i completely agree i live in NY and before 9/11 people did not like giuliani. he wasnt looked at as a great mayor.he was the guy that would arrest everyone to protect park ave from litter!! then you see all these people now saying how great giuliani was for NY lol. look at NY today its all rich foreigners!!! there is no soul to this city anymore.

scott i live in NY and to act like because you once lived here you are in some way more knowledgable on this subject then most is a ridiculous statement. look at CINDY from FAIRBORN, OH she seems to be mmore accurate on the subject then you and she isnt even from NY!!! amazing....lol

Posted By Joe, Old Bridge, NJ : November 29, 2007 4:14 pm

the best part about this forum is that you get to see how the opposition works. instead of discussing the issue of giuliani they say its actually more importnant that someone that worked for hillary ASKED A QUESTION at a debate!!! thats right ASKED A QUESTION.......the absurdity of the accusation is that this is worse then what giuliani did puts things in perspective doesnt it?

scream "PLANT!"

Somebody should dress up as one at the next GOP debate.

Hmmmm...it appears you were privy to information on the state of the Guiliani's marriage that even Mrs. Guiliani wasn't aware of Scott, because I recall a certain press conference where Donna Hanover Guiliani basically said they were working on their marriage and she blindsided by Rudy's announcement that he was leaving the marriage in favor ofhis "good friend" Judy Nathan. But I'm sure you YOU know better. After all, she was only the (legal) wife.

Looks like you are one of the fool-aide drinkers: You posted "I mean if it came down to a Giuliani vs Clinton for the White House – the voters would need to choose between a mayor with sound fiscal experience and a social liberal background…"

True GOP – voting for a crook, a man who runs with crooks, has no morals, and by the way, if you got information from anything other than Faux News, you'd know Rudy has padded his resume with lies, and misleading statistics ... the only fiscal experience he has is hiding the cost of his affair with his not-yet-third wife.

Come on, Rudy, why aren't you addressing the truth of the issue. Because the truth of the issue is you're a slimy, lying, corrupt weasel.

First, one needs to understand that regardless of what certain political people are doing, there are mandatory levels of security coverage that must be maintained (by law).

No one has all the facts sufficient to make any valid judgment one way or the other; and if the cost incurred would have happened irregardless of where the Mayor had gone, then there is no point to the story whatsoever.

What you have just pointed out, even if I don’t think you realize it, is the hypocrisy of the republican party!

Fondest Wishes During this Holiday Season,

Your Friend,
Fidel

The force at which you people consistently try to create drama and instigate controversy, without even knowing the facts of a story is ridiculous... keep riding the "Conspiricy Train" of the Clinton Crime Family.

The same Universe as the Dems do Walter... the same as the Dems. Do you not remember a certain Bill "BJ" Clinton, cheating on his wife and being nominated by his party. Think before you speak buddy, think before you speak!

Posted By Ryan Indianapolis : November 29, 2007 3:13 pm

Oh, poor Ryan, are you upset because the questions could be submitted by all citizens and some of them are Democrats? I realize that Bush has trained you to think that only supporters should get a voice in government, but that's not really reality.

CNN opened up the Democratic Party's Youtube debate to all voters. If I recall, there were questions asked that weren't softballs, then, too. Secondly, too bad if you don't like the Youtube debates. The submissions were from predominantly younger voters, so what did you expect, since they're sure not registering as Republicans in droves (unless they want to vote for Ron Paul).

How can that be right and how could the people of NYC let that happen? Please don't elect this man...we'd be better off changing the laws and giving George W four more years...at least we know what we'll get.

This guy has more baggage than an airport carousel.

Ru911dy, it's over.

When does their brain say that this is not a good man?

Please, whatever higher power is listening, don't let this slimebag take any more high office.

And, please, whatever higher power is listening, don't let reporters falter or shrink from digging all they can about ALL of the candidates.

I'll be so easy... go ahead republicans PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE give the nomination to Rudy!!!

GO RUDY 08!!!

NYC budget was around 24 Billion a year when Rudy took over the opportunities for curruption were boundless yet Rudy played it straight and ran a tuaght ship.

The lefties hate him and fear him..

A man who fires people when they gain the trust of the people is surrounded by enemies. Giuliani meet the best police cheif you ever fired, Richard Bratton.

More to come.

Rudy is a politician; of course he's fed out of the public trough.
Nobody should be surprised by corrupt NY politicians, of which Hillary is one.
If you don’t think she’s corrupt, you’re ignoring history.

Not many “good” people become politicians

A bigger story is the fact that Hillary had her tentacles in the debate when one of her advisors was asking questions about gays in the military. First Hillary plants questions at her own appearances and now she's planting them in debates. She needs to be stopped!