January 21, 2008
Posted: 05:44 PM ET
 Atlanta Mayor Shirley Franklin.
Atlanta Mayor Shirley Franklin.

(CNN) — With Bill Clinton standing only a matter of feet behind her, Atlanta Mayor Shirley Franklin Monday appeared to take a shot at recent comments the former president made on Barack Obama's candidacy.

"We are about to witness the impossible being probable," Franklin, who has endorsed Obama, told the crowd at Ebenezer Baptist Church in Atlanta, where King once preached.

Franklin said that in times of trouble, America "stretches to elect a president from uncharted places — a mill worker's son, a first lady, a Mormon, a Baptist preacher, and even, ladies and gentlemen, a black man."

She added, "We are at the cusp of turning the impossible into reality. Yes this is reality, not fantasy or fairy tales."

Franklin's use of the word 'fairy tale' harkens back to comments Bill Clinton made earlier this month that have since been called insensitive and offensive by some high profile African Americans.

Speaking to New Hampshire voters on the day before that state's crucial primary, Clinton sharply criticized the media's coverage of Obama and said the idea that he has always been against the Iraq war is "the biggest fairy tale I've ever seen."

Those comments helped fuel a highly charged back in forth between Obama's campaign and that of Hillary Clinton on the issue of race. Both senators last week called on their supporters to move past the issue.

– CNN Ticker Producer Alexander Mooney

Filed under: Barack Obama • Bill Clinton


Andrew   January 22nd, 2008 12:35 pm ET

Sorry forrestine Eubanks, not everyone is a racist.

Sure, we shouldn't have our heads in the clouds, but we should also not bury our heads in the ground. People who vote based on race or gender or sexual preference are ridiculous. On that same note, those that follow blindly based on a past president or trivial matters are no better.

Tony, Enterprise, Alabama   January 22nd, 2008 8:34 am ET

She knows she took President Clinton's remarks out of context, and that he wasn't talking about Obama's candidacy.

She knows better, because the tape has been played ad nauseum. But that's okay, get behind him, vote for him ONLY because he is black instead of because he's qualified; and alienate the entire rest of the country.

Blacks make up about 13% of the population and 13% of the electorate. If every black man and woman voted for Obama they could not get him elected. He needs all the rest of us to get elected. So put the race card back in the deck, you whipped it out, now put it back.

We have an unqualified President in the White House right now, can we afford another four years?

Jgian   January 22nd, 2008 8:09 am ET

Shirley Franklin is a disgrace as a mayor. Her comments to President Clinton were based on nothing but lies, but then what can we expect from our mayor? She hasn't done anything positive for Atlanta during her terms. Conventions are leaving the city due to the high crime rate.

"Yes We Can"   January 22nd, 2008 5:11 am ET

Thank you mayor Franklin for your speech. Unlike the other leaders in the African American Community who worship the Clinton, you have shown your independence and strong character.

Let Billary have a taste of their own medicine. Obama supporters be ready to stay home in Novermber if these guys are allow to continue to place this good cap bad cap dirty politics. Stay home if Obama is not on the ticket. Let the Republican win the presidency in Novermber. That will teach the establishment of the Democractic party a lession.

Arthur Holmes   January 22nd, 2008 12:19 am ET

Former President Bill Clinton is joke. His wife Hillary goes on about experience like she is more knowledgeable than every person running. I'ts news to me that her time in the white house as the first lady counts towards her experience credits. Bill Clinton and his wife Hillary are fakes because they have not done anything directly to improve relations in America. In fact I don't recall Bill or Hill doing one thing specificly to help black's anywhere.

The South Carolina debate was one of the most unfair exchanges I've seen between candidates. Wolf Blitzer was BIAS towards Barrack Obama because he did not allow him to respond to the attacks of Hillary and John. Is it that difficult for a news media to be fair… What a joke. CNN, Obama will win in spite of your blatant attempts to shadow his image and quiet his voice. You cannot cut and paste Clinton in as pesident.

rw   January 22nd, 2008 12:17 am ET

Di said: where bill clinton was when the rwandan genocide was going on…

Subsequent to Mogadishu where under the UN mission the bodies of American soldiers were dragged through Mogadishu streets by savage mods and 54 Pakistani soldiers were killed, after which the UN pulled out, the world community dared not get involved in Rwanda.

anti obama   January 21st, 2008 11:49 pm ET

barrington: the playing field has changed in the last two weeks: whitres and women are being demonized by your canidate….read the blogs read the polls

forrestine Eubanks   January 21st, 2008 10:12 pm ET

Moderation is nice, but America's neck is on the line and we need a shrewd, experienced, connected, insightful, wheeling and dealing statesman to rise up and lead us from the brink. We are at a precipice in American history and if we are not to have the barbarians descend upon us as did Rome- it's going to take more than any of these candidates are showing us-least of all Obama. Frankly, he's not in the club, so he can't participate in the game in any meaningful way. Our enemies are sharpening their knives and laying their plots while we engage in a popularity contest for our next president. Obama, Huckabee, Richards and Edwards need to go home so we can have a better look at the other possibilities. And someone needs to tell Atlanta's mayor that we are in a fight for our lives not a seance where the "impossible becomes the posible"

forrestine Eubanks   January 21st, 2008 9:58 pm ET

Tell the truth Rob! Obama is not electable and if he wins the nomination- white Americans will come out of the clouds to send him a resounding NO. What does it take for us to get the message deal with the reality of our situation. The whole thing is a sham , fairy tale is a nice euphemism for it. MLK died so we could voteand you can bet your last dollar that I ain't wasting mine on no dressed up nonsense. Yours trkuly, an old, committed, been around the block activist who took her head out of the clouds and put her ear to the ground.

forrestine Eubanks   January 21st, 2008 9:50 pm ET

Please wake up- Clarence Thomas is black yet he votes the furthest right on the Supreme Court. Obama may be of "colored" skin tone, but there ain't nothing about him black. He was out there enough to cite his admiration of Ronald Reagan, and up in a black church pulpit talking about homophobia. What planet is he on. Perhaps he needs to win to finally aid the sophistication of self-serving wanne-be- white negroes-mad cause they aint- like Atlanta's mayor who spend their time and efforts having temper tantrums at white folk when it dawns on them that "they ain't got no power and aint running nothing but their mouths"instead of doing something of lasting consequence and substance for black people. The Republicans must be laughing their heads off- playing African Americans for the fool. Obama won't have an ounce of input, say-so, power, informatkon or nothing else if, God forbid, he does win. He won't even be included in the "real" conversations. Ask the black mayors of this country to tell us the real deal Wake up folks he's just another trick in the deck to derail the next election. Who's paying him? The wish is not the reality!

Doreen   January 21st, 2008 9:49 pm ET

Hon. Shirley Franklin
We the Islanders are with you!
It is time for a change with the Black Prsident

We have overcame!!!!!!

Big up (Respect) to you Mayor Franklin

Anonymous   January 21st, 2008 9:43 pm ET

Bill Clinton got a taste of his own medecine…he started a dirty campaign and along the way lost all the respect that many leaders had for him. Atlanta's mayor was more GRACEFUL than he ever will..

Walker   January 21st, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Poor John - He is really being left out

sharon   January 21st, 2008 9:27 pm ET

we have waited eight years for this. how sad we are why are we letting the money making media do this? such fine smart people who are running for office they are all so tierd now and have been run all over the country we need to stand up for them since the media has not we can't afford four more years so lets vote are hearts and not be swayed by the media.

Walker   January 21st, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Is there anything about Hiliary that she doesn't like or that she hasn't done. I wish they would have left their egos on the podiums.

James   January 21st, 2008 9:21 pm ET

Stop whining!!! Billary has had free reign to beat up on Obama. Billary is trying to bully their way back into the White House. Too bad so many people are looking back instead of forward… Where is Moveon.org?

KitchenBuddha   January 21st, 2008 9:16 pm ET

Abbi Tatton is TOO hot…tell her!

Jack ny, ny   January 21st, 2008 9:14 pm ET

she was sure strong enough to give Obama run for his money in tonight's debate. Obama was going um..a..um…o…um.

_________________________________________________________
Bill January 21, 2008 8:20 pm ET

Why can't Hillary stand on her own two feet? Will she run and hide behind Billy's coat if she gets elected and things get tough? Come on folks…the last thing we need is two Clintons in the White House…let alone one!

Barrington   January 21st, 2008 9:11 pm ET

Rob, you've obviously underestimated the viability of Obama's electability, try watching CNN, reading your newspaper, etc., in case you didn't know, there are millions of people, black, white, latino, etc. that feel he's the right choice for President, outside of Iowa. Those of you who are closet racists, will eventually have to deal with the inevitability of a president who's not a WHITE male, whether it be Obama or some other candidate in the future. Wake up people, America is changing. White is not always right for leadership in this country.

Jenny, Worcester MA   January 21st, 2008 9:01 pm ET

Once again, the morons of the democratic party, which is unfortuantely most of the party, will re-destroy the party with their dead-end identity politics.

They deserve defeat in 2008, if they have nothing to offer other than such ribbish.

docrock,lewisville,tx   January 21st, 2008 8:58 pm ET

Today ,we as Americans honor the memory of a truly Great American.He was not murdered,he was assassinated,becuase he spoke of Equal Rights as man.He just happened to be Black.I believe with all my heart that,even though I am a White man,he loved me as an equal,while in truth,he was a far better man than I could ever hope to be.So please all of you that care enough to support a candidate,let's lose the racist hate that seems to be rising.Please refrain from using the Reverend Dr.Martin Luther King Jr.'s name as a shield or a club.I will gaurantee that he would not want one moment spent on devisiveness while there are American soldiers of ALL races and gender shouldering the entire burden of the war,while the poor are hungry homeless and helpless.To play this game that seems to be insane.Please honor Dr.King as a man if nothing else.

Rob   January 21st, 2008 8:42 pm ET

Barrington

Do you really believe that a skewed Iowa Primary shows that Obama is electable? He isn't and it doesn't take a rocket scientist to do the math. Racism doesn't come from just the likes of Sharpton and Jackson. Whites are just as racist and outnumber African Americans 3 to 1. Just because they are not registered or don't take part in the Primaries doesn't mean they won't come out of the woodwork it Obama does win the nomination.

And if you think that the GOP won't pull out all of there cannons to fuel the race issue, you live in utopia. This whole thing stinks of Karl Rove. Eliminate Clinton now because Obama is the only one they know they can beat. Look at who the GOP is behind. McCain or should I say, Lil Bush…

Wallace Brown   January 21st, 2008 8:37 pm ET

I am a Black male in my mid-fifties who has always voted for a Democrat for President but if Hillary Clinton wins the Democratic nomination I will vote for a Republican for the first time in my life. If a Republican did what the Clintons have been doing - character assassination, mud-slingling, lying, and disaparaging Barack Obama my people would call them racists and be 100% correct. Why is it that the holier than thou Clintons get away with a hi-tech lynching of Obama and there is silence in our community???? I do not worship at the altar of Bill Clinton and what he and his henchman working for Hillary are doing is despicable and it's high time Black leaders stop being silent about it.

SD2   January 21st, 2008 8:34 pm ET

So sad to see such disparity amoungst the american voters.So much money spent for so many people, I beleive the money could be used for americans that really need the support, for their daily lives.

Pat   January 21st, 2008 8:32 pm ET

When GW Bush was running for President, his Ex-President father did not attack his Primary opponents, he simply campaigned for his son by highlighting his attributes. This seems to be the appropriate approach, in my opinion. Bill Clinton is dirtying up the process and making us wonder about Hillary's ability to stand up for herself. "Finding her voice" impressed me not at all. It sounded like something she should have said to her New Age shrink. It was not something for the possible Leader of the Free World to admit. Mayor Franklin should have kept her opinions to herself, my thinking. It is too easy to take these conflicts personally, whether you are Black, a woman, a Mormon or a Baptist. I liked McCain's response to Chuck Norris regarding his age: I may have to send my 95 year old mother over to wash his mouth out with soap"! I won't be voting for McCain but I felt he responded with friendly rivalry. He made his point.

Barrington   January 21st, 2008 8:28 pm ET

Shame on Bill Clinton, he's taken black Americans support for him for granted for too long, he's been dubbed America's first black president, which is a joke and an affront to a legitimate black presidential candidate such as Obama. The only reason African Americans have supported white Democrats in the past for president is b/c there's never been a viable black candidate like Obama. And since his Iowa victory, we have woken up and realized that our votes don't have to be taken for granted and we have the power to vote for someone who truly represents us. Shirley was telling like it is.

Beth   January 21st, 2008 8:21 pm ET

Vote for Hilliary and get Bill for President. Isn't that against the law? Who want a dynasty? Will Chelsy be next? Obama has a passion for the people. The Billary's a passion for the Presidency. Wake up people - until you have been President, none of us have experience! The Clinton's have their place in history - let it be over!

Bill   January 21st, 2008 8:20 pm ET

Why can't Hillary stand on her own two feet? Will she run and hide behind Billy's coat if she gets elected and things get tough? Come on folks…the last thing we need is two Clintons in the White House…let alone one!

Lees   January 21st, 2008 8:19 pm ET

Enough, enough, enough about race or gender or anything else not related directly to the issues. I am so tired of baseless comments fueled by the race card, which only exists because people continue to trot it out when it suits them. I live in the Atlanta area, am of color, and am so disgusted by the elitist power brokers who feel they can say what they wish because of their color. Franklin is among them. Vote for Obama because of his record if you wish, but stop the support and entitlements because of his color.

Farrell, Houston, Tx   January 21st, 2008 8:15 pm ET

The Clintons have never been held legally accountable for anything they say or do, they always get the "free pass". Voters need to say NO to the Clintons and stop giving them a free pass, when is America going to learn.

james madison   January 21st, 2008 8:14 pm ET

Green? You are talking about green? Bush was a ONE term governor from Texas. He hadn't been to Europe until he was elected president. Obama was a Law Professor prior to becoming a United States Senator. Change is what we all talk about, what we all want. Let's fix was has been broken in the last 8-12-16..20 years of Bush and Clinton presidencies. How long will two families rule this country? Aren't their other people qualified? Yes, there are. Let's get someone new. Someone smart with an educated perspective. We won't make progress with the same, same and same.

Bill, Covington,LA   January 21st, 2008 8:14 pm ET

Both Shirley Franklin and Bill Clinton need to wake up, they are not just dreaming, they are having nightmares.

tblem   January 21st, 2008 8:14 pm ET

Shame on you Shirley! This was an irresponsible comment focusing on a man who did more for our community than any other high profile American since MLK Jr. AND worst yet, to do this on the day we honor Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and his legacy makes it even more deplorable.

David Smith   January 21st, 2008 8:11 pm ET

Just plain rude! Mayor Franklin, shame on you!

T.Ford, Richmond, VA   January 21st, 2008 8:10 pm ET

America wake up!!!! We are in trouble as a country. We have been divided for years and look where it has gotten us. If you have a problem with people that are a diferrent color than you, than it's time for you to grow up. The word race should be eliminated from all documents, polls and applications that try to separate us into a certain group. We all breath the same air, we all bleed red blood. When is the last time you bought something that said, made in America? If we can't come together as a people then the American dream will continue to be a rode side bomb.

Dan, Minneapolis, MN   January 21st, 2008 8:06 pm ET

The "tipping point" has occurred with such remarks on this auspicious but public setting. It is a contest based on race and there are going to be unanticipated consequences by bringing the issue of race to the front.

Teri   January 21st, 2008 8:05 pm ET

John, you are just spinning against the Clinton's. Obama's wife has appeared several times on TV for Obama. Part of the joy of a spouse is to support each other. Instead of looking for trash and turning every thing into a story to support their belief, could humankind concentrate on what is the best way to honor our county and the citizens in it. I think Obama might be a good president after eight years of being taught and trained how to "Walk his Talk". He is charming and talks very well. All he needs is for the more experienced Democratic leaders to teach him the problems to over come, and how to REALLY create the CHANGE he talks about. Thank you for Being an American that is Honest and
Sincere about making this world a Better Place.

Maria   January 21st, 2008 8:04 pm ET

Clinton is not attacking the black community. He is counter attacking the opponent. He is backing up his wife, the best way he can, as a politician. Senator Obama is doing the same only in a less direct way. He apologizes for the INDISCRETIONS of his campaign staff and he is using the back community to bring up Racial problems. I really don´t trust Obama and I don´t think that he is up to the task to be a good president.

Alan   January 21st, 2008 8:03 pm ET

While I can't stand the Clintons, he DOES have a point. You would think the media is marrying Obama with how much attention he gets.

Kyu Reisch, Radcliff, Kentucky   January 21st, 2008 8:03 pm ET

Atlanta Mayor, What are you talking about? You can support Obama, but you can't cover Obama's record. Bill Clinton said his Anti Iraq War is fairy tales, it is true and Clinton was right. Obama and his wife attacked Hillary from the beginning, why he can't stand Clinton's true statement? This is very important for our Country, we decide our President, so we need to know about candidate as much as possible. I don't like Obama's attitude, he gave an evasive answers about himself. He is not ready for the President yet.

Mike T   January 21st, 2008 8:01 pm ET

If Hillary's last name wasn't Clinton and she hadn't been married to Bill Clinton, nobody would even know who she was and nobody would care one iota what she says or thinks.

And if her husband hadn't come out and campaigned for her: first, she wouldn't be a Senator, and second, she wouldn't have won a single state in this primary. I really think that most of the people voting for her think they are voting for Bill Clinton, and do not understand that he can't be president again. They need to read the Constitution.

Clinton also gets help from the media, including CNN. Ever notice that every time there is a story about the 3 candidates, like the one on the CNN homepage right now - Hillary's picture is first, Obama's is second, and Edward's is third. Is that supposed to be subliminal, or what? Further, they always seem to choose a flattering picture of Clinton, and the worst pictures they can find of the other two. Is that not bias as well?

earl illingsworth   January 21st, 2008 8:01 pm ET

The fact that Bill was no where to be found six months ago baffles me? But, and that's a big But , Hillary's coronation has hit a road block. Can someone spell Obama, yea , and he's uniqued in every way, this young wipper-snapper! Can you imagine, he dares buck the system. As a sophomore senator against the dynamic dual. What managerial skills does Bush #43 have, please don't answer that,or Bill Clinton?(advocate for WALMART&Co.). We have a congress so old and inbetted that they make Ceasar Agusta's Senate look like kindergarden kids. Obama is so right for America now that the Clinton's, good cop, bad cop, and alittle trianglation mixed in, can't get this young imaginative and realistic senator from Illinois to diviate his message! He knows what americans want, health care, job security, better schools,and a respectable pull out of Iraq with dignity. Go Obama!!!!!!

1971guy   January 21st, 2008 8:00 pm ET

Franklin: worst mayor ever; family all crooks (true and it had to be said)…sorry shortcake..

Robert, Gastonia, North Carolina   January 21st, 2008 7:58 pm ET

Why is it when we try to point out the double standards Obamas people call us racist? I am the furthest from racist you can get. i grew up in the north where equality really does exist. I am also a gay man and stand up for injustice wherever it may be. This is hypocricy and I will continue to call it out.

mmp   January 21st, 2008 7:56 pm ET

what does it say when a wife needs to send her husband out to fight her battles? i had a lot of respect for bill clinton but have lost much of it in the last few weeks. who is running for office here? bill or hillary?

Please   January 21st, 2008 7:56 pm ET

My question is, how does Bill Clinton saying the coverage of Obama's war record is a fairy tale, become about race? Does that make any sense at all? The media heleped and Donna Brazile spoke without thinking. But Obama will only hurt himself with this line, people don't want to see a candidate cry racism, especially over something like their record on the war, which has NOTHING to do with race. If i were Obama id call people like Donna and Clyburn and tell them to just be quiet

Robert, Gastonia, North Carolina   January 21st, 2008 7:55 pm ET

another example of whats good for the goose is not necessarily good for the gander. Will the black community rise up and demand an appology? i doubt it. The double standards thrive.

troy   January 21st, 2008 7:54 pm ET

Easy for you to say skin color means nothing Jim, after all how many non white presidential candidates have you ever voted for?

Jack ny, ny   January 21st, 2008 7:53 pm ET

Mayor Franklin just showed that she has a brain as big as pea. She is talking about this that has been calrified. Well she thinks she is on Jerry Springer show.

shortcake72   January 21st, 2008 7:51 pm ET

Thank you Mayor Franklin. Somebody had to say it, and you did good. Bill Clinton is out of control. It makes me wonder if he was a phony all along. Stay in your lane, Bill Clinton and play fair.

Dee H   January 21st, 2008 7:51 pm ET

At least Bill Clinton will take the hit like a man. Obama is a sniveling wimp, who does'nt like to stand and fight on his own. He has to have the media and others do the fighting for him. He's a smooth talking stuffed suit, trying to use race as a shield. He's a softy and has no backbone. We don't need a CRY BABY in the White House.

Vic, Las Vegas, Nevada   January 21st, 2008 7:51 pm ET

This woman is a sad example of an informed individual.

OK now folks, it's gonna be the 50's and 60's all over again.

Jim in Columbus, MS   January 21st, 2008 7:50 pm ET

I think it's very sad that the South Carolina Black community is probably going to give Obama more than 80% of its support just because of the color of his skin. If he was a white senator from Illinois with two years of experience, they would be clamoring for a Hillary Clinton presidency. The Clintons, both Bill AND Hillary, have done more for the Black community than Obama, but now they're
"untouchable"? What a shame!

Ray   January 21st, 2008 7:48 pm ET

THANK YOU Irma!! Thats for all those stupid people asking who's the one running.

Fo   January 21st, 2008 7:47 pm ET

OK, I just want to make sure I've got this straight…

Hillary Clinton's supporters (including BIll) can attack Barack Obama any way they want, including distorting his record and parsing every little thing he says until it's inside-out, and that's fine, it's just how elections work.

But if Obama's supporters fight back, it's the "whining" of a "baby" and proves he "can't take it," or even worse, it's a slander endangering the entire party and dishonoring mom and apple pie.

OK, got it.

Now there's just one more thing I want to get straight…

If an African-American supports Barack Obama, it's obviously only because he's black and that's short-sighted and wrong-headed. Or it's because we're all star-struck by Oprah Winfrey. Or because he's never been asked a serious question by the media.

But supporting Hillary just because she's a woman is neither short-sighted nor wrong-headed. Indeed, any failure to support Hillary is clear evidence of misogyny. And there's no way any of her supporters could be star-struck by Bill. And Hillary, who was called the "presumptive front runner" for over a year, has never had a bit of positive press in her life.

Nope, no double-standards in this race!

docrock,lewisville,tx   January 21st, 2008 7:47 pm ET

Are we in the twilight zone?I was under the false impression that this was a Presidential Primary.Not only have the best candidates already stepped out,Now we as a Nation have turned this into a race/gender war.Freedom of speech is imperitive to Democracy,but to wish ill,or threaten to switch parties if YOUR choice for President is not only foolish,but it undermines everything the Reverend Dr.Martin Luther King JR. ever stood for,or believed.To use his name as a political tool,is not only reprehensible,it cheapens this Great man's memory.Come on Democrats,lets try to be civil.Try not to use the Hate word,and remember that the laughter you hear is the Republican Party literally busting a gut laughing.If you want four more years of declining wages,the Health Crisi worsening,the rich getting richer and the middle class disappearing completely,call each other names like children in a playground,and I'll gaurantee a Republican win in November.Stop this insanity now please.

troy   January 21st, 2008 7:45 pm ET

I still don't believe white Americans would vote for a half-black man over a white male Republican for President, in fact I believe it to be impossible. Especially with the bigoted Hispanics supporting anything white.

And yes take a look at these countries where these Hispanics come from, and how they treat dark skinned people.

Mike T   January 21st, 2008 7:45 pm ET

"Watching CNN this afternoon it looked like one long afternoon of commercial for Obama. "

Yet every time there is a story about the 3 candidates, like the one on the CNN homepage right now - Hillary's picture is first, Obama's second, and Edward's third. Further,they always seem to choose a flattering picture of Clinton, and the worst pictures they can find of the other two. Is that not bias as well?

1971guy   January 21st, 2008 7:45 pm ET

obama won't unite b/c this dem and many others will either vote rep or stay home if he wins nomination….how is this uniting people? 85 percent of blacks voted for him in Nevada; 35 percent white and less hispanics? He and his bickering are tearing us apart!r?

Tom Davie   January 21st, 2008 7:42 pm ET

Racist have join the board. Hillary people.

v.ananthan   January 21st, 2008 7:41 pm ET

Am I dreaming??
Afro american politicians, afro american actors, afro american talk show hosts all are giving thier unconditional support to OBAMA and at the same time critizing the Clintons and the race is NOT the issue???

CJ   January 21st, 2008 7:40 pm ET

I like you already Mayor Franklin because your words are true. Truth always, and I repeat truth always prevails over lies (hint, hint Bill). I think Franklin said just the right thing at just the right to a former President who was finally sitting down with his mouth closed and one who thinks he is above the truth. Remember he is the president that was IMPEACHED, he knows how to lie and get caught at the same time. Keep it up Bill, your approval rating is dropping faster than W. Bush and that is a lot. BC is acting like it is his race and how WRONG he is on that point. The American people know darn well that if they vote for the name Clinton on any primary ballot, they won't get Bill even though he wishes it could be him, instead the voters would get someone who claims to have the experience that BC has, lies and all.

irma   January 21st, 2008 7:40 pm ET

Okay, you think Bill Clinton invited himself? So the mayor would have said that anyway? I think the invite got her national media attention and she knew it. Then took a swing at him. Now everyone is talking about it. She knew what she was doing, she's a politician. I guess some will do anything at any cost.

Murry   January 21st, 2008 7:39 pm ET

Thank you, Mayor Franklin for putting things in perspective. Hope for a better world is not a fairy tale as MLK showed us. Obama is the best candidate to carry us forward. Vote for Obama 08

James Brown ( Independent )   January 21st, 2008 7:39 pm ET

Bill Clinton disgraced the oval office and now he is making a total arse of himself. The Clinton's have no shame , but they are about to earn some. The DNC will start penalizing the Clinton Campaign if o'l slick willy keeps acting out in un-truthful underhanded ways.

JJ   January 21st, 2008 7:37 pm ET

I like you already Mayor Franklin because your words are true. Truth always, and I repeat truth always prevails over lies (hint, hint Bill). I think Franklin said just the right thing at just the right to a former President who was finally sitting down with his mouth closed and one who thinks he is above the truth. Remember he is the president that was IMPEACHED, he knows how to lie and get caught at the same time. Keep it up Bill, your approval rating is dropping faster than W. Bush and that is a lot. BC is acting like it is his race and how WRONG he is on that point. The American people know darn well that if they vote for the name Clinton on any primary ballot, they won't get Bill even though he wishes it could be him, instead the voters would get someone who claims to have the experience that BC has, lies and all.

Don   January 21st, 2008 7:36 pm ET

Bill Clinton never called Obama's campaign for President a fairytale. Why is this women bringing up an issue that should really be laid to rest. Even more strange, why isn't the media all over this. Could it be that its not from the Clinton side stirring up trouble??

vp las vegas   January 21st, 2008 7:36 pm ET

Obama needs to watch his mouth. I was at the caucus in Nevada. I got to see first hand the intimidation tactics and hear the lies from his camp. Obama can drop the saint act. I would switch parties rather than vote for someone who employs the tactics his camp has used.

Marlene   January 21st, 2008 7:35 pm ET

Nik T: "Is he gonna whine and have his buddies in congress defend him? Obama is a baby, a whiner, and a novice."

How on earth can you criticize Obama for fighting back? Hillary has Bill doing all her dirty work for her. She did dirty deeds for him for years, he's paying her back and they're both disgraceful, shameless, and disgusting.

Obama is fighting and slogging his way through the mud, calculating smears, and idiocy that the Clintons and their machine throw at him with his head up. He refuses to stoop to their level and I'm proud to be supporting him, a real person.

Most Americans can see the truth. Obama will revive our country.

Chris, Orlando FL   January 21st, 2008 7:34 pm ET

Appalling. Is the Mayor dumb, deaf and blind? Has she not been briefed on what occured here? Bill Clinton NEVER implied that Obama, his campaign, or his chances of getting elected were a fairy tale. The President was speaking directly to the Senator's views on Iraq and the war. Bill's comments should never have been associated with race. For Shirley Franklin to make such an incendiary remark, ESPECIALLY given that she is an Obama supporter, is outrageous.

DemAtty   January 21st, 2008 7:31 pm ET

I am not against Hillary, just FOR OBAMA…the racial issue is disgusting…the Clinton campaign has been flirting with this line for a very long time (educate yourself on it)…they have managed to blur it and now they want us to pretend that there could not have been a racial motivation behind Billary's comments…give me a break…

The Mayor's comments are tacky…please get back to the issues…endorse him…do not carry on these arguments that are dividing us all… Bill (as much as I love him) needs to let his wife win her own presidency…it was his selfish acts that gave us years of Bush!

As for Obama being green…WOW…I guess there is a reason why OBAMA is mostly being supported by highly educated people….I'm kidding…honestly…the man broke into politics through work in inner city Chicago…community organizing…working with both the left and the right….give him his propers! Hillary deserves hers too…

If we keep this up, Democrates jeopardize the general election…

Lisa, Corpus Christi,Tx   January 21st, 2008 7:31 pm ET

How is it the Clinton's throw race out there first, but anyone who dares to challenge Clinton's comments are labeled as racists or playing the race card?

President Clinton should be very proud of himself. He has accomplished a great deal in the last few weeks:

1. Dividing the democratic party…possibly beyond repair.
2. Dividing voters along racial lines…most blacks supported Hillary until he
opened his big mouth..so it was never about race.
3. Causing embarassment to America as a whole. He is a former leader of the
greatest country in the world, and he is behaving like a complete moron.
4. Reassuring the rebublicans they will have a member of their party in the white
house in 2009 because democrats no longer have a party leader, as Bill
decided the ends justifies the means…to hell with the democratic party.

I support Edwards, but will vote for Obama if he receives the nomination. I will under no circumstances vote for Hillary Clinton. I am looking at McCain if she receives the nomination.

tomw   January 21st, 2008 7:31 pm ET

i will post on here what i have posted on others to anybody that says obama is whinning u must not be reading or watching tv —— hilary was crying bill keeps getting in the face of the press and there team took a union to court in nevada because it wasnt fair. obama has only said that he thinks it is desparate and troubling. wow that doesnt sound like whinning but what the clintons are whinning all the time

David S   January 21st, 2008 7:30 pm ET

Well, we have a war in the democratic party. Big surprise. Can you imagine what it must take to wake up every morning and say, "I should be President of the United States?" That's a whole lot of ego and it makes sense that both of them may get so caught up in winning this election, they do things that should not be done. I think Hillary is smart and capable; I think she has sold out her values over time in order to win this election. I think Obama is smart and capable, and frankly, his message of bringing the country together is more important to me than anything else. I am a White, Jewish Gay man, so go ahead, slander me. I am voting for Obama. (BUT I WOULD RATHER VOTE FOR GORE!!).

Tom Sims   January 21st, 2008 7:30 pm ET

The real issue here is that Bill Clinton made the remark. Not Hillary. Hillary gets to take the high road while a former president gets to say whatever he wants. Maybe Bill should be allowed to debate for her as well. Were supposed to be deciding between Hillary and Barak. Its not whining for the Obama camp to question who is really talking and who should be taking responsibility for the comments being made.

Jo   January 21st, 2008 7:29 pm ET

It boggles the mind… It is such a HUGE stretch to say that because the Mayor used the words fairy tale in her proud accounting of all those who are contending for the nomination, that she was slapping Mr. Clinton. It often feels like a fairy tale: a woman and a Black person seriously contending for the nomination for President of the United States. I never thought it would happen in my lifetime. I am so proud of us. And so bleeping tired of the media. Would any of you honestly have thought that Ms. Franklin was saying anything other than, "can you believe it?" with her words if the media hadn't gone dirt digging. It seems to be about the only thing for which reports in general have much talent these days.

DB   January 21st, 2008 7:26 pm ET

Did you ever think Bill invited himself to this gathering, trying to sway some votes. The Mayor has already stated who she is supporting and on MLK day it is a tribute that a Black man is in the contention for president. 50 years ago no one would have ever thought that was possible.

irma   January 21st, 2008 7:23 pm ET

Maxine, Hillary Clinton is running for President. Her husband is supporting her by speaking on the campaign trail as are the spouses of others. Her husband is President Clinton, when he speaks, people listen, mainly the Republican media so that they can tear him apart. Obama, Obama's supporters and backers are jumping on that Republican bandwagon in order to make Obama seem victimized; even though he has received positive media attention that has pushed his campaign as the "chosen one." Unfortunately, the Obama campaign has unnoticed surrogates who get to fling mud which his supporters and media use over and over. So the former President is being asked to shut up, by the upstanding citizens of our Democracy; because no one is allowed to say anything negative about Obama. Hillary has worked on behalf of Children’s issues all of her life; that is the number one reason I support her. Her philosophy is one that I also share; do what it takes to help Americans function financially, and other ways that will benefit the whole family. Provide funding for education and specific social programs that help to train people for better jobs. I read her books, I know where she stands on issues and as a teacher I believe her because it is the same reason for why I teach. Level the playing field. That is why the Republicans hate her. She is seen as a socialist. Pro society is apparently a bad thing because that’s where tax dollars would have to go.

Kris In Atlanta   January 21st, 2008 7:23 pm ET

This Shirley Slur is insulting to me for two reasons. One, it shows how pathetic and self-serving the mayor's comments are in attacking President Clinton: She happens to be Obama's campaign leader for this area! Talk about hypocritical. Second, as a lifelong Atlantan, I certainly do not believe Shirley Franklin should be criticizing Bill Clinton for anything. Bill Clinton spent his career helping people to better themselves, many of whom may have in turned voted for Shirley Franklin here in Atlanta, a mayor who in the opinion of myself and many others, is very ineffectual, surrounded by scandals, dishonest and happily in the pockets of big business.

She ran for office promising to eradicate homelessness; instead it increased under her watch! She sounded ridiculous last week admitting, shamelessly, that she had no idea an old run-down building centered downtown, a massive complex by architectural standards, merely blocks from her office, served as a de facto homeless shelter. Talk about out of touch! Shirley should stick to what she knows best-being a do-nothing, know-nothing mayor-and leave Bil Clinton alone.

Brennan - Seattle, WA   January 21st, 2008 7:22 pm ET

Martin Luther King JR would have done the same thing.

It is called "Speaking Truth to Power"

In this case Bill Clinton is holding the power of his ex-presidency and expects to get no backlash when he distorts and misconstrues his wife's opponent.

It amazes me that the Clinton's who for so many years stood for equal rights and now when they are faced with an African American candidate, they corner him and marginalize him with his "blackness". Barack Obama did not want to be "The Black Candidate". The Clinton's saw it as beneficial to their campaign to paint him into that corner and did so without hesitation. They got caught doing it and are now getting called on it, rightfully so.

The Clinton's will do anything to win the election and unless Obama mobilizes the masses against the establishment it will be difficult to counteract their tactics. It remains true, however that Hillary and Bill will be the unifying force for the Republican Party should they garner the nomination.

Steve, Lyons, CO   January 21st, 2008 7:21 pm ET

An Obama supporter says:
"I have a dream and it has been realized a candidate and a future President that will transcend this nation - we have friends in the blue states and the red states - we are all one, we are America!"

All that I'm suddenly seeing from you Obama people is divisive hatred - you attack the Clintons as if they haven't always been staunch supporters of black and other minority rights. You act as if Bill Clinton was a failure as president. You say you won't vote Democratic if Hillary gets nominated.

You don't have a dream. You have a demand. And you'll help further screw up America by handing this election to Republicans. Keep up the good work, loudmouths. Keep showing us that Obama couldn't bring together the country with the increasingly angry rabble that supports him.

Julie S. Hope, AR   January 21st, 2008 7:20 pm ET

barack the vote! Barack All the Way! Hillary for VP (without Bill)

LV   January 21st, 2008 7:18 pm ET

As Americans we must stay focused on the "real" issues when making a decision as to who should be out next President. Most importantly, the reality that Obama fails to take a stand on critical issues.

The fact is that Obama voted "present" 129 while in the Senate. He voted "present "on a bill that sought to protect the privacy of sex abuse victims, a bill that imposed stricter requirements for parental fitness for adoptions, on a bill that would increase penalties for the use of firearms within 1,000 feet of a school, an on a bill that would prohibit the presence of adult sex shops near schools, places of worship, and day care facilities. He refuses to stand up for a woman's right to choose repeatedly as his "present" vote demonstrates this on important legislation. We need someone who can take a stand, and this is definitely is not Obama.

Hillary became the first Democrat to offer a fiscal stimulus package. Then Obama followed 48 hours later with a stimilus package that included the same proposal that Hillary had submitted 2 days earlier. the only differnece bing that he provided $10 billion to Senator Clinton's $30 billion. Ask yourselves what does this say about how he prepared he is to take on the role of President of the United States?

People get your heads out of the sand, do your homework, and vote based upon the real issues which include: immigration, war, education, and our economy. We are not voting for the golden globes, whomever we elect will represent us to the world. It's time we vote for someone who can make a difference — vote for Hillary!!!!!!!!!!

Jean   January 21st, 2008 7:17 pm ET

I believe that should read "back and forth", not "back in forth". Does CNN have an editor?

The Smart One   January 21st, 2008 7:16 pm ET

I am proud that Mr Obama is running for the highest office in our great land. Carry on sir, HOWEVER! I am sick and tired of every single person taking the issue of race and blaming it on why someone is not a qualified candidate! Just because someone is of color does not mean they get "special treatment" and it seems when someone makes a comment against someone of color, whether it be true or not, it ends up being racist. Folks, Madam Mayor, it is time to grow up. Vote for who you believe is the best candidate for President and support them. Keep race out of this office, please oh please keep it out!

Christian, Tampa FL   January 21st, 2008 7:15 pm ET

Bill should never have used a word as incendiary as "fairy tale" and he knew it the moment he said it. The word seemed far too loaded to be used just about Obama's war record, and it really gets Barack's supporters fired up, because we resent the idea that we just can't have a President Obama.

To Bill's credit, I think he's tried to step back from the zeal he showed.

LaDonna   January 21st, 2008 7:15 pm ET

I Agree Bill Clinton needs to chill, How is Hillary Going to be president if she can not even deal with the debates on her own and leave it to hubby.

Jay   January 21st, 2008 7:14 pm ET

Maxi, I remember John Edwards had some ads some time last years

Joy   January 21st, 2008 7:14 pm ET

Its Seem OK to say attack or question the other Democratic or Republican candidates about their RECORD or political positions but NOT OK to attack or question OBAMA's record or polical position without being labeled a RACIST, a LIAR???

Is this some form of REVERSE DISCRIMINATION? What will OBAMA do when criticized at at later time (if he ever wins the PRIMARY or the PRESIDENCY) by the REPUBLICAN's, the MEDIA or ANYONE? Are they going to be labeled RACISTS or LIAR too? Will he have his supporters go on TV, Radio or on their FACE to a congregation on people inside the CHURCH discredit the person questioning his records or position. Does one have to be "NICE" to someone because he/she is BLACK, ASIAN or LATINO but you CANT be "NICE" to someone because he/she is WHITE? If one places himself/herself in this political ARENA, he/she should be able to take all GOOD, BAD and UGLY!

If OBAMA can't take the HEAT now, how can he take the HEAT later?

Mati   January 21st, 2008 7:13 pm ET

All I hope is that the last days will wake up Americans. What this woman did was disgraceful! Same with Clyburn "chill out on Obama". Who is Obama? and what should ALL Americans expect from him? Unity? change? hope? Nothing he did so far suggest this will happen. This is not about African Americans only, its about ALL Americans.

If he wants to speak for 12% and manipulate the other 88% to reach his goals, its not going to happen. He created division between parents and their children, between black and the others, between less educated and educated. I cannot speak for race, but older people will always care about their children and more educated people will always have a social responsibility toward those with less education. There is no division there, as it started to surface during Obama's campaign. And the worst it can happen is to create a racial divide.

I don't know how Bill Clinton made the black and white Dems to stick together around him for so many years, and now Obama succeeded to induce this stupid division. He was unable to compete with Hillary on real campaign issues so decided to use the race card. Irresponsible.

Ibeam   January 21st, 2008 7:13 pm ET

Even the dem leaders are pissed with the Clintons….Everyone is tried of the Clintons. Now that the pressure is on, once again, we see the true nature of the Clintons. Instead of bring people together, they are trying to drive them apart…Come on people we can do better…

Cha   January 21st, 2008 7:12 pm ET

Watching CNN all day it looked like one long patronizing day for Obama. CNN is pro-Obama. All news items are trying to make Bill Clinton look utterly pathetic, when he is only responding to arguments by Obama. CNN should be asking the candidates about the "real" issues - economy, home forclosures, Iraq war, health care. Where is responsible journalism these days?

National   January 21st, 2008 7:12 pm ET

I think that if Mr. Obama win the presidency he will divide the country even more I don't. Know why Black people just talk about race and not the things that are better for this country, In my own oppinion that I'm intitle to because the constitution say that. I think that most black are even more races them the white one, when you talk about anything that is black you have to be very carful because they get insulted on anything, I'm starting to feel simpathy for Mrs. Clinton. I'm spanish just in case and i'm not racist i'm just saying what think on all of this, I think that Mr. Clinton has the right to defend his wife and that's what he is doing i don't see anything wrong with that..

Thomas, NV   January 21st, 2008 7:10 pm ET

HILLARYLOVER - If the statements Bill made were even remotely factually accurate as you claim, please site references. Valid sources please, not the Hillary cheerleading squad.

Hillary voted for the war, which is accurate. Did she hope that one wouldn't pass as well?

Frank- Boca raton, FL   January 21st, 2008 7:09 pm ET

Stop this "Barack has no experience" crap! Remember, HRC with all her "extensive" experience voted FOR THE WAR! After a few years of heavily critizing the IRAQ war she voted in support for another potential war.
Bush was the governor of a very large state before he took office. We all know what a great job he and done. Has anyone read Dick Chenney's resume lately!! Pretty experienced guy don't you think!!
Shame on us as american to elect the same people again and again and then wonder why we are falling behind…way behind in the developed world.

Bob Sadler   January 21st, 2008 7:08 pm ET

My next vote for president: Gladys Knight! A black Mormon woman with appeal to anyone who has great taste in music!

Thomas, NV   January 21st, 2008 7:08 pm ET

Obama is not a whiner. He has stated that he feels as if he is running against both of them. The Clinton tactics, while very strategic, are highly inappropriate. It is not appropriate for Bill to slander his wife's opponent. Michele isn't out there blasting Hillary, and Bill could follow that example. Of course, Bill could have followed many examples in the past and made this a much easier run for Hillary, but he couldn't keep his pants on long enough for that. Anybody who believes the words that come out of Bill's mouth after his legacy of misdirection is an Idiot. Of course, that just depends on what your "definition of IS is."

Obama is not taking swipes at the former president either, but rather constantly defending himself from Bill's attacks. Don't you get it? He is running interference in order to keep Obama from actually convincing the general public that he is more qualified than his opponents, which he is and the facts are there to support that statement.

Let's lose the negativity and let these candidates talk about the issues. Bill is just there to preserve his legacy by running a negative and misleading campaign against Obama.

Are you voting for her, or for him? And if so, don't you think that it would be wise to achieve unity within the Democratic party instead of tearing it apart at the seams? Now I understand why I've remained independant for so long. This constant bickering and divisive behavior is only going to ensure that a Republican is elected again. If Clinton supporters were wise, they would ask Bill to put a sock in it as well, before he destroys this party and any chances that we do have of getting a Democrat back in the Oval office.

May the best candidate win, but not in a way that will divide this country once again and allow for 4 more years of a government that supports the rich and steals from the poor.

scaryjello   January 21st, 2008 7:07 pm ET

It is a myth that Bill ever did a thing for the black community. What walls/ceilings did Bill break? What walls/ceilings are there? It is a myth. Opening house in Harlem does not equate to performing great things for the black community. Lets clear house. I am young and impatient and I want to see some change. I don't want to spend my life in a time where nothing happens. Go Obama!! Unity, prosperity and brotherhood.

Mike Scarangella
Nuclear Engineer

James D.   January 21st, 2008 7:06 pm ET

For those of you calling her statement "disgraceful" , etc….if THAT is disgraceful, I'm at a TOTAL loss for words to describe Bill Clinton's dishonest rants and Karl Rovian tactics against Obama. I applaud her statement as a way of saying…"Bill…Stop your dishonest campaign against Obama. Play fair".

Bill Clinton, within the last 24 hours has been called out by Jim Clyburn, Rahm Emanuel and TED KENNEDY to back off with his DISHONEST, baseless attacks on Obama. The discussion between Bill and Ted Kennedy was "heated". When politicians tell other politicians…PUBLICLY….that they've crossed the line and to "chill"…it must be perceived as VERY BAD behavior. Bill Clinton is the one disgraced.

JC   January 21st, 2008 7:06 pm ET

Honesty, Unity, Progress, Experience (real life), results, inpirational= Obama

Lies, Devisive, Step Backward, Silve Spoon, failures, depressing=Hillary

Let's join together for America with the one candidate who is looking forward, leading with a positive message, and had proven results and more experience with no failures - Obama 08

Concerned   January 21st, 2008 7:06 pm ET

Again, another ridiculous distortion! I hope the good folks of Atlanta can see a lack of talant and tact when they hear it! The Clinton's have stood for civil/human rights longer than many of the Barack supporters have been alive…please be serious! And as far as Hillary she actually has a higher rating with human rights groups such as the Save the Darfur campaign because she has worked longer and harder toward human rights than her competition–and this is just one small example of her life long record speaking louder than his elaborate speeches.

Paul   January 21st, 2008 7:05 pm ET

PLEASE can we get back to the issues!!! Barack was the one who started the "Change" deal, everyone jumped on board after saying it was silly. Now Hillary wants to use it and say she has been doing it for 35 years. She even has tried to use the whole fired up and ready to go. So tell me this Black, White or Green, should we have the best decision maker in office or the best connected person? should Chelsea be the next president after Hillary, after all she will have more "experience" the anyone. if you really look at what Hillary and Barack have done on there on merit not there friends or spouses, you'll quickly see the smoke and mirrors not to mention Washington connections. Lets be done with that already. Please look at the facts and don't go for this whole distraction campaign. There was a time and season for the Clintons, it has come and gone I voted for him both times. They are not my enemy. Lets Grow Up as a country and put this silly fighting over race away for good we look very immature and silly in the world view.

OBAMA 2008   January 21st, 2008 7:05 pm ET

I am glad someone is noticing that Bill Clinton is having a real hard time accepting that maybe just maybe out new president will be black a better than at the job than what he has been what our current president has been and he doesn't like it. but if Bill wins OPPS I mean Hillary wins then he will get to run the country all over again and people are stupid not to believe that!

irma   January 21st, 2008 7:04 pm ET

Yeah Phil! Great comment and I know what you mean…..Pretty slanted editing huh? There are comments that are just verbally outrageous and those make it through time after time. Yet criticize the actual media you are commenting on and forget it! Hillary wins New Hampshire; Media discredits voters by saying women felt sorry for her, and Obama tries to overshadow his loss with having the media announce support from Kerry. Hillary wins popular vote in Nevada, despite Culinary Union endorsement for Obama. She received votes from people concerned about housing and Obama and media reduce her victory by claiming it was about the delegates. Anyone see the pattern? Now a mayor brings up the racial divide by misquoting Clinton and Obama supporters are all over it, cheering her on. Not issue based, race based. Very telling indeed……..

Genni   January 21st, 2008 7:03 pm ET

Did I see that correctly? Barack was chewing gum at the MLK event today??? Yikes, Oprah would not approve!

Karl   January 21st, 2008 7:03 pm ET

I couldnt be more proud of someone to stand up and not be afriad to let her voice be heard. I think Dr. King would be smiling right now
I'm voting democrat regardless but..

OBAMA FOR PRESIDENT!!!!

Keith Blake   January 21st, 2008 7:02 pm ET

I love these comments. Relevant, Articulate, Challenging…

Maxi   January 21st, 2008 7:02 pm ET

Actually, Jay, I don't believe it has to do with money. Apparently there was a early state pledge signed by all democrats, that prohibiterd any kind of campaign activity (outside of fundraising) in states that do not adhere to the DNC calendar. Since Florida is one of these states, and since their primaries are not yet over, an add on CNN (who broadcast in Florida), the Obama add is in violation of this pledge

Ed   January 21st, 2008 7:02 pm ET

BTW………Didn't Bill Clinton also say today at the MLK ceremony today how much it moved him as he sat alone at the age of 16 and watched or listened to the "I Have A Dream " speech and that he remembered so vividly what he was wearing, what he was feeling, that he cried, and it changed his life? Let's see the "I Have A Dream" sppech at the Lincoln memorial was August 28, 1963 and William Jefferson Clinton was born on August 19, 1946, I guess it moved him so much that he forgot that he was 17 years old. Do your research. Get Informed, Stay Involved, and Free Yourself ! ! !

kay   January 21st, 2008 7:01 pm ET

Unbeleivable and dispicable. Obama is OVER after South Carolina. I hope this week goes by fast for the Clintons, they should not have to take a racial beating like this!!!

Joojo   January 21st, 2008 6:58 pm ET

I am really disappointed at how the media wants to gag the Clintons but rejoices when shots are fired at them. Its ok for all the African Americans to vote en-bloc for Obama but…………I think what it boils down to is just to see the HRC lose but I guess the more they go at them, the stronger they become. Anybody remembers when the ex-president was quiet when Michelle Obama and Liz Edwards were running around making so much noise?
Take it Obama will never win

di   January 21st, 2008 6:58 pm ET

can someone tell me where bill clinton was when the rwandan genocide was going on… the clintons cannot bash the bush administration over katrina.. they are all the same.

Wayne   January 21st, 2008 6:58 pm ET

So When does the Mayor of Atlanta apologize for purposefully distorting what Bill Clinton said? Playing the race card on MLK Day. Is that fitting, ironic, or just the "New" politics Obama keeps talking about.

David S., Chicago, IL   January 21st, 2008 6:57 pm ET

Bring it on! Let Bill continue his rampage! Campaign all you want, it will only backfire on himself and HRC supporters…good luck with the old!

Next time, maybe Hillary will learn to tell her husband to shutup, unitl then, I STILL WILL NOT VOTE FOR HILLARY - have fun try to convice other millions of democratic voters…

OBAMA ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!

I have a dream and it has been realized a candidate and a future President that will transcend this nation - we have friends in the blue states and the red states - we are all one, we are America!

Chloe   January 21st, 2008 6:56 pm ET

You Clinton supporters just do not get it. Obama's campaign was never about race…that is until Billy Boy made it about race. Why can't you guys be honest. This is just another one of the Clinton's shameless tactics…throw race out there, divide the party, and then claim "my words were miscontrued". Hilary and Bill both have IQs well above normal, they were quite aware of what they were doing. I guess most of Hillary's supporters do not, as they just don't get it.

If Hilary is receives the nomination, then the democrats get exactly what they deserve…at least four more years of a republican in the white house.

Rob   January 21st, 2008 6:56 pm ET

NEWSFLASH…

CNN comes out of the closet. No longer is FOX alone in one-sided reporting.

Today CNN clearly endorsed Obama, a DemoPublican, for President. While not coming out and directly saying it, it became clear with most of it's coverage promoting Obama and the Race Card, while blasting Bill Clinton. It became clear that Blitzer, Dobbs, Cafferty and a host of others are not journalists but big-headed Pundits just like Bill O. (journalists report facts, pundits spin facts).

Jason   January 21st, 2008 6:52 pm ET

It is about time someone put Bill in his place. He united the country during his presidency, but now with his antics he is dividing the party trying to promote his wife's bid for the presidency.

If he continues to prepetuate this party infighting then he might as well hand the keys of the White House to the Republican nominee.

Bill, have a Coke, a smile and shut up please.

Charlie   January 21st, 2008 6:51 pm ET

I was at the event today. One thing CNN got wrong is that Clinton was in the crowd in FRONT of her, down in the first pew (she was up on the stage). But everything else is right on. She was definitely needling him, and good for her. She also said one other thing that might've been construed as pro-Obama. Franklin mentioned that Georgia was on her mind and, judging from recent media reports, it's also on the mind of the next president of the United States. The crowd really roared for that one, and I think that Franklin (an outspoken champion of Obama) definitely was referring to Obama's appearance at Ebenezer the day before, and the crowd definitely picked up on it.

Of course, Bill Clinton got his chance to talk. And of course, as always, he used it to talk about Bill Clinton, and Bill Clinton's legacy. What a guy.

Phil   January 21st, 2008 6:51 pm ET

I AM POSTING THIS AGAIN, as the moderators seem to be biased and refuse to post it. someone explain why if you are not allowing it, why?!?!

RE: Franklin said that in times of trouble, America "stretches to elect a president from uncharted places — a mill worker's son, a first lady, a Mormon, a Baptist preacher, and even, ladies and gentlemen, a black man."

Wow! If that is not a racially slanted comment I do not know what one is. As a 37yo WHITE male from Central Indiana (pretty much red-necks here), I lived my entire life in small town USA,, spent 4 years in college just outside of Chicago, and I have heard racist remarks. For Mayor Franklin to try to once again apark the racial fires, and on this most important day of honor for the most highly revered of all MEN, Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. is not only a disgrace to her official powers, is is also a disgrace and slap at President Clinton and all of America. I have said it on here before and CNN refuses to publish it, so here it is one more time. . . Senator Obama lacks integrity, courage, and the experience necessary to lead AMERICA!!

My comments are as follows:

OK Folks, it is simple, and it is not the Democrats, not the Republicans, not the Clintons, not the Obamas, who ar starting rumors and rhetoric. It is the ratings hungry, try to get ahead media. This campaign has not been fought on a racial or sexist line until now, because of the commentary and questions of reporters, Like Tim Russert. I watched in horror as he badgered Senator Clinton attempting to get her to jump into a racial fight. I feel she very clearly explained how the media (and Senator Obama’s camp) had taken her (and President Clinton’s) comments out of context in an attempt to “muddy” the proverbial waters and get away from the issues. One reason for this is that Senator Clinton has the experience to understand and relate to the issues. Senator Obama is out of his league and it does him well that the media has taken the campaign on this negative route. He is best served by this turn because he does not have to fight the battle himself, he can let the Media do the dirty work.

timetogetinvolved   January 21st, 2008 6:50 pm ET

Ant from Texas. I can't believe you paraphrased a quote from a movie. "Real times require real leadership…from Day 1″. I guess you are quote happy like Obama

You could be a little more creative.

Obama is a whiner. How could we ever think he could be leader? How could he make the tough decisions? He doesn't even have his own original thoughts. His quotes are becoming tiresome.

We need to have someone challenge him. No other candidate has people come out and say quit picking on my candidate.

At least we know Hillary will put up a fight. We don't know that about Obama. Where is you moxy Obama!!!!

irma   January 21st, 2008 6:50 pm ET

Those of you who keep talking about how embarrassed you are about the Clintons, please…you claim embarrassment while flinging insults. Yeah, you're so above it all.

Jay   January 21st, 2008 6:49 pm ET

Maxi, the other candidate are not use CNN because they do not have the money. Barack's supporters are pouring in money like crazy.

Genni   January 21st, 2008 6:49 pm ET

I'd like to give Bill a hug!

maxine   January 21st, 2008 6:48 pm ET

I keep asking and nobody will answer. Which Clinton is running for president???? I was a Clinton supporter, voted for Bill, but standing back and looking at all of this, is not what I want from my president. I don't mind people getting tough on the issues, but nobody brings up the Clinton's past as much as they bring up others. I am undecided, but the Republican's are looking better every day. And after reading these comments I am really looking hard at voting that way. I don't want another four years of Clinton, Bill did some good during his time in office, but our family struggled just as much with him as they did with Bush. So give me a break and let's start looking at the issues not race/gender or name calling. If Hillary wants to be president, then she needs to fight her own battles, not having Bill fight them for her.

Undecided with distain.

Hope-FUL   January 21st, 2008 6:47 pm ET

HIllary Clinton. Barack Obama. Two people, albeit candidates for the Presidency. Still, it will take hundreds of thousands of people to destroy the Democratic Party. The question you should ask yourselves is which route will you take. Will you take every effort to ensure the Democratic Party remains united throughout the race to the Oval Office or will you seek to destroy it by narrowing your own analysis along the lines of race and gender?

irma   January 21st, 2008 6:47 pm ET

Obama needs to face the fact that Republicans have been attacking the Clintons since the beginning and they have provided his campaign and followers with all the slick, catchy phrases that bring in the college kids. The fact is, nothing President Clinton has said about Obama is false. Nevertheless, Obama's campaign strategy once again is, talk about how bad the other side is being rather than what he will do. What's wrong Obama, don't have any REAL ideas to pedal?

Tom Davie   January 21st, 2008 6:46 pm ET

There is a whole pile of people in Iowa I bet are uttely disgusted that Obama made this big effort to 'transcend' race . We judged him on his promise of hope.

But now these STUPID people are painting him into an african american corner and now RACE MATTERS a lot. All to win a state that is going to go Republican anyways. Always has.

South Carolina isnt much of a 'swing state' .

Obama wants to throw it all out the window for this state?

This is all going to come down to this.

Black people have to vote for Obama cause if they dont they are 'traitors' to their race , and need an african american president .

White people must NOT judge the guy on his RACE and give him a fair chance blah blah blah………

Hes doing such a fantastic job at UNITING the country now isnt he?

He has no idea what kind of ugly crap he is going to have to face now thru the nomination and if he wins, the general election.

Duop Chak, Colorado Springs, CO   January 21st, 2008 6:46 pm ET

CNN: Dig deep inside Democratic party.

Shani   January 21st, 2008 6:46 pm ET

She should be ashamed of herself! She is not a candidate and has no right to attack others!

Jay   January 21st, 2008 6:45 pm ET

Well Hillary can not win without the independents and some republicans, the youth and the African america vote. That was why AL Gore and John Kerry lost. Remember Bill Clinton won with the African american vote.

The fact of the matter is, no one can win without this block of voters,

DeeDee   January 21st, 2008 6:45 pm ET

Good going Obama!

Some untier he has been by crying the race card and dividing the democratic party, just what the republicans's wanted. A month ago he said he was not running as a black candidate just a democrate and look at today, he is playing the victim to the fullest.

People should be ashame by only backing a man just because of his color, and not his substance.

All the crying and whining his campaign does really will scare me, if he becomes president and we are attacked again. Who will he blame then race the Clintons, maybe Bush for making American's hated.

I just read today he was trying to get the Minnesota republican votes so that Hillary can't win. Contacting republicans to try and promote him there. I have been saying he is a repulican ploy all along and now that just seconds my notion, to destroy the democratic base, since Bush has made thier (republican) base weak.

Thank the lord the blacks around me see him for what he is, and not the fluff he spews.

Duop, Colorado   January 21st, 2008 6:45 pm ET

I love it when people get no subject to discuss.

Carole (VA)   January 21st, 2008 6:44 pm ET

I realize news clips are, of necessity, brief & lack a lot of context, but if the clip you're running of Bill Clinton's most recent "attack" on Barack Obama is the worst thing he said, I'd hardly call that an "attack." In responding as he did, Obama continues to show himself as an academic more suited to his ivy covered halls, at times dour and humorless, and perhaps too thin-skinned for politics.

Karen   January 21st, 2008 6:41 pm ET

Please stop writing Clinton/Obama. Obama has had lunch with Bloomberg. If you read anything other than the political ticker you would know this.

UNITY 08′ is the group of politicians (current congresspersons included) and corporate interests who are tired of not getting their special interest legislation passed. They watched the people trying to take back their govt and have decided to step in. They have selected Bloomberg as the candidate that can satisfy their agenda. Obama (the change agent) is being looked at as a possible VP.

angelina_ MN   January 21st, 2008 6:39 pm ET

Please note carefully who is being so disrespectful, and also who is also carefully creating division in the party, making it a racial issue, a gender issue and now thanks to BILL we can add the sexual issue.
Bill can not wait to go to the WH_____all of the interns..watch out.

I am embarrased by these two they have gotten so low so low. They use minorities and civil rights only when it is to their advancement of power, but if an AA is running for president, they call it a fairy tale. I dont care how people interpret it, or hear it or want to understand it, we all know what Bill meant.

Rob   January 21st, 2008 6:39 pm ET

Karl Rove behind the scenes???

Nominate Obama, someone we can beat by using the same tactic we'll use to defeat him. RACE…

Ray   January 21st, 2008 6:38 pm ET

Shame on Franklin. This was not the time and place. I'm sure had Hillary said something, Then EVERYONE would be attacking him.

Linda   January 21st, 2008 6:37 pm ET

Bill Clinton needs to stay out of his wife campaign be the supportive husband and watch from the side lines because if she gets elected I fear there are going to be two President Clinton running this country one at a time . And even if she gets the nomination I'am voting Republican.

Shrimp Barnicles, Africa   January 21st, 2008 6:37 pm ET

Put 10 toddlers or young children of different race and background in a play room and ask them to play together. They will never seperate themselves to one corner by race. They will play together as though they all came from the same womb. We are the ones that teach and groom these kids on race sometimes knowingly and sometimes unknowingly.

If the flesh of a 30 year old white man is removed from his body and the flesh of a 30 year old black man is removed from his body you cannot tell which one is a white the man and which on is the black man. The color of their blood, veins, kidney and all that are the sa