I was appalled at Obamas remark. What are you, American or a "brother" -Talk about racist! If a white person had said that they would have been crucified! I want a President that is NOT going to divide us. Go Hillary!

The Last Word on Race.

The Black Democrat voters of South Carolina have certanly answered the Pivotal question of the 08′ Democrat debate season. "Do you think Bill Clinton was the first Black President of the United States?"……. By a 80% majority they have concluded that the 42nd President of the United States was "Not A Brother"…..

"SORRY BILL"

Some people feel that Obama's terrible reference to race and dancing ability was just a lighthearted joke. — Since Obama's father was black and his mother white — Would it be a lighthearted joke for any of the other canidates to ask Obama if he has one leg that dances better than the other?

Can someone from CNN please explain why this question was asked? At the beginning Wolf Blitzer said that this debate would be about the issues. What does this question have to do with the issues? Do better CNN. Worry less about ratings and more about responsible journalism.

I'm sorry but all you people who are offended or didn't like this comment need to lighten up in my opinion. It was a joke.. everyone in the room was laughing. Clearly he wasn't being racist and was just trying to make light of a clearly absurd question.

Why do white people get all worked up when they can't say something that a black person can get away with saying? Give me a BREAK! Try waking up in the morning and being black in this country for ONE DAY. Try living with the legacy of slavery and discrimination that is inherent in EVERY INSTITUTION this country holds dear. There is a double standard, because we face discrimination EVERY DAY. If you don't get that, maybe you should wake up.

Guess what…I'm biracial too…and when you walk down the street as a biracial person, they don't say,"hey, she's white" they say. Oh, she's black. Dishonoring your white mother? I don't think he dishonors his white mother. I don't dishonor my mother by marking the box "african american" either. It is what it is. If he said he was white, nobody would believe him.

What happened to my post CNN? It was right after Zima's! It wasn't offensive! Ever hear of Free Speech? This is ridiculous!

Are we forgetting that Hilary laughed at Obama's comment? If it was such a racist comment (which it wasn't), then maybe she should have said something to take advantage. Instead she laughed and added her own humorous comment. Some of you people are mentally insane and wouldn't know a racist comment if it smacked up upside your heads.

"Racist?" Anyone who was legitimately "offended" by that response has serious issues. How about Hillary adding to it by saying it could be arranged? Certainly you must have been offended by her joining in this hateful display. Oh, wait, but you're all HRC supporters grasping for anti-Obama straws, aren't you?

And to all the "Obama isn't black…why doesn't he talk about his white family members," people: Obama has not been running as a "black candidate" or as a "mixed race candidate." He frequently mentions his "mother from Kansas," and his "grandfather who fought in Patton's army," and I've seen plenty of pictures of his mother's side of the family in campaign ads. If you read his books or have just been paying attention to his campaign you would know this.

If you want to take issue with the media labeling him as "black," fine, but to suggest that Senator Obama has either downplayed or disrespected any aspect of his heritage is just a flat-out lie.

Obama gets in trouble when he goes "off script" because his true self shines through. Remember that next time you are entranced by his oratory.

Hillary Clinton 2008

We keep hearing that President Clinton did a lot for black people. What EXACTLY did he do? The state of some of the schools attended by black children are still delapidated and have been delapidated prior to 1992 and after 2000. The injustice in the legal system never changed much during his presidency. The gap is still the same, or even wider. I am stumped at what may have been perception rather than reality.I say it's the "feel good" effect.

Jingle bells, jingle bells, the Clintons are laughing all the way. They are getting down and very, very dirty with Obama because he presents a real threat to her bid for the White House. Then she turns around a tries to accuse him of starting the fight. That is so typical of people like her. What the Clintons understand very well about black people is that they are disloyal to each other and they are stupid. That is why people like President Clinton and his wife can say such awful things about Barack Obama in the name of politics and get away with it. The balck people will go out and put their X where it hurts.

My biggest fear is for Obama and his family, because I worry about the 00.1% American who can stop him. The Clintons know it and they are doing a good job of trying to destroy him while lauging in the face of all the black Americans they claim to love so much, because they know that they can get away with what they are doing, with people like Rangel to back them up. Shame on you Mr. Rangel.

As a former president who may have done a lot for African Americans and who has so obviously been one of the best presidents, he is still, and will always be remembered as the Billy "Mon" guy. That is his biggest legacy.

"S" i hope there are not too many racist out there like you. Blacks are what puts dems over the top when candidates run for office!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! There are actually millions of us in america that vote or do you live under a rock? What happened to "every vote counts" grow up!!!!!!!!!!! Monorities decide the vote. If hillary is the nominee, I'll take mccain. At least he's honest. Don't think if she the nominee she get elected, Billary went too far.

QUIT BEING SO SENSITIVE people! Geeze. It wasn't meant to be a 'racist' question or answer. You all laugh at Chris Rock, Dave Chapelle when they say things of that nature, but Barack Obama's not allowed to say it?

Hmmm.

:::rolls eyes:::

Relax everyone. It was funny- Period.

When did Obama become black? I've always believed we are defined by our parents. He seems to embrace the heritage of the African father that abandoned him but ignores the white mother that raised him alone. He is as much white as he is black. To only call black is to dishonor the accomplishments of his mother. As someone who was raised in Detroit (95% black), I can tell you that it takes more than birth and skin color to make you a "brother". Please remember that. By the way, I'm neither black or white.

Here come the closet Racist. Your media asked the dumb question to begin with. Why is he asked the question to begin with. Ask Hillary why she is pretending to be a Feminist.

The race is now racially based. What a shame! "Dance"? It appears Obama is the candidate of race…Too bad.

Tricky question with light weight.Toni Morrison started the race thing by saying the comment .And by referring the question to Obama was a direct injection of hatred between the presidential hopefuls.We are all brothers and I guess everybody knows that.But by asking the black thing question, maybe Hillary could answer if she married a black president.People are too much on Obama jus because he is a lone first runner.Never be surprised when things turn around the jukebox and theaters will be playing "Head of State" movie by Chris Rock.All we want is a president who can liberate this country from the suffering and hatred from the outside world.

I was just a great sense of humor. There was nothing racist about it. My thing is that people of cultures are differ from each other. I am so tired of the race thing. yes, remember calling ladies nappy headed hoes is racist ……not just checking out how some one dances. Yes, blacks and whites do dance differently. And there is nothing wrong with it. I was just humor. Hillary even thought it was funny and stated it could be arranged. For one that questions should have never been asked. Bill would never be black. He would never understandt the legitimacy of being black and the hardship that comes with it. That questions was just inappropriate and ignorant. Because how can you ask a black man about a white man being the first black president.

Also, that debat was so heated that a bit of humor did create laughs and a sigh of relief from hostility of words.

Keep in mind who the audience was – primarily Black. The question was ridiculous, so Obama can be forgiven for giving a silly answer.

Hillary is the most racist candidate of either party. Why dont they ask about her comment about Middle Easterners and 7-11's? At least Obama's comment was not mean-spirited like Hillary's

If Clintons are so "down", why is it that President Bush installed Colin Powell and Condoleeza Rice in such powerful positions, not Clinton. Simple – Democrats will say anything to get elected, then screw the common man once they are there. Republicans will talk straight, like it or not, but in the end they are more fair.

As a White guy, I see no problem with Obama's remark. And if it was reversed, I would also see no problem with it. We shouldnt be ashamed to celebrate our differences.

That is a pretty racist thing to say….

Obama's joke was inherently racist because it plays to stereotypes about African-Americans having rhythm while Caucasian people do not. Imagine if Hillary Clinton or John Edwards had made such a joke. They would have been eaten alive by the media and the African-American community. Obama (and many others) need to understand that racism has many facets and can come to/from many directions. It isn't directed only at African-Americans. It is possible for African-Americans to be racist toward White people. While Obama's campaign seems to be accusing others of playing the "race card," it seems that he and his campaign do it just as much, if not moreso, than others. Someone needs to take Obama to task for his racist comment, and caution his campaign about its own tendency toward racism.

sounds like racism to me. not the first time he has said backhanded racist comments. how about several times during the even referring to Hillary as the women , he as the black candidate , and then we have that guy "referring to john Edwards" denigrating the white man. Can you imagine if a white guy said we have Hillary as the women, me as the white guy and then referred to obama and then we have that guy.

How would Obama or the AA community react is someone called him a 'White' president? How would the media respond to anyone calling him such? What if Clinton said "Well, let the FBI investigate how well he (insert some stereotypical trait generally deemed good that a white man is known for, but blacks are not) before I call him a (insert some fantasy word for how white's exclusively relate to each other)". Can you imaine the scandulous uproar that would ensue? It cuts both ways, and jokes regarding racial stereotypes in any direction should be taboo.

Obama – you should not have touched that one.

At least HRC didn't whimp out and vote "present" numerous times when she did bother to show up. Mike(MD), Colby and Karen, they are all politicians they don't intend to change anything, and they don't care about us. They care about money and power.

The whole question is an INSULT to African Americans!

Bill Clinton was not African Americans..duh. How offensive that they would give the title "first black president" to a white guy…..

Blacks are being bamboozaled, and they don't even notice

Colby and Karen
If you want to report the truth maybe you should also note that HRC has missed 103 votes and is #6 on your list at 23.3%. These are the typical Clinton tactics to distort the truth and only point out parts of the truth to discredit their opponents and make themselves look good. We as Americans are smarter than you think

It is amazing how Hillary can do everything just to get to the White House. She is spending her time attacking others just to destroy their image. She didn't realize till now that the dirty political campaign has been the real reason why honest people are staying away from Politics. I understand that it is the best way for the Establishment to stay in Affairs for a while again, but it won't last longer. American people are smart and the won't buy it this time. She claims all the time she fought for Universal Health Care when her husband was in power, but she didn't get till now why she failed. Well, when you spend your time sharping dirty and division strategies, when you eat in the plate of lobbyists all the time, you are bound to their desiderata. I wonder how she is going to accomplish all she is promising to people with that same mistruth political style.

I am glad Obama decided to respond strongly to each one of her gossip from now and on.

I think it is tacky to ask if Bill Clinton, a very non-black man, is black? So if someone asks me a dumb question like that, like Obama, I will give you an equal type of answer. It was classic and I LOVED IT. lol

And by the way, in regards to Obama making the "dance comment".

A lot of you folks say that we should lighten up, that it was all a joke, that people shouldn't make such a big deal about it…

It's these little stereotype remarks that do major damages in dividing our country. A major political figure should not be saying such things.

A sense of humor is a necessary but not sufficient quality in a president. Obama's response demonstrates, again, that the man has a sense of humor. Neither Hillary nor John Edwards can top Obama in this regard. And you may not believe that a sense of humor is an important qualification for the presidency, but it is. Hillary is too wrapped up in herself, like most individuals who lack a sense of humor;. She's Nixon in a dress. Of course, a sense of humor is not, by itself, sufficient to qualify anyone for the presidency. If it were, Abott and Costello would have been a winning ticket. Nevertheless, we should be wary of anyone who lacks it.

Without a doubt, the dumbest and least entertaining question not only of this debate but of all past 2007/2008 Democratic debates. As SuperTuesday approaches I wanted to see how the candidates would respond to future challenges in America surrounding affordable education, terrorism, the deterioration of the American family, energy independency, the economy, and etc. Hmmm…what question was wasted, Was Bill Clinton the first "black" president? It was presented to only Obama, how dumb was that. That ignorant question deserved a humorous and ignorant answer.

Two things…

First, did anyone notice Edwards' face when Barack made this comment? It looked like he was a bit uncomfortable and that he probably thought it was a racist remark…or maybe he was thinking "Man, if I had said that, my candidacy would be OVER in a split second!". Double standard much?

Second, I do believe this was a racist comment. I mean, think about it! This was NO different than saying "I don't know if Bill is a brother, I'd have to see him play basketball" or "I don't know if Bill is a brother, I'd have to find out if he listens to rap music", is it not? How rude and how ironic that the black candidate is actually the one that is invoking race in these inappropriate ways more than anyone else.

Last His "dancing" arguement clearly fails when considering his lethargic gyrations on Ellen's show several months back…just goes to show Barack, you cannot make broad statements like this!

Dr. Paul would NEVER say anything like that.

This whole thing (democratic prmaries) is a lot of double standards: race/gender. I was a bit taken aback by Obama's performance last night. Stuttering and fumfering, not answering questions; the not explainining the 130+ "present" voting record; the stereotyping (he'd have to see Bill dance); and telling John Edwards that Edwards can have the white male vote??!?!?? Neither Clinton nor Edwards would EVER speak in such a way. And if I am not mistaken, when the "Bill Clintong dance" comment came up, the camera panned the audience, and did I not see a few audience members stunned by this remark (as was I)? Obama may have just self-destructed. Go HIllary '08!

Hillary supporters nice to know that you come out without your hoods too.

It is amazing to me that Obama could be attacked for a racist remark when the entire premise is insulting to HIM as a black man that he isn't "black enough."

@ Mollie…that's actually not true at all because Al Sharpton actually hates Barack Obama..do not forget that he thinks he is capable of being the president and has shown a strong resentment against obama because he knows he could never be taken seriously

Obama made light of Toni Morrison's appeal to black stereotypes as making Bill Clinton "black" by adding another stereotype in a joking manner. He did not, however, do a good job in explaining his position.

It was very similar to Hillary Clinton's play on the "that hurts my feelings" comment from the debate a few weeks ago. I am not a HC supporter, but I found the comment funny and not at all sexist.

Hillary Clinton mocked a female stereotype. Barack Obama mocked a Black stereotype. John Edwards even mocked a White male stereotype (always being the majority and how this was different).

To say that Obama's comments are racist is ridiculous.

John's question was rediculous and irrelevant.

What kind of retarded question is that anyway? Is Bill Clinton black? Obama should have said "No, Bill Clinton is not black – next question" Maybe they should have asked him if Hilary is a man while they were at it. These debates are a complete and utter waste of time and provide ZERO insight into the candidates' policies or political ideologies.

Barack is no brother either, end of story.

OMG white people please stop whining and acting so shocked!!! Yes, black people can say things about their own race that others can't say. It's sort of like talking about your family. You might say something negative about your sister or brother and it's ok for your to say, but if someone else said it, then it wouldn't be cool. All races have internal stereotypes for instance the Irish are known for drinking–do you really want me to believe that Irish and non Irish white people never make jokes or comments about it?

It is ok for a black man to stereotype a white man but if the tables had been turned……………..!
I am so disgusted with this race issue.

Since Obama came on the scene there has been something about him that I don't trust. As time goes on he is showing his true colors. His arrogance and swagger are too reminiscent of Bush. He does not have enough experience and has not said anything definitive about how he will handle the country. Plus, he can have all the ideas he wants but he has to get them through Congress and without having the ability or experience to play on that field he will fail at every turn.
Why is there so much debate over Bill supporting Hillary and speaking out? Obama's wife left her job to be the "little woman" behind her husband. Her comment about hillary not being able to control or run her own house how can we expect her to handle the White House is one of the most sexist and outdated remarks uttered yet!! How can such a successful and educated woman have such a small mind?Obama is not what the Press has portrayed him to be and his true agenda will come to light soon. Let's hope it's before this Country makes him the nominee…

Don't ask any stupid questions like that anymore. That was a waste of Obama's and everyone else's time.

Why was he the only one asked the question? He should have told the truth no Bill Clinton is not the first black president. Just cause one person said don't make it so!

If all this stupid stuff keeps getting in the way – we may end up with a Republican in office again

For those that think the question was improper to ask, I can agree with that. However, the question was backed up by it being a legitimate quote that was made and they wanted Obama's opinion on it.

Personally, I think that Obama needs to leave the joking to John Edwards. He has the personality to pull it off a lot better. When Obama does it, for some reason, it comes off to me as very immature.

As for the debate as a whole, I have to say that both Hillary and John really impressed me while Barack was left in the dust. Hillary seemed to answer the most questions and John wasn't too far behind in that. It was as if Barack would start off on one thing, get lost, and forget what he started off with quite a few times. As a live speaker, he leaves me very cold. John has an engaging personality and Hillary seems to be the most in tune with what she's presenting and the facts behind it.

I just have to say NObama in 08! I think a Clinton/Edwards ticket would be very appealing after last night!

Speaking of Rezko, I just read two articles, one on the Chicago Sun Times site, and one on ABC's. The information provided in these articles is quite concerning. Rezko did donate more that $40,000 to Obama. Not to mention the fact that Obama was able to purchase Rezko's land for $300,000.00 under the asking price. That's quite a donation. All while it was plublicly known that Rezko was under investigation and soon thereafter under indictment.

Did Bill Clinton really do anything for the economic and social justice of the Black community? Evidently not. Have the quality of the lives of Blacks and working class of all ethnicities really improved? The question is laughable. Bill Clinton really catapulted the selling out and outsourcing of the States like no one before him. It seems like they believe if they say something over and over long enough people will believe their lies. And to believe that Bill Clinton was the first Black president is to use Obama's race against him to the Clinton's favor. As if to nullify his running as a candidate. To the Black community: don't get suckered again and I say this from a white perspective. Go Obama!

As a Hillary supporter, I really enjoyed this part of the debate. I understand that Obama could neither agree nor disagree with the statement because he would anger someone either way, so I thought his answer was a lighthearted way to please everyone. In general, I'm glad Joe Johns asked this question because it reminds people of the Clintons' long, long history with the African-American community, from Bill's childhood in segregated Little Rock, to Hillary's work with the Children's Defense Fund, to now.

OBAMA HAS NO business running this country!!! He is neither experienced enough nor does he know how to handle himself in tough situations. He seems too volatile and immature as well.

Wake up.

Had Hillary or President Clinton made such a sterotypical comment about Obama the ever so Honorable Reverend Sharpton would of had their heads on a platter or maybe he would or orchestrated some sort of March up and down the streets of D.C.

I have noticed, and you will also if you pay attention, Obama is the one that always brings race into the conversation, every time. I would have no problem whatsoever voting for a black man based on his accomplishments. For instance, Collen Powell. Obama cannot give us a clear stand on anything. When he is ask about plans his answer is always, "Change." Meanwhile we are left wondering what change? The dance and true brother comment was bad. Had any of the other candidates made the comment , we would see someone on the news this morning asking that we "go a little easier on Obama." Today the report is how Clinton and Edwards piled on Obama. I think Obama fuels these bickering sessions so he can divert attention away from real issues, not have to answer real questions as to hisplans, and keep the media charging that the Clintons have again been bad to him. We need to forget black, white, woman, southern son and just vote on who will serve this country best. This race thing keeps popping up and it seems to be a major fuel for division. People are tired of it , we just want to hear how they are going to help this country and ALL it's people.

To the person making the comment…"There is so much ignorant Hillary supporters here…" re-read this and see if it makes sense to you. Perhaps, just maybe, you will see that while you are referring to others as "ignorant", you can appear ignorant as well. That's if you really caught it.

One of the benefits we have here is "freedom of choice". You make no sense calling people "ignorant" because they choose differently. Everyone has the right to choose, and they are not ignorant because they do so.

If you went to a store and bought a shirt and your friend bought jeans, is your friend ignorant because he did not buy what you bought?

CNN IS ALWAYS LOOKING TO TEAR DOWN OBAMA FOR THEIR FAVORITE, THE NASTY COUPLE, BILLARY AND BUBBA.

EVERYBODY KNOWS OBAMA WAS JUST BEING HUMOROUS.

If any white politician had made this remark, the NAACP would have pilloried him, the media would have scathingly condemned him, and his career would have been over before the 5 o'clock news.

I didn't know that "dancing" made the "brother. Actually, dancing is of little significance, as far as I am concerned, unless it is done as a profession . Personally, if I had a man who danced, but he was lacking in communication skills and full mental abilities I would not be interested, at all!

I suppose this was a joke of sorts (the brief excerpt that I saw), but I have been curious why Obama calls himself "biracial"….is this suppose to separate him from others? Pardon my thoughts, but I thought most of us were biracial…."of, relating to, or involving members of two races ".

If this comment had been made – in any forum, in any context – by any other candidate, we'd be hearing about it for weeks, maybe even months. Al Sharpton would be going nuts…people would be asked to resign, recant, repent, etc. etc. etc. There truly is a double standard when it comes to these types of issues…

Obama's answer, as most of his are, was asinine and ridiculous. He uses a LOT of words to say NOTHING. He cannot get through a sentence without a lot of "uhs" and hesitations. He is NOT READY to be President, not by a long shot!!

HILLARY '08

The "dance answer" was a very racist remark, but it didn't come from an African-American. It came from bi-racial man.

CNN had its female reporter ask all the dumb and superficial questions. How sexist.

And, speaking of Rezko[the referenced slum lord], where Obama wasn't
truthful there either. What, he claimed he only worked 5 hours for the
man. REALLY?

Since early 90's when they became friends, after also making deals with
each other, Rezko became a money bundler for Obama. They became quite
close and bought their homes next door to each other 2 years ago, after
winning his US Senate seat. He also then agreed to buy some of Rezko's
land so he had more, for about $100,000.00. News and reports Rezko and
his circle have given about $160,000.00 to Obama and that does not include
their special deals with buying stocks, etc.

Obama has decided to donate what he considers about the amount he received
directly from Rezko, aproximately $40,000.00 to Charity.

But remember, he doesn't know the guy, he just worked about 5 hours with
him.

For people to be even discussing this issue when we face much broader issues should be ashamed of yourselves. What happen to keeping “Race” out the debate? What happened to Wolf promising to ask the questions on the issues? What about all of the people sending in questions just for CNN to ignore the American people just as Washington have been for years?
On a day we honor Martin Luther King JR, .and we still can’t get over the race issue in this country and have to stoop so low to make it about themselves. As a white male I take offense to the comment that Bill Clinton was the first “Black President”. Until he has walked a mile in the shoes of a black man, no one can say they are black or understand what it is like to be black. I also find it appalling to see how people think that just because Obama is black that he can’t lead this country. Well if it were not for the strength of the black man who helped build this country with their blood, sweat and determination to be free equal men , this country wouldn’t be what it is today. The same men who gave their lives on the fields of battle and the streets of this country to fight for freedom, equality and the pursuit of happiness and yet last night we are still bringing race into this Presidential Campaign.
If anyone wants to know which President did more for the African-Americans, do we forget that if not for the courage of President Abraham Lincoln to abolish slavery in this country? “A person shouldn’t be judged on the color of their skin, but the content of their character.” These are the words we should be using to determine ones ability to lead this country and I for one would be proud to have Obama be my leader, because he has that character.

I was offended by Obama's comment because it plays into a stereotype on one hand and plays into the "are you black enough" thinking on the other. If race is not the issue, then why bring that up?

And I'll be offended if I want to be and will get over it when I want to, but I will remember this when I'm deciding who to vote for. He should not have answered the question and particularly not in a silly way.

As for Toni Morrison owing anybody an apology…it is not her, it is CNN for choosing her.

While I thought that the debate was contentious on all sides, I am totally tired of men not letting women answer questions without interrupting. If you want to lose my respect and more importantly my vote, keep interrupting as somebody is starting to answer a question and keep nit-picking throughout the answer. The rudest sequence I saw was when Hillary was trying to answer a question and Obama kept interrupting and making little comments. I was not impressed.

This particular question and other questions to Obama were unwarranted and created unnecessary conflicts. Obama did not want to give any credit for Clinton's presidency. So, he brushed off the question with the dancing abilities like answer. It appeared that Obama had decided to take on Clintons on the debate. But he failed in his attempt, and had to go defensive. Hillary though critisized by the media of her body language, did tit for tat to Obama and showed him his place. She knew that she had a slim chance winning SC as Obama was given such a rock star status by the media that african americans are bound to vote for him. But, Hillary's performance was for the national audience (Feb 5 election) who can see her as a strong, well informed leader who has thorough answers to every issues. Obama is just a good orator who presents himself well. But, no substance.

It was a good natured joke, get over it and add some humor to your lives! Also it may be wise for many of you to get your blood pressure checked.

I had a feeling Obama was going to lose it at the debate lastnight,
because he has such a angry look on his face. His mannerisms were were
showing hostility. Then he proceeded to do opposite of everything he
claims. 'Let's move on, but first…….' 'Stop attacking, but [I'll
slander Bill Clinton for claiming he's lying'] let me attack Bill Clinton
and you'. Like a child having a temper tantrum, he went way beyond
anything he could ever claim 'other Washington politicians' to have done.

Major hypocrisy with Obama.

And then his comment that John Edwards would receive the "white mans vote".
Nice, huh?

Now reports are that he is breaking a campaign promise and will campaign
in Florida. Check please.

Is that a question to be asked in a political debate??? Do you people really debate his answer??

When/if all Americans will get to political maturity and stop watching such trash TV as CNN, people around the world might start hoping for a better future. For now, I can only feel deeply sorry for such a decent intellectual having to go into the dirty reality of the Clintons (quite some examples of morality, indeed) and such an intellectual prostitution. America might not deserve someone as Sen. Obama yet. Too many people are used to hearing the same demagogy over and over again and the system is therefore just reproducing itself. Don't be surprised when you create some other monsters!

He had to address the question that was asked of him. I am glad that he did so in a joking manner. The whole idea of the thing is a joke. Come on….everyone knows Bill Clinton is not black. I think the answer was appropriate.

It's about time someone showed some humor in this race, other than the preposterous and kooky things the Clintons say.

Kudos for anyone who can cease to take themselves so seriously.

Obama can bring being HUMAN back to the White House.

Some Clinton haters only see his bad side and refer to it as black thing…Ludicrous. Please he or she ( whether black or white) that have not sinned throw the first stone.

For every human has weakness and non of us here has the right to judge anyone which includes the ex president. Clinton was a great president and will remain so, no one will take away that from him…

Stupid stupid question….stupid stupid comment…

The question ranks right up there with, "Does this dress make me look fat?" There is no acceptable answer and you should not even try.

Bill Richardson for VP!

Caywen -
Let me guess…you'd be the first one to stand up and cry "racism" if something "somewhat stereotypical" offended you, right???? But it just doesn't matter as long as YOU'RE NOT OFFENDED??? Is that correct??????

Listen up, racism either needs to go (across the board) or it stays (across the board). Black people don't get to have it both ways. We aren't going to take a poll every time someone says something possibly racist to see if it offends the majority of you and if doesn't then it's ok. PICK A LANE or QUIT CRYING!

The Facts-
Poor is poor no matter the color-let us all understand that-
Why is John Edwards left out out so often? Is it because he is honest and the other two can not stand up and make that claim? We need answers!
When will they all JUST ANSWER THE QUESTIONS?
We the American People deserve to listen to the answers and not be preached at.
Honesty is the best policy so- LET US HEAR IT!
We all need the next President to work for US–so, let us hear just what he or she will do for us and HOW it will be done. NO more promises -just to sound good-
They need to be made to answer the questions or leave the debate.-We have the right to ask for that!

How black is Obama? I haven't seen him dance either or really do a whole heck of a lot to reach out to the black community. I think he has more to prove that Bill does.

'Olivia' what was so "racist" about what He said… The original quote wasnt from Him in the first place. Second, the quote in and of itself is about the fact that "Slick Willie" is a P.I.M.P., we've said that for years. The 'Bill Clinton is OUR first black president' comment IS tongue-in-cheek!
And by the by for 8 years folk have said that comment in the community, now that the media have they wont let IT go. THAT 'Olivia' is what skews the issues!

Eric, you are right, racism is a terrible evil thing, no matter who perpetrates it, even Obama. Lets end racism. Fight on Eric. Imus was wrong, Kramer was wrong, Jesse Jackson (hyme town reference for those who don't remember) was wrong, Obama was wrong, Walter Kronkite (here's a blast from the racist past) was wrong. You don't have to be a victim of evil to recognize it. Especially something as disgusting as racism.

As a former Obama supporter this absolutely was a racist comment. If Hillary was asked "Senator Clinton as you know Senator Obama's mother is white. Do you think that he would be considered a black or white President if ellected? Hillary's response: Well I would first have to see if he can read well before I decide whether his mother rubbed off on him or not if I was going to consider him a white president. Not a perfect analogy, but you get my drift. Another low blow that is ok for Obama but not others. After you peal back the same old speeches that continuely are reruns of the last you have a politician just like the rest. Dont fool yourselves. Do the research and get informed Obama is with out a doubt no qualified for the most powerful position on earth. Hillary is the gop's worst nightmare.

I do not support Obama–in fact, I believe that he is dangerously right wing and certainly insulting to women of all colors…but it IS different when he says something like the dance comment than when a white person says it! He is black; he is not saying it from a position of power-over. He is clearly not racist against black folks, so for him to make this remark (even if we can agree that both the question and the answer left much to be desired in terms of good manners) is utterly different from what Imus did when he attacked African American college athletes with a remark intended to call up a degrading, racist stereotype. Obama was MAKING FUN of the stereotype–showing at once how ridiculous the stereotype is, as well as deflecting an unanswerable question–not using it seriously to insult a BLACK person. For me, it was the only time in the debate that Obama WASN'T acting from an ISM; SEXISM!!!! Have cnn viewers lost the ability to analyze subtlety, or to understand the politics of power?

obama needs to be a brother before he can say what one is!!

There is so much ignorant Hillary supporters here, and former OBAMA supporters, it is funny the former supporters are fair weather supporters who either support Hillary or Edwards and was trying to jump on the OBAMA bandwagon. OBAMA will be the nominee, let Hillary is it is her select EDWARDS to be VP and we will see how far they both go in this election. OBAMA or bust or should I say if it is not OBAMA the Dems will be Busted!

Also, OBAMA in the uniter he is dance around the question, but to my European brothers, CLINTON IS NOT BLACK, NEVER HAVE BEEN NEVER WILL BE, GET THAT STRAIGHT!

I would like to apologize for incorrect information I gave. LBJ did not call Martin Luther King a "degenerate preacher" as I had written, he called him a "hypocrite preacher." It was J. Edgar Hoover that called him "a tomcat with obsessive degenerate sexual urges." I again apologize to all.

I wish Hillary had countered with this: "Hold on a minute there Barak, by that criteria I am not sure if you would qualify either. After all I have seen you dance on Ellen"

I think Edwards won the debate with Hillary a close second. Barak came off like a spoiled brat and Hillary let the first three or four little digs go before she had enough and finally retaliated.

I think Barack answered the question with humor. He answered fast and intelligently and that question shouldn't of been asked to begin with. It was doubled sided no matter what he said. He keeps trying to keep race out of this, but ,of course, it had to be brought up. He wants to be judged as a candidate and a person. Hillary didn't win anything last night. Her answers were canned and sounded like the same speeches for the last 35 years. She now has a worthy opponent to face who has a vision. Let's see how she handles that.

Why so much concern about a comment on dancing? The candidates need to put their emphasis on what they are going to do about the economy. Didn't anyone take notice of the stock markets around the world? Or the Feds rate change this morning before the stock market opened? Let's see the candidates specifically state what they will or would do to fix our monetary problems. Both Obama and Clinton could be working on the economy if they spent more time in the Senate chambers. If we saw them actually working the last two years, perhaps we would know exactly who to vote for.

May be, they should all compete by performing in PRESIDENTIAL 'IDOL"

He doesn,t yet have enough experiences (cf H.C) dealing with national and international issues. His time will come.

To all those who keep saying, "its just a joke, have a sense of humor, no harm no foul". Remember what's good for the goose is good for the gander. You can't have it both ways. Look at the "outrage" and backlash everytime someone who is not black makes a "joke" that can remotely be construed as racially motivate. It is simply not acceptable, or is it?

KM, I agree 100%. A stupid question deserves a stupid answer. Why did they even ASK that? Seems the only party playing the race card is the media!

The question asked of Barack was absolutely ridiculous, and his answer was not racist in any way, and if you think it was, you need to get some thicker skin and quit being a freakin baby. It had absolutely no similarity to the Don Imus incident.

Hillary 08, the one that will ruin the democrats chances of getting the white house

Obama 08, the only one that can win by a landslide

All you people who thinks Obama's comment was racist, where were you when black youth in New Orleans were referred to as thieves while whites doing the EXACT same thing were called trying to survive? To put Obama's comment in the same line as Imus' stupid remark is not only unintelligent, but shows racism itself. Obama didn't call anyone out their name, like Imus did. In addition Obama was responding to a faulty assessment that Toni Morrison made of Bill Clinton. Until Clinton has to think about his skin color in the eyes of law enforcement, a loan officer, an interviewer for a job, or a white woman walking down the street, he will never know what its like to be a black man in America. It shows me that some of you don't know what racism really is since you've had the privilege of not ever having to experience it.

Obama, what kind of racist remark is that? white men can't dance?
God help us if this was turned around!!

The question should have NEVER been asked which is the biggest issue here. Barack can't seem to get away from questions regarding race no matter how much of a non issue he tries to make race. I will NEVER vote for another Clinton. The republicans will win in Nov if Hillary wins the nomination.

KM, then he should have kept his mouth shut and passed on it.

Haven't we all learned by now that it is not acceptable to make racist jokes, or statements in this country? White people get raked over the coals for making statements similar to this.

I wonder if anyone will criticize Obama for implying that there is some dance gene that enables African Americans to dance better than whites.

Can't we just have a political debate without race being a major factor, Obama?

I guess not.

Yeah, I have to chime in with the "inappropriate question, appropriate response" crowd here. That question was deliberately put to Senator Obama because it put him in a difficult position. If he says that President Clinton wasn't the first black president, then he's functionally ridiculing Morrison and making light of Clinton's (B) ties to the African-American community. If he says that he was the first black president he alienates himself from his historical position as the first black president. Basically, it came down to him either sounding like a racist or a sell-out.

I though he handled it beautifully and gave it an answer as ridiculous as the question itself. He paid homage to Clinton's work for African-Americans but also pointed out the simple fact that he's not black, did not grow up as a black person, and does not have ties to the culture we associate with African-Americans (I'm sorry, but growing up in the South during segregation does NOT count as living the African-American experience). The joke at the end only exemplified why Obama is a better choice for president: he keeps his cool, isn't politicizing constantly, and seeks the higher ground of calling the question what was and finding the common ground we all share in this matter, an ability to laugh at ourselves and our backwards ideas.

Toni Morrison said: "After all, Clinton displays almost every trope of blackness: single-parent household, born poor, working-class, saxophone-playing, McDonald's-and-junk-food-loving boy from Arkansas"

I cannot believe that CNN would stoop so low as to ask this question in a serious forum (same goes to the "Black Elite" who keep it goind). It is insulting.

Obama gave a ridiculous answer to a RIDICULOUS question. He could not win with any answer.

Toni Morrison owes the public an apology.

All of Clinton's dittoheads who lie and twist Obama's words sure are out and about today! God forbid she show a little humanity and make a joke that's not totally scripted. Everything she had to say last night was either attacking or defensive.

Bottom line is that Obama is doing so well because 1) half his supporters love him and 2) the other half hate Clinton and will vote for a republican before they vote for Clinton.

This is just my opinion, but democrats are in denial about how disgusted most Americans are with the Clintons. There is a reason Gore lost, the same reason there is a good chance any democrat but Clinton would win the general election.

We need to move on. Edwards or Obama. NOT Clinton.

Those who think this is a racist remark: why? No one was offended and it was good natured and humorous. Also, contrary to popular belief, there's nothing wrong with minor positive stereotypes. It's like saying Asians play classical instruments. Not generally true, but who cares – it's kind of true and kind of funny. If we can't poke and have fun with the idiosyncrasies of difference races, we're doomed to fail in our pursuit of interracial and intercultural harmony.

and if former president clinton can dance will obama admit he was the first black president?what a dumb thing to say.dr.king would be so proud????

that was a dumb question to begin with. if you ask a dumb question….expect a dumb answer. obama did the only thing he could…joke.

Please folks, have a sense of humor. And some jokes (like it or not) can be owned by different groups of people. Get over it. Your taking offense is "ill advised" and "the controversy is over". Obama and Tiger Woods are showing the rest of us how to deal with these 'non issues' with grace. Don't heap all your angst on them.

There are plenty African American public elders who'll give you their views on these tired old issues. Leave Obama alone. He can poke fun at the stereotypes, they asked him about Toni Morrison's opinion on Bill Clinton being black for goodness sakes. It was a non issue already.

Laugh or don't ;augh. Just stop being so easily riled up.

Hillary and Bill are playing dirty politics…. what goes around comes around. I will vote Republican if Hillary God forbid wins the Democratic nomination. She is a sycophant.

jones

Let's not forget that Obama is half white also.

Love how the Hillary supporters spin everything, well i guess if you can't win a debate look at it in a positive way… and since Obama mentioned dancing lets say its racist…..HILLarious, If anything it was a bad question for CNN technically a loaded question to ask not a bad way to answer it on behalf of Barack he defused the question and then played a joke off of a stereotype which is no more stereotypical than labeling Bill the first black president in the first place… The only thing that this debate showed was that Hillary cracks under pressure and visibly gets upset when she doesn't get her way. which is a true weakness and one that the Republicans will attack in the election.

I was surprised that it's ok for Obama to make that comment,
but if someone else, like Lou Dobbs, Imus, or HECK EVEN BILL CLINTON himself made that comment , everyone would be screaming RACIST. But it was OK for Barack to make that stereotypical comment, huh?

Hypocriscy runs deep with him.

The "Brother" comment was very racist. If a white person (Bill or Hillary) made that comment in reference to Mr. Obama, the African American community would be furious and demand for an apology. Speaking of "Brother's", Mr. Obama is biracial. Should he be clasified as a "brother"? He goes on and on about being a "black" man but he's obviously forgetting about his "white" heritage. Hillary Clinton made a comment about how the democratic race was between a White Woman, Black man, and White Southern Man. I watched that evening as a news reporter tried to make it out as if she was being racist. I was very happy to hear from a black woman who quickly told the reporter to get a life and stop trying to create issues that are not there.

Go Hillary!

All this year’s Mr.clinton was a black brother , Today because there is a blank issue to lead the country , He needs to prove , that he is a brother .
This is going splint the country on race , The Mr.Obama should be able to show some compassion for his party leaders and move on with some
Humble qualities.

Where's Al Sharpton following Obama's comment? If Clinton or Edwards uttered it, Sharpton would be all over them to drop out of the Presidential race; he divides the country with his hypocritical stances over racism i.e. Imus and Kelly Tighlman of Golf channel. Obama should also apologize to the black community.

Let me see, cheating on his wife, then lying about the affair therefore breaking the law. The unproven charge by women that he forced himself on them and raped them is akin to what President Johnson said about Martin Luther King, "a degenerate preacher."

It's obvious that Bill Clinton isn't black. CNN asked a dumb question. Obama gave the question more thought than it deserved.

Well, well, well. So Obama engages in racial stereotyping. Open mouth, insert foot? Don Imus must be laughing his posterior off.

I think Obama just blew any chance of getting the nomination.

Pay close attention, America. Racial and/or gender stereotyping, by ANYONE, isn't the kind of thing we want in our White House.

THE QUESTION ITSELF IS RACIST!!!!!!!!!!!

It does not matter if a black woman coined it and blacks have embraced the phrase. CLINTON IS NOT BALCK and thus therefore COULD NOT have been a BLACK PRESIDENT!!!!!!!!!!!!

Obama was trying to stay polite without seeming offended by the comment.

BUT I WAS!!!!!!

I think the statement about Clinton's dancing step should not be taken seriously.We make certain statements either for fun or due to…

Listen, the comment was RACIST! The question was stupid, for sure, but the COMMENT was racist. And Obama should know better.

By the way readers (and CNN, for that matter), Democrats are NOT the only candidates running for President. There are some AWESOME, smart Republicans running as well, including John McCain and Ron Paul.

Don't fall into voting Democratic just because you always have.

The Clintons continue to bring race into the debate in order to label Obama as the black only candadate and by doing so turn white voters away from Obama. This little trick might work in the democratic nomination process but keep in mind these tactics are turning off black voters. And if Hillary thinks she can win the general election without full support of black americans, she must be dreaming high. Black votes are crucial in key swing states like PA, MI and OH. A state like Maryland is blue because blacks make up 29% of voters and vote almost 9 to 1 to democrate. Black voters are also important in VA and FL for democrates to have any chance to win. So, the Clintons should be very careful. Their dirty tricks to win the small prize might end costing them the big one.

Shame on Obama. And he's the one who doesn't like the references to his being a black. I guess it's okay for the blacks to be racists —but definitely not for the whites.

We cannot afford to elect a president who shimmys around issues. Clinton and Edwards are articulate and on target when questioned. Obama has to have a prepared text or he cannot express himself clearly. When one carefully listens, he interjects low level "uhs" several times in each utterance and hesitates frequently. Imagine that kind of thinking/speaking inability when conversing with another world leader. He is tentative and hesitant and currently lacks the depth of experience and knowledge we need of a president. Also, he and his openly passionate wife have made this a race race. For Mrs. O, this appears to be another civil rights issue. Not. It is a presidential issue; who can do the job.

I, have watched every debate so far, and each one sinks to a new low, I am sick of all this race vs gender vs poor Edwards. I don't care if Bill can dance, he can at least blance a budget, can Obama? That is what I as an American want to know!!OK, by now we have it Obama is Black, Hillary is a Woman and Edwards is the one stuck in the middle. I am tired of jokes, this country has some very serious issues to confront, education, healthcare, unemployement, gas prices, Americans are losing homes everyday, children still go to bed hungry, wake up people and talk about what should be important to us, what will our country be like in another four years, who can lead us out of this mess BUSH has created for us. Maybe if we stop reacting to the race vs gender issue the media will stop playing it up. I am proud that we can say that a woman is running and we can accept it as a country, also proud that in my day a Black Man can stand before us as a serious respected canadiate for the highest office in our Country and we have accepted and embraced that in our hearts. But, now which of these persons can get the job done to ensure America can recover from the harm that Bush has caused. We are still losing sons and daughters in a country that hates us, and will never be at peace, we are losing sons and daughters to our streets, to drugs, and proverty. So many things need attention isn't it being fair to ourselves to demand from those asking us to trust them with the most important office in our country to show some respect for us and set a course of action that we can understand. If we as Americans want change then it must come from within us all, we have to demade that we get the best, to make us the best again.

I feel that Obama deserves some praise on how he digged it out with Hillary. Hillary was very ready too. Whoever becomes the nominee should take the other as running mates I guess. The dancing joke was just a joke.

Somebody, please, please explain to me why the media continue to give Obama a free pass on his record and his statement?

No way in the world Hillary ever would be able to get away with breaking a pledge not to run ads in Florida. Can you imagine the press firestorm? Yet not a word about still one more blatant Obama retreat from his word.

How do the media have the nerve to continue their biased coverage?

I thought Sen. Obama's reply was very funny and it didn't offend anyone. Someone here made a comparison with Don Imus… Man, do you remember what language Imus used?
Please.
And as per the media treating lightly Obama, just read the New York Times or Cnn. Hillary Clinton has been cocooned from the beginning and the only ones who attack her are actually the voters… not the media. A perfect example of this is last night: Hillary started the fighting with a 2 min+ list of accusations to Obama. 2 min+… NOBODY got that much time from Blitzer… Talk about par conditio…

Bill Clinton is NOT BLACK! The Clintons have done things on purpose to secure the Black Vote for Hillary! WAKE UP AMERICA!

If BILL AND HILLARY CLINTON were such a proponents of African-Americans and Civil Rights, why are 581,530 people living in Washington D.C. (80 percent of which are Black) without voting Rights in America? Hillary says she was involved in he White House Affairs when her Husband was in Office; so why didnt she take up this fight? Bill Clinton had the opportunity to push a pending bill during his two terms in Office which would give Washington D.C. residents the right to vote. The United States Constitution says there will be "NO taxation without representation" in our nation. Yet 581,530 people (80 percent of which are BLACK) remained taxed without a voice in the government they pay for.

GOOD WORK BILL! If you actually did some work in Office instead of chasing Interns with Cigars, maybe you would have a real civil rights victory in your pocket. But you left 581,530 people (80 percent of which are BLACK) disenfranchised in Washington D.C.

HOW DO THE CLINTONS know what it is like to be Black? I resent that! They only call Bill Clinton the "First Black President" because he played the Sax, smoked weed, and cheated on his wife. AS A BLACK MAN, I am offended that White men who do such things seem to get a "Player Card" and admitted into the fold. ALL BLACK MEN DO NOT played the Sax, smoked weed, and cheated on their wives… and those things DO NOT MAKE BILL BLACK!

Lighten up. It was a joke. A really good one actually, and a nice response to a stupid question. I can't believe Obama is the one being accused of injecting race into the campaign, when, in fact, its the clintons, the media, and the debate moderators. What a stupid question, and, an absolutely classic response.

I'm baffled by the fact people are referencing Hillary winning debates. So far all I've seen is a power-crazed, flip-flopping, pre-emptive war proponent who is summarily owned in debates time and time again.

CNN, get stuffed with your self-serving sensationalization of the most sacred process for democracy.

Blitzer was wonderfully minimalsitic in moderating, so that the candidates could talk. Kudos to you Wolf. your intelligence may not be above average but your integrity shined last night.

Let me tell you – if a white person said "we'd have to check out his dance steps to see if he's really a brother" – all hell would have broken out. Al Sharpton would have been calling for that person's head. Here we go again – what the black person can say and what the white person is forbidden of saying. Double standard and don't give me that crap that the black people have been living with double-standards for years. GET OVER IT!!!! You want to know what's keeping the black man / woman down? Him / her-self – that's who. No one else.

How is it that a black candidate can make the remark "I'd have to see him dance" an it be regarded as "funny" when if a white candidate were to make the same comment it would be considered a racist remark?

WHY is the press and the media sucking up to Obama? Is it not obvious that the man can't answer questions and he is GREAT at sidestepping.
The remarks last night if they had come from Hillary would have been considered racist and the media would have jumped all over her, but with them coming from Obama everything is just hunky dory.
..Obama is NOT what this country needs and his comments, his arrogance and his inablity to answer questions straight forward are beginning to really be a problem.
He DOES NOT have my vote PERIOD! When he ACTUALLY can aswer a question, stop his whining and be straight forward with a real plan instead of just "promise of change" then maybe he will get some more support. As it is, no way. and get over your better than you attitude that is beginning to show.

Definitely a racist remark on behalf of Obama. He is just holding back and trying to be polite in public. We do not need him let loose in the white house.

Go Hillary.

As a first time comment maker I'm so sorry to see that my response was not acceptable.

January 22, 2008 10:01 am ET
Your comment is awaiting moderation.
Obama did a good job of answering a 'no-win' question. I wish that the moderators did not feel the need to ask questions that have so little relevance to the issues at hand. It is still early in the race but I keep watching and waiting for debates that promote topics of substance.

What is that supposed to mean? You can't dance unless you are black? Sounds racist to me…

I have watched all three democratic debates in '08 and so far have gone from republican, admittedly mostly out of ignorance, to huge Edwards supporter. He has earned my vote and I have signed up on his website to join his campaign and spread the word about him. It is a shame that more people haven't given him a chance. He shows an amazing amount of passion and to me displays the most willingness to fight for not only change, but improvement for America as a whole!

You have got to be kidding me. You people get so hung up on the oddest things…

What a DOUBLE STANDARD! Why is it that a black person can say something that receives laughter and applause from both whites and blacks in the audience, and the media also portrays it as light, innocent humor (which is actually how it was intended to be by Obama)……BUT…if that statement was made by Hillary Clinton, John Edwards or any white person, then the statement would be considered stereotypical, racist, inappropriate, insensitive, and so on. Plus the media and black leaders around the country would have a field day with it and it would be debated for days and weeks and would probably take that candidate out of the race because they'd now be labeled a racist. But it would've been the same light humored remark…just spoken by a different person of a different color. I'm sick of this double standard that exists in our society. Obama basically made fun of and stereotyped John Edwards as the standard "white male" several times during that sit-down portion of the debate and Edwards and everyone just laughed it off and yukked it up, and Obama come away from it with the perception that he has a good sense of humor. I just don't get it and I'm sick and tired of it!

This question was "totally" out of line, especially when ALL candidates were touting their relationship and/or beliefs consistent with Dr. King's "judge by the content of character and NOT by the color of skin! Why was the question not posed also to the other candidates?? Just because Bill Clinton (whom I admire) likes African-American culture, that can never, ever make him Black! He has and will forever be a card carrying member of the "While Male Club" and never has and never will walk in the shoes of an African American.
Ask Hillary if she's married to a Black man that was President.

Everybody chill. It was the lightest moment of a disappointing night. Ggrrrrrrrrr!

Look, Bill is not "Black" and Toni Morrison based her comment on negative stereotypes of Black Men, eats fried foods, cheats on his wife, etc. hardly anything to be proud of! Barak Obama's answer was funny, because the question was horrible! Bill Clinton is not, was not, and will never be a Black Man. As the wife of a Black Man I am offended by Toni Morrison's comment and all other People that try to call Clinton the First "Black" President!

Last night's debate showed that Hillary is so very apparent with her sharp tongue and her body language. I would not want her to represent America to foreign dignitaries — she wears her feelings on her sleeve! She has been the slippery, cagey politician (along the same lines as her husband who brought shame to OUR White House)!!! Let's focus on a brighter future with someone who is untainted and willing to gather and go forth with a clean record and take our nation to a more respectable future!!!! Let Obama, a well educated, brilliant young man, lead our country. He could do no worse than the Clintons and Bushes!!!

What was Barack supposed to say? It was a stupid question based on a quote taken out of context by Toni Morrison, which she said in the middle of an article about Bill Clinton's indifelity.

He handled it with a sense of humor, which is all a good man can do when asked a stupid racist question. He is running against someone who has the luxury of playing good cop while her husband, a former presdient, can say apparently whatever untrue thing he wants. Even senior sentors are calling him out on his bad behavior, and coming from Ted Kennedy you know Bill must be wrong.

As for how black Bill Clinton is, I think he has this way of making everyone feel they are the most important person in the room, that their issues are most important to him. It was what I used to like so much about him, though those good feelings ar ebeginning to eride as I see how he will say or do anything to ge this wife elected and get a chance for a do-over for himself.

Barack the vote! OBAMA 08.

Whether William Jefferson Clinton may be an honorary African-American will not necessary make him the nation's first black president. There were stories that 0one of Warren Gamiel Harding's ancestors was of African descent. Since the standard of the time defined a black person as a human being with any African blood, President Harding would qualify. As for the truth of these rumors, the President was unsure. What is cleqar;y true, the mere fact that others( including his own father-in-law) believed them made President Harding a victim of the racism of that time. While President Harding is remembered for the scandals of his admionistration and his unfaithfulness to his marriage vows, he was also the first President to oppose segration while speaking on Sothern soil.

Obama can't even dance. I saw him on Ellen. OMG, what a joke… God help us all when he tries to become President.

Hillary 2008!!!!

It was a great debate… I think Obama succeeded once more in pushing all of Hillary's right buttons, turning her in what she really his Hulklarry… I wonder how (if she ever is elected) she'll be able to handle the stress of the presidency…

Obama, all the way…

from a white voter who can't dance

As for all of the exchanges between Hillary and Barack, I'd have to say that EDWARDS came out on top. He probably came off looking the best while the other two kept leveling charges at eachother. As heated as it gets, there's still underlying respect among all three though. Right now I am teetering towards Edwards from Obama, but It's still early.

Hey Obama-haters:

Hillary Clinton laughed at the joke, so does that mean she is an ignorant racist also?

All the commentators on TV gave Obama kudos for his comment.

If being able to dance makes you black then race shouldn't be an issue in this race? Did anybody see Sen. Obama on "Ellen" ?After seeing that, Obama should be referred to as the "John" candidate. I guess Obama loses on this issue too.

I am so tired of hearing Obama whin every time something is said about him like a spoiled child. Hillary has been going through this for a long time now and it's about time they stop. I was glad that Edwards came to her defense for once. If Obama doesn't want the race card to be played why does he keep bringing it up.

Obama is the only honest person running in this race. I can't wait to see the look on shrill Hill's face when she loses. Guess what Hillary….all your lies are going to undo you!

Come to think of it, I haven't seem Obama dance. Maybe he did that in his comedy routine in NV where he impersonated Hillary and spent the entire stump time ridiculing her through a skit. Hmmm, George W. Bush "hunting for WMD" at the press dinner. Yes, a definite kinship between Obama and W.

Sure Bill Clinton can dance –especially to the right tune… my question to Obama is:
Can you play the SAXEPHONE like brother Bill Clinton can? …then talk about dancing brother — keep on dancing Hillary and Bill –u still are the best democrats in the land…
Supporter from South Africa

If this campaign is going to be about Bill Clinton, let's talk about that. I was a huge supporter of Clinton but have not forgotten his betrayal of the trust of the American people. I have not forgotten all the wasted time during the Ken Starr ordeal. I have not forgotten how it felt to defend him when what he did was indefensible. Has everyone else forgotten?

As a Black Man, I was embarrassed by Joe Johns' rediculous question. I put that question in the same category as asking is Barack Obama "black enough". I only wish Obama would have answered the question with a stern NO instead of making a joke about it. Although that question is only a big joke!!

1. This isn't racist. You guys have no sense of humor; maybe Hillary Clinton is rubbing off on you a little too much.

2. What's MORE RACIST? Toni Morrison saying that Bill Clinton was our first black president; this is the most ridiculous statement ever, and absolute FAIRY TALE. Why isn't anyone offended by that?

This is the first debate i've ever watched. I was not impressed with the bickering and personal attacks. I was a Hillary supporter, then a Barack supporter now i'm really on the fence. John Edwards was the only one with class and stayed on point.

Hey guys, lighten up with the dance remark, where's the racism.

It was meant to be humorous … something we all laugh at each other about every now and then. We take things too seriously sometimes.

HOW W'D U HAVE ANSWERED THE QUESTION IF YOU WERE IN HIS SHOES?

It was about how black Cinton really is?

That was a double edged question for Obama…a no win situation. He keeps it light, he gets blasted…he answers it seriously, uh-oh…he's playing the race card. Shame on the media for perpetuating the race issue.

Apparently, you all missed the "Dancing Bill Clinton" doll. That dude can really cut a rug!

Thats the best Obama can come up with. He looked very shaken in this debate.

So, just so I'm up on the current thinking: Racism against Black people – BAD. Racism against White people – GOOD? Why does Obama get to not only play the victim but constantly throw out the race card, and yet he can make racist insinuations about White men and everyone thinks it's just great. Im getting really tired of Obama and his double standards.

Karen,

How is that the oddest line of the night? Look at what is happening now: Hillary is off to California while she leaves Bill to campaign for her in South Carolina. Given the attacks from both Bill and Hillary, I think he had a fair point.

Hillary Supporters, I am not sure what debate you were watching, but Obama answered everything and fired back some good ones. Edwards did have a good debate though.

Obama/Edwards '08

It is interesting to see many of HillBill lovers bringing up race in subtle ways – European American brothers?? Keep your race in your head not in your words or actions.

Talk about perpetuating sterotypes!

This struck me as a very racist remark – and I'm not even black…some of my black friends, however, also took this as racist.

It is amazing how the American public wants politics as usual in Washington. The bottom line is, even though Obama is the one that will bring true and real change, the thought of a man of color running this country is holding him back. This country is sad and it is only a matter of time before that blessings that God bestowed upon this country are taken away due to such barbaric thinking.

Many African Americans believe that if they get Hillary, that we will return to the days when Bill ruled the White House. Wonderful economic times, but that doesnt mean that it will happen again. Besides any president that gets us out of the war will save billions that can go towards staving off a full recession and paying down our debt. Its not rocket science.

Many caucasians, though they wont be truthful about it, take issue with a man of color running this country, when instead it should be about getting us out of this war, turning the economy around and fixing the health care and education system across this country. Yes, race is still an issue in this country. Lets be honest.

Another thing that gets me, is that Bill even had the gaul to talk about Obamas experiment with drugs. Obama came clean. Isnt it Bill that said that he puffed but didnt inhale? What a crock. Didnt he also say when he got busted with the intern, that it depends on what your definition of is is? Huh? Politics as usual. a bunch of bull!!!

Wake up people!!! Dont get caught up in the woman or minority running for president or one says his or her plan is complete and they will put this amount of money into this program, etc. The truth is that they wont really know the true state of the economy until they are in the drivers seat.

Besides, this is about America and what is best for our children and their children, and so on. What does color or gender have to do with this?!?!

Edwards was silly, snaky and very forceful …Even so he was saying good stuff but his foundation is weak something is clearly missing under the heels of Edwards. I can not put it in words but it's obvious. Either Hillary or Edwards can overcome the Republican in November. Hillary needs to be broken and learn true wisdom that make one a true leader. Obama appears to be more honest. I am not White American or African American . This is my opinion. As a citizen of the United States and as a NPA …I will not ever vote for Edwards or Clinton. America is very emotional!

The good thing is that everyone was able to discuss the issues….but Barack had to defend himself from the former president and his spin on all of Baracks words and policies….besides the Clintons have a clean slate…and If I remember she was the only was last night getting booed….yes Booed.

Who cares whether Bill Clinton can dance? There are imporatnt issues
that need to be addressed and the candidates need to stop small talk
and get to the meat of the matters. Where's the Beef? Americans should
want to hear straight talk and stop enough of this nonsense. This
is an insult to our intelligence. And whether Bill Clinton is a brother or not
does not pay the bills! Let's get our act together. Tell the public like it is and
let's put an end to beating around the bush. Enough is enough!

Ohhh…, this must be one of those questions that Wolf was so proud of his viewers for asking. CNN debates are a scripted joke..

John Edwards rose above the fray and showed the world who the best candidate for US President is…NC's favorite son, JOHN EDWARDS!!!!

Obama's remark was racist and I cannot believe he said it really. Is this the best he can do under pressure?

Look guys, you all know that Bill Clinton is not a african-american man. He is a caucasion male. So I think that is racist to suggest that his past weed habits and cheating on his wife compares him to black men. Yes, there is no doubt he has invested much of his candicacy in minority issues, but he is not black at all. Our country has never elected a black president in out history. So stop asking that dumb question!

Marshal Phillips, Wichita, Kansas January 22, 2008 10:29 am ET

How 'bout a Reality Show with a dancing Bill Clinton And Obama doing the two-step?

Don't forget George W. Bush, Dick Cheney, KKKarl Rove, and Tony Snw doing the "Misinformation Shuck & Jive" they've perfected over the past seven years….

Well, who is making the racist remarks now? If Hilliary or John Edwards had made that comment, the NAACP and other black organizations would be all over them. At the very beginning I really thought this guy might be something…but all he does now is disappoint me. I still don't know who to vote for, but Obama is at the bottom of the list right now. All talk…and nothing backing up his plans.

All (except maybe Edwards) appeared Petty, not Presidential.
The level of the debate was low the first half.

What Obama should have said:

John, you are my brother. Hillary, you are my sister. A year or so ago PBS ran a doc on a scientist who gathered DNA samples from people all over the earth in order to track the first human migration. In short, from anywhere on the planet, ancestry and migration point toward an African origin. All humans are African. You are not only my brother in Christ, you are my brother in scientific fact.

There is no need to talk about race for there is only one. Go see Lucy. "Ethiopia, the cradle of humanity."

Your brother, HH

I'm an Obama supporter, but I did think this was kind of an odd comment…

I was turned off by the remark, he was just playing into the same ignorant racial sterotypes, that have caused so many in this country to judge others inappropiately!

This is a stupid question because it a loaded question how can Former Persident Clinton be of European decent not African decent be the frist black president just because he played a sax on tv. Why didn't he ask Mrs clintion that stupid question .I took it very racist to Black America that the people started laugh. I know the of American European decent took it as joke

Left out of the story was Hillary's comeback to Obama's "I'd have to see him dance."
"Well, that can be arranged!" she said.

How 'bout a Reality Show with a dancing Bill Clinton And Obama doing the two-step?

thats hilarious!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Another double standard! If a white man would have made such a statement regarding such, he would have been called a racists. I.E. "if he could jump higher and not be able to swim, etc".

Why is it ok for Barack Obama to make a joke about "checking out Clinton's dance abilities" before deciding if "he's a brother?" If Hillary Clinton made that joke, everybody would be all over her about it.

Can you image if Edwards or a Media type made that dancing remark. Rev Al Sharpton would be all over them like white on rice (no pun intended) and calling for them to be fired and run out town.

Barack kept his cool and even made a joke to counter a very stupid comment. Hillary just kept exploding under pressure. Bill Clinton just slept through the MLK tribute.

Go Obama!

Once and for all. Bill Clinton is NOT African American. He has done many good things that have benefited that community but , so has Abraham Lincoln, JFk and LBJ. So please stop it already. The moderators dissappointed me with the constant referrence to race. There should have been more Econ questions.

I thought it was a tacky response.

Toni Morrison needs to be kicked in the teeth for making this ridiculous statement in the first place. No, he is not a brother. He may empathize with the black community but he has no idea what it's like to be black. Unfortunately, Barack had to make light of this question because to give the real answer would have meant a regression back into the racially charged dialogue of past few weeks. It was a no win scenario, so while I cringed at the dance reference, I understood where he was going.

It was a stupid question, anyway… why don't they focus on the issues? What, the media can't find 5 minutes to ask about climate change? Other important issues?

Dems are done. Republican are the real winners…

I saw Obama dance on Ellen, and trust me, he was no James Brown.

Personally, I think the comment was funny but, after the histrionics around other flip statements made by people in public, I feel the need to point out that if a white candidate had made the quip that candidate would have been lambasted

It was sad to see that even the African-American candidate thinks that the way to find out if somene is black is to see if they can dance. If Hillary would have said the exact same thing there would have been an uproar by now. Running to tired stereotypes is not funny even if a black person is the one doing it.

Dance? That was just a tacky, petty little stereotype. That's it? That's all he can come up with. I don't know who I'll support but I sure love watching that guy bomb every debate he has.

My favorite line of the night: We Are Just Getting Warmed Up.

Oddest line of the night: "I can't figure out who I'm running against"

Last night enforced once again, why I could never support Obama, on so many levels. He said several things that indicated to me that on some level, he is a racist and he has been divisive by making this campaign about race and attempting to belittle the positive work both Senator Clinton and President Clinton have done on behalf of civil rights. It would appear it's perfectly okay for Senator Obama and his wife to attack Senator Clinton but the second she brings out anything about his record, his misstatements or questionable dealings everyone goes to pieces and cries "foul." What's with this double standard? Why is it no one is allowed to question him on anything? Senator Clinton addressed him several times last night as "Senator Obama" and yet he called her "Hillary." No respect. I could go on but what good would it do? It seems Obama supporters only see and hear what they want to.

What a stupid question. What was he supposed to say? "Yes he is black"

Oh, 'brother', Obama. . .they are 'dancing you' right where they want you!!

I want to know why on earth the question was asked in the first place. It was insulting. I lost a lot of respect for CNN last night.

Hey, commenters – get a life! This was a light moment, a breath of fresh air. Breath deeply.

Do you think Bill likes fried chicken and watermelon? Can't be a "brother" if he doesn't, right, Barack? And we all know that white guys can't dance, right, Barack? But you can, because you're a "brother", right? Or are you only a "half brother", on your father's side?

What an idiotic statement. If Hillary, or God forbid, Edwards, had made a comment this racist, they'd be crucified by the media.

If the national media does its job with this story, Obama's candidacy is done.

I'm a huge fan of Obama, but this dancing joke about Bill didn't go well with some of our European American brothers.

Obama did not want say is the CLINTONS love for junck food, womaniser as one of the reason that racist poet called him the black president, not all black people like junck food, and womanise otherwise Mcdonald's would have an african name, and cassanova is satanly not an african if obama had pionted that out am sure if cauld have fallen in the trap of being just a Race Candidate , NOT all black people are poor, as not all black people can Dance but i would rather not dance well than be poor, womanise, and over weight

I'm not sure about dancing, but that old boy sure can sleep!

p.s. He is a pos!

Have them all play a game of hoops…winner gets the nomination! lol

Good answer Obama. Keep them rolling.

I saw Barack Obama dance on the Ellen Degeneres and based on that performance , whether Barcak is a "brother" is questionable.

Ive decided that I love hillary. Im not voting for Obama.

There are a lot of black people that have no rythm at all and can`t dance well, as there are a lot of white people that dances very well.It does not prove anything.
and has no nothing to do with who will be best president.
Mr.Clinton is a hell of a guy.He proved it. As for Obama,he should start by proving
what he can do .I am not sure at all that he is so pure.

The comment about "being a brother" was really racist. If a white person would say that it would be world headlines and the person would be bounced out of office. Hillary was the only person involved in the debate that offered solutions to problems instead of over using the words change. At this point, I've "changed" my mind and am going to vote for Hillary instead of Barack. I realize that America needs solutions to the problems.

I ain't an Obama supporter, but he answered it probably the best way he could, however, this may raise questions or even worse linking him to someone like Jesse Jackson which could spell out to be trouble.

If dancing ability is the only requirement, Obama would be as white as me. Have you seen the Ellen clip?

Something is wrong with Obama, he can not leave the Clinton's along. After Bill Clinton finsh his campaign this week. Obama, will lose S.C. Saturday which is good.

Obama did a good job of answering a 'no-win' question. I wish that the moderators did not feel the need to ask questions that have so little relevance to the issues at hand. It is still early in the race but I keep watching and waiting for debates that promote topics of substance.

The Clinton strategies is working. They're making Obama fight back so that it could diminize him as an unifier and, more importantly, the issue of race was brought up purposely by the Clinton Machine to portrait him more as a racial candidate rather than an AMERICAN candidate. I'm totally dissapointed with the Clintons. I think my choice would be Republican now.

This was not a debate question. If Obama had answered any other way it would have become racist – he answered an inappropriate question brilliantly.

Mrs. America, I guess you just found your excuse for not voting for a Black man!!! Because if you think Obama is slippery, then you must have been sleeping for the Bill and Hillary first show. Know wants to live through that again. And every man knows that Hillary did not forgive Bill. I would not be suprise if Hillary divorces Bill as soon as gets elected!!

Hillary is going to Win the Rase….

It was a response to a racist question. Mr. Obama had a choice of taking the high road ("Mr. Clinton has done a lot for people of all races in this country, and he is a force for equality…") or to show the voters of South Carolina and the country that he, Mr. Obama, is still a "brother". He chose the latter, and only he among the candidates could have said it.

To K. Rove:

Saying black guys can dance isn't the same as nappy headed hoes.

To Olivia:

Bill is 61 years old. There's no way he can dance better than Barack. And, who is "we"? Are you speaking on behalf of all of a certain demographic or are you speaking for yourself…clarify!

IM SO TIRED OF THE RACIAL REMARKS WE NEED TO COME TOGETHER OUR FUTURE DEPENDS ON THE NEXT PRESIDENT SO REMEMBER TO CHOSE THE RIGHT PERSON FOR PRESIDENT BASED ON WHAT THEY WILL DO FOR US AS A NATION NOT ON RACIAL COMMENTS MADE BY EACH OTHER.THIS IS SAD TO SAY BUT RACIAL REMARKS OR MADE BY ALOT OF PEOPLE OF ALL NOT FINGER POINTING NAMES BUT THEY KNOW WHO THEY ARE AND IT NEEDS TO STOP NOW,.

Olivia, what is racist is the question. After Obama pleads for the media to stop focusing on race and focus on the issues he get this stupid question. He handles the question well given the circumstances and gives a lighthearted answer.

National Security and Jobs produced over seas that have access to our personal information. I believe if foreign countries have access to our personal info posses a threat to our national security in the US. What will the candidate do about this? Fraud and Identity theft is a big problem in this country.

I am sick of hearing O'Bama is the black candidate. He is only 1/2 black and 1/2 white. We need to say American candidate. However I am still for John Edwards for all Americans, black white,purple,northern, southern etc.

what if a white presidential hopeful had made the same remark? the race card would have come flying out.

Olivia, if you think that was racist, you've never seen racism. Ever.

I thought this was as good as it gets, when ever the Clintons are down in the polls they become illusionist. Nice try Bill but nobody really bought it this time. Try a cowboy hat or sombrerro when you go out west again.

This was the best part of the debate. And I do not find it to be a remotely racist remark. It's just good humor!

Yep. Im glad people caught that. We all know It was meant in good fun but……..

I guess white people cant dance? HMM? Where is Clyburn RAGING over this comment?

Oh, thats right, racism only works one way for Clyburn.

Back on topic though.

Its easy for Obama to get all the laughs when he is sitting in a room FULL of African americans at a BLACK meeting hall.

I wonder how well Obama's jokes would go over in a meeting hall in Florida PACKED with 60 year old white women ?

I'm getting really tired of the media lie that Obama is the first leading black candidate. Jesse Jackson won five primaries and caucuses in 1984 and seven primaries and five caucuses in 1988. After winning Michigan in '88, he was considered the frontrunner.

We rarely hear the fact that Hillary Clinton is the first woman in the history of this country to win a primary.

Yesterday, at debate Obama made a statement about the stock market may have a problem tomorrow due to some other country's stock market having low numbers and Wolf shot back, no one knows what will happen on Stock Market. Well, apparently, Obama DID and was able to connect the dots!

I have little to joke about since I really don't feel "represented" by any of these candidates.

It was really a silly question to ask, so it only deserved a silly answer. It seems to me that Bill Clinton is running for president again. He seems to be getting more airtime than Hillary. I think the deck is stacked against Obama. If Hillary wins who's going to be running the Country Hillary or Bill????

WHY DOES BILL CLINTON HAVE TO BE A BLACK MAN TO BE ABLE TO REPRESENT THE BLACK PEOPLE?

God help anyone else up on the stage had those words left their lips…

DOUBLE STANDARD of who can say what!

Isn't this code language of blacks by which white America should be deeply offended?

Hey, Donna Brazile, isn't this when I should become offended as a causasion and begin flinging around my perosnal hurt? No, you say. It's not the same for non-blacks? DOUBLE STANDARD!

What are you saying now, Donna Brazile, CNN and the others who race to the offended side of the street at the first chance?

DOUBLE STANDARD.

I VOTE HILLARY TO MAKE THIS CHANGE

It was a dumb answer to a dumb question!!! If this was a debate, how come Edwards and Hillary did not have to answer. I'm ashamed of Joe for asking such a stupid question. Just because ONE black women feel that way, all BLACKS do not!!!

Looks Like Hill may win in S.C.

Economy just tanked.

If any candidate or aide to their campaign had "joked" about having to see if Senator Obama could dance, play basketball, or any thing remotely racially associated with African-Americans, they would be crucified in the media and by the Obama campaign as racist remarks. But it's okay for Senator Obama to say such things. I am really angered by the double standards the media endorses in regards to politics. R Heruska, NC

First of all, for CNN to highlight this "again" and of all things this pretty much tells you who is making this a race issue. It was said in jest, and we're smart enough to get it. Anyone taking it further than that are trying to ignite something that didn't previously exist. FACT. White people dance and Black people dance and they do generally do not dance alike. Who cares. Let's talk about the partisan and post partisan message and why we as Democrats think that Republicans are the root of all evil. History has consistently shown us what a divided nation accomplishes. It's time for some unity. If you want to send a message on color why not ask the question why it is we are so focused on Red vs. Blue?

I'm offended. Obama's statement was racist and reprehensible.

The remark Mr Obama made is not funny nor it is cute, it is stereotyping blacks, if you can not dance then you cannot be black which is so untrue there are people in the black race that cannot lift a foot to dance and are proud of their black culture. This race stuff has to stop somewhere; it appears that Mr. Obama himself is pushing the race card. I find his remark "offensive" and more that of someone on an Imus show rather than a presidential candidate. Is this how he would represent our country with these so called funny/cute remarks?

As an Obama supporter I winced when he said that. Everyone laughed at first but I was afraid that at some point some nut would try to pick it apart as racist and that would hurt him.

Hey…Bill will be your brother, momma, and daddy too….if it will help him reclaim the Clinton dynasty!

I say–let him go back to his philanthropic work…send Hillary back to the Senate–to help President Edwards make the changes she's so passionate about.

Bill Clinton is definitely good at pretending he appeals to every community, but he has done nothing for this black man.

Another great, newsworthy story from CNN. Don't you guys have anything better to do?

what was that comment to mean about Bill Clinton, dance, and brother? Bill Clinton is white and Barack is half white. Which brother did Barack mean? I thought it was a funny ( haha) comment and, at the same time, funny ( strange) comment to make….
Obama did say that he felt Clinton's reputation was well- earned and that was a direct answer to the question. Many times, in my opinion, is so good at slipping around direct answers!

well Hillary did show that she can handle the boys. She did terrific job in showing Obama where to go.

Olivia,

No this is a racist comment, when have you ever heard anyone ask a white person these questions???????!?!?!?!?!?!?!?

CNN’s Joe Johns asked Barack Obama whether he thought former President Bill Clinton was the nation’s ‘first black president,’ an observation famously coined by black Nobel laureate Toni Morrison.

That man is not a black president – he is white…Case closed! That is insulting and degrading to every black person to suggest that some white man is a black person. But we already know the makeup of this country now don't we!?!?!?!

The clinton's did nothing for this country or for Black people. Post facts about what they've done – you will never see any because they did nothing.

Olivia, if you cannot take a bit of humour, too bad because the rest of America can! You were funny Barack, best soundbite!

I thought it was funny.

I have no idea if Obama is the best candidate, but he is a pretty sharp guy. Sharp would be a nice change of pace after the past 7 years of incompetence and waste from our executive branch.

Bill would have to be awake in order to dance wouldn't he?

Would that be sleep walking?

I agree with "Hillary hates cats", Slick Willy earned his nickname for dancing and yes sheep "skirting" the issues.

While he was "skirting" the issues, we were getting bombed all around the world and when the recession hit after the DOTCOM bust, he did NOTHING because he was "busy".

At least the shrub is attempting to do something.

Hillary is also an excellent dancer as she can vote FOR a bankruptcy bill and then "be allowed" to state that "she was happy that it didn't pass".

Nice move Hillary.

ABC.

Mrs. America,

What dirt are you talking about? The much talked about Rezko issue? Edwards and Clinton brought up points that have been addressed time and time again, but rely on the ignorance of the American people and the reliance on sound bytes to generate opinions.

Obama has the right to defend himself and his record and it's disappointing that his words are being twisted like no other and he had to spend so much time straightening it out.

Olivia, it's a play on the ridiculous caricature set forth by people call Clinton the first Black President.

What was left out of the transcript above was Clinton's remark: She could have just let it go with a laugh but, no, in The Clintons' typical in-your-face-about-everything, she said: "We can arrange that".

The big question however is: how much Red Bull will it take to keep Bill awake long enough to compete in the dance off ?

Guess what, He still did not answer the question, Just like Hillary said. He never answer's any of the questions during debates. Its a yes or no. No time for jokes, who are you, Huckabee?

Come on Mr. Obama.
I suppose Bill Clinton will be judged on his "basketball skills" also!
That is one of the most racist remarks I've heard during this campaign.
You may say you want change, but your rhetoric belongs in the past.
You know, before MLK and LBJ got together to sort out the mess.
Go Hillary!

As I've thought…and said to many of my caucasian, asian, latino, and black friends…Obama is a TRUE POLITICIAN…he's accused Hillary of saying just about anything to get elected while he does the same thing. I was really disappointed that Mr. Obama can't go past his political ambitions to admit the President Clinton has done more than any other top politicians out there, black, white, asian, latino, to the cause of the African-American. It is disgusting that Obama would rather say that Ronald Raegan, as good as he was for brining down communism, as a tranformer of America than Mr Clinton. Wake up Mr Obama! Who was fighting for your race when he was in the White House? Reagan or Clinton?

How important will the black vote after Saturday?

Olivia, lighten up. It was one of the most endearing parts of the debate. Remember, he was posed a question. How was he supposed to answer? He was engaging, honest, and humorous.

The reality is the question was loaded and Obama was able to deflect it with humor. The reality is also that no other candidate could have said that and not been called a racist. If he had asked about Bill's like or dislike of watermelon it would have came from the same stereotype.

Such a racist remark – and of course no comments from the press! If Hillary or John Edwards had said something like that – they would have to abandon their campaign – such a double standard. It's unbelievable.

Barak Obama let Queen Hilary talk in your stead. When she is finished then attempt to speak. That's the only way to confront Clintonism.
Since her 35 years of expertise is inter-twined with that of her President Clinton husband then, on the issues also include his record.
Education: The Corridor of Shame and Special Ed is reflective of past administrations. That is systemic of false hopes.
Economics: It was the Clinton administration with the support of a Republican Congress and Senate that did the damage.
Get tough – Don't be percieved as a WHIMP!

Bill needs to shut up, stand behind her, and let Hillary run her own race. In my eyes, he is nothing but a bother and a hinderance. I wouldn't vote for her anyway. I don't want another guaranteed scandal ridden presidency (and yes I know Bush's has been as well). I don't forget the past and choose to learn from what they both did before as a team.

Good comment but if a white person had said it, they would be in jail by now.

Had a white man made a comment like this about a black man, he would be called a racist. I guess because Obama said it, it means he has humor?

Olivia, lighten up- it was a joke, and a very funny one.
"K Rove", that's stupid- anyone could have said that, and it would if been a joke. On the other hand, if Obama called someone a "nappy headed ho", he might have had a problem.

"Hillary HATES CATS"- thank you for that stupid, non-sequitor comment. Bill Clinton is not running, and this story is about Obama…..and after 8 years of Bush, Clinton looks like a choirboy.

"Mrs. America", I didn't like the bickering either- but I disagree with you about Obama being "slippery". I thought he did an excellent job at answering the mostly unfair jabs that Hillary tried to hit him with- the one about working for a "slumlord", for example. He was a junior partner at a law firm who worked for a total of 5 hours on a partnership between that slumlord and a church group serving the homeless.

I usually consider myself Hillary supporter, and would definitely vote for her over any Republican, but attacks like that one are just more standard political nonsense, and are disappointing. Obama is the only one who actually talks like a human being who means what he says, and not a focus-group-programmed machine that waits for openings to spit out one of 10 canned, rehearsed applause lines. The more I see him, the more I like him.

Olivia, if you consider that answer racist, consider the question. He answered absurd with absurd, and rightly so. And note that he did address the AA affinity with Bill Clinton to boot.

Mrs. America, I agree that there was way too much bickering, but when one candidate levels distorted truths at another, the candidate on the receiving end deserves to try to clear the record on camera. Hillary played the Clinton game well, and Obama wasn't able to thoroughly explain his reasoning in the alloted time. However, I wouldn't determine that he's "slippery" because sound bytes are not his most effective means of communication…

It's a shame that more Americans don't just do research on all the candidates. They all have books, websites, and voting records.

i find fault in the question….. they asked him a racist question … he answered and now (here we go again)… he's the racist…. you have got to be kiddin me…people please

HILLARY 08 ALL THE WAY TO VICTORY

It's such a stupid question to ask if Bill Clinten was the first Black President!!! Do you wanna fool me? Bill is as white as Bush! Please stay to reality! It's so offending to Millions African-Americans and even Africans.

Hillary Clinton will win, no matter how much you people continue to attack her. Once again, Obama was backed into the corner when confronted on the real issues! Without his pre-written speech he's clueless on the issues!

Hillary owned the stage once again at the debate last night! John Edwards was pretty good too. Was glad to see him question Obama on his record too!

It wasn't racist it was a joke. I'm black and I don't have a lick of rhytm. So?

I am so sick of this race talk. No one can criticize Obama without being called a racist. Isn't that what we have in Bush – a president who calls all his critics a politically charged name – un patriotic? I will not vote for Obama and put up with more censorship through "political corrrectness."

Obama has been given a free pass – no questions about his muslim family members one who is a political leader in a muslim country, his education in a muslim school, his present votes or anything of substance. We are expected to cheer his empty statements or be considered racist.

And by the way – he is biracial NOT black

Does that constitute a PRESENT decision?

Obama sure knows how to keep calm when a racially charged question could have easily been taken out of context. Though is answer to the question of if Bill Clinton was the first black president was NO, he brought fun jokes into it. Bill might be disappointed but it is what it is.

Have these democratic debates really helped race relations? Is Bill Clinton the first black President. If black people believe this then they have an identity crisis on their hands. A lot of black people also said that Barach was not black enough.

I bet that after this weekend, that none of the candidates will mention MLK. It was just useful to them to score political points during the debate. I'm also wondering how Hillary is going to balance her Latino and Black support at the same time since the issue of illegal immigration has caused a lot of concern in the black community.

Oops, I just played group politics right out of the democratic play book.

Senator Obama comments were as light hearted as the question in itself. Who could take such a ridiculous question any other way? African Americans have always commented that President Clinton had some soulful ways ( like the way he played the saxophone). That particular comment was made publicly by more than just Toni Morrison (such as by comedian Chris Tucker) in a jesting manner. It was all said as a compliment and in good fun toward President Clinton, who at the time was well liked by the majority of African American voters.

Hilarious. What I like about Obama is that his answers are unscripted and authentic.

By contrast, Mrs. Clinton's answers – even her attacks – are always canned and full of dead air.

Obama was exceedingly succint and on point in the debate tonight, to include his answer to this rather absurd question. Hillary was frantic and spoke in circles and platitudes. I am a Republican who is seriously considering voting Obama should he win the Democratic nomination.

Obama is right. We need to see him dance

This was a stereotypical comment about blacks by Barack Obama – If I were Black, I'd be embarrased that he would inpune that we have to be good dancers to be Black.

I'm glad Senator Clinton spanked him tonight.

I'm from Sudan I'm not an American but if I was, I would've chosen Obama. I'm black but that doesn't have anything to do with me chosing Obama. When Obama speaks, I see a man that I can trust. Someone once said, "Please God, if You can't make me thin, make my friends fat" That's what Clinton is saying. Clinton didn't start attacking Obama untill she felt like she was loosing. When she started loosing, she started saying, "If the people are not falling in love with me, then they should not fall in love with you, too (Obama)". I like what Mike Huckubee said after the N.H. campaign; he said, "I rather lose with dignity then win with dishonor." Mrs. Clinton is not saying that and if I was to vote, I don't think I would give my voice to a person with such mentality.

Jurkuch
Dallas, TX

As an African American woman, I resent the fact that the media has "adopted" the moniker that President Clinton was the first "Black" president just because a single author called him that. Where was the vote of the rest of our community?

Bill Clinton did a lot of positive things. But he also slept around, soiled the "People's house," lied, and gave out pardons to felons like candy. He was contemptuous of our tax dollars when "attempting" to set up his office in New York (asking for much more financial support than any other president in history) and only put his office in Harlem after being embarrassed in the media.

Balanced reporting means remembering his entire legacy – not just the warm and fuzzies.

And please note that, like you always do, CNN has truncated Morrison's comment. She said that she expected "to see in her lifetime." That's pretty much because – in the 1990's, none of us ever expected the country to move towards electing a woman or African American so soon.

Toni Morrison was within her right to give Clinton that name. Doesn't mean the rest of us agree with it.

Don't you think it would have hit the fan if Hillary or Edwards had made a joke about blacks being good dancers or perpetuated any other strereotype?
I guess since Obama is black…it's OK????

FINALLY.

Someone exposes the fairy tale for what it truly was. Is it fair that Bill Clinton has gone 15 YEARS without anyone questioning his dancing abilities?

Thank you for asking the important questions, CNN. You know, the ones that don't further fuel the Race vs. Gender "debate". Honestly, who cares about actual issues?

Michael Jackson 2008!!! Not only can he moonwalk, but we can avoid the race AND gender debate.

Nonsense, Mr Obama.
I am a brother,really "black" brother.Not even light skinned. But when it comes to dancing one would say that i got two left feet.
Being a good dancer does not make any one Black.

This is what we want:
a very talented and genius president for the future of the States.

You think Obama could've pulled this comment off in Iowa?

I am a NP CA voter and I am delighted to finally see a better list of candidates to face the republicans in the next election as I find no TRUST so far in any of the republican candidates except for McCain. I admire the ability of making the best of any debate as John Edwards did in the NC debate. I believe we are heading for some real fun in this election and the first time we get to see a diversed participation. Obama, is really great in speaking, I am concerned he can actually convince and perform once in WA but; so far, he is causing a stir for which most of us the voters are delighted to see and admire. Clinton, comes too selfish but with vast knowledge… Edwards, probably the best VP for the two front runners.

Obama,

The question was do you think Bill Clinton was the “first black president”. The answer you gave was respectful to what Bill Clinton has done in his two terms as president, but than you said “I would have to investigate more Bill’s dancing abilities, you know, some of this other stuff before I accurately judged whether he was in fact a ‘brother,’”…

Please stay away from the black stereotypes, you won Iowa because you did not conform to any ones stereotype, you appear to be above that.

Bill Clinton gained an enormous amount of respect justified or not from the black community, however, HE IS NOT the first black president.

I love Barack Obama. I love the fact that he is an astute, articulate, and very capable champion for people of all races in America.

There is no doubt in my mind Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. would have been very proud of him. I am proud of him and look forward to voting for him on February 5th.

Tammy Bullock

Are you serious? You ACTUALLY just posted this as news? Could you focus any more on what color Barack Obama is? I know he is light skinned and all, but i'm pretty sure everyone has figured it out by now, so you can stop drilling it into the ground CNN.. noone cares, and i'm outright offended you have heaped this slop on us.

Clinton was not the first black president. He contribute a lot to the african American society and a lot of black people love him for all he did but Bill Clinton has done his two terms and its time to give somebody else a chance. NO MORE CLINTONS!! We need Somebody with a fresh face who will bring about quality change and unite the American people. I think Obama is the best candidate for change and will no doubt be the first black president of America. Remeber: Race or gender might play a important role in this election but the when you look on the other side of this all the people of America is what matter most. People have now realise that Obama is ready to be a leader and morte than ready to serve.

Clinton was not the first black president. He contribute a lot to the african American society and a lot of black people love him for all he did but Bill Clinton has done his two terms and its time to give somebody else a chance. Somebody with a fresh face who will bring about quality change and unite the Amerivcan people. I think Obama is the best candidate for chane and will no doubt be the first black president of America. Remeber: Race or gender might play a important role in this election but the when you look on the other side of this all the people of America is what matter most. People have now realise that Obama is ready to be a leader and morte than ready to serve.

I love Obama. I love Bill and Hilary. Being a African American it hard to say whether Clinton was the first black president. I like Obama, wanta see him dance.

ANYONE else making a bigotted reference to blacks and dancing would be drawn and quartered, but Obama can insult his 'brothers' and get away with it. It is because of comments like those, the rest of the world, and Don Imus, thinks its OK to repeat them. Shame on Barack for perpetuating prejudice and myth. A bad, tasteless joke from a man who wants to be a role model.

That was the Dumbest question ever! CNN insist on making barack the black candidate.

I was offended at the remark! I felt he was portraying racism by saying that a person of different color could not dance the way a black man could. It's time Mr. Obama shows exactly what he will do for the white community. We already know he us 100% behind the black community., but haven't really heard what he will do for the whites.

It was a ridiculous question and it should NOT have been asked. CNN was looking for soundbites and to make both candidates uncomfortable. It has NOTHING to do with being a leader of this country and CNN should be ashamed they wasted valuable time of the viewers and the canditdates with it. There is so much that voters want to hear about the issues and the plans of these candidates.

Barack Obama handled the question well – as well as an insignificant ridiculous questions can be answered.

CNN when Jan 31st rolls around – can you ask the questions that are on the voters minds and not inane divisive attention-getting questions for ratings? PLEASE!

Good question — but maybe we'd rather know – if we voted for Obama's white half would we be considered racist?! (oops my bad). It really is too bad that the media and Donna Brazile had to start focusing on Barack as THE black candidate. Now if he wins SC by a landslide, everyone will just dismiss it as go figure – who else are all the African American voters going to support?!

And the most honest answer to the question, what is your biggest weakness – should have been = that he can't quit smoking. Maybe that's why he appeals to all the guys who see him as a manly Marlboro man rather than a girly man as Arnold likes to call sissies (Although to be fair, Laura Bush is a closet smoker and nobody says you've come a long way baby anymore.) So does Barack puff cigars with the good old boys club too LOL. About as relevant as the debate…. NOT

Hmmmmm, if Hillary or John were to make that type of remark, they would be labelled racist, but it's okay for Obama to say it…..BAD BAD BAD
Oh and the ability to speak well in a public event…what happened to Senator Obama?
John Edwards was very worthy and should be reinforced for his efforts, he was refreshing, and in my opion he should taken Obama to the carpet for making him feel insugnificant since there is a woman and an african american and there is John. Again very rookieish and not pretty for someone whos is suppose to be runnung a campaign for hope.

Bill can dance and play the horn – how about Barack?

This was Obama's best moment in the debate. He was out shone by both John and Hillary this evening. He doesn't handle scrutiny too well, and it showed big time!

i am taken aback that obama used the phrase "whether he was in fact a BROTHER" when referring to bill clinton. for someone who has been saying that this is not about race, such a racial phrase is telling.

So if say, John Edwards, or any other white person, said in response to this question “I would have to investigate more Bill’s dancing abilities, you know, some of this other stuff before I accurately judged whether he was in fact a ‘brother,’ – Would anyone think it was funny?

Bravo Senator Obama!

Senator Obama probably did not want to comment on a divisive race question that should not have been asked in the first place and I think he gained points by side stepping the question.

Shame on CNN for not asking tougher questions!

Asking a question regarding a quote from Tony Morrison was not appropriate.

We all can attest to the fact that Clinton is not black no matter how many people know him in Harlem. It was a question asked to lighten the mood and since a black women originally was attributed to the phrase its politically correct to ask Obama this question. So now my question would be: Is Hiliary going to be our fist lesbian president? Just kidding *<{:0) Seriously though he handled the question tactfully and it was a very comedic situation but if my question would have been asked would it have been in poor taste?

Clinton has done more for black people before Obama was 10. Obama is no Clinton…studder studder

Look we've got one shot at this. When you listen to the Republican comments, they tend to favor Obama. Now wonder why they would favor him and try to belittle Hillary? Could it be that they would rather face him than her in the general election? Could it be that they think their chances are better if Obama wins the Democratic nomination? Do they think it would be harder for them to beat Hillary?

Think people, think.

Personally, I think any of the Democratic candidates would be better than what we now have and what we could have.

I'm voting for experience, the one I believe has the best chance to win, and the one that has a former President as an assett. I will vote for Hillary.

ONCE AGAIN OBAMA SHOWS HIS SHALLOW AND JUVENILE ATTEMPTS AT HUMOR. I FIND IT INCREASINGLY DIFFICULT TO BELIEVE THAT THIS LIGHT WEIGHT IS CONSIDERED A VIABLE CANDIDATE FOR ANYTHING EXCEPT CLASS CLOWN. I TRULY BELIEVE IF HE WERE A WHITE MALE, HE WOULD NOT BE ANY MORE VIABLE THAN MIKE GRAVEL WAS. HE BRINGS VERY LITTLE THAT IS WORTHWHILE TO THE TABLE. ENOUGH ALREADY

SO I GUESS BILL CLINTON CAN SLING MUD AND OBAMA DOES NOT HAVE A RIGHT TO DEFEND HIS RECORD. COME ON PEOPLE. YOU KNOW THAT IF YOU ARE IN A RACE, YOU NEED TO DEFEND UNTRUTHS SO PEOPLE VOTE FOR OR AGAINST YOU BASED ON THE FACTS. YOU PEOPLE ARE SO "IN LOVE" WITH THE CLINTONS THAT YOU BELIEVE ANYTHING THEY SAY. OBAMA HAS A RIGHT TO DEFEND BILL CLINTON'S NONSENSE. WHY? BECAUSE WE ALL KNOW THAT DEMOCRATS ARE TERRIFIED OF THE "CLINTON MACHINE." GUESS WHAT, THEY CAN BE TAKEN DOWN.

THAT'S WHY I WOULD VOTE FOR A REPUBLICAN BEFORE HILLARY BECAUSE I KNOW REPUBLICANS WON'T BE AFRAID TO TAKE ON THE "CLINTON MACHINE."

I thought, particularly according to Obama's attitude this campaign, that we were all brothers (and sisters). Now there's some "stuff" we have to live up to? I think this remark was very telling of Obama's true self. He who espouses the importance of words, should have chosen some different words tonight.

LOL Didn't "Americas First Black President" fall asleep at a MLK event today in front of everyone and the news cameras. That video was priceless. I can hear the lies and excuses now. " I did not fall asleep at that event"

Yeah America really needs 4-8 more years the Clintons in the White House.

I found that "dance like a brother" comment to be annoying.

First, a white person couldn't say it without being called racist.

Second, to play with the race issue like that, after a week of whining about the Clintons being racist to him, just made him look disingenuous.

all i know when a clinton was in office gas was $1.10

all you clinton haters make me sick. when he left…….. the country was in good shape.

bush= record profits for exxon. $3.50 per gallon. subprime……. and s&l in the 80s.

yeah i know…….. its not his fault …… 9-11 and competition from china??????

GO HILLARY………… and yes we get bill for free.

oh yeah so only black man van be brother . so who played the race card and who benefitted from it . its omvious now —————-OBAMA
GO HILLARYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

He has no choice. If he must agree with brother Morrison, then he will put a gun against his head. He will never truly answer such question, even his Mom is asking for a mercy from Theodore Robert Bundy.. )

Correct. It is very patronizing that Bill Clinton wants to claim he was our first Black President. So if he wants to make the claim, jokingly, then let Obama jokingly make him earn it. LOL

The reality is how in the heck can Bill Clinton try to be African-American. He is as southern of a red-nosed good ole boy as anyone can be. And although that is cool, Bill is who is he, one thing he definitely isn't is Black.

I don't know if that question was meant to be funny but I certainly found it patronizing!

Maybe Andrew Young should have answered it and not wasted Barack's time.

Here's a few race facts for you:

- Between 1994 and 2002, the average time served by African Americans for a drug offense increased by 73%, compared to an increase of 28% for white drug offenders.

- In 1994, African Americans served an average of 33.1 months for a drug offense; this grew to 57.2 months by 2002.

- Time served for drug offenses for whites increased from 29.1 months in 1994 to 37.2 months in 2002.

- African Americans now serve virtually as much time in prison for a drug offense (57.2 months) as whites do for a violent offense (58.8 months).

About 10.4% of the entire African-American male population in the United States aged 25 to 29 was incarcerated, by far the largest racial or ethnic group—by comparison, 2.4% of Hispanic men and 1.2% of white men in that same age group were incarcerated.

A report by the Justice Policy Institute in 2002, the number of black men in prison has grown to five times the rate it was twenty years ago.

Today, more African-American men are in jail than in college or the military!

In 2000 there were 791,600 black men in prison and 603,032 enrolled in college. In 1980, there were 143,000 black men in prison and 463,700 enrolled in college.

There’s a lot of internal soul searching and education that will be required to reverse this trend.

I'm glad Mr. Obama made the statement, for if Don Imus had said it, he'd be off the air.

I have a question in regard to Obama being the first "black" man to run for the office of president.
Is his Mother not white?
So, excuse me – but does that not make him as much white as he is black? I do not understand the need to align himself among the African American voters. Does he feel that to be his best way of becoming president?
I have lost some respect for him in recent debates because he seems to play on the "poor me" – not knowing "which" Clinton he is running against. If he is to be president – he will need to learn to take criticism from all directions.
Thank you for the opportunity to post my view.

What I wish someone would explain to me is WHY we are allowing BILL CLINTON to take such an "in your face" position in this election process. Granted, he was once president, but I thought Hillary was the one running for president, not both of them! No other candidate has their spouse in the forefront, running their mouth, making comments, giving opinions, etc. Has it dawned on anyone besides me that as Hillary runs for president, we are getting an awful lot of Bill, too?? Are they are actually running together?? Is that legal or fair for two people to run as one candidate? If Hillary does indeed win, will we have to look at Bill's face all the time, or will he be a quiet "First Spouse" and stay in the background like all the First Lady's do?? I don't get why we are allowing this "dual candidacy" to take place and why no one speaks up about it. I had enough of Bill Clinton when he was president, and although, as a Republican, I could actually consider voting for Hillary, I don't think I can stomach four — or possibly eight — more years of Bill Clinton's face or mouth!

This is totally a racist remark. "I would have to investigate more Bill’s dancing abilities, you know, some of this other stuff before I accurately judged whether he was in fact a ‘brother,’” joked the Illinois senator." We bet Bill can dance alot better than Obama. We seen Obama dance. And its just like his debates. Boring.

Best part of the whole debate right there.

good answer way to avoid the bait!!!!

What I want to know is who is Obama's mother?

I thought she is a caucasian woman from Kansas…..

Has Obama turned his back on this heritage? Why does he call himself an African American when he is half caucasian?

I am not slamming his black heritage. He has forgotten he has a white heritage also.

So when we talk about a black man and a woman running for president, we are not quite accurate, are we?

Even though tonight's debate convinced me that my gut feelings have been right–that Obama is too slippery for me to be supportive of anymore, I have to admit I got a real kick out of that dancing statement. Obama showed a great sense of humor. I also am giggling about the "an African-American, a woman, and John" statement.

I did not like the beginning bickering. That's so bad for the party, but someone has to bring up the dirt that Obama has been getting away with for so long because the press treats him so delicately. And if Obama becomes the nominee, he has to learn how to start giving answers because the Reps sure aren't going to let him off easy.

Good debate, most of it. Wolf did a great job in some touchy circumstances.

I didn't like his comment. For a man who says he doesn't see color, he needs to be more aware of how he portrays African Americans.

As a Black man, I understand the approach Obama took in answering the question. He dosent want to turn off anyone segment of America in his answer and I give Obama credit for how he answered the question until the part about dancing only becasue it plays into sterotypes.

I feel that CNN should not have asked that question during a debate. I feel that CNN had Joe John ask that foolish question because it would have have flew if Wolf asked the question. CNN, stop playing into the race issue and attempting to divide this country. Bush has already done enough damage by dividing.

The entire question of Bill Clinton being the first black president is offensive and is not a question that belongs in a debate. Was Hillary asked how does it feel to be married to a black man? Of course not!! Bill Clinton is not black ! The claim is made when he needs something from black people. The question is demeaning and basless. More time should have been spent on the economy, jobs and civil rights.

I am ready to put all my dimes on the table, that what was said by the socalled white american in your survey was all conceited.

Wait for 5th february and the world will know……………….they will not put their votes where their mouths are!!

Wow, just look at the double standard racism that Obama can get away with. If a white candidate would suggest that white people do a certain thing better than black people, he would be crucified by the media.

This is why race relations suck in America. White people have to sit back and take the brunt of racist jokes and all we can do is smile. Say something similar and risk losing your career and reputation.

ROFLMAO Thats RIGHT! We see NOW that Bill is competeing with a " Brother" he is playing Dirty. Typical.

True colors ALWAYS show through sooner or later.

If a white person would of made that comment they would be called a racist.

Bill Clinton Can dance around the truth.