspaper (www.spiegel.de, or http://www.focus.de) is impossible. They will not publish it. However you find alot of racist anti arab, and extremly anti Islamic comments published. I just wonder if you can actually sue those papers for racism.

CNN stands for censorship. Thank you for deleting my comments posted yesterday. This further shows why blogs are the best source for news.

I agree with Moran

I was very disappointed to see Jim Moran publically telling the truth. As we all know, American civilisation is predicatd upon the importance of lying; if public figures begin telling the truth we might have to stop going around the world butchering people – our very raison d'etre.

Bravo Jim Moran, and mucho kudos for your courage and spirit of integrity!

Everybody already know that. So, no comment.

S.B. Stein E.B. NJ : September 20, 2007 9:24 am wrote: "Israel is the only true democracy in the Middle East".

Some democracy. Israel allows ethnic Jews to freely emigrate to Israel, but won't allow non-Jews to return to the homes they had before 1948 and 1967. Israel is a racist state that practices ethnic cleansing and continues to steal Palestinian land.

People are over-doing and over-stating AIPAC as the only reason for the Iraq war. I believe that AIPAC had a role in pushing for Iraq war, but people don't understand above all it's economic interests and the ultimate reason OIL. Then you have Arms Manufacturers who are benefitting from this war and the "War on Terror" fiasco. It's like this, if you push one country to buy arms, then you have the neighbouring country trying to compete with each other and there by having an arms race. This has been going on for decades now, when poor countries need to be concentrating on improving the situation for it's masses, it's pumping massive amounts into buying arms.

If people want a full stop to all of this undue influence of lobbyists, there needs to be public financing of the campanigns. Untill that day comes, we are going to see more wars, misery, violence etc perpetrated against innocents across the globe.

For those that believe that the U.S. went to fight in Iraq for Israel, you have no basis. The countries that I see provide the most worry/cause for concern to Israel are Iran, Syria and possibly Saudi Arabia.

AIPAC is an organization that lobbies the Congress on issues related to Israel. Both Jews and Christian (I am sure that there other are involved) work within the group. As was mentioned by other people, there are other lobbing groups. Frankly, I thought that it could have been either AARP or the NRA that could have been labeled the most powerful lobbing group on the Hill. One of the reasons why AIPAC has been seen to be supporting the war was that the attitude the Bush administration had (has) is that you are with or against us with little if any middle ground. It was seen as better to be connected than on the outside at the beginning of the Bush administration since the Republicans controlled Congress.

There are several reasons, now and then, that the US supports Israel. One is that Israel is the only true democracy in the Middle East. I don't consider Turkey a part of the Middle East. There is also an independant judiciary that enforces the rule of law including freedom of speech. How many Arab/Muslim countries have that? During the Cold War when the Arabs were receiving aid from the Soviet Union, Israel was the counter point. Israel has also been a source for technological advancement that has benefited the US as well as Israel. These are some of the reasons why the US supports Israel.

Ask yourself this, why do (most if not all) the Arab countries that surround Israel refuse to accept's right to exist? What have the Arab countries done for the Palestinian Arabs living in their country as well as the West Bank and Gaza? Refugee camps and weapons to make suicide bombers? Is this constructive?

Zionism gives a bad name to Jews AND TO EVERYONE ELSE!

The orginal CNN posting on this topic contains the following regarding AIPAC: "A spokesman for Moran told CNN Tuesday, "It is not the Jewish people, but an organization aligned with the Bush Administration… that he critiqued."

AIPAC is aligned with the Bush administration??? AIPAC stays close to both parties–that way AIPAC is never out of favor and always able to influence. For example, go do an Internet search on "Pelosi" and "AIPAC".

Glad that Waxman shows exactly which country he is loyal to, and his respect for the First Amendment. I used to have much admiration for Henry: NO MORE.

Thanks for the clarification,, Congressman Waxman.

The Jewish lobby, Aipac, is the largest lobbying organization in this country. They control congress, press and act in the interest of Israel only, not the United States. This nothing more than legalized bribary. Why is it that each political figure must please AIPAC if they were not so influential. Can you imaging if an Arabic lobby had the same influence as AIPAC. Wow that would be considered terrorism. I say to all Americans, you lost your country to a small group of dual citizens, warmongers profiteers. Were else in the world do you have so many people running your country with dual nationality Israeli and American. If they were truly American they should renounce their Israeli nationality. They should all be tried for treason.

God forbid that ANYone have an opinion on AIPAC, et al, that does not include lying prostrate at their feet, groveling, and taking whatever they dish out.

To even question whether AIPAC exerts an undue influence on the direction of United States foreign policy earns one a quick and unsubtle slam as an "anti-Semite."

Personally, I'm tired of being Israel's bully-boy in the Middle-East and around the world.

Does Israel exert too much influence on American policy? Yes, yes and yes.
Guess I'll now be attacked as anti-Israel, anti-Jewish and whatever else these people feel like saying.

Par for the course.

The Israel lobby plunged us into war with Iraq and they'll do everything in their power to plunge us into war with Iran. Israel wants America to weaken the Arab countries for Israel's security. By fighting in the Middle East we're effect protecting Israel. America should stop acting like Israel's b**ch. Wake-up and see how much of America is controlled by Jews.

Never has such an economic and geographically insignificant country had such a powerful influence over American policies as Israel does through its agent, AIPAC. Moran is right and the rest are just lining up of some AIPAC cash.

Sad but true: this incident wouldn't have become a typical "anti-semitic" news if it was said by some Israeli politician. Even Israeli citizens are free to criticize such orgnizations and not be labeled anti-semites!

You are missing too many facts in this case. Look at people like Larry Franklin, where he worked, who he worked with, who he had access to, what he was charged with and maybe the whole picture will come into view.

I wonder what these same bloggers would have been saying had it not been the Democrat, but Republican congressman that uttered these comments. ... I can only guess.

The article posted by CNN includes the following:

"A spokesman for Moran told CNN Tuesday, "It is not the Jewish people, but an organization aligned with the Bush Administration… that he critiqued."

AIPAC is aligned with the Bush Administration??? Oh really? AIPAC is smart enough to stay close to both parties–this way Israeli interests will never be out of favor.

Nancy Pelosi is close friends with Amy Friedkin, a former AIPAC president. There is a soccer field in Israel named after Pelosi's father.

AIPAC was implicated in trying to get Jane Harman (D-CA-Jewish) appointed as chair of the House Intelligence Committee.

And I could go on.

Moran's lame attempt to backpedal only proves that AIPAC wields undue influence over U.S. politicians.

Congressman Moran is a hateful racist. I hope to see him punished for his hate speech just like Don Imus. It's only fair, right?

Isreal is hated because the oppression islamic fundamentalist regimes need a scapegoat and someone to deflect there oppression and poverty onto, and once again it's the jewish state.

Oh right. It has absolutely NOTHING to do with the formation of Israel and displacing millions of Palestinians, right?

It's like saying they hate us for our freedoms. A teenager in Syria doesn't give a damn about our freedoms or Israel's wealth; he might give a damn if we're bombing his neighborhood or Israel is sending tanks into Palestine.

Seriously, would you blow yourself up over petty jealousy? "Israelis have better TVs, I can't live with that!" Or maybe it's, "Israelis just killed [X] people, someone has to do something about that!"

Cong Moran is 100 percent correct. The $120K hoyer has received from AIPAC talks quite loudly as well.

Of course he's facing heat.

He's facing heat from AIPAC.

I don't understand why everyone thinks AIPAC is only composed of Jews. True, they are the majority in the group, but I am Christian and I am proud to say that I have lobbied with AIPAC twice, along with a good number of other Christians. It seems to me that this board has just become a forum for people expressing their latent anti-Semitism. It really is disgusting. We are all God's creatures.

I'd be concerned if a PAC has any kind of influence over the president in making a decision to enter into any kind of military conflict. I'd be even more concerned if $$$ was paid to any of our lawmakers and foreign policy leaders that would influence the president's decision to go for it. There's no amount of money that could replace the precious lives of the brave men and women who valiantly served this country and gave their lives believing they were securing the "freedom and safety" of U. S. citizens.......very troubling indeed.

Moran's assertions, if true, only sheds more light on how business is conducted in Washington and how badly we are in need of a serious change and desparately need people to serve this country in a decent and honorable manner for the benefit of all our citizens....not just a privileged few. That's not "liberal" or "conservative" thinking.....that's just right thinking. When will we ever get this thing right?

The Cleveland Indians just swept the Detroit Tigers. How come Jews, Cleveland being a notorious Jewish town, don't get any credit for this, because from reading these posts it seems people actually believe Jews hold ALL the power in the U.S. Seriously though, United States needs Israel because it's the only true ally US has in the middle east. And for all you folk that truly believe we should just leave the middle east alone, then I suggest moving to Greenland because there is no way that a huge power like US can not be involved. And for the poster who commented that all the jews were for the war, let me tell you my whole family (even relatives in Texas) have been democrats and against the war...and we are jewish. Scary scary world!

I've read most of the comments but still no one has explained how or why AIPAC would want to push the US to war. They seem to be content to just shout out that the US government is in the hands of AIPAC, case closed.

I am shocked and a little disheartened with the number of people expressing such a viewpoint on this web site.

One thing I don't understand about the entire conspiracy theory: Aren't there limits to how much one lobby can give a particular candidate? Therefore, how influential can they really be? Maybe I'm ignorant.

Don't give me that:
"Oh, it's the old canard of Jewish power" (aktually no, zionist power):
it looks like duck, walks like a duck, quacks like a duck but hey, don't dare calling it a duck. That is anti-semitic! Puh-leeze...

Because the AIPAC and others retort with accusations of antisemitism should not mean the rest of use should turn a blind eye to what is possible in today's world. The media reports what it wants to and politicians are like most people, opportunists.

Finally, someone with the guts to tell the truth. It is about time and I command him for it. America needs to take back it's foreign policy from interest groups such as AIPAC and others.

David B. from Northern VA: your reaction is typical of all of you who are quick to label as "anti-semitic" anyone whose opinions happen to differ from Jewish organizations, people, or the State of Israel.

I, like most Americans, oppose the war in Iraq, and don´t like to be called "anti-American" for doing so. Get it?

Moran is a patriotic American! This is an issue that we need to be talking about as a country.

AIPAC is not a lobby for Israel as originally intended....a Jewish homeland...but what Israel has become....a Zionist provocateur in the Middle East. Many Orthodox Jews say exactly that, and even held a huge rally in New York to make their point clearly visible. So are they "anti-Semitic" or just people honoring the core of their Jewish faith?

It is good to see that the folks from CAMERA are here. CAMERA.ORG is an organization dedicated to ensuring that American media is roundly punished for saying anything truthful about the influence of right wing Israeli groups in our politics.

AIPAC is a symptom of the Israeli-defense complex in the US. We send billions to "defenseless" Israel for weapons, they buy weapons from our defense industry, and the defense industry spends money to reelect congresspeople who vote to send billions to "defenseless" Israel.

It has nothing to do with religion or ethnicity. Israel is just a handy excuse to keep the cycle going, and war is a handy way of ridding the customer of excess inventory.

If you dispute the influence of AIPAC in the media, look at Wolf Blitzer's previous job. He was a paid lobbiest for AIPAC, and is now a top correspondent at CNN. When I first heard this, I thought that it was just some antisemetic ranting but it is in fact true.

AIPAC does not control everything in politics, but to deny that it is incredibly influential is just as delusional as asserting that we are winning the Iraq war.

What's all the fuss about? So Israel wants to sink Iraq into the desert - that's an undeniable fact, so my question is: What's wrong with it and talking about it?

Theirs no doubt the Jewish activist group AIPAC, supported the invasion of Iraq. The group's primary concearn is the well being of Isreal. AIPAC is free to push for what ever they want. The problem is our incumbent politicians, whom are afraid to standup to anyone who produces money. AIPAC will spend money freely against any incumbent politician who does not support AIPAC's positions. As a result no one speaks against them for fear of a backlash such as this. AIPAC scares the daylights out of incumbent Republicans and Democrats alike. As we all know the problem is not AIPAC, the problem is an incumbent government fearful to take any position which may endanger it's re-election. I personally applaud Rep. Jim Moran, D-Virginia, for speaking up.

Attention conspiracy believers:

Why no uproar over the incredible influence the oil or pharma lobbies have?

These and other similar corporate interest groups exert FAR MORE influence with far more impact to the average American, yet no one seems to worked up about them?

That's why the rest of us believe that you're biased, because you single out a specific group that really doesn't even rank in the real world of beltway influence pending.

It's not anti-Semitic to be anti-AIPAC or any other lobbying group. However, it is anti-Semitic to do as so many comments have done (and as Moran explicitly did NOT do) to leap from AIPAC to old chestnuts like the US is fighting Israel, Israel is the 51st state, and Jews control the government and determine its policy. (over 70% of Jews voted Democrat in the last election, by the way, so much for Jewish control!).

Rep. Moran is to be commended for speaking truth to power, namely the powerful Zionist lobby AIPAC.

The report misstates the issue when – in the headline – it says he is taking heat for comments on the "Jewish Lobby." Rather, it was the American Israel Public Affairs Committee he was taking on. He wasn't taking on Jews – heck, he was writing in Tikkun, which is a Jewish magazine, as noted, and a leading voice in the interfaith peace movement.

Ok Obama, tell us the truth.

Tell us about the billions wasted off budget. Tell us about the true deficit. Tell us why Democrats won't even discuss Social Security and Medicare and the huge tax increases our children face . Tell us that tax revenues are at record highs and that tax cuts work. Tell us that spending is the real reason behind deficits.

Tell the Iowa farmers that the farm bill is a colossul waste of billions of dollars on unrelated pork. Tell us why the highway bill will fund a museum in Las Vegas but not repair bridges.

Yeah right Obama, tell us the truth. But, I'll guess your version of truth will be alot different from mine!

This is disgusting. 70% of the public backs the initiative to go to war. They get war weary. 30% still support the war according to polls. Then we start scapegoating parties, races, nations, anything in our way rather than blaming ourselves?

And the racism...seriously with that much white hair you would think he'd have grown up by now.

I find it sad that so many Americans have NO CLUE what is going on in the middle east. Israel is a toothpick on a pizza. The pizza are muslim countries that have very little wealth and very high amounts of hate and oppression towards wester societies (AMERICA and EUROPE). The toothpick (Israel) is less than 1% of the middle east and has high wealth and high liberalism. Isreal is hated because the oppression islamic fundamentalist regimes need a scapegoat and someone to deflect there oppression and poverty onto, and once again it's the jewish state. Can you blame Israel for being armed to the hilt? I don't. They are not threatening anyone. Iran is threatening. Please people, learn a little before speaking. Any yes, this guy is an idiot. AIPAC is only a factor in the Iraq war. Ofcourse, scapegoating jews is what the world does, and apparently many americans are too uneducated and small sighted to see the hate that 99% of the middle east has towards them.

This congressman is using an age old tactic which is deeply rooted in antisemitism. When in doubt, why not blame the Jews?

Hiding behind charges of "anti-Semitism" is getting old when it comes to addressing the overdue influence of this lobby on U.S. policy, akin to playing the race card. Israel owes its existence to the U.S. and depends on us for its continued defiance of UN Resolution 242, which is a prime fuel for ongoing Middle East discord and helped set the stage for 9-11. The prevalence of Jewish surnames in government and business makes clear that this is not a helpless, trod-upon minority but a major director of the U.S. economy and power structure now profiting wildly from the Iraq war. Moran told the obvious truth and gets labelled anti-Semetic....if someone calls Hillary down does that make them a misogynist?

100% if Moran on this one because its a fact

Apparently this topic has released a "surge" of closet anti-semites as I knew it would.

Obviously, most of you are ignorant of the history of Israel. It's not only the Holocaust, it's 2000 years of persecution. Israel is surrounded by hundreds of millions of Arabs (and Iranians) who would be happy to see the Jews wiped off the face of the earth. Israel was created so the Jews don't have to put up with all the crap they've been putting up with all those years. And the world can't stand it.

There is condemnation and boycotts of Israel but it's funny that countries like Sudan, Cambodia and Rwanda can get away with genocide and the world does blink twice.

Jews (and Christians for that matter) don't walk into pizza places and discos and blow themselves up killing innocent people.

The US supports Israel because it's a democratic country in a sea of 12th dictatorships and monarchies. And because it's close to the oil.

Does AIPAC exert influence on the US government? Of course they do. Just like any other PAC. But wait. It's the Jews. They shouldn't have so much influence. They run the government, banks, commerce, THE WHOLE WORLD.

Was AIPAC in favor of invading Iraq? Probably but then so was the majority of the American people.

Jews have been instrumental in civil rights, fair labor practices and charities.

I personally don't like what's going on in Israel but it take two to tango. Terrorist Hamas and the corrupt Palestinian authority are responsible for the suffering of the Palestinian people a whole lot more than the Jews.

And to all you people who have used this issue to spout your ignorance, find out the facts before you babble.

It is infuriating to me how such sway is held over politicians who would so much as dare criticize the role of AIPAC. The threat looms large- perhaps the worst punishment being termed an "anti-semite". This is entirely unfair. Fortunately, as these posts are evidence, free speech exists and the type of intimidation practiced on our politicians isn't all-powerful.

1. concerning some of the comments here, I'd say they prove We don't control all the media. not yet anyway.

2. Sheesh... You nail a guy to a piece of wood and 2000 years later people still hold a grudge. get over it already.

Tina, you say "These people are so greedy – they are all in it for the oil, for power, it has nothing to do with terrorism" Yes, Israel has taken over all the oil territory of the countries around them. Greedy, oh yes. Dork, you live in Chicago. Has Chicago ever had a Jewish mayor? Do they have a name that pops up everytime something anti-Jewish is said. Who is the head of the Church in this area. Name a Black Leader. Name leaders in general. They are part of the culture here...and they are not usually involved in riots, name calling or fights. So shut up and don't buy their wares or from their business. If you don't get along with your husbands family, one can easily see why.

This is absolutely ludicrous. Steny Hoyer should be stripped of his leadership position.

such stupid statements. AIPAC did not push nor support the war. If I recall they would prefer getting rid of Iran, if anything. Most of all they'd like to be left alone. Since its inception their neighbors have sought to destroy the place, in spite of it having UN backing. Blaming Israel is like blaming Jews for all the hate they received in Europe years ago. This is not one sided...how come nobody is screaming about the rocket attacks from Gaza. How about the concept of a nation electing a party because they promise to remove a country from this earth? How about the anti-America propaganda from the Islamic terror factor. Come on...why aren't the Islamic countries helping Gaza. This man is being used and letting it happen. Hate the bad Jews.

Hey Norfolk,Va:

Israel receives over half of all of the U.S.' "foreign aid". How can you say that "Even that much is considered too much by an Israeli populace that feels constrained by American interests"?

I lived in Palestine for over a year, and Israelis were constantly laughing at me, telling me that it didn't do any good for an American like me to try to help Palestinians because Americans will continue to send all the money to Israel. They brag about how much money and military aid the stupid Americans are giving them, and they are confident the gravy train is not going to stop any time soon.

I was in Palestine when Katrina hit New Orleans. Palestinians were horrified, watching the news coverage and seeing all of the stranded people in New Orleans. They all asked me if I had family or friends there and expressed their concern for their suffering.

The Israeli reaction? To demand that the U.S. send them "their" 1.7 billion dollars in "disengagement aid" immediately, so that it didn't end up going to those folks in New Orleans instead. Meanwhile, Israeli newspapers were running ads, encouraging Israelis to send money to only help Jewish victims of Katrina.

Constrained? They are laughing at us.

The Lawrence Franklin espionage scandal (also known as the AIPAC espionage scandal) refers to allegations that information regarding United States policy towards Iran was passed to Israel through Lawrence Franklin via staffers affiliated with the American Israel Public Affairs Committee. Franklin, a former Defense Department employee, has pleaded guilty to several espionage-related charges and was sentenced in January 2006 to nearly thirteen years of prison. Two former AIPAC employees have also been indicted.

As a Jew, I've heard similar anti- semitic remarks all my life; Jews controll the US economy/Hollywood/ Media/Govt/UN/world currency markets, etc. etc. What this slimy politician fails to admit is EVERYONE's trying to buy & influence US policy All The Time & Why? Because slimy politicians like him have been whoring out our goverment for years! If anybody pushed Bush into invading Iraq, it was Cheney & his mystery mutinational sponsors like Haliburton (who've cleaned up Billions)! & No! Haliburton isn't controlled by us Jews either! I challenge CNN.com (who's also not controlled by us Jews) to post this!

I am one of the most liberal people you could meet, strongly anti-racist, pro-women's rights, I'm not against illegal immigrants, etc. etc.

I don't have anything against (or for) Jewish people. They don't evoke any strong emotions in me at all. Regarding Isreal, now that they have ceded land for the formation of a Palestinean State, I'm cautiously supportive of Israel.

But I recognize that special interest groups and political action committees (PAC's) wield undue influence over our politicians. AIPAC is one of them, and their history is clearly pro-Israeli.

I don't think Israel controls the US government. But does Israel wield some degree of influence over our politicians via AIPAC? It seems obvious.

Is that a good thing?

I don't think so. I don't like it when gun lobbyists and Big Oil use their PAC's and lobbyists to funnel cash to their pet politicians. But at least they aren't at the beck and call of a foreign nation.

Domestic PAC's are bad; how much worse, foreign PAC's?

http://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn/A63578-2003Mar31?language=printer

For those of you who are new to politics, US foreign policy in the middle east is dictated by Israel. Check out whatreallyhappened dot com.

Labeling people antisemitic because they criticize the government of Israel and those who support everything Israel does is a despicable and morally indefensible tactic. Call me an antisemite if you wish to–it will be a filthy lie–but I will say what is obvious to anyone who cares to look at reality honestly. Israel's government has acted, on many occasions, irresponsibly. I and many others who are sympathetic to Israel, believe that those actions have not been in the best interests of Israel or anyone else. The Israeli people and government have, understanably, developed a bunker mentality that does not promote sound policymaking. Unqualified support for Israel's extreme actions, such as the attacks on Lebanon, does not serve Israel's best interests and have injured US interests.

I believe the West, including the US, owes support to Israel. A millennium of antisemitic persecution mandates such support. That does not equal unqualified support for Israeli policies when such policies, in the judgment of the West, are wrongheaded and counterproductive.

RE: B ny ny

The American people have a right to know the TRUTH!!!!!
Read and understand the facts…24 Billion Dollars being sent to Israel daily!!!!

I love emotional do-gooders! Always using terms like TRUTH and facts, get educated, read and understand.

Every argument is presented in this manner, ...the facts are!...

According to federalbudget.com the national debt is currently 8.9 trillion dollars. (Nothing to be proud of, that's for sure!) But according to B above, we could wipe that out in nearly a year(8.76 trillion) by suspending the 24 billion PER DAY that we send to Israel. The 8.76T is MORE than our combined federal budget of 2006 which includes foreign aid. For a country of just over 7 million (Israel), that works out to 1.2 million dollars per person. Wow, we probably could afford Universal healthcare for that kinda cash! A chicken in every pot, hell, some pot in every chicken.

All I'm saying is, be very wary of those who are incredibly enthusiastic to share the TRUTH with you where politics is concerned.

Steny..thats jewish isn't it...!? How many of the "lawmakers" and top administration officials are dual American-Jewish citizens...? Lieberman, Abramoff, Pearle, Kristol in the media..? In the Congress..? How many of our lawmakers are lobbied by AIPAC..and given campaign funds from AIPAC..? Who is pushing for a war with Iran..using the U.S. troops and resources (even while we send them billions in foriegn aide)..Israel...of course Israel's double agents are running this country..using our wealth and our soldiers like a great big attack dog for their benefit...some of us are not stupid or Jewish

AIPAC is being called out here NOT the JEWish people, I am a Jew and am against this lobby!!...people wake up!! The congressman is totally correct on his point. This lobby has too much power and must be stopped

MORAN COULD NOT BE MORE CORRECT!!!!!!!!!!

ALLISON WIGGINS

I don't know whether this man is anti-semitic. He does appear to be rather foolish, as he caused a big uproar the last time he brought this up, yet he brought it up again. However, isn't it true that a large number of Jewish people, and even the Jewish government, were in favor of the war? I mean, it was in Israel's interest to get rid of Saddam Hussein, who attacked Israel verbally and with SCUDS on more than one occasion. I don't think those interest groups control our government, but it's believable that they were one voice being heard.

Side note...its 16 million dollars daily, not 24 billion...its somewhere around there per year, none the less absolutely rediculous. To say it is anti-semetic is absolutely ignorant. Eunice, my friend, you have just made several arguments more clear that Bush went to war for oil, the media is controlled by a select few who can manipulate our minds. (the dancing in the street was actually from another event that was replayed on 9/11 to rally support for invasion) also if saddam posed as such a threat when really hes not...well i guess we could make the point that he already won the war when we played into his game. Congratulations to the media as well, take CNN for example, articles about this Palestinian/Israeli conflict are entirely biased towards Israel when ISRAEL is invading and ISRAEL is killing the Palestinians...and the Palestinians are trying to defend themselves during this oppression. Its sad America is so blind to this murder

We fought this terrible war for two main reasons: 1. Israel, 2. Oil, we wasted more than half a trillion dollars of our taxes for this losing cause and more importantly we lost 4000 of our finest. was it worth it? I think not, Its time to punish AIPAC for there crimes against our country. Bring back our troops and stop our blind support for Israel NOW!!!!

We're becoming a nation of idiots – "Obama is too white", "The Jews Made Us Do It". GWB had this on his agenda from his father's administration. 9/11 was the excuse, not the cause.

To think otherwise rational people could be "made" to support the war by a lobbying organization, regardless of its premise, is ludicrous.

Why would we not meet with the Israeli government prior to an invasion? Unlike Panama, Grenada, or other housecleaning invasions, here we only had one regional ally – and by the way – only one regional ally with atomic weapons. Pull the plug on Israel and you imperil not only the Middle East, but Europe and Asia as well.

Bravo! At last, someone with the balls to speak the truth.

Great Marketing: Way to push the Book

I mean, would anyone here, ANYONE AT ALL, have heard of this book without this emotionally jarring, highly volatile statement that warrants front page attention?

Go ahead read the book – whatever – I'm sure its useful, if not completely accurate – but see this coverage for what it is: a marketing tool to push a book. NOT an intriguing expose on politics or a brave soul saying "what everyone knows." I'm in PR, so I can say this.

Rile people up with catchy, engrossing headlines, and they'll click on the story – GUARANTEED.

Enjoy the book.

The response from some of these bleeding heart pro Israels is so typical and down right hilarious. Now who is really a racist, who are you trying to kid. LOL

Enough is enough, our arrogance is in direct response to your arrogance.

The truth of the matter is, everybody knows the horrors of WW2 on your people, and yes there is sympathy. So you can stop using that as an excuse.
But 60 years later your continued hatrid and treatment of the Palestinian people has to change.

The fact is, until the Palestinian people get a real homeland (1 country), nothing will change, but only get worse. And that is the arrogance of Israel – I know not one of you pro Israel folks could even utter those words.

As a Jew by birth and practice, I often find myself sorting out these firefights on line, even within my own family. As a believer in peace and dialogue.

First, I am not offended by Moran's remarks. I have long despaired of the malign influence of AIPAC on foreign policy decisions made in the region, as much as I have despaired of the of the growing intermingling of Israeli strategic priorities (survival) and Bush strategic priorities (oil, profit, and control in the region). I don't believe they overlap very well, but AIPAC does.

In my daily life, I find that Jews of conscience support Israel, but have been able to separate that support from the idea that whatever Israel does is fine. Many American Jews were appalled that Ariel Sharon, who allowed, encouraged the genocide of Palestinians in the refugee camps to occur, was ever permitted to participate in the government. There is nothing anti-semitic about that sentiment; in fact, it is the ultimate pro-semitic position to take.

What the message many Diasporan Jews took from WWII was "Never Again". This was expressed two ways; the hypermilitancy of Israel, a Jewish homeland, necessary to defend and defend itself again from groups expressly committed to destroying it– and the belief that we will never allow genocide to be used as a weapon of war again, be it Darfur, Serbia, Palestein, or Iran.

Moran comments on the strategic alignment of Israeli and United States regional goals around the policy goals of the Bush administration; AIPAC, already convicted of passing classified information out of the United States, is the visible arm of the American movement that supports Israel, regardless of the stubborn ineffectiveness of it's policies towards Palestinians; Mr. Moran more closely reflect the views of many American Jews who are fearful of Israel and the United States finding ways to manipulate each other to accomplish strategic regional goals that are morally vacuous and poorly considered.

That is blindness. Moran lacks elegance, but he speaks a truth here that resonates with this Jew; not because I am self-loathing, but because my upbringing as a Jew requires me to consider justice and not expediency as part of every decision I make as a person and a Jew.

Being critical of someones actions and beliefs does not constitute racism or anti-sentitism. Anytime anyone questions the motives of the Jewish lobby they are immediately condemd as such. I have much respect for this guy for stating fact at what will likely be his own expense. It is time we stopped playing stupid, stop submitting to our guilt complex regarding Jews and call them out for what has become common knowledge – that they are deeply rooted in US foreign policy. It's shamefull on our part to allow our elected officials to kowtow to Isreal. Intolerable comes to mind as well. Call me antisematic if you like, but let it be known, I do not hate Jews.

If you search/Google "aipac cufi" you will find that Christians and Jews want to bring about war in Iraq to speed up the second coming of Christ. When these two groups work together, they are an influential group that gets their agenda addressed because few lawmakers want to infuriate the Christian Right. I think Moran is pushing a deeper agenda into the public spotlight by exposing the groups AIPAC and although still in the background, CUFI.

So it has come down to lobbyist to run the country. How shameful, that we have to hide behind CNN “write your comments” to voice our opinion or thoughts that has nothing to do with anti-Semitisms in the first place. Flashback: March 2002 – We didn’t find any WMD in Iraq and need little more time to search the whole country –IAEA. Richard Norman Perle, Paul Dundes Wolfowitz and Douglas Feith pushed so much for the Iraq War that anytime given to Saddam would be have been unacceptable to them. If you look at their affiliation to different groups you will see it yourself where do they stand. I don’t have to convince the audience, everything is on the internet for you to read and educate yourself.

B,

"Read and understand the facts…24 Billion Dollars being sent to Israel daily!!!!"

I don't even know if it's worth giving you the facts, but the US does not send 24 billions dollars daily. In FACT, they send 1/8 of that a year. Even that much is considered too much by an Israeli populace that feels constrained by American interests.

Whether or not Moran is being anti-Semitic, anti-Semitism is on the rise all over the world. In light of the fact that the media have done so much to bring that about, do you really think that the Jews control the media and government?

I support Jim Moran 100 percent. I believe that if we as Americans free ourselves of this burden Israel than "Terrorism" will be defeated.

How is this any different than saying South Florida unduly influences our Cuban policy? I can't say whether these views are influenced by anti-Semitism, but it is concerning that whenever someone criticizes a lobby, be it Cuban-Americans over Cuban relations or Hispanic-Americans over immigration, the cry of racism is immediately and harshly brought down upon the heads of those who dare utter opposition. Usually, the phrase 'they doth protest too much, methinks' applies when aggressive, self-indignation is on display.

While America is Israel's oldest and truest ally, it is my feeling that our ally holds too much sway over American foreign policy.

This is a topic that is wholly under appreciated! Thank you CNN for covering it! The fact that ANYONE who offers legitimate criricism of groups like AIPAC and the like are labeled 'anti-semitic' is unjust. Study the facts and read your history, These particular groups, that have a pro-Israel agenda, control much more than people realize. They are organized, well-financed, and powerful.

President Carter's book illustrates this point in some detail.

If the Red Sox lose the division to the Yankees, I guarantee it will be the fault of the Jewish Lobby. They have been manipulating the strike zone to favor Yankee hitters. Last time I checked, George Bush started this war. But it's easier to blame Jews. My Jewish friends are mostly anti Iraq war, unlike myself who supports shooting terrorists. Truly, if you want to blame the Jews, blame them for trying to stop this war. But that wouldn't be much of a news story, would it.

He's right. The Zionist Jewish lobbies in this country are pulling all the strings. And they DO run the media, Hollywood, the publishing industry, the fashion industry, and the banking industry. Their sneaky way is to cry "anti-semitism" every time someone catches on to them. There are many leaders in this administration who have dual citizenship as Israelis. Yikes!!!

why is it that it is okay for americans to go settle in Palestinian territory? 20%to 30% of the illegal settlers in the palestinian territory ARE AMERICANS. Does anyone remember when Katrina happened Israel was pulling out of the settlements and the U.S. gov't sent over 2.2 billion dollars to help them with the pullout at the same time there were people dying in the streets of new orleans."Israel is asking the United States for $2.2 billion in additional aid to help pay for its upcoming withdrawal from the Gaza Strip and parts of the West Bank," the Israeli deputy prime minister, Shimon Peres, said Monday.
Why? Once again Israel caused this mess and we have to go to their rescue yet again. This of course didn't get much media attention at the time because of Katrina. So if anyone thinks that the Jewish lobby does not have any influence you are nuts.

bravo for speaking the truth mr. moran...anyone who denies this is either a fool or a coward...

To GS in Allentown:

The U.S. filled an unmarked El Al Boeing 747 cargo conversion with tactical nuclear weapons at Langley AFB, VA, headed for Israel at the beginning of the Yom Kippur War. Who says they don't need the U.S. to fight their (its) wars?

Bush made the call to invade Iraq and say in Iraq. Bush is the "decider" as he puts it - not anyone or any group. If you don't like the war, good - but don't start blaming anyone but the person who is the "decider."

Of course they are! And, it isn't anti-semitic to say so, either, it's just a fact. Since French voters insanely elected Nicolas Sarkozy, a Jewish conservative. Now, they find out that he is a Zionist and is actively pushing for a pre-emptive war with Iraq and Syria becasue of their nuclear programs. The "Jewish Lobby", better termed the "Zionist Lobby", because only a minority of Jews are Zionists, is responsible for "globalization", George W. Bush, and Hillary Clinton, three of the worst thing to ever happen to this country.

So where's Rudy and why isn't he demanding that a Republican apologize for once?

blame bush and those oil rich texans.

Why does anyone who dares to question the actions of Israell immediately get branded anti-semitic? Why must the actions of this one country be beyond criticism? Any intelligent/informed person knows that some of Israels actions are not anything to be proud of. Jimmy Carter got it correct when he said that it was practising aparthied yet he was immediately villified for his comments. The Gaza strip is one huge open prison. Palestinian children die for want of basic services.Poverty is endemic yet this country supports israel without question. It is time to have an open discussion on how far this country should go to support Israel and how many of the UN resolutions and international laws that Israel flouts should be enforced. Only then will we begin to solve the very grievous problem of the Middle East.No doubt I will immediately be branded anti-semitic for saying this but I think the time has come to stand up for very open questioning of our policy towards Israel and its powerful lobby that is at the root of so many injustices in the Middle east.

AIPAC does not represent the fine Jewish people in the USA. It directly represents Israel, and is a foreign lobbying organization. And it is very good at it's job. Our government is controlled by money (just look at how much money is being spent on the various presidential campaigns this year), and we, as Americans, have no one to blame but ourselves for letting money control our government, and the decisions it makes.

Some replies to the above

GS Allentown, PA : September 19, 2007 12:08 pm wrote "If anything, the United States keeps Israel from responding with overwhelming military force."

Of course we do GS! We even pay Israel not to take military action! And Israel knows we will pay. At least in this cases we are smart enough to prevent Israel from drawing us into broader conflict.

Mindy Chatsworth, Ca. : September 19, 2007 11:53 am wrote "My father was part of the American soldiers that liberated the concentration camps of Bergen-Belsen and Dachau..."

I wonder what America's greatest generation would say if they saw how Israel has since abused the Palestinians, stolen Palestinian land, and made Gaza a prison. Mindy, I recommend you take a trip to West Bank and see for yourself how times have changed.

It is shameful that this topic has not been seriously discussed in public. It seems obvious that an organization such as AIPAC would support U.S. intervention in the Middle East. There has been documentation in books such as "Pretext to War" that show how Israel was involved with supplying information that would sell the Iraq War to congress. The U.S. should not fight Israel's battles.

The Senate leadership is all up in arms about Moran's comments in an article about AIPACs advocacy on the Iraq war. It is interesting that the leadership is calling for Moran to retract his statement and say he was inaccurate in his comments. Interestingly enough, the Israeli media backs Moran up.

Here is an article in haaretz, an Israeli newspaper:

http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/836374.html

Moran clearly wasn't the only person to notice this:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn/A63578-2003Mar31?language=printer

This was reported in the Washington Post four years ago!

Here is coverage from overseas in 2005:

http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Middle_East/GE19Ak01.html

This article in March in the Jewish Journal was taken off line TODAY, but is still available in Google Cache and in Internet Archive.

http://209.85.165.104/search?q=cache:F5Y7m1qRfF8J:www.jewishjournal.com/home/preview.php%3Fid%3D17384+aipac+iraq&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=46&gl=us

Is someone trying to suppress the record?

Such an ineresting view on things – war in Iraq was in Israel's interest?
Destabilization in the region is in the interest of the small country, surrounded by much larger enemies on all sides? And oh, btw, by the time we went to Iraq – it was so devastated by the sanctions that it was no threat to anybody – attacking Iran or Syria would be much more beneficial to Israel. Supporting the war and CAUSING the war – is two different things. For those who are still in favor of "Jewish conspiracy" – read "Plan of Attack" by Bob Woodward and see wihch country was consulted about the plans of this disaster (hint – Saudis), look at who profitted from it and whom the first Bush administration consisted of and realize it was oil and ideology that lead to this war, not the "great and all powerfull" Jewish lobby.

How can an American open his mouth wiht an oppinion against AIPAC without being accused of Anti-sematism.
We are Tired and Fedup of being acused of Anti-Sematism whenever we try to open our mouth to defend what the American people believe is right or wrong.

oops, there s a block quote under my name above in error – I meant to criticise someone else's rude comment and didn't get the quote correctly identified and attached to my identification of bigotry.

Moran has a history of weaving back and forth over the line of anti-semitism, even if his most recent rant is cleverly wrapped in a pre-emptive deniability.

It isn't about who, what, or why we are in Iraq. It is about when are we getting out. We are spending too much taxpayer money there and not enough here.

Rep Moran represents the typical uninformed mindset that the Jews are behind all the worls evil. He would make an excellent fascist

Moran's remarks may have been inartful, but does anyone seriously doubt that the Iraq war is primarily about oil and Israel, or that American Jews are indeed well-organized and therefore powerful?

He is correct in saying that AIPAC was supportive of the war. Can someone attack AIPAC and not be called anti-semitic. AIPAC does hold an abusrd amount of sway in this country. So does the NRA. They are well organized. These remarks aren't anti-semitic.

Congressman Moran, do not stop there, Virginians should be proud of this PATRIOT for saying what is the TRUTH.
Has Israel apologized for KILLING so many Lebanese women and children, for dropping cluster bombs-by the way, where did that inquiry end up?? Ask your congressman and senator, or better yet, ask Congressman Moran, he´ll tell you!! Has Israel paid for all the destruction it caused in Lebanon, of course not, the US is, as well as other countries, WHY????? Because they never pay their foreign debt-it is always forgiven. And they are getting $30 billion in arms, why not give it to the poor in THIS COUNTRY OF OURS.
And, then, the US defends its f(r)iend in the Middle East and allow those trigger happy jews to slaughter at their own will and to imposse sanctions on the palestinians also at their own will,WHY???
The idiots are WE who allow this to happen, Congressman Moran, DO NOT APOLOGIZE, you will be reelected and don´t bow to the pressures of that other idiot Hoyer for asking you to do so.
As for the republicans, they are as useless as tits on a bull.

Politics 101

Of course the Jewish Lobby pushed to Invade Iraq. What did you think? They would simply sit back and twiddle their thumbs after the extermination of 6 million men, women and children? Or just close their eyes and hope their enemies would go away? Hardly! They're going to do everything in their power to thwart their enemies including building the nuclear bomb – which they've done. So what's a few Jewish lobbyists in a town filled with lobbyists? Politicians make me laugh – they pretend the AIPAC isn't influential but attending AIPAC functions is practically a right of passage amongst politicians; what's more the AIPAC is quite able to quash legislation whenever Israel's interests are at stake. But what's good for the goose is good for the gander – which is why there are plenty of American lobbyists overseas. Welcome to politics 101 people.

Joe Rankin

Jim Moran is a hero to express what we all know but do not dare to say. Of course AIPAC was behind the catastrophic war with Iraq. That's because AIPAC does not care a bit about America and only cares about Israel. Just like they are now pushing us into a war with Iran. And not only AIPAC also zionist media like foxnews and zionist congressmen like Liebermann. Wake up America! We have a fifth colonne amongst us that only cares for Israel!!

I don't understand how anyone can be against Israel unless they are anti-semetic (and most don't believe they are). You name another country in the world besides the U.S. that does the amount of good that Israel does. And, they are a true best friend to the U.S. AIPAC is one of the finest and smartest organizations there is. All it takes is common sense to figure that out.

You know you're anti-semetic when you are outraged to see a story on Israel sending in a missle to Gaza that might kill an innocent, but it doesn't bother you that Israeli towns have been bombarded with over 200 missles send indiscriminatly at civilian targets from Gaza just since June.

I agree with Moran. He is speaking the truth. AIPAC has Israel's interests at heart Duh! Which does not always follow what is best for the USA. Its amazing to see all the Dems jump on him..kinda pathetic. The attacks on him prove his point.

I'm just amazed that America gives Israel over 5 billion dollars every year for nothing. While people in New Orleans can't get nothing from a government they pay taxes to. People criticize Mexicans and other immigrants but no one ever mentions the Jewish population...are they not immigrants as well? yet they isolate themselves and basically do what they please no questions asked.

If you think his comments are anti-semetic you much be jewish or republican.

I agree with Congressman Moran. It's Likud and Neocon policy which PUSHED us into war by wispering lies into the ear of Bush II. It is the paranoid Israeli Right (not all Israeli's) which bears large responsiblitly for the Quagmire we are now enmeshed in. The other two big players were "the Grand Game/White man's burden crowd" and "Big OIL/Business". Time to leave Iraq to the Iraqi people. Time for foreign occupiers to leave.

If I criticize Jerry Falwell or Jim Bakker or PTL, does that automatically make me anti-christian?

AIPAC is a POLITICAL organization, not a religious organization.

What is wrong with you people who automatically label ANY criticism of AIPAC as "anti-semetic"? This is ridiculous!

I find Mr. Moran's comments to be both accurate and ignorant at the same time. Obviously, public speaking and the thought that goes into it, is not his strong suit. But even more disturbing is the reading of the comments posted here. Anti-Semitism is, sadly, alive and well in the U.S. Not from the Congressman, but from the readers of your web stories.

Finally someone has the balls to speak the truth.

Folks this is not about anti-semitism or Racism. Any time Israel's name is brought up in a negative light, all of a sudden it is equated to Anti-semitism.

The comments were about the Israeli Lobby, and their influence on getting us into Iraq. They are pushing for us to act on Iran as well. The day this country begins to realize that AIPAC and Israel's interts are NOT; ABSOLUTELY NOT; equivalent to America's interests will be a great day in the history of this country.

Get your heads out of the sand peolpe. We are and have been fighting Israel's wars in the MidEast too long. Anti-Israeli is not equivalent to anti-semite. There are many Jew who are not Zionist, and actually oppose the state of Israel.

"Read and understand the facts…24 Billion Dollars being sent to Israel daily!!!!" Posted By B, NY, NY : September 19, 2007 11:58 am

That would be $8 trillion a year, 3 times the total US federal budget. Perhaps you should read and understand the facts (some arithmitic may help too).

Sadly, we are witnessing what happens when cousins marry.

I agree with Mr. Moran 100%. This war was pushed by AIPAC and other prominent Jewish pundits (Kristol). Its about time the truth was spoken, I admire his hutzpah! I am not anti Israel, it just happens to be the truth!!!

Can we please not call it "Jewish lobby?"

AIPAC stands for America-ISRAEL Public Affairs Committee.

As an American Jew, AIPAC doesn't speak for me.
And all polling suggests they don't speak for most American Jews.
http://www.galluppoll.com/content/?ci=26677

(For that matter, I'm not certain they speak for most Israelis...)

I think He's has the Right to voice his thoughts and opinions with responsibilty. This is The United States of America or is it The United States of Isreal in America?

Needless to say this Congressman has stepped over the line and should apologize not only to the Jewish Community but to all his fellow Congressmen and women as well as the people he represents.

It also sounds like the old south bigotry coming out.

I agree with Representative Moran and it irrates me greatly that when you say something like this you are automatically painted as an anti-semetic. Maybe 60 Minutes should do a piece on AIPAC and let us all know more about the organization and then we can all draw our own conclusions about whether or not Representative Moran is right or wrong.

this is what always happens when someone says something that could be interpreted as biased.... rather than assess the comment and use it as a springboard for discussion, the author is immediately discredited and dismissed, even if there is some validity to the point. various lobbies exert great power on the decision making process, and many of those lobbies have influenced domestic and foreign policy. the representative just stated the obvious; now he has to face the consequences for a simple observation
about power, not about a people.

In order to clear up Mr. Sterling's accusation of anti-semitism, anti-Israel and anti-Semitism are comparing apples and oranges. A vast number of the Israeli population are of European descent, not of Semitic ancestry. This is a state issue not an ethnic or religious policy that Mr. Moran is exposing.

I do not understand why there is this myth that Israel needs the United States to fight its wars- other than to be a mask for anti-Jewish sentiment.

If anything, the United States keeps Israel from responding with overwhelming military force. Think of the overwhelming military victories that Israel has had since 1948- the United States cannot say the same.

Israel can take care of itself, they learned the important lesson that nobody cares about the Jews.

What this congressman said is anti-Semitic and it reveals the dark currents underneath the Democratic party.

So, a Democratic congressman joins those spreading the old "blame the Jews" lie (he actually was at it since 2003)! In the context of the war in Irak, this libel is most notoriously being pushed by Profs. Walt & Mearsheimer. It's sad to see that many people are ready to accept this anti-semitic canard, while ignoring the facts: Bush and Cheney were hell-bent in their determination to have this war and get rid of Saddam, regardless of the lack of any evidence of WMD in Irak. They are the decision makers. They made their minds up based on their
wishes to gain control over that oil rich and strategically important country (quite unrealistic wishful thinking, as it turned out). This is where you find the reasons and responsibility for the invasion of Irak – in Bush's and Cheney's grand goals and decisions to pursue them, not in views expressed by some Jewish neo-cons, or in the actually inexistent support of AIPAC.
Quite regardless of these facts, it seems that this anti-semitic libel is gaining momentum; this is why it's important for the Democratic party to stand firmly against it.

Isn't everyone missing the real point here. It is about the powerful lobbying groups who dictate our policies. Whether it is the Religious Right or the AIPAC, as a nation we should not sit by and let the few rule the majority. It is about time more people were not so "politically correct" and think more about the greater good for ALL people.

Wow! It is quite humorous that so many of you concede such power to a group that represents 3% of the population. Do you think that the Christian Right does not influence power in America? What about the AARP? AIPAC may influence the govt., but so does the Insurance Lobby, Pharmaceutical Lobby etc. influence policy too. So many of you believe in conspiracy theories too. Jews do this and jews do that. It is funny. Do you think jews go to meetings on Fridays and talk about which person from Dallas needs to make the World Bank do this or another person from St. Louis make the the American Govt. do that? Oh, I need to go. I need to let my jewish neighbor know to call the Prime Minister of France. I want to get my wine cheaper.

I believe Rep. Moran is speaking the truth. We need to fact the fact that our unconditional support of Israel comes at a cost to many in the Middle East. Palestinians are suffering for what? Why are lawmakers scary of the Isreali? I do not want my taxed dollars to support the Israeli effort in stealing land from the Palestinians and inciting wars in the region. The world need to be united in its effort to bring peace to Palestine!

Nothing like blatant bigotry from the hypocrisy laden party of tolerance to keep things in the right political perspective.

Wake up people the Jewish Mafia is calling some of the shots on K Street and Wall Street shaping our public, foreign, and economic policies. The Jewish community is highly organized and very influential on a global scale.They are integral with American politics. Firmly instep with the far right neoconservative movement. Isarael doesn't have a seperation of church and state, and neither do we. It doesn't take a Washington insider to tell you that fact. Sincereley, Not an anti-semitist

northern va is NOT anti jew..i've lived here my entire life. This is not some hillbilly town. It has so much diversity...one of the most thriving places in america.

Why doesn't Israel just mind their own business for once?! Why the heck do we have to give them billions of dollars?! And for what..to kill Palestinians, take their land, so people in the Mideast could hate us for it?? Just STOP giving them so much money, so people over there won't hate us. If anything, they have the RIGHT to hate us...look at all the horrible things we do to them!

FINALLY, someone has the courage to tell the truth!!! Unfortunately, the good congressman will now be vigorously attacked by the AIPAC jackals. AIPAC is destroying America.

Congressman Moran should not face any heat in regard to his comments. The American people have a right to know the TRUTH!!!!!
Read and understand the facts...24 Billion Dollars being sent to Israel daily!!!! While Americans can't even get proper wages, Healthcare and a sufficient working infrastructure for the 21st Century!!!!!
Shameful to political correctness

NavyBlue wrote: "Rep. Moran is absolutely correct in what he said. And the minute one speaks up and out about the truth of AIPAC you are ridiculed for being a "racist" "anti-Semitic" as a way to silence the person. This is communism. ... The only loyalty AIPAC and their ilk have is to Israeli which is NOT in America's best interest but rather treason against America."

Navy, accusing people of being communists and being traitors is pretty strong language in political debate. This is especially true when it is obvious that you have no idea what Communism is. You certainly don't like being called anti-Semitic by people who have no idea what anti-Semitism is, do you?

Is there a powerful Jewish lobby in Washington, funded by wealthy Jews? I would be amazed if there wasn't. There are powerful lobbies in Washington protecting and promoting every noble and as well as crooked proposal. Does that mean that supporting Israel is communism and treason? Of course not.

On the other hand, are immigrants, Jews, Hispanics, Blacks, Asians, and others quick to spot racism where there is none? Yes they are. Are they also quick to spot racism where racism is really there? Yes they are.

Is a dialog that consists of name calling and false accusations of the suppression of information the kind of dialog in which patriots engage? Especially at the beginning of this grim and unpromising new century? It is not.

I am afraid that some people are painting a broad brush about the whole Jewish community and that should be totally unacceptable. It's our duty to defend each other of all communities. We have Jewish folks like Keith Olberman to other high profile stars that criticize these lobbying groups and their influence. We HAVE TO REMEMBER that no particular country, race, religion is the problem, but a small part of each and every community that want to control the rest of us.

Every opinion poll taken before, and during the Iraq War the past four years has shown a higher proportion of Jewish Americans AGAINST the war than the general population. AIPAC is as strong a lobby as is the tobacco lobby, pharmacutical lobby, various energy lobbies, teachers, doctors, unions, lobbies etc. Lobbies are legal and their job is to do what is in the best interest of their members. To smear an entire people as being in control of America because a lobby voices an opinion that differs than yours is racist and anti-semitic. To take two former advisors to the President who happen to be Jewish and smear an entire people because you disagree with their views is also racist and anti-semitic.
The Democratic party has always received 80% of the Jewish vote, and last time I looked Democrats were and are opposed to the war in Iraq. The old hatreds that lie dormant come out in the open whenever someone sees "a Jew" as the blame for all the worlds ills.

Anti-Semitism is no longer those who hate the Jews but rather those whom the Jews hate. Read some some Theodor Herzl, a Jew, and see how he used Anti-Semitism for the Zionist movement.

Since there are too many of you anti-semitic bigots on here to address personally, I will just say this to all of you –

I am sick and tired of Jews being blamed for every bad thing that happens in the world. Hitler did the exact same thing in Germany and it worked. He blamed the Jews for the Versailles Treaty that ended WWI and imposed harsh peace terms on Germany. He set out to exterminate an entire race of people and, in some cities in Poland, he actually succeeded.

My father was part of the American soldiers that liberated the concentration camps of Bergen-Belsen and Dachau. He saw "the final solution" up close and personal. What he saw there has haunted him all his life. He has been fortunate to live a long life and is enjoying his retirement, but if he ever read the lies and filthy propaganda from some of you on here, he would be livid with rage.

How dare any of you say that it is the Jews who are behind this godawful war in Iraq? How dare you use us as scapegoats once more? It was this administration that orchestrated the lies and misinformation that justified our invasion of a sovereign nation that presented no national security threat to us. They are the ones who bear sole responsibility for this mess. Don't blame my people for something that has absolutely nothing to do with us.

Those of you here who are spouting hatred and venom for the Jewish people are not better than Hitler and the rest of his Nazi henchmen. You should all crawl back under the rock from which you came. I promised my father I would always remember what he told me about the concentration camps and fight prejudice against my people anywhere, anytime. That is why I speak out against those here who are once again trying to repeat history by spewing garbage. You are a disgrace to this country.

Finally, someone in DC has the guts to speak the truth. I'd re-elect him in a second if I lived in VA.

Why can't anyone comment about anything Jewish without getting their wrist slapped. Moran never blamed the Jews so I am not sure who this is anti-semitic. He is only calling the AIPAC as a responsible party for pushing the Government to initiate this war. Please read carefully. He never said anything against the Jews or the Jewish religion or Israel. He even said that they do not represent the majority thinking of the Jewish population. He just said that AIPAC lobbied very well for this war.

Does anyone think it is an "accident" that Israel is pushing for war with Gaza and Iran today?? Jewish, Christian, Muslim – we are all human beings – let's try to keep the world safe for ourselves and not be sounding the war drums on ANY plain! Rep. Moran may have opened up discussion points that citizens of the US need to have amongst themselves publicly – and quickly. Society and civilization are at stake here, folks!!!!!

I believe this war was started by a Mr. George W. Bush. The whole disaster is the fault of Mr. George W. Bush. Laying blame on some lobbying group is insane. This is the President's debacle.

It is not anti-Semitic to be wary of AIPAC.
As others have said before, Wake Up, America. Read up.
Unglue from the sitcoms and reality shows to study the truth.

Thank you very much Rep. Moran. It is refreshing to hear at least one congressman speak the truth for a change when it comes to Israel. And judging by most of the comments here there is a lot of agreement. AIPAC and Christian extremists have walked hand in hand with each other for several years.

Why is it anti-semetic to question anything Israel does? This has nothing to do with the Jewish faith but everyting to do with the Israel the country. As ususal the media will try to paint it as being anti-semetic because the media loves sensation. And other congressman will use it to campaign on. I have a great deal of respect for the Jewish faith but I have a very low opinion of Isreal's policies and our country's blind support for Israel.

I think it is high-time for our politicians to step forward and point out the power AIPAC has as a lobby and our blind protection of Isreal may lead us into a war that can not be won.

If Israel is all ginned up for war with Iran let them go for it, I just do not see the need for us to get involved. If we ever go to war with Iran (which I hope we do not and would find hard to support) it should be with the larger support of all our allies and not just to protect Israel. After all, the Israelies chose to live in the middle of snakes nest of people who dislike them.

RE: Mark, Jessup, MD

And how do you determine that during the Clinton years the U.S. "We wasted millions watching Sadddam"

If you think that's a waste of money, consider this: we've spent 315 Billion dollars in Iraq and Afghanistan (the vast majority in Iraq). Just to clarify that's $315,000,000,000.00. Now here's a little perspective on what that would look like...

Three-hundred-fifteen billion dollars ...

Update : July 21, 2006

This is the amount of money the US has allocated for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, to be spent by September 30, 2006, the end of the fiscal year. And the Senate is working on a spending bill that will add another $50 billion more in spending for 2007.

This pile is 125 feet wide, 200 feet deep, and 450 feet tall.

450 feet is the height of a 38-story building. It's the hieght of the Millenium Wheel in London. It is also the height of the Luxor Hotel in Las Vegas and the Louisiana State Capitol Building.

If you were to stack the money in a single stack, your stack would be 19,887 miles tall, enough to wrap the Moon at its equator almost 3 times.

http://www.crunchweb.net/87billion/

THE BIT DOG ALLWAYS HOLLERS THE LOUDEST.

There are powerful people in all communities who tend to exert power and it just so happens that AIPAC uses it towards a nefarious end. There have always been people who stand up for "other" side going against their own country, race, religion because it's the right thing to do. We should be very careful in labeling people and to remember not to be too ideological in nature

I agree with the Congressman. AIPAC is out of control–they are like a Super Power–people are terrified of AIPAC–
The give Jewsih people a bad name.
AIPAC- stop your bullying.

Rep. Moran is absolutely correct in what he said. And the minute one speaks up and out about the truth of AIPAC you are ridiculed for being a "racist" "anti-Semitic" as a way to silence the person. This is communism.

Why don’t AIPAC and their ilk refute the claims with an honest debate instead of name calling? Because AIPAC and their supporters can't because it is the truth!

AIPAC is not loyal to America, her interests, the citizens interests and her sovereignty either. The only loyalty AIPAC and their ilk have is to Israeli which is NOT in America's best interest but rather treason against America.

WAKE UP AMERICA these people are traitors and this will be the death of America as we speak. America is on the verge of communism because of lobbying groups like this!

The post by John Thomas, Edina, MN: You are absolutely correct! I agree totally. Go RON PAUL! And the AIPAC and their ilk are in great fear of this man as they should be!

NO MORE WARS FOR ISRAELI

thank God that there are still few politicians who have enough courage to stand up and criticize AIPAC. And rightfully so. There have been many instances in the past ( Bush Sr., Carter...) who have been sharply criticized for their comments on various Israeli tactics, and somehow AIPAC gets the upper hand on it. Wake up America and open your eyes!

This is a silly discussion! AIPAC is the most powerful lobby in the United States and is supported by wealthy and influential people who want to benefit Israel by influencing the policies of the United States.

Any other theories regarding the objectives of AIPAC are moot and only cloud the true nature of AIPAC and other lobbying groups in Washington.

The "SOLE PURPOSE" of AIPAC is to influence US policies abroad, just as the SOLE PURPOSE of ADL/SPLC is to influence Americans domestically.

For those of you who wish to decry reality go stick your head in the sand and keep your ears warm!

Btw, AIPAC/ADL/SPLC are not the only groups in the United States lobbying on behalf of a Religion, Civil Rights, or Foreign Affairs, so don't get your knickers in a bundle.

I am Jewish. Every criticism of Israel or a pro-Israel lobby group does not amount to Anti-Semetism. Although there are those who hide their Anti-Semetism behind attacks on Israel. In this case Congressman Moran has spoken the truth and there is no Anti-Semetism. AIPAC does not speak for me or all American Jews. I am against the war and against the Bush administration.

Anti-semitism is alive and well in this country, and is displayed vehemently in the comments of this thread. I have to agree with the other poster that whenever there is a government debacle, "Blame the Jews". As a Jewish Democrat in Moran's district, I had the opportunity to participate in a community event around Darfur at our local synagogue. Moran said all the right things and by all rights, seemed to convey the same passion we have for addressing the horror of Darfur.

But like I have personally experienced in my life with direct anti-semetic remarks, from both friends and foes, I am convinced the anti-semiticism is always there as an underlying sleeping dog.

In terms of Moran, the Jewish community is not seeking a puppet, nor do we expect to agree with him on all issues, but we do expect respect and no anti-semetic remarks.

If we as Americans can't figure out that the Bush Administration was hell bent on going to war in Iraq before 9/11, and it was because Bush #1 didn't take out Saddam, then we all have a big problem. Our administration is a laughing stock in the world, we've dug ourselves and huge hole, and we have a President who is a pawn......but by the tone of these responses, the common theme is as I said previoiusly, "Blame the Jews".

Ludicrous. Sad. Pathethic. Just shear ignorance. And as a Jew, very, very scary indeed.

Never truer words were spoken by Jim. The pit-bull attack dog that is the AIPAC will try to chew his leg off but truth is sometimes a hard pill to swallow.

The criticism I hear from the posters about Moran's comment is that it is anti-semetic, not that it is inaccurate. AIPAC does not represent the Jewish community in the United States, it is a lobby for Israel. If a lobby, any lobby, is going to take a position and advocate that position within the US government, it is fair game to point this out. The only critique you can reasonably make of those like Moran who point this out, is that their comments are not true. And if not true, then I think you can fairly make the anti-semetism connection.

I encourage all to learn all you can about the history of Palestine, Zionism, the founding of Israel, the 1948-? wars, and the plight of the Palestinians.

The opinions of most Americans has been slanted by what they have been fed by the media and entertainment industry. Why...most Americans don't even know who I am.

Wow. That is right. When all else fails, go to the historical scapegoats, the Jewish people. (Incidentally, why would of Israel "conspired" to push the US into invading Iraq???? Wouldn't you agree, that, Syria, or Iran pose a much greater risk to them, than Iraq did?!?!? Check your facts)

Jim Moran has always been an anti-Semite; this latest statements just adds to his records. This also show were the democrats are heading. There is an increase anti-Semitism from a hardcore block within the democratic party, Jim Moran today reflects that block. Its amazing how he tried to ally AIPAC with the Bush Administration in order to attract various of his colleague.

well, we're not blaming the Jews. we are blaming a corrupt and easily paid off government of the United States of America. as was stated earlier, it does not matter if we have Dems or the GOP in office, it will still be business as usual and corporate greed buys them all and they do their bidding. they look out for the interests of the multi national corporations and not their constituents. this is all planned and carefully orchestrated and we see another attempt going on right now with Iran.

You wait like you did for Hilter and see what is coming. Ask yourself do you want to be an Islamic Country.

Yes then you will not have to fight, if no they are coming for you.

History repeats itself, but this time bigger.

I agree with Moran. He statement was very accurate and not antisemitic. The truth cuts like a knife!!!The cry babies cry anti semitic. Typical of the religious fanatics who back tyranny and totalitarism. Keep up the good work Moran.

How dare all of you. The victim mentality in this country is out of control. No one is admitting mistakes, no one is willing to step up to the blame , and now you place the cause a war on a group of people who make an easy scape goat. You must fear and hate Muslims, for they are violent and uncivilized. You must fear and hate Socialists because they threaten your pocket book. You must fear and hate the Jewish, for they are manipulative and conniving. You know what that sounds like? Fascism. Being white and Christian is the only way to be a patriotic American. I serve proudly in the United States Army 10th Mountain and I have my Combat Infantry badge, can you say the same? Oh, and by the by, I was born in Israel

The American people and our Senators have every right to question the motives of AIPAC. If you think they don't have undue influence ask yourself why Joe Leiberman is the only member of the Senate suggesting Gen. Petraus should invade Iran! He's the one voters should oust.

For a detailed analysis of the AIPAC's influence check out "The Israel Lobby" by John J. Mearsheimer and Stephen M. Walt

It is absurd that critics of AIPAC have to defend themselves against broad charges of anti-Semitism. AIPAC is a neoconservative Israeli lobby and as numerous polls show, does not represent the prevailing views of Jews / Israelis on issues pertaining to the war, inter alia. I'm glad Moran has had the courage to call out AIPAC for what it is.

He tells the truth...America let's listen

If all America does is fight Israel's wars why weren't American GIs on the ground defending Israel from invasion in 1948, 56, 68, 73??

And for all those who complain that AIPAC has too much power, why don't you don't do something about it and create your own lobby? Whatever power AIPAC has it worked hard to get that. It sounds like commenters on this board want that power usurped but don't want to spend any time or money to build their own network of lobbying power. How very un-American of you.

It looks like the anti-Semites are popping up all over. The invasion of Iraq did nothing for Israel. The status quo before the war, a declawed Saddam Hussein being hemmed in with internationally-enforced no-fly zones, was perfect for Israel.

If the fantasy of the bigots were true, why wouldn't Israel have made a huge military move to push out many Palestinians (like the ones that danced in the streets on 9/11) at the same time?

The Israelis were sophisticated enough to realize that Bush, Jr's plan would be disastrous (like the older Bush also predicted) because it would have the effect of strengthening their worst enemy: Iran. Also, having permanent American bases in Iraq actually reduces Israel's importance in the region, so saying that AIPAC pushed the invasion for Israel's benefit is just anti-Semitic garbage.

It's sad that political pressure groups think they can influence policies, but then hide behind religion when singled out for their lobbying activities. And if they don't want to be seen as a pressuring group, LOOK AT WHAT THE VERY DEFINITION OF YOUR ORGANIZATION IS!

He is telling the truth and the negative way this was reported (comment about the fact that he will probably lose his job) shows that the Jewish community controls the media.

Anyone ever notice that you cannot say anything negative about Israel or jewish people with out getting blasted. Look at the whole Palestinian/Israel fiasco. That place is a mess, why? because due to their beliefs a religious sect feels they have the right to displace others.

I agree with Moran.

I never thought any US congressperson would have the guts to say the obvious. They are all so afraid.

Clearly, the Israeli lobby is pushing the US to invade its neighbors (Iraq, Iran) for "free" defense.

The Israeli lobby buys the US congress with tons of campaign donations and threats of bad publicity.

Absolutely excellent!
The truth needs to be spoken, and when it is, just look at who is offended by it and speaks out about it, and steer clear!

Cries of anti semitism chill the debate about how we got into this mess and shame on the Democrats for not standing up for free and open debate.

Jimmy Carter offered his criticism of the matter...now he's labled an anti semite.

American Jews influence the country's policies in the mideast...significantly. That's a fact. It's their right as Americans to do so. But if they supported the war in Iraq, they must answer for it jsut as the President must.

It's no different than the influence that Cuban-American's have regarding our long suffering embargo against Cuba.

I'm only surprised that he stopped just a bit short of saying that AIPAC and the Elders of Zion drink blood. Maybe next time...

When someone says something negative about Israel or the Jewish Lobby, certain people rise and claim that he said "a conspiracy controls the U.S. government", then that conspiracy that doesn't exist rises up and tries to take him out. Happens every time.

Why should he have to retract a true statement or be accused of "anti semitism" for speaking about about the pro-Israel Lobby and our one sided support for Israel. Questioning our support of Israel and Israel's military and Palestinian policies does not equal anti semitism!

I agree that AIPAC pushed for the war. But, as Moran pointed out, they do NOT represent the majority of American Jews. I am one, and they certainly don't stand for what I believe in. I also think that it is naive to believe that it was ONLY AIPAC support that caused the war: what about our concern about oil? what about the "America as an Empire" meglomania from people like Rumsfeld and Cheney? Neither of the two is Jewish and it is a massive stretch of imagination to believe that they would be shouldered aside by AIPAC. And what abbout the Christians who believe that supporting Israel will bring Jesus back? All of these things were factors – and none were important enough on their own.

It is a shame that this kind of statement is coming from a U.S Congressman. Makes one to wonder how he got relected into that office. He is not well informed about the WAR it seems. He knows nothing about that region and nothing about the threat that Saddam posed to the world oil market. It is sad to blame AIPAC for the WAR. People are crying over paying almost $3.00 for a gallon of gasoline. Saddam wanted to control the entire oil market if he had the opportunity and we would have been paying $50-$100 if he did because he hated U.S so much. That is why he invaded Kuwait in 1990. Saddam posed to the world as if he had nuclear weapon and the world watched the drama between him and the U.N inspectors. We all watched him dancing on the streets of Baghdad on 9/11. Everybody believed he was a danger to the world because he was a mad man. Almost everyone in the U.S supported the war including majority of our law makers. U.S was winning the war in IRAQ until the Media started broadcasting pictures from Abu Ghraib Prison and that was when the war took a different turn and they started killing U.S soldiers. Any right leader would have done what President Bush did. To think otherwise would have been catastrophic for America. The war would have come to us whether we liked it or not just like it did on 9/11 because America did nothing after the Embassy bombing, USS Cole bombing, 1993 World Trade Center bombing. Let us not forget. History will prove George Bush right and one of the greatest Presidents America ever had. Americans and Politicians especially should stop bad mouthing the war while our soldiers are there risking their lives. We should be praying for them and praying for wisdom for our President on how to end the war and bring our troops home.

Thank you all for your time.

If this Jewish orginization and other Jews are supportive of the Iraq war why aren't they serving in our military? Jews make up about 2% of the U.S. population (5-6 million) but you could probably count those who serve without taking your shoes off.

Of course. Plus the filthy country they represent is behind most of the worlds ills – terrorism.

It totally dissussed me to think we give billions upon billion of dollars to the Israels every year so they can continue there one sided effort to wipe Palestine off the map.

The so called country of Israel needs to be split in half, so the Palestinians can have 1 country, not the 2 little separate pieces they have and Jeruselum needs to be made a separate entity similar to what the Vatican is in Rome, one that can be shared by all the worlds people and not controlled excusively by the Jews.

My wife is a Jewish American and even she agrees with his statement. We both also question why America uses the "untied nations resolution # blah, blah, blah, when referring to other countries (such as Iraq, Iran) yet do nothing to make Israel abide by resolutions passed that required them to remove themselves from pre war land. Making statements against Israel is not anti-semetic. Read what Semetic is sometime and you will find that the Jewish people are not the only semites. Stop using the wrong term.

The U.S. & Israel have been partners in crime for decades now! It's time to end this criminal relationship!

INSTEAD OF NEGATIVE COMMENTS ABOUT THE ISRAELI LOBBY MR.MORAN SHOULD BE MORE CONCERNED WITH THE IRANIAN PRESIDENT COMING TO THE UN WHEN THEY USE OUR FLAGS AS DOOMATS IN IRAN TO STEP ON. HE SHOULD BE EXERTING HIS POWER POSITIVELY

Moran's comments were questionable, but the bigotry displayed in these comments is disgusting.

Jews rule the world? And whites have no rhythm. And black men can't be trusted around white women. And Germans love war. And Japanese are good with electronics. The Irish are drunks. Latinos smell. Give it a rest.

It's about time we stopped thinking like the 12th century, isn't it?

I am shocked by the offensive remarks by this idiot Congressman. However, I am even more shocked by the anti-Semetic tone of the comments by a lot of the CNN community that has e mailed their thoughts. It is shocking that so many of the comments agree with this bigot. This lawmaker should resign immediately. He is clearly prejudiced, and his record proves this. It is sad to see comments that agree with anti-semitism. You might disguise the
anti semitism with psuedo-intellectual arguements: but the ugly truth comes out loud and strong in a lot of the previous comments. Unfortunately, we have a lot of ignorant bigots in this country.

Mr. Moran is right on the money. It is good to have someone who is not afraid to say the truth.

J. Moran's comments are ignorant. The Jewish community, just like Americans as a whole are divided over the wisdom of the Iraq war. Moran attempts to distance himself from claims of Anti-Semitism by claiming that AIPAC is a mouthpiece for Bush. Anyone who knowns anything about AIPAC or the American Jewish community knows that these groups are not in the back pocket of GWB. Jews tend to vote heavily Democratic.

When will Anti-Semites, like Moran, come to grip with the fact that Israel is our only dependable ally in the entire Middle Eastern region? Israel is virtually the only democratic nation in the entire, unstable area, and Israel supports American policy, ideology and way of life. Moran clearly allows his hatred and jealousy of the Jewish people and nation to infiltrate his political positions.

What the senator said is 100% true. Until when the US will stay Israel's slave? all what the US is getting from that is hostality from the world and more terrorism.

rful. They control this country and Israel is the 51 state of the union. Anytime anyone says anything that is true about Jews, they are labeled anti-semetic. You can dog any other culture, or race and that is okay but never say anything negative about Jewish people. Just take a good look at O J Simpson. It was not okay for OJ to publish that disgusting book but as soon as Goldman had it in his hands it was no longer a disgusting book. Guaranteed if Goldman was another Black man, Chinese or Mexican it would not have gotten that much attention. Tell me again who has the power in this country and who controls it. Just my opinion, but then who am I.

I support this American Patriot of a Senator to stand up to AIPAC and FINALLY state what is obvious to those who care And are paying attention. He speaks the truth, but will surely be labed and libeled as antisemitic. Support this man, and urge your local representatives to do the same, and help eject AIPAC from our hallowed halls in Washington. Israel should influence nothing in American politics, lest we continue down this darkening path toward Iran.

You would have to be a nimrod to not believe that we are fighting Israel's war. Of course we are.

Not only do we give Israel billions of US tax dollars (when we are broke ourselves) but we also spend billions towards this war and shed the blood of US Citizens on Israel's behalf.

Shame on all of the politicians who lack the courage to stand up and say what all Americans understand – we cannot be Israels benefactor forever.

It is sad to read these comments. I suppose the myth of the Jewish conspiracy is alive and well. Why did I ever think otherwise?

I too believe that certain special interest groups wield too much power, but that goes for all of them. Where is the hysteria over Lockheed Martin, NRA, the Corn Lobby, the Irish lobby, the Christian Right and on and on. We could try to blame each of them for all kinds of stupid decisions made by our elected government.

That's right, we elected these leaders. The U.S. is a democratic republic. Bush, Congress, and half of this country believed that the invasion was justified. You can't blame one lobby for that mistake. You shouldn't fall back on the Jewish conspiracy, blame Israel, and hate the few when we are all responsible for our government's actions.

AIPAC has in fact, been pushing for this war for years. Just look at Lieberman's stance on it.
The US is fighting a proxie war (occupation) on Iraq for two reasons: oil and Israel. Period.

What Moran said: AIPAC and the rest of Jewish lobby are very powerful and exert that power.

What Hoyer and the Jewish Lobby said he said: Jews control the U.S. government.

My opinion: The Jewish lobby exerts influence that is out of balance with the number of Jews in the U.S. population. The Jewish lobby's interests are often not the same as what U.S. interests should be. Moran spoke the truth now he is being attacked as an anti-Semite.

Why should he have to retract his comments when they are true?

Moran is correct and it is a matter of fact. The Lawrence Franklin/Douglas Franklin Espionage scandal (also called the AIPAC Espionage scandal) makes this a matter of public record. The successful prosecution of this case proves this point.

AIPAC, the Israeli right wing, and the White House neo-con inner circle were behind the policy of invading Iraq.

It is a disgrace and shame that most of our politicians have their money-grubbing noses up the AIPAC derriere.

There is more freedom to discuss these issues openly in Israel (which I support in general), than in the USA. Our political and news machines are aligned with the Israeli far right, and the results have been tragic for Israel, the USA, the Palestinians, the Iraqis, and the world. We have been the worst enemy of Israel by supporting very poor strategy.

The best fundamental change that can come to the US government and the political system as a whole is the immediate banning of all special interest groups and lobbying groups, and their lawyers. Finally, a government by the people, for the people, with an end to corruption.

People, especially our elected representatives, need to be very careful in discussing this issue because of the sensitivities on both sides. On the one hand, yes, AIPAC did not "officially" take a position on the war, but behind closed doors it was well-connected to the foreign policy establishment and certainly exerted influence, both within and outside the Bush administration. However, you can't paint the entire American Jewish community with a broad brush because of the activities of one (albeit, the largest and most influential) political action committee. Moran may have had the right intentions in highlighting the influence of that group, but, unfortunately, his comments open up a Pandora's Box of anti-Semitism. As a result, he should clarify is remarks and promote healthy discussion about the reasoning behind them. Finally, those who might hold negative opinions about AIPAC, or misguided beliefs about the influence of Jews in general, should not use this issue as a pretext for furthering their own anti-Semitic causes.

Moran is correct. There is a BIG difference between AIPAC whos loyalties belong to a select group in Israel and the American Jewish community. The American Jewish community are Americans just like the rest of us. AIPAC is a small group of people that DO have unacceptable influence in Washington and a cabal relationship with religious extremists in the USA.

It NEVER fails: criticize the state of Isreal's actions/politics/foreign policy, or make statements of FACT about AIPAC's influence over Congress -and the chicken littles plug their ears and scream, "antisemitism".

This old ploy to silence dissent is losing its punch – better think of something new to divert our attention. Hurry!

I am skeptical of Moran's claims especially since he does not back his claims with facts.

Saddam Hussein had so many enemies that there are trucks load of people who had much to gain in invading Iraq. For example, Chalabi and the Iraqi National Congress were a major factor in the push to invade Iraq.

Indeed, Chalabi provided reports of weapons of mass destruction and alleged ties to al-Qaeda –all of which has turned out to be false.

So, one can argue that Iraqis themselves, not the Jewish PAC, lobbied the U.S. government for the Iraq invasion.

about time someone said it.

i'm surprised he was re-elected after his comments in 2003.
google AIPAC + Senator Percy

As a native Washingtonian I have always been aware that Israel could do not wrong in the eyes of the American government regardless of the party in power. I have asked many intelligent people why this is. To date I have received no answer. What have they got on us?

As a liberal Democrat living in Mr. Moran's congressional district, I am hanging my head in shame at the comments of my congressman. He is such an ardent foe of Israel, a beacon of liberalism, women's rights, free press, gay rights, and the rule of law....values that liberals such as myself (and sadly, not Mr. Moran), should embrace in a foreign country.

So there is a lawmaker who has the guts to speak the truth........telling the truth is Not antisemitic. However, it isn't hard to see that anytime you question AIPAC, you are called an antisemite. America, why do you think that is? I thought this was a nation which prides itself on free speech, but not when you question anything to do with the Jewish lobby or Israel. Talk about sacred cows! Don't you find it odd that Christianiy and Islam can be criticized and questioned everywhere we look, but the minute the word Jewish appears, everyone ducks, runs, points fingers, calls names and yes, threatens?

I guess Rep. Jim Moran should thank his lucky stars he wasn't Tazered for using his First Amendment Rights and speaking up on this subject.

The congressman is an idiot spouting neonazi propaganda. As a Christian I am appalled and believe he needs to be, not only censored, but run out of town tarred and feathered. Why is it always Jewish people blamed for everything foolish administrations fail at? This guy is just too ignorant.

Scapegoating the jewish community for society's troubles? This sounds strangely familiar. Hmmm... I can't remember where this has happened before. I think the place where this has happened starts with a G and ends with an -ermany.

Would it be anti-semitic to say that AIPAC pushed for the war? Ask Steny Hoyer if it is inaccurate that AIPAC exerts power. If it doesn't exert power, why would Moran "take heat" for his comments or have his re-election challenged? There is nothing wrong with supporting Israel, to the contrary, but let's be clear that groups like AIPAC exert an undue amount of influence on U.S. foreign policy.

Call me Anti-Semitic if you must, but when normally peaceful guys like Joe Libermann & Stephen Spielberg were frothing @ the mouth for "taking out Sadaam" it did make me scratch my head.

I think the congressman is correct. Unfortunately, anything said against a Jewish organization or person in North America or Europe is always spun in such a manner that the true message is lost. Jewish people are to be admired for the way the help each other and thrive, but in the process they overwhelm local populations with their power and issues.
There is no denying that that is the case in North America, and it will take more than one congressman to bring this to the forefront.
Although international relations are complex, there is no doubt that the green light Israel enjoys and the pro-Israeli policies of the United States do not come from limbo. And politicians can’t or won’t handle this hot potato.

I am getting confused. I thought the Libs said the war was the work of the evil Bush-Cheney coalition, now they say it was the evil Jewish lobby. We wasted millions watching Sadddam during the Clinton years, even the most liberal Dems came out saying Saddam needed to be ousted, until Bush actually had the guts to do it. What will be the Libs answer tomorrow? Space aliens?

how did someone this ignorant get into office?

Finally, someone has the courage to tell the truth about the war and other parts of Us foreign policy. Why the lobby has any power over our affairs is a mystery to me, but they must be stopped and removed from any influence. I am so happy to see someone step and confront this issue and the lobby. thank you!

Does anyone out there not believe that what Moran says is true? The Jewish lobby exerts such sway over our government that we guarantee Israel's currency and natiional debt, and pay them 24 billion per year for absolutely nothing.

Why can't the nation of Israel be criticized for something without being labeled an anti-Semite?

When in doubt, blame the Jews.

Some folks are just too sensitive. So Moran says that a Jewish organization supported the war. Why is that bad? Does that group represent all JEWS worldwide? An offense against one is an offence against all?

It's like saying that the Clintons are racist white rednecks because they were from the South. And of course we all know that only racist white rednecks live in the South!

That is what I love about this country. There are people has the courage to tell the truth.

TYPICAL ANTI SEMTIC COMMENTS FROM PEOPLE WHO INSIST THEY ARE NOT! NOT SUPRISED.

Posted By William,Miami Fl : September 19, 2007 10:25 am

It's "chutzpah"

While Mr. Moran's constant criticism of the Jewish community certainly does scream anti-semitism, that's something his constituents need to take up with him as they are the ones who chose whether or not to reelect him. However, I do believe he does speaks truth to a certain degree. I can't help but think that Joe Lieberman's transparent motives in beating the war drum in Iraq and Iran are evidence of this.

To clarify, I'm referring to this statement: "In 2003, Moran apologized for saying Iraq would not have been invaded without the Jewish community's support."

Because we oppose the policies pushed by AIPAC and the governemnt of the foreign nation of Israel we're anti-semetic?? He shouldn't apologize for telling the truth about a foreign nation that seems to be dicating US foreign policy in the Middle East.

The fact that people respond to criticism of AIPAC with "that's anti-semetic" just confirms that the criticism is well-founded.

The United States is not beholden to Israel. AIPAC is the most powerful special interest group in the US. AIPAC promotes the interest of Israel, not the US. Saying so is not "anti-semetic."

For starters, you're a guy who doesn't know the American government too well: Moran is a Congressman, not a Senator. Try reading the story next time.

I'm Jewish, I'm opposed to the war in Iraq, and I've never had any association with AIPAC. The Congressman's statement amounts to nothing more than "Blame the Jews," which is, of course, increadibly offensive. Gross generalizations about religious or ethnic groups do not advance the political diologue in this country, and they should be rejected.

I wish the article was a little longer explaining why he felt this way... why AIPAC would want the war, etc.

In my estimaiton, it's a silly comment.

Moran says that AIPAC is an "...organization aligned with the Bush Administration." That makes no sense. They are a PAC and will lobby whoever is in power.

To the others who have posted, was it Israel or oil that prompted the Iraq War? Or does it not matter to liberals as long as the war is criticized?

To David B, from Viginia;

I'm not a Jew but I'm a Jewish sympathizer and I could tell you this that the day will come when not even this country will stand side by side with Israel and forget Europe.

AIPAC may not "officially" have lobbied for the Iraq war, but that doesn't mean it didn't happen.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn/A63578-2003Mar31?language=printer

Senator Moran may not have the fact's correct on Aipac but it is true that the mainstream of American Jewish thinking etc. is very organized and are very powerful. They control this country and Israel is the 51 state of the union. Anytime anyone says anything that is true about Jews, they are labeled anti-semetic. You can dog any other culture, or race and that is okay but never say anything negative about Jewish people. Just take a good look at O J Simpson. It was not okay for OJ to publish that disgusting book but as soon as Goldman had it in his hands it was no longer a disgusting book. Guaranteed if Goldman was another Black man, Chinese or Mexican it would not have gotten that much attention. Tell me again who has the power in this country and who controls it. Just my opinion, but then who am I.

BRAVO!, Finally politicians are not afraid of speaking out loud against this administration, directly or indirectly, it involves final decisions made in the oval office. It is not an attack on the Jewish community, but a slash at the activist within the Jewish community that, through political and economic pressure, can influence policy. He should not retract his statement; Corporate America is not ran by someone at the White House, is the power of the wallet that runs this country, elections are purely symbolic.

The antisemitism of the "new" Democratic party (see the Daily Kos etc) is finally appearing in Congress. It was just a matter of time.

I have believed that for some time. The silence of the Jewish community spoke and speaks volumes. Lieberman to this day has vociferously supported the war.

For once some one has the chuspa(sp?), as they say, to speak out about it

He's just finally verbalizing what has been very well known regarding AIPAC. Thankfully at least one of our politicians has the guts to state the obvious.

It's just a shame and a disgrace in this country that we have become so "politically correct" that an honest assessment of this situation can't be made without cries of antisemitism.

So because it's a Jewish organization, it wouldn't foment aggression against Muslim states?

Ludicrous.

People miss the point when the associate comments like this as being anti-semetic. Moran is not saying that Jewish Americans are behind the war. He is saying that a powerful Jewish Lobby is behind it.

Just because he is criticizing an organization that is Jewish doesn't mean his is criticizing Jews. Anyone who does a quick study on AIPAC will see that the organization has some disturbing influence. And, I am friends with many Jewish people, who see the same way.

Dear Mr. Moran:

PAC like the jewish PAC excert power, not because they are well organizez, as you claim, but becasue people in positions like your ALLOW them to have power BY BENDING TO THEIR DESIRES!!!!!

David B from Virginia,

How do you consider Moran's statement against a lobby group to be 'anti-semitic'? By the same logic, our accusations of the regimes in Iran and North Korea are anti-Muslim and anti-Asian.

It wasn't a lobbying group that was "behind the invasion of Iraq," it was the President of the United States. If you're saying Bush is so easily swayed that a lobbying group could talk him into war, then there's just one more reason he should be impeached and tried for war crimes.

These comments are not anti-semitic. Anyone who declares this as such is aggressively abusing the term. He is speaking the truth that everyone knows but no one (in Washington) is willing to say.

David "B" wrong wrong wrong ,

NORTHERN VIRGINIA is not anti JEW ,just anti AIPAC , it is about time this was said by someone in some sort of elected office. The same can be said of the last war in Lebanon, the whole mideast conflict has to do with the JEWS taking over.

Remember before 1948 there was no ISREAL ,only Palestine.

Jews are useing same tactics against Palestine as NAZI's did in Poland in 1939.

The Jewish lobby, Aipac, is the largest lobbying organization in this country. They control congress, and act in the interest of Israel, not the United States. This nothing more than legalized bribary. They should all be tried for treason.

Speaking truth got one Hebrew beheaded & another nailed to a cross about 2,000 years ago.

Just because he is criticizing the position and actions of a lobbying group does not mean he is anti-semetic. That phrase is used far too often anytime someone criticizes Israel.

Your hometown is not anti-semetic. What Moran is saying is the truth. It is not the Jewish people, as a whole, it is Pearle, Wolfowitz – and others who are part of PNAC and the Bush administration. One the one hand, I am happy to see people knowing this and speaking up, but on the other hand, it is immediately thought of as "anti-semetic." My husband is Jewish, I am not an anti semite, but I am anti Bush, anti war, anti Cheney, anti APAC, anti Pearle, anti Wolfowitz...these people are war mongers. Moran should have said it in a way that would not immediately label him as an anti semite b/c that is always the argument, and then things are hushed up. These people are so greedy – they are all in it for the oil, for power, it has nothing to do with terrorism. Wake up America. Moran – keep saying what you're saying.

There's no room in Washington for such racist ideology regardless of which side of the aisle it comes from!

He is right; maybe American people will wake up and see who is really calling the shots.
We didn’t need that war, it was not in our interest.

Ah yes... classic move...
When all else fails, blame the Jews.

Can we ask for this guy's head on a platter now?

So, for speaking the truth, he should "retract his statment"? Seriously, people, WAKE THE HELL UP! It doesn't matter if you vote Republican or Democrat (in most cases), because either way you'll end up getting corrupt, self-serving scum! If you sheep would finally start to realize this, our country would become a much better place.

And then, we have Ron Paul. He certainly sticks out like a sore thumb in this race, doesn't he? Oh, maybe that's because he is HONEST, PRINCIPLED and UP-FRONT with all of the IMPORTANT issues that face this country and threaten its demise. Wake up, people, this is our country.

He is right and from what I understand if we speak in prophetic terms the US should just stay away from that region, its a heavy burden for us to carry plus Israel may not be as strong as the US but Israel will survive alone trust me.

I never thought of my hometown area - Northern Virginia - as an anti-semetic place, but Moran keeps saying these things and keeps getting elected, so I guess it is. Shameful.

It's about time !!!

I agree with Moran. The entire basis of PNAC was the support of Israel and the security of it's borders.
He shouldn't be blasted, it's the truth..Why did Perle and Feith and that crew go and visit Netenhau (sp) in the first place back in the late 90's, if Israel wasn't one of ther primary factors with drumming up a war against Iraq?

AIPAC's power is shown here. A congressman says what almost everyone in Washington knows to be true, but are afraid to say, and he is threatenned with a primary challenge which will probably be funded by AIPAC. The story shows that no one attempts to disprove his statement, but rather state that he just can't say it out loud. AIPAC will attack anyone who criticizes Israel for anything, or shows sympathy for the people living under their occupation. How did a groop representing 3% of our population get so much power? now there's a story that will never be examined in our corporate mass media.

Oops..., lost those votes.