Comments on: Gergen: A Political masterpiece http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/ All politics, all the time Mon, 21 Dec 2009 22:07:36 +0000 http://wordpress.com/ hourly 1 By: marie http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569844 marie Fri, 29 Aug 2008 12:03:44 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569844 I was in total awe as well. What a speech! An amazing man! I was in total awe as well. What a speech! An amazing man!

]]> By: J.D. http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569831 J.D. Fri, 29 Aug 2008 12:01:55 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569831 I have been an Obama supporter for a long time (although not as long as many others). I watched the speech with my kids (ages 15 and 13). The 13 year-old fell asleep (no real surprise there). The 15 year-old, who is not political at all, thought it was incredible. For me, I thought the speech showed both promise and failure. The promise is that we can change the way we debate the issues and resolve the conflicts that face our nation. Obama spoke of the need for common ground, and the need for civility. He properly honors John McCain for his service and his sacrifice. And by doing so, he challenges all of us to do the same -- to debate these matters with force and with respect. However, he failed to echo the call that John F. Kennedy put to us over 40 years ago -- to ask what we can do for our nation. Both major political parties err when they proclaim what "they" will do for "us." I for one am tired of the "what's in it for me" theory of American politics. ("This election is about you" was one of his biggest disappointing themes.) We already have too many Americans being asked to shoulder the burden for us -- those who serve on distant shores to protect "our freedoms" so we can go out and "spend" for our country, or those who work at minimum wage so that we can have all the comforts we need, or those who benefit from huge tax cuts so our schools can be underfunded. We as a nation are at our best when things are at there worst. When we rise together, not because we have to do so, but because it is the right thing to do, we can accomplish more than we can possibly image. Why else do we have countlerss volunteer firefighters who band together and train every week, and risk their own safety, in the simple belief that when a neighbor's home is buring, the right thing to do is put the fire out. My hope is that Obama can make civility a central theme of this grand debate. Then he should go the next step and call on this nation to share the sacrifice to overcome the challenges of the day. If he can do so, he would have truly changed our world. I have been an Obama supporter for a long time (although not as long as many others). I watched the speech with my kids (ages 15 and 13). The 13 year-old fell asleep (no real surprise there). The 15 year-old, who is not political at all, thought it was incredible.

For me, I thought the speech showed both promise and failure. The promise is that we can change the way we debate the issues and resolve the conflicts that face our nation. Obama spoke of the need for common ground, and the need for civility. He properly honors John McCain for his service and his sacrifice. And by doing so, he challenges all of us to do the same - to debate these matters with force and with respect.

However, he failed to echo the call that John F. Kennedy put to us over 40 years ago - to ask what we can do for our nation. Both major political parties err when they proclaim what "they" will do for "us." I for one am tired of the "what's in it for me" theory of American politics. ("This election is about you" was one of his biggest disappointing themes.) We already have too many Americans being asked to shoulder the burden for us - those who serve on distant shores to protect "our freedoms" so we can go out and "spend" for our country, or those who work at minimum wage so that we can have all the comforts we need, or those who benefit from huge tax cuts so our schools can be underfunded.

We as a nation are at our best when things are at there worst. When we rise together, not because we have to do so, but because it is the right thing to do, we can accomplish more than we can possibly image. Why else do we have countlerss volunteer firefighters who band together and train every week, and risk their own safety, in the simple belief that when a neighbor's home is buring, the right thing to do is put the fire out.

My hope is that Obama can make civility a central theme of this grand debate. Then he should go the next step and call on this nation to share the sacrifice to overcome the challenges of the day.

If he can do so, he would have truly changed our world.

]]> By: Dimitri http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569830 Dimitri Fri, 29 Aug 2008 12:01:51 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569830 Awestruck! Is that what you’re looking for? Someone who impresses you with his speaking ability? Look for substance people, not fluff. Hitler was great as a speaker also, not so as a leader! Obama is all wonderful promises, but how is he going to pay for it? Windfall profit taxes on big oil? They don’t make enough money to pay for his commitments. Let’s not mention the fact that nobody called for windfall profit taxes when all of you were all obscene money during the housing boom! It was called free markets then. This guy is just another politician. Say anything you need to get elected. Awestruck! Is that what you’re looking for? Someone who impresses you with his speaking ability? Look for substance people, not fluff. Hitler was great as a speaker also, not so as a leader!

Obama is all wonderful promises, but how is he going to pay for it? Windfall profit taxes on big oil? They don’t make enough money to pay for his commitments. Let’s not mention the fact that nobody called for windfall profit taxes when all of you were all obscene money during the housing boom! It was called free markets then.

This guy is just another politician. Say anything you need to get elected.

]]> By: petena http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569828 petena Fri, 29 Aug 2008 12:01:22 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569828 Absolutely brilliant! And it is only because the man is intelleigent, knowledgeable, and articulate. I can't see anyone in the GOP even coming close. Absolutely brilliant! And it is only because the man is intelleigent, knowledgeable, and articulate. I can't see anyone in the GOP even coming close.

]]> By: lynn http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569827 lynn Fri, 29 Aug 2008 12:01:06 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569827 Obama has always had these qualitites. The media has just bought its own snarky line about who this remarkable man is. The media line fed upon the negativity of first Clinton and now McCain. We with eyes wide open always saw who Obama truly was. He has always been this, but tonight he gave a performance that made it impossible for the lies and deception of the media's anti-Obama narrative and GOP smears to stand against him. The media now has to clean up its act. No one needs to fawn over Obama, but the media should stop with the double standard and the lies and criticize McCain just as much as it criticizes Obama. And when McCain gives a lousy speech say it, because he mostly does. Obama has always had these qualitites. The media has just bought its own snarky line about who this remarkable man is. The media line fed upon the negativity of first Clinton and now McCain. We with eyes wide open always saw who Obama truly was. He has always been this, but tonight he gave a performance that made it impossible for the lies and deception of the media's anti-Obama narrative and GOP smears to stand against him. The media now has to clean up its act. No one needs to fawn over Obama, but the media should stop with the double standard and the lies and criticize McCain just as much as it criticizes Obama. And when McCain gives a lousy speech say it, because he mostly does.

]]> By: rich Phila pa http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569826 rich Phila pa Fri, 29 Aug 2008 12:00:56 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569826 Obama's speech offered nothing we haven't heard him say before, and it contained nothing substantial. I think everyone was awestruck by the theatrics and pyrotechnics and failed to see that the story line was just the same old stuff. So much for his promise of CHANGE. I eagerly await CNNs "balanced coverage" of the RNC!! Obama's speech offered nothing we haven't heard him say before, and it contained nothing substantial.

I think everyone was awestruck by the theatrics and pyrotechnics and failed to see that the story line was just the same old stuff. So much for his promise of CHANGE.

I eagerly await CNNs "balanced coverage" of the RNC!!

]]> By: Bob Ballentine http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569825 Bob Ballentine Fri, 29 Aug 2008 12:00:44 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569825 Obama's speech was one of the best speeches I have heard, and the best acceptance speech I have ever heard. I didn't think I had any hope left for this country, but he helped me find some again. He makes me believe my children may actually have a future. Obama's speech was one of the best speeches I have heard, and the best acceptance speech I have ever heard. I didn't think I had any hope left for this country, but he helped me find some again.

He makes me believe my children may actually have a future.

]]> By: Larry in TX http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569824 Larry in TX Fri, 29 Aug 2008 12:00:43 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569824 Obama's acceptance speech was inspiring. I was amazed how every single sentence was something that brought a nod of agreement, a moment of reflection, or even a cheer. McCain has a lot of work to do if he is going to convince me that he's the man for this job. I'm all ears. Obama's acceptance speech was inspiring. I was amazed how every single sentence was something that brought a nod of agreement, a moment of reflection, or even a cheer.

McCain has a lot of work to do if he is going to convince me that he's the man for this job. I'm all ears.

]]> By: Unfit for the Presidency http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569823 Unfit for the Presidency Fri, 29 Aug 2008 12:00:40 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569823 David Gergen wrote, "I also sensed that we saw tonight an Obama who is growing into a new, more mature leader — stronger, tougher, harder-hitting than he had appeared only a few weeks ago." What you really saw was a man whose foundation for leadership is weak and whose rhetoric fails to match his ability to enact real change. Of course you heard stronger and tougher (and may I add totally scripted) language because the only thing this poor excuse for a candidate can do is create the appearance of a leader by barking loudly because he has no demonstrated record of actually having done any thing of real substance. David Gergen wrote, "I also sensed that we saw tonight an Obama who is growing into a new, more mature leader — stronger, tougher, harder-hitting than he had appeared only a few weeks ago." What you really saw was a man whose foundation for leadership is weak and whose rhetoric fails to match his ability to enact real change. Of course you heard stronger and tougher (and may I add totally scripted) language because the only thing this poor excuse for a candidate can do is create the appearance of a leader by barking loudly because he has no demonstrated record of actually having done any thing of real substance.

]]> By: Not so Eloquent Independent http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569821 Not so Eloquent Independent Fri, 29 Aug 2008 12:00:36 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569821 This will be an interesting election, and I am definitely watching both sides to see who gets my vote. This will be an interesting election, and I am definitely watching both sides to see who gets my vote.

]]> By: Ron http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569820 Ron Fri, 29 Aug 2008 12:00:18 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569820 It was an incredible speech to end an amazing convention! It should put Obama over the top and heading straight for the White House. It was an incredible speech to end an amazing convention! It should put Obama over the top and heading straight for the White House.

]]> By: James http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569819 James Fri, 29 Aug 2008 12:00:11 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569819 Could not agree with Gergen more. I do not see Obama as a typical Democrat, using the typical "failed" Democrat ideas. What he said last night was unheard of from a major political player... it was about integration and the potential power we have if we can take care of our marginalized and disempowered. I am thinking... and I think he stands on his own. The experience argument is ridiculous... the past eight years proves this. Fresh and new can be a good thing for this nation... we are not ready to become the Romans of the modern era. Could not agree with Gergen more.

I do not see Obama as a typical Democrat, using the typical "failed" Democrat ideas. What he said last night was unheard of from a major political player... it was about integration and the potential power we have if we can take care of our marginalized and disempowered.

I am thinking... and I think he stands on his own. The experience argument is ridiculous... the past eight years proves this. Fresh and new can be a good thing for this nation... we are not ready to become the Romans of the modern era.

]]> By: McCain for Pres. http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569818 McCain for Pres. Fri, 29 Aug 2008 12:00:08 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569818 The people following Obama only want to see a bi-racial man in the white house. He is half white, how is that forgotten by the democrats and the press. Anybody can give a speech, lets see how he does in the debates. The people following Obama only want to see a bi-racial man in the white house. He is half white, how is that forgotten by the democrats and the press. Anybody can give a speech, lets see how he does in the debates.

]]> By: Bosworth http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569817 Bosworth Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:59:54 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569817 I agree that it was a "political" masterpiece - emphasis on "political." The emphasized adjective, however, is hardly indicative of quality or substance. Most of his "details" were pretty much for the partisan activists; little more than preaching to the already converted. Obama may have believed what he said; he may not have. It's hard to tell with a guy that has not a single political accomplishment, other than being the favorite of a cadre of partisan activists. I'm still waiting on hearing some actual "how to's" (such as how exactly can an executive branch CEO cajole congress into his tax breaks - whatever they are). In theory, these should come out in the debates with McCain. However, I suspect that he'll stick to the usual vague generalities, throw in the word "Bush" ad nauseum, and hope no one notices his utter narrative ineptitude. Of course, he'll always have the advantage of the MSM protecting him by emphasizing that any tough question is unfair, racist, etc. His anointment before an Olympian temple didn't impress me the way it apparently does a large body of the faithless seeking a new religion. Frankly, I think I'll stick with my own religion and try to focus separately on political realities. I agree that it was a "political" masterpiece – emphasis on "political." The emphasized adjective, however, is hardly indicative of quality or substance. Most of his "details" were pretty much for the partisan activists; little more than preaching to the already converted. Obama may have believed what he said; he may not have. It's hard to tell with a guy that has not a single political accomplishment, other than being the favorite of a cadre of partisan activists. I'm still waiting on hearing some actual "how to's" (such as how exactly can an executive branch CEO cajole congress into his tax breaks – whatever they are).
In theory, these should come out in the debates with McCain. However, I suspect that he'll stick to the usual vague generalities, throw in the word "Bush" ad nauseum, and hope no one notices his utter narrative ineptitude. Of course, he'll always have the advantage of the MSM protecting him by emphasizing that any tough question is unfair, racist, etc.
His anointment before an Olympian temple didn't impress me the way it apparently does a large body of the faithless seeking a new religion. Frankly, I think I'll stick with my own religion and try to focus separately on political realities.

]]> By: Frank http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569816 Frank Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:59:52 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569816 I thought Obama's delivery was excellent, his speech clear and cogent, and the night a historic one to be sure (despite that saying so has become rather trite at this point). Two other points were obvious to me: (1) Obama's platform consists of protectionism, interventionist government, taxes on wealth-creation, and some sheer fantasy, like ending our importation of oil within 10 years; and (2) his supporters will be very, very angry if he loses in November. I'm not sure which prospect frightens me more. I thought Obama's delivery was excellent, his speech clear and cogent, and the night a historic one to be sure (despite that saying so has become rather trite at this point).

Two other points were obvious to me: (1) Obama's platform consists of protectionism, interventionist government, taxes on wealth-creation, and some sheer fantasy, like ending our importation of oil within 10 years; and (2) his supporters will be very, very angry if he loses in November.

I'm not sure which prospect frightens me more.

]]> By: Not so Eloquent Independent http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569815 Not so Eloquent Independent Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:59:48 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569815 To be more accurate, Obama's DELIVERY of his speech was amazing. People need to know that most if not all politicians depend on speechwriters to write their speeches. Of course they also have a lot of input and they would certainly need to approve the contents first, but the speechwriters deserve a lot of credit for this. To be more accurate, Obama's DELIVERY of his speech was amazing. People need to know that most if not all politicians depend on speechwriters to write their speeches. Of course they also have a lot of input and they would certainly need to approve the contents first, but the speechwriters deserve a lot of credit for this.

]]> By: Trudy Duffy http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569814 Trudy Duffy Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:59:41 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569814 I harbor no doubt Barack Obama will lead us with intelligence, grace and fierce determination. His speech last night was purposeful and direct, spelling out clear choices ahead of us not based on dividing us, but seeking common ground for the common good. He is a politician who can lead us at home and in this new century internationally. As a 60 year old white woman,I have found a candidate worth fighting for and proudly to cast a, vote for. Due to his influence I learned to text message, blog, volunteer, register voters....and believe we are a better country than the legacy of the past 8 years. I am weary of attack ads and divisive politics of fear. I harbor no doubt Barack Obama will lead us with intelligence, grace and fierce determination. His speech last night was purposeful and direct, spelling out clear choices ahead of us not based on dividing us, but seeking common ground for the common good. He is a politician who can lead us at home and in this new century internationally.

As a 60 year old white woman,I have found a candidate worth fighting for and proudly to cast a, vote for. Due to his influence I learned to text message, blog, volunteer, register voters....and believe we are a better country than the legacy of the past 8 years.

I am weary of attack ads and divisive politics of fear.

]]> By: Ontaya http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569813 Ontaya Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:59:33 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569813 I totally agree with you. This movement is real and Obama/Biden will be marching to the White House come January 2009! I totally agree with you. This movement is real and Obama/Biden will be marching to the White House come January 2009!

]]> By: Steve http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569812 Steve Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:59:23 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569812 I watched a different speech than most of the respondents. Typical political pablum again. What we don't get from Obama and also will not get from McCain as well are solutions to the issues facing our country. We have become a nation of soundbites. The American people deserve better. Debate........debate soundbites. Basic story telling ........who, what, why, where, when and how. Demand answers built around those responses. Neither of these two gentleman prefer to acknowledge your intellect and respect you with real substantive responses. I watched a different speech than most of the respondents. Typical political pablum again.

What we don't get from Obama and also will not get from McCain as well are solutions to the issues facing our country.

We have become a nation of soundbites.

The American people deserve better.

Debate........debate soundbites.

Basic story telling ........who, what, why, where, when and how.

Demand answers built around those responses.

Neither of these two gentleman prefer to acknowledge your intellect and respect you with real substantive responses.

]]> By: Phil, Ashburn, VA http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569811 Phil, Ashburn, VA Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:59:17 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569811 I like the new Obama. Stand up and fight against the smear tactics and personal attacks. How dare McCain uses his kids to make an ad. No more. We the people want a different kind of politics. Can't wait for Nov 4th. I like the new Obama. Stand up and fight against the smear tactics and personal attacks. How dare McCain uses his kids to make an ad. No more. We the people want a different kind of politics. Can't wait for Nov 4th.

]]> By: georgia independent http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569809 georgia independent Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:58:30 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569809 His speech was excellent. It inspired, made me think, made me angry, and made me believe that we CAN make a difference. Maybe if we start believing we can change our country, it will happen. A leader that can inspire people and support their efforts for change is needed. The Republicans offer nothing but warnings, threats, worries, dismal reports, and blame on everyone but themselves. It's time for us to take a chance as a country and say eight years was MORE than enough. Let's go forward. No way, no how, no McCain. His speech was excellent. It inspired, made me think, made me angry, and made me believe that we CAN make a difference.

Maybe if we start believing we can change our country, it will happen. A leader that can inspire people and support their efforts for change is needed.

The Republicans offer nothing but warnings, threats, worries, dismal reports, and blame on everyone but themselves.

It's time for us to take a chance as a country and say eight years was MORE than enough. Let's go forward.

No way, no how, no McCain.

]]> By: mike http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569808 mike Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:58:07 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569808 I am still waiting for some one to tell me what Obama is hoping to change. The Dems are selling 2 things- America sucks and is a terrible place and we are all victims , we need goverment to succed sounds like socialism to me I am still waiting for some one to tell me what Obama is hoping to change. The Dems are selling 2 things- America sucks and is a terrible place and we are all victims , we need goverment to succed sounds like socialism to me

]]> By: admirer but not supporter http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569807 admirer but not supporter Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:58:02 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569807 A black man's nomination is a historic and thrilling moment. It makes me even more proud of our country. (A woman's nomination would have been also by the way.) However, race, religion or gender is not the reason to vote for a President of the United States. Obama simply does not have the experience to be President. A black man's nomination is a historic and thrilling moment. It makes me even more proud of our country. (A woman's nomination would have been also by the way.) However, race, religion or gender is not the reason to vote for a President of the United States. Obama simply does not have the experience to be President.

]]> By: RTV http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569806 RTV Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:58:01 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569806 Looking at the comments above, as usual it is clear that the people who are in support of President Obama have good reason for their support, while those who don't are either misinformed themselves or practicing intentional misinformation. There are no good reasons to NOT support Obama. How can you support tax breaks for oil companies at this point in history ? In the name of free enterprise? If so, as I said, you are either ignorant, or would hope that we would be ignorant. Obama, Biden, Kerry, Gore, Clinton, Clinton, and a host of others will be calling you out in the days to come. Hold on tight because you will be rocked. Looking at the comments above, as usual it is clear that the people who are in support of President Obama have good reason for their support, while those who don't are either misinformed themselves or practicing intentional misinformation. There are no good reasons to NOT support Obama. How can you support tax breaks for oil companies at this point in history ? In the name of free enterprise? If so, as I said, you are either ignorant, or would hope that we would be ignorant. Obama, Biden, Kerry, Gore, Clinton, Clinton, and a host of others will be calling you out in the days to come. Hold on tight because you will be rocked.

]]> By: carel http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569805 carel Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:57:55 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569805 The USA is the leader of the free world, but only Americans get to vote. If this election was thrown open to the rest of the free world, Obama will take it in a landslide... I am a white African and no politician has ever inspired me as much as Obama. I fear that McCain will have an even heavier hand and impulsive trigger finger than Bush. elieve it or not, America can get worse... Obama is the only person standing between a great nation and a failed empie. The USA is the leader of the free world, but only Americans get to vote. If this election was thrown open to the rest of the free world, Obama will take it in a landslide... I am a white African and no politician has ever inspired me as much as Obama.
I fear that McCain will have an even heavier hand and impulsive trigger finger than Bush. elieve it or not, America can get worse... Obama is the only person standing between a great nation and a failed empie.

]]> By: Jan http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569804 Jan Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:57:51 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569804 I couldn't agree more-It was truly an historic speech --an amazing speech and right on target! My fervent hope is that Obama does get elected-my greatest fear is that he will not. I have voted in every election beginning with Goldwater in the 60's;(yes, I am a lifelong registered Republican); I've watched every convention since then and have avidly followed politics my whole life. I honestly feel this is the most important election our country has ever faced-it is a turning point for our nation. I can only hope we turn toward Obama. I couldn't agree more-It was truly an historic speech –an amazing
speech and right on target! My fervent hope is that Obama does get elected-my greatest fear is that he will not.
I have voted in every election beginning with Goldwater in the 60's;(yes, I am a lifelong registered Republican); I've watched every convention since then and have avidly followed politics my whole life. I honestly feel this is the most important election our country has ever faced-it is a turning point for our nation. I can only hope we turn toward Obama.

]]> By: Rich - Thomaston, ME http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569803 Rich - Thomaston, ME Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:57:47 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569803 So the question still remains. After last night's speech, does anyone really know what "Change" means? So the question still remains. After last night's speech, does anyone really know what "Change" means?

]]> By: Betty http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569802 Betty Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:57:45 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569802 I think democrats like big goverment. I am a democrat and the one thing that bothers me is the party is always looking for a hand out instead of taking care of ourselfs alittle better. Who do you think pays for all the tax breaks,etc that Obama wants. That would be Us!! So maybe this country needs to watch spending, drive less and also take care of our families. Obama said in 10 years he wants us off middle east oil but what he doesn't know is the middle east is not the main suppler. It is Canada and Mexico. So he needs to get his facts straight. He gives a good speech but no experience behind the speech... So this democrat will not support Obama with zero experience. This country needs experience not just dreams. I think democrats like big goverment. I am a democrat and the one thing that bothers me is the party is always looking for a hand out instead of taking care of ourselfs alittle better. Who do you think pays for all the tax breaks,etc that Obama wants. That would be Us!! So maybe this country needs to watch spending, drive less and also take care of our families. Obama said in 10 years he wants us off middle east oil but what he doesn't know is the middle east is not the main suppler. It is Canada and Mexico. So he needs to get his facts straight. He gives a good speech but no experience behind the speech... So this democrat will not support Obama with zero experience. This country needs experience not just dreams.

]]> By: Nancy http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569801 Nancy Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:57:42 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569801 You are correct, it was a masterpiece, great way to describe it. You are correct, it was a masterpiece, great way to describe it.

]]> By: Anthony http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569800 Anthony Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:57:40 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569800 As an independent voter along with my wife who is a democrat will cast our votes for the next President of the United States Obama. I am pleased that Joe Biden is the V.P. since I thought he would have made an excellent President, I was a Hillary Supporter, now turned to Obama as Hillary will be pleased. Hopefully Hillary will be added to Obama's Cabinet in a role that will help us in Health Care or even as Secretary of State. With such talent and brains we can pull out of the economic dive we are under. Republicans have had their way too long and it is time we booted them out of Washington. Lets win back the Senate and House and put some decent thinkers in the Supreme Court. Bring back our military and deal with American issues that have gone unattended. God Bless America. As an independent voter along with my wife who is a democrat will cast our votes for the next President of the United States Obama.
I am pleased that Joe Biden is the V.P. since I thought he would have made an excellent President, I was a Hillary Supporter, now turned to Obama as Hillary will be pleased. Hopefully Hillary will be added to Obama's Cabinet in a role that will help us in Health Care or even as Secretary of State. With such talent and brains we can pull out of the economic dive we are under. Republicans have had their way too long and it is time we booted them out of Washington. Lets win back the Senate and House and put some decent thinkers in the Supreme Court. Bring back our military and deal with American issues that have gone unattended. God Bless America.

]]> By: Steve from Oshkosh http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569799 Steve from Oshkosh Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:57:33 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569799 Most political speeches leave me cold, but Obama's was moving and heartfelt and left me feeling inspired and hopeful. I truly hope he wins. The unfortunate thing is that the Republicans are masters at cynicism and smear tactics, so just about anything Obama said will be twisted and ridiculed rather than sincerely addressed. The fact that Bush was elected twice (sort of) shows how little ability they require of their candidates. That fact that 1/3 of Americans still think he's doing a good job says a lot about the electorate. Most political speeches leave me cold, but Obama's was moving and heartfelt and left me feeling inspired and hopeful. I truly hope he wins. The unfortunate thing is that the Republicans are masters at cynicism and smear tactics, so just about anything Obama said will be twisted and ridiculed rather than sincerely addressed. The fact that Bush was elected twice (sort of) shows how little ability they require of their candidates. That fact that 1/3 of Americans still think he's doing a good job says a lot about the electorate.

]]> By: Michele, Pittsburgh, PA http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569798 Michele, Pittsburgh, PA Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:57:27 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569798 I agree, David. As a registered Independent in a swing state who usually votes Republican, I was genuinely moved by his calls for common ground on social issues where I often lean right. John McCain will be hard pressed to top that speech. I agree, David. As a registered Independent in a swing state who usually votes Republican, I was genuinely moved by his calls for common ground on social issues where I often lean right. John McCain will be hard pressed to top that speech.

]]> By: Penny http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569797 Penny Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:57:15 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569797 Yes, a masterpiece indeed and for all the nay sayers America must once again find her voice or be drown out forever. Regardless of your affilitation, the truth is, America is at a crossroad and we must consider the consequences of our choice. Today, my family and I choose to take a chance on Obama. Yes, a masterpiece indeed and for all the nay sayers America must once again find her voice or be drown out forever. Regardless of your affilitation, the truth is, America is at a crossroad and we must consider the consequences of our choice.

Today, my family and I choose to take a chance on Obama.

]]> By: T GUY http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569796 T GUY Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:57:09 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569796 Just what I always expected of him, he delivered. Obama.........08 Just what I always expected of him, he delivered.

Obama.........08

]]> By: William http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569795 William Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:56:36 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569795 Few can accurately debate the merits of the proposals Barak Obama advanced last night; but even my 14-year son, watching the speech with us last night, had the sense to ask: "If Mr. Obama is going to cut taxes as much as he said, how is he going to pay for all of the new programs?" Few can accurately debate the merits of the proposals Barak Obama advanced last night; but even my 14-year son, watching the speech with us last night, had the sense to ask: "If Mr. Obama is going to cut taxes as much as he said, how is he going to pay for all of the new programs?"

]]> By: Kenny http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569794 Kenny Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:56:35 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569794 You hit the nail right on the head with your appraisal of the speech. You hit the nail right on the head with your appraisal of the speech.

]]> By: Deb, Allentown, PA http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569793 Deb, Allentown, PA Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:56:28 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569793 Typical White Person, you said you heard socialism last night. Obama is not advocating socialism; as he said last night, he's advocating MUTUAL RESPONSIBILITY. But in any event, why is socialism so bad? There are a number of socialist countries, mainly in Europe, that have lower poverty rates, higher education rates, lower infant mortality rates, lower suicide rates, higher life expectancy rates, better healthcare, et al than the United States. Maybe socialism isn't quite as evil as you make it out to be. Typical White Person, you said you heard socialism last night. Obama is not advocating socialism; as he said last night, he's advocating MUTUAL RESPONSIBILITY.

But in any event, why is socialism so bad? There are a number of socialist countries, mainly in Europe, that have lower poverty rates, higher education rates, lower infant mortality rates, lower suicide rates, higher life expectancy rates, better healthcare, et al than the United States. Maybe socialism isn't quite as evil as you make it out to be.

]]> By: Mo Stanny http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569792 Mo Stanny Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:56:20 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569792 AS A REGISTERED REPUBLICAN, HE'S GOT MY VOTE. LAST NIGHT'S SPEECH REMOVED ANY DOUBT ABOUT HIS ABILITY TO LEAD US AWAY FROM THE ABYSS WE ARE NEAR FALLING IN TO,,THE QUESTION NOW IS DO WE HAVE THE COURAGE TO CHANGE THE COURSE OF OUR COUNTRY AND LET COURAGE,, NOT FEAR GUIDE US.. GOD BLESSED AMERICA LAST EVENING. AS A REGISTERED REPUBLICAN, HE'S GOT MY VOTE. LAST NIGHT'S SPEECH REMOVED ANY DOUBT ABOUT HIS ABILITY TO LEAD US AWAY FROM THE ABYSS WE ARE NEAR FALLING IN TO,,THE QUESTION NOW IS DO WE HAVE THE COURAGE TO CHANGE THE COURSE OF OUR COUNTRY AND LET COURAGE,, NOT FEAR GUIDE US.. GOD BLESSED AMERICA LAST EVENING.

]]> By: McCain doesn't get it http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569790 McCain doesn't get it Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:56:03 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569790 I couldn't agree more David. Last nights speech was a masterpiece. Can you imagine mcCain or Bush delivering a speech like that? Not only delivering it but writing it? I think that should be a requirement...write your own speeches. I also love how Republicans love to label others...socialism..do you even know what socialism is or you just hear it from Bill o'Rielly? Keep up the great work Republicans...you've got a few more months. Just try not to completely run the car off the road. I couldn't agree more David. Last nights speech was a masterpiece. Can you imagine mcCain or Bush delivering a speech like that? Not only delivering it but writing it? I think that should be a requirement...write your own speeches. I also love how Republicans love to label others...socialism..do you even know what socialism is or you just hear it from Bill o'Rielly? Keep up the great work Republicans...you've got a few more months. Just try not to completely run the car off the road.

]]> By: Really http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569788 Really Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:55:42 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569788 The guy is so revolutionary. He is going to change Washington. He is going fight for the "working" people. He is going to give everyone health coverage. He wants to end the war. He wants to play robin hood. Sounds like the same crap the democrates spew every election. They are "just words." Bottom line, this guy is only going to represent about half of the American poplulation. Hopefully he will nationalize everything - oil, auto, all education, healthcare and any other idustry that makes an evil profit. The guy is so revolutionary. He is going to change Washington. He is going fight for the "working" people. He is going to give everyone health coverage. He wants to end the war. He wants to play robin hood. Sounds like the same crap the democrates spew every election. They are "just words." Bottom line, this guy is only going to represent about half of the American poplulation. Hopefully he will nationalize everything – oil, auto, all education, healthcare and any other idustry that makes an evil profit.

]]> By: sandy http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569786 sandy Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:55:24 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569786 Hillary was my choice. I have been wrong about Oboma and can admit it. He is right about everything he said. If we think our country is going the right way, vote Mccaine. I know no one who is not struggeling right now and it is getting worse. He will turn this country back to how good we had it under Clinton. People were employed, companies were not closing. No one was claiming bankrupsy to just live. Come on, we have a chance to change it.I do not care if he is yellow in skin. He is just like we are and wants the same good things for his children. He will be very judgemental before he goes to wars. He will talk and make us look better to the world. How can you not vote for that????His speeche made me cry. Hillary was my choice. I have been wrong about Oboma and can admit it. He is right about everything he said. If we think our country is going the right way, vote Mccaine. I know no one who is not struggeling right now and it is getting worse. He will turn this country back to how good we had it under Clinton. People were employed, companies were not closing. No one was claiming bankrupsy to just live. Come on, we have a chance to change it.I do not care if he is yellow in skin. He is just like we are and wants the same good things for his children. He will be very judgemental before he goes to wars. He will talk and make us look better to the world. How can you not vote for that????His speeche made me cry.

]]> By: Matt, Pittsburgh http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569785 Matt, Pittsburgh Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:55:22 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569785 I saw a well rehearsed telepromter reading last night. Anyone wonder why Obama won't debate in a town hall forum? He says McCain won't debate the issues??? He's the one who is trying to hide. He now has the rest of the summer to explain his socialist agenda of redistribution of wealth (re: tax hikes), Reverend Wright (why didn't Lord Obama disavow him until there was public pressure to do so?), an energy plan that will help in the short term as well as long term, his friendship with Bill Ayers (the guy who wishes he would have done more harm in his bombings of govt. buildings?). I heard the same old liberal crap. No change, just the same old tune. Oh yes, maybe the change Obama is talking about involves now voting "Present" in congress instead of Yea or Nay. McCain Hutchinson '08 I saw a well rehearsed telepromter reading last night. Anyone wonder why Obama won't debate in a town hall forum? He says McCain won't debate the issues??? He's the one who is trying to hide. He now has the rest of the summer to explain his socialist agenda of redistribution of wealth (re: tax hikes), Reverend Wright (why didn't Lord Obama disavow him until there was public pressure to do so?), an energy plan that will help in the short term as well as long term, his friendship with Bill Ayers (the guy who wishes he would have done more harm in his bombings of govt. buildings?).

I heard the same old liberal crap. No change, just the same old tune.

Oh yes, maybe the change Obama is talking about involves now voting "Present" in congress instead of Yea or Nay.

McCain Hutchinson '08

]]> By: John Raffaele-Phoenicia, NY http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569783 John Raffaele-Phoenicia, NY Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:55:14 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569783 Mr. Gergen, Your analysis is spot-on. The symphony was a masterpiece. He not only conducted the music but played it as well. The voters must consider his ability to rouse, orate and lead. We need that type of President to heal this broken political atmosphere regardless of some of his ideas and plans. It was music to my ears last night and hopefully will be just as symphonic to a majority of the electoral college on November 4. Mr. Gergen,

Your analysis is spot-on. The symphony was a masterpiece. He not only conducted the music but played it as well.

The voters must consider his ability to rouse, orate and lead. We need that type of President to heal this broken political atmosphere regardless of some of his ideas and plans.

It was music to my ears last night and hopefully will be just as symphonic to a majority of the electoral college on November 4.

]]> By: Joanie Kravitz http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569782 Joanie Kravitz Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:54:54 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569782 Obama injected American's with a much needed dose of hope and pride in what America could become, if given the chance to have him as our next President. I will treasure the first speech in eight years that I could watch all the way through and then again the next day. Obama injected American's with a much needed dose of hope and pride in what America could become, if given the chance to have him as our next President.
I will treasure the first speech in eight years that I could watch all the way through and then again the next day.

]]> By: John http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569780 John Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:54:40 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569780 McCain is Bush. Stop drinking the Kool-Aid. McCain is Bush. Stop drinking the Kool-Aid.

]]> By: Michael, Florida http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569779 Michael, Florida Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:54:34 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569779 Notice the Obama-haters on this board only bring up his PERCEIVED lack of experience because they are AFRAID of the resonance of his ideas and of his concrete plan to take America back from the corporate CEO's who have paid the GOP for the priviledge of owning this country, this war, and this GOP government. To the guy who said he heard "socialism" -- you need to clean the wax out of your ears. I heard what the founding fathers imagined this government to be - there for the people who need it most, and only when the need it; there for the environment so that we have a planet for our children; there for our military, active duty and veterans and their families. I could go on and on. So keep spouting off about his perceived lack of experience, the Greek-style set last night, and other truly important issues in this country. The rest of us are moving forward, with our heads held high, proud of our country, proud of our party, proud of our candidate. Notice the Obama-haters on this board only bring up his PERCEIVED lack of experience because they are AFRAID of the resonance of his ideas and of his concrete plan to take America back from the corporate CEO's who have paid the GOP for the priviledge of owning this country, this war, and this GOP government. To the guy who said he heard "socialism" - you need to clean the wax out of your ears. I heard what the founding fathers imagined this government to be – there for the people who need it most, and only when the need it; there for the environment so that we have a planet for our children; there for our military, active duty and veterans and their families. I could go on and on. So keep spouting off about his perceived lack of experience, the Greek-style set last night, and other truly important issues in this country. The rest of us are moving forward, with our heads held high, proud of our country, proud of our party, proud of our candidate.

]]> By: Sharon http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569778 Sharon Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:54:30 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569778 I have to admit I voted for Bush the last two times but I also have to admit I am done with them and I will vote for the Democrats again. He is in this century and will use the tools necessary to keep us competitive ( the idea to text others was brilliant). Mc Cain doesn't even know how to use E-mail. We need someone in this century. I have to admit I voted for Bush the last two times but I also have to admit I am done with them and I will vote for the Democrats again. He is in this century and will use the tools necessary to keep us competitive ( the idea to text others was brilliant). Mc Cain doesn't even know how to use E-mail. We need someone in this century.

]]> By: Emmanuel http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569777 Emmanuel Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:54:22 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569777 It was a great speech, one of the best I have heard in years. The man is a brilliant politician. However, I am worried about the Democrats, The only reason why Clinton did relatively well was that he had to deal with a house and a senate which were heavily republican for most of his terms. I smile when I hear the Clintons talk about how they balanced the budget and cut spending, THEY HAD TO DO IT! they had to work with the Republicans in order to get something done at all! I worry about possibly having a democratic administration combined with a house and senate. I remember what a disaster Jimmy Carter was, 18% inflation, real estate prices in the toilet and above all a dismal foreign policy with the exception of Israel and Egypt peace talks. Carter's policy towards Iran is directly responsible for the rise of Islamic terrorism and all the problems we face today. Yes, the Bush administration has made many mistakes, some of them very large and costly like going to Irack which was a mistake in my view but they have had to deal with unusual problems like 911 and high oil prices and they have done reasonably well with the economy considering what they have faced. In my view, Bush is not great but Carter was far worse! and I really don't want another one like that! It was a great speech, one of the best I have heard in years. The man is a brilliant politician. However, I am worried about the Democrats, The only reason why Clinton did relatively well was that he had to deal with a house and a senate which were heavily republican for most of his terms. I smile when I hear the Clintons talk about how they balanced the budget and cut spending, THEY HAD TO DO IT! they had to work with the Republicans in order to get something done at all! I worry about possibly having a democratic administration combined with a house and senate. I remember what a disaster Jimmy Carter was, 18% inflation, real estate prices in the toilet and above all a dismal foreign policy with the exception of Israel and Egypt peace talks. Carter's policy towards Iran is directly responsible for the rise of Islamic terrorism and all the problems we face today.
Yes, the Bush administration has made many mistakes, some of them very large and costly like going to Irack which was a mistake in my view but they have had to deal with unusual problems like 911 and high oil prices and they have done reasonably well with the economy considering what they have faced. In my view, Bush is not great but Carter was far worse! and I really don't want another one like that!

]]> By: jjjjjoe http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569776 jjjjjoe Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:54:05 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569776 If you prayed for rain to fall on Obama's big day at the open mile-high stadium, you prayed to the wrong god! If you prayed for rain to fall on Obama's big day at the open mile-high stadium, you prayed to the wrong god!

]]> By: ark http://politicalticker.blogs.cnn.com/2008/08/29/gergen-a-political-masterpiece-2/#comment-1569774 ark Fri, 29 Aug 2008 11:54:02 +0000 http://cnnpoliticalticker.wordpress.com/?p=15319#comment-1569774 God has again shown His love towards America. In Obama, a revival has begun. Long live America 4 Obama/Biden. God has again shown His love towards America. In Obama, a revival has begun. Long live America 4 Obama/Biden.

]]>