December 7, 2007
Posted: 05:00 PM ET

Huckabee's immigration plan is derived from a National Review article.

BLUFFTON, South Carolina (CNN) — The nine-point immigration plan released Friday by former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee came with a footnote:

"Note: This plan is partially modeled on a proposal by Mark Krikorian, Executive Director of the Center for Immigration Studies." That proposal by the conservative anti-illegal immigration activist was published in the National Review in May 2005.

Not only is Huckabee's plan strikingly similar to the magazine piece – in some cases, it contains exact quotations copied over from the article.

For instance, the Huckabee plan states that "Employment is the chief draw for most illegal immigrants and denying them jobs is the centerpiece of an attrition strategy."

Krikorian's article contains that same statement, verbatim.

Another example: Krikorian writes that "A presidential candidate should promote better cooperation by supporting legislative measures such as the CLEAR Act, which aims to systematize the relationship between local law and federal immigration officials."

Huckabee's plan seeks to empower local authorities by promoting "better cooperation on enforcement by supporting legislative measures such as the CLEAR Act, which aims to systematize the relationship between local law and federal immigration officials."

In all, there are nine instances of similar sentences or phrases appearing in both plans.

Huckabee said Friday he "absolutely" wanted his plan to mirror Krikorian’s so closely, and that the footnote made clear that his campaign did not plagiarize the article.

"We unapologetically admit that we have based it on the proposal that was in there, because we thought it was really one of the most rational approaches," Huckabee told reporters Friday.

The cribbing from Krikorian, who is known for his position in favor of major new limits on immigration, comes after charges from Huckabee’s Republican rival that he is soft on illegal immigration, a major campaign issue in early-voting states like Iowa and South Carolina.

– CNN South Carolina Producer Peter Hamby

Filed under: Immigration • Mike Huckabee • South Carolina


BORN AMERICAN, TEXAS, TEXAS   December 11th, 2007 10:39 pm ET

Guys on a side note, all illegals aliens are as legal as Christopher Columbus. lol.

Karen Houston TX   December 9th, 2007 11:23 pm ET

It absolutely amazes me that Mitt Romney has been the only candidate who has had a plan to deal with illegal immigration that did not deal with amnesty. He is the one that spoke openly about penalizing employers, he is the one that threatened to withdraw national funding from sanctuary cities. Huckabee comes up with a copy- cat idea and all of the sudden he is a super hero.

This man makes me sick! He is a snake! If he wins the nomination I will not be voting!

Derrick. Hagerstown, MD   December 9th, 2007 10:33 pm ET

Is it just me, or does Huckabee look like he's throwing up a gang sign in that photo?

dmw, roeland park, ks   December 9th, 2007 5:58 pm ET

The comment from CA-Native made me question the comment. This person actually believe Hillary took ideas from Obama. What a joke.

Obama has no ideas. All of what he ever says is, I offer HOPE, takes a jab at Hillary, then he takes Hillary's, Edward's, Dodd, Richardson, and Biden's ideas from them working years to try to make America better and claim them to be his own.

You can tell Obama does not have a clue because everytime he is asked a question, he can not formulate a complete thought. If someone really stands for something, one would think that person would be able to articulate it without all of 'uh's' you get from Obama when he is not making a speech.

He is NOT ready yet to be President.

Thomas, Gainesville, Florida   December 9th, 2007 10:57 am ET

Tom Tancredo has been saying the same things for months if not years! ATTRITION THROUGH ENFORCEMENT! The only GOP candidates that can actually be trusted on the illegal immigration issue are Tancredo, Hunter, and Paul. The others have only recently "seen the light" on this issue and are adopting these three candidates ideas as their own (and not just on this issue!).

Check out the NumbersUSA website
http://www.numbersusa.com/index

They say:
"(December 7) Every candidate wants voters to think he/she would end future illegal immigration. But NumbersUSA's Roy Beck finds that of 15 candidates of both parties, only six are even making promises that rate them as "good" or "excellent" on fighting future illegal immigration. Likewise, only four of these 15 are making promises that rate them as “good” or “excellent” on reducing legal immigration, which is at its highest level in history."

"In the Republican race, former Senator Fred Thompson (Tenn.) and former Governors Mitt Romney (Mass.) and Mike Huckabee (Ark.) are outdoing each other to adopt policies to try to look as good as Representatives Tom Tancredo (Colo.), Duncan Hunter (Calif.) and Ron Paul (Tex.). Take a look."

"In the Democratic race, only Rep. Chris Dodd (Conn.) appears to be adopting more immigration reduction policies. Take a look."

This site links to another site:

http://www.betterimmigration.com/candidates/2006/prez08_gop1.html

Scroll to the bottom to see what the candidates' PAST records indicate - not what they're promising.

(Note: these organizations do not endorse candidates. They compile and assess information only on the immigration issue.)

Kristy Sanborn, Buckhorn, Mo.   December 9th, 2007 10:00 am ET

Several months ago, congress decided not to approve the immigration reform bill that President Bush and several others worked very hard on, the vote was very close though. I have to wonder, did congress not want it to pass at that time, so it could become a major election issue as it has become?
People didn't want the issue dealt with months ago, why do they now?

Joe Dierte, Grand Canyon   December 8th, 2007 1:41 pm ET

You have my vote Mr. Huckabee. Most Americans would love to see a crackdown on the employers of illegal immigrants and many could get their jobs back.

Jonathon Truth, Middleton Missouri   December 8th, 2007 11:57 am ET

Its great to finally see a candidate take a postion that will actually fix the illegal immigration problem. Comprehensive illegal immigration reform is just a sham, written by corporate special interests and full of unenforcables and loopholes. the Comprehensive approach would basically create an open border and unlimited importation of cheap labor, effectively putting all Americans out of work.

Walt, Belton, TX   December 8th, 2007 10:14 am ET

Huckabee and Romney claim all kinds of public service but neither had the guts to serve their country one day in the Armed Forces. Neither has put their life on the line for their country. They have only lived off the largesse of the American taxpayer. I, for one, do not want either on of them occupying the White House as my Commander-in-Chief. They will both acquiesce and we will all be speaking mexican or farsi in no time at all.

Independent in IA   December 8th, 2007 10:11 am ET

Huckleberry would be a complete disaster to this nation if he makes it to the White House. Please don't allow this jerk to win.

Dana Saar   December 8th, 2007 9:39 am ET

And your point is?

Samuel Jefferson, Richmond Virginia   December 8th, 2007 9:13 am ET

The CIS is not a racist organization. The racists that currently are the most active is the lets let in all Latinos from south of the border and prohibit anyone else from entering. These racists are big business enterests, too lazy to modernize their facilities or just too cheap to pay a respectable wage. These racists seek to reduce the status of latinos to subhuman labor mechanisms. Pigeonholed as people who will all ways work hard for little or nothing.The cure is to repeal NAFTA and pressure Mexico into distributing their wealth and create decent jobs for its people.

K. Wilkinson MG TX   December 8th, 2007 9:01 am ET

"Note: This plan is partially modeled on a proposal by Mark Krikorian, Executive Director of the Center for Immigration Studies." That proposal by the conservative anti-illegal immigration activist was published in the National Review in May 2005.

Does anyone else see Huckabee grabbing onto someone else's plan because he figured that his own, "Lets put them all through college" plan wasn't too popular. Talk about Flip-Flop with just a dash of deception.

Recipe For Disaster:

Take one Baptist minister
*Must be "the Christian" candidate
Add over taxation
Rub generously with bankruptcy
Mix with illegal immigration
Throw in a few rapists
Add a bunch of Evangelical zealots
Sprinkle with deception to taste

Cook in a White House for four years!

Kevin, Bel Air, MD   December 8th, 2007 7:32 am ET

I am sure glad watched the CNN debate. While I thought it was staged too much, It did give me my first opportunity to watch and hear Gov. Huckabee. He is the type of republican I like, conservative!

Ian, Little Rock, AR   December 8th, 2007 3:58 am ET

Interesting that CIS is also tied to racist organizations: http://americaabroad.tpmcafe.com/node/28668

"The CIS, as well as many other anti-immigrant groups, were founded by one man - a known White Supremacist by the name of John Tanton."

Dax, Carlsbad, California   December 8th, 2007 2:23 am ET

I like Huckabees gangster signs. Right on!

KEITH JAMES LOUTTIT   December 8th, 2007 1:11 am ET

Well if it's true it's not really his idea, then who cares who makes it work?

Did Roebling invent suspension cabling for bridges? Did Shakespeare really write "To be or not to be…"? Did Al Gore actually connect the first two computers all by his self? Who cares, we all enjoy the benefits of the work provided by millions of unknowns.

Great men have the farsightedness to see beyond the mediocre by standing on the shoulders of greater men!

Doom, Ramona, Ca   December 8th, 2007 12:31 am ET

he doesn't have an original thought on anything.

Lynn, FL   December 8th, 2007 12:09 am ET

So what's the big deal? He admits that he liked someone else's plan and gave them the credit due. Better to be honest than to put out the same plan as someone else and claim he came up with it himself like so many others do. It is amazing how when a candidate starts to do well in the polls, everything they do is suddenly hit with a negative sounding slant from the media.

Apollo F, Seattle, WA   December 7th, 2007 10:31 pm ET

Is this the same Huckabee who wanted to give scholarships to illegal aliens (he calls them 'children' but if they are going to college, they are no longer minors).

They are jumping in line in front of people all over the world who want to come to America. Go back home, get in line and come here legally.

We must not give benefits to illegal aliens. Why not? We are a nation of laws. We are a very generous nation, as well, but we need to follow the law and must not reward people who, by their very presence here is breaking our laws.

Huckster has no credibility on this issue of illegal aliens (or on being tough on crime…what was it, 650 clemencies and pardons? Mitt Romney did not pardon one single person. Now that's tough on crime!)

HUCK,LA.   December 7th, 2007 10:15 pm ET

HUCK IS IN THE SURGE -GO HUCK FINN A REAL AMERICAN,YEAH!! FAIR TAX, YOU HEAR THAT!!!!! TAKE BACK AMERICA PEOPLE NOW!!!

HS, Columbia, SC   December 7th, 2007 9:56 pm ET

Wow, CNN, you are so biased, it is pathetic. You put out there an accusation of cribbing with NO evidence and then make it look like the campaign is in the wrong. In fact the campaign has been perfectly upfront in stating that they admired Krikorian's approach so much so that they based the plan on it. Krikorian is flattered; you see it as plagiarism. Why don't you go ahead and endorse Hillary Clinton? We all know you would hate to see a conservative win, just admit it. It's pathetic.

Justin   December 7th, 2007 9:47 pm ET

LOL. What do people expect? This guy can only run if he adopts other candidates and activists positions. How about something original from Huckabee besides tax hikes and dishonesty.

huck,la.   December 7th, 2007 8:22 pm ET

Thats one reason I like HUCKABEE! Other issues he is right on target!

Pat, Pittsford, NY   December 7th, 2007 7:52 pm ET

He cited his source, what's the issue?

Gary Denson   December 7th, 2007 7:48 pm ET

YES!!! finally a candidate for president who has respect for the rule of law and respect for the middle class working people who have seen theri jobs given to illegals or seen their wages drop due to competition for illegals. Going after the employers of illegals is the only way and most Americans would like to see them and the ACLU thrown is jail.
MR, Huckubee you just won my vote!!

Tim, Minneapolis,Mn   December 7th, 2007 7:41 pm ET

Hey Huck, paying the college costs for illegal immigrants' kids also is a big lure here.

Alan, San Angelo Texas   December 7th, 2007 7:37 pm ET

The Center for Immigration Studies produced a laughable piece dramatically overstating the impact of illegal immigrants on the uninsured problem in America. If Huckabee wants to keep his honesty label, he needs to shed any association with CIS.

Ca Native   December 7th, 2007 7:28 pm ET

Wow - if we could actually get CNN to do a side-by-side comparison of Hillary Clinton's policy statements (that come after Obama) to his originals… voters might see how Hillary is effectively plagarizing Obama.

Naah… on 2nd thought - that would put Hillary and democrats in a bad light. Scratch that idea!

CNN has too much work on their plate preparing for the next Demoplant Debate.

Comments have been closed for this article

subscribe RSS Icon
About The Ticker

The latest political news from CNN's Best Political Team, with campaign coverage, 24-7. Sign up for our twice daily Ticker emails. Got a news tip or feedback? For complete political coverage, bookmark CNNPolitics.com.

CNN=Politics Screensaver

CNN=Politics ScreensaverTap into the power of The Situation Room. Download this powerful new tool that keeps you posted on the latest political news from the campaign trail.
Download (4.1 MB, PC only)

Follow us on Twitter

CNN on TwitterGet Ticker updates the moment they appear online via the Web, SMS, or instant messages.
Follow politicalticker

Categories
CNN Comment Policy: CNN encourages you to add a comment to this discussion. You may not post any unlawful, threatening, libelous, defamatory, obscene, pornographic or other material that would violate the law. Please note that CNN makes reasonable efforts to review all comments prior to posting and CNN may edit comments for clarity or to keep out questionable or off-topic material. All comments should be relevant to the post and remain respectful of other authors and commenters. By submitting your comment, you hereby give CNN the right, but not the obligation, to post, air, edit, exhibit, telecast, cablecast, webcast, re-use, publish, reproduce, use, license, print, distribute or otherwise use your comment(s) and accompanying personal identifying information via all forms of media now known or hereafter devised, worldwide, in perpetuity. CNN Privacy Statement.
Home  |  World  |  U.S.  |  Politics  |  Entertainment  |  Health  |  Tech  |  Travel  |  Living  |  Business  |  Sports  |  Time.com
Podcasts  |  Blogs  |  CNN Mobile  |  Preferences |  Email Alerts  |  CNN Radio  |  CNN Shop  |  Site Map
© 2008 Cable News Network LP, LLLP. A Time Warner Company. All Rights Reserved.
Powered by WordPress.com