September 11, 2008
Posted: September 11th, 2008 08:20 PM ET
Weigh in with CNN's analysts and contributors.
Weigh in with CNN's analysts and contributors.

(CNN) –On the anniversary of the September 11 attacks, presidential candidates John McCain and Barack Obama each take the stage to discuss service and civic engagement in a forum at Columbia University.

What do you think of their ideas? How does the role of service determine what kind of nation we live in? What does national service mean to you?

Along with CNN Senior Political Correspondent Candy Crowley, CNN Senior Political Analyst Bill Schneider, CNN Political Analyst Roland Martin, and Republican strategist Bay Buchanan, thousands of you weighed in.

Click "comments" below for a look at the entire conversation.

Filed under: Barack Obama • John McCain


becky in va   September 11th, 2008 10:31 pm ET

obama, as usual, gave deliberate and serious responses about community service, and how to implement same.

meanwhile, i am still in shock that so many american citizens are elated by the choice of palin for vp. if you were a woman who supported hillary, and have made a gender based decision to switch to the mccain/palin ticket, then you are a walking contradiction.

Leah DiMarco, Texas   September 11th, 2008 10:31 pm ET

Today was the first time that Palin was asked questions since McCain announced her as his pick. In my opinion she failed terribly. We now know that she doesn't have a clue what the Bush Doctrine is and now she has made comments that are saber rattling with Russia.

I am very fearful for America and the world.
Please God, do something to end this nightmare.

Bill   September 11th, 2008 10:30 pm ET

John McCain is coming late to the game on national service. He has, if anything, denigrated non-military service and he allowed a whole host of speakers, including his VP candidate, at the RNC to do the same. Obama is the man on this issue. McCain can't touch him.

Suzanne   September 11th, 2008 10:30 pm ET

RE: ConcernedAboutAnotherElephantintheRoom

I have to agree with your statements. What concerned me the most, was the obvious war mongering comments that lingered in my household after the interview was shown. Our country is becoming increasingly cynical about wars and why they are waged, and here arrives Gov. Palin, who only seems to speak about more war.

Then, in stark contrast, we saw a great forum on service from the Presidential candidates.

What I don't understand is why or how people in this blog continue to say Obama is in over his head, especially when it comes to a forum on service. I mean, wasn't it only a week ago that Gov. Palin made fun of Mr. Obama's history as a community organizer?

jeanie   September 11th, 2008 10:30 pm ET

Palin cannot run and hide because she does not like how newsmen ask her questions. It is such a shame that she is getting away with such behavior. The media would not let a male candidate get away with it. why should we let a woman?

larry   September 11th, 2008 10:30 pm ET

For the person who commented about the poor performance of the educational system in Illinois... You should take a look at ours here in Arizona...

Adam   September 11th, 2008 10:30 pm ET

You should be ashamed of yourself. I have never seen such outragous, disgusting lies and slander in a presidential campaign. It would be funny if it weren't so revolting.

McCains Ads are literally lies. He changes quotes to suite his needs, lies about sources, lies about accomplishments, and NOBODY IS CALLING HIM ON IT. These are not half-truths, he is not streaching the truth, HE IS MAKING STUFF UP, and putting it on TV. Why is this not front page news? How is this OK?

THIS IS YOUR JOB!!! DO IT FOR THE LOVE OF GOD

Lanre Akinola   September 11th, 2008 10:30 pm ET

Palin does not George Bush Doctrine, in fact, that was so dissappointing. So what the hell have the Republican puppets been training her on foreign policy.

Eyes open   September 11th, 2008 10:30 pm ET

I will never watched FOX There news is pulling teeth of an elephant so many reporters so many lies must be good republican money put to work . They might as well end every show PARTY AT BUSH HOUSE

Pascal   September 11th, 2008 10:29 pm ET

What does everyone think of Governor Palin suggesting that we may have a military conflict with Russia. Can the US military handle a war with a world power like Russia right now? The military is already straining with the Iraq and Afghanistan wars. A war with Iran right now would bring us to the breaking point. I can't imagine us being able to do anything about Russia while we have those conflicts going on. I'm sure our European allies would look the other way on such a conflict.

What do you guys think?

Mark Fahey   September 11th, 2008 10:29 pm ET

Is it possible for Mr. McCain to see the damage he is doing to this country by choosing to follow the Rove tactics in this historical election? Please try to stick to the topics – REPAIRING AMERICA from the Bush War on America. Can he restore civility to the Rep. Party and maybe himself.

Mary Nell Billings   September 11th, 2008 10:29 pm ET

How can Palin be ready to be VP behind the oldest presidential candidate if it took two weeks of preping for her first interview after being nominated?

Diedre Douglas   September 11th, 2008 10:29 pm ET

Who talked generically about 'service': John McCain

Who spoke with specifics about what 'service is: Barack Obama.

Advantage: Obama

Tommy   September 11th, 2008 10:29 pm ET

This event was the type of coverage that this nation deserves and needs. The Palinsky distraction and Rove inspired divisiveness is useless – except for the Republicans who love it – for it serves their purposes. "Who cares about the country – win at all cost". Thanks finally for moving away from the distractions – at least for a few minutes – and returning to the ideas that matter.

Bruce   September 11th, 2008 10:28 pm ET

"Private sector has the solutions, not government." "1000 points of light" "Faith-based initiatives". The republicans SOUND like they are all for private citizens improving their communities themselves .... but heaven help you if you actually do it – Guilliani and Palin are going to expose you as a clueless sap at the republican convention.

Get a clue! The republicans only care about you if you are carrying a gun (ideally as a private citizen vigilante) or if you are an investment banker that screwed up and is forced to leave your job with a multi-million dollar severance package.

What a country. What a poor, sad, screwed up country ...

larry   September 11th, 2008 10:28 pm ET

How long do we as constituents give someone to show that they really want change? Is it a month, 6 months, 26 years??? The problem is, the change that John McCain's looking for is that which jingles in his pocket. He has had his chance, he has shown what he can do for our country. He has proven his "maverickness". He has shown us his true inner feelings that war should only be used as the last resort when in his speech in pursuit of the Iraq attack he said.. "Now is not the time to give peace a chance". Way to go John... you did wonderfully. John McCain getting credit for the "surge working" is analogous to wrecking the family car, and then asking for credit for spray painting the headlights. You don't get credit for anything good regarding this atrocity. I challenge anyone to in all honesty tell us just one good thing that has come from the occupation of Iraq.

Kate   September 11th, 2008 10:28 pm ET

Obama was clear, inspiring and intelligent. McCain offered more of the same canned answers. Enough is enough!

Jace   September 11th, 2008 10:28 pm ET

I am an old Democrat, and a black man, and all I have to say after that is this...... And I'm sure this won't be posted!

I love John McCain now, that man (as much as I hated him to begin with), hit it out of the ball park! Palin is a welcome figure as well!

McCain is substance!
Obama is not substance!

jeanie   September 11th, 2008 10:28 pm ET

The fact that Palin is picking and choosing her interviews states she may not be ready to govern the USA

Joel Carter   September 11th, 2008 10:28 pm ET

We should not focus on military only but we can do the volunteer in the civic services, medical services, scientific community. The people of America can work and volunteer at the same time and separate times as individuals. Think about taking a job and try to find the time to volunteer. For example, I worked at Target and take a volunteer as holiday helpers. It will help your karma aura around your bodies. It is important to have good karma and do not let your karma go bad.
:)

Louis Bellantoni   September 11th, 2008 10:28 pm ET

Yes the candidates were both very convincing. McCain convinced me that he wants another war in the name of national service. Obama convinced me that he wants national service for the sake of the nations people.

PNK   September 11th, 2008 10:28 pm ET

I noticed that Obama, which he has done before, said "we" a lot in the forum. As in "we believe, we want, we know" etc. I get what he's trying to do, and this is a good facilitative technique for a teacher/professor, which he used to be, but I'm beginning to think he needs to inflect more "I think, I feel, I have seen..." and the like to come across as more direct and as someone who has a plan and can take charge.

Mark   September 11th, 2008 10:27 pm ET

Obama is more in tune with humanity and the need to inspire Americans to greater things. He understands what it takes to truly make American great. I just don't feel a connection with McCain and he certainly does not inspire me. Obama would unite us all to get things done and improve our nation whereas McCain would simply be a continuation of the past 8 years of division. I have made up my mind.,

JayHawkDad   September 11th, 2008 10:27 pm ET

Go Robert.....you were the only CNN "political" analyst tonight who was a straight shooter on providing real commentary about the Palin interview. I asked my wife to answer the questions Sara P was given and she blew Sarah away....and she is a hairstylist, not a Govenor of Mooseville. Just like McCain, she danced around the issues and lacked providing any real solutons. What did I take from it, God help us if this woman becomes president and is a finger away from pushing the button.

Lacy Lady   September 11th, 2008 10:27 pm ET

I thought Obama did a GREAT job tonight on the forum. I agree that children and young adults can learn to give their time for many programs that help. I am an senior citizen and can still remember when my brother and I went thru our neighborhood during WWII and collected papers and scrap iron . Also I knit blocks for afghans which were used for army cots for the soldiers. The Red Cross taught us how to knit . We as children 10 and 12 years old were so proud to due our part for the War effort.
Our families were given ration cards for sugar, coffee ,gas & etc.
The children in our neighbor wrote letters to the men in service by
V-Mail. Our parents always filled our car with many-to conserve on gas. My cousins were in the Navy and on Pearl Harbor on that fatal day . Many many cousins, uncles, fathers served in that War. Some never returned.

Jen From MN   September 11th, 2008 10:27 pm ET

Tonight was a refreshing take on politics. It was nice listening to two adults.

I also enjoyed tonight was about McCain and Obama and what they would do for/with this country.

Palin and McCain were not connected at the hip and we were reminded who is actually running for President.

Both men did a fine job.

Beverly   September 11th, 2008 10:27 pm ET

I have yet to understand the Palin bandwagon. The entire charade reminds me of the story of the Emperor's New Clothes. I am disappointed in women who do not look beyond their gender, and in men who look only at the lipstick. The world looking on must be amused and terrified all at once. This election offers the opportunity for America to truly define itself. Will it be defined as intelligence or glitz?

sandy levin   September 11th, 2008 10:27 pm ET

I was so impressed with Obama not that McCain did bad but Obama was truly inspirational and full of hope. I am old enough to remember John Kennedy and he speaks with the same kind of heart. I can truly see him representing our country as President much more than I can McCain. McCain can't have Palin at his side every minute and besides what she knows about foreign policy she just learned to prepare for her interview with Charlie Gibson.

Patriot - S. FL   September 11th, 2008 10:27 pm ET

I thought it was pleasant, no "gotcha" – a nice chance to listen and decide. I preferred McCain, but it was much more pleasant than the debates – which seem like they are trying to trip them up – a game of the anchors trying to show they are on stage – we do not care to hear from them, we want to hear the candidates

Darren   September 11th, 2008 10:26 pm ET

It's an American tradgedy that this election (as well as the past two) has become "American Idol". There should not even be a debate as to whether or not Gov Palin is qualified. The media and the Republicans would have made the Democrats look like idiots if they had chosen someone of her stature (20 months as Governor of Alaska!?!) – Dan Quayle anyone?
We are seeing, daily, how this country, economically, is taking on water and sinking faster and faster. We have John McCain using the same "Rovian" scare tactics we've talked about for eight years and some of us keep voting this way. How is this POSSIBLE? When the country had enough guts to vote for Bill Clinton over a war hero, we prospered. They say people vote their pocketbooks...now they're voting for their favorite magazine covers.

Lindsey   September 11th, 2008 10:26 pm ET

There was no one person who dominated the night. If McCain's approach appeals to you, you think he won the night, if Obama's approach is more your speed, then you think he won the night. The bottom line is that this year we have TWO candidates that their respective parties should be proud of this year. I just hope mine wins....Obama/Biden 08!

Jonathan Davis   September 11th, 2008 10:26 pm ET

To Laura

Perhaps Barack would go after John if he had used made a comment about Michelle, his wife, but the point is she is his wife. Palin is his Vice President. You do know there is a difference, right?

cindy   September 11th, 2008 10:26 pm ET

the taxi driver, the coal miner, the night clerk at 7-11 also risk their lives every day, as do many others. this idea that government work (police, fireman, teacher ) is more noble than the private sector is sickening.

Lone Star Wolf   September 11th, 2008 10:26 pm ET

I know one thing the issues that OBAMA pursue are not the direction America needs to be thinking of going at this time. Socialism of medicine is not a direction to follow. Taking our military and running in the face of the enemy is not an option. Attacking Palin(Women) in general like he did Hillary is low as low can get. If he thinks this is the way to the Oval Office then he's off track. Raising taxes in face of a failing economy is a disaster. Plus the man does not have the experience John McCain has. For security OBAMA gets a F- while I give McCAIN An A+. For me the low morals of the Democrats have drove me an ex 51-year Democrat away from the Party. BILL AND HILLARY are ruining themselves by campaigning for him. I will vote McCAIN/Palin 08.

Dave, Houston, TX   September 11th, 2008 10:26 pm ET

I'm an Obama supporter and I thought McCain did a good job. I thought Obama was terrific. He's the only candidate in this race (or even in many of our lifetimes) that could credibly say that he wanted to make government "cool" again.

I was very pleasantly surprised by Obama's answer regarding having ROTC at Columbia. I was cringing that we were going to get a long, convoluted, non-answer that politicians often give. But, he directly said, "Yes!" I hope his directness helped others realize what a great candidate I support.

KEITH   September 11th, 2008 10:26 pm ET

Bay, I do not think this forum will change votes ..but a better performance by Obama would energize the youth vote in the universities who will come and vote when it matters...

Jack   September 11th, 2008 10:26 pm ET

Olivia, you mentioned Kiwanis Club. Service organizations like Kiwanis or the Optimists, Rotarians, Junior Leagues, Lions Clubs, Shriners and the like [decided not to mention Moose]. These organizations do the heavy lifting for charity work locally. In years past many of them had annexed youth service clubs like Interact and Key Club, to name a couple. I don't see that any more.
These are the people the candidates have to win over and it is surprising how they are probably leaning.

Toby Price   September 11th, 2008 10:25 pm ET

I hope people were watching tonight, while McFlipflop told us how great community service was, when last week McCain and Palin were both ridiculing community service.

Please vote with your brains...PS How many of us are going to volunteer to serve when President Palin invades Russia? That is after Charles Gibson explains where it is to her.

Walt   September 11th, 2008 10:25 pm ET

Will someone tell that fool Bill Schneider that he's right that Bush's approval rating is low, but guess what? Congress' approval rating is a LOT LOWER. Whadda ya have to say about that Bill Schneider old buddy?

I want to move to Canada   September 11th, 2008 10:25 pm ET

This was a dream forum. America is too lazy and too spoiled to volunteer for anything. This is all a crock...If you watch any television you see that we are more interested in American Idol or the latest scandal of the day. Americans are unfortunately sheep..These two candidates should be debating every week just like the primaries. We dont need people to volunteer, we need people to stay informed and educated so they can make responsible decisions. I think it is unfortunate and sad that America will make the same choice as before and vote for the Republicans. We will not learn as long as you the media continue to feed us this garbage and play their game. They know you too well...They know how you are going to react...Its all ratings based and it is not journalism...Wait til October when we go to code red because of some fabricated terror plot..Watch this rerun and realize you are the problem....But as long as your ratings are high, that is what is best for the Country....Vote for Dave Chapelle....

Ade   September 11th, 2008 10:25 pm ET

@Jeff

You must have been watching a different forum!

Kristiaan   September 11th, 2008 10:25 pm ET

Palin chose 9/11 to give an interview to convey herself as emotional, yet strong. That, coupled with the fact that no one would badger her in the interview or attack her from afar giving today's date was crafty, but it will only fool those who want to be fooled. Palin has little experience, and will follow Bush policies to a T or model her own policies with Bush's as a mold. This is because she, being new to national politics, has yet to formulate opinions about such complex issues.

oldtimer   September 11th, 2008 10:25 pm ET

How in the world did the dems allow the discussion to be switched over the a VP canidate? They have lost their marbles. This will kill the election for them as public is now discussing her and her ideas rather than the dems ideas.

The repubs baited the dems; the dems took the bait and the discussion was switched from Obama = Change to McCain/Palin = Change.

So, the repubs continue to be better politics than dems.

Bob   September 11th, 2008 10:25 pm ET

Heard of the Bridge to Nowhere?

Meet the TEAM TO NOWHERE!

GOP candidates want to lead us back to the 1950's. Unfortunately the world is far different.

Amy Noir   September 11th, 2008 10:25 pm ET

Obama seems more sincere, and he was already for Change.

McCain cheat his Wife Multiple time, and so how can you trust him.

Stuart   September 11th, 2008 10:25 pm ET

People in the military donate to Obama's campaign at a 6 to 1 ratio over McCain's! What does that tell you!

Nav Baldeo   September 11th, 2008 10:25 pm ET

Roland,

I am very interested to hear about how the candidates feel about their relationship with Canada. Believe it or not, being from Toronto, our newspapers and media have been saturated with US election news and so we are all caught up in the race. One could also argue that we are very affected by it since much of what happens in the States spills over into our big cities of Toronto, Montreal, Vancouver, etc. I just wanted to know if you or any of the other members of the best political team on television could shed any light on how McCain and Obama would approach trade with Canada and do you believe the democrats would be able to build a universal health care plan? With Canada providing so many natural resources to the US (water/hydro, lumber, etc) and the two countries sharing such an open border, do the relationships between the two come up enough on the campaign trail?

Nav from Toronto

manchild   September 11th, 2008 10:25 pm ET

Jeff
McCain dominated. Get Real. Get Obama.

Diva   September 11th, 2008 10:25 pm ET

Roland,

I'm responding to your statement at 8:37 pm....I am in the music industry and it's very true that illegal sampling will cost someone big bucks.

...........................
McCain is old & old-fashioned, and his attempts to reach the American people are underwhelming and unoriginal.

Marlene   September 11th, 2008 10:25 pm ET

Why does CNN keep having Republican and Democratic strategists reacting to the candidates/ i am watching Anderson Cooper asking them to respond to palin's interview with Charlie Gibson....they give just the party line. It is so predictable it makes me sick. Why not find a different way to get a response: non-strategists to give their reaction?

Don   September 11th, 2008 10:24 pm ET

By choosing Palin for vice president, it shows that McCain lacks the necessary judgement to be president...Palin shows that her emotions got the better of her when she fired her then brother in-law without any real evidence of foul play. This means that she lacks the patience and perserverance that a vice president should have...I will not vote for McCain and Palin if they could not come up with any real explanations about the matter as to why he picked her and why she had fired her ex brother in-law...

Palin in headlights   September 11th, 2008 10:24 pm ET

What a deer those weren't the toughest questions by Charlie G. and she had major problems just so irritated like why Charlie they said you would baby me. It's my first time.

Ross from Texas   September 11th, 2008 10:24 pm ET

Ok, lets change this pig stuff,
"Put a beard and mustache on a pig, it’s still a pig"

There now, all the men are deeply offended...

Elinor Miller   September 11th, 2008 10:24 pm ET

To see Barck Obama speaking at Columia University on the same night that Sarah Palin's interview is being aired by ABC shows the stark contrast between someone who has thought deeply about the issues, who has an original and brilliant mind and who can lead American forward and someone who is a mere token parroting lines fed to her by the McCain campaign. God save America if she becomes vice president.

Emilio Bejel   September 11th, 2008 10:24 pm ET

I think that both Obama and McCain performed rather well. It was a tie.

Latonya Bailey,27   September 11th, 2008 10:24 pm ET

no more Bay Buccanan! She is a fool. Anyone who will insult their own integrity to make another fools comments sound creditable is a puppet!
Robert Zimmerman keep giving her the business! Anderson, Please take your career to the most serious place it has ever been and ask the tuff questions. and when they try to dance call them on there nonsense.
People are depending on the media to keep them honest!
L

Epiphanik   September 11th, 2008 10:24 pm ET

Sarah Palin, to me, looked and sounded like she wasn't prepared for ANY of the questions she was asked on today's interview. She had a "deer in the headlights" look on her face. Not confident at all. And it totally annoys me to hear Bay Buchanan talk about how great Palin did, and how the less experience she has the better. That's just ridiculous.

kathy ng.   September 11th, 2008 10:24 pm ET

I just hope that America stop making governor Palin to be a celebrity here. I hope we can focus on the issues to make this election right.
Governor Palin is like the ex-contestant of American Idol: William Hung., the one who did not get any singing talent but turned into a celebrity just because he sang so bad.
I admire governor Palin because she was able to balance between work and handle 5 kids. But I strongly believe that we need a vice president but we don't need a mom here.

Thomas   September 11th, 2008 10:24 pm ET

If you vote 90% of the time with President Bush....Then your qualfied to be the next President of the Untited States of America...

Put some lip-stick on Mcain...

marie   September 11th, 2008 10:24 pm ET

I think Obama did a great job. Why would any dummy bring up Michelle being proud of America in this forum is beyond me. I didn't hear Obama talking about "mandating" community service either. He simply is trying to encourage more people help out their community which is needed to help get this country on the right track, among a host of other things.

Lynda in FL   September 11th, 2008 10:24 pm ET

Great forum and timely; with Ike heading toward Texas. To all of you from Texas, my prayers are with you. To myself and everyone else; it is time to put our words into actions. We must SERVE in any way we can to help Texas and the other city on the coast line.

P   September 11th, 2008 10:24 pm ET

No one has to pay income tax if you read the admendment, know I don't, it says that companies have to pay on thier gains not thier income, so everyone who is paying income tax now is being taken advantge of, buy the IRS, and the congress that knows the truth about it!

Sarah palin is a lier   September 11th, 2008 10:24 pm ET

She is a twisted lady! She wants ANOTHER war with Russia!!!!!

libwoman   September 11th, 2008 10:23 pm ET

concernedabout.....hahahhaahahah...you are sooo right! It's a relief to know that there are still thinking people out there!!!!

Darryl   September 11th, 2008 10:23 pm ET

Senator John McCain,

What do you say when your own VP selection take money from the federal government in earmark and than say she change her mind on the project for which the money was requested. Canceling the project but keep the money and deverted the money for other use..

I am not a rocket sciencist but isn't that a CRIME?

i GUESS YOU ARE MAKING HER FAMIOUS AND WE WILL KNOW HER NAME SOME VETTING?

How many more days?   September 11th, 2008 10:23 pm ET

Good lord look at these comments... how many more days do I have to hear and read moronic comments? For once I would like a clean election. I follow politics but can't take much more of this crap.

Snoozi   September 11th, 2008 10:23 pm ET

Obama would not mandate, but rather offer a reward in reduced college expenses in turn for community service. Why not? Prisoners breaking rocks is not gonna help the crime in this country, but giving all people a purpose greater than themselves is a step in the right direction. Prisons are still open and wil always be there, now asking those who get welfare, no demanding, service in return for those benefits is a great idea. It would be almost like real work and they mght just take a leap in to the job market and start to sustain themselves.

Carole   September 11th, 2008 10:23 pm ET

Watching the Palin interview I saw smugness. Palin's response to did she think about declining McCain's offer when it was made. Amazing, she didn't mention a word about thinking about her family situation, she went all out for herself and said absolutely yes. None of "let me think about it, I've just had a baby with special needs, my daughter's pregnant and underage and not married, my son is going off to Iraq, I have a small child in elementary school, etc.." That's the first thing that comes to my mind. I need to consider my family and what this will mean to their lives before I make a decision that big. I think it's all about her. Her ego appears to be quite big and we know where that got Cheney. Watch out folks, if she can kill a dozen caribou at a shot forget the poor guy just standing out in a field minding his own business.

Her responses along with McCain's tonight – folks I think we're in for another war – you pick the country – I don't think they care.

Charlene   September 11th, 2008 10:23 pm ET

You don't get it, when you vote your are voting for the ticket. let's keep this real McCain is older and has had medical problems. She could be our President. Tim Russert was fine to and now he's gone. I will never gamble our Country with her.

Jeremiah   September 11th, 2008 10:23 pm ET

I think we all need to take a step back and think about today. Regardless of whether you are Republican or Democrat, today was something extraordinary. To see McCain and Obama come together, put aside all the bickering and really just focus on what today means was inspiring. Today shows that we can put aside differences and focus on what is important, this nation and our people.

DEMOCRAT FOR OBAMA   September 11th, 2008 10:23 pm ET

Mccain seems to be extremely lost without Palin and from watching the Palin interview so far this evening Palin seems to be very nervous and unsure about the questions that was being asked. It would seem that she would seem a little more confident and relaxed now that she's back home in A-LAS-KA.

Let's put her under the microscope like we did Obama.

NO BIAS NO BULL....

Democrat for McCain/Palin   September 11th, 2008 10:23 pm ET

Elephant....are you nuts? Obama can't spell BUSH DOCTRINE!

mike   September 11th, 2008 10:23 pm ET

She has more experience than Obama and she is no.2 on the ticket. The Messiah i forgot has vast experience as a community organizer. What a joke. He hasn't answered a tough question in 19 months because the liberal media has coddled him all this time. How can you say you are for change when you have never changed anything. He was in Chicago with their corrupt operations and failing school. What has he changed. All you Obama supporters or shall i say sheep, Name me three accomplishments that Obama has made?? Oh that's right he has no accomplishments, except graduating from an ivy leaage school. McCain Palin ) '08

Southern Girl for Obama   September 11th, 2008 10:23 pm ET

This was a good forum, however, I too would like to see both candidates answering questions together in this venue. I thought that McCain had an advantage at Saddleback since he got to go on second (as well as prepare for the questions as he listened to Obama). That said, now it is even. Let them both answer without the benefit of "prepping" at the other's expense.

I choose to be inspired. Barack Obama will win in 08.

Allan Comport   September 11th, 2008 10:23 pm ET

I am a long time CNN faithful viewer. I however find Bay Buchanan's comments so blindly partisan to the point that I cannot watch segments when she is involved. She brings no analysis, no expansion of thought, and no critical thinking to any question or issue presented. Her only comment tonight has been a repeat over and over of "I think Gov. Palin's answer was excellent". I count on CNN for a more indepth and thoughtful response to the issues than that.

PNK   September 11th, 2008 10:23 pm ET

Now that I hear McCain's answer about the joint forums, all appearing on stage together, etc. I feel more like he has possibly done better tonight than Obama. I missed McCain's piece, watched Obama's and wanted to like it :) but at times I felt myself going "uh, what was the question again??" as he went on a bit.

Arnold   September 11th, 2008 10:22 pm ET

I could care LESS if either of these candidates were convincing today on September 11th. They said they wouldn't use today as political. Then why didn't they BOTH stay out of the spotlight, away from the cameras, and have today focus solely on the tragic deaths of the 3000+ victims of that horrific day? I want to hear from family members, and firefighters, and the people actually involved rather than a useless parade of politicians.

Jamie   September 11th, 2008 10:22 pm ET

I would like to hear Senator Obama's views on Affirmative Action.

Adrienne   September 11th, 2008 10:22 pm ET

William Dalton, this form about service. It is not a debate about the issues you demand answers for. Obama explained his idea of service and explained in detail the path ways to it he would implement.
William Dalton, how are we going to pay for a needless war?

Democrat for McCain/Palin   September 11th, 2008 10:22 pm ET

Obama is going tax almost everyone more than they are being taxed now. He wants taxes on home profits (that ought to help the housing market!) He wants to revive the death tax where the govt. gets over half my kids inheritance after an exemption. Inheritance dollars I have already paid taxes on once!!!

If Obama were white, he wouldn't have a chance!

Nathan Hale   September 11th, 2008 10:22 pm ET

Olivia, your right you can't take back your words like when Obama said that Rev Wright was his 'mentor' well thats great he's being mentored by a crazed man, whose anti-america, thats the kind of President I want!!!!!

jay   September 11th, 2008 10:22 pm ET

more of Obama's BABBLE,no real substance.kinda reminds of a used car salesman trying to sell a clunker with a bad wax job.

Loyal American123   September 11th, 2008 10:21 pm ET

Why is the "best Political Team" afraid to talk about Social Security?
Republicans say it is in crisis you the shortfall in &) yes 70 yers is the same order of magnitude as the debt George Herbert Hoovewr Bush added to the National Debit.
Is this cowardice or bigotry or bias on the part of the BPT?

"average" american, Missouri   September 11th, 2008 10:21 pm ET

Mr. Roland Martin – how would you define "average" American. Tonight, on t.v., on commenting about Sarah Palin's earlier interview with Charles Gibson, you commented : "The average American must now be asking what NATO is." Just how stupid do you thing the "average" American is? Does one need to be "above avergae" like have a Ph.D. to know what NATO is? I am an average American and I know what NATO is and what the premise is behind the alliance. Mr. Martin you are a SNOB.

libwoman   September 11th, 2008 10:21 pm ET

Jeff:.....are you for real??.....I wish you and your family well while our economy collapses in the best inerest of Irag.....they don't care about YOU!

David revta   September 11th, 2008 10:21 pm ET

McCain sounds confident and now with Palin on her side , democrates watch out. Its not going to be easy.

Dave Speas   September 11th, 2008 10:21 pm ET

It amazes me that this was to be a break from political action today and most of the comments were politically based. I enjoyed just hearing about the thoughts of the two candidates without keeping score. Mr. McCain did not ask that Mr. Obama not hear his answers and Mr. Obama was just as honest in his answers as Mr. McCain. For one night it would have been wonderful to not hear from the political commentators except for the positive elements of the two men's conversations. It probably was too much to ask for but I enjoyed getting to know both good men better.

christofer in ohio   September 11th, 2008 10:21 pm ET

They were both good, but i think Obama is more inspiring, and isnt that what a leader is supposed to do? -inspire the people>

Doug, Ohio   September 11th, 2008 10:21 pm ET

I'd say Gov Palin is every bit as experienced as Joe Biden's running mate.

chinwem   September 11th, 2008 10:21 pm ET

how come mccain and his campaign cant come up with a campaign motor of his own. his copying obamas change message, saying his now the one that's inspiring and pretending to be supporting cummunity service, while mocking those who actually do community service. the GOP is good in stealing-and i dont put any thing past mccain

Republicans for Obama   September 11th, 2008 10:20 pm ET

I HATE my party after this election... All we do is bash the other side and not talk issues. Its because McCain has no issues that will benefit the average american!

Ken   September 11th, 2008 10:20 pm ET

anyone seen continflas well Obama talks just like him the more he talks the less he makes sense! He beats around the bush! just doesn't answers any question to the point!

Salman   September 11th, 2008 10:20 pm ET

It sounded like Bush with lipstick!

mendossa ferary delly   September 11th, 2008 10:20 pm ET

my point is everyting obama said hegonna do mc cain copy that the next day he start talking about thats mean copy also obama came with slogan chance he is the first one talking about change now mccain said he gonna change change what icant take it anymore

Barbara   September 11th, 2008 10:20 pm ET

Jeff – I disagree with you. I don't trust McCain. He is NOT the one to lead us at this time.

P   September 11th, 2008 10:20 pm ET

Bay Buchanan is a total liar

John Illinois   September 11th, 2008 10:20 pm ET

I have to laugh at these people saying Obama "inspires" them so much. How does a guy that hasn't accomplished anything as a state legislator or as an absentee senator and says absolutely nothing as our state of Illinois collapses economically and educationally due to the total corruption of his Democrat Machine party inspire anyone? Why anyone thinks that being a community organizer, someone that talks some of his neighbors into something, is qualified to be President is unbelievable. I don't get it.

Fiscal Conservative/Social Progressive   September 11th, 2008 10:20 pm ET

Reading these comments makes it painfully clear. The Country has never been more divided. A look at the two Candidates makes it even more clear that Obama is the only Candidate that can fix things. We need a reset folks, Bu$h and his neo-cons have divided and destroyed this nation. It is time to rise up and take the Country back. CHANGE is Obama's platform, not McSame's who voted in line with Bu$h over 90% of the time. Some of you need to wake up before we become a 3rd world country. We are headed in the wrong direction and we need a drastic 180. Obama is the man to guide is. There are many of us out here that are losing faith. We need a youthful/fresh approach to politics, not a tired old war hero.

Art   September 11th, 2008 10:19 pm ET

Can anyone tell me why McCain continues to milk his POW story?
He has never acknowledged the service of others. My grandfather was a widower, when all 4 of his sons were in Vietnam. It was an unpopular war. Protesters saw them off and when they returned cab drivers treated them as if they got back from a vacation. While McCain got a heros welcome, they were met by protesters who called them babykillers. Once home, they hung up their uniforms and put away their medals as if they should be ashame! There's a million stories and we keep hearing about McCain. Kerry was slammed for that!!!!

Linda   September 11th, 2008 10:19 pm ET

I thought Obama was just great tonight. I am a 65 year old white woman and I think he is very inspiring. The American people need to listen more to his message and see that he has the country's best interest at heart. I am a life long Democrat and would not think of voting for McCain even though I first voted for Hillary in the Primary.

Obama/Biden 08 and 12

San Diego Moon   September 11th, 2008 10:19 pm ET

Democrats for Palin--Who are you?

That's like saying Moose for Palin.

What logic are you operating from? You're not a democrat.

bea   September 11th, 2008 10:19 pm ET

I'm bored!

ConcernedAboutAnotherElephantintheRoom   September 11th, 2008 10:19 pm ET

This is my first comment on any blog ever....I am compelled to address the Palin interview...if a vice-presidential nominee has no idea about the content of the Bush Doctrine, but attempts to answer a question about it, how can we expect that she is well informed about any policy domestic or foreign? 4th grade spelling bee participants are taught to ask for a definition of a term before spelling or answering a question about it. My expectation is not that she would know about every policy or doctrine, but my concern lies in the fact that she attempts to falsify her knowledge which only sheds light on her ignorance.

Jeff   September 11th, 2008 10:19 pm ET

Nobama! Keep the Change. Stop this Obamanation!

scott   September 11th, 2008 10:19 pm ET

McCain has spent half his life in the sist pool of congress so lets elect that one.. lol we are so smart

sav slim   September 11th, 2008 10:19 pm ET

I think palin needs to stop trying to gain attention and popularity by playing on the intelligence of real working moms because a real woman and mother would not put her career in front of her children and can acknowledge when its time to put your career on hold and take care of your family which clearly comes second in her life!

Macy   September 11th, 2008 10:19 pm ET

Palin's choice has served its purpose. Derailed the voters from asking the tough questions ..... of themselves first. Who do we want to be in charge? Someone with a plan or a hip-shooter??

Mary   September 11th, 2008 10:18 pm ET

I am tired of the McCain campaign and all the nasty lies. I thought he was going to run an honest campaign. He hasn't and I have lost all respect for him. McCain has lost his integrity by aligning himself with the likes of Carl Rove. What is even sadder is the fact that so many people don't bother to research and believe those lies.I also question his judgment with his VP pick....yes it is making for an interesting campaign....but he should have picked someone who would be able to step into the Presidency. If he wins, God help our country if Sarah Palin is President!!!!
It is interesting that this year the republicans can never answer a question that is asked by the press....they always turn it into criticizing the other candidates. If I was Campbell Brown , I would have loved to scream :"Just answer the question!!!!!" I find it very sad that so many Americans can actually believe these half truths and taking words out of context. I heard the whole "lipstick" talk and it was about McCain .

McCain had several very qualified , intelligent Republican women to choose from. I would have respected him if he had chosen a qualified woman.

I came from a small town of 7000 people....there is no way that being mayor of a small town qualifies one to be a President or Vice President of the United States. Organizing groups in Chicago, teaching constitional law, working in Ill. government, and in the national goverment most certainly provides more experience and exposes one to more of the world. I can guarantee you that no large company would hire someone to lead their company with Palin's experience. I have worked with "pit bull" women and know that they do not make good leaders at any level. Knowledge, intelligence, cooperation and team work make for successful leaders. I have traveled throughout this country and live in a very small town now. I do not think that questioning Palin's lack of national and international experience is making fun of small towns. It is just a fact!! I have been a department head, president of many organizations and that does not make me qualified to be President or Vice President. The two Presidential candidates and the Democratic VP candidate have had national and constitutional experience.( Obama studied international studies and he has experience with constitutional law in addition to his job experience).The Republican VP candidate obviously does not have that experience. If she is ready to take over as President , she should have been ready and knowledgable enough to talk to the press and answer questions now. A crash republican course in national and international affairs just doesn't make her ready.
I just listened to her interview....she is NOT qualified!!!!! She talks at a third grade level.....heaven help us!!! Maybe she should have blinked...what arrogance. Do you thnk she knew what NATO was before this week???? Do you think she actually knows where Iraq is now????Maybe she would qualify for some position as a support person in a McCain presidency, but not at the top!!!!

Dwayne Baty   September 11th, 2008 10:18 pm ET

In eight years of listening to Bush and political talk about President Bush.. I have never heard of Bush Doctrine! What is exactly Bush Doctrine? Is this pre-emptive strike? no embryonic stem cell research? economic policies? Doctrine composes of many items of belief and action plans...not just military action plans...so to ask a question WITHOUT clarification is a loaded question...and should not have been asked in that way..

mms   September 11th, 2008 10:18 pm ET

why is mccain trumpeting his military service over and over again as the main qualification to be president. Fred thompson, in his speech, made a statement saying that being a POW doesnt necessarily qualify you to be president. after over 25 yrs in govt is it time for change!!

Mrs. Texas Teacher   September 11th, 2008 10:18 pm ET

I thought Obama sounded very presidential talking about what he has been talking about ever since this campaign began for him over 18 months ago.

McCain has opted all these issues from the Obama camp! Sheeesh... it is so obvious he does not have an original idea in his head! That is because he is only running for office... I think he made that pretty clear tonight! He is just doing whatever he has to do. If that means lying and attacking falsely... it's just part of the game. He made it clear that this is all a game! I don't think Obama is playing games. I think just like he started out as a community servant, he wants to make a difference in the lives of the common people, NOT Ultra Rich!

mark   September 11th, 2008 10:18 pm ET

Nobody is denying Sen. McCain's legendary service. But Sen. Obama's service is one that people can relate to. It's one of everyday struggle and one of helping those around you who are also struggling find the light at the end of the tunnel. His plan for America is nothing less than A+. He knows what everyday people have been through, what they go through and what they will face. Because of this he knows how to bring better days. He has my vote.

VLB   September 11th, 2008 10:18 pm ET

Hillary supporters are going to vote for McCain just because Palin is a woman. If McCain wins, Republicans will write themselves another big raise, Democrats will struggle to pay bills and serve food on their tables. But most importantly, the Hillary supporters will feel vindicated. The Republicans played the divide and conquer game and may win. Then, they will sit around a table laughing at how stupid woman are to base life determining decisions on ones gender. Decisions made on emotions, feelings, and stupidity are all the reasons why I would never vote for a woman.

Republican for Obama   September 11th, 2008 10:18 pm ET

Enough said what was i thinking

Cheri   September 11th, 2008 10:17 pm ET

Gov. Palin showed all the intellect of a high school senior fresh from a civics lesson in her interview with Charlie Gibson tonight. It was tough to watch. I cringed as she often repeated her scripted responses in lieu of appropriately thoughtful, intelligent, genuine answers. It is totally clear to me now why her Republican handlers have kept her away from the press – they already knew what we just found out tonight. Even a soft-shoe interviewer made her look sophomoric and weak. As badly as I wanted her to do well for all the women out there who aspire to political heights, it seems her style isn't unlike George W. Bush, presenting a sort of robotic, regurgitative repetitiveness under direct questioning, reflective of an average IQ at best. I am now convinced Sen. McCain's lacks the judgment necessary to be President for believing she could do the job at this stage in her political life. The Republican ticket has lost my vote.

Big Vic from Reagan Country -Part II   September 11th, 2008 10:17 pm ET

I heard sone outrage about the infamous lipstick remark. Frankly, I am not sure about the concern. A right wing attempt to look liberal and yes it does look ugly.

I have to hear McCain express outrage over the remarks leveled at Obama. One college Republican said Obama's lips could float him to Cuba. Obama has been referred to as "uppity".

Where are the Republicans on these clear racist slants? Right, they are silent.

As for McCain talking about service, I guess in his mind it has to be the right service, like miltiary service in Iraq.

Mayra Garcia   September 11th, 2008 10:17 pm ET

Did you watch the same Sarah Palin interview? Roland, maybe some people don't know about NATO but this is a person who could be President. She was obviously prepped for this and kept repeating 'talking points' such as "we can't second guess Isr'ael" and "I didn't blink". So she's confident, so what. She doesn't have the knowledge or experience. John King is saying that she did well. She's not applying for a job as journalist, toast master or Ms. Congeniality.
I was waiting for her to say "World Peace". Candy Crowley is also making excuses for her. Palin could be our Commander in Chief and you are not doing your jobs if you do not raise the bar. Would you accept these answers from a man or from Hillary Clinton? Heaven help us you're sure not. Let the republicans defend her, that's not your job.

Republicanturnedindependent   September 11th, 2008 10:17 pm ET

I think that if Barrack Obama continues with this Mr. Nice guy tactic, he will be left behind in the gutter. I am an independent leaning towards Obama but I am absolutely disgusted by the response (or lack thereof) of the Democratic party to this ongoing, sustained and unprecedented attack on them– especially as these attacks distract from the issues.

I feel no sympathy for Obama because he should have known the Rove type of politics by now and prepared for it.

Now the Republicans have scared the media including CNN. Booo.. Mr. Cooper!
Anyone who opposes them is hung on the cross and given a crown of thorns. Any criticism of Palin is deemed sexist, how outrageous. She is a big girl playing with the big boys, if Hillary could not hide behind the "I am a girl claim" well, neither should she.

I am a mother, NRA member, hunter, soccer mum... etc etc... but will NOT be voting for a continuation of the same old administration. Ps: Who was polled regarding the swinging of all women to McCain because his VP nominee has breasts like us?? How ridiculous.

If Obama loses this election, history will never deal kindly with him. He has no excuse because in the present circumstance... change of any sort... coming from a FRESH perspective will suffice.

Leesa   September 11th, 2008 10:17 pm ET

Hmmm...yeah, the Dems have been in control of Congress for the past two years. All the Democrat congressmen elected used the same campaign slogan as Obama...change...need to change what Bush has done to the nation. And what have they accomplished?? Absolutely NOTHING..oh wait...they spent the past two years blaming Bush for everything when they should have spent the past two years working for the american people. Obama/Biden and Nancy Pelosi are jokes. Yeah...I want four more years of them...NOT!

Not worried about job losses under McCain. ...my husband is a coal miner...at least MCCain has a real energy plan...more worried about his job if Obama is prez.

McCain/Palin '08...REAL change!

Jim   September 11th, 2008 10:17 pm ET

Well, Palin readily admits to being a pit bull. We all know that's a dog you cannot trust.

Loyal American123   September 11th, 2008 10:17 pm ET

Although we "know" no one ever cheats on their Social Security taxes, would you be amnemible to enacting really severe penaltiesfor a new commer to Social Security Cheating? And maybe civil penalities for guys like Justice Stephen Breyer? He is a confess Social Security Tax Cheat!

yvonne   September 11th, 2008 10:17 pm ET

I think Obama did great in articulating a vision for this country. On a different note.
Why is Palin talking to foreign governments.
What goverments have Alaska been dealing with.
Its dangerous having all these different people talking to foreign goverments.
I can understand Biden but a canidate who has no foreighn experence and why is not the press all over this.???????????/

Bridget McCurry   September 11th, 2008 10:17 pm ET

William Dalton, maybe community service is not accountable, but college is, and Obama couln't have chosen a tougher path, or exceeded more. His degrees aren't in journalism.

Douglas   September 11th, 2008 10:16 pm ET

Why did'nt they show all of the members from Palin's son unit,it's not right to pick out an individual only because of who his or her parents are when other services men and women are doing this everyday.

Victoria   September 11th, 2008 10:16 pm ET

Enough of the forums. I want the debates!

kai   September 11th, 2008 10:16 pm ET

Katiec, The reason all media want the republicans in office is because they want DEREGULATION. Then super wealthy Like Murdock etc can have all the radio, tv and internet business in a given area. Then they really can control what we see etc on TV. Think about it!!!
KAI

libwoman   September 11th, 2008 10:16 pm ET

I think that the whole idea of a "conservative woman" is an oxymoron.
By the way......SHE is not running for president. Let's keep our focus on the candidates. I wish her son well in Iraq. After all....it is her religeous war that her poor son is fighting..........sad.........sad how uneducated so many americans are. THINK people!!!! THINK!!

P   September 11th, 2008 10:16 pm ET

By the way we change each and everyday, anyone that fears change is afraid to live as a free person, with GOD given rights, were the founding fathers afraid of change to start a new nation,were the slaves afaid to be free, is a even a baby afraid to come out of the womb, but the Repbulican wanst everyone to be afaird so that the people will get thier information from them. Without change we can not live without change the world does not go on everything would stop at one point of time.

CHANGE happens to us each and everyday of our live, all those who time at this momnet in time are facing and over comming chnage everyday!

Peace   September 11th, 2008 10:16 pm ET

I'm voting for Obama an educated man and a great role model. Not for an old maverick that got caught and was probably brainwashed America deserves a winner . Not two republicans losers

someguy   September 11th, 2008 10:16 pm ET

I liked it. Everything was very civil and to the point. It showed the good in both candidates rather than exploit the negatives. Obama and Mccain's position reflects the democratic and republican different views on what role government should play, which they both were asked. I support Obama's stance which is that government playing a role in it all doesn't ruin the opportunities for volunteer work. Which has been demonstrated before with fema and the red cross.

Jeff   September 11th, 2008 10:16 pm ET

McCain clearly dominated tonight. Obama is clearly in over his head. No real plan. No leadership. No expereince.

Darnell Johnson   September 11th, 2008 10:16 pm ET

I just want to know why there was no mention of Palin stating that "energy" is the foundation of national security. How has she made the country energy independent?

MaryAnn   September 11th, 2008 10:16 pm ET

McCain is Bush. Don't forget that.

R. Cooper   September 11th, 2008 10:16 pm ET

Beware America, It now War on Russia under the McCain-Palin ticket!!! OH MY GOD!!!!!!

Walt   September 11th, 2008 10:15 pm ET

Here are the hard questions these men must answer:

1. How are you going to save Social Security?
2. How are you going to get the economy on the right track?
3. How are you going to handle the energy crisis?
4. How are you going to make the United States self-sufficient again?
5. How are you going to make Congress stop spending more than it
takes in?
6. How will you win the war in Iraq and Afghanistan?
7. How are you going to turn around the deficit?

These people (both parties) have yet to have any definitive answers. All they do is dance around the issues without giving us answers.

I'm all for change, but change to what? A person that talks a good game, but when it comes right down to it can't deliver on the promises?

The media isn't demanding that the candidates give the American people any kind of rational plan instead of empty promises.

But come November, we, the American people will vote a team into office, whoever wins, it's going to be one heck of a circle jerk.

sameer   September 11th, 2008 10:15 pm ET

why dont media scrutinize obama's state voting record .where he had hundreds of vote as "present" as they are obsessed by sarah palen's record . it just shows that he just dont want do the right thing for the people but do the safe thing for his political career.

Squazzo   September 11th, 2008 10:15 pm ET

Senator McCain has disappointed me....I voted for him in the 2000 and 2008 primaries, because I thought he was the best Republican candidate and really stood on his own as an Independent thinker....his ACTIONS over the course of the past 6 or so months have shown me that he is compromising his beliefs to get the support of the very people who sand bagged him in the 2000 primary (Karl Rove) just to win an election, especially with the choice of Ms. Palin, who is extreme in her beliefs and another polarizing figure that this Country does not need right now....we need someone who is truly in the middle with the best interests of all Americans at heart-Joe Biden and Barack Obama will be receiving this Republicans vote

Adam   September 11th, 2008 10:15 pm ET

democrat: why would u jump ship as soon as ur candidate didn't"win" if Obama wins Clinton wins. we are all one party.

Yolanda   September 11th, 2008 10:15 pm ET

I was very inspired by Obama's call for action amongst citizens. We are in this together. I'm very turned off by the Republicans sitting on their high hypocritical horses and looking down on people who want more for their communities. As a woman, I can appreciate the advancements we've made in this country. Palin is representative of that. I am leary of her being a heartbeat away from running this country. She is a fiery, unprepared, mouthy, shady Governor. I would constantly be living in fear if she were Vice President. I pray that the American people can see past her in your face substanceless rhetoric.

tony gunslinger   September 11th, 2008 10:15 pm ET

Hey, you rednecks out there:

Service means sacrifice, remember? To serve your country meant giving up some freedoms to make our nation secure. Now, to make government change, to make the people of this country proud of being Americans, you need to sacrifice your IGNORANCE and PREJUDICE to see clearly that educated people are not elitists who look down on you. They are the ones who designed your roads and cities, they are the ones who wrote the Constitution, they are the ones who organizes military strikes, build your computer games, make your guns work, solve logistical problems on food, economy, who builds the foundation so you can run around being the arrogant xenophobes that you are.

So take a moment to squash your ego this November and vote based on facts, not Family Values, or Moral Values or NRA or Abortion or Church or Skin Color or Sex or Lipstick or POW. That would a service to your beloved country.

Sam   September 11th, 2008 10:15 pm ET

You guys better watch out she may come on to you all. If/when ever she becomes VP...lol...

Lester1282   September 11th, 2008 10:15 pm ET

If allowed to drill for more oil in Alaska and off shore, do you think the oil companies will market the oil oversees or keep it hear at home?

Would they exploit our natural and strategic resources, at the expense of the already overburden tax paying citizen ??

Would the candidates guarantee the resources would be used to benefit all Americans, and not just give in to the greed of the oil barons?

Clinton   September 11th, 2008 10:15 pm ET

I think Obama did a great job and presenting his answers to the American public...He sounded more convincing than McCain. After viewing Gov. Palin interview, finally, I am not convinced by her. As running for VP she should at least know what the Bush Doctrine is. I am changing my vote for Obama.

Terence   September 11th, 2008 10:14 pm ET

Please can someone answer this one question; how can someone run for one of the highest offices in the land and be investigated at the same time? If it was the average joe, we would have no chance at all of getting hired at any job.

CMH   September 11th, 2008 10:14 pm ET

There is no country that gives more "community" service – internally and externally – than America. Maybe Michelle could find a way to be proud of that? I've been to numerous third world countries where American missionaries and aid workers have been volunteering for decades. Additionally I've worked in numerous soup kitchens and homeless shelters where ministries and volunteers give their time and money to help the needy. Most of their deeds are done below the radar and unrecognized by the "socialistic" media that only recognizes government run programs. The last thing we need is for Obama to mandate community service through the federal government. If more prisoners were made to break rocks we'd have fewer criminals and therefore more fathers raising their children and therefore more productive people and therefore less need for community service. Government needs to punish wrongdoing and get out of the way to those that want to do good.

truth-Chicago   September 11th, 2008 10:14 pm ET

Bay I really want to connect with you because, I think you are out of touch with reality. The reality is that your party has ran the White House for 8 years and look at the state we are in.

I just graduated with a Master's Degree in IT. Why can't I get a job? I volunteer in my community and with my church. But because of the decisions that Bush has made the economy is terrible. I could not afford to go to college so I took out loans. In three more months the government will be calling my phone. On top of that I served in the military and they never kept their promises. This is a reality.

But I guess I should have been a republican strategist they seem to be working pretty hard to convince the American people that everything is okay.

MikeC   September 11th, 2008 10:14 pm ET

Holy cow.. Watching Anderson 360 and the big story (besides the hurricane) is Palin Palin Palin.. Why aren't they taking about the McCain/Obama forum.

Loyal American123   September 11th, 2008 10:14 pm ET

Are Americans more in fear of the external threat to their security or to the interla threat from loss of savings, unemployment, corporate cheaters and pressure gruups that allow hedge fund manager to pay less in taxers than a blue collar worker?

Monica   September 11th, 2008 10:14 pm ET

Hi I just text message to everyone in my blackberry (200ppl) in remembrance 9-11& our service to our beloved country…you're more than welcome to help spread the word

"Check it out…Obama wants to make Govt COOL again!" Alright!!! Spread the Word! Let's get involved cause Yes Together We Can!

jackiefu   September 11th, 2008 10:14 pm ET

Goodness.
All of these comments are really indicative of "polar positions" that will not be changed by any factual postings/arguements by eithr side.
That being said, isn't the "play " for the few supposed "independents"
a pretty big deal?
I would think that logic and reason based on "positions" would prevail over sexist and racist comments by either side.
Come on MF's, tone it down.

Lee-Lee in Oklahoma   September 11th, 2008 10:14 pm ET

From what I read Biden was answering a question from the floor if he thought Hillary would make a great VP.

Also from what i've seen on tv(news) McCain used the term lip stick on a pig before Obama.

Kimberly from North Chicago,IL   September 11th, 2008 10:14 pm ET

I thought Obama did an excellent job and thathe kept every focused on the task at hand..Good Job

Darryll Petrancuri   September 11th, 2008 10:14 pm ET

(Follow-Up) Since a VP by implication has to be ready to step in should the President not be able to execute the duties of the office, would you agree that Joe Biden is better prepared to do so than Palin, and that Biden will remain true to the party platform and ideology where Palin would attempt to move her administration much further to the right?

jim   September 11th, 2008 10:14 pm ET

I found it interesting that McCain said there should be more incentive for the Military to help with retention, and his idea was to pay pilots more. Those that already have a college degree. He failed to mention he wouldn't even show up to vote for the new GI Bill. A bill that was co-sponsored by over 60 senators. By the way, he would have voted no.

Grace Needed   September 11th, 2008 10:14 pm ET

Well done CNN! I appreciate this opportunity to hear our candidates views without all the tensions of a debate. They both did well.

Sophia   September 11th, 2008 10:13 pm ET

So Sarah Palin knew about how NATO works – rather, she knew (kind of) about the most obvious principle of the Aliance. I must say, in Europe, for example, school kids under age 12 know this. It is so amazing to see people think "wow, Sarah Palin interviews so well, she really is not so bad, she is bright, she is GOOD!", all this only because she knows 1+1 = 2. I guess the expectations were so low that when the woman demonstrated an ability to utter coherent sounds everyone fell on their back. And even more amazing – because she knows 1+1=2, Sarah Palin is confident she can be the vice-prezident of the United States, and could step into a presidential role – without blinking. She embodies the danger of ignorance. That she can be taken seriously is an American phenomenon. Being Legally Blond is OK in a comedy, not in real politics in troubled times.

Michael A. Colletti   September 11th, 2008 10:13 pm ET

President Bush – 1) Soon will be sending more troops to Afghanistan 2) Is talking to Iran 3) Will be reducing troops in Iraq 3) Now allowing limited attacks in Pakistan against the Taliban and Al Qarda. I wonder which Presidential Candate proposed the above and which scoffed at them.

Monix   September 11th, 2008 10:13 pm ET

Roland,

I really appreciate your commentary. I think you always see thru the rubbish. Thank you

Beck   September 11th, 2008 10:13 pm ET

Isn't it GOOD that Sarah Palin doesn't know The Bush Doctrine?? What better proof that she is Not an agent of Bush – how can she be accused of "four more years" when she doesn't even know the Capitol Hill chant of the past eight??

She's fair, she's honest, she has a lot to say – same for Obama, same for McCain (...I wish Biden would stop yelling at us, so I can tell what he's all about).

Let them All talk – and let's All listen...and then decide. We The People do not have to stoop as low as the media will go – we can rise above and choose with intelligence, caring, and trust that our instincts prove correct.

And Roland – this may shock you, but little 'ole me KNOWS WHAT NATO IS! jeez -

Monica   September 11th, 2008 10:13 pm ET

Hi I just text message to everyone in my blackberry (200ppl) in remembrance 9-11of service to our country...you're more than welcome to help spread the word

"Check it out...Obama wants to make Govt COOL again!" Alright!!! Spread the Word! Let's get involved cause Yes Together We Can!

Olivia   September 11th, 2008 10:13 pm ET

Senator Obama by far understands community services much more than Senator McCain...McCain's vice presidential candidate very condescendingly remarked about those who perform community services...Having served for many years in both my community personally and with a large Kiwanis group I am still reeling about the laughing attitude at the RNC...You cannot take your words and attitudes back once they are said...Even in politics...

Ralph of Denver   September 11th, 2008 10:13 pm ET

So when asked earlier today about Palin's experience on foreign policy, McCain simply replied she's and expert at energy? What the...?? I don't want that kind of programed response from my president, nor do I want a governor who refuses to listen to her ethics advisor as the back-up!

dani taylor   September 11th, 2008 10:13 pm ET

Can see us now at WAR with the whole world Seems people think its not important she don't know what the Bush Doc. was...hmm what else will think its not important what she needs to know...and Hey palin his name is charles not charlie...how disprectful of you...but thats your arrogrance

Laura   September 11th, 2008 10:13 pm ET

While I appreciate Candy Crowley trying to be fair-saying that people in "rural Missouri"don't know what the Bush Doctrine is and therefore it won't matter that Sarah Palin doesn't -IT DOES MATTER. Someone who could, not unreasonably, be President within the next few months SHOULD. Unlike many who feel comfortable with Gov.Palin because she is "just like us"...I am very comfortable with a President who is smarter/more educated/more worldly, etc. than I. In fact, I prefer it!

Mark   September 11th, 2008 10:13 pm ET

One: Charles Gibson lost his newsman cred when he started doing GMA; it was a softball interview. Two, why is everyone giving her so much credit when she's been holed up with Bush's people all week to get her ready? All this proves is she's a good parrot. Three, why do all of the news agencies continue to hire people inside the political system? None of these people will tell you the truth! Here's the lowdown on how your "experts" will take this interview: Democratic operatives will say she stunk and the Republicans will proclaim her the Second Coming. This is like asking Hillary Clinton her opinion on a Bill Clinton speech.

Shawn Irwin   September 11th, 2008 10:13 pm ET

Palin is a PAPER TIGER. At her first speech, the audience started cheering loudly at the very beginning . . . not a RESPONSE to a good speech . . . . it appeared staged to me, the audience seems to have been urged to cheer loudly. It had nothing to do with the content and delivery of her speech which in its entirety could be considered devisive and mediocre at best.

Palin supports making Georgia a member of NATO, then goes on to say that if Russia attacked Georgia we must defend Georgia, but, that there should be no "cold war". It appears she is ignorant of the how alliances of this type sparked the beginning of WW I.

Just recently a REPUBLICAN, Dana Rohrbacher, of California, who
supported the WAR IN IRAQ, stated that the war was started by Georgia, that Georgia broke the truce.

And we should add them to NATO? Palin is naive and inexperienced, and, dangerous because of her ignorance. And were she elected, she would be one heart beat away from the presidency.

Good choice John.

Suzanne   September 11th, 2008 10:13 pm ET

I was not raised being taught to do service, but as I matured, I realized that service for my fellow Americans not only helped them, but made me grow as an individual.

I am a non-traditional student, and being able to do service and it help my education would be wonderful.

Government should be a source of inspiration, and as we have seen in the past 18 months, it IS an inspiration, positive and negative.

Lisa   September 11th, 2008 10:13 pm ET

Military service is the ultimate service, no doubt. Because John McCain served his country and was a POW shouldn't be the reason we voe for him in Nov. When he started his quest for president, I could have voted for him becaused he bucked the system here and there. Now, I can't because he is just another Republican trying to "win." We do need change and will continue on the same old if he is voted in. He's not change he is a part of the republican machine who I have come to despise. I despise their dirty Carl Rovian politics and feel like they don't get the average Joe/JoAnne in this nation. They are so out of touch.

Latonya Bailey,27   September 11th, 2008 10:13 pm ET

That interview was the most ridiculous thing on t.v. Why does she not know what the Bush doc. is? she looked like a deer in headlights.Then she had to be led by the hand for her answer which still was bogus. Maybe most regular folks don't know what the doc. is about but she SHOULD!
Get ready republicans, Palin is going to get more face time and America will see how unprepared they both are.
L

Stephen Whitney-Wise   September 11th, 2008 10:13 pm ET

McCain asks people to fight for him so that he can do what he thinks is best for the American people. Obama says that together we can accomplish great things for America. McCain believes that he knows what it best for America. Obama says together we can discern a course of action. Obama's book "The Audacity of Hope" sets forth his thinks. McCain's book, written by a co-author, is all about McCain's ideas about himself.

I would rather have a leader like Obama who listens and leads than a leader like McCain who thinks he knows what's best and tells us what to do.

Hurricaine ike   September 11th, 2008 10:12 pm ET

When other people's children are sent to Iraq, it is the will of God but when Sarah Palin's son is deployed to Iraq, it's not God will. The reality is robbing her back now.

charlie   September 11th, 2008 10:12 pm ET

can someone answer this for me? why doesn't anyone ask McCain what he means when he basically says that Barack could have prevented McCain's team from using this mud-slinging, Karl Rove tactics against him by having townhall meetings with him???? CAN ANYONE ANSWER THIS FOR ME? PLEASE!

stefanie   September 11th, 2008 10:12 pm ET

I know what the Bush Doctrine is and I am just a housewife. Palin should know, as well as every politician.

Jill   September 11th, 2008 10:12 pm ET

Govenor Palin's son should not be allowed to go to Iraq; I fear he will be a target and put other soldier's in harms way. His deployment may have been in the works before she was selected for the ticket, but now is the time for sanity to prevail. It sure is a nice publicity clip for the Republican's, but don't jeopordize others for a 30 second news piece.

Dee   September 11th, 2008 10:12 pm ET

Why on Earth are Candy and David G taking up for Palin regarding her pathetic interview today? If this were anyone else, that person would have been scaled and filleted by now. Please, no special consideration for the newbie. This is *national* politics and our future depends on it!

Nick (California)   September 11th, 2008 10:12 pm ET

Martin and other surrogates should not be allowed on national TV, especially on channels which claim to provide unbiased coverage. Martin is clearly a Obama supporter and he can never provide a unbiased opinion about any issue. I am disappointed with the national media be it Fox, CNN or NBC, everyone has already picked up their sides. Ultimately, it is the end viewer who is suffering and is being misinformed and forced to make misinformed decision resulting in putting wrong people in office, who are ruining the country.

Kate, NV   September 11th, 2008 10:12 pm ET

BK- We can afford these programs because Obama plans to cut wasteful spending, tax big oil companies that are making record profits and require Iraq sitting on billions to start footing the bill to rebuild Iraq. Meanwhile, McCain wants to continue a war and based on Palin's interview today, would consider going to war with Russia. If Americans were more involved in community service locally and internationally, we would have more peace in this world. There are people struggling in this Country and abroad and some of us are fortunate to have luxury. It's not all about you, think about something bigger than yourself. Obama walks the walk to encourage people to take personal responsibility about helping others less fortunate. Bill, I disagree. He's not talking about a government bail out. He is talking about the government being a leader to encourage personal commitment to service.
Why is that wrong? Wasn't our government asking for volunteers for Gustav last week?
Obama is inspirational and makes me want to be a better person and give back to others less fortunate with my service- whether in the military, community or internationally. We as a nation and the world should think more like that.

theroadrunner   September 11th, 2008 10:12 pm ET

Both candidates expressed support for national public service, though it seemed that McCain has more reservations about it, fearing "creeping socialism." Obama seemed to take the position that there are plenty of problems to go around, and that these problems could be used to bring citizens together in a creative and positive sort of way.

Andy Panda   September 11th, 2008 10:12 pm ET

Why does Sarah Palin sound so angry in her interview with Charles Gibson tonight? Shouldn't she be happy to answer reporters questions? she has no idea what she has gotten herself into!!

Willa-PA   September 11th, 2008 10:12 pm ET

William Dalton September 11th, 2008 10:04 pm ET

Adrienne- You have to be kidding! Obama uses his 'change' platform to answer every question as possible, rarely giving a definitive answer. For example, where does he plan to pay for this universal healthcare? How does his plans for education actually help failing schools? To these and other questions, Obama has hid behind his transparent shield of change, avoiding real plan making.

Spoken like a true republican...

craig   September 11th, 2008 10:12 pm ET

where do i watch this interview eveyones talking about it and i cant see it ?

phil   September 11th, 2008 10:12 pm ET

I think they want us all to get into community service because they know the economy is going to tank. They want us to take care of ourselves because they wont be able to. All of our political choices are gloomy.

disappointed in CNN   September 11th, 2008 10:12 pm ET

CNN is getting more one sided than ever these days........... so much for objective journalism

Demus   September 11th, 2008 10:11 pm ET

William Dalton : like McCain uses his POW issue on everything ? hmmmm to wrongs dont make a right .

ray   September 11th, 2008 10:11 pm ET

Nobody is asking John McCain.........about his choice of VP, all what some folks are saying was Obama made a wrong move of not picking Hillary.........Would McCain have picked a black man if it was Hillary that won the primaries?....................it shows what he care about.........just to win the election

Fofo   September 11th, 2008 10:11 pm ET

I think the republicans will continue make attempts to damage Obama while avoiding the central issue of this election: the economy. Second, the attacks on the democrats being unpatriotic and being soft on national security will continue as the election nears its climax. Perhaps, the democrats can be bold enough to attack the national security issue head on in their own ads. See it goes like this: "It's three AM.... McCain's having chest pain ( or something critical about his health). Do you have confidence in Palin as commander-in-cheif?." McCain's running on national security as part of his credentials, but yet his choice as VP is reckless. We are being distracted by the personalities of this election as this past two weeks events have demonstrated.

fofo

farah   September 11th, 2008 10:11 pm ET

Bill, how do you know it won't change the dynamic of the race? Between this and Palin's interview (she doesn't know what Bush doctrine is), Obama is going up and McCain climbing down.

Anonymous   September 11th, 2008 10:11 pm ET

Palin, is not educated at all did you hear her?

lex   September 11th, 2008 10:11 pm ET

Obama was a community organizer in Chicago....What the heck did he accomplish? That place is a mess. More killings this summer in Chicago, than deaths of soldiers in Iraq.

Mike (Corpus Christi)   September 11th, 2008 10:11 pm ET

Sarah Palin is not only not ready, but she is scarily not ready. I truly would not mind having McCain as a President; but he is 72, she can not be a President. We have already let 8 years of our history be soiled with an incompetent leader that had to rely on neo-con think tanks to make his decisions, because he was too stupid and doesn’t have any intellectual curiosity.

dani taylor   September 11th, 2008 10:11 pm ET

I personally found her arrogrant...CHARLIE?...to me that came off an unprofessional. His name is Charles. Even my friends who were here...took as if she was talking down to him

Lulu   September 11th, 2008 10:11 pm ET

Obama is all about government initiated service programs...
and guess how he pays for these programs...
BY RAISING OUR TAXES!!!

Amen   September 11th, 2008 10:11 pm ET

I would like MC Cain to address why he voted with BUSH over 90% of the time and expects people to believe he's for change . Americans are not fools i hope they can't be tricked into following a cult leader who was so nervous he picked a runner-up wanna be beauty queen that is tougher than him so he better not go hunting with her cause on she will return

Anonymous   September 11th, 2008 10:11 pm ET

I am a Canadian living in Vancouver who has been following this election closely. I think that America has a tremendous opportunity to really take stock of themselves and how they live their lives, the role they play in the world, their responsibility as global citizens and the legacy they are leaving future generations. The US media also has an opportunity to take a good, hard long look at its responsibility to inform and enlighten instead of sensationalize, dilute and exaggerate pure information that is so vital for the citizens of your county. The health of the American people, the environment and the economy should be the primary concerns of all the politicians involved. It is everywhere else in the world. Government OF the people FOR the people....isn't THAT the American way?.....just wondering.
Christine Haebler

Jeremy, New Orleans, La   September 11th, 2008 10:11 pm ET

Why don't we hear anything from McCain? I never questioned his age until recently. He just seems worn out. I think the republicans have surrendured. I agree with Clinton – Obama will win by a landslide!

robert   September 11th, 2008 10:11 pm ET

Wiliam–You have to be kidding! We spend 10b a month in funding this war on Iraq. As Sen Obama has stated repeatedly if we stop this crazy spending and pull our buts out of Iraq "responsibly". We can probably afford Universal Heathcare, which we need.

Robert
Iraq Veteran

Loyal American123   September 11th, 2008 10:11 pm ET

Would you pardon or commute the sentence of Jothnathan Pollard the traitor?
If yes under what pressures from the Israeli Lobby?

Susan   September 11th, 2008 10:10 pm ET

Did anybody notive that John McCain said that being in Washington had divorced him from the everyday problems of the American people?

Gary in Tennessee   September 11th, 2008 10:10 pm ET

Every day more dirt is dug up on Palin, give it a few more weeks and McCain will be wanting to change his VP nominee because of out and out lies, hang on everyone the best is yet to come.

Donna   September 11th, 2008 10:10 pm ET

Roland...you are the MAN!!!!!

becky in va   September 11th, 2008 10:10 pm ET

i am still in shock that so many american citizens are elated by mccain's choice of palin as his running mate. if you were a female who supported hillary, and are now in favor of palin, then you are a walking contradiction. shame on you!

hopeful for USA   September 11th, 2008 10:10 pm ET

i think both candidates did well to explain what serving ought to be . but sen barack obama i think is the best to know how tap into the spirit of every young american to serve this great country.

Demus   September 11th, 2008 10:10 pm ET

well democrat hope you have no kids or your rich cause if McCain is the Pres. you will need the money and no kids to suport

Darryll Petrancuri   September 11th, 2008 10:10 pm ET

Does the Republican Party have so little regard for women voters that they believe just because a substantial number of Democratic women voters were disenfranchised by Obama's pick of Biden that they can 'steal' these voters by nominating a women as McCain's running mate?

for the people   September 11th, 2008 10:10 pm ET

Biden should step down for the good of the people ant the party and Obama should ask Bill clinton to be his #2. Its hard to make change on the outside looking in .

Dave   September 11th, 2008 10:10 pm ET

Can we get a VOLUNTEER public service to replace Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid so we can abolish them. Charity and socialism are NOT the same thing. Obama may mean well but Marxism is un-American on every possible level.

Michael Goldsholl   September 11th, 2008 10:10 pm ET

When are you going to stop pretending that Obama isn't an American Christian. He is admittedly a Muslim who's agenda is a Socialist one.
He is going to tax this nation to death and impliment a a healthcare plan which wlll destroy this nations quality physicians.
George bush Has kept this country terrorism free for seven years.
When are you going to admit this fact?

A Fellow Patriot   September 11th, 2008 10:10 pm ET

Senator McCain said going to "Washington has somewhat divorced him from the day-to-day challenges people have". Isn't that just the opposite of why you go to Washington? To engage the challenges your constuencies face and advocate on their behalf?

It is Obama in 2008 and 2012   September 11th, 2008 10:10 pm ET

Certainly the American people see clearly how great Sen. Obama would be as the next commander-in-chief, and how great he would be to restore America's image abroad. He will definitely get many votes…many votes !

Annette, Washington, DC   September 11th, 2008 10:10 pm ET

I really don't think McCain was in his element. We tend to think if you are in the military then, you have given the greatest sarcifice to die for your country. I hope our minds aren't that small and thinking from the far distance, athough servicing in the military is a sarcifice, there are no appointed level of service, one good act, is not better then the other good act. There is no degrees in giving and servicing.

To sat aside and belittle any act of community service as a joke or laughing point, is more elitist then speaking and understanding ideas and concepts.

I was that person Obama mention, during the aftermath of Katrina, I volunteered with EMA, and worked side by side with the red cross, later to be offered a position with a local volunteer organization, serving my community and communities in the metropolitan DC area. So to mock such a great calling is ludacris.

Tom   September 11th, 2008 10:10 pm ET

Bay Buchanan is a rightwing flack who added nothing to this board. Others, especially Bill and Roland, tried to be objective.

New Yorkers for Clinton   September 11th, 2008 10:10 pm ET

Thanks for hosting this CNN. You all do a great job !

scott   September 11th, 2008 10:10 pm ET

PALIN IS A DOCUMENTED CROOK

Texico From Mexico   September 11th, 2008 10:10 pm ET

Well at least the Republican party has their own "Paris Hilton" now.

Michigan2008   September 11th, 2008 10:09 pm ET

Did anybody also hear McCain say that being a Major means dealing with the problems of original Americans. He mentioned that him going to Washington was a lot easier, because in that position you are not being confroted with that insight into the lifes of Americans. WHAT??? He actually admitted having no insight at all!!!

Seriously? I think that sentence could become a problem for him. Can't believe that our experts didn't jump right onto this statement.

Adrian-Santa Ana,Cali   September 11th, 2008 10:09 pm ET

The people have the president they deserve. I now understand why we have "W".

what_happened_to_experience   September 11th, 2008 10:09 pm ET

Why is there all of a sudden this talk of another round of so called stimulus checks (read more money we'll just have to pay back later anyway), less than 2 months before the election. I saw this on the news today, along with the additional disclaimer that getting one depends on who you vote for? Any idea who's putting this one out? hmmm

Pierre   September 11th, 2008 10:09 pm ET

Obama is drawing his inspiration from the past.

So in SOME respects, America @ its best ( some what )
Service for state and community were the norm of the day.
Granted times have changed, but respect, honor and service never
go out of style.

America needs to sit and think about what do they really want.
What picture do they want to send the world.

McCain has my respect, but he will never get my vote.
He thinks he deserves being president before he possible dies.

He isnt president material.

For America.

For this world.

And this time.

Maybe if this were 1955 and the war(s) were just over.

axt113   September 11th, 2008 10:09 pm ET

Obama carried the night, his answers were deep and thoughtful and he came across as really understanding how to get the country moving again, Obama is like a modern FDR

Teresa   September 11th, 2008 10:09 pm ET

A. Louis! You are so right! Anyone else heard of FDR? Hmmm didn't he die in office in his third term? The fact is when the government stepped in and made jobs and helped the people (hence the meaning to "democracy" actually being used), the nation as a whole becomes stronger. Yes, individualism is a good thing, but it should not be the only thing, and we must remember that.

ScaredAmerican   September 11th, 2008 10:09 pm ET

What is wrong with Bay Buchanan!?! This is the worst case of playing "ostrich" I think I've ever seen. The snippets that I've seen of Sarah Palin's interview with Charlie Gibson, not only show that she is NOT ready to be president, but that she is completely incompetent! Her body language showed just how unfamiliar she was with substantive questions. She could only answer questions when she was "given" details in the question and then she answered very vaguely. She is an absolute fraud. The fact that anyone would vote for John McCain with such an incompetent running mate is VERY SCARY!

Breck   September 11th, 2008 10:09 pm ET

Why is CNN not posting my comments? I just talked about how McCain needs to actually say what he is changing and talk about the economy.

robert Parker   September 11th, 2008 10:09 pm ET

CNN is a corporate entity with corporate interests: You are a bunch of scum bag liars. Obama is going to win in a landslide. Even is red neck Tennessee a drunk guy commenting on gas prices said, "I believe the nig=34 is going to win because he cares about the poor." I tried to get comments for a local publican on the candidates and had a very hard time getting anyone to give McExxon a positive nod... your polling is a joke. You're not better than Fox and you're Certainly Not News!

MIchelle Douglas   September 11th, 2008 10:09 pm ET

i meant did NOT want MLK DAY.

Jack   September 11th, 2008 10:08 pm ET

I dole out "community service" to probationers daily and remind them it is not punishment but and opportunity to see what it is like to give rather than take from their community. Youth service is almost non existent in suburbia. There are pockets of service – designed by local chambers hosting teen leadership or "mission" work by church youth groups that is essentially helping disadvantaged people. But a comprehensive expectation like what we see in some European countries? In USA it doesn't exist. We're too busy looking backward.
It is time we listen to Thomas Freidman who writes in his new book that we "are no longer in the Post 9-11 world." We are the the Pre- something else world and the sooner the candidates and the fourth estate catch up the sooner USA will stop the slippage. Could it be a pre-alternate fuel and climate era?

jo ann brown   September 11th, 2008 10:08 pm ET

Obama addresses the lobbyist as one of his change proposals.

It appears that there is another group in Washington that bears watching. The negotiators – who are they?

Reading about Sarah Palin, this is what I learned about "The Bridge to Nowhere." November 2005 the negotiators deciding on the 2006 budget decided to change the original earmark 452 million dollars for the bridge to nowhere to a gift to Alaska with no strings attached. This decision was made because they wanted to cut 50 billion dollars from medicaid and foodstamps and they could justify this cut and allow a 452 million dollar bridge to nowhere be built.

Demus   September 11th, 2008 10:08 pm ET

All these polls are just a joke . Its a way to sway the people on there vote. A poll is like the presidental run off you say one thing and do another and these so called polls are not anything in stone if some says yes to McCain on a poll in 2 days they might not see that way anymore but the news will talk about it over and over to down play the presidental person they dont like "Hannity" he cant write one good summary about Obama . Keep it simpel America to much bla bla bla on the news than what we really need to hear or know. Forget the polls forget the Dem, news or Rep, news America do what you know is right dont let these news ppl influince you with there nonsince

Texico From Mexico   September 11th, 2008 10:08 pm ET

What are you taling about William? McCain is th eone who answers nothing at all...just tries to use catch phrases! At least Obama goes into detail

Sen. Barack Obama, it's your time !   September 11th, 2008 10:08 pm ET

The American people are getting a chance to see how great Sen. Obama would be as president of the USA and how great he would be to restore America's image abroad. He will definitely get many votes…many votes !

Eric   September 11th, 2008 10:08 pm ET

The keyword for me is "inspiration". A leader who can inspire me will get my devotion.

I believe Obama is that leader. Barak!! I'm ready to knock on peoples doors on your behalf.

Earnie   September 11th, 2008 10:08 pm ET

I haven't heard McCain give any specifics at all when he talks about what we should do. Just Rhetoric. At least Obama is giving us something.

Adrienne   September 11th, 2008 10:08 pm ET

Barbara, sometimes we can't hear past our own bias.

Carol   September 11th, 2008 10:08 pm ET

Absolutely no comparison between Senator Obama and Senator McCain. Senator Obama is articulate and answers every question
with clear explanation of what he wants to do.
On the other hand Senator McCain is very dull, not really giving any clear idea of what he wants to do.....of course appealing as he always feels he must to "faith based" groups.
Senator Obama is absolutely the right man to run this country, he has all the qualifications, the poise and the intelligence.
This country needs to elect this highly motivated Senator, who inspires that same motivation around the country, then and only then can this country feel proud again.

Snoozi   September 11th, 2008 10:08 pm ET

Paul
As a matter of fact I lost any ounce of respect that I might have had for Guilliani or Palen with those remarks

DEMOCRATS FOR PALIN   September 11th, 2008 10:08 pm ET

I would of preferred to see both Senators McCain and Obama answering questions together at this event.

bill m   September 11th, 2008 10:08 pm ET

"Palin: Sanctions on Russia may be needed "

says it all

EvangelicalForObama   September 11th, 2008 10:08 pm ET

I appreciated the forum of this discussion tonight. I think there will be a time for a debate later on, but I think it's good to just give the candidates a forum to share their views and answer questions like this. Thanks, CNN.

warren pielak   September 11th, 2008 10:07 pm ET

To Candy:

Candy,

I am 42 years old, and have been watching CNN since it's
inception. I am from Canada, and luv American Politics. I
am a news junky, and watch American news and other
American news channels all the time.

You, yes you, Candy, are the best reporter I have ever seen
and listened to. Bar none. You get at the heart of the matter,
and you are brilliant, to say the least. Keep up the good work,
and never forget that you are the best. I know you are a modest
person, and will take my comments with a grain of salt. But I
am quite serious. There is no one better, that I have seen/
listened too, in Canada, or in America. You rock girl! :)

All the best!

Warren :)

Breck from VA   September 11th, 2008 10:07 pm ET

I think McCain needs to tell is what he is going to change. I think he needs to lay out detailed plans rather than rhetoric and empty words of change when his record shows the opposite. I think he needs to explain why trickle down economics have never worked before but will start working if he is President.

truth-Chicago   September 11th, 2008 10:07 pm ET

Bay, you are obviously in the tank with McCain. Bay answer this for me if military service is the ultimate act of service according to McCain, why did he not approve the GI Bill?This is the same bill that he has received $200,000 in pension. As rich as he is, why would he donate this money to help military people. It is ashame when a soldier after serving in military comes home and can't get the help he needs. It so bad that he commits suicide. God!!! Action speak louder than words.

Bay let's get real and stop being in the tank for your party. Be in the tank for people;the people that can't make ends meat t yet they volunteer their church and in their community.

One thing I can must say that McCain is right about this that ordinary citizens volunteer. That translate to that why don't Cindy spend more time. She could volunteer everyday and still won't have to worry about paying for the seven houses they own.

Drow   September 11th, 2008 10:07 pm ET

I WANT MORE CANDY :) !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

David   September 11th, 2008 10:07 pm ET

Did I miss something ? I don't think Mrs. Palin answered Charlie's question on The Bush Doctrine... What is the Bush doctrine anyways? Looks she was totally caught off guard.

Sylvia   September 11th, 2008 10:07 pm ET

CNN, where the is the politcal ticker on what Sarah Palin said on the ABC interview when Gibson asked her about her national security credentials? She answered that her credentials have to do with energy. Why isn't Candy, David G and Gloria B asking, people don't really know Palin? They have been asking this about Obama since the Senator entered the race, why aren't they asking this of Palin?

Estelle   September 11th, 2008 10:07 pm ET

This was the most one sided forum I have ever seen. You both were on the side of Obama. Why was he able to listen to McCain's answers. He was prepared – I certainly hope the two of you will not be available to do the debates. John McCain is an honorable, decent person and deserves to be the President. He has much more experience than Obama.

Ambrosio's dad in Canada   September 11th, 2008 10:07 pm ET

During her interview, Sarah Palin sounded like she was being interviewed for a job at a fast food restaurant.
Unsure, uncertain and uncomfortable is what I got from watching her.
She tried to mould her rehearsed rhetorics to flow in her answers.... and it simply didn't work for me.

WG   September 11th, 2008 10:07 pm ET

McCain has a deeper problems with his VP choice than I thought. SHE DOESN'T KNOW WHAT THE BUSH DOCTRINE IS!!!!!!!!!I -----

Sally from Cali   September 11th, 2008 10:07 pm ET

Please, more candidates talking about issues!!

This was great. Thank you CNN. Thank You Columbia U. Thank you Candy, Roland, Bill, Bay. Thank you Sen. McCain and Sen. Obama!

We must do this again...before Nov 4.

Dan   September 11th, 2008 10:07 pm ET

Why didn't CNN identify the ethnic, gender, etc breakdown of the Republican delegates (like was down during the Democratic delegates)? I think there would have been a BIG difference!!!

Larry   September 11th, 2008 10:07 pm ET

WOW! Let's just break down what Palin said:

1) Russia launched an unprovoked attack on Georgia.
- this is a BLATANT LIE, it is public knowledge that the Georgians attacked South Ossetia and began bombing Tsinkhali in an preemptive unprovoked strike, having in fact bombed the main hospital in the city.

2) War with Russia is an option on the table.
- is Palin diluted or just ignorant beyong comprehension? Have we not forgotten Sarah, that Russia is armed with roughly 5000 nuclear warheads?

It pains me to no end to hear all of this Russia bashing, when in fact Russia is not in anyway an aggressor. In fact, Russia had a duty ensure the peace in the region of South Ossetia, and was following the directive of a UN resolution to restore the peace and ensure the safety of Ossetians (most of whom have Russian citizenship). Also take into account the US's new missile defense system which essentially boxes in the Russians in the west, you begin to understand why the Russians could get upset.
Palin's comments regarding Russia are entirely unfounded and with regards to her proposition on war, is she attempting usher in a dreaded nuclear showdown with the Russians???

Lynn   September 11th, 2008 10:07 pm ET

Palin looked horrible, and was clearly unable to do more than guess, regarding extremely important issues. She OBVIOUSLY did not know what the Bush Doctrine was, and I expect someone running for VP to know this basic doctrine. Palin was a deer in the headlights, then resorted to her typical lip-smacking, and even winked at Charlie during her evasive response, as a manipulative way to throw him off. How utterly and completely tacky.

TLeigh   September 11th, 2008 10:07 pm ET

I totally agree with Frank. The government and the American people should be working in a partnership. This is not the government vs the American people. I have several family members in Irag and Afghanistan and I would like to have them home. Their mission is important but it is also important to recognize that we have a mission here at home too.

I hope that our next president is able to start creating peace....in a humanitarian way. Meaning.... keep the politics out of it and do what is right.

P   September 11th, 2008 10:07 pm ET

Palin is crazy, so she never thought of her family husband, daughters or sons, did not come to mind, being in the postions of possibility of being killed when it came to her decision on where or not to be the VP, now I know she is a total nut case at least spend a day or two on it!

Dwayne Baty   September 11th, 2008 10:07 pm ET

If the question was asked about preemptive strike then that is different that "Bush Doctrine"

Cheryl   September 11th, 2008 10:07 pm ET

I thought Obama did awesome tonight- he is right that young people needs to be continuously inspired to serve their country- I live in a small town in Northern Ontario Canada and my 9 year son has been inspired by the US election campaign- thanks to Obama's extraordinary ability to move people- and to get their attention

what_happened_to_experience   September 11th, 2008 10:06 pm ET

Why is it that mccain was talking all about experience this and experience that for months, then after he saw Hillary's great speech and Obama's pick, he all of a sudden does a 180 and goes with Palin, someone with almost none? And then she has the nerve to also criticize Obama's lack of experience (when she's pretty much in the same boat). Doesn't that seem hypocritical?

MLB   September 11th, 2008 10:06 pm ET

Okay, I'm outta here. There are clearly people here who watched this forum with a very closed mind, and are only blogging here to be jerks and show everyone just how closed minded they are. No wonder the campaigns are so nasty... Not only do we allow it, we're the same way. I don't wish to participate in that.

Art   September 11th, 2008 10:06 pm ET

In response to the question to Obama about jr. officers resigning how can you blame them if NCOs could do that, many would. After 9/11 Pat Tillman and others enlisted by records. This was a call to defend our nation and many felt the military was being used for personal reasons. It seems that tour after tour, has taken its toll. Many have told me you begin to think this maybe this is the tour that I don't come alive.

Sandra   September 11th, 2008 10:06 pm ET

I think it is really sad to see such down standards in the media, particularly the commentators. I've watched faithfully for weeks and since Palin came on the scene, you hardly ever hear the media talking about Obama (unless it something negative) and there is literally nothing on Biden and what he is doing. Come on people, let be fair to the Obama team.

Just like tonight,(I know the hurricane is important) but if Mc Cain-Palin had that interview, Camble and others would have many comments. There is no question who the republican are in the media because there comments and air time is geared towards them. Not much different than Christ Matthews !

Last thing, the people of American need to wake up! What kind of person would put their 4 month old baby on hold for a campaign? What kind of mother would be on the campaign tail instead of spending time with their son who is about to be deployed?

I know many are saying you wouldn't say that if it were a man, Well you are right, but it is a given that when a mother has a baby that she will be there for that child if no one else is. She will put here children before ourselves.

democrat   September 11th, 2008 10:06 pm ET

Its a McCain night for sure. Obama has lost his touch. I hear when Obama went to see the troops in Afga. he didn't say much at all to them but instead played baketball and was more interested in getting his picture taken for the people back home. I think we democrats would have done better with Clinton. So its McCain for me.....

sunmoonstars   September 11th, 2008 10:06 pm ET

thank you seth u took the words right out of my mouth!!!!!! but why hasnt 1 of these silly reporters called him out on it? another thing i kept hearing obama say tonight is "yes & i think mccain is right".

Jacob   September 11th, 2008 10:06 pm ET

I wish CNN would focus more on the REAL criminals that caused 9/11, as well as focus more on the LIES that they helped report to get us into Iraq.

Paris   September 11th, 2008 10:06 pm ET

Frank thank you.

You get it.

Thank you

Drow   September 11th, 2008 10:06 pm ET

EHY DON'T WE SEE ALOT MORE OF CANDY... I LOVE YORU OBJECTIVITY AND INSIGHT

Louis   September 11th, 2008 10:06 pm ET

I joined the Marines in 1980, The only thing I knew at the time was to fight. Now middle age I find it hard to find a new place to serve.

I would rather serve under Obama than McCain.

Obama is awesome !   September 11th, 2008 10:06 pm ET

Sen. Obama is best qualified to be our next president. He is smart, wise and uses good judgment. His policies are the right solutions that the American people need at this defining moment in history. McCain votes with Bush 90% of the time. I choose not to take a 10% chance on change. The REAL change that this world needs can only come from Sen. Obama.

John of Southampton   September 11th, 2008 10:05 pm ET

Does anyone have a comment about how the pollsters are getting there data? Many adults between the ages of 18 and 30 only have cell phones and not land lines (home telephones), which means that the polls may be missing out on the younger voters.

Lou   September 11th, 2008 10:05 pm ET

When is the media going to ask Obama if he is ready to be president and why?

When is the media going to begin to do a little research on Biden's past?

Barbara   September 11th, 2008 10:05 pm ET

I think Typical white person gets it. Mandatory community service is not volunteerism. This is a principal of Socialism and complete government control with the promise of something later... that most of the times never comes. The opportunities our country offers which is what makes it original, special and different is what males it exceptional, and if the government was to control everything and have he government mandate what you MUST do and give back to your country is NOT FREEDOM, and it is NOT what this country was founded on.

anonymousONE   September 11th, 2008 10:05 pm ET

The earnings of the American workforce undergird the efforts of our valiant soldiers who protect our rights and freedoms. Domestic employment and military service are complimentary, one would not exist or would lose purpose without the other. Neither is more important, but leaving your 2 yr old to go into harm's way is usually the more difficult path.

darby   September 11th, 2008 10:05 pm ET

It is amazing to me how people can listen to something like this and then come away with completely different impressions of what they have heard. Louis L'Amour said, "Nobody is ever convinced by argument...They just think up new reasons for maintaining old positions and become more defensive."

Heather   September 11th, 2008 10:05 pm ET

Amen to that BeBe!

CM   September 11th, 2008 10:05 pm ET

Obama hit it on the head tonight. We need to all get together to pull this country out of the hole the GOP has dug for us. McCain seemed more content to turf all service besides military over to the private sector.

Becca   September 11th, 2008 10:05 pm ET

Sen. McCain has served his country well, and we respedct and appreciate him for that.... He as 25+ yrs in the senate...but, it is not just the years of military service or years in Washington that qualiy you for the presidency. There is all sorts of experience that might prepare you to be president. More presidents than not, did not have military experience, including the current commander-in chief. A presidency is not and "earned" position. It is up to the American people to decide based upon a candidate's varied experience, world view, knowledge, temperment, and leadership qualities, whether or not that candidate is ready to be president.

Robert   September 11th, 2008 10:05 pm ET

On the CNN web-site, why is it that you only show a photo of Obama and you only quote Obama in the headline, but not John McCain? Is it because you are "fair and impartial?"

D. Alexander   September 11th, 2008 10:04 pm ET

Since John McCain answers questions so well, can he honestly answer why he lied about being divorced from his first wife (noted in his book) along with all his other "hidden scandals?" He sure didn't put "Country First" when he cheated on his first wife with old dope head Cindy!!!

If the Obama camp wanted to play dirty politics, all they have to do is watch CNN's Revealed . The great war hero didn't have a problem cheating on his first wife. His only response was, "I take full responsiblity for my actions." Oh, and don't forget about rich Cindy who was stealing prescription drugs from and charity organization that she was suppose to be working for (but instead getting high)!

McCain should be glad that Mr. Obama is running a clean campaign. I would have a field day on this clown!!!

D. Alexander

Paris   September 11th, 2008 10:04 pm ET

Barbara:
Obama is for socialism at his core.
What he has learned is to how cover it with his Harvard degree.

Vince   September 11th, 2008 10:04 pm ET

Palin is a Trojan Moose. 4 more years of Cheney style VP Politics.
I remember my days of CO in Brooklyn NYC working with the local schools to build playgrounds. I was deeply insulted by her demeaning comments about people who take their own personal time to work at bettering their community.

Bonnie   September 11th, 2008 10:04 pm ET

Silas, Who raised you? Sounds like you still have some growing up to do.

axt113   September 11th, 2008 10:04 pm ET

This is economies of scale, the government has the scale

Keith   September 11th, 2008 10:04 pm ET

So much for not talking politics, I think this is the perfect day to meet with Clinton and then afterwards go to the school that I graduated from and have a fair and balanced discussion.

The only thing Obama did today was promoted is his campaign.

Adrienne   September 11th, 2008 10:04 pm ET

"Overall Obama is presenting more thoughtful, detailed, and innovative ways of service."

"I sat through Saddleback too — Obama seems much more at ease here. More direct, less meandering."

I 100% agree with you both hear. good insight.

kristin   September 11th, 2008 10:04 pm ET

Obama once again said about his grandfather serving but yet records show that his grandfather Dunham signed up 6 months after June 18, 1942. And also in his book Dreams of My Father he said his grandfather nerver fought. So did he or didn't he.? He had an advantage of where it was tonite. but it was nothing new they said. I would have like to know when he said he thougt about joining the service so why didn't he ? Also the comment he made on ABc's This Week last Sunday about saying "His muslim faith, and repeated it and George Stephanopolis correct him and said your christian faith. You tube pulled it. He looked confused. what was that all about? He needs more time , he is not ready . He says that McCain agreed with Bush 90 % of the times well he agreed with the dems 97 of the time.

PJS Stillwater, MN   September 11th, 2008 10:04 pm ET

The line that I will remember is in McCain's response to the question about what would he do as president for college grads who want to do service but have so much debt they can't afford it.

McCain's nonsensical response included "the busiest people are the busiest people." What does that mean?!?

Irma   September 11th, 2008 10:04 pm ET

Obama, you inspire me!!!! What a wonderful concept, joining hands to help our country, even us senior citizens. I would do it under your leadership, of course!!!!!

You are the inteligent, articulate, gentleman we need as a leader!!!!
I know we will become a better country with you as our President.

YOU HAVE MY VOTE

Adam   September 11th, 2008 10:04 pm ET

we do not need to have bad terms with Russia. This is a new age of peace and prosperity and we are being left behind. The past 8 years we been held or even surpressed from this prosperse times. We need to be on good terms with everyone and join in with the new ages.

we also need a president that can work a computer.... it is the INFORMATION AGE

Obama 08

William Dalton   September 11th, 2008 10:04 pm ET

Adrienne- You have to be kidding! Obama uses his 'change' platform to answer every question as possible, rarely giving a definitive answer. For example, where does he plan to pay for this universal healthcare? How does his plans for education actually help failing schools? To these and other questions, Obama has hid behind his transparent shield of change, avoiding real plan making.

Larry   September 11th, 2008 10:04 pm ET

Until EVERYONE admits they need to clear thier head, put down their prejudice (whatever that might be), forget what they heard in the media and on the internet, then focus on the facts...AFTER, they serve a week with habitat for humanity or the red cross helping hurricane victims, nothing is ever going to change. We better get it right or we are going to suffer the consequences.

Javone   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

William, please stop blowing smoke. Obama made his background known...period! THEY decided to re introduce that information in a horribly negative way. It matters not what someone thinks of it...it is noble and deserves respect!

Cam   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

I am disappointed that McCain chose to go on the offensive rather than be honest about the attacks by palin and Guliani. That showed me a person who is not willing to be accountable or "change" anything. He can't even change his own people, how would he suddenly change governement?

M   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

Vik, have you not heard Sarah "Puppet" Plain's repetitive speech? She uses it all of the time, and I bet you I can recite some of the lines by now. Obama has many fantastic, bright, new, promising ideas for this country. Please open your ears and your heart.

robert   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

barbara–this is the US not Cuba...Wake Up. Open your mind to intellectual thoughts..

Go Senator Obama!

Drake   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

Why is it that McCain claims that his time in the POW camp taught him to not be selfish, but he came home from the camp and cheated on his handicapped/ill wife with a "girl" in her early 20's.

While McCain is quick to say "Country First," what about putting one's "Family responsibility First!"

Heather   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

I remember working along side my father doing communtiy service ! I loved it! It gave me happiness to know that I was helppinga family out who had so little. I do believe communtiy service is needed in fact in my old school district we hada160 hours of communtiy service that was required to graduate. I believe that it should be a requirement to graduate but not so many hours.

Eleanor   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

The worst thing about this whole election year is the unfair media coverage. The black analyst have nothing bad to say about Obama even though it's clear he doesn't have the experience and he wants to cut his teeth in the white house. Then there's the attacks on Palin. Both parties said that they would bring change, but how is attacking the other party change. Lipstick on a pig? Is that something that a presidential candidate should say? What does that say about his judgement? I don't get it.

Barack Obama IS Our 44th president!   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

McCain sounds like Bush, he leaves many unanswered questions in the minds of the American people.

Sen. Obama answered his questions remarkably. It was a fantastic night for him.

BeBe   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

If there ever was a time for community service, now is it! The sad, shameful truth is that our children who live in poverty would suffer greatly without local food banks, non-profit health organizations, etc & the self-sacrificing people who donate their time & energy. Our priority should be to focus on serving our own communities–not that we shouldn't help others around the world, but if we don't help our own people, how can we even begin to justify it beyond our borders?

Jeff Gregory   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

Will Americans actually recognize before Election Day that if John McCain is such an "agent of change" he's had nearly 3 decades to use his alleged power and influence to make change in the area of energy independence, making quality healthcare affordable for all citizens and forcing our wealthiest citizens to pay their fair share of taxes? In these and so many other areas, John McCain's idea of change appears to be more of the same.

Independent Voter   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

My vote goes to obama.. more sense than mc cain.

Im worried about our 6% unemployment rate
Budget Deficit, High food price, Weak dollars, Foreclosure. I think about my kids future if they will be able get new jobs. I see the big difference 8 yrs ago.

scott webster   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

didn't president bush promise to shake up washington? Look what we got from that Republician

Jeff in Los Angeles   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

By the way, I went to Iraq and Afghanistan in 2006 and 2007, in a band playing for the troops. It was my way to give back to the soldiers, who are protecting this country. It felt so good to know I was making a difference in someones life. Giving back, whether it be donating clothes, helping put people back to work or find a home, tutor a child after school, or yes, even going to play music for the troops, and get their mind off of the war for a few hours makes you feel GOOD. Obama seems to get it, and McCain doesn't.

sarai   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

Go Obama! You did well and did not evade questions or talk soundbites like your old grandpa.

KM   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

Good lord. Mayors fill potholes, trim trees and make sure the garbage is taken away? There he goes again....

MIchelle Douglas   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

How do McCain feel about civil rights. Remember he did want MLK a holiday. He told the folks in on MLK anniversary that he was sorry. It took him 40 years to admit he was wrong. Wow is that the kind of president that we want. Takes 40 years to admit that he was wrong.

john   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

Obama is under polling because they are not counting all the black people who will be voting and young people Obama wins easily

john   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

I think senator Obama did very well

Catherine   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

Service is a good thing, and why I understand the need for it, I think mandatory service is a bad idea. I for one don't want to have to serve in the millitary especially with the George W. Bush experience. I've learned the hard way. We might get another president who will think he is smarter than every one else and enter into another holy war.
I have always have a lot of respect for people who go into public service but this year is the first time that I was actually motivated to do it and Barack Obama was my motivation. All John McCain has done is make me feel as if I'm selfish for not joining the military. All his talk of being a POW is getting weary, I wonder if hadn't been a POW, would he have anything to campaign about.

roberta   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

Sen Obama is on the right track we have to look to the future 21 century our young people are our future we have to make our country strong education our young there has to be a change. I am 62 year old and I have been inspired to serve I will . Thank you Sen Obama

Ramesh   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

America needs a leader who inspires, removes our dependency on oil and focus on alternative fueling.

Ever since Obama spoke about, less TV for children, reduce energy.

I have initiated a movememt within my company and home by making sure we turn off our laptops, once a week work from home, stop my children from watching TV and playing computer games.

You need a leader whose ideas can inspire and motivate people in the right direction.

When I see McCain, I see him as a great person who helped and served our country. He is definitely a great person. My heat too goes out for him when I see him on stage.

Definitely Obama needs to consider him as a security advisor or defense secretary when he comes to power. Likewise, McCain needs to consider Obama for his energy policies and continue to motivate people in the right direction.

At least for now, I am definitely convinced that Obama will win this election. He will definitely cause a big change to our country like what President Clinton did.

Ol' Bob   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

There has never been and there is not now any shortage of opportunities for young and old to participate in meaningful and valuable community service.

Rotary played a major in eradicating polio, worldwide. That is just one example, many other community service organizations are doing similar work.

Organizations such as Rotary, Kiwanis, Civitan, and many others, including colleges and universities are sponsoring thousands of student international exchange programs.

The government is not the answer, it is the problem in promoting community service and international understanding on the individual level, which is where it counts.

Jeff   September 11th, 2008 10:03 pm ET

Given how the mainstream media has been pimping for the Democrats for so long, isnt it amazing that the McCain campaign has been able to get its message out there to the point where they are in a dead heat? Amazing, I think... the silent majority kicks the media elite in the behind again.

David   September 11th, 2008 10:02 pm ET

I just want to say for all of you people who are looking for the poll that had Obama up on the military vote. If you are having a hard time finding it in the left wing media, chances are its not that accurate. Also, keep in mind that unless you poll the whole military all of these little polls that these groups do are meaningless. Oh and if your friend is mixing politics with his military career he's not a real soldier anyways.

Leah DiMarco, Texas   September 11th, 2008 10:02 pm ET

William Dalton – Yes, Palin and Giulianni MOCKED 'community organizers' during their speeches at the Republican convention.

patsy in iowa   September 11th, 2008 10:02 pm ET

I don't know how anyone could choose McCain over Obama after seeing them both in action tonight.

Eliza Willis   September 11th, 2008 10:02 pm ET

Babe Buchanan knows that Palin did not recognize what the Bush Doctrine is. Sorry Babe, but the Bush Doctrine means something very specific just like the Monroe Doctrine and the Reagan Doctrine do. The problem with Palin is not that she doesn't have experience. The problem is that she does not possess the most basic knowledge about public affairs beyond the limited world of Alaska state and local government.

Al   September 11th, 2008 10:02 pm ET

Barbara, were you not listening? He specifically answered the questions with implementable detail. Give me a break, seriously.

Heather   September 11th, 2008 10:02 pm ET

I remember working along side my father doing communtiy service ! I loved it! It gave me happiness to know that I was helppinga family out who had so little. I do believe communtiy service is needed in fact in my old school district we hada160 hours of communtiy service that was required to graduate.

Shamara Funches   September 11th, 2008 10:02 pm ET

Bay, She really did not know what the bush doctrine was?

sai c   September 11th, 2008 10:02 pm ET

Roland, Obama did not answer the question that the Democrats are belittleling the town mayors when you say its not experience. I remember you started the talked that talk that the Republicans are doing it to community organizers after Palins speech.

Heartlight 3, Maui, HI   September 11th, 2008 10:02 pm ET

Someone please tell John McCain that one of the big things we as voters would like to see changed about Washington is the meanness and nastiness of presidential campaigns. Obama has been trying to demonstrate that change, but it's hard when the other campaign insists on taking it as low as possible.

Derrick   September 11th, 2008 10:02 pm ET

why palin

Texico From Mexico   September 11th, 2008 10:02 pm ET

McCain broke the cardinal rule. You never ever hang a fellow vet out to dry over his military record if its honorable. What McCain did to John Kerry 4 years ago by backing the swiftboaters was a disgrace to this nation. You may not agree in politics but you never attack a fellow vets war record, especially one who went to Vietnam as was wounded.

mn   September 11th, 2008 10:02 pm ET

after her interview, she needs a dictionary! how possibly she doesnt know BUSH DOCTRINE? too bad jhony angel wasnt there!

jordan, sc   September 11th, 2008 10:02 pm ET

In your segment reviewing the sarah palin interview, the former republican campaign manager of mitt romney said "obama suggested taking this to the un security council where russia has veto power" at the end of the segment.

why isn't anyone calling her out and saying that mccain said the exact same thing live on CNN cameras??? it was on the jon stewart show of all places, he replayed mccain quoting it. the hypocrasy of this "expert republican" is absolutely astounding...

Frank in Augusta   September 11th, 2008 10:02 pm ET

I disagree with Bill Schneider's comment about Democrats, and Obama wanting the government to be a source of inspiration. the source of inspiration should be individual citizens who take that into government.

JMT   September 11th, 2008 10:02 pm ET

I have to get this in quickly. I thought Palin was awful tonight with Charlie Gibson. She seemed as though she was following a script and if Charlie pushed her too hard then she would emphasis her script by making it seem as if getting a pitch higher would make her sound understandable. I watched the Obama and McCain forum and if people really listened to the true issues and responses, instead of being sidetracked by silly non-issues, Obama would be much further ahead. Although I don't believe in Polls.

New Yorkers for Clinton   September 11th, 2008 10:02 pm ET

Regarding your editorial you posted yesterday, does everyone now agree that Obama made a huge mistake by not asking Hillary to be on the ticket? 18 million votes and all of his brilliant backers couldn't see as the editorial highlighted that McCain of course would come out with such a surprise–Palin is energizing the party and impacting the independents decision to vote McCain. Shame Obama didn't see this coming.

mamanomia   September 11th, 2008 10:02 pm ET

I am really hearing an Imperialist style of hyperbole from both McCain his running mate..It scares the bjeebees out of me...What are we to become if being the world's police is the goal...So much to be done within the borders...building up the citizens through education, jobs and a strong economy is primary to anything we hope to attain outside of our borders.

Bridget McCurry   September 11th, 2008 10:01 pm ET

Silas, Obama doesn't plan to force, but provide incentives, like college tuition.

Dana   September 11th, 2008 10:01 pm ET

I listen. I listen to every side. When I became a public school teacher (16 years, now), I became a democrat (for painfully obvious reasons), whereas before I only followed the directives of my very Republican father. He was a Goldwater Boy. I was his daughter– and didn't know squat on my own.

Tonight, I listened again. Tonight, the forum, for the most part, was a good one.

Advice to the Obama campaign (not that I'm an expert. I would never pretend to be . . . but . . . ") : The Republicans will parse your answer to the "health care" question about civilian/volunteer service to the country. The question from Judy Woodruff concerned whether your adminstration would provide the same health care benefits (as provided to the military) for those "others" who "serve" our country. You intimated that you would not. You intimated that there were "degrees of service."

How do you reconcile your answer tonight with your commitment to universal health care? These things are connected. .Did you mean what you said?

While I will still vote for you, the GOP will use this against you and I wonder how you will address this particular contradiction when some enterprising GOP intern is smart enough to call you on your blunder (or Anderson or Wolf or Chris, et al).

I have a feeling that the Dems are going to mess this up . . . all over again.

Dana L. Davenport
Douglas, GA

Diane   September 11th, 2008 10:01 pm ET

Have to admit that McCain did a decent job this evening, but he should be thrown out of the republican party for dissing them and Pres. Bush.
Who is he trying to impress anyways–some of the American people who may not realize what really is going on with him and his "swift boating" of Obama. Obama responded more precisely with the questions and didn't meander like McCain.

huh   September 11th, 2008 10:01 pm ET

GO,,,,, Lesser of the two evils...

manchild   September 11th, 2008 10:01 pm ET

Its like McCain thinks he is owed the presidency because he
got captured and was a prisoner of war. He and Palin are playing
a brilliant game,but it will not work. They discuss everything but
they're agenda for us Americans for the next 4 or 8 years. I cannot
afford another 4 or 8 years of this same old...washington...
high gas,food prices,energy prices etc. And you all are fools if
you let this emperor and his new clothes back in the white house.
I want a debate on the issues of Americans...our economy
etc.

Laura   September 11th, 2008 10:01 pm ET

Why no Democratic Strategist to offset Bay B. who is just a spokesperson for McCain?

FAIRNESS

Cheryl   September 11th, 2008 10:01 pm ET

I honestly don't think these types of forums will help people who are undecided. What i do think that will be the ultimate thing that makes people decide is the people on the ground knocking on the doors, making the phone calls, the precint captains on election day and all the other volunteers. Obama has the people, gawd do we know we have the people, and McCain you never see pounding the pavements. So keep focused and maybe someone can report on what happens behind the scenes and in the field.

MaryAnn   September 11th, 2008 10:01 pm ET

Obama is a breath of fresh air. We need a change. America can not afford a republican repeat.

jean from fort lauderdale   September 11th, 2008 10:01 pm ET

Did you see the interview with Sarah Palin and Charlie Gibson? She
just showed America how far out of her league she really is. Those
scripted responses had George Bush written all over them. Even the
pronunciation of "nukuler". Hopefully, next time she will be better prepared.

San Diego Moon   September 11th, 2008 10:01 pm ET

QUESTION FOR ROLAND, CANDY OR BILL ABOUT POLLS:

The media keeps reporting on the even split in the polls. It strikes me as odd that what we don't hear about very often is how far ahead Obama is in the projected electoral count–which is what matters right?

Isn't it true that Obama is really leading this race by a more than comfortable margin?

Kathy   September 11th, 2008 10:01 pm ET

Tell me this is a joke! This woman isn't ready for this position. I can not believe how she stumbled all over the ABC interview.

Jan   September 11th, 2008 10:00 pm ET

I wonder if Palin and McCain use the same "coach" because they both used the words "inalienable rights" in their interviews today. You know, you don't get to hear those words everyday....and McCain said them twice tonight in the forum and Palin once (so far) with Charlie Gibson. Did you see her dance around the fact that she had NO CLUE what the Bush Doctrine was???
If McCain knows exactly how to get Bin Laden (he brags every speech) then what is he waiting for? Isn't it his duty to tell the people who could go and get him?

Obama-Biden 2008 and 2012   September 11th, 2008 10:00 pm ET

Many people are getting a chance to see how great Sen. Obama would be as president. He will get many votes...many votes !

Roger   September 11th, 2008 10:00 pm ET

Why would Judy Woodruff bother to give McCain's answers to the questions to Obama, since undoubtedly he was allowed to listen to McCain's interview? Was that fair, or biased?

Do you really think Obama would have been ready to answer the ROTC question had he not heard it in advance?

heather4Obama   September 11th, 2008 10:00 pm ET

Bay Bay Bay you are not reporting fair....you just see red and swear it is blue...you wont even say it is crimson...come on Bay get a reality check...you make my eyeballs hurt from rolling...Come on be honest.

Denise   September 11th, 2008 10:00 pm ET

I pay not attention to the foolishness the media keeps broadcasting over and over again. Lipstick on a Pig...please, those who keep harping on this need to see the whole speech before jumping on the Plain defense wagon. I am concerned about the FACTS and our country is in a whole log of trouble. The facts on of our countries, economics, our nations security here at home more so that abroad, as well as how we as a nation is perceived abroad, education, civil rights for all people, government spending and the trillions of debt we are in, the housing crisis, plus some...the true issues. A candidate should be chosen based on how they stand on these issues not on how they look, how old or young they are and especially not based on their race and or their religious affiliation. RELIGION HAS NO PLASE IN GOVERMENT...hence the separation of Church and state. I think the GOP and the Evangelicals have forgotten that or maybe the thing Americans are stupid and will not notice. When a candidate spouts their religious beliefs as a major part of how they make their decisions to govern us (Americans), we all should perk up and get scared...can we say Iraq and the Iraq war. Not to say that being spiritual is not good thing I am very spiritual but not everyone in this country feels the same way religiously or worships in the same way. Our president needs to govern based on the whole country which is made up of many different people and religions. Our country was founded on the basis that all men should have the ability to worship as they pleased but it seems that the GOP have sided with the Evangelical Right and feel they can manage my religious life better than I can. Govern based on the many not just the few.

Angelique Louis   September 11th, 2008 10:00 pm ET

Thank you, Thank you, Thank you!!! This forum, during this day, reminded my of why I served in the Army for 20 years, why I am serving our government today and why tomorrow I am going to go out and find a way to serve my community. To see two very special individuals talk about their experience in serving our country and how they plan to have people once again find a way to serve our great country, whether through federal service or community service was wonderful.

There was a question posed about a President that inspired people to go out and serve their country and I believe both candidates missed one really important President – Franklin D. Roosevelt. The government stepped in during the era of depress and put the American people to work to build the infrastructure we have today. When WW2 occured, the government asked people to sacrifice and they did. Children help they parents build victory gardens so that our servicemen had food. Their sugar and other food goods were rationed. They bought US bonds to help fund the war. Hollywood stars did tours to entertain our servicemen. Business restructure so that they could build airplanes and warships. Women went to work in the factories there husband who went to war used to work at.

That generation and the revolutionary genration is and was one of our nations the finest!!!!

Janice Il   September 11th, 2008 10:00 pm ET

Obama talks to much when asked a question, on and on by the time he is done you forget what the question was. Yes , no not in his vocabulary. To much Bull.

Jim - VA   September 11th, 2008 10:00 pm ET

Bring back the draft! Three years mandatory service for everyone – starting with the quals for the Oval Office, Senate, Congress, etc.etc.etc.

By the way – Obama started his young life as a Muslim. If you don't think so, stay in Disneyland.

Undecided Independant "American" vet – no pathetic derivative, sensitive, "you owe me" person.

VRM   September 11th, 2008 10:00 pm ET

For a lot of people, the conventions and the subsequent reports on them were the first time they were introduced to the candidates. I think that the Republicans were ill advised to use snarky cracks at community service as Palin's hello to the world.

David   September 11th, 2008 10:00 pm ET

Leah, the venue didn't offer the opportunity for "mud-slinging." Needless to say, there's been plenty so far and more to come during the 50+ days.

Mike   September 11th, 2008 10:00 pm ET

It appeared Obama had all the questions since he didn't studder in his answers. After reading the blogs, not all military are for Obama only ones who won't read about each person's history of service. For those in uniform and those who are not, World War I and II, Korea, Vietnam were all entered in while the Democrats were in office. Republicans watch included Granada, Gulf War and Iraq and Afganistan. In Obama's forum, how are we going to pay for everyone's College? There goes our taxes and bigger government.

truethat   September 11th, 2008 10:00 pm ET

women always ask for equal rights and never expect the consiquences, investigation will come, false comments will come, you are to show you are able to take it. remove your sensitivity, and accept equality.

the mc mcain is the worse i have seen. i have never heard so much of the same thing, which mor i hear it sounds worse and the lies,

mc cain is the candidate of change, changing his mind, was it not exprience e was running on?

Paul Gillham   September 11th, 2008 10:00 pm ET

Leah, no, like you I appreciate a serious, civil debate. I just thought the whole subject was a joke. The President is involved in so many important issues. Making sure the Salvation Army's doors are still open is way down on the list.

Patricia   September 11th, 2008 10:00 pm ET

Obama appeared to me to be somewhat tense. He gave a decent speech and I give him credit for that, however, I am still not comfortable with the idea that someone who has very little experience could running this Great Nation. Especially not at this very transitional time.
Good show Obama.
I'm voting for McCain this time around.

Barbara   September 11th, 2008 10:00 pm ET

At the end of the day, Obama really didn't answer any questions. He blabbed on and on about bigger government control on everything, specially in the seeing how it can motivate people to serve in order to get a perk like free college. Speak to the Cubans and they will tell you about the fundamental changes Castro spoke about and meant to do, and look at what they got.

michael   September 11th, 2008 10:00 pm ET

instead of the pole which chandidate would you rather drink a beer with ask the question which candidate would you rather smoke a joint with
thats a question ill awnser

Adrienne   September 11th, 2008 10:00 pm ET

McCain talks in simple mind catch phrases. Obama goes deeper with and explains actual paths to his plans.

Keith   September 11th, 2008 10:00 pm ET

The media does not want civil just watched the all the cable networks like Fox it's like waiting to be brainwashed by these entertainers which they seem more than reporters and they have no problems lying right to your face. Republics are the worst like they learned straight out of the Bush doctrines liar liar.

Patty Veselka   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

Obama..shows humanity by including all...his knowledge is incredible....his even demeanor is so wonderful in contrast to the last 8 years..he gets that real people do extraordinary things!!

Earnie   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

I feel censored. It is okay. It is what I have come to expect from the media these days. All sensationalism and reality stuff. No substance or hard questions. Can't blame a citizen for trying. I miss the time when Journalists were journalists!

MB   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

I have been on the fence with this election. But the more I think about Palin disrespecting community service and claiming that she turned down the bridge to nowhere when she really didn't, the more I think it will be hard to vote for that ticket. At least Obama doesn't seem as mean-spirited.

William Dalton   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

Mike- Palin and Guiliani never condemned or denigrated community organizers. They merely noted that it really is not political, executive, or frankly even relevant experience, and cannot be marked as such.

Chris from Va   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

there are too many mis-informed people here! Have you heard an unscripted Obama? Every other word out of his mouth was uhhhh. Please tell me what he has done for his country and state! Nothing. Dick Durbin does the work while Obama campaigns! Then so he doesn't get kicked out of the party like Lieberman and kicked to the curb like Hillary he give Obama credit for the work! The 90% absentee voting is a FACT!!!

Demus   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

I have been listing to these two men talk about our military and what would they do to keep ppl in the military. Well If I was the Pres. this is what I would do for the FULL military ppl : FREE HEALTH CARE , FREE HOUSING [on base] NO TAXES [at all] also they would get better pay after four years of service they would get $80,000 to 100,000 a yr. The military ppl give up all there rights just to serve us and to keep the mother land safe for us all. Also the big companies [tabacoo] would take half of there profits and put it to health care / cancer research. Also the Oil companies would take half of there profits and put it to fixing our roads, highways, bridges. WE NEED A NEW PARTY called the Party of the People.

oldblogger   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

The best team is McCain and Palin.
They tell the truth
They do not say Uh,Uh,Uh.
Sarah did an excellent job on her press interview.
I would trust her and certainly
Candidate for President, McCain.

vanessa   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

McCain did not spell out how his philosophy of change and national service would look in terms of government initiatives, programs, or support.

On the other hand, Obama was specific. There is a proverb that says, "without a vision, the people perish." He laid out a clear vision. One under which this country will prosper. And it will, in my opinion, go a lot further to strengthen our security against outsiders who try to cause us harm.

Vernon C. Rucks   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

Senator McCain says his derisiveness towards Senator Obama because he didn't agree to the town hall debates. And that is why his ads have been going negative. Will some body point out how childish of a response that is? Isn't it like, I am throwing bricks at your house because you won't play with me.

jay   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

psychobabble!!!!!!!

Ben   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

I wish politicians were not so... professional, you know? I do not know where we are going with this business in Pakistan and Georgia, with Putin and Chavez, and of course with the Iranians as well.

Since I do not know where this is all going, and because it is so difficult to know what any politician might do to win an election, I am at a loss as to what to think about this election.

Can we still see all the angles? We should remember the end of Carlito's Way, when you fail to see all the angles. It seems like so very much is happening. Can we resurrect Teddy Roosevelt or something?

Don Melton   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

Bay,,,, what you mean is: that this forum ,,, you hope wont change a vote. I take a lot of issue with your single issue thinking,, I have watched you and your brother for years.. Based on what I hear from both of you its always about the life issue,,, it always goes to that issue ,, except for "protecting" your pro-life candiate at all costs.

Carole   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

McCain somehow manages to bring up his POW experience no matter what the question posed. I was, however; very surprised by his response on foreigners coming in to the U.S. on Student Visas. I'm not an Isolationist. However, if I'm not mistaken, the pilots who flew those planes into the WTC and the Pentagon on 9/11 came into the U.S. on Student Visas and learned to fly at a flight school in Florida. The problem with these So-called Student Visas is, this is a very large country-once they're here, they can be anywhere.

Beth   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

This forum was really interesting, and I loved the comments from the analysts as it went along.

The bottom line for me is that Obama speaks from the heart, is real, and I believe with every ounce of my being that he cares about this country and the people in it. And while I'm sure McCain has just as much love for this country and the people...I just don't feel like he has the "big picture", like Obama does.

I was a Clinton supporter, but more than that...I am a Democrat. Obama has my vote and full support.

And Roland...you're amazing! I love your idea of a year of trying to make a difference. What a wonderful place this would be if we ALL did that. Kudos to you!

Beth – Altus, OK

Maureen   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

I work at Wesleyan University where Obama gave the commencement speech in May; the entire speech was prodding the graduates to commit to service to their community, state, or country. It was extremely moving.

Tom from NJ   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

I guess Bill Schneider can't identify three of Mr. Obama's accomplishments that clearly define his ability to lead. That's not a problem; neither can Obama's Campaign Manager.

As for Ron; Get a life. I would not go around saying I to be a liberal and Republicans think it's about them, them, them! You are wrong Ron! When was the last time you gave to a charitable organization, when was the last time you sent a package to someone you have never met that's serving in the Afghanistan and Iraq theaters of war?

I doubt if the thought ever crossed your mind Ron because you are a liberal and onlt think about you, you, you!

Franky   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

You want some advice on 9/11?? Do good!!! Be nice!!! Be respectful!! And most importantly, be honest!!!! Read a book, write a letter, visit your girlfriend, etc. Do good deeds. It doesn't have to be today or tomorrow or the day after, be nice to people...our country deserves better...

And by the way, I do good things so don't think I'm all talk!! LOL!! I do have a lot(I mean, A LOT) friends, so...LOL!! I walk the talk baby!! LOL!!

Take care guys...

jackiefu   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

Is the demo motto "be right and Lose"?
You people don't understand the American voter proclivity for the underdog/abused/ media repressed/ position/candidate.
The more Palin is abased, the more votes you are delivering to the GOP.
I can't believe no one in the Obama/Islama/bin laden party doesn't get this....Thank God...or Allah...whatever delivers victory in November.

PARTY LOYALIST   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

I wish Obama was the President in 2000. I voluntereed in Americorp, Peace Corps, and the Watts Labor Community Action Committee (WLCAC). I probably would have done a lot more if I felt the government would have given financial incentive.

Now I'm going in to debt attending law school. Obama's hands-on approach to making America a better place is exactly like mines. And I'm going to keep working to create a better society. But man it would be nice if there the government was more supportive.

Ajspeak   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

I think the candidates (and Obama is my pick) should be talking about the 'so what' for each of the issues- so that people 'get it' about why any of these things matter
-securing healthcare coverage for kids and uninsured- what that means to those who already have it: lower premiums overall because taqxpayers and those are are insured are not funding the freecare pool
-shoring up the economy- so that our national security is ensured, foreign interests won't be the only ones who can buy US real estate,
-getting out of Iraq- so fewer of our servicemen die needlessly, so we can spend the money at home and avoid tax increases, and have money to fund education which is vital to our future
-change in Washington- so that insiders and friends of the powerful will not be able to get rich, run the economy into the ground, and leave the taxpayers to pick up the tab
they need to be giving the answer to 'so what' on each of their planks.

John   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

Somebody should have told Sarah Palin what the Bush doctrine is? Maybe she should have called me.

andrea, NY, NY   September 11th, 2008 9:59 pm ET

Is Mrs Palin willing to to go to war with Russia for Georgia? That is madness. Georgia was the aggresor. If we follow American foreign policy since Wilson's 14 points of 1918, the two separatist provinces deserve their independence from Georgia. May be there should be plebicites in both.
A war with Russia will be nuclear. That will mean the end of civilization as we know it and, perhaps, the extintion of life on the planet.
US foreign policy needs a reality check: WE NEED THE COOPERATION OF RUSSIA – BETTER: THE FRIENDSHIP OF RUSSIA

Brian from Ontario, Canada   September 11th, 2008 9:58 pm ET

From a Canadian perspective, I have often admired Americans' sense of civic duty and service that we, sadly, sometimes lack. However, I hope that my American friends will one day regard "the government" as less of a threat and more of a tool (a limited one at that) to accomplish things that individuals cannot.

Senator Obama appears poised to make a positive difference through limited government, which I hope folks embrace - rather than vote against their collective interests. However, as an outsider I am sure you will collectively choose what is best for your nation.

Whatever the choice, we will still be your great friend and northern neighbour (except for Alaska!)

Cheers,
Brian, Windsor, Ontario

jody odonnell   September 11th, 2008 9:58 pm ET

Both the candidates are missing the point: America needs real leadership to restore our democracy, civic discourse and the idea that people have to compromise to accomplish anything. Our country is continuing to split over the cultural issues the politicians serve up like so many hot-potato volleyballs. Let's show the world why the United States is a great nation rather than just telling everyone all the time.

axt113   September 11th, 2008 9:58 pm ET

Obama came out and proved why he is ready to be president, McCain proved why he should stay a senator

Cam   September 11th, 2008 9:58 pm ET

I would love to see many more of these types of forums (although with talk about all the other issues indivdually, ie. economy, energy, -war, etc.

John Illinois   September 11th, 2008 9:58 pm ET

I have to laugh at these people saying Obama "inspires" them so much. How does a guy that hasn't accomplished anything as a state legislator or as an absentee senator and says absolutely nothing as our state of Illinois collapses economically and educationally due to the total corruption of his Democrat Machine party inspire anyone? I don't get it.

MLB   September 11th, 2008 9:58 pm ET

When I was young, my father insisted I do community work (volunteering at YMCA, various things through church). Sometimes it was frustrating, but the truth is I liked it... and more importantly, I learned from it. I think mandatory service is a great idea! Many young people don't realize how rewarding service is until they're confronted with it... How else will they know?

Interested   September 11th, 2008 9:58 pm ET

I think the best line from Obama campaign right now would be, Joe Biden saying,

"John McCain wants to be our next president & I say, Thanks, but No thanks."

This would be like stealing reps own line & if it catches up it will give Joe Biden the much required air-time....

DEBBIE   September 11th, 2008 9:58 pm ET

AMERICAN PEOPLE PLEASE WAKE UP LETS FOCUS ON THE ISSUES GO TO CSPAN AND LISTEN TO THE RIDICOLUS PEOPLE CALLING IN WE NEED TO GET THIS WRIGHT. LETS BE HONEST AND NEUTRAL REMEMBER THE WEALTHY DON'T HAVE TO WORRY.
THANK YOU

Mo   September 11th, 2008 9:58 pm ET

Better to sound tired than to be tired.

Jane   September 11th, 2008 9:58 pm ET

Ever since John McCain chose Sarah Palin as his running mate, the political landscape has been sliding downhill like a mudslide. Talk about a smear campaign. John McCain who used to stand above other Republicans in his refusal to fight dirty has thrown himself willingly into the mud. He was one of the few Republicans who could, and did, set aside bipartisan politics. It is disheartening to see a once respected Senator lower hiimself to Rove-ian methods. As for Sarah Palin – I am dumbfounded at the number of people who are willing to vote for her without really knowing anything about her. I question why she and McCain are hiding her from the media and the public except for carefully staged settings. What is she hiding? Since McCain has put her in the position of being a potential President of the United States, it is irresponsible to allow her to dodge tough questions.

Typical White Person   September 11th, 2008 9:58 pm ET

There are many groups – non-governmental – for kids to learn to serve their community and their country.

Problem is, the left tries to dismantle them! Take the Boy Scouts...the left can't stand to have a non-religious kid just tolerate the oath to God and country. They are suing the uniforms off of these kids. Girl Scouts, recreation programs that incorporate volunteerism.

Community service for school credit or money is not volunteerism.

Veronica Petchak   September 11th, 2008 9:58 pm ET

Hey what happen to the money we gve her for the bridge? I hope it fixed some roads.

Sean   September 11th, 2008 9:58 pm ET

So then this forum was basically like the Faith one? Because that didn't seem to change anything either.

Bianca   September 11th, 2008 9:58 pm ET

Thank you president Obama.

FreeNLovIt   September 11th, 2008 9:58 pm ET

God help us! We're all going to need it. I see an inspired Democrat and an individualistic Republican.

Jake   September 11th, 2008 9:58 pm ET

Seth – Why can't Republicans tolerate nuance? It seems like, going back to Kerry, Democrats have been labeled "effete" and "wishy washy." Those tactics simply won't hold up in '08, Obama is a much more powerful orator.

I do remember a President, a rather recent one in fact, who preferred looking at things as black and white, win or lose. Never danced around anything but burning brush. I can't recall, however, how that turned out for the country.

Jeff in Los Angeles   September 11th, 2008 9:58 pm ET

McCain said he admirers Obama's service as a community organizer, and tried to say it was OK for Sarah Palin to attack him because he was attacking her as a mayor of a small city. The way she attacked him was sarcastic and demeaning. Obama was never demeaning in his account of her being the mayor of a small town. McCain said nothing about Guiliani laughing at Obama's community service record. The bottom line is, this was John McCain's convention. He controls the message and the tone. He can say all he wants tonight about giving Obama kudos for his community work, but the message and tone of Guiliani and Palin's remarks at the convention speak the truth.

robert   September 11th, 2008 9:58 pm ET

Headline will read 5 Nov 08:

"President Obama"

God Bless America

Tell the truth   September 11th, 2008 9:57 pm ET

Bill

Obama's answers appear to be far more specific than McCain's.

What new? Obama has always been more specific than McCain's. You guys are telling the truth on this blog. Try telling the truth on TV

Sharon   September 11th, 2008 9:57 pm ET

Why was Obama just cut off early???

jazz   September 11th, 2008 9:57 pm ET

This is our opportunity young, old, men, women, black, white hispanics, asian etc... lets get toguether and vote for barack obama. It will be a big mistake to vote for John Mccaine and now its even more dangerous with sarah palin wich has no foreign policy experience and no brain, I saw her speakin at the new interview and she sounds like she learned all the scrip!

Blair for Illinois   September 11th, 2008 9:57 pm ET

This is my first time blogging and this will be my last with CNN. Everyone of the commentaries are so in love with anyone but McCain that they don't see all sides.. PLus nothing get posted, I guess if it doesn't fit their agenda, then it doesn't get posted. Thank god for the Bill Oreilly interview or no one would know how Obama about thinks. Glad he admitted the surge was successful..

Kibo   September 11th, 2008 9:57 pm ET

"Somebody watched the tape and learned something."

It sure would be nice to have a President who learned from their mistakes, rather than insisting that they're correct no matter how many fact checkers call something a lie.

scott   September 11th, 2008 9:57 pm ET

It's a shame that the political Right keeps latching onto Obama's words and phrases and either tries to claim them (McCain's new mantra for "Change" or the statement that "Washington is broken") or tries to twist them into something inappropriate (the "lipstick on a pig" misdirection, which became another non-story in the media spotlight). Republicans need to embrace the community spirit instead of the dog-eat-dog mentality.

Tonight's forum on CNN was actually refreshing in that I got to hear McCain speak without too much rhetoric–although he fell back into it often. And I got to hear Obama discuss the how-to aspects of what might be implemented if he becomes President. I will be voting with my conscience as always, but so far Obama has given the most thoughtful answers and inspires the most optimism in regaining the America I want to live in.

Janie   September 11th, 2008 9:57 pm ET

How can Obama inspire young people to join the military when he never served in the military himself? How was he able to say this with a straight face? He is all smoke and mirrors.

TLeigh   September 11th, 2008 9:57 pm ET

First, this is probably the most important election we might see (depending). What I am fascinated with is the lack of that insistance to make a stand and name the top 3 necessary changes that need to be made in the US. Neither candidate has really put their foot down what is on their agenda. They get asked questions about this and that and they end up answering in a noncommitted manner. You can't take that seriously. Where is the strength!

bray   September 11th, 2008 9:57 pm ET

Where did Bay go? Republicans are always outnumbered on the CNN site. wonder why?

Michael Smith   September 11th, 2008 9:57 pm ET

The Palin-McCain ticket scares me to death!

Tanya   September 11th, 2008 9:57 pm ET

I'm with you Snoozi. I took great offense to Palin's comments about Comm Org's.......I don't take it lightly.

Paris   September 11th, 2008 9:57 pm ET

This will not change anyone's mind.

Sarah B   September 11th, 2008 9:57 pm ET

Obama is a breath of fresh air compared to what we have endured the last almost 8 years and compared with the old white haired dude.
This country cannot stand another 4 years under McSame!

Jim   September 11th, 2008 9:57 pm ET

What is the Obama record of change in his home state and especially in Chicago?

"average" american   September 11th, 2008 9:57 pm ET

Roland Martin – define "average American." I just heard you on t.v., in reference to remarks made by Sarah Palin re: NATO – you said the average American is now asking "what is NATO?" Just how stupid do you think we are? I am an average American and I of course know what NATO is and what the premise is behind this alliance. You are such a SNOB and have no idea what the average American is about. Do you think the Average American is illiterate and dumb?

Deborah Walker   September 11th, 2008 9:57 pm ET

I see the America I want to believe in in Senator Obama 's vision AND I am working triple time to help achieve that vision of America. I don't see myself in the America that the Republicans describe. In fact, the rhetoric of McCain/Palin and the Republican strategists scare me badly. Their ways of being evoke "base fear" and I don't want to contribute to that fear. I'd rather fight for "hope" of another way of being as a country, in the spirit of John F. Kennedy, Martin Luther King, Jr., Robert Kennedy AND all of those who fought and died on America's soil as well as the soils of other countries to have the UNITED STATES of AMERICA operate as "one" and as an inclusive nation. Obama and Biden, "stay the course"........keep on insipiring us to be better, to be the best we can be as a nation!!!

Jim K   September 11th, 2008 9:57 pm ET

.........and if McCain "knows that he'll get Bin Laden," then WHY is he keeping it a secret until he's elected?

Sherry, Atlanta   September 11th, 2008 9:57 pm ET

PALIN'S INTERVIEW, AS WELL AS MCCAIN'S INTERVIEW. . . .ENOUGH!

NEITHER KNOW WHAT'S GOING ON IN AMERICA-OR THE WORLD!!!

Frank   September 11th, 2008 9:56 pm ET

It's funny how much everyone on here is whining and crying like a bunch of babies over Sarah Palin. She has little experience, granted, but she's running as V.P., not like the unqualified Obama that's running for President. Both are unqualified, but thank goodness one will have 8 years to mentor as V.P. instead of trying to jump right into the role.

The saddest part of all this is to listen to Roland Martin defend him because he's black. How else can you justify putting someone in the White House with so little qualifications. Fanboys for Obama, get a clue.

Kate, NV   September 11th, 2008 9:56 pm ET

BK- we can afford all these programs because Obama wants to turn financial responsibility back to Ira

Anonymous   September 11th, 2008 9:56 pm ET

This was the most one sided forum I have ever seen. You just gave Obama the right to discuss all his mistakes. Why was he able to listen to the answers from McCain. He stated several times that he listened to McCain. I hope the two of you will have no input in the debates coming up.

rlkidd   September 11th, 2008 9:56 pm ET

Sorry , I can't vote for Sen Obama, I like the way he comes across, but,
I believe that a lot of his early experiences will guide his future policies.

I do not believe that he is a muslim, but his formative years exposed to this religion will continue to guide his actions.

I am just not willing to take the chance with him.

Bob   September 11th, 2008 9:56 pm ET

I have been a lifelong democrat (age 42). This year I considered (strongly) voting for McCain because I believe that he truly isn't a right wing nut job. However, by pandering to the right wing fringe with his selection of Pallin, I have no choice but to vote for Obama. The selection of Pallin is offensive. It shows that McCain is no different than others in that he cares more about getting elected than the country. Given his age and the tremendous ageing effects of the presidency the Pallin selection is irresponsible. Shame on you John McCain!

Today Pallin felt war with Russia could be considered. Are you kidding? She went to school (college) where/ and to how many. Give me a break. This country needs to grow up and elect leaders with intellect.

Leah DiMarco, Texas   September 11th, 2008 9:56 pm ET

Perhaps Paul thinks it was a snoozefest because he is like so many other Americans that want to see politicians fighting with each other all the time? It was nice to see civility on the TV this evening and no mud-slinging.

Tracy   September 11th, 2008 9:56 pm ET

I think it is important to note that the only reason the presidential race is so close is simply because Barack Obama is black. I am amazed that many (not all) white people would rather vote for 4 to 8 more years of Bush policies (war–McCain's career was built on it and Sarah Palin supports it), very little diplomacy, trillions in debt, high unemplyment, astronimcal gas prices, etc. Racism truly is a disease. It is sick.

Melanie   September 11th, 2008 9:56 pm ET

To watch John McCain and then to watch Barack Obama should make it so easy for the American people to see who really has what it takes to bring this country together and fix what is wrong. It was so great to watch Sen. Obama, he gets it, he has it, he is going to be our next President! Just look at what Bill Clinton said today.
Thanks for hearing me,
Melanie

Art   September 11th, 2008 9:56 pm ET

I have never seen a VP nomined who is unknown and yet so quick to accept the nomination only to be sheltered from the media. With the poor selection he had to choose from it's no wonder he turned to someone nobody knew but with the information that is turning up, I think it's going to hurt his chances!

Chris   September 11th, 2008 9:56 pm ET

john September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET
"Obama never answers any questions. Mccain is better."

Seriously!?!?!?!? I heard some greant ideas about national service from both candidates today, but the best idea I heard all day was Obama's idea to give college scholarships for those who earn it through volunteering.

Yawdie   September 11th, 2008 9:56 pm ET

Just a question: Why is it that the republican strategists are surprised when Sen. McCain stays awake?

"McCain looks strong and energetic" – Republican strategist, Bay Buchanan.

David   September 11th, 2008 9:56 pm ET

I am a young husband, father of two children and very much a family man. I have a very difficult time understanding why a mother of a special need child who is helplessly 4 months old for God's sake will choose to make her priority money, power, and prestege well over her precious son who needs her more now than he will ever need her in his life. Has Mrs. Palin ever given an explanation as to why she would make such a selfish choice? Mrs. Palin should really have process this bate carefully and not allow herself to be used by Senator Mc Cain like Mr. Powell was used by Mr. Bush.

Douglas   September 11th, 2008 9:56 pm ET

Bring back the Draft,when Mccain Served there was a draft and he loves to focus on his time served ,so he should'nt have a problem bringing back the draft.

Sarahkatheryn   September 11th, 2008 9:56 pm ET

Vik, I don't think BO pandered – his whole campaign is about service and inspiring americans to serve hence his line "we are the ones we've been waiting for"

Shannon - Independent Voter   September 11th, 2008 9:56 pm ET

I think palin is a warmonger also, either that or she is simply following the repub script of "scare the voters with war talk so we can win". These people are truly, truly pathetic. They are desperately trying to hold on to the power.

The only thing that is really, really scaring me is the thought of them in the white house for another term. As a matter of fact I am downright frightened.

Paris   September 11th, 2008 9:56 pm ET

Obama seem to be very proud of this nation today.

You would think with all this great things about America Michelle Obama would be proud!!!!

charles in cincinnati   September 11th, 2008 9:56 pm ET

question: why do you have a "republican strategist" on the boards here but not a democrat...or independent? bay obviously can't overcome her bias and be objective, so why not even up the teams?

R.Sanford   September 11th, 2008 9:56 pm ET

Tonight after watching the Palin interview I'm convinced that the only reason she was chosen was to get women votes. Palin is not prepared to become President if McCain was unable to lead. McCain voted with Bush 90% of the time & Palin can't seem to effectively answer a question. I will vote for Obama he's qualified & ready to lead.

Edward in Fort Worth,Tx   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

I want to know why all I've been hearing about for the past 48 hours is "lipstick on a pig"? Do you think perhaps the media can get back to the real issues most people care about?

Manny   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

I still hear people saying that Obama needs to reach them or convince them to vote for him... how come I don't here people saying such things about Mccain. Its as if he needs to be perfect or people will just vote for Mccain. How can people say they just don't know Obama.. never before have we had this long of time in regards to debates- over 20 in all. People have had much shorter time to pick a president. The toll on this man should be taken underconsideration. He is still here after that of Clinton and we all know Mccain had months of time off and got the jump on campagning for president. In addition, are people forgetting who funded all the campaigns. Why is no one having issues with all the people that work for Mccain that serve special interest before that of ours. Those were not fans in the front rows... but that of lobbyiest... and what about that fact that Mccain uses Bushes speach writer. Just venting.. thanks

Jeff   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

Both candidates did a wonderful job getting out their talking points. Eight years of lunacy from Bush with the prospect of another four from McCain don't sit well with me.

Hey, I didn't know Georgia and Ukraine were in NATO. What did I miss?

Why can't the media ask and press for real answers to their questions? Both candidates need to be held to a higher standard!

Chris from Va   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

Feeling good about people is great, but having to support others is not my job! I work HARD for my money RON the proud liberal. You try having 40% come out of your check and speak the same then. That is what your party wants to maintain and increase! No thank you!

Mike   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

Snoozi perhaps now you know how community organizers felt when the riotous laughter broke out at the RNC after Guiliani and Palin's slams.

Matt P   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

What I would like to know is why people continue to miss the boat on the GOP considering itself the "Christian Right". We have McCain, who had multiple affairs on his first wife (including with his current wife) and, according to his daughter, dated a stripper. On the other hand, we have a VP candidate who was pregnant when she got married. They both hate liberals (exactly the opposite of Jesus's "love thy neighbor") and are against the environment (the opposite of God's command on the sixth day to take care of the plants and animals. We've also Rudy Giuliani and Newt Gingrich, a couple of other multiple-affair guys. Why do people keep believing that the GOP is the "Christian party"?

I WANT THE TRUTH   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

palin did not even know what Charlie was talking about. She needs to stop.

Q   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

Also, why did they specifically ask McCain if he thinks we are better than other countries TWO TIMES? Then, when Obama says we are the best country in the world, they don't press him on it ???

Dexter   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

Hey! Snoozi..chill dude. Get some tough skin. We as Americans have the right to disagree and just because it's with McCain does not matter!

GOP for obama   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

YES WE CAN!!! now i remember why i am an intern for his campaign!! for a min sara palin got me worried, i thought i should go into the lipstick buisness. BUT IM CONFIDENT I CHOSE THE RIGHT GUY. OBAMA 08

Jenny   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

I am an independent voter. I was going to vote for McCain before he picked Palin. With McCain age and health history his choice of VP is crucial. I do not undestand why he picked somebody with so little experience. There are other more qualified female republician choices he could have gone with. Almost everything Palin came out with in her speech have been shown to be half-truths. Examples of these are "bridge to nowhere" ,dealing with corruption in Alaska, and putting the plane on ebay. I also think her family is signicant issue giving the age of her children and her effectiveness in doing her job. I also think it says something that she is not giving any hard hitting interview yet. If she is not ready to be candiate then maybe she should drop out.

John Jon   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

Roland Martin, I am a Canadian white male who greatly admires and respects your opinions. I have one question. Do you think this rece will be so close or do you think Obama will win by a landslide?

Audrey   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

john – maybe you're not listening. do you not understand him? maybe you need a dictionary!

William Dalton   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

Bill Schnieder- Thank you for the clarification, and I agree. I only think this will make people more conscience of the election.

Don T.   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

Ron,

Why don't you be a bleeding heart Constitutionalist? Both parties will end up doing the same thing – big government. John Quincy Adams said that even if you're the only vote for an issue, if it is done by principle, then you will never lose that vote and you can cherish it. Stop voting for the lesser of two evils – vote for principles you can agree with – our Constitution.

Paul Gillham   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

Snoozi, I am no scorning your service. Quite the contrary I laud your service. But the President of the United States is not the President of the United Way. They have many, many more pressing issues to deal with.

Toni   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

I dont know what to think why wont the hard questions be asked Im dissapointed again I took time out to watch another info commercial.
Listen 19 years ago my sister serving in the army brought her 6month old home for me to watch because she was on call to go to Irqa 19 years later my brother who served in the first and now the second gulf war is retiring and its still going on and now the child I took care of is now in the Mariens I want dam answers on What is going to be done so this doesnt happen again I want to know if im going to be able to afford to buy gas I want to know what is going to be done to make going green affordable I want to know a lot of things would someone in the media get some guts and find out please

Charlie Lea   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

What matters in this election is not whether Sarah Palin intelligently answered Charlie Gibson's questions. What matters is how the uniformed voters, many of which couldn't answer or understand the questions any better than her, perceived she did.
Politics is all perception.

Timothy Morton   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

Very interesting threads. I will be very keen to watch what I can and/or find out more about the forum. I'm pleased to hear of detailed plans from Obama.

Is it possible that Palin doesn't know about the Bush Doctrine (see her ABC interview today)?

Abed   September 11th, 2008 9:55 pm ET

Obama's plan brining home the troops is great, but I hope he has a plan helping them find a job, if we are to send lets say 45,000 troops to afganistan and 100,000 come home thats another a lot of people coming home with out jobs I think Obama could use them to build a Green Army use their skills to help make this country go green it would be a nice transition as well as open more jobs. Right?

Jose   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

Republican's don't care to please anyone but their base, that's not a way to rule

Tina   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

Candy if there were more people like you, the world could be a better place.

I voulunteered for Katrina & it was the most rewarding experience ever. Taught me to keep my feet on the ground & think twice when complaining. When we go through bad moments that's when you understand how much we need each other. Democrats, republicans, rich, and poor. The reality is that we are only human beings.

Taff Gafoor   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

Two major reasons that have influenced the diminished level of service in this country are

(1) Corporate America, through downsizing, reengineering, and outsourcing, have made the American worker less loyal to their employers who even demanded more hours of work and responsibilities of their employees.

(2) The lack of confidence in our leadership in the Whitehouse which seems to want to go to war for any and all reason. Young men and women just are not going to risk their lives when they have no sense of loyalty and leadership in the Whitehouse.

Senator Obama is the candidate who can inspire the nation back into service. Unfortunately, people like Gov. Palin and May Giulanni who mock community service do not help either.

ObamaSuks   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

mcain/palin08 BABY

I WANT THE TRUTH   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

John what are you smoking over there? You are delusional. Okay Obama never answers questions? Get it together and turn around and tell McCain that he did poorly in comparison to Obama. you have to be on the inside to say that.

David   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

I eagerly await the debated – Presidential and VP. Americans need more substance from both candidates. These "sound bite" sessions aren't providing the needed information for most to make a decision.

Paul Gilligan   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

Obama expressed a view that the American people have the need, desire and willingness to take on the responsibility of public service. Service to our Nation needs to be cultivated but first they must be asked and I believe they will respond. This is the right view at the right time in our Nation

jazz   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

I dont know what the media says but Obama is surely going to be a bright president with new and fresh ideas, that will inspire millions of young people to be better and will take our country where it never has been before.

Edward   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

Too bad nobody asked McCain how he plans to wage a war on Russia, but I guess he would have to be out of the picture for the cocky wacko from Wasilla to lauch this war. There's the McCain foreign policy model war first collect the facts later.

Deborah in Scottsdale, AZ   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

McCain's thoughts about nongovernment service organizations is currently what happens regularly. Situations occur in people's lives where they don't get up from the governmental groups and start their own search and research what they need to do about an illness, a disaster, etc., and if it weren't for those organizations and outreach to the community to help other Americans, there would be no improvement in New Orleans, Mississippi. They have yet to solve those problems and they the government failed them. Obama did community service without the aid of government so why would we need to downplay either of their positions on community service?

bq   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

Having listened carefully to both McCain tonight and Palin's interview, I'd feel secure with either being on the receiving end of the dreaded 3AM call.

david   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

RON??????? GO TO CHURCH.

jay-jay   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

Obama did a good job. He remains true to his principals. He is a proud democrat. He believe goverment is not the solution but it is necessary to open opportunities for the people...Unfortunately..Americans are too racist.....to see that

Janice in the mountains   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

CNN commentators – thanks for your wise words and comments. I appreciate your efforts!

Sarahkatheryn   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

RE: Candy Crowley "why do they stay in the senate"

good benefits?

EJ   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

why? because you say so bill? who appointed you and your collegues the arbiters of what will make a difference on the dynamics of the campaign. You folks have been wrong so far.

Bill Hodges   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

Candidates have mentioned service – why can't we get out welfare recepients (those that are able), to previde some form of service in exchange for their welfare? In addition to their contribution, it may also provide them with training and connections for gainful employment

Great thought but do you really think those that could would actually do something for the FREE Goverment check! Don't hold your breath waiting for that to happen. They will just cry discrinmination and slave laboe, and that applies to all races so don't call my comment racist because it is not just the truth.

Jonny   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

i think that the next president is going to win by the votes in the peninsula of banana

VA voter   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

Is the media going to pickup on the fairness of having Obama listen in on McCain's part or is that part of the media bias that will get overlooked?

Guess by not moderating this query is the answer

Stevenson   September 11th, 2008 9:54 pm ET

The world is waiting to love America again but not with MCsame. China is waiting to lead the world but with Mcsame it will come earlier then we thought because with McCain and Palin we go back to the fifty's.

P   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

McCain basically said that we are slaves to the country that we live in, I know one thing I am not a slave to any country, and if that means that we have to fight and die to prove to McCain that the America people are not slave to this country called America!

We are free McCain not Slaves to America this country does not own us!

ill1   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

maverik someone who says one thing and does something totally different

David- TX   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

One thing people should recognize is that the military is not the only way people can serve the country even though it might be the most important

Typical White Person   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

Ya, with a 50% dropout rate in schools, and a large percentage of graduates functionally illiterate, they really should be forced to pick up litter as a graduation requirement.

yeesh

Bev   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

Oh, one more thing ... if McCain knows how to change Washington, why hasn't he done it yet?

My biggest complaint with this forum? The moderators didn't ask follow-up questions. There were so many opportunities, but they just let 'em slide right by. Nor did they press either candidate to actually answer the question posted. (For example, when queried about the RNC and Palin's shocking attitudes towards Obama's community service, not once did he condemn those behaviors, but he never answered the actual question, and nobody pressed him to. C'mon, Judy, you know what to do; DO it.)

Kristina   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

I'm afraid Obama may get lost in the details at times...does anyone else notice this? He is articulate, but the details are not his prospective job.

Strategy, big-picture, good listener, personal confidence, decisiveness, delegation, etc.

These are qualities I think I'm hearing in McCain more. His understanding of leadership seems more practically learned than Obama's. Obama seems to well-versed in the principles of leadership...but the practical application...I'm just not comfortable.

Kristina,
Michigan

Independent in NC   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

I appreciate supporting community service, however, all the good intentions in the world are not going to change anything until people want to change things for themselves. And most people do not want to do that; they want someone else to fix it for them.

Todd   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

Bill, you summed it up perfectly. Liberals will like what Obama said, conservatives will side with McCain. It was basically one long commercial for each.

furmande   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

Once again Obama does not have the courage to call out memebers of his own party who are out of line...Rep Cohen. It shows the continued ignorance of our politicians. I will not call them leaders because few of them lead...they only fall in line and try to talk a good game. Please stop talking and have the back bone.

Sasha   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

Obama just can't answer a question directly. *yawn* Get to the point already!

roberto   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

this forum is going to help to start this race get back to the issues. ooops what is sarah palin going to do?

Shannon   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

Roland, excellent suggestion about a petition. I will definitely look into that.

Jan in MI   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

I totally agree with YESSIR......Obama is very inspiring, and I also want to do what I can to help our country.

I am ashamed to say that I have been to busy caught up in the ups and downs of my own life....and my childrens lives.....I care about things, but have never acted before.

Go OBAMA /BIDEN 08

ron   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

Its funny how people se waht they want to see! Open your mind and set it free!

Firefly   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

It looks that way, Palin seems to have more camera time then McCain...she is always with her. if you were not following the trail, you would think – She is running for president.

"HOW FUNNY IT WOULD BE IF PEOPLE DEMAND SHE BE THE PRASIDENT. :-) "

Texico From Mexico   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

Did you know that JFK is the only President that donated his entire salary to charity? I have this feeling the Mr. Obama will too. This man inspires people.

Heather   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

I'll admit Obama has good ideas and so does McCain so where do we find the balance people? I'm only 17 years old and I am already tired of the same old Republican and Democrat routine where they bash each others heads in until America decides which one is the better "fighter."

Pam   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

John, I'm not sure what answer you wanted to hear because Obama answered in detail all that was asked of him. Perhaps McCain appeals to your short attention span.

Damisi   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

National service should be mandatory... namely service in the military. When these "arm-chair patriots" with flags on their trucks talk about how Obama and the democrats are weak on terrorism, it gets to me. Many of these critics never served in the military.

The point of mandatory service is not to reinforce the idea of free will, it is to achieve the aggregate goal of EVERYONE contributing to help each other. If this policy were implemented, maybe the our countries citizens will begin to consider other people's realities, instead of just their own.

David   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

I still want to know if "community service" for Obama included a stint with ACORN, which has settled in a lawsuit over voter fraud. Even if it's an internet rumor, it deserves to be addressed in the same way rumors about Palin have been addressed.

I'd also like to hear Obama talk about it himself, because he seems to do a great job responding to these kinds of things.

Snoozi   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

Maybe Paul thinks it is a snoozefest for people because he has no interest in service. I, for one, do have an interest and I am serving and I don't take it lightly when others scorn that service

Paul   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

I could just see McCain and conservatives trying to shrink government down to nothing.
"I'm running for president so that one day we wont even need a president anymore".

Sherri   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

McCain-Palin = DRAFT

Vik   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

Look. The bottom line is both are going to talk about the need for service in a forum that professes that. Having said that, I thought McCain came across as very service minded and sincere in his answers, and Obama I thought pandered and was preachy.
The truth however is that both have served the country in their own capacities one as a man who sacrificed his body for the country and another his time as a community organizer.
So as far as I can tell, Obama is beginning to look tired and repetitive. His hope message is getting old and not resonating as it used to. I don't know why this is, but he seems he is out of it lately.
I believe Sarah Palin has done to Obama, what Obama so successfully did to Hillary. Who is this new person trying to unseat ME syndrome.

Caroline   September 11th, 2008 9:53 pm ET

What I get from McCain (and people on this forum): you want to serve our country? Join the military. It's better. You're more "noble".

What I got from Obama: you want to serve our country? There are any number of ways–choose the one that's best suited to your talents and strengths.

I'm a teacher of English, but after hearing Obama speak, I'm interested in retraining to serve in a more necessary area, like math. I'm spurred to take action. Watching McCain I felt like maybe I should just step aside and let the private sector and "faith-based charities" do all the service for me. Hey. Why don't we privatize the military if they can do it so much better than we?

Caroline

LeaAnn   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

I hope that the American people will open their eyes and see that Barak Obama is the change that our country needs right now. Sarah Palin is a fresh face in the political scene, however not at this time is she ready to hold this high of an office,I am sure her time will come. The time is not now to risk the chances of our future to fall in her hands. She has got a bright future and maybe someday it will be Hillary Clinton vs Sarah Palin.

M   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

Obama is such an inspiration to us all. We NEED him as our president! God Bless Obama and God Bless America!

Karl Rove sucks   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

mc cain is karl rove puppy

MLB   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

John,

How can you say Obama never answers any questions? Did you watch the forum? Obama was specific regarding many of his ideas, and he answered the questions directly.

Yawdie   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

OBAMA really, really inspires me. I heard him talk tonight about a corps of volunteers working with veterans to help the get back to their lives in their communities. That is something that I would definitely want to be a part of.

Go Roland!!!!!!!

Dave-o, Honolulu HI   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

Why don't you talking heads ask some questions with some meat instead of the softball questions you ask perpetuating the myth of the liberal media. The truth appears to be that you are pushing the Republican agenda and the Bush Tax cuts because if you do the math, Obamas tax plan would increase most of the talking heads on cnn and fox and every other media outlet. Come on guys ask the real questions of Palin. She flip flopped on the "bridge to no where" only when it was clear that Congress and the rest of America was outraged. She didn't oppose it. She was the queen of pork that most Governors are. Come on. What state governor isn't pushing their congressional delegations to bring home the pork. If the lipstick fits...

I gotta say that the Republicans are remarkably "thin skinned" about comments in the media. If Sarah Palin is offended by the lipstick on a pig remark...that's nothing compared to the "swift boat" lies that the Republicans perpetuated as if it were true.

Come on Candy and Wolfie...ask the real questions and stop trying to change this election.

Silas Dogood   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

Mandatory community service... Great way to teach kids to get involved. Force them into doing something, rather than lighting the path and showing them the value of a strong community and sense of civic pride.

Educate. Be a role model. Don't force it down their throats because you don't know how to raise children to be adults.

Danielle   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

Would I pay more taxes if I knew that I would be covered if I got sick....

YES!

Would I pay more taxes if I knew my children wouldn't have to pay loans thirty years after graduating from college?....

YES!

Would I pay taxes if my country actually took care of me in my old age and cared about the families and children living in this country instead of taking my tax dollars and bailing out companies who fail but still have enough money to give tens of millions in bonuses???

Thats a no brainer. YES!!

Will someone ask the question why did the government shot down the notion of bailing out homeowners but jumped at the opportunity to bail out Bear Sterns and Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae.

O.C.   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

Am I the only one who is really outraged by the McCain campaign ad which claims Obama wants kindergarten students to be taught comprehensive sex education? This was a complete distortion of the facts and a new low particularly because it involves children and stokes false fears. I can't imagine why the media is letting that ad slide.

Nicole in Ga   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

I think this is where the focus needs to stay. We are too caught up in Palin, forgetting that the main deal is ultimately between Obama and McCain. I mean, how often have we heard from Cheney during the Bush administration ?

John   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

I like the forum idea, maybe a fact check forum would be appropriate. I think both candidates need to be held accountable for their misleading and sometimes completely false statements and attacks. I think both candidates need to explain their tactics to the American public however I think Mr. McCain would have far more explaining to do.

virginia   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

obama can answer any question ask without even thinking as McCain does. Obama has a plan and it really sounds like something we have needed in a long time.

Jeff Gregory   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

Tonight, watching Sarah Palin speak with Charlie Gibson was a REAL eye opener. No longer does a question exist in my mind about her foreign policy experience - because she has NONE. Her ignorance as to the definition and scope of the Bush Doctrine, her insability to answer even the most simplistic question about her personal philosphy about U.S. foreign policy...and more...has convinced me the John McCain's first major decision (of selecting Palin) was the debacle for the ages.

Tracy   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

I think it is important to note that the only reason the presidential race is so close is simply because Barack Obama is white. I am amzed that many (not all) white people would rather vote for 4 to 8 more years of Bush policies (war–McCain's career was built on it and Sarah Palin supports it), very little diplomacy, trillions in debt, high unemplyment, astronimcal gas prices, etc. Racism truly is a disease. It is sick.

Sarah- ARIZONA   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

Obama rocked it.

He is the only candidate for president that can truly inspire the young to serve this beautiful country.

Mcain can't do it.

Obama has already began to do it with his campaign.

Reagan   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

I am glad to hear some people are finally inspired to volunteer due to Obama's comments. The rest of us are tired of holding our communities together. Maybe that will be the one thing Obama accomplishes since it won't be as President.

Kibo   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

The problem with asking for a civil campaign based on the issues is that whichever campaign is behind on the issues will only have two choices: create distractions and use gimmicks or lose.

McCain has been clear that he will seek victory at all costs, both in Iraq and in politics, even if I don't think we can afford 4 more years.

Brad S. in Knoxville, TN   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

I am a middle of the road in political terms, and I think that if I had to give grades based on tonights forum on service that:
Obama gets an A+
McCain gets a C
Score this forum for Obama and give him a four to six point bump in the polls in the next week!

Tanya   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

John, you can't be watching the same forum the rest of us are watching......why am I not surprised, some people NEVER get it!!!

Nathan   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

Obama's a good guy, very personable and inspiring. But that doesn't mean he's the -right- guy. He can tell me about the BILLIONS in spending he wants to -add- to our budget after he fixes the budget to where we have those billions to spend without going further into debt – but it's something I don't see him talking about and frankly, don't think he understands how big of an issue our nations debt is. A few tax increases on the rich won't pay for all the programs he wants to start.

laurie   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

It was so great to see Obama again on message and displaying his leadership role/style. OBAMA '08! With all the publicity coverage this past 1-2 weeks, the real facts/issues have been so diluted. If only we could have more days like today where silly season is silenced. Laurie (Centerville, Ohio)

jazz   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

Obama was better than mccain, I think mccain looked just like jorge bush answering questions, everything is a joke to them. When people are loosing their homes, and food is so expensive!

Kirk   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

Candy,

The treatment of McCain's military record by Obama, and almost all other democrats, has been overwhelmingly positive. When compared to the unsubstantiated attacks that John Kerry was forced to endure about his military service during the 2004 election, the key difference between the election strategies between the two political parties becomes evident. I can only hope that this election, unlike the last, will not be decided based on partisan attacks.

Esencia09   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

I don't trust a man who seeks to equate himself with a messianic figure. Messiah's are called to make the ultimate sacrifice for humanity which is to give up their own life. If this is the case, Obama should give up running for President and join the priesthood.

Saad, NJ   September 11th, 2008 9:52 pm ET

Both candidates spoke very nicely regarding our military… but I wish they would for once slip in some plan and strategy to make this world a rather more peaceful place. If their plan works, we will have no need to increase our military and considering inflation, continue to increase the funding for our military.

I know all of teh above is wishful thinking but hey… I am asking to slip that only once… afterall, we are the country rest of the world looks up to and listens to…. or at least used to!!!

amle   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

McCain is an inspiration. Obama never served his country in the military. Oh yeah, he hates the military and what they stand for.

mike   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

Now is the time for the Democrats, center/left independents and liberal Republicans to mobilize. No more sitting back waiting for someone else to speak up for you! Obama has a chance of losing to McCain/Palin. Actually, losing to Sarah Palin.

This is no joke, no American Idol gaffe, but the real deal – our beloved nation is at stake.

We've got to kick it into gear, because the right has got their game face on and they are playing the media very well. Sarah Palin has the look, the sound-bites, the attitude down like a made-for-TV movie (yes, that's exactly what it's looking like...just like Matt Damon recently said...only a bad movie).

Come on everyone. Tell your neighbors you care about who gets elected, and while it's a nice story that a soccer mom can become president of the United States, I honestly don't want a "pitbull with lipstick" in the Oval Office.

No more Bush policies. Let's try something different, and better, for a real change – Palin/McCain sure aren't it!

THANKS.
Mike

DREW79   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

I really enjoyed the interview and this forum only made it infinately better

namit   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

Today mccain mentioned some thing very new to me... You are on accelerated path to citizenship if you participate in military.. I feel thats some thing we dont want ... We want patriots.. You cannot bargain on national security...
Can some analyst put some detail comment on this..?

Pat   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

I was so pleased to see just the Presidential candidates and no VP crap going on. I think it truly showed the candidates on their own without props and ads. This is the way the entire campaign should go and I think McCain should do a re-think on on shoving media attention to his VP instead of himself. I do think the American public would appreciate this.

Shirley-Ohio   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

I saw parts of Palin's interview and I see why they wanted to keep her out of the media. This election is a joke and McCain should be ashame of himself for what he did, picking her for Vice President. I know the other two potential VP women of the Republican side is LOL.

Toby Price   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

I am just glad to hear someone speak with specifics, with solid ideas, and with a sense of where America really is. Obama is that man. What happenend in this country over the last 8 years? Our standards have been lowerer. Bush was awful, and bc of that McCain seems like a good idea to a lot of people. I personally feel compelled to want to do more for America every time I hear Obama speak. He inspires me and I believe that he is totally in touch with CLEAR IDEAS on how to make this country better.

Jason   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

Obama has always been the stronger speaker to me and this idea of 'service' is important to the core of Obama's platform to me. If I could roll back the clock five years and have my volunteer service pay my tuition well.. whew.

Also in related news, Sallie Mae told me here in my last semester at college they are no longer offering private loans. I think a big overlooked demographic here are poor college students like me, living off ramen noodles just so I can get by from day to day. I realize working families have it rough, but lets see a lot of working stiffs juggle full time work, full time college and try to squeeze in being 'on call' for your job and woken up every ten minutes for a tech support. It's like having a child without the tax break.

What I wouldn't give for a little volunteer work now.

mike   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

Now, David Gregroy on the other channel, you know the repbulican who replaced Olberman, is just ranting how great McSame was. Of course he is now reading his blackberry getting his talking points!!!
Gross, MSNBC has turned red in a matter of months!! No objectivity, Cnn is the place, especially in the morning!!! '
Obama's answers were more direct. McSame over does the sympathy card...

Pam   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

If McCain knows how to fix it and understands it (whatever it is) why hasn't he fixed it before promising now. The man has been in Congress forever! Seems to be the same promise as that to get the guy who lives in a cave. LOL

Judy from Austin, TX   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

I'm not a fan of the 'controlled environment' question/answer stuff.

I would like to be the one to sit in a room with both candidates and do the questioning myself. THEN, I would get some real answers to the issues important to me and my family.

ken   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

Here's a question that has been bugging me lately...why is Todd Palin always on stage with the missus? He's a stooge...or is he?

oldblogger   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

Mr. Obama is not giving credit where they are due. The Mayor's duties are more than taking care of the garbage , etc.
If he were to govern any town, city or state he would know.
This was making light of Governor Palin's duties. I am sure this does not bother her at all.
Some people are a little jealous that they have never had any duties,
Just sit in the Senate and vote present is what I have heard.

MD Democrat   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

I agree with you Bill. But I do believe that Obama has changed the dynamic across this country of what it means to serve and to be involved. Win or loose (and I pray that he wins), he has changed my life.

Linear090   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

Mr. Bill Schneider, you wear cool hats! You're cool!! :-)

tim   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

so explain how barack is ready...

he hasn't proven anything to anyone.

he's a good speaker and you like what he has to say. No more qualified than anyone else in this election

GBrown   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

Bay says this forum won't change a vote – because it has been a civil discourse? Is the American public so stuck on slogans and ideology that ideas and policies just don't matter anymore?

CJ Scott   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

My one and only comment is maybe we should start a new blog and call it "Can The Press Ever get It Right"!

Q   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

What's up with Kanye getting arrested? I thought Barack's speech "changed his life"?

Susan O   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

So why is it when Palin or McCain mention the word war people freak out?
Obama came right along and what did he talk about, war and making everyone serve because it is not fair for some to and others not!

It is amazing how Obama people are not listening to the real words.
For people who profess to hate war you sure like to fight!

Lloyd   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

It was nice to see the candidates being civil for a change....but YOU guys? Sheesh.

It's sad to see honest dissent labeled as 'nonsense' and 'silly' in what's purported to be a civil setting.

I'm sure they treated Thomas Jefferson the same way.

Adrienne   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

Well, Obama did much better.

Sandy in Missouri   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

I am so frustrated – with the candidates – with the media – with everyone involved with the presidential campaign. The issues are what’s important – not the personalities. The Sarah Palin sideshow has completely dominated this election – this domination is leading to a false sense of competency. Please lets re-focus on what’s important – McCain & Obama and what they will do to fix the economy.

Dave   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

Did McCain slip and say that unlike a small town mayor, he's all the way in Washington out of touch with what's going on? I don't have the direct quote, but I jumped out of my seat.

Steve K   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

I'm 57....served in the military, and I didn't need a ra ra speach from someone like Obama

tialin   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

What Sarah Palin has proven to me is that the religous are just plain mean. They are absolutely full of hatred and hypocracy. She isn't doing much to attract to me to the church. You know the same people now voting republican in the south because of the same values used to be known as yellow dog democrats. But I think somewhere along the way as the kkk became less socially acceptable they decided to call themselves republicans. I live in Oklahoma and I have to tell you I'm honestly afraid to speak my mind in public because I fear I might be lynched for voting democrat. I'm having trouble feeling the love of Jesus here.

Oh and by the way I am absolutely without a doubt a God fearing, God loving, God praising, bible reading, praying, church going christian.

I WANT THE TRUTH   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

MLB once I woke up from McCains speech that is exactly what I was doing. A "Friends rerun was on and was way more interesting. He needs to be genuine and let the chips fall were they may. I think he is scared to do so. But Obama is not that's why we listen to him so intensely.

ron   September 11th, 2008 9:51 pm ET

Bill – thats because Republican's are so closed minded. Its all me me me- I know I used to be one of them. Now I am a bleeding heart liberal, and proud of it. Feels good to care about other people more than yourself!

CLA   September 11th, 2008 9:50 pm ET

"Superstar Palin"?! Check her record, check her outright exaggerations and possible lies. Watch Randi Kaye's report from Alaska today. Read other blogs. I agree that the Dems shouldn't "attack her" – not because she's a woman (it's the 21st century, so who cares?) – but she needs to be pressed beyond talking point answers, as does McCain.

activist mom   September 11th, 2008 9:50 pm ET

I am surrounded by High School kids with mandatory community service requirements and I BELIEVE IN IT!

mike   September 11th, 2008 9:50 pm ET

that's right bill, i don't think they mentioned lipstick once haha

David   September 11th, 2008 9:50 pm ET

I am a communitty organizer and I did not take offense to comments made at the RNC because being a community organizer does not make me ready to be president. It is a valuable experience but not a good qualification to be president.

And McCain did not steal change he has actively done it by reaching across the isle. What change is to most people is having our government work together and gettin rid of the partisan bickering. Obama has done some but very little working across the isle.

Everyone says McCain voted his party line 90% but Barack voted his party line 97%. Some years McCain was only around 60% party line. He crosses it when he thinks it benifits the American people.

Will, NJ   September 11th, 2008 9:50 pm ET

Why can't a campaign take place in a month? It's the Information Age and with a few clicks, anyone who cares can find the information they need on ANYONE. Have we become so lazy these people need to force it down our throats before we get it? It's been a year and a half and people still claim they don't know the candidates. I'm starting to think the undecideds just like the attention.

Seth   September 11th, 2008 9:50 pm ET

I am ready to hear Obama answer a question with a direct answer instead of rosie rhetoric dispensed round pear shaped tones. Every time he was asked a question that required a strong direct answer he danced around it with all his ideas about how wonderful everything should be, with NO plan as to how to get there! It sure sounds nice to wish things into being, it is a different thing entirely to actually implement programs that fix real problems.

Bob R   September 11th, 2008 9:50 pm ET

Hold it ! McCain was asked if he'd bring in say a democrat in his cabinet and yet Obama wasn't ? O sure right....balanced interviews.

Jose   September 11th, 2008 9:50 pm ET

Why are we talking about her? shes not going to be the president, shes going to be doing dicks job. Its all about Obama Vs Mc

JC   September 11th, 2008 9:50 pm ET

Here's a new GRE analogy for the ages–let's see if anyone can get it right:

Obama : McCain :: Love for one's country : Love for one's country club

There you have it. A new GRE Hit Parade analogy. It's not necessary to live by it, but you might just vote by it.

Obama/Biden 08

Nat in Vermont   September 11th, 2008 9:50 pm ET

So, Bill/Candy/Rolland, kinda off topic, but did the crowd at CNN expect this to go anywhere but down? Kinda hard to keep it organized, were you guys expecting less posters?

Anonymous   September 11th, 2008 9:50 pm ET

The media is supposed to be a referee in this thing but they appear to be"Palin struck"...this election is too important to the nation. CNN like Fox is now simple focused on "generating a story".

Jim   September 11th, 2008 9:50 pm ET

In some coumtries, the gov't will help pay the high costs of medical school, in exchange for public service to low income, rural areas for a period of time after residency. The cost for treatment for one of those doctors is extremely inexpensive, $2.00 in one country. I see this as a way for the government to aid its citizens directly, both the doctor and the patient. We have problems providing medical care in low income and rural areas. Paying someone's student loans in exchange for needed public service seems to me to be a win-win situation.

Tom from NJ   September 11th, 2008 9:50 pm ET

To Bill Schneider
Inspiration form a good Democrat will NOT protect America and Americans from another terrorist attack, give us REAL energy independence, or grow our economy!

Please get real, this feel good stuff just won't cut it for my children and grandchildren we and they need a real proven LEADER!

Where has Mr. Obama proven his ability to LEAD? What has he accomplished that makes him a LEADER? Please give us three examples that clearly define his leadership abilities and past acccomplishments that have caused his PEERS to rally to his causes.

There are none sir! In my opinion he's not a leader, just a talker and talk comes CHEAP!

john   September 11th, 2008 9:50 pm ET

Obama is a phony. Mccain tells it as it is.

Jake   September 11th, 2008 9:50 pm ET

Where's Giuliani or Palin to belittle the community organizers tonight?

I thought, coming into this, McCain needed to say to me, "I'm capable of understanding Americans and what needs to happen in every community to turn this country as a whole around."

What I'm walking away with is a man who thinks that 30 years in Washington is a positive thing. Just because you know the name of every lobbyist doesn't mean you're the best at thwarting them.

amle   September 11th, 2008 9:50 pm ET

What a boring forum..

Did Obama really say "i want to make America cool" lol uhhhhh
what a dumb answer

gilbert   September 11th, 2008 9:50 pm ET

The media seems to be in love with Sarah. Instead of calling her out on the rude and sarcastic speaches shes giving around the country! Cnn is also guilty of trying to make this election about the personality and connection rather than the real issues that matter to most Americans! (I believe purposely to help McCain-Palin)...Also it's a very good coinsidence how Obama's high poll numbers with veterans was completely ignored by the media!

Atul Saini   September 11th, 2008 9:50 pm ET

We have shortage of Gas at this moment! I am so sorry that people keep talking about new sources of energy! Just increase the supply and the prices will come down.
Today the gas prices are high and all these people are telling us to stop driving. What would you do in case we have a food shortage and the prices shoot up!
Will you tell all of us to stop eating or increase the supplyl.

Mae Lovelace   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

QUESTION:

What percentage of African American lives in the town where Gov. Sarah Palin live and govern her term in office?

I would like to know!!

Kenneth   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

It is a sad comment on America's Corporate priorities, that a frank discussion on service and commitment to America has to conform to the constraints of the commercial interruptions.

Jennifer   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

Obama should agree to some of those town hall meetings that McCain keeps crying about. That will refocus everyone on just the two of them again and he'll blow McCain away.

McCain=the draft   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

Candy, And all of a sudden, after 26 years, McCain has all the answers! He's been part of the problem!

Kim-Canada   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

OK a moment of humour...Palin has done one interview and already the McCain camp is scrambling....gotta love it. Can't wait till she gets out on her own...late night tv comedians are excited I'm sure.

Thank you to the greatest politcal team on television for such great blogging. Appreciated it greatly.

Samina Hayaat   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

What's problem with Bay . She looks like sore loser. Could not say one good thing for O'bama.

40-ish, White, Independent, Woman   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

Americans: Where is your moral outrage? Palin is an affront to the Democratic process.

Press: What happened to your objectivity? You have completely failed in your responsibility to tell the truth.

Dash   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

Roland, it is great to see new great energy into the American news media. You are a great American which much perspective. Stay healthy, and keep up the great work...

Dash-1

NOT LAID OFF....YET   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

I agree with yessir! I have learned so much about leadership and personal responsibility observing Obama. His influences are many.

Roger Woodin   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

sen obama hit a homerun bravo

Defining moment   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

McCain essentially equates service with the military ... WAR WAR WAR that's all he can talk about. He's trying his best to act civil on national TV, but will resort to sleazy ads full of lies the minute he steps out of that building ... what a fraud!

Paris   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

Why is it that no one brings up the fact that she is a GOVERNER.

She was defending herself.

Javone   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

My problem with Mccain claiming that he respects community organizers is why in the world did he allow not one, not two, but THREE people including his vice presidential choice to down them like that. "Not sure if that is even a real job". WHAT?????? He is quick to come out wanting Barack to condemn statements by other people but won't condemn the statements made by his own campaign staff. Nation of whiners indeed!

marina   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

The tide is turning again. Obama did a wonderful job.

Girlpower   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

I am still watching this, and I still have the same opinion of Obama- I have to laugh because he wants to be our President. And while he is a good speaker and has "lofty" plans which everyone can aspire to, I just didn't see in his background where he accomplished anything that would give me reason to vote for him. He has shown nothing; he just talks about what he is going to do. I gotta give it to him. He's just a really good speaker, that's about it.

Toby - Atlanta   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

I am scared of Sarah Palin. I have a Journalism degree and a Masters. I'm a tough mom, have managed large budgets, and negotiated sizable vendor contracts. I'm no more ready to be Vice President or God-forbid President of this country, than my neighbor.

I've always supported Barack Obama and have particularly admired his judgment, intellect, and over 20 year service to this country. I want my leaders smarter than me - but obviously still able to identify with my needs and concerns. How many Columbia and Harvard educated individuals decide to work for low pay in poor neighborhoods in order to create job training programs and improve community safety?

As a woman, I want equal pay for equal work and the choice to make my own decisions about my body. I want separation of church and state.

What makes the McCain/Palin ticket so different from Bush/Cheney? Isn't eight years enough?

Nat in Vermont   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

@ Red State Tex: If "The Government" is the problem- how do we fix it? That's kinda a vague complaint.

Paul   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

I cannot falthom another term of Repulicans. Eight years of hell...American respect worldwide has fallen to all time lows...the economy has fallen to all time lows...the job market is in disarray...the confidence of Americans has vanished.
So, why, in any common sense arena would America want to endure another four years with a government who cares nothing for their own people?
McCain is from yester-year...he resonates from a period where America was once a proud nation rich in accomplishments. But what worked then will not work now.
America needs a new direction with new ideologies and a new perspective to take it forward. America needs to break away from its past...it needs to start doing things that will prepare its future...ITS CHILDREN...to be ready for the challenges of today and for tomorrow.
Is the new direction with the leadership of Obama and the Democrats?
It certainly does not lie in the hands of the Republicans...so why not try the alternative...vote Barach Obama.

Firefly   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

America is still the land of "Opportunity" but is bleeding internally.

Gov is still important to create roads, parks keep things organized for us all...without this control humans will be in termoil as you can see in other parts of the work – the reason we have our loved ones in the harms way.

We need new thinking to gather what has been scattered in gov, in our lives and we need a leader who can inspire us, who see the future, who can gather people to make the see the sense of "community service" and why that becomes the core of how we think about other human beings...and not be so self centered.

Our first responisbily is our country, then rest of the world. We need thrive so we can help others. "You can't expect a ill person to cure another ill person – can you? then how we can help others, if we can't help ourself.

Wisconsin_Dem_Erich   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

why do conservatives say keep government out of it but yet want to impose their views on the women of America about their own bodies. yea, keep government out unless it beneifts the religious conservative right. what a double standard.

Texico From Mexico   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

'What kind of a peace do we mean and what kind of a peace do we seek? Not a Pax Americana enfored upon the world by American weapons of war. We must adjust our own attitudes. For in the final analysis we all inhabit this small planet, we all breathe the same air, we all cherish our childrens future and we are all mortal"

~ JFK

Wonder if the Republicans ever head this speech?

Bev   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

This was big for Obama. He was comfortable and eloquent without being too wordy. He was gracious and completely responsive. Didn't dodge a single question. He answered, then amplified, and with specificity.

McCain obfuscated and evaded. Now the public is responsible for negative campaigning? By that logic, 99% of Americans would be voting for Obama since McCain began the negative stuff many many months ago.

Andrea Mitchell et al. are calling it "high minded," and I guess it was, in light of today's sad anniversary. But I think both McCain and Obama are gonna come out blazing tomorrow.

And I can't wait for Palingate to be fully exposed. If she's impeached as Governor before the election, what does McCain do then? I might note that Biden said only yesterday that Senator Clinton might have been the better choice. I smell something floating in the air, but I'm not sure it's from an elephant or a donkey.

This has been FANTASTIC. Thanks, CNN, for giving those of us who love a lively discussion an outlet for our various frustrations and honest concerns.

karin   September 11th, 2008 9:49 pm ET

he is a breath of fresh air. saying military service to the anon guy up there is better than another. wake up. you need a certain mindset to kill people. you have a different mind set to save people. being a dr. is different from being a lawyer...but they can both do goo.
the right wing is so hateful. what a turnoff. ugh

EJ (USA)   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

I loved this forum. It was so warm and American. I think it was a perfect way to commemorate 9/11. I do wish the tone of the forum would rub off on the negative McCain campaign.

jerry   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

I thought the press was not going to use cheap tactics today in honor of 9/11. OK so you don't the meaning of that word!!! Did some not notice Obama is 1/2 white?? Has no idea what blacks in USA had to live like in history.

Bill Schneider,
CNN Sr. Political Analyst
  September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

Well, this forum was deliberately non-political, so there weren't any fireworks and none of the candidate were particularly put on the spot.

But the essential difference that emerged was Obama stressed government as a source of inspiration for service while McCain was more inclined to advocate for service via private sector organizations.

But in the end this forum will not change anything in the dynamic of the campaign!

darby   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

Obama is back !!! I get that good feeling again when I hear him speak. Go Barack, git 'er done !!!

MatterOfFactJack   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

You know – i never went into this election on the side of either one of these two candidates. It is utterly amazing to me how blindly people will follow a candidate and ignore the obvious in certain situations. It is proof that pot and mtv have taken a toll on the american minds over the past 20 years.

I love the comments about Palin's inexperience by bloggers and commentators and the willingness to ignore the inexperience far beyond Palin's by the primary candidate Barack. Amazing. Drink the Kool-Aid Drink – crazy! Now tell me MTV and Pot has not affected your minds lol. WOW! That's all I can say is WOW!

Bill Hodges   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

Seriously, this man Obama inspires me to want to do more for this country. He really is a breath of fresh air.

Fresh air? Sounds like your breathing Ether. Look at the facts not the gloss and smooth words.

Bill Maloni   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

I can offer several reasons why the McCain-Palin ticket is the wrong one for the nation, but let me highlight one that I expect most people–not that familiar with the Washington DC "inside the Beltway" scene– understand.

The next Administration has about 9000 high level political vacancies to fill, somewhat less for McCain, since some current GOP appointees would stay on.

There is no "moderate Republcian talkent pool," just the regular true GOP believers, who have been carrying feckless and abysmal policy calls in virtually every federal agency and regulatory office in town, financial services, stem cell research, health care, eductaion, Iraq, environmental, etc. etc..

Our nation and its government would operate more honestly and fairly, if all of these political GOP operatives were forced out of their job by an incoming Obama Administration. That won't happen if McCainwins.

Rob B.   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

I'm sorry I"m one of those young voters and I've never paid attention to Politics but Obama inspires me to do better not for just myself but for people in my community. Man. I respect McCain but Obama just reaches a spot in my soul that makes me actually believe in the American dream. That is not only possible for me but for anyone who works hard. Obama needs to be our President.

Mike   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

At 57 I have discovered that one man whether President or not, can only do so much to help the country. However, someone that inspires and motivates others to step and change will get my vote everytime.

Claudia   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

Obama is the next REAL inspiring President Americans have been waiting for. The new USA generation is the hope for this country! Obama can become a true leader who we can count on, can'y the American people see that? It is beyond my understanding that people are actually considering voting for MacCain-Pailen ticket, are you serious? A man who has been in the power for so long and has done nothing! and what about a lady who judges others on such strong conservative beliefs, yet has a daugther who is pregnant and who feels forced to now get married probably because "Mom' put her on the spotlight of the entire world!

Come on Americans! Make the right choice for a TRUE CHANGE, the change we are screaming for! VOTE FOR OBAMA-BIDEN!!!!!!!!!

Lyndon, New York NY   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

The saddest thing is knowing that the content of this forum and the manner in which is was moderated and held will be reduced to the background noise in lieu of tomorrow's next new attack ad.

Our politics is more a referendum on who we are as an electorate as it is the politicians who try to earn our votes. If we tuned out the nonsense and demanded solutions, then every day could turn into a forum or debate on substantive issues.

sil   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

For anyone who actually has the interest of this country at heart will vote based on facts that party affiliations. I, as an independent thinker does not believe that Palin can handle the enamous task of a U.S. President should something happen to Mccain. We should not forget that Mccain is not the young man he once was, and that means his vp candidate should be ready on day one.
For these reasons I am not sure if I will voting for Mccain.

Nathan Hale   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

big government is bad for the US, Obama is bad for the US, the basic unit of society the FAMILY needs to "change" more then anything then you won't need public works programs....

If the nation turns back God, then and only then will things get better.

Char   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

I'm 35 years old and have never volunteered, I'm ashamed to openly admit. But, Obama has inspired me to serve a cause bigger than myself.

john   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

Obama never answers any questions. Mccain is better.

Nate   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

The problem that I have with the whole campain this year is that people are loosing their houses to forclosure, loosing their jobs, no healthcare, economy is in the dumps, yet the candidates spend hundreds of millions of dollars on a campain. A recent article said that the demcrats want to raise 100 million dollars a month for three months. How many people could be bailed out of forclosure if all these rich donors would donated to those who were loosing their homes and loosing the jobs and not people who are already making hundres of thousands of dollars a year. If the candidats want to push for CHANGE, hold a dinner to raise money for the American people, not to spend 100 million a month on a political campaign.

Marc   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

I thought both candidates were extremely civil and had interesting thoughts. McCain, however, definitely seemed to focus on service as something to do with national security, matters of war, defense, etc. Notice how his questions and answers led in the direction of Russia and Georgia, and he talked quite a bit about military service. Obama had a nuance about teachers here in the U.S. and civil servants, etc. although he definitely also discussed civil servants working in foreign countries.

Sherry, Atlanta   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

NO M L B, I watched McCain and laughed, 90% of his speech-sound as though "he was on another Planet", totally "Out Of Touch" !

And Palin, talking about going to War!

Where does McCain and Palin come from?

OKC for Obama   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

Loved the Forum....well only caught Sen Obama's part 'cause I was channel surfing between HGTV and ESPN.

Candy & Roland....You Guys ROCK!!! You too Bill

Blue Dog Democrat   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

Why is everone making light of The Baracuda and her inexperience. 21 months 21 months this is crazy. John McCain has been yelling about Country First and clearly he was putting the country second when he picked the Baracuda. Here is a man who has had cancer four times, and is age 72 or 73 and he picks the most inexperience person to be his runnning make. Can you see the Baracuda in a show down with Russia in Nuclear talks. She is just a mess. I had respect for John McCain before he picked her. I always said that I would respect John McCain's campaign before any other Republican. That wa before this insult to the American people.

Paul   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

They stay in the senate for the health care plan of course :)

Risa   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

Obama really expressed his point that service starts with the government's influence. He is the president that can inspire youth to participate in the well-being of our nation.

arlene, CA   September 11th, 2008 9:48 pm ET

I say Wonderful to Barack Obama. We need Barack for President. l00% plus agree with this guy. I could listen to him talk about the future of our country all day/night. Yes, We Can. Obama / Biden

Robert   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

I think Obama made a very good point about getting young people involved. When I was in high school the only opportunities a was informed of was military service, fast food, and school activities such as sports or stamp clubs etc. I never knew about any public service that was available such as Peace Corps etc.

andrea burns   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

i went to teach english as a foreign language in the czech republic for 4 years. this was my service to america. i did not receive even a thank you from the state department nor any other departments of the american government !!!!!!!!!!!!

Rodney   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

MC Cain is still the same Maverick that left his wife in the time of need and voted with Bush over 90% of the time all you have to do is open you eyes and your minds to see Obama is the real deal and educated man who is also a great role model to all men and women that anyone that commits him or herself can be anything even President. MC Lame is and always will be the same clone of Bush.

Ron   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

Can anyone here tell me McCains plan for the economy, oil prices, mortgage problems and education? I havent heard McCain mention any of these very serious issues.

Shay   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

I hope very much that Obama wins i must admit i'm terrified of McCain i believe he will bring great change.. but only to his own exclusive neighborhood i know Obama may have the experience but i dont get it how people say McCains military record shows his ability to lead. to me it shows his ability to get shot down and tortured and the whole staying for 5 extra years..yes very honorable.. but would he destroy america to save its honor too?

betty byth   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

I don't believe a word Obama says, it's double talk. I'm sick of
hearing the whining everytime someone has an opinion that
defers from his. Not ready for the big time.

Mike T   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

All I have to say is that if McCain wins, this country is in big, big trouble. He has NO clue as the shape the economy is in, let alone any idea how to fix it. We are in big trouble, folks....And as for Palin, I'll just let her dig her own political grave, when she stops hiding behind McBush and begins to speak to the press. Give each of them enough rope and they'll do the work themselves....

Greg FL.   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

Great job to the moderators. I love this forum. thanks CNN. Love ya Roland Martin.

DREW79   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

I have always wanted to do more for my community. I feel Barack Obama knows how i feel.

Rick   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

Has anybody looked into the Gun Control Act of 1968 and the Lautenberg Amendment as it would apply to Trooper Wooten? I have read in the Alaska newspapers that while Trooper Wooten was under a protection order his badge and gun were taken from him at the end of his shift and returned to him at the beginning of his next shift. It is my understanding that military and police are not exempt from the Lautenberg Amendment. I believe it clearly states that it is a felony for anyone under a protection order to have guns or ammunition and it is a felony to furnish someone under a protection order with guns or ammunition. He and his supervisors may be guilty of a felony. Is it something that might be worth looking into?

Kelly   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

Great, add "engage in war with Russia" for yet another reason why this amateur is not ready to be a heart beat away from the Oval Office.

Just because you can "see" Russia from your state does not make you an expert on Russian foreign policy or national defense.

Doesn't she have some minion to fire to occupy her time instead of sabre rattling with Russia?

Leah DiMarco, Texas   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

Senator Obama will be our next President of the UNITED States of America.

mark   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

yessir, sign up for the military

Jackie - Canada   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

In reply to yessir – Obama inspires me to do more for my country and unfortunately he's not one of my choices in our election.

Jamie   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

Good question for Senator Obama:

You benefited from affirmative action in your younger years and look where you are today. But America has changed since your youth. Today, what are your feelings about affirmative action and do you think it has helped foster instances of reverse discrimination?

Michigan1   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

I am an independent voter and have always been disgusted with the negative campaigning in previous elections. Unfortunately it's still present in the current campaigns, but I really feel that John McCain is providing a direction, optimism, and energy to help return the pride in America. Another important trait of McCain is to walk the talk, popular or not. When is the last time that happened in D.C.? As much as none of us want our troops at war, he was right about the surge, and in the long run this will benefit our troops. McCain's foreign and domestic policies are far ahead of his rivals.

Plain and simple, McCain has the experience, strength, and zeal to lead this nation.

Steve K   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

Good Point Laurie. They go in common men...come out multi millionaires.

C. Gutierrez   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

During his interview tonight, Obama boasted that his campaign created 1,000 hours of volunteer work. If Obama's supporters have only contributed 1,000 hours nationwide, and he thinks that is a lot for the entire campaign in the entire country, then he's not as astute a community organizer as he claims to be. Think about it, 1,000 hours divided by 50 states, is only 20 hours per state! Anyone who has ever been involved in true volunteer efforts knows that that is a ridiculously low number!

Jen From MN   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

Obama did a great job. He really made sense and was genuine.

Obama represents goodness and kindness . . . A great American influence.

He really knows how to put things into perspective and I enjoyed listening to him.

Jim K   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

Senator Obama's support of the recent GI Bill and John McCains lack of shows a glaring disregard for respect of the sacrifice of service our military have devoted to our country.

Don't throw the Hanoi Hilton back at me. There are thousands and thousands of POWS in this country who DON'T wear that fact "printed on a tshirt"

Carl Rove running another Republican campaign while ducking supoenas makes a joke of our judiciary.

MD Democrat   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

I love that you said that yessir, I feel the same way! I have never been so inspired and I'm 60 years old.

phil   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

A president is only as strong as the people he surrounds himself. Palin isn't the worst choice but beyond her the Republican pool is really thin. McCain can't win without some good people with him. This will become an issue before its done.

Mo   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

This forum will definitely win more votes for Obama!! I think that the more the two candidates get the opportunity to express themselves and their ideas, we have more clarification of what they stand for.
The old way of governing does not accomodate our country and our world today. We need Barack Obama to help us make this much needed transition that speaks to not only just "specific" people, but ALL of us who have the honor of being called an "American".

Susan Nedza Lastres   September 11th, 2008 9:47 pm ET

What is service for me? Service is not a one time commitment; it is a way of life. For me, it meant choosing to be an emergency physician who cared for all patients no matter what their needs or ability to pay, it meant to choose government service as a part of my career, it means teaching the next generation of physicians about the trust that others put into their hands. It means being a role model for my children, that individual accomplishment is hollow, if not coupled with community service and commitment to others.

Bonnie   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

Bay, that is all the republicans are concerned about, changing votes, Obama wants to change the way the government is run., and by the way, republicans are doing every underhanded thing to change the vote.

Pam   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

OMG, are there really Obama supporters in WV? No, it can't be true!

Frank   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

William Dalton, how can you say McCain's experience with the economy is great? His economic policy is a mirror image of George W. Bush!

I don't know of too many people who are doing so well since the current administration took over outside of the oil business. Maybe it is time to try something different.

celebration1   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

Obama You are so energizing!!! How lucky are we to have an opportunity to vote for THE REAL THING!!! Horay for AMERICA we finally have a candidate that will bring us back to our moment of glory.........President Obama 08

independentdad   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

i served this country during the first Gulf War. I didnt do it at first to serve my country. I did it so I could go to college. While serving, I found that I loved this nation. However, if people dont think they can trust the leaders of this nation, why would they serve???

Linear090   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

Obama is quite inspiring and a breath of fresh air that has been long needed in this country for so long. His speeches carry through the air like a fine note played from a musical instrument. I put my full support on the Obama/Biden race.

Tanya   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

No Bay- it may not change a vote but it will change at least one person's thinking. Getting out and serving a community and giving something back because someone...anyone inspired you to do so is the greatest feeling.
The problem I have with today's Republican Conservative is that they preach about their faith and some of the one's I've met are the most mean-spirited and are downright unkind towards others. You can't have it both ways, though many of them try.

KM   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

Frankly, the Faith forum was a better comparison of candidates. How unfair that Obama gets to listen in and tailor his remarks to what McCain already said.

Debbie   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

I've never been asked, as a white woman in the south, what my opinion is....
Where are these polls coming from..or do I have to pay to sign up to get asked?

FLARTIST   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

Time for America to wake up...time to move forward from the tactic if fear and mud slinging!

Brian   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

Stunning! I watched McCain on the Forum this evening and was moved by what he had to say. I really believe he sincerely loves this country and believes what he is doing is the best course of action. Then, Barak Obama spoke and I was floored. He truly understands what having a vision can mean for helping this country to transcend its current situation and become a leader. I have to say that a vote for Obama is a true and tangible vote for change. McCain, although authentic, just does not understand what vision means.

Nancy Valentino   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

Can't a person get this Obama to answer a question without going on with all the ehs- ums- mms- and just give a straight answer...

PLUS– can you prove that he is legal to run for president on this country? All papers on him are locked up and we can't even see his health record. But you guys thought it was O.K. that Clinton hid his also......So, I won't expect an answer from your station!!!!!!!!!!

Bob   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

The paid Obamabloggers are out in force tonight....keep spewing out your hate....in case you haven't noticed you are driving your candidate to defeat....keep up the good work!

gc   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

I do volunteer in the inner city becuase I feel it is my duty as a Christian and human being. And guess what, those people want to work hard and make thier lives better. Many just don't know how.I think Obama hit this one out of the park!

Sergeant Wag   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

Breath of Fresh Air = Wind Bag in this case.

DJ WAZU   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

Mr Obama inspires me. Mr McCain does not.
I am 48 years old and would absolutely be willing to go to Iraq only and only if Mr Obama win the presidency!

TRYING TO SAVE MY MORTGAGE   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

The best thing that could happen this year would be to elect a SMART POTUS

international khaladi   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

Bill, if i ever get enough money to buy cnn, i would make you the captain of the ship. woolf would retain his position as #1.

American   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

It was so wonderful watching this amicable forum. If only the remainder of the campaigning could be so civil.

Wisconsin_Dem_Erich   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

as a first time voter, i do have to say this is one heck of a contest to get started with no doubt about it

FrancescaY   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

Senator John McCain talk about how he is going to extend military, get more fund for the Peace corp., America corp, and possible created new programs that has to do with service. Those ideas are great, but McCain campaign is about lowing taxes. What I want to know? Is why didn’t your correspondent asks a follow up question? Such as, How you are going to pay for these programs without raising taxes?

Shannon   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

Well, I'm not sure this anything for either candidate one way or the other, but it was a good forum to bring public service into the general conversation. It was great to see both candidates discuss the many ways one can serve his country. Referring to one earlier comment, the military do protect our right to do public service in t he first place, but let's concede that there really would not be much point if there was nothing to protect in the first place.

Moira   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

Barack Obama is such a great candidate, intelligent, clear headed, with integrity and outstanding plans for positive change for this country. John McCain and his bulldog with lipstick VP would destroy the country if they were given the chance to lead it. I hope they will not be given that chance, as if they do, we will all be in much bigger trouble than we are in today. Vote for Obama!

Megan From VA Blue 08   September 11th, 2008 9:46 pm ET

Roland, Bill, and Candy(my fav) are awesome.. Great !

Terry G.   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

John McCain had more makeup on his face than a wh*re on payday.

William Dalton   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

Deborah- His message of change is registering with youth because youth want change. That's good, and right. However, one can't say McCain is for 'same old,' because in reality he is not. His platforms are very different from the Bush administration.

Louise   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

The Republicans are scared that the forum tonight will change votes. Hopefully, voters will see how presidential Obama is, and McCain needs to go home, and let another generation take over.

Sheryl in Virginia   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

Senator Obama is so inspiring. For me, in a difficult time due to the financial tumult of the last 8 years, I am again inspired for the USA. Yes, we can make this a better country ... the country it should be. Thank you, CNN, for providing the platform this evening. Senator McCain is a "hero" and all that, but I am more inspired by Senator Obama's vision for the future. Go Barack !!!

Carl   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

The only reason why the Budget was balanced in the 90's was on the back of the military....Look at how the Defense Department's budget was completely reduced...When I was in the Military we did not have enough funding to repair our combat vehicles.. What is the sacrafice?

EqualBranchesofGovernment   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

Oh no..............we might need some "service" down in Texas with Ike coming.

Common Sense   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

Wow...America, we actually discussed issues today and not a word about 'lipstick'...George Washington must be proud. Good Job guys!!!

SDO   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

Doesn't it seem odd that just a couple weeks ago McCain was putting out that celebrity ad about Paris Hilton, and now we have to look at the Beauty Queen VP? Jon Stewart must love this.

Christopher Mathis   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

YES WE CAN!!!

Gee, Alabama   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

Country First!

Question: Which Country? Iraq?!?!?!?!?!

STB   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

jopat and others-

I happen to be one of those that gets scared by short succinct answers to complex issues. It means the politician doesn't understand the complexities or doesn't think that I could. Either should scare people.

I am consistently impressed with the depth and breadth of Obama's answers. Not only the depth of knowledge expressed on the issue but the ability to show how any given issue effects others.

Sean

Texico From Mexico   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

What has McCain done for Veterans in 26 years? Nada...

dan bonner   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

When Charlie Asked Palin about the Bush Doctrine she didn't know
what he was talking about! Isn't that great!

JPL   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

sa - it is only elitist to be in community service, if it is not faith based, if it is then you are doing the work of God, and that is a blessed act. I happen to think that it is a blessed act, to serve, no matter why or where, if it is borne from a desire to make the world a better place.

Dexter   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

If Obama becomes president I will serve in the Navy!

FLARTIST   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

This a great moment...Obama was wonderful!

Shannon   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

I think Obama speaks to my generation so much. We are big on the issues and were listening believe me we are.....I think they both did a good job..

anon   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

While Obama would clearly be a role model for youth and disenfranchised citizens, Sarah Palin represents a brand new model for American women and youth.
Multi tasking, ethical, and motivated to serve, she would be an intelligent, energetic, and positive model of the strength of conviction. Obama cannot claim the scope and breadth of personal and professional victories she has already achieved.

Russ   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

Funny-I have left 3 comments in favor of McCain and none were posted. Must be primetime!!!

Another Canadian.   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

Does the saying out with the old and in with the New (young) come into anyone's mind here. Its time for the next generation to govern this planet.

LouAnn   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

Bill....nothing wrong with Government being "cool". I think it's a "very cool" idea. The man definitely has something!

Linda Buie   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

Glenn Beck, Amy Holmes and Ronald Reagan son needs toget their heads out of their butts. I can not believe that he would say something so stupid as Palin is Ronald Reagan reincarnated. That shows you that he thought nothing of his father. Palin has done nothing more than any other small town Mayor-her claim to fame was that she sold the state jet on ebay and fired the state cook.....look at the money she billed back to the state for travel for her family–she should have kept the jet!!!also she billed them for meals at her home!!! she claimed she got rid of the "BRIDGE TO NOWHERE" but we now know that is not true. She only dropped it the bridge when they questioned her...No one knows anything about her..we only know what has been filtered to us...we have not heard from the people of Alaska-we are not stupid..

Martiniano Obamite   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

How long will it take for the angry white men to realize that voting for Palin won't get them a lap dance?

John (Texas)   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

I can't wait till we get both of these guys on stage... these live forums are a bit of a tease and a waste of time.

I want to hear them respond directly to each others ideas... and HOPEFULLY (but not likely) we can get a good debate without pointless scandals (i.e. lipstickgate)

The end of the month can't come soon enough!!

Laurie   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

Candy – you know exactly why they stay in the Senate for decades. And the answer is NOT volunteerism.

Mike   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

I do not I have a problem with Sarah Palin, it is John McCain that I have a problem with. I'm worried that for all his talk of "change" he is just using that poor woman to boost his ratings and get elected and then he will shove her aside and be another 4 years of Bush and the "Old Guard" Republican "Good Ole Boy's" politics. That scares me to death. After seeing Sarah on ABC tonight, I feel that she is the one to trust, not McCain. After all, he's had years to "change" Washington and he voted straight line Bush 90% of the time! I hope he is NOT just using Sarah to get elected! What a jerk that would make him and what saps that would make the American people!

Ken   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

Candy,

Why don't you ask McCain that question?

Shannon from Oklahoma   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

This is not about changing votes and I have decided this election is so polarizing on the Republican's side that those supporting John McCain obviously can stand his attacks and politics. However, for the rest of us this is just a great opportunity to really understand their plans better.

Jessy King   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

I love Candy Crowley more!

Joseph   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

What about Obama belittlering Palin as a Mayor you are all so Bais.

MB   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

Roland – I so appreciated your commentary article the other day which basically said call it like you see if – if you are brave enough to say you will support a candidate and not base your decision on race or age.

My mother-in-law was yelled at by some stranger who saw her pick up an Obama book at the store yesterday....blurting "you are thinking of voting for THAT are you?" She at 78 was so shocked and frankly scared she said in her Georgia drawl "I am still undecided" which she SO isn't, an Obama supporter from day 1.

She said your article rang so true about people "who can't put their finger on it" as to why they don't know yet who they are voting for are coming from points of racism and ignorance and views that don't include progress or rational thought.

Thank you!

Brian Green   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

Interesting that you did not post my comments on McCain's spiel about 'all men created equal' yada yada in America. Is that because it hit home for you too and you prefer to keep your head and as many other heads as possible firmly stuck in the sand ?????????????

Brian   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

just listen to the difference between the two – how can one argue that Obama is not the better Presidential material? it's amazing to me after listening to both – it's not even close? – these upcoming debates will expose McCain's weaknesses.

Maverick Democrat !!!   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

Candy , You're the Greatest !!! , Sending Love For Michigan !!!!!

jonjjones   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

After seeing in her ABC interview, that Plain didn't even know what the "Bush Doctrine" was, I am convinced that Saturday Night Live should get her to play herself in Saturday's opening show. The name of this comedy troupe, if I remember correctly, is "The Not Ready For Prime Time Players"!

John   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

Bill-

If the issues are not being asked in this forum, why don't some of you do a better job of asking them......instead of spending 16 hours talking about the political impact of a statement someoen made.

And when did Obama start with personal attacks? I didn't see any of you (accept for Roland) defend him when he and his wife have been called out of their name.....and where is the story about Republicans calling them uppity?

Pek   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

i agree. i think obama is doing really well in the forum. especially since he comes off more sincere than mccain. one thing that bugs me about the forum is that they didn't ask either candidate about the current situations involving georgia and pakistan. palin thinks that a russian invasion (or even percieved "bullying") of georgia or ukrain, would be a justifiable reason to go to war. at the same time president bush is ignoring the national soveriegnity of pakistan by launching subversive operations against alleged terrorists (resulting in the death of numerous civilians), ARE WE ALL POTS CALLING KETTLES BLACK? i would love to have heard mccain and obama discuss this.

rose   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

What a copy cat...Obama repeated everything McCain said and you posted it under his picture as though it was his original inspirational idea.

Donald Stuckey   September 11th, 2008 9:45 pm ET

Obama did a very good job. He seems more comfortable than he did in the last form. He stuck to his message, and reiterated a number of his policy proposals, his campaign should be very pleased with his performance. I hope he will do the same when the debates start.

Arthur   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

I am for Obama. McCain will be no different than Bush. His voting record proves it. As for being ready to lead, Palin isn't anywhere close. She was mayor of a city of 6,000 and Governor of a small state (population, not geography) for less than two years and already is being investigated. Obama was not just a community organizer, he was also a civil right trial lawyer, constitutional law professor and U.S. Senator. I see no comparison. Don't forget he has Biden as V.P. No one can possibly question Joe Biden is immeasurably more prepared to take over as President and Commander in Chief than Palin. She would have no idea what to do. A Palin Presidency would be worse than George W. Bush.

Douglas   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

I wish Cnn, would do more to challenge both of the candidates instead of playing it safe. How do they feel about Father's RIGHTS ,taxes on overtime wages,property tax exemption for schools ,when you reach a certain age and no longer have kids in the school system and can not pay your property because your on a fix income .Taxe exemption for senior Citizen who collect social security.etc

B. Harrison   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Bay-

Do you have anything good to say about Obama. Come on, just one nice comment.....LOL.

thad   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Can I please hear one comment from the cnn crew that is in favor of MCCAIN. You guys are so biased its unreal. You cant see the forest for the trees.
You want a democrat in office so bad you will accept Obama???
Vote Mccain

Steve K   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

S. Morgan....good point

mark   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Public or Private school for their kids????? I can only afford the unionized public monopoly.

Earnie   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Let me rephrase that. He said another draft would be APPROPRIATE!

Joan   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Maybe not Bay, but it is a breath of fresh air to hear both candidates leaving out the sniping.

I WANT THE TRUTH   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Okay lets see how long it takes FEMA to get to TEXAS. My guess they already left.

BK   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Nicole, Obama is just going to spend it in Afganistan. Thats not a free war.

Pete in Tampa   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

The best "public service" anyone cn perform is avoid politicians like the plague. With rare exceptions, politicians view public service as the willingness of the public to serve them.

ARE OUR VETERANS RECIEVING THEIR BENEFITS?   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

I am loving this! I appreciate the commentators joining the forum to level up the discussion. It's much more civil and informative. Stay with us! Continue this format!

Tom   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

when people say this forum is not going to change a vote...it must mean only one thing – you are nervous that people may actually think there are other kinds of service beside miltiary service that is commendable and worthwhile.

Bob   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Gee wasn't Ronald Reagan only a governor before he took office!

Martha   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Obama,Lets move on to details rather than continue to repeat the same rhetoric we have been listening to for two years. Those two years he was paid as a Senator but seldom showed up for work.

P   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

The McCain people should watch what they say when putting down others who have to clean up thier mess that thier edics have caused to the people as a whole. Telling a nurse, doctor, lawyer, farmer, cattle rancher, road paver that what they do deon not matteris completely craze. The military deos not produce anything that supports them the people here in the U.S. who work in each and every field that exists all across the U.S. can go on without , but the military which is completely dependent upon the citizens of America should be morwe thankful for whta they do for them. No militray farms for itself, nor does it produce the clothing that they wear, nor does it produce the equiptment that they have to use to do the job that the America peolpe has tasked them to do!

glen   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Palin is pro-life and is opposed to abortion in all cases.
What if the woman was raped.

Palin admits to smoking marijuna as a youth

Signs of a drug addict.

Alaska is still the largest per-capita recipient of federal earmarks, requesting nearly $750 million in special federal spending and obtaining $295 per citizen from the federal government.

More earmarks than Obama.

In Palin's 2006 gubernatorial campaign, she supported the building of a bridge from Ketchikan to Gravina island which was later nicknamed the "Bridge to Nowhere" due to the island's population of 50. the $223 million Congressional earmarks for the bridge was criticized nationwide as wasteful federal spending.

So you did want to build the bridge.

Palin favored an "exit plan" for the war in Iraq

Sounds like Obama’ to me.

Greg   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Great to know that when McCain dies of old age while in office, his VP is willing to go to war with Russia. Great plan GOP! Thanks for your concern for the future and our kids.

Pam   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Small towns are hurting and trying to do the best with what they have. As a trainer who specializes in nonprofit development in small rural communities, I am quite puzzled with the feedback that network surveys have provided. They must not be surveying the same people that I have worked with for the last 20+ years.

paul from Canada   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Listen to both Canadidates, Obama talked facts and in details but Mc Cain was rubbling and jumbbling no Issues no facts. Job well done. Well presidented Obama, Thanks

Kim-Canada   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

My prayers are with those in danger of the wrath of Ike.

William Dalton   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Haha Cindy, good point. But I think that only advances Palin's position, really!

FLARTIST   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

This is the best America has to offer...not more of the same..which is what McCain is!

Jim   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Candy- point well taken

sa   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

I don't understand some people characterization of Obama as this villain. He is candidate who brings hope to a lot of America.

Tommy   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Roland,

What do you think about ordinary people coming on talk shows to talk about the real problems in their life and who they feel will do more to help them? Wouldn't this more effective than the pundits talking for us?

LISA   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Bill, I guess Obama can't do anything right in your eye sight.. Oh do you guys think he favors McCain a lot could be your half Brother DUDE..

Obama has done a great Job Tonight good for you President Elect Obama..

Cool and calm Love it.

Michelle J   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Dave...relax no one is DEMANDING that you serve, only asking. Surely that is a better option than manditory military stop loss.

Sergeant Wag   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Candy...

Because we can't get them to vote for TERM-LIMITS.

Jessy King   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

We all admire John McCain, but Obama needs to hit on the fact that John McCain keeps changing his mind on issues, McCain and Palin has not stopped attacking Obama

alex   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

MLB you got me I was one of them!!

evan french   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

why did obama remove the american flag from his plane???????

Scott   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Obama come on tell us something you’re going to do now not about starting early with the next generation.

VA voter   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

so is the media going to pickup on the fairness of having Obama listen in on McCain's part or is that part of the media bias that will get overlooked?

Barbara   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

I'm horrified to think John McCain belives Sarah Palin could server as VP and perhaps President. After watching her on ABC tonight, I know why the campaign has been keeping her quiet.

David McFadgen   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

As a Canadian watching CNN and other US media it so obvious that the US media is so incredibly biased against the Republicans. When will the American public wake up and demand truly unbiased and objective reporting from the media. CNN you should be ashamed of your coverage of the US election.

John Illinois   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Roland and Candy, what is your opinion of these: I want to see Obama get hammered on education. In Illinois, we have just about the worst, if not the worst, education system in the country. Also, hammer Obama on the total corruption in the Illinois Democratic Machine of which he is a part of. Illinois is almost in economic collapse as well. We have not heard one word from our absentee senator (for approx. 75% of his term) regarding any of this. He also has accomplished nothing as a state legislator or senator of Illinois. Sorry, community organizer definitely does not cut it.

Liz   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Well I would say McCain has kept his momentum after this "forum". Perhaps Obama will agree someday to debate McCain.

for McCain!!   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Wait, Obama wants to increase the military size, but cut the funding? hahaha. that's smart. Obama can't even answer a question without talking for 5 minutes off track. He's not so good without a teleprompter!!

Linda Carpenter, Phoenix, Arizona   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Barack Obama is such a wonderful leader. His ideas make so much sense and he looks forward to a peace time. McCain and Palin, all they see is more war, more bombing, more death, more kids in the military with little pay and no support. How MCCain can claim to be about service and for vets when he votes against every bill designed to help them. He even voted against the recent GI Bill that increased educational benefits, saying it is too generous. MCCain dropped napalm in Vietnam, destroying generations of people. He has received benefits for 40 years as 100 per cent disabled while voting no and trying to cut beneifts for returning vets and downgrading dianoses of PTSD. How does he get 100 per cent disability while still working full time? He should donate whatever he gets to veterans who are homeless. I am sorry but I do not see him as a hero, not even as someone who tells the truth.
Barack Obama and Joe Biden are the real deal. They will work to make regular Americans have a better life. They will work for veterans, teachers, and all workers, not millionaires.

Andrew   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Nicole if you haven't noticed today's budget deficiet numbers are $483 billion dollars this year. By my math the Iraq war is costing $120billion for the year. All stopping it means is we are in less of deficiet than we were before. THE COUNTRY IS STILL BROKE!

yessir   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Seriously, this man Obama inspires me to want to do more for this country. He really is a breath of fresh air.

DeeinNC   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Obama offered substance rather than empty rhetoric. I am deeply impressed and will vote for Obama. Bay you're 0 for2.

AP   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

"You can't monopolize what it means to be an American."

Great point, sa!! And I do think small-town folks sometimes believe they are more "American" than people who live in the cities. It's the "Heartland" mentality. Geography has nothing to do w/ patriotism!

Kujo   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Roland and Bill, a question for you...

I remember when it was determined we won the cold war. The explanation we got from the Republicans was the Regan forced Russia to weaken their economy by continuing to fight a unwinable war in Afganistan.

Now we are doing the same in 2 countries in the region. US complained that Iran is arming the enemy.

Well Yay, why not. If it worked for the US agains Russia, why not do the same thing. If we are getting stronger in Iraq, move the support to Afganistan.

Aren't we falling into the same hole?

Steve in Pekin   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

Bill, I am not sure that McCain is running against Congress and Washington, my belief is that he is trying excite the base by saying he has been for what the Republicans have done for the last 8 years. And as a majority the last 6 it has been NO vetoes and anything the President wanted. I liked the McCain of 2000 and 20004 he actually had some different ideas, now it is the same as everyone else. I think Obama is now trying to fight against all the old ideas not just Bush.

Kaity   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

I just started watching the show at 9pm. Maybe I am lost or just don't get it, but...we have many more issues to be discussed other than giving service in this Presidential election campaign. I am a believer in service and I volunteer in my community. My employer allows us 16 hours a year to perform community service. I just don't understand this special presidential candidate forum on service. We are at war, our economy is pathetic, gas prices are outrageous, we need healthcare...why are we debating service???

Chris   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

While everyone is searching for a bad thing about both candidates, I unconditionally see two great men. The only problem is getting everyone to come together for the common cause. Energy policies of George Bush have failed and John McCain endorses the same ones in place today. I thought John McCain was so against what is truly wrong with Washington, however he strays so far to the right to flock to all the republican votes, as opposed to his first presdiential run in 2000. What does that truly say about his dedication to listening to the people?

Barbara   September 11th, 2008 9:44 pm ET

I'm not inspired by McCain – Barack Obama inspires me.

I don't trust McCain – no trust = no inspiration ---

Cam   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

Candy......HAHAHAHAHAHA......awesome!

Phil in Texas   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

great forum...we need to talk about the issues more!!!!! cut out the silly talk.
great job candy and roland, love ya!

Red State Tex   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

Bill you are right, Government is the problem not the solution, seems like I heard that somewhere......

Melissa   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

Bay, Perhaps Obama's "lofty" explanations are taking into account that fact that not every American operates with the same intellectual capacity that you do. Sorry if you are bored with his lofty explanations, but I'd prefer that all Americans understand the policy's he's proposing and what he represents. He's not catering to your comprehension. He's talking to the American people – who happen to come from all walks of life and education levels.

I've yet to hear explanations on much from McCain at any point in time... I'd take lofty or brief at this point... a good idea would shock me. The only ones he's had were someone else's first. I feel like half of his rhetoric these days was taken from Obama's playbook. I don't buy it. He needs to tell us what he represents and HOW he plans to get things done.

Sanity_2008   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

==

Roland Martin raises the issue of a "civil tone" to the campaign...

How about just blowing a whistle on diversionary nonsense like this "lipstick on a pig" issue raised by the Republican campaign? I'd settle for a campaign that sticks to real issues, "civil" or not.

Candidates' actual, factual backgrounds, records, histories are germain to any political contest – that is NOT "mudslinging". All the stupid nonsense about flag pins, preachers, lipstick, figures of speech – now THAT's helping to dumb down the process.

In my view, this is a tactic from the Karl Rove playbook that benefits McCain.

wb   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

This forum is as dumb as the religious one. Has the media lost its mind.
I turned if off at 9:10. Yes Yes its good to serve. We all know that. Is there no real journalists anymore. Lets get the debates going and please lets not let every knuckle head ask questions.

Sherry   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

David- McCain genuine? PLEASE- " Change " was Obama's slogan – McCain is anything but genuine- He's a conspiring " COPYCAT" two faced and "reaching " by his VP selection of S. Palin Reaching his way AROUND the issues of this nations " real " everyday people that MCCain knows nothing about. HE's FAKE-

jill   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

If McCain/Palin wins....I may just move to Canada..I cant take another 4 years

Rhea   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

I agree with Obama encouraging a sense of unity. His determination to bring this sense of unity to the international community will also serve us well. American seems to be involved in operations that breed enemies. We need to get back to building partnerships.

Texico From Mexico   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

Why is CNN so biased towards the GOP? i thought they had their own network called FOX?

Tiffany, Atlanta   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

Opportunities for everyone and not just the privilege! Obama what are you thinking? Surely the republicans don't want to hear that!

Sportsbabe   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

Sen. Obama was perfect.
He had nothing disparaging to say about his opponent. As usual, can't say the same about McSame.

Diane   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

I'm so tired of the media. I wanted to throw up listening to all the crap about the lipstick comment. God, it had to be debated for two days, like there was nothing more important. What crap. Let's get to the issues. You are not fair and balanced, you do whatever to get viewership on your station, and readers on your website. I guess you think the American public is pretty stupid and can't see through your bias.

If the media wouldn't have made such a big deal about the lipstick comment, IT WOULD NOT BE A BIG DEAL. Your headlines read like it was intentional against Palin, knowing that was just not at all true. The unfortunate part of that is that the country is full of idiots that don't read the article. They form opinions based on scathing headlines THAT YOU PRINT TO GET RATINGS/READERS.

I don't believe the polls that say McCain is ahead. I think it depends on how they are taken, and they are done in such a way to make it appear so. It's well know the media is largely controlled by the republicans, and it's so obvious it makes me sick.

OBAMA FOR PRESIDENT.

Richard Waite   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

I have not read the lengthy string of comments above but have been meaning to write to thank Roland and Jeff(rey) for calling Bay Buchanan (the other night) on the reasons for questioning Sarah Palin.

Chris from Va   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

Candy and Bill, how does Obama come across as detailed and genuine? He changes his accent on where he is speaking... Last time I checked he wasn't from the South! John and Sarah are more substance than Obama. Where has Joe Biden been? Keeping his biggoted views under wraps! Who is hidding now???

cashflow   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

If we cut all the PORK Projects that we do not need on both sides, stop paying the lobbists half a million dollars a piece to vote their way.
Like Palin payed a lobbyist to help get her that bridge to nowhere...before she decided she way against it – - – but kept the money anyway......we can afford to fix America's infrastucture, pay teachers a decent wage....and so much more! There are more than 1700 lobbyists for 465 Congress members! People use your head!
McCain is a third term for George Bush! Look at the facts – this Country cannot afford to have McCain as president. Were really in trouble as a Country...I'm a white 53 year old republican (female) and I'm voting for what;s best for my grandchildren to come!

Leslie McCloud   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

I really think Sen. Obama was excellent in tonight's forum. It was almost based on principles he promotes and details in his campaign speeches. I am behind him !00 percent. I cannot wait until he is president.

zina   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

Obama is wonderful with the specifics tonight!

Roland/Bay – What do each of you think of his defense and critique of the Republicans Convention's belittling of community organizers?

Teddy   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

What will work? Did Bush's plan work?

deborah, WV   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

Obama's right about young people that want to serve our country and their abilities. I am presently working with a young student teacher in Huntington WV that is impressive in his maturity and desire to work hard to serve the young students that he hopes to teach.
He is also an Obama supporter, as am I, and we are both excited to work for the Obama campaign in our area. Obama's message of Change and service registers with all age groups

Vishal   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

Bay- why would you support mccain? why would any woman support mccain? I guess you don't like to be paid equally for equal work. Women for McCain is RIDICOLOUS!

Linear090   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

Candy Crowley, I LOVE YOU! :-)

Jim   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

in the end no new news, other than Columba needs ROTC back?

Steve K   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

NO NEWS here tonight

Jo   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

Why wasnt Michelle Obama at ground zero today 9/11?

Jacob in detroit   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

Hello,

its seems like media and Mccain camp wants to talk about the Lipstick comment. can you talk about the problems real people facing right now. especially in Detroit and Michigan and tri-state area.

Ed from Tampa   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

Question – what did you hear tonight that changed your mind or help you make a decision, if anything?

Mark   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

Why did McCain get the full hour and Obama got 40 minutes??

Doug-Pawling   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

Judy in Pa-
The problem is the bad guy always gets the girl!

You see how he treats her when he gets her!

Just like a women of Abuse they keep coming back for more!

Candy Crowley, CNN Sr. Political Correspondent   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

It kind of makes you wonder…

Both these guys have been dumping on their own jobs in the Senate (Obama: Mayors work, we “yack.” McCain: you get “divorced” from real people’s problems.) Why do they all stay there for decades?

ok, don’t answer that.

Andy   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

Barack, I mean President Obama NAILED IT. I sense a momentum shift never to be reliquished.

Kathleen   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

"pal-in" comparison to Obama

Vets for Obama   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

My point about McCain not supporting the troops at home goes to how we feel about him having everyone pat him on the back all the time... When he was in Hanoi he no choice, survie or die... No he has a choice and he votes against Vets health benefits... This is why we are against him... Please cover this story... For the soldiers

DREW79   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

No way Roland I was very interested in this interview/forum. Apparantely you guys are decided on who you will vote for . You can change the channel ut those of us who havent decided yet. this is good stuff.

Barbara   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

I give it *****

Edward   September 11th, 2008 9:43 pm ET

A lotta fluff! Platitudes and no policy from either candidate.

ss   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

You are wrong Bay.....I was leaning toward McCain. Obama answered the questions far better. I will now vote for Obama

Sojourner2008   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

Lyndon from New York . . . You are soooooo right!!!!

drill4oil   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

this blog sucks

FLARTIST   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

This guy is what a President should be..and will be.
President Obama!!!!!

cj   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

Great job Obama!

Matt   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

Community organizing in Detriot for a short period of time does not qualify someone to lead a nation. That neighborhood is not reflective of the entire country. Our issues, needs and security are far greater. The only appealing aspect of Obama is his age. His greatest deficit is his lack of qualifying experience to lead the most influential democracy on the face of the planet. My only wish would be that his followers were more concerned with the finer details than they are blinded by the hope and hipe of someone who has no experience leading on the national/internation level.

Ernie Funderburk   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

What I'd like very much to understand is how a man, so opinionated
and sure of himself as Barack Obama; someone who is going to
lead us through the hazards of the early 21st century with a war
lingering that needs to be won and market troubles at home because
of fiscal irresponsibility and greed, has to count "leadership" of his
current campaign as a flagship of his readiness! That's about the
lamest thing iI've heard in the political arena in a long time.

Paris   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

Roland I wish you would come out and be upfront with people and make your support for Obama public.

I would have respect for you then.

James   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

Its not just about who's watching this live. The soundbites will be on blogs and newscasts and the cables nets for the next few days.

Aubrey   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

Roland Martin, I know you were behind Sen. Obama the entire time, but I had to say policy wise, Hillary Clinton killed him. But honestly I did like Bill Richardson. A little bit of Huckabee and Ron Paul, not so much!!

Ruth   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

THANK YOU, CNN, for this forum. It is the first moment of clarity and civil discourse in weeks. Keep it up. We want to listen to them, not the pundits tell us what they said and what we are to think about what they said. Tonight is like a breath of fresh air. Please stop reporting the talking points from the campaign managers and let us hear more from the candidates in moments such as this. We don't want debate, per se. We want to listen and think. And we aren't electing their managers. again, my truest thanks for tonight. It was good.

WakeUp   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

No wonder republicans cant stand Obama, we wants to destroy the hold republicans have on this country by opening up the goverment, people really will have a say! That scares them!

Roland Martin,
CNN Political Analyst
  September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

S. Morgan, cut the nonsense.

BOTH McCain and Obama were in New York at Ground Zero. Stop ignoring today's reality.

Denny   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

Why cant people open their eyes and see democratic candidate is the right choice for our country? The republican candidate has clearly illustrated is ideas and policies which are not going to better our country. Now he is trying to switch to make the democratic candidate look like the bad guy. And he calls that reform with his so called VP choice. This is what happens all the time. The facts are floating but we do not wanna think outside the box. Why?

NonNaiveAmerican   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

The Palin strategy is working only because it has appealed to individuals who wanted a reason to cheer for McCain but there was not enough there to make them stand up and cheer. This includes the Republican Base. Palin gives these individuals something to stand up and cheer about, whatever that maybe. As an American I plead with everyone to not be caught up in the pomp & circumstance of this election. Mcain is running for President. Obama is running for President. Their plans for my future, your future, your childrens future and your grandchildrens future are far too important. We can not risk or afford to have a continuance of what we have had for the last eight years. You would not marry someone after knowing them for a couple of days and then bring them home and say family meet your new Mom/Dad, trust me he/she really is qualified to take care you. Now this has nothing to do with how great the new spouse may or may not be, this goes directly to the decision made by the head of household. As a member of this great Country, the great State of Texas, the great City of Katy, and the Head of my Family I should never have to be forced to accept a decision that was based on a gut feeling. Thank God Almighty we are a Democratic Nation where we have the option to cheer on a popular canditate or Vote on a Presidential Caniditate. When all the cheering is done and it is time to Vote, I pleade with my fellow Americans to look at both Presidential Canditates with explicit detail, especially their economic plans. You will see that both candidates are, now, advocating change. You will also see that there has been, and still is, only one Presidential Candidate vying for change that benefits our American Families, that Presidential Canditate is "Senator Barack Obama".
Barack should be encourage to stay the course and keep promoting his policies for change. He should continue to be the leader we want to Vote for not cheer for. We truly need him for change in all of our lives.
So let the Republicans focus on playing games , and cheering, while we focus on getting the Votes out for our Presidential Canditate, "Senator Barack Obama".

NotNaiveAmerican

Joseph   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

John McCain and his crew have run the dirtiest, mosty dishonest campaign I've ever seen and somehow, they get away with it. And as more and more comes out about Gov. Palin's record and the shenanigans she pulled up in Alaska, and the lies about "The Bridge to Nowhere" among others, if this is what we want a heartbeat away from the presidency, well, I am dumfounded.

Todd Heap   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

Bill – "Spoken like a true Democrat!"

He speaking about young people and last I checked "Cool" is a term used in the young community. I guess Republicans are too stiff to use the term.

James Cox   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

I stopped blogging just to hear him

Carly   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

S Morgan, Obama was in New York and wasn't just having lunch. You know something significant happened in New York on 9/11 too!

Dan   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

I hope that McCain didn't just plan this forum to steal Obama's ideas to use as his own in the debates.

glen   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

After viewing the life story on Senator McCain on Cnn I have come to the conclusion that he is a very ungrateful or appreciative of his first wife’s dedication and devotion toward him. To come back from a war and have extra marital affairs says a lot about his morals and his conduct. If you are not dedicated to the one who love you how can you be
dedicated to your country.

SC   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

Obama is so much more nuanced. He also listens, and is willing to listen. If you had both candidates in the room and someone started telling a long and involved story, who would engage the person? Obama would. He is inspiring and would inspire all Americans.

Wisconsin_Dem_Erich   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

Obama needs to start going after all the lies being told by the McCain/Palin camp. They are getting away with wayyyyyyy too much. it's time to show America what liars McCain and Palin are!

Sandy   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

So what if He talks that way, He problably spoke like that all his life. If Obama likes to think before He speaks thats ok with me, because you all know if He jumps out and mispoke you would be down His throat. Face it Obama is in this position because the peopleand Deligates spoke, like it or not. People are trying to find all kinds negatives on McCain and Obama, I look at them as Humans and not Gods therefore can make mistakes and have a change of heart. No person on this Blog is perfect so stop the whining and get on the issues.

Jim   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

do you Barack wants to be a president that inspires people? He must have said it 20 times tonight.

Barbara   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

Okay, what is everybody rating it???

Jeremiah   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

I think it's hard to think about volunteering when you are working 2+ jobs and having a hard time paying bills. There's a severe moral issue here, I think that most people are so down in the "dumps" that the issue of serving our country is very disconnected from the average american. Im only 25 but my father who is twice my age has never seen this country in such bad shape.

American   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

I just had a funny thought. I wonder how Sarah Palin would answer these questions.

Dexter   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

Good one Paul!

Nick G   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

Sarah Palin is nothing more than what Spiro Agnew was to Richard Nixon. She will do all the dirty work so McCain won't have to and look bad. It's a shame that Americans let hype and trash talking control their emotions and good judgement, instead of taking a deep look at the candidates and what they are offering. We need to vote for what is in our best interest of our country whether you are a Democrat or a Republican and not let distractions and pity comments or hype distract us from the real issues.

I WANT THE TRUTH   September 11th, 2008 9:42 pm ET

Amy we are not downplaying the Military in fact we are doing the exact opposite, but it is not hte only service.

Skip   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Not impressed with Obama...

Tera   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Sa, I'm so glad you said that. No one can put a definition on what it is to be an American. Thanks for saying it!!!!!

Colt   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

When Obama was cheered by one girl when he mentioned energy independence–McCain is aiming for the same thing also.

Jamie   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Good question for Senator Obama:

You benefited form affirmative action in your younger years and look where you are today. But America has changed since your youth. Today, what are your feelings about affirmative action and do you think it has helped foster instances of reverse discrimination?

Tria   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Why is it ok for for the government to build a bigger army, but not for the government to fund community more service programs? This country has spent enough talent and treasure on war, why shouldn't our Government focus on helping Americans, not just preparing for the next war?

Kim-Canada   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Obama says he'd like to lead by inspiring, I think he inspires just be running for president

Andrew   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

I am a college student and listening to Obama, I can tell that he is speaking from the heart. It was terrific!

Kathy   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

We all need to be inspired to serve; the young with their ideology, and us oldsters who see the finish line coming up fast. I work with inner city kids trying to get through their first semester of college. Now that is inspiring. AND they are all doing community service as well.

RAY PADGETT   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

The event was too short ... a shame

RDas   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Instead of conducting staged, phony and divisive debates, you media barons should consider doing more of these presidential forums that Judy Woodruff and Rick Stengel just did. I got a great sense of each candidate without the constant one-upmanship that debates create. Each person got a chance to present their ideas without any interruptions and in a civil atmosphere. –Obama supporter

Pat, Fayetteville, NC   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Roland,

How could you go in a booth and vote for George Bush for governor of Texas? His ego will not permit him to acknowledge that he may be wrong about a matter. During his term as governor, he could not bring himself to believe that some of the prisoners sentenced to death may have been innocent. His inability to acknowledge an error has sent thousands of young men and women in harms way to Badraq. And to end it all, neither he nor his VP served in a war when they had the opportunity – Vietnam!

Killings in Badraq have eased up, but that will not change the horrific damage to human life that has already occurred.

STB   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

jopat and others-

I happen to be one of those that gets scared by short succinct questions to complex issues. It means the politician doesn't understand the complexities or doesn't think that I could. Either should scare people.

I am consistently impressed with the depth and breadth of Obama's answers. Not only the depth of knowledge expressed on the issue but the ability to show how any given issue effects others.

Sean

Beverly Combs   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

How can it be that the chairman of the Republican Party in Macomb County, Michigan, a key swing county in a key swing state, is planning to use a list of foreclosed homes to block people from voting in the upcoming election as part of the state GOP's effort to challenge some voters on Election Day. "We will have a list of foreclosed homes and will make sure people aren't voting from those addresses," party Chairman James Carabelli told Michigan Messenger in a telephone interview earlier this week. –per Citizens For Legitimate Government, article by Eartha Jane Melzer on Sept. 10, 2008, Michigan Republicans plan to foreclose African-American voters. Lose your house, lose your vote.

Russ   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Where's Obama going with the service speech?? He got paid as a community organizer right?? How is that service??

Ann   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

yak, yak, yak. If Obama's not giving a speech, he just stumbles on his words. He changes the subject when he doesn't have an answer and he definitely talks as a community leader...not a President. The President of the United States hires people to do this job, he doesn't have time to do it himself. If Obama were to win the Presidency I envision him hiring someone else to make the though "presidential" decisions while he takes on the task of inspiring young people to serve. Yep, he's just a community organizer.

Lee   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Barack = Boring

mark   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Do any of the canidates send their kids to public schools. Someone find out.

Deborah Walker   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

I see the America I want to believe in in Senator Obama AND I am working triple time to help achieve that vision of America. I don't see myself in the America that the Republicans describe. In fact , the rhetoric of McCain/Palin and the Republican strategist s scare me badly. Their ways of being evoke "base fear" and I don't want to contribute to that fear. I'd rather fight for hope of another way of being as a country, in the spirit of John F. Kenndy, Martin Luther King, Jr., Robery Kennedy, AND all of those who fought and died on America soil as well as the soils of other countries to have the UNITED STATES of AMERICA operate as an inclusive nation. Obama and Biden stay the course....keep on inspiring us to be better.

Teddy   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Wooo, great forum

ChrisParks, Buffalo NY   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Bay,

Obama may have chosen an insider - but Biden is one who is independent of the bs and who knows how to get things done!!

Carl   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Change starts from the inside out...........He is out of touch..............Simply superficial............

Mike, Syracuse NY   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

I believe Obama probably believes most of waht he's saying. There's just nothing in his history that says he can achieve 10% of what he says he will. Idealism without ability is just wishfull thinking.

Chris Durham North Carolina   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Oh, but we can afford a 10 billion dollar a month war from McCain??!! BK get real!!! Find another excuse cause Conservitives haven't been fiscally responsible since Reagan!!

Candy Crowley, CNN Sr. Political Correspondent   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

A gracious moment for Obama: talking about young people being inspired by McCain’s story, there are no digs - nothing. Usually on the campaign trail he begins with: We honor John McCain for his HALF CENTURY of service.

MLB   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Roland, I'm not so sure. People are intrigued by Obama and love to listen to him speak. I wouldn't be surprised if folks were flipping back and forth between the forum and another program while McCain was on... waiting for Obama to take his turn.

freedomanjel   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Yes! A world, not as it is, but as it should be!!

lostinthemadness   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

By the way, not to slam veterans because as I stated I am a veteran, my husband is a veteran, my only child is actively serving and has just return from a one year deployment in the war, my father and brother served and retired from the military as well as my husband. I have many friends that served. However, not one of them would qualify as president. I am totally confused. McCain is best to serve as president because of his POW experience. One thing I remember on his bio is during his POW experience 5.5 years of captivity he was not aware of anything that was going on in America during his time. Which I believe was a critical time in America and it gave us a different perspective on wars. Just because America deem it necessary to go and fight wars does not make it right. I would be more afraid of McCain being our president because I am not sure he was not emotionally affected by his POW experience. His behavior from my perspective appears to be labile and unpredictable. His JUDGEMENT is so in question. Please someone lets talk in terms of reality and truth. Some folks are serving because the military is the only one who is HIRING!

May   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

The difference between Obama's style and McCains is Obama treats all of us citizens like we are intelligent and can understand his points.

Mary Jo Raulerson   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

My son is currently serving with the TN National Guard, now deployed to Louisiana in support of efforts to recover from Gustav. The way it looks now, they will probably be needed following Hurricane Ike, as they served following Hurricane Katrina. He served in Iraq on a fuel convoy in 2003. I want to thank both candidates for their support of our military men and women. My son had never expressed one moment of regret for volunteering to serve in any capacity needed. As Senatory McCain said, the reward of serving a cause greater than themselves is why they do it. Senator Obama's support of military service, and the need to recruit from all segments of society was also most appreciated by those of us whose children are willing to lay down their lives for the right of those who disagree to be free to do so.

spiveyivey   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Obama is on tonight!! And especially appealing to the youth! It helps he will be on SNL this Saturday as well! More youth apeal!

chris   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

watching this, I'm thinking that they're both pretty good in their own different ways. But McCain is totally isolated amongst the GOP, and a president has to work as leader of a team. Good guy doesn't mean good team, and we all know how atrocious the McCain team is, so definitely Obama 08...

From New York   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Laura from Boston

didn't you get it??? First, the "war" between Obama and Clinton was for the primary...of course they fight against each other, it was like a competition...then..did you get the lipstik to a pig?? Obama was refering not to this woman caming from nowhere, but to the repubblican party and just in case Palin was not the pig, but the lipstik....She started this silly story of the lipstik...and American women looooooooooooooved it.....Please....be more flaxible!!!

Cheryl   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Speaking of education, what will Senator Obama do to protect the future of students by preventing a school system from losing its accreditation, when the problem is with the school board and not the students?

Paul Gillham   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

If John McCain wins this election, I think people will look back at the Saddleback forum as the beginning of his turnaround. This forum is basically a draw, and very dry. No change of momentum. McCain rolls on.

Drich   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

We live in a society that is aroused by what they see, especially where I come from(SE Washington DC) If the Government does make it a bit more flashy or cool but diciplined...then I think it would have better numbers. I think the military commercials do fine though.

Mike in Chicago   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Bay Buchanan said: this forum is not going to change a vote.

That's a republican strategist's way of saying that Obama has done much better than McCain in this forum.

Bill Schneider,
CNN Sr. Political Analyst
  September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Like a good Democrat, Obama wants government to be a source of inspiration.

That's not something Republicans talk about.

mk   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

What is Obama talking about, he makes no sense, please give this man a telepromter.

mary   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

What a bore Mccain was!!!!! He had no specific answers for any of the questions that were asked. He side swiped all questions. Do not vote for mccain. if you heard palins interview she could not answer any foreign question. Does American really want this woman to be a hearbeat away from the presidency.. I don't agree with her shooting innocent moose and to have her kids particpate. She wants to kill polar bears, does not believe in pro choice,

Sydney   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

I disagree with Bay. Everytime a canadate goes out on the media circle, they have an oppurtunity to either keep, gain, or lose a vote. Right now, I believe that Obama, with his thoughtful ideas and specific comments, he is earning some votes.

LouAnn   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

When Obama talks, he inspires me. He makes me want to go out into my community and join an organization to help in some way to make things better right where I live. I truly believe that if he is elected, things will change. People will start to pull together and community service will go through the roof. I definitely think he can accomplish what he wants to. He is a very inspiring man.

Erica Perez   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

I'm not real experienced in politics and stuff but it seems weird to me that the McCain people wouldn't let anyone ask Sarah Palin questions when she was out with John McCain. Then they had to get her all prepared and stuff for one interview. If she's so ready to lead, why couldn't she just be like the other candidates and get out there and answer questions from reporters and people, like all the others?

Tom   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

This is why Obama wont debate McCain 1 on 1.

Irinna   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Military service is regarded as unique in that we who serve swear an oath to protect and defend our country. And that's what we do. It's our mission. We serve our nation proudly.

Those who contribute public volunteer service don't swear an oath to protect and defend our country.

That's the difference. McCain's been there....Palin's son is being deployed. McCain and Palin both know (will know) the stresses that go with having a child in a combat zone. Unless you have that perspective, it's truly difficult to understand what it's all about....

B. Harrison   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

I love this live blogging. Why don't we do this more often?

me   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

I was waching Obama and I don't believe his ready to be president .
No I do not support specific tax for the military. I do not support Obama at all.

Dan   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Roland is so jaded.

Carl   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Roland, I agree with David. Obama "learned something" alright, how to lay it on thicker and heavier as he goes along. He's jsut to smooth for my liking And all has answers are, "government, government, government". That's just too much!

Lisa   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Bay,

Why are you always trying to sell Palin? Is it because you know we aren't buying her?

Chris   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

JFK wouldn't have supported REVERSE DISCRIMINATION, BAMA!

Angry, Gun toting, Bibli thumping, white male   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

Hey bill Schneider, what exactly has obama laid out in the way of a program except change? what will he change? from what to what?
1045 I enlisted in the USMC. When did the obama enlist? in which branch?
What has he ever done for his country?

Roman   September 11th, 2008 9:41 pm ET

You know, it's real nice to actually hear someone explain their answer instead of giving me some quick line that they don't know what it means or talk like they have no clue.

I've had to live with a president who does that for 4 years now!

Roger   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Mr Obama: To acknowledge the number of people in this country who have no health insurance, and to do NOTHING about it is disgusting and unacceptable. Only third world countries don't have the resources to administer healthcare to their citizens! First we need to determine who is being enriched by the current system; the heads of health insurance companies are paid an obscene amount of money; lawyers have positioned themselves in the mix(little that is good can come from this); many of the insurance companies are non-profit and yet pay millions to their officers(obviously disposing of profits); patients need to be screened for wasting the system's money for lack of care and knowledge of good health; etc . . . . I believe that the Federal Government cannot administer a satisfactory system of health care! It must be organized in small enough regions to be policed by the Federal Government, but administered by states. Whatever system is proposed for universal health coverage needs to be protected from rape by the people who are covered, in order for it to survive without becoming a burden to taxpayers.

Brooklyn Girl   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Obama did not answer the question about why he chose not to serve in the military. If he did not want to join the military, then how can he inspire others to do it. Obama made a mistake in saying that he once thought of serving in the military because it makes him look less patriotic than McCain.

Tom from NJ   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

To Bill Schneider and Candy Crowley;

Of course Senator Obama feels much more at ease here;
He's not being challenged to THINK; he can just talk, talk, talk without being questioned or the content of his responses being challenged.

That's the best thing for him; the commentators are doing a miserable job.

Iteachoneofu   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

I have so much respect for Mr. Obama. Helping others who may not have the strength to help themselves is a great blessing on both sides. I went back to teach at the inner-city school I attended as a child. The housing project where I grew up is directly across the street from the school. My students tell me how bad it is living there now. When I tell students I grew up over there, they are in disbelief. Then, they see there is hope. I am rewarded daily when I see my children strive and rise to meet the high expectations. God saw fit to bless me with a wonderful single mom, who really worked hard to raise my siblings and I. I'm blessed and fortunate to be able to be of service to my students and their families.

Ragan Walker   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Is it just me or is the GOP trying to pull one over on the "blue collar" Americans. Its funny that they dressed up all of Bush-Cheney ideals in a dress and now its considered change?! It took me awhile to support Barack Obama, but as a former Hilary supporter its insulting that the GOP thinks that nominating a female VP is going to sway my vote! This election is between John McCain and Barack Obama-–Wake up America and lets wipe the lipstick off of the McCain campaign.

Scott   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Look, we need a Democrat in the white house for a while. We have been focused on foreign affairs for the last 8 years, what say we focus on the good ole' USA for a while, get your bridges and roads in shape, help our own people and make this place worth living in again.

Laurie   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Obama is speaking very thoughtfully, but what I am hearing is a whole lot of talk about government expansion. To some, this may be welcome. To others, this is a major red flag.

rose   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

I hate to burst everyone's bubble but John Kennedy got us into the Viet Nam war...

NY Dem   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Obama is doing a WONDERFUL job tonight!! He is laying out his plans effectively and thoughtfully. He is giving us specifics and straight answers.

Kathleen   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

vision, vision, vision.....that is what we need....

Snoozi   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Both candidates have done a good job of talking about public and non-profit based srvice to this country, the difference is Obama has walked the walk. What , afterhis military sevice has john mccain done in the private or non-profit service areas? And what is his stance on taking care of our military after they come home or move back in to the private secter. Obama has shown what he brings to the table, McCain would go on in the same vein that we do now. Our responsibility to these brave men and women does not stop when they leave the military

Nicole in Ga   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

We can afford Obama and his programs once we stop spending 10 billion dollars a month in Iraq.

I WANT THE TRUTH   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

i noticed BAy does not have much to say anymore whats wrong Bay ? Still picking your mouth up off the ground. We know he did EXCELLENT!! Its okay to admit it. Democrats don't hold grudges we might even be able to use your help when your ready to come to the good team.

Tina   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

I hope that you post my comment, please. I have been asking myself how can these campaigns spend so much money in negativism and not in services? I'm idealistic. I believe that in setting the example and let it speak by itself.

Thanks.

William Dalton   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Bay Buchana- I agree completely. This forum almost seems like a waste of time- just the candidates rehashing their obvious support for American patriotism on the commemoration of 9/11.

As for which of the two candidates is the better possible president, the choice is clear; John McCain. His experience, realistic view of the problems facing the country, and his realistic answers are far superior to those of Barack Obama, who answers to what he thinks the populace wants, and knows doesn't need. McCain's plans for the economy, education, healthcare system, foreign relations, and a new reformed maverick government are what the country needs. And don't get me started on the energy crisis Obama plans on 'solving' by taxing the oil companies, which, must I remind the economically blind democrats, has been PROVEN to fail! I wish people would see beyond the obvious and look at what will work.

Red State Tex   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Obama can Talk the Talk, but Sarah Plain WALK'S the WALK.

Christian, Tampa FL   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

It's true! The Obama Campaign does work us like dogs! But it's extremely empowering work and frankly I enjoy being pushed out of my comfort zone to do what I believe is right.

mary derricotte   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

I think John McCain better watch his back, today she told Charlie Gibson in an interview she is ready to be President. This chick is a by any means necessary. She power hungyr and is going to disrupt his bid for the Whie House

KofTX   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Jopat,

I think what you're trying to articulate is Obama is reflective and thoughtful. McCain is spontaneous and rash at times.

I'm so sick of fellow Americans hating a person because they are SMART AND NUANCED!

Obama was president of the Harvard Law review...DON'T HATE HIM FOR IT.

This is like high school all over again...Nerds vs. Jocks, blah, blah, blah...

SEA   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Roland: LOL @ your Hillary comment~your being messy now!

Kevin   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

My father always told me: "In the last days, men will become so wise in their own eyes, they will become as fools". Mr. Obama, you are that man.

zina   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Obama is wonderful with the specifics tonight!

Roland/Bay – What do each of you think of his defense and critique of the Republicans Convention's belittling of community organizers?

Lady   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

I personally believe Obama and McCain are sincere candidates. I also sincerely believe that Obama is the man whom we need as President bc he realizes the changes and programs needed to really help Americans function and be productive...not a three hundred dollar refund. What does that really do for us in the long run?

Michelle in Los Angeles   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

McCain and his party are pure evil. All you have to do to know this to be true is listen to the evil spirited words that come out of their mouths. They talk about crusing evil, and refuse to "stand up" to those that speak hate and practice racism.

Sarah is a joke. Sure she energized the party, they were starving, starving people eat anything. They have no standards, they will fall for anything. "The proof is in the pudding". She has neither said or done anything to qualify her as VP, and McCain has clearly shown bad judgement in picking her. In addition, the hyporocracy – wanting to draw the crowds he critized Barack for. +
cCain is old, tired, ub-educated, and part of the past. He has gotten this far on luck.

We need a president that is part of the future. One that is computer literate. One that is liked around the world, and can restore America to its mountain top.

Typical White Person   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

All of these opportunities exist already. Forced volunteerism in schools and calling it "community service" is ridiculous. Present the opportunities and let people decide what they want to do.

al   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Why is John McCain hiding behind Sarah Palin's skirt, Sarah has 5 kids of her own she doesn't need another child.

I thought John McCain was looking for a VP, now it turns out that he was really looking for a new mommy.

Reagan   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

I would like to point out that Obama's big sell idea regarding seniors volunteering at schools is already going on. My 12 year old in a very blue collar rural school has met people such as Neil Armstrong,retired and active politicians, professional athletes, Chess champions etc.

I am hearing nothing other than America needs around 900 trillion dollars to support these programs he is throwing up there? Can he make it rain gum drops too?

CW in DC   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Bill, what's wrong with the government being "cool" again? I know when I was 13-14 working with the summer youth employment program he in DC (back when there was funding for it), I worked with the government, and I did feel it was a cool place to work. If there was more positive outlook on what the government has to offer, maybe there wouldn't be so many that are leary and suspicious of the government.

Bill Hodges   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

How about this to all of my anti-tax friends (yea, you, Grover Norquist):

If we care about the military so much, would you support a specific tax that would go only to the members of the military that would significantly raise their pay and benefits?

There are plenty of programs that are not working that would more than cover this cost without adding more taxes.

Whitney   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

When will the media begin to outline the issues, rather than getting caught up in the "star of the hour" and all of the other related nonsense? All I have heard about is Palin for the last two weeks, without any regard or questions concerning the issues that matter most to me as a voter: the economy, education, our crumbling infrastructure, energy, and the ongoing wars. Come on. I'm not trying to "media-bash"- but I don't want to hear a year from now about how our economy is still stuck in reverse and McCain/Palin have no idea how to proceed. Let's be a little more analytic upfront, folks, while your vote still counts.

JAD   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

You are correct BK he has no clue what it will cost to do what he has told everyone he wants to do. He needs to take time off and get a real job and pay bills like the rest of us. Learn to budget.

Lily   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Obama is doing great....and he's so more specific than McCain. Obama has a clear vision.

Dexter   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Roland, do you think Obama just made a mistake by giving mayors that much credit with Sarah Palin as a former mayor?

PLEASE POST THIS!

Shannon from Oklahoma   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Obama is doing great tonight! His answers are very consistent and thoughtful.

Ruth   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

I LOVE it that Barack listens to the questions and answers them, not just spouting a stump speech. I respect this man SO much. He will get my vote even though the demographic folks tell me I'm not supposed to be on his side since I am a 63 year old white evangelical voter.

I believe Obama. I do not believe McCain. How could I when he has not only run a campaign totally opposite to what he promised, but stolen all of the themes from Obama for which he once mocked him. Does he think we the electorate are so ignorant that we can't see through this?

AP   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Obama is doing very well. Lot's of policy specifics as well as the larger "vision."

Press McDowell   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Remember, Martin Lither King was a community organizer, the rights for women to vote was started with community organizers and remember the United States was started by a group of community organizers.

Onyeka   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Come on David! When Obama speaks, everyone want to stop and listen. I feel that Obama does speaks from the heart and is genuine.

This man is focus today, he came with a plan and McCain came with jokes.

michael   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Roland...if they commited to a civil "Issue" only campaign then neither of them would win...Ralph Nader would. Elections stopped being about issues many years ago. Now its about who can get more popular and get more press coverage. Obama won more press that Hillary and now Palin is getting more press than Obama.

Vets for Obama   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

I guess I need to o over to FOX they seem to be more balanced these days

Andrew   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

This double talk is dizzying in the fact that he keeps saying all the answers will come from Washington but if you really want it fixed act locally? Sounds like more broken programs that fix nothing to come and we are on our own.

Lori   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

McCain wins this forum hands down. Did Obama answer any of the questions decisively? McCain emphasized that he did not want to make a bigger government with service oriented careers. Obama wants to clean up Washington and make government bigger?

Kap   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

ROLAND I agree with you that all types of service are righteous and that we shouldent get into a comparison game..that being said dont you amdit that there is something very special about doing service in the millitary esppecially these those men and women and putting thier lives at risk for the ENTIRE country.

Kevin   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Roland, as usual you are on point.

Ben K   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Folks, this is why we like Roland. His bias may be obvious, but he unlike many on the left and the right, he'll call out his candidate.

Sarahkatheryn   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

"we sell too many of our citizens short... they want to be involved"

actually true – today's 18-29 year olds are more active in volunteerism than any other generation.

Joe   September 11th, 2008 9:40 pm ET

Bay, would you ever admit when Obama does or says something good? :-)

Mshauri   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

lol. wow.. to think that someone actually believes that McCain is more genuine than Obama... Now, thats a scary thought!!!

Go Obama

An Engineer from
California

Rob   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Sorry but Obama can unite the country and McCain cannot. Oh here is a question referring to Palin. Obama should stay away from that subject. I cannot understand why the R's don't speak the truth on her. She is not qualified. Period!!! It was clearly a political pick and it will put the country in grave danger. The Republican ticket are not Mavericks they are Storytellers. Stories about how they run a clean campaign, stories about how they will clean-up Washington when they have been the party responsible for the divide in this country. Oh the hyprocisy.......I loved Jon Stewart's show showing the hyprocisy of the R's with Rove, O'Rielly.

EJ (USA)   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

I liked Obama's line about how paying attention is a big part of citizenship. Not enough people even pay attention.

Mark   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

So...is anyone going to ask Senator Obama if he heard the questions posed to Senator McCain beforehand? Are you not wanting to 'rock' the boat with someone you are backing? Simple question that can illucidate the voters about someone's character.

As Roland noted...it appears that Senator Obama 'watched the tape"

C'mon...ask the question!

Jenny in CA   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Obama just sounds much more in tuned with EVERYONE is America and he is more understanding. McCain is still learning the Internet...like that commerical (I just discovered the Internet)

McCain is all about Military & thinks the private sector will step in and do it all in place of Government...Please..spare me

Brandon_MI   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

I agree with Barbara, Roland, and Julius. Some of you are confusing throughtfulness with "long and winding" or somehow being less "genuine" than McCain. Your partisanship is showing. Obama is doing great tonight.

Jim   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Bay- I agree... Tonight really isn't anything new and won't change a vote... actually the monerator's seem bored (Judy looking away)...

Snow97   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Two teensy points:

(1) Just because anyone CAN be President as a matter of federal constitutional theory doesn't mean that any one SHOULD be President as a matter of national interest. If you are ill-informed about the nuances in policy affecting our national security, international obligations, and domestic financial condition, you should reconsider running for office - for the sake of your country, which deserves the best brains for the job.

(2) It IS harder than rocket science. I'm so tired of hearing anti-intellectualism bandied about as if it were an all-sufficient virtue. There's a difference between what is NECESSARY to being elected (i.e., being a person the ave voter wants to have a beer with) and what is SUFFICIENT (i.e., having the judgment to weigh options, having the background to make decisions based upon some iota of personal knowledge).

thad   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

How can we put a man into office with no experience? If you look at a real job interview, who would you want? Look at the resume's.
Not even a contest.
we need a real person in office. WE NEED PALIN!!!

Loyal American123   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

How may of you would like to have yopur share of the Social Security Trust fund invested in Fannie Mae, Lehman, Bear Stearns etc as President Bush promised you was best for your retirement?

Jim   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

This forum makes it clear, that if Obama had accepted McCain's invitation to do joint town-hall appearances, we would have had a more positive and more constructive presidential campaign.

Carl   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

How many times has Obama visited Iraq? Words, Words, How is the main question?

Wendy in NC   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Sen. Obama has such a global view on everything, his intelligence just amazes me and I am inspired just listening to him. I was a Paramedic and EMS professional for 31 years, about 1/3 of that was as a volunteer and I finally hear a candidate acknowledge that as service to my country. Thank you, Sen. Obama.

BK   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Did Obama request that him and McCain not be on stage together? I think Obama is scared of McCain.

sa   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

i am not sure why some Americans perceive community service as some elitist idea or obama as not genuine. Are small towns that suspicious of the rest of the country. You can't monopolize what it means to be an American.

Eric   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

David, McCain does not/has not answered the question. He plays dodge ball!

charles yancey   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Heck, I think it's more important to find out why the press has been silenced on the breaking story yesterday of Corruption within the Government employee's and the oil companies employee's – sex & drugs and illegal contracts? How could it dissapear overnight? Not a peep anywhere! We live in a country where the Government censors our news to keep themselves out of trouble – shame!!

Roland Martin,
CNN Political Analyst
  September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Great point, Paul!

Wish I would have thought of that one.

You get the gold star...for the moment.

Who can top Paul's observation?

GOP for obama   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

How can you guys not like this inspirational JFK figure..

Yaz   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Kudos!!!!! Obama didn"t take the bait. Mayors in small towns and community activists roles are very important in this great land.

Fabian   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

I guess I came from a different stock where self sacrifice for your country means something. Where you give up the comforts of your home and family and possibly not come home one day to your loved ones. Sorry but you cant compare Peace Corps to dodging bullets in combat.

Brad   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Candidates have mentioned service – why can't we get out welfare recepients (those that are able), to previde some form of service in exchange for their welfare? In addition to their contribution, it may also provide them with training and connections for gainful employment...

jt-msp   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

I think that Obama is right and McCain can't keep his promises and Obama can keep his word.
Now thats in my oppinion but you might think differently.

Sarah- ARIZONA   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

obama is totally genuine David.

dont be dizzy from obamas answers.... when theres an easy answer to a question ur not getting it right.

things are too complicated these days.

obama is a philosopher.. he thinks things through and makes u think abt what u should do also

turtleposer   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

What's so bad about Barack Obama's thinking before speaking? Thinking before doing? Knowing what is going on first before deciding a course of action?

Isn't it more shallow to spout platitudes & rigid ideology the way McCain often does?

Penny in NC   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Obama, If you could put a committee together to take on the task of healthcare for everyone, who would you ask to head this group?

Maggie   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Obama sounds fresh and smart and the real "change" candidate to me. McCain on the other hand, gave the "right" answers, but really without the actions to back it up – his campaign has been run very dirty and all his speakers mocked community service at the rnc. Obama definitely wins on this forum and in fact, appears very presidential.

Monica, Texas   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Obama's "Making Gov't cool again" was the statement of the night....

Tracy   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Oh Kay, YOU ARE SO WRONG! This forum will change quite a few votes, from McCain to Obama!

From Chicago   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Guess what folks... the money for all these "community service" ideas Obama has... is going to come from your taxes!

Ed   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

This most disturbing part about McCain and Palin in regards to service is their war for war's sake mentality. He wants an endless war in the Middle East and she wants to have Georgia join NATO just so we can attack Russia. These Republicans are to expensive for the American working person.

and beside, John McCain is 5% maverick and 95% Bush league.

dcloye   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

BK – in some ways, "we" are performing service to the country by working hard enought TO "afford" government programs.

Aubrey   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

As a very moderate democrat, it took me a long time to get behind Obama

Leah DiMarco, Texas   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Senator Obama is much more interesting to listen to than listening to McCain's canned answers. Senator Obama truly does inspire and makes a person think about the future and what our great country can do.

David   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

I looked up Socialism in the thesaurus and it has COOL listed.

April in Texas   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

People can volunteer watching a neighbors child or something or shopping for an elderly neighbor it doesnt matter how big or small the task is but its the generocity of doing something for another. People pick up on that and it can be contagious..

Wade   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Obama has won my vote. I want the government to be "cool" again.

freedomanjel   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Sorry y'all, Obama gets it when it comes to community service and he will bring about the change in our communities that is so desperately needed!!

gerri   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Thanks for helping me make up my mind.Your moderator just did it for me,I will vote for Nader.

flabbergasted   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Scripted much? Ms. Palin is clearly very good at doing, saying and being exactly what she is told to by the Big Boys in the Big League. And the Republicans dare to call this progress for women? We need a vice president, not a spokesmodel (we have Cindy for that...)

Cody   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

Could an effective analogy for Gov. Palin be an armchair quarterback? She has no federal or international relations experience to speak of yet she feels an effective strategy for dealing with former Soviet States is to admit them into NATO then defend them. The possibly of her running the country (McCain is quite old) would be akin to ESPN holding a lottery to see which lucky viewer may be the head coach on Superbowl Sunday.

Chris   September 11th, 2008 9:39 pm ET

I am 17 years old and this is the opportunity of a lifetime for anybody my age and a year older of course. Barack wants to pull in and work with the people that are going to shape this nation. We won't even need to be part of government anymore in order to make sure our voices are heard...Sarah Palin and Rudy Giuliani need to quit talking down on community organization, because it is truly what drives the ideas of American innovation all across the nation...- "Walking a straight line in a crooked world"- Barack Obama on his high school newspaper staff.

Blair for Illinois   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

No bill, alot of america knows what a community organizer is. The question is, how does that give him experience to be PRESIDENT? That's great that he has done it, but if I'm not mistaken, Roland has family that are community organizers, are they qualified to be president??

Kathleen   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

"it takes a village"

Kujo   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

Roland,

Would not mattered if the moderator asked them to commit to continuing a civil tone....

the If Obama said "I ate Pigs in the blanket for dinnner", then the McCains camp would say that was racist and Obama promised, then Obama's camp would say bla bla bla

it would be over before the weekend.

An American (independent thinker)   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

Bay, we knew that already. You only care about votes however you can get them...What about the country, do you really care? Or just about your party winning?

spiveyivey   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

Paul - You're still watching so I don't buy what you're saying!

Laura   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

I had a phone call. What did Obama say when asked whether he thought that Sara Palin's being a mayor is also important service?

Kathleen   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

I wish the media as a whole would focus on the campaign issues and the policies these politicians intend to institute. There is so much focus on the rhetoric and "juicy" tidbits of these peoples lives, there is little substance given to their actual plans. I believe a persons past decisions give a good inclining as to how they will make decisions in the future but we need to look more closely at what they intend to do if elected. If the media would report on the issues that truly matter, we would all be more well informed voters.

DREW79   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

What a great Interview we should do this everyday until the election

larry (WV)   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

I think the reason he is doing better here it is more of a neutral setting. Saddleback were evangelical's wanting him to burst into flames.

SEA   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

BK...Well, we certainly can't afford the non-existence of any program except War which has been the norm under the last eight years of Republician rule: $8+ trillion dollars and counting? I'll take the programs of Obama anyday.

Confused   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

When are we gonna stop arguing about more or less government and start talking about getting it to work.

Carl   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

What about a "Fair Tax"?

Sierra   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

If you are going to moderate my Palin comments you should moderate them all including the very first post.

Shame on you CNN!

Lisa in Ga   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

If you say so Paul.. but I see u r still watching it!

Susan   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

This forum is a waste of the candidates and my time. Barrack is doing well. Why are they not talking about the issues. It seems as if McCain is giving a stomp speech. Ombama is at lest trying ti inspire.

NY Dem   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

BAY– The point of this forum is to come together and talk about SERVING OUR COUNTRY. Who cares if votes change based on tonight?? Are you republicans that obsessed with the polls? What about Country First?

erik e   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

you guys at cnn call yourselves the best political team on tv. start throwing inside and hard at all 4 of these candidates on where they stand on issues, including and especially sarah palin. you should all in the media be outraged at the sequester of palin by the mcain campaign. how can the american people put their lives and trust in a person to lead who doesnt have the stones or feel in her duty as a candidate to respond to their issues. where does she stand on poverty, crime, homelessness, abrtion, civil rights, infrasructure, health care, aids in the inner cities and the world. this is your job, this is what we americans expect of our news outlets. for gods sake you live here too right? this next pick affects you too right? stand up for america for once and not your corperate bosses. not to do so questions all of your patriotism and loyalty to this country and all that waych your station for info. ENOUGH!!!!!!!!

EJ (USA)   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

Very nice Obama. Very nice.

AP (ATL)   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

I think there will be a new campaign on the issues from this point forward. The Silly Season is over...at least for Obama's camp. Watch and see...

mobiusinformer   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

Good idea, RM!

Maybe, just maybe, the better question would be to the candidates:

What have they DONE since September 11, 2007 aside from TALK and self-promote?

They're both a little thin in that area considering the influence they have.

bob   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

obama;s change change change , bush bush bush, obama stop hiding behind a bush, and the only change abama is going to make is to change the name of the whitehouse, to the cribbbbbbbbb

D   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

He even knows the name of the French scholar! This guy is brilliant

Michael   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

I thought this Forum was a great opportunity for both candidates to reflect back on a national tragedy and more importantly lay down a plan for dealing with another in the future.

TLeigh   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

Generally speaking:

I am glad Palin is on the ticket for VP basically because HIllary should have been on it. I think both females are strong, gutsy and needed somewhere in the whitehouse other than just standing there and waving. I wish the media would quit picking on Palin and get past the "fresh meat" syndrome. Lets concentrate on what is good for America.

When it comes to Obama and McCain – First they can't promise anything because it has to go through Congress, so it is very foolish to promise anything...I get that. I don't really care who served and who didn't....I am eternally grateful for our soldiers and appreciate the freedon that they provide.....that said it should not be the deciding factor here. As an American I want to know who has it on their agenda to tackle; Healthcare; Job stability in the US; Decreasing our deficit; and who is willing to work with other countries and concentrate on peace and stop threatening war at every turn. I am sick of the US being viewed as the big bully. We represent Freedom and Prosperity. Interesting our jobs are going to the Middle East ...the same place the terrorists came from and have tested our Freedom as a country.

Dale in Louisa, KY   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

I agree , Roland. This is the way we should approach politics all year long. I mute the negative ads, and would love to see the moderators hold them to only ads about what each would do, not negative personal attacks.

Connie   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

They keep talking about Washington needs to change, ARE THEY NOT in Washington already? I do notice that Obama never answers the questions, he talks around them. Any reason for that?

Paris   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

Then why did Obama said he would reduce the size of the military during the primary?

Iowa grant   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

My 2 cents on community service and the military:

the main problem I had with the RNC's message of small town values vs big city elitists is that our communities are more intertwined than ever. There is bound to be a wal-mart in a small town, which puts globalism and sweat shop issues right there. Big cities are full of people from small towns.

In Iraq, when a small town kid and an inner city youth are in the thick of things together, don't they bleed the same American blood?

That cultural division that the community organizer is somehow 'less than' seems out of place.

Jessy King   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

those comments make Democrats WEAK

wayne   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

RE: The forum...
is maccain serious about his policy involving community service volunteers?
aren't these the same community organisers that Palin was ragging on during her VP nomination acceptance speech?

Amy, PA   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

David – I disagree. I think McCain is less genuine then Obama. Who's record is more consistent? In the past 8 years McCain has completely changed who he was. He's just been around longer to have perfected the perfect political persona. Obama is being genuine to himself, and that often gets used against him.

P   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

I wonder how many people will show up at McCains rallies when Palin is not there, lets see how embarresing it will be for McCain whne she has her own rally and 20k or 30k people show up and he has only 2 or 3 hundred people that he had to bus in to his rallies. And why is that McCain harledy evers take wide shots or far away shots of his rallies to make it seem as if there are more peole these by keeping the camera very close to the stage?

mark   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

Yes, Bill- community organizers are left wing. I work with them everyday. You pundits are out of reality. Get in the real world and see that most of these things have a nice sound to them, but have zero impact.

Wesley   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

I'm loving all of these "superstar" Sarah Palin comments.

Superstar=Celebrity.

All of the Republicans gobbling up the very traits they condemned Obama for....your hypocrisy is beautiful.

Tony - Boston   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

How does the parks system, the highway system relate to service? The Highway Act was a Republican initiative under Eisenhower and the Parks Service was an initiative under Teddy Roosevelt, another Republican. He should have talked about some of the Great Society programs or the or Great Depression programs which brought Americans together.

KAREN   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

MR MARTIN,IF IT IS RACISM FOR 10% OF WHITES TO NOT VOTE FOR OBAMA BECAUSE HE IS BLACK, IS IT NOT RACISM FOR 95% OF BLACKS TO VOTE FOR HIM BECAUSE HE IS BLACK. NO OTHER DEMOGRAPHIC GROUP VOTES IN SUCH A MONOLITHIC PATTERN. PLEASE GIVE A STAIGHT NO SPIN ANSWER,ieYESOR NO.

Typical White Person   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

So why don't they ask Obama why he totally avoids unscripted town hall meetings on the same stage as McCain??

sjprugh   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

Roland the McCaint campaign is causing this ridiculous race to date. They are all about distraction and misdirection, not Obama.

Bev   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

To the vets:

I'm a veteran of North Georgia College in Dahlonega, GA, but I graduated before they would even allow women to officially take military courses. I did, without credit, and have been a dove ever since.

My father fought in WWII and Korea. I lost 7 people in 'Nam, including a fiance.

I respect you without question. And I do not belittle the service you have been to our country. But military service is simply not BETTER than any other type of service.

The *Presidency* is the highest service one can give one's country. And you don't have to have military experience to BE President (e.g., Lincoln, FDR, Reagan, Clinton, Bush – which doesn't count since he never left the State of Texas).

As for other high service callings, where would be we without Harriett Tubman? Dr. King? President Lincoln?

Please, try to set aside your warrior natures and simply listen, as objectively as possible.

I love you all. But I probably wouldn't sleep with you. In college, maybe, but you'd have had to have been an Army Ranger (!)

(Sorry. Had to inject from reverse sexism in there.)

Red State Tex   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

His Obama ever seen a government program he didn't like?

Cam   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

Bill, when he said that I thought of Clinton playing the saxophone!

Anne Hamil   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

This Russia as "emerging threat" garbage was so planned to create the illusion of Palin having some sort of foreign policy insight. Insight because Alaska is near Russia. Ask her how much she knows about Canada! Alaska actually shares a border with the place!

Lew   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

Obama is on point on the number of Americans participating in this election.

Jawinka Smith   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

I still can't get over the fact that Obama got time to rehearse since he heard McCain's questions and answers...

jon samuel   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

Hey liberal "Freedom Loving Patriot" – PLEASE please keep bringing up qualifications! I beg you liberals to do that. Our VP nominee as Governor trumps your President-wannabe junior Senator who has done nothing but run for Pesident without ANY accomplishments. Obama hasn't run anything except his mouth. Pls keep it up!!

Becky S.   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

Why is Obama so afraid of the hometown forum? Because people would expect a real answer and not his holier than thou double talk. He is afraid of a real debate with John MCCain or Palin for that matter. He might have to actually answer a question and we saw how poorly he did that on Bill OReilly, talk about a stuttering mess!

Oly   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

Polls? Are you serious? You can't trust polls – they are anything but unbiased! Have you ever been called by a polster if you didn't live on the NE coast or in FLorda or Ohio. Come on! The military votes for Obama? Ever talk to a soldier son? As k some what they think – you will find a completely different take than what the media is 'revealing'. CNN, NBC, NYTimes – these guys have an agenda that is quite clear. I caught CNN taking their automatic polls OFFLINE twice when McCain was ahead – or not rporting changes for up to 4 days....wake up America – Democrats and Liberals are not your friends – they want more power, more money and more control...

dialuz   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

People need a safety net in this country and then we'll all be in better position to serve in many ways. We waste far too much talent when children lack health care, quality education, and the basics to thrive. So, for those of you concerned about the government providing a safety net, do you not understand that it SAVES money in the end and makes our country BETTER!?!

Donald Stuckey   September 11th, 2008 9:38 pm ET

This is why so many people like Obama especially young people, because he is the one simple thing he's paying attention to them.

josephine   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

how come judy asked obama 2 questions and prefaced them with" john mccain said........" i thought the answers were not to be based on what the other person said. that is the reason they are there separately.....................this is what happened when he debated hillary and she got the questions first. why does he always need and be givens clues? and the media isn't biased.boooooooooo

Jim   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Hi. I live in Anchorage. Governor Palin really doesn't seem to like to make herself available to answer questions. For example, she and her staff have nothing to say to the legislature about troopergate and they seem to be leveraging their Department of Law to shelter themselves from subpoenas.

Not just with troopergate, but also more generally, I wonder if Governor Palin will ever sufficiently answer questions and address the public's doubts about her qualifications, or if we will have to settle with her soundbytes.

Steve in Pekin   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Ifully agree Roland, (comment to Military guy on Service), I think this is very narrow minded since not everyone can serve in the Military (health reasons, other restrictions, possibly had a felony at a young age), but these people can definately stand out serving in other areas that we desperately need people.
I agree that the someone that is in the Military should be HIGHLY respected, but should not be held any higher that others that serve in other areas.

Shannon   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Hey Cool is an Independent word too. I would like it to be cool...

Roland Martin,
CNN Political Analyst
  September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Obama just said that without government there would be no Civil Rights Act.

I bet Sen. Hillary Clinton hit the roof on that one!

Remember when the Obama camp ripped her by saying that without President Lyndon Baines Johnson, Dr. King's work would not have become a reality? I know her folks are like, "Now you say it!"

rose   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

The nitty gritty fact is Obama is a good talker with no experience.

Robin in GAg   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

BK...we would be able to afford all of these programs that Obama wants to implement if we were spending billions on a needless war and on high gas prices...you cant blame Obama for wanting to improve this country through worthwhile programs that help the average American...blame Bush and the Republicans for wasting our money....

Russ   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

I agree with Tom- Obama is playing the crowd. "I want to make the President cool again" Is this a strategy? Sounds like hope- thats not a strategy either.

Krissy-pooh   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

I agree with BK. How can we afford Obama's programs especially now?

Patricia, Philadelphia, PA   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Why is it because Obama doesn't give "yes" and "no" answers, that he's lofty and wishy-washy? (BTW Jopat., wishy-washy is so 2004). These issues that are discussed are not just black and white and the fact that he discusses it from more than one side, shows he's thoughtful. I appreciate people thinking before they speak.

Concerned Alaskan   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

We do not need a superstar VP, we need one who knows what a VP does all day. I just cannot believe the break the media is giving to Palin and her lack of leadership qualities.

We need change, not more of the same GOP politics. Palin may have had a chance to bring change about, but it's obvious now with her blatant lying and half-truths that it's not going to happen from the right.

Carly   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

To the young lady who said this forum wouldn't change one vote... It just did.

Mohamed   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Obama is doing a great job and is very inspiring. Let's vote him in on November 4th.

Dexter   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Bill, do you think Obama just made a mistake by giving mayors that much credit with Sarah Palin as a former mayor?

Big Ern   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

I honestly thing that people are afraid of Obama because he is educated.... see comments from David. I'd rather have a smart president rather than a good storyteller.

Ken   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

David

McCain was overly political and stale.

Mark   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Another example of CNN's leftist leanings... on the main page... there is a picture of Obama.. the headline states his points on being an American.... um, didnt McCain speak as well tonight? Where is his picture on the main page?

drill4oil   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

They should do an actual debate so we can all see Obama stumble his way through the questions

CW in DC   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Roland, I think that Obama has constantly tried to stick with the issues but he couldn't let untruths, slandering, and distractions go unnoticed. We'd have a rerun of the Kerry campaign if he did that. His latest statements of "Enough is Enough" should be the new theme of his campaign.

Demus   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

I have been listing to these two men talk about our military and what would they do to keep ppl in the military. Well If I was the Pres. this is what I would do for the FULL military ppl : FREE HEALTH CARE , FREE HOUSING [on base] NO TAXES [at all] also they would get better pay after four years of service they would get $80,000 to 100,000 a yr. The military ppl give up all there rights just to serve us and to keep the mother land safe for us all. Also the big companies [tabacoo] would take half of there profits and put it to health care / cancer research. Also the Oil companies would take half of there profits and put it to fixing our roads, highways, bridges. WE NEED A NEW PARTY called the Party of the People. just a lil of my thoughts thx CNN

Kevin   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Roland, it's called the 1st Amendment – get over it !

Vets for Obama   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

I don't know why you won't take my posts, will some one email and tell me what I am doing wrong...? I am recording this and I will show your censorship if you don't respond...

Will, NJ   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Why so much emphasis of the military why do we need to be fighting so many wars? There's one and only one war we should be fighting and that is the one against Al-Queda. We wouldn't need all these extra troops were it not for the blunders of the current administration and their gunslinger attitude. With troop suicides as high as they are, VA incompitence, and soldiers returning home dead or maimed, the focus should not be getting more people into this mess, but rather fix it. We can't strong-arm Iraq into security and we can't remain there indefinetly. Our military is tied up and exhausted and we have less and less willing to join. Our country has become much more vulnerable to attack due to this great displacement of our military.

Nathan Hale   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Roland, the personal attacks are sadly part of politics you of all people should know that, its been going on since before Lincoln, and it will continue.

inner city problems are the responsiblity of the family not the government,

sunmoonstars   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

is it just me? im sick & tired of watching obama b n asked a question & never given a answer. obama just stop you will not be a great leader for this country nor a good one! the only thing your good at is BS! i dont believe you care about this country, i feel you only want to make history!!!

Capt. Carl   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

I think more people would eager to serve if Washington wasn't so corrupt. I mean, what's the use? Politicians are embroiled in scandal on a weekly basis. Who wants to give up time for that?

EqualBranchesofGovernment   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Was Max Cleland respected in his campaign when Republican's showed ads with him aligned with Osama bin-Laden?........Max Cleland's a hero yet his service was disparaged. It makes me sick!!

Jan Moore   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Ray
"Don't count on this forum to change a single vote" This forum is great as it overall has avoided name calling and mudslinging. Is this what you think gets votes..the name calling, mudslinging and making "mountains out of molehills" to keep your candidates in the news?

Julius - Shreveport   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

David, Obama is a breath of fresh air, not the same ole hot air coming out of Washington

NoGOP   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Every time I watch the man, I am reminded of how much I love Barack Obama. He is my hero.

I WANT THE TRUTH   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Roland I agree that would of been a great thing to ask for.

Tiffany, Atlanta   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Obama is strickly about bringing about change for the better for all Americans! Young, old, rich and poor. It's amazing that so many people say that they want change and will cast their vote for McCain.....

Victor   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Roland,

And who would be the judge of what constitutes "sniping and personal attacks" as opposed to "relevant character and personal history issues"?

- Victor

Sam   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

David, listening to Obama speak right now, how can you say that he isn't speaking from his heart? Everything he is talking about tonight is exactly why he is running for president, and it is where he comes from.

yeah right   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

He is not only brilliant but so Inspiring

Jessy King   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Why did Obama just say he wants government to be cool again, that is a terrible thing to say, government has to work right, not be cool

Kevin from VA   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Why is Bay Buchanan here? All she's going to do is bash Obama. How one sided she is. Of course she's going to be saying how much better McCain is, just look at her title!

Cam   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

I'm vrey impressed with Obama tonight

Colt   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

I wasn't too thrilled when McCain jumped on his soap box about reform 3 minutes into his portion.

And as far as Obama so far-he is reacting better than at Saddleback and is giving more direct answers than I think some of the people on here are giving him credit for.

Mimi Boos   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Did Obama answer the question of whether the democrats belittled Palin's experienace as a small town mayor???? That was the question that was displayed on the CNN screen.

Jim   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Fox is open conservative, msnbc is open liberal, CNN is subtle, shrewd.... pitching a right wing message.

Wayne   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

I love the fact the Obama has a world view. I love the fact that him and Biden have worked together officially in the Senate. They have the makings of a great team that will not provoke countries that would love to be our enemies and they can save some money trying to defend the U.S. from such enemies and do some good.

McCain is too old and 90% like Bush. He may become senile, if he is not already, just like Regan. Then, we will end up with ...cannot speak her name with out thinking "girl, what did you get yourself into" ... Lord, have mercy . . .

Sarahkatheryn   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Make government cool again?! really? I didn't get involved in politics because its cool – I'm all about the finger foods....

Q   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

How can we motivate our young people to serve when we constantly bash what our military and our president is trying to accomplish? Unite. Do the Town Hall meetings Barack!

sa   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Bay, why so negative. What happened about inspiring Americans. Roland made a good point about what everyone thinking what they can do to help their country. Reading some people's posts and well as my own feelings, this forum is doing something

BTW, my goal, since i am currently in medical school is to serve in an undeserved area.

G Smith   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Please please ask him what he will do to help America's rural volunteer Firefighters? America needs them for normal emergencies and certainly they are the front line for terrorist emergencies and natural disasters. They are disappearing rapidly. What can he do to keep them? They do not need college credits and usually are working men and women raising families.

Annville, PA

Vishal   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Only in America would people complain that someone is being too coherent and his answers are too long and informative.

No, we'd much rather have the short sighted, unintelligent remark...a simple yes or no, with no evidence to support.

Liz   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Roland, you should take on that civil tone, and show them the way.

Lila   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Emphasis is put on math and science in education for people who want to serve as teachers. What about READING and spelling?

How can there be excellence in math and science without reading spelling skills?

Bill Schneider,
CNN Sr. Political Analyst
  September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Obama wants to make government 'COOL' again.

Spoken like a true Democrat!

Toby   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

David,
How can you measure how genuine someone is. Your comment was not genuine. Was it?

Laurie   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Here's what strikes me so far: McCain gave answers that were direct and concise, sometimes simply answering "yes". He also stuck to the forum's theme of volunteerism. Obama, by contrast, is giving long, sometimes convoluted answers that stray away from the original question. He also seems to be using this forum as an opportunity to campaign. He almost seems to be stumping. He was asked a question about volunteering after 9/11 and went off on some tangent about his energy policy. Huh? Incidentally, it's interesting that both McCain and Obama were asked about Gov. Palin's perceived belittlement of Obama's stint as a community organizer, yet neither were asked about the Obama campaign's perceived belittlement of Gov. Palin's stint as a small town mayor – which instigated the whole matter. Interesting.

AJ   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Bay, you had better hope this forum changes a vote otherwise your guy is going to be a Senator for a very long time....

Charlotte from Michigan   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

Jopat you say Sarah Palin is a super star? Thought she was a hockey Mom,

We don't need a superstar in the White House, we need a strong President

Alex   September 11th, 2008 9:37 pm ET

factcheck.org

Great website. The truth behind the absurd ads put out by both sides, though I would highlight the prevelance of McCain ads...

MLB   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Well, David, I think the point Roland is making is that the roles were reversed at Saddleback... McCain told the story there and did well. Obama is telling a story now and doing well... That's all.

US MARINE   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Why is obama talking about increasing our military when its already in process. Im a recruiter ,and the Marine Corps is in the works now to increase from 175,000 to 220,000 to reduce our rotation cylces on our marines. Why is it hes trying to claim the kudos for action already being conducted and why is it he has a you tube video talking about reducing our nuclear forces and military. WHATS THE TRUTH.????

Colo Sprgs, CO   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

I like Obama's $4000 tax credit for 100 hrs. community service proposal.

Brian   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

People: How can anyone really argue the difference between these two candidates? All due respect Sen.McCain, Sen.Obama is polished, intelligent, diverse, and well-informed on all of the issues – he needs to be the one leading our country starting in November – how can some of you see it any other way?

Angela   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

I am not sold on Obama , but I do agree with him that "leaders" in our government should encourage the people of this country to be inspired- to give what and when you can and to make sacrifices. Sadly, government ,in the past eight years especially, has done nothing to inspire us- jobs going overseas, wages down and prices up, horrible housing market, inflation, high unemployment and underemployment, failures in Iraq, failures in the real terror war in Afganistan, CEO 's pocketing millions while companies go under or have to be bailed out, corruption, GITMO, etc etc, etc..........

I just don't want anything remotely close to Bush and Cheney. This country can't take much more. I do worry that Obama is too far to the left and McCain is just another Bush... too far to the right.

Palin did go too far in downing a "Community Organizer". Her resume is just as thin as his is!!!!! Palin is just another Dick Cheney with lipstick!!! (Sorry, couldn't resist another lipstick comment)

Carl   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

I have two teen age children. The two of them have been very involved with community service to the elderly. When they receive a grade for participation the attitude is not nearly as endearing as when they volunteer with no reward. Service should not be done for recognition, but out of being genuinely kind and courteous. Whatever happened to "Doing unto others as you would have them do unto you". America cannot forget the Golden Rule...It starts in the home not at an organization....

Deborah   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Obama speaks in specifics. I love the story he's just told about the vet in Montana whose brother committed suicide. I'm a Southern middle-aged white woman who's voted Republican for 20 years, but Obama is getting my vote this year. He won me over with this brilliant and poignant speech in Philadelphia on race a while back. "Lofty" will be a wonderful change after George Bush, who I voted for twice.

Bambi   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Go Barack.

From Canada.

Steve K   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Guess they don't have your Genius...ROLAND.

Teddy   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

they are both genuine David, it comes down who is actually going to do something about it and who actually has a plan, as far as I know and other people agree....Obama is far more specific than McCain.

Ran Sarkar   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Are people really fooled by the GOP's distracting attacks and propaganda? All because they have no good policy positions to discuss? The polls seem to indicate they are.

McCain had some nerve promoting an honorable campaign tonight when his has been downright dishonorable. Obama has been trying to talk about issues while McCain has been trying to cut him down.

Palin is a joke. GOP is incredibly selfish to pick her for political gimmick, especially given McCain's age and health. They're not letting her talk to the media and citizens to avoid her gaffes (already – taxpayers support Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, Georgia and Ukraine in NATO). And this woman is ready to be President????

Barbara   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

I agree Roland – I'm in NC and the Rep. ads here are disgusting. Helping Obama tho. HA

s. morgan   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

So let me get this straight. McCain goes to Pennsylvania to be with the families of Flight 93 and Obama goes to be with Bill Clinton. This guy just doesn't get it. He can't take one day off to do the right thing.

John Illinois   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

I want to see Obama get hammered on education. In Illinois, we have just about the worst, if not the worst, education system in the country. Also, hammer Obama on the total corruption in the Illinois Democratic Machine of which he is a part of. Illinois is almost in economic collapse as well. We have not heard one word from our absentee senator (for approx. 75% of his term) regarding any of this. He also has accomplished nothing as a state legislator or senator of Illinois. Sorry, community organizer definitely does not cut it.

Lyndon, New York NY   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

People are getting confused because they're not used to listening to a politician give ACTUAL answers with some real substance to them. We're used to listening to silly soundbites and catchphrases that we've lost the ability to sort through someone's words and interpret them into a way where we can understand.

Maybe if we listened more, it wouldn't be as hard.

grizz   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

The rich will not like to afford Obama but they have had a free ride for eight years now its time to pay up .

ron   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Bay – you are so wrong – It jsut changed mine!

Andy McCowan   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Hey why you guys and Mccain and his camp are talking about Miltary record and Obama's community service.

Can Mccain and his camp and you talk about a solid answers for the present situation that the country facing.

1. economy.
2. Jobs.
3. Inflation.
4. Mortgage crisis
5. gas prices.

Come'on Folks.
wake up.

Amy   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

I find it interesting that so many sit at their computers and freely make comments as to how our military is not "the most important" when, in fact, our freedom to do just that is what they are the front lines protecting. How easily we relish in our freedoms and forget where they came from...

BK   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Roland, Obama got to hear McCain and his answers and Obama is still uh uh and wishy washy. He is too weak.

Reg   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Clay, you are right on... the media has put way too much attention on the lipstick comment. I mean Lehman brothers is going down in flames, and the Government just took over Freddie and Fannie and all we can talk about is lipstick on dogs and pigs?

CSpann   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Reach
Ask Licoln, ask Marshall, Ask King.
Progress is made when you reach further than your fingertips.
What is within you reach is easy to attain...and to lose.
But when you reach for that which you can not see;
Move in faith toward that you will not realize;
Then you will make progress

RAY PADGETT   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

I SO AGREE WITH YOU ROLAND !!!!!!

Tommy   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

If Barack is elected our next President, I hope all the people who are speaking so harshly against him remember what they said when we're able to go around the world with pride and how we'll be welcomed again because we have gotten back our standing with the world by not tryimg to bully everyone else around and trying to force them to be like us.

Nat in Vermont   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Anyone who is anti-tax clearly doesn't understand that without taxes, no matter how good or bad your intentions are, they can't function. The government needs taxes, and frankly not just on the poor or the rich. Look at other countries such as Canada, very high taxes in comparison with us, yet they and many others have free healthcare.

Of course, stopping the war would let up on the whole increasing the budget deficit by 400+ Billion dollars thing. But hey, I'm not the prez so what do I know?

mary   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

roland, your ideas are inspiring and thought provoking

Ken   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

BK

We have a $10 billion a month war in Iraq. How are we paying for that?

Scared for the future   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

BK – Truth be told I dont think we can afford 4 more years of the current administration. Funny how they scream dems are tax and spend liberals yet the last dem we had in the oval office reduced the deficit but the republicans have taken it to record levels and all you can say is that we cannot afford to change things? If America doesn't do something soon we will soon realize we are in the same position Rome found itself. A suprise to realize you are on the decline.

I WANT THE TRUTH   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Its amazing to actually learn and be inspired to do something for a country that has not done squat for me in the last EIGHT YEARS

Bill   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Obama's answer to his response to Palin's shots at community service is the best answer I've heard to a question in the entire campaign. He stayed positive and focussed on joining forces with others, and expressed how important community service is to shaping young people.

mark   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Roland, I am a teacher and the union owns your guy and basically both parties. They say it is for the children, No it is for their base and pocketbook. The same will happen with govt sponsored service.

Sergeant Wag   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Roland,

We know he can do that. Look at his "tape watching" on...

The Surge
Rescinding Bush's Tax Cuts (and taxing not hurting the economy).
Offshore Drilling
ETC

You call it tape watchiing. I call it POLL watching.

MM in Illinois   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Buchanan you are you to say that this will not change a person votes. I would rather have McCain change a vote on the issues rather then character attacks.

mike   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

"Anyone can be president, just check the requirements in the constitution. 1. Age 35 or over. 2. Born in the USA. 3. Can't be in the active military. That's it. What is all the fuss about qualifications? If the founders wanted more they would have spelled it out. Palin meets the requirements."

you can't be serious. this is just a glimpse into the retarded thinking that gets clowns like george bush (and his dad) into the white house. what a poor, poor argument. you, sir, like so many others, are an idiot... and probably retarded. according to your ridiculous logic: michael jackson, oj simpson, danny bonaduce, courtney love, ozzy osbourne and tom cruise are all qualified to be president.

nice work, dummy. hey, wait a minute... your name IS george... is that you mr. president? wow, finally something that DOES make sense.

mike   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Roland, that would just lead to more broken promises.

Paul Gillham   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

This forum has to be a big win for McCain. It is such a snoozefest, most people have probably changed the channel. McCain has the momemtum right now. This forum will not change that!

Cat   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Every day, I tune to CNN on Sirius, and every day I hear a Sarah Palin speech. It is always the same speech, despite being given on different days in different places. Often, CNN plays almost all of Palin's redundant speech then cuts away during McCain's speech.

(1) Why does CNN treat Sarah Palin as though she is the candidate
rather than McCain?

(2) How is a Sarah Palin speech news? She is not announcing new poilcy. She's not even using a new stump speech.

Your coverage of Palin has been excessive and not sharp enough. One of the CNN commentators during the day wanted to talk about the comments about Community Organizer during the republican convention and continually referred to how Guiliani made the remark–with ZERO mention of the fact that Palin used it and continues to use it. Anyone listening would not have known Palin was using the line, as well. Deliberate? You tell me.

You frequently let your Republican guests get away with the most ridiculous falsehoods without questioning them. You repeat what is said without the probing questions one might see from the BBC, for example.

And I am sick of your fluff pieces on Palin. Please get back to the issues and stop letting the Rove republicans succeed in turning everyone's head away from what really matters to the American people–jobs, healthcare, security.

Rick Larkin   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

On a day where we were not going to have partisan politics what is up with the dude from Time that clapped during and after McCain's responses and NOT once with Obama. I like the selection of Judy Woodruff as she always is independent but again, CNN is feeding pig with no story here. You want to be trusted, then don't show preference with either language or body language, report the news and ask the questions. Tell Time Magazine Editor not to clap for one and not the other. Show respect for both, no matter who you are.

Scott   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

I don't understand how people can believe anything McCain says. He looks like a used car salesman when he smiles, it is obviously fake. On the other hand, when Obama smiles, he looks natural. That say a lot to me, but maybe I am just biased...or am I?

Aubrey   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

I understand moderating the post but CNN is taking away freedom of speech by not posting all the comments. If you call this a live blog that anyone can join in, then you need to keep it that way and not censor what you want to hear!

judy in PA   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

I like Obama's answers better than McCain's. His are more thoughtful.

Bill Schneider,
CNN Sr. Political Analyst
  September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

He's portraying community organizing as a form of voluntary community surface, working with churches - which it is!

To a lot of Americans, community organizing sounds vaguely left-wing.

It's not.

Dexter   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Roland, do you think Obama just made a mistake by giving mayors that much credit with Sarah Palin as a former mayor?

David F   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Reagan: I don't get it. You're dizzy because you can't follow Obama's points?

Anonymous   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Ditto the Stepford V.P. Comment. ENOUGH said!

James   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Why is there a republican strategist in this forum but no one for the democrats?

Dewayne Armstrong   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

I too am utterly disturbed at why the media keeps enormous political coverage of Palin's star status. You all should be composing all her and McCain's lies in your segments and ask the so-called evangicalistic and christian communities why they are condoning and supporting out-right liers? Then, ask them: If McCain and Palin will debase themselves in lying in an attempt to fool the American Voters for this election, What happens when they get your vote? Lying thiefs for the Big Oil Companies in the Temple!So, I am asking all those who call themselves religious and faith-based: Is Palin the public voice for all you believe in? And, does this out-right lying support your views and God's will?

Silene Young   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

jopat – How can you say that? Obama is giving clear, detailed explanations of issues. Just the fact that you want to vote for a "superstar" in this election shows us where the problem is. We are supposed to vote for people based on issues, intelligence and capabilities, not appearance and not stardom!

sjprugh   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Obama really exhibits a soul of service.

Matt Poynter   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

Obama appears to be evolving and learning from past experiences.

If he can use this to pivot off of and hammer his message this will be a different race next week..

thad   September 11th, 2008 9:36 pm ET

HUSSEIN is his name. DO you really want this man leading your country????

Rob   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

He's finally inspiring me ! Finally I understand what all the fuss is about!

michael   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Does Obama always speak in very short sentences? Maybe he should have requested a teleprompter. Did anyone watch the O'Reily factor? I am a democrat and just can't bring myself to vote for this guy. Not that I am a big fan of McCain either. Is is to late to get someone else?

American   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Wow, he inspires me. I'm sitting here thinking what can I do to serve my community!!! And Roland, your challenge is something I'm willing to take on!

Carla   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

i wish ppl would not be soooo closed minded. i just dont understand. if we look at the economy everything is so expensive. we were handed a bunch of garbage and now we are in 2 wars and Gov Palin stated at the beginning of the program that we will probably be in another war (WOW) ask any military person now serving their 3rd tour of duty if they would want to go fight in another war. A blind person can see who benefited from this war. if we have 4 more years of this we will be in a depression for sure

roberto   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

take away mcains service in the military. what else does he has to offer. take away palin beauty. what does she have to offer. mcain can offer 90 percent of agreeing with bush. palin can offer a speach that she reads over and over again since RNC. i can not wait for the debates . GAME ON

Julius   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Obama is just a show with salesmanship. I hate the way he describe sexism but the first to scream racism. Bring back HILLARY!!

Sierra   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Watching the discussions and have noticed that McCain was answering the questions directly and it sounds like Obama is talking around the questions and not answering direct.
It sounds like it will cost us a lot if Obama is in the office and it scares me with the talk about him liking the unions.

MD Democrat   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

and they said that a coin was flipped so it could have just as easily have been McCain listening to Obama

Brad in PA   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Roland, that is a good question. Republicans talk a lot about cutting taxes; however, how many would be up to an extra tax that goes specifically to increased pay benefits for the military? I’m in the Navy and I am disappointed in McCain in the way he has treated increased benefits for the military especially the largest increase in military educational benefits in or generation.

As a member currently serving in the navy, I can’t vote for someone, irrespective to their prior armed forces affiliation, who doesn’t support the men and women who makes it possible for him to have the right to deny us the right to higher education.

Brad from Arizona   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Bay is correct – neither this nor Saddleback will change any votes. But hopefully it will get some of the undecideds to gravitate to one candidate or the other. I'd prefer Obama based on tonight's ideas.

Justin Gagnon   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

How rude to say this wont change a vote? Americans arnt stupid, less than two months to go, yes this could change a vote. Remeber a McCain supporter is a vote for him. An Obama supporter is a vote, and a donation and a volenteer.

Roland Martin,
CNN Political Analyst
  September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

WHY didn't the moderators get McCain and Obama to commit TONIGHT to continuing a civil tone for the rest of the campaign?

They should have forced them to go on record on this night and commit to ending the sniping and personal attacks and stay focused on the campaigns.

Gaurang Doshi   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

All IT jobs are going to India and our people are being replaced by H1B Visa holders. How would any presidential candidate ensure that our children have the proper motivation to go for IT Education when all jobs are going to India and our engineers are loosing jobs here as H1B visa people are willing to work for half the money?

FGP   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

BK, did you feel the same way 8 years ago about Gore?

jill   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Jopat..he has no choice but to go into more detail..because after 18 months..people are still saying they dont Know Barack..So sit back and listen and get to know him...By the way Sara Palin just came into the game..but I dont see people saying they dont know her..I wonder why

mary   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Mccain did not give any specifics to any question that was asked. All he is concerned about is military, military...........watch out america

I am so sick of him talking about his service. i have to change the channel. I can't stand looking at him and listening to him. He just does not get it. Who cares what you did then what are you going to do for america and me now. get a grip mccain

Jennifer   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Obama certainly took the high road in his response to being bashed for his time working in community organizing. Wish the McCain campaign would extend the same decorum in this election.

Audrey   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

I don't understand how ANYONE could not agree with this man's policies.

Republican's/conservatives have a complete different world view. I just don't understand.

Obama's policies and views are SO universal. How could you not cheer it on?

Bryan B.   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

BK of course Obama is not going to do every single one of his programs in 4 years, McCain won't get all of his goals finished either. No president ever has. It simply is not possible. Campaign promises are goals and wish lists.

Teddy   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

I don't think we can afford McCain period

Silas Dogood   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

If you think about it, she really is running for President. Mc Cain has his history of health issues, he's up in age and has the potential to not make it a full term.

Sanity_2008   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

==

What's puzzling to me is the support John McCain gets from so many military personnel and vets.

The Bush regime has basically shafted vets – medical atrocititiesat vets' medical care facilities have been widely reported and acknowledged even by Bush regime operatives – and McCain supports Bush 91% of the time.

McCain also opposes the Webb-Hagel bill to expand the GI Bill, including educational benefits.

Yet McCain continues to wrap himself in the mantle of "supporting the troops", and receives a major chunk of support from this segment of voters.

Go figure...

==

anon   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Wow – did Obama just slam all American mayors for 'pot-hole filling and tree trimming"?

Jen From MN   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Obama is so inspiring. Really has a great grasp on what service is and how important it is for the American people to step out and help in any way they can.

Cindy   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Interesting that Obama go to hear everything McCain said....and that he is saying similar things.... Didn't this happen with Hillary?

Donald Stuckey   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Now this is the best of rock Obama he gave a very good response to the small-town mayors comment made by a McCain as running mate.

mark holmes   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Mr. obama says that he wants to see more young people serve in the military.and i tryed to join.but was told i could not because i said i would not lie about my past history doing drugs.i do not use them any more been about 7 years and one year since i tryed to join .i am a saved christian man for about 5 years.will you fix this problem?

Lee   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

I agree with Jopat – he seems less confident and is stealing a lot of McCain's lines here tonight. Where are his own ideas?

Martin Tease   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

what Obama should have said about Palin is that her experience in the PTA which is community organization typically is the stepping stone that many begin with as they move on to higher levels of public service.

ww-New York   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

HELP PEOPLE HELP THEMSELVES!!!!! GEE, I HOPE THE REPUBLICANS CAN NOW TELL THEIR SUPPORTERS THE MEANING OF A "COMMUNITY ORGANIZER"!!

Mark   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

McCain was congenial and likeable. It's amazing to me that McCain can do a complete 180 on everything he said and ran on during the primary and now pick up on what's working with the people, Obama's message and vision, and suddenly McCain is a great reformer! How stupid does he think we are?? It's way too easy for him to get away with this crap when you have moderators that are no longer the watchdog press but are the lapdog press. To consider this forum as "news" is a sham! CNN might as well change their name to SNN (Spin News Network) their bias is showing and it's very insulting.

Saad, NJ   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Both candidates spoke very nicely regarding our military… but I wish they would for once slip in some plan and strategy to make this world a rather more peaceful place. If their plan works, we will have no need to increase our military and considering inflation, continue to increase the funding for our military.

I know all of teh above is wishful thinking but hey… I am asking to slip that only once… afterall, we are the country rest of the world looks up to and listens to…. or at least used to!!!

George Coles   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

I am disappointed that while discussing public service that there has been no mention of long established organizations like Kiwanis, Rotary, Lions, Shriners, Optimists and others like them?

Ohio Girl   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Roland--remember the cone and allegations that McCain cheated????? Yeah, Obama learned a few things from Saddleback all right......he learned to go second and listen to McCain being interviewed first.

John   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

YES WE CAN am sorry America will be du#m to vote for McCAIN.....

Kim-Canada   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Roland and Bill, don't you both feel motivated to go out and volunteer in your communities right now after listening to Obama. Imagine further how he will inspire once he's president!

Omar NY   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

jopat, maybe you got too used to Bush and Mccain, so that when someone who can articulte and express their views with specifics and in perfect detail, you can't keep up...Inellectual individuals are following a true leader.

Pete   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

The moderator has it wrong. The obama knee jerk response was belittling Palin for her work as Mayor, pliz get that right.

Larry Hines   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Does anybody know if any of these contestants have any plan to install hate crime laws in indiana, cause i've had many that's done hate crime towards me..and the police dont do nothing...im black and have kids..i dont want them to go through that...this question is to any analysts

gerri   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Whats the matter Bay?Cant take a little critism.No answer?

Sue, MI   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Barack is showing great composure at not just slamming Giuliani and Sarah Palin for their hateful comments about community organizers. I really think he's taking back this campaign again!

Kujo   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

I think we all can agree, Red or Blue, that we do not want to reduce Gov Spending well at the same time address the issues concerning Americans.

But to me, what money we do spend is much better done within our country and on projects that will improve our infrustructure (both physical and economic) then to send the money over sea's.

In this election, this is where I see the difference in these 2 candidates.

David   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Roland, and that is the difference between McCain and Obama – McCain is genuine and Obama is...well...something less than genuine.

Liz   September 11th, 2008 9:35 pm ET

Yeah Obama worked on the streets, that's where he met Ayers, Rezko and Wright.

Barbara   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Obama motivates me for the 1st time in 48 years (yes, I'm 65)

I WANT THE TRUTH   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

BK we can't afford to not have his programs!

Ann   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

I also want to know why the media report lies just because McCain and Co. say them. Why not record the statement and then do some actual reporting and note that the lies don't accord with the facts.

I also want to point out that the Bush fiscal record means WHOEVER becomes president will HAVE to ask for higher taxes.

Kevin   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

I'd like to know why B.O. believes that allowing babies who are the product of a failed abortion and have been born, they are alive, do not have the same rights as an adult. In 2001, he was the only person to stand on the Senate floor and speak against a Bill that would make this practice illegal. Christians do not practice Infantacide and they certainly are not in favor of killing innocent babies who are alive and well. Senator BO was the only person to actually stand and speak out against this Bill. Not shocking for a man whose response to what he would do if his daughter were to "make a mistake" and get pregnant; he would "get rid of it" because he wouldn't want her to be "punished for making a mistake". Wow !

Rob B.   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Obama doesn't ride his life story McCain reminds people every other sentence about his POW status. Obama have some GREAT Ideas and the fact that it involves everyday people is refreshing. He is a thinking man's President and I think people are seeing it now. McCain can not ride his image to the white house.

lostinthemadness   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

was that question asked of McCain?

glenn   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

McCain/Palin are running on Earmarks. They will stop Earmarks.

So What?

Will the economy be fixed when earmarks are stopped?
Will the soldiers come home from Iraq when earmarks are fixed?

What else can they offer to me as a voter other than earmarks?

Paris   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Candy that is what experience gives you, more confidence and ease.
Senator Obama is learning……..
That is why you need experience to be the commander and chief of the United State.

Mr Ciar   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Hello
The Libertarian Party has nominated former Congressman Bob Barr, the Constitution Party has nominated pastor and radio talk show host Chuck Baldwin, and the Green Party has nominated former Congresswoman Cynthia McKinney. Ralph Nader declined to seek the Green Party nomination and is running as an independent candidate for President { PRESIDENT
What makes the news reporters not report on all the runners for president. hmmmmm
Cant we the people count higher than 2
Arent we allowed all of the truth
so we can make a better more informed choice
an intellegent choice.
put everything on the table then let us choose
But then if we really did have a vote then that would be a CHANGE
Thank You for your time

Jodi   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

McCain is my man. A man of respect, honorable, a man of his word, a man of great integrity. McCain has EARNED my vote.

Brandon_MI   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Jopat, Obama's answers aren't long and winding. I don't know what you're watching, but he's doing A LOT better tonight than he did at the Saddleback forum.

Keith   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Talk about one sided garbage, – This show is a sham.

Franco Russo   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Obama is avoiding the question on "Small time Mayor" and has turned it to victimize his belittling of community organizer

thad   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Mccain should have never agreed to the setting. I cant wait until the debates. Obamas bottom lip is going to be as white and dry as it was when Oreilly interviewed him.

DeeinNC   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

It'd be nice to know the rules for this blog since it seems impossible to post here more than twice if you are not a commentator. Sorry for being interested and wanting to exchange ideas in this forum:(

DREW79   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

I may have changed my vote due to this forum/interview

I change that i def changed my thought process on this election

Caroline in Michigan   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

who moderates this and why can't I post? A Canadian is posting and I cannot?!

Barack is doing great! He is a breath of fresh air and hopefully people will get back on track and the Palin distraction will come to an end.

I find it disturbing that it has all degenerated into "Entertainment Tonight" type of nonsense.

Colin   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

I find the medias coverage of the campaign to be very biased towards McCain at this point. He is not being grilled on the hard questions while at the same time they are grilling Obama on every little detail about his record. I sense an agenda here and its not too hard to imagine where from. McCain's claims as a veteran make me sick. As a veteran myself I'm offended by McCains almost absolute abandonment of this countries veterans. He really should have some shame, he is more than willing to send men and women to die but he isn't willing to pay to take care of them when they get home and need medical and psychological support. Its clear to me who McCain really is and its a disgrace.

Jake D   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Rolland, your right, he messed up big time and this is a great example of his versatility and willingness to change his approach

Permanently Confused   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

I think that when the debates come, people will see how much more calm and collected Obama is. They will also see how McCain would rather attack than process the situation.

Tera   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Since when did it become a bad thing to have a thoughtful nuanced answer. I think one of the problems with this country is that we want this quick 30 second answer to everything. NOTHING IS BLACK AND WHITE!!!! I'll take nuance over 30 seconds at any time. It means you thought about your position. I get nervous when folks just fly out of the mouth. It means most of the time that you didn't think!!

Blackknight   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

I think we need more people volunteering to be tutors at the high school in my neighborhood. I think the increased productivity of the average american worker has decreased time spent volunteering.

Gallup, FSM, Palin   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

I read that McCain actually had a lead in the polls, and I wonder about the polls.

I actually got a call from Gallup two days ago. I answered the first thirty or forty questions. The next one was about religion. I don't really have a religion so I probably should have said I didn't have a religion. But instead I said I believe in Flying Spaghetti Monsterism. After that, the person from Gallup did not have any more questions.

This leads me to wonder if people with unusual religious understanding are under-represented in the polls, and what other built-in biases there must be to the polling process. I also started to wonder if there is a bias. It could have just been a coincidence.

Besides that my main impression of the campaigns recently is that Palin is such a strong orator, and I don't trust a person who doesn't blink once in a while.

I heard Palin on the radio today saying "When McCain becomes President, ..." and to me that is a lie because nobody knows the future until the votes are actually counted.

WRM   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Why can't they talk about anything with more immediate impact on our economy - for instance: With Gustav and Ike and the damage they have done to Cuba and Haiti, and considering the damage that Ike is likely to do to our oil supplies, along with Russian bombers landing in Venezuela,why don't we renege in Georgia, back off Russia, make a quick but long lasting deal for oil with Venezuela, and offer statehood to Cuba in exchange for their opening the country up to American homebuilders to help Cuba recover from the devastation of the storms. Our current point in time offers the new president a way to reverse, in a few years, what the Bush family has destroyed over many years. We could again be friend of the World while improving our economy in the process. But, no, Mcain is trying to stir up a 1970's debate on ROTC. And you guys are debating who said if first and who said it more intellectually. Talk about something useful.

gc   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Roland Martin,
CNN Political Analyst September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

Anyone of conscience would! One's answer determines the level of conscience they have, be they Dem or Rep.

GC in rainy West Texas

Girlpower   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

I agree-votes aren't going to change here. But it just may influence some people to go out and do what Roland suggested. All this for the better of our country.

diogenes49   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

I think that Barack is finally getting his mojo back. He does extremely well in this forum, and frankly as an avid Obama supporter, I was a little fearful how this would go. Having John McCain as President of the United States would be a national nightmare. It is true, he has voted the Bush mind over 90% of the time. Now he is trying to rob Obama of the change mantra that has been his for over 19 months? What ever happened to experience? The McCain campaign has changed and manipulated things to do one thing, and it has nothing to do with National Service or whatever. He is willing to lie, distort facts, and cheat to become President. Get on track Barack, it is far too important for you to win this campaign.

Don wood   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

our nation will be stronger, safer,and better served after the election of nov. 4 th. we americans need to work hard every day to make this wonderful country as great as it can be, to show the world how we the people of this great nation have and will lead the world.

Russell   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Can we afford McCain and all his programs?

Daniel   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

CNN is pro-Obama to the extreme. It has been said that 2008 is the year that our mainstream media died – and I'm starting to agree with that.

Once again the homepage of cnn.com is completely in support of Obama. I'm trying to get used to going to foxnews.com instead of cnn.com because of this obvious bias.

For years cnn.com has been my main news site online – but truly folks, I cannot handle this extreme bias any more.

Thank you.
Danial

Capt. Carl   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Roland, I would support a tax that would go directly to military members, but is that even remotely possible? Don't you think Washington would find a way of diverting the funds given time?

Loyal American123   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Rudy Guilani said Biden needed to get in writing as a Vp candidate.
Did Rudy's 1st wife gwet it in writing?
Did Rudy's 2nd wife get it in writing?
I kno Judith Nathan has it in writing>

I WANT THE TRUTH   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Bay I know your party hopes that it won't change a vote. Sorry to break it, but it is going to change a lot. The lipstick on the pig and slandering his name is not enough to stop this man. Good try though. GO OBAMA!

Colt   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Mayor...trim trees and garbage taken out?

Devon E   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Fabian i would think that you owe a little more respect to our service people like our nurses, doctors firemen and police officers that ensure our safety here at home. It's not very hard to honor those in the military but you don't have to insult those who do a lot for our country here on our home turf.

Johnny   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

I like Obama's comment!

This is a nice repreive/setting from the the divisive partisan politics that consistently gets displayed throughout this campaign by both sides and enflamed by the media.

This general focus area is one where it seems Obama and McCain share commonality. As Americans (Republicans and Democrats) we spend more time pointing fingers at the other party for what they said or what they have or haven't done than trying to find the areas where we have common ground and working from there.

Being an American isn't a zero sum game however both parties and candidates have forgotten some of the basic constructs and principles that our forefathers fought so hard for many years ago.

Copperfield   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

Funny how "this forum is not going to change a vote" after Obama is giving good, detailed answers. Before he came on though you were ranting about how great McCain was presenting himself Bay...

GOP for obama   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

at least obama isn't lying about his cone of silence

Andy   September 11th, 2008 9:34 pm ET

BK-
By ending the war in Iraq and raising taxes on the rich by less than 1% would pay for everything.

mary   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

homerun for obama....talking about Montana Matt is another example of his focus on unity for all Americans.

drill4oil   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

I guess since that's not as much as Obama's 180 days she's not qualified.

Bill witmer   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

Hey BK – well then you go to another country like UK and canada. Look at their programs. we are the only country who do not have healthcare for all. Get a life dude.

LOL   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

Jopat perhaps the difference between you and many of us in here is ADD?

Nathan Hale   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

the inner city problem is the responsibilty of the family, and parents and not the government

rose   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

On a cold dark snowy morning, I stood in a long line, with my young sons to listen to Barak Obama. He made me cry because he spoke about things I care deeply about. The next week I applied for US citizenship, hoping that I may get to cast a vote for Obama.

Today, September 11, I will became a US citizen and Obama gets one more vote. My vote cost me $675 and I will treasure each vote I cast.

He deserves my vote, the one I waited 41 years to cast. Now I need him to FIGHT so that my vote matters. I need him to FIGHT so that I can shed tears about things I care about. He needs to FIGHT so my boys can grow up in the country they deserve. Vote, Vote, Vote!

Michigan Mike   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

Current "slanted" CNN Headlines:

Obama: 9/11 has made us stronger?

Palin a " cocky wacko"

Palin killed the bridge, but kept the money.

I guess I am too idealistic too think that CNN will report the news.

Out of curiosity, are your censors going to censor this response.

WATCH OUT....Ted Turner.....I might ruin you....then BUY you!

K   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

Bay- you should pray it doesnt change a vote because if it did your guy does not stand a chance He is does not have an agenda other than run negative negative negative with the Rove crew. I respected McCain before he put the Rove crew on his campaign I thought he was bigger than that.

MD Democrat   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

How can anyone say that McCain is to the point in his responses? Obama gives specific examples to everything he says.

Jamie   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

Obama is stuttering alot.

Ronald   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

The government "in theory" is by the people, for the people...somehow, this has totally been forgotten. Just because someone is elected President, they are still bound to the voice of the people. As far as experience, I want a President flexible enough in their ability to understand the world has changed dramatically in the last 10 years, having 30 plus years experience means absolutely nothing. As an old mainframe programmer of yesteryear, I know "skills" and "experience" can be outdated. I also hear often about the Democrats wanting to increase spending on programs as if this is a bad thing, 10 billion a month could go a long way in this country toward energy independence research, but instead it is being spent on a US military backed Iraqi "freedom". Sorry folks, democracy has to have a separation of church and state to work, the government can't be a certain religion or it's destined to fail.

C from GA   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

Can someone tell me what the "Country First{" slogan of the Republicans means – honestly? Is it Country before Family? Country before yourself? Country before your job? Country before Community? And what qualifies as "Country"? National level service? State (governors, etc) Community?

I honestly can't see how any of the rhetoric here (either side for that matter) is "Country First".

Thanks

Chris Cabcabin   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

Palin is a walking, talking, breathing insult to all Hillary supporters.

But let not make her the main topic because she isn't worth it.

McCain or should I say McBush has made a mockery of the election ever since he has chosen her. And now McBush is running on a topic of Change????

ENOUGH!!!!!!!!!!! Enough with the past eight years and McBush's 26 years of the same old politics in Washington. We need a new leader with a new vision to take America back from the far right GOP. They have ruined are economy, ruin our countries reputation on the global scale, ruined housing, split us in to red and blue states more so then ever before, have us in a BAD WAR....I can go on and on really. So please America WAKE UP!!! We do not need 4 more years of the same GOP agenda that has ruined our country. Obama and Biden are the leadership our country needs! Free health care! A better Economy with more jobs and better education for our youth!!! Lets rid ourselves of our dependency on oil and be the leader of alternative fuels for the world!!! WE MUST TAKE OUR COUNTRY BACK PEOPLE!!! End the RULE of the GOP in the White House and bring back HOPE to the United States of America!!! God Bless!!!

Reagan   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

I am getting dizzy from Obama's answers. Is it possible to stay on one point rather than skimming the surface of several general "ideas"?

cg-msp   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

I don't think McCain was straight to the point. I would find it refreshing if any of the candidates could just answer without overthinking and strategizing.

Misha   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

BK, america is spending ten billion dollars every month in Iraq, of course we have the money. what are u talking about BK

Jawinka Smith   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

I just scrolled up. My last submitted comment is true. Obama got to hear the questions AND McCain's answers?

Oh brother! I give up on American politics and fair treatment of candidates in forums and debates.

Yeah, he'll knock it out of the park, alright. Just like my kids who get a copy of my test before they take it. Shameful.

Charlotte from Michigan   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

I think Senator Obama is doing a wonderful job of answering questions. He is right about one thing, if the whole country came together as they did after 911, we could bring back the America we knew before.

The GOP has broken the back of this country and we need a whole new way of running the country and we need a democrat, my vote will be for Senator Obama.

I am also so disappointed that the GOP feels that since they put a woman on their ticket, we women will not question her. She needs to be questioned, she needs the same scrutiny as Hillary Clinton. She only has one thing in common with Senator Clinton, she is a female.
She is too right-wing radical for me.

Jessy King   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

About PTSD, and taking care of those people, how does the future president get the congress to agree to fix the problems

Ed from Tampa   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

actually – we can't afford not to have Obama elected.

Aubrey   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

Once Sarah Palin is cleared from her own investigation then we can call her a superstar.

Concerned as well   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

This Forum is great to hear what both candidates think about service and some other issues. But the sad truth is a lot of the people that vote in November won't vote for one or the other because of the issues. They will vote for McCain or Obama because of what other people tell them to think, or because of stupid chain emails spreading ridiculous rumors and then taking them as fact.

The truth is no matter what party someone belongs to voters need to RESEARCH the issues and decide who can best lead our country. Not have others think for them and tell them how to vote.

Go Buckeyes   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

When will Obama say he's a "white" & black candidate?

Judy T   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

I'm not sure why Obama said that he would encourage more young people to become educators and then pay back their loans if they teach in the most needed areas. They already do that in most states, maybe all have some type of tuition repayment program. My daughter owed $40,000 and the state we live in paid almost all of her school loans. She did not teach the 5th year to have them completely paid so she did owe $8000. Give us something new. What about all of the other service careers that young people choose such has nursing? Politicians = more of the same.

Felicia   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

I'm not sure why Obama appears to sound "lofty" or "pandering" to some people. Just because he takes the time to understand the question and provide a thoughtful answer, does not mean that he's lofty or pandering. At least he takes the time to understand the question and really think about the best possible outcome BEFORE he says or does something stupid and/or not in the best interests of the country (unlike the last 8 years and the other presidential nominee).

David   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

I would support a tax system that only taxes for needed projects decided by the american people, except for military, highways, and a few others. Let put the others up for a vote. Let's let people opt out of taxes going to things like Abortion Clinics. You can tax the same amount but let us opt out of certian projects. Get rid of the idea of using the tax system to redistribute wealth but give safety nets for people that fall through the cracks.

Krissy-pooh   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

Great Answer

Cynthia Nashville   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

See those people (ie Lt Colnel, Sergeant) are just like McCain in that they believe the best if not the only way to serve your country is to join the military. People that share those view are insistent on military service and I feel like they want to impose that view on all Americans. I really feel if McCain is elected it will only be a matter of time before we have a draft no matter what the circumstances. The ultimate sacrifice for some is yes serving in our military as my husband is doing now. However for myself the ultimate sacrifice is running a non-profit organization right out of home practically to help people in my community and eventually throughout our nation.

Jessica   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

Why won't Obama do town hall meetings with McCain? It places the questions in the voters' hands, instead of 2 or 3 moderators.

Jackie   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

My two cents worth ... as a Canadian, here's to Obama winning this election and bringing the US back to being the country that is was, but even better. And to CNN reporting more about the issues your country is currently experiencing (eg. your economy), rather than lipstick comments. You all have a great leader within your grasp. They don't come along very often.

Cindy   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

Roland – You need to take the ONE THING proposal on the road. It has legs. Inspired! Talk about in on the air so more can hear the challenge!

sjprugh   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

jopat... you are out of your mind. Unclog your ears, will you?

Big Ern   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

After watching this forum, I have only really learned one thing.... that McCain has stolen several pages from OBAMA's playbook. The sad thing about this is that he is being lauded for saying the same things that OBAMA has been stating now since the beginning of the campaign.

Also, just one last quick comment..... Sanctions against Russia? Go to Georgia and defend it? Are you serious? Does the Moosehead even know what that would cause?

Christy   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

There you go Bay, you look good on the defensive. Now get there and stay there republicans.

Jake D   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

If we can afford a 1 trillion dollar illegal war, I think we can afford health care and education.

anon   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

Is America clamoring for a National Service 'czar' ? Is this a high priority for a country in this current state of affairs?

Deb, Allentown,PA   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

I'll ask again. Why do you have a Republican strategist commenting, but no Democratic strategist?

Brandon_MI   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

I'm an Obama supporter, but I'll give props to both of them tonight. I think they've both done great at this forum. I don't get why it's so hard for some of you to admit that the other side isn't pure "evil" and sometimes they actually do well.

Shannon   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

Bay we all know your voting for Mccain. It may not change your mind but it may change others. You dont know what others are thinking?? Thats just silly....

Vishal   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

Obama has run the most innovative and inspiring campaign in US history, IMAGINE what he could do for America!!!

Jan Raimer-Cunitz   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

I think a great majority of the people that are going to vote have already decided who they're voting for and most of them aren't watching the news or paying attention to the ads because of the negativity. I know in my family and with most of my friends, we're watching sports, drama, comedies, anything but politics!

Rudiger   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

Hey Roland,

Have you heard about this Poll that shows Obama having a huge lead among military vets and servicemen?

Tony - Boston   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

So McCain would appoint Obama, but Obama says "there's some work that's gotta be done." How the heck is that post-partisan? That's a pretty partisan answer.

David Dedig   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

I would like to correct something someone posted earlier. In No way is what Sen. Obama suggesting a compulsory National Service. If you want to join National Service, just like the Military, you would receive your education like under the G.I. Bill for your service. Brilliant idea, and not compulsory.

Joy, WI   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

Bay, I see you're on the spin detail tonight...

Nick from CA   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

I have said it before and I will say it again, just because McCain says things faster or louder, that does not make the thing he says correct. Obama's answers may be longer and more complicated, but that is because they contain ideas instead of rhetoric.

Darryl   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

I am cocerned that Obama tells you what he thinks you want to hear. I just cant trust this guy...

Bryan B.   September 11th, 2008 9:33 pm ET

Bay I got a question for you...didn't Pat say that Palin was a "Pitchfork wielder" (or some such thing) of his during his presidential run or MSNBC? I don't like I don't like Pat Buchanan, and I want to know more about Palin's past political affiliations.

Isaac   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

OH, grow up Bay...You're just upset that you've been wrong about Obama from the start. You expected him to come out and get hammered by McCain and he is BETTER than McCain. Just accept it and quit complaining.

mark   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Bill, stop apologizing for your guy– Thanks Candy for being the only objective journalixt

Shawnna   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

I really think that Obama is doing a terrific job tonight by talking specifics. And he hasn't said "uhm" once!

alex   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

As having served in military I think it is important part of service. However I think is crazy to look down on those who do not serve. Lets be honest everybody is not made for the military. They can be just as effctive working in inner cities where much help is also needed.

Mo   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

to BK, expanding the military on a Chinese T-note is??

jackie   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

hey BK

YOu think we can AFFORD THIS WAR? 10 billion a month?

He would SAVE us money compared to that!

JoPat you like straight to the point? how about critical thinking? That would be a nice change from Bush for me!

Vicki Stein, MI   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Thank God, Bay, because Obama will win, then.

Teddy   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

The Matt story is inspiring...

nganenu   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Obama is so generous. he never ignore mccain's contribution to this country. shame on MacCain hiding behind a womwna to diminish the service to the nation.
nganenu

CSpann   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Bay–

Does a forum have to change a vote to be an effective discussion on issues in America? Shouldn't the issue be what good ideas have been presented?

democrat4life   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

not to brag but I think that Obama was the stronger of the two he gave specifics especially about teaching and service. very inspiring – Bill, Candy, Roland? your thoughts

Heather   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

I sure do wish they would lower the voting age! Go McCain and Palin!

Roland Martin,
CNN Political Analyst
  September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Obama seriously learned his lesson from the Saddleback forum.

McCain was masterful in telling stories and playing to the audience.

Not Obama.

So what do we get right now? Obama telling a story.

He knows he screwed up in California.

Somebody watched the tape and learned something.

fran   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

QUESTION FOR ROLAND MARTIN. IF IT IS DEEMED RACISM FOR 10% OF WHITE VOTERS TO STATE THAT THEY WILL NOT VOTE FOR BARACK OBAMA BECAUSE HE IS BLACK, THEN WHY IS NO ONE INCLUDING MR MARTIN COMMENTING ON THE APPARENT RACISM DEMONSTRATED BY THE PROVEN FACT THAT 95% OF BLACK VOTERS SUPPORT OBAMA? THE BLACK VOTE IS THE ONLY DEMOGRAPHIC GROUP THAT VOTES IN SUCH A MONOLITHIC PATTERN(ACCORDING TO CNN POLLS). THANK YOU IN ADVANCE FOR A STRAIGHT FORWARD, NO SPIN ANSWER.

Sergeant Wag   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Sherry,

Mussolini was "on-topic" most of the time.

Andy   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Bay, you sound like my conservative Republican fiance when she knows she's wrong...

Aubrey   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

I dont think we can afford McCain, we are already in a deficit from war, McCain would continue that deficit. Last time I checked democrats usually have a surplus when leaving office!!

Bill witmer   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Put Mccain's military resume in to trash. That is not what we need right now.

we need a person who can get us out of the recession.

Joni Jones   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Bay – at least you stay committed to the cause...cynicism.

Maryellen   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Service? Anyone in politics is of service, no way I would do it! I respect all politicians that run, and serve, and that is another service, to be a politician really. There is Military Service, there are Social Services, and I think McCain represents Military and Obama Social. Quite reflective of the party's I would say.

Michael   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Hey Roland, that is an interesting Idea!

Dean Bumgarner   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Who will be there to serve the investment bankers and defense contractors if we don't elect McCain? Roland, your comment on
the rich hating government handouts unless Bear Stears, Chrysler,
or Fannie Mae needs it was brilliant. Call Obama's campaign
manager and tell him to replace the lipsticked pig comment with
that one!!!!!!!!!!! Do it NOW!

ww-New York   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

LOL BK, we can't afford Bush's/ McCain WAR either.. So your point is???? PLEASE!!!

chip   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

It is remarkable to think that obama has any weight when it comes to inspiring anyone to serve. What has he ever done?

Becky   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Thank you Bill, Roland, Candy & Bay – who would have thought 10 years ago people could sit on their sofa's at home and have thoughtful discussion direct with media. This is a great way for the media to connect with what regular people are feeling about what's going on as it happens.

Garrett   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

BK.. like we can afford 10billion dollars for Iraq/month??

RAY PADGETT   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

I like Obama, but the moderators need to ask some REAL HARD questions here ... American's are waiting for the content ..

Marshall Clark   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

My comment was waiting moderation but seemed to disappeared. I was asking why the candidates and pundants don't explain how they are going to accomplish all the wonderful programs they are explicating. Has the presidency change from executive branch to legislative ?

Chris Morton   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Dear Senator McCain (sent to him online),

I watched and listened to your presentation on social service made tonight at Columbia University in New York. There is one question I have about your comments, please could you help me with an answer.

You said very forcefully that faith-based organizations should be encouraged to continue their social service work, which, you said, is independent of government involvement, including funding. There are two parts to my question:

First, faith-based (also called churches) organizations, I thought, are
tax-exempt. This means, in effect, that everyone pays for them, including the government who must recoup taxes lost through exemption by finding it elsewhere (and the American public is usually that elsewhere) – is my perception correct?

The second part of my question focuses on the support of the government of faith-based programs and their social service work as created by Mr. Bush. You have not mentioned (that I have heard) what you intend to do about this support
- will it be continued, will its development be changed so that it does not fail as it has in the Bush White House, will you expand it, and if so, how?

One of the largest faith-based organizations involved in work in Louisiana is the Salvation Army, and it is also one of the highest government funded organizations through faith-based funding and other grants – it is also one of the largest, and yet you stated categorically that these organizations are not funded by the government. Why did you say this when a large number of them get this indirect and direct funding often funneled through local, county and state governments to local chapters? As 501(c)3 organizations all of these faith-based groups have access to a wide array of government grants, particularly those that are "managed" at local, county and state levels. The continued very poor monitoring of these grants and their uses are a cause of very great concern, often resulting in widespread abuse, but little is done about this – will you monitor 501(c)3 government grant spending including faith-based grant spending better and with some verve?

I am really perturbed about the answers to these questions – either you don't really know or you forgot, which in both cases is very serious.

Chris Morton

Judy H.   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Cecile – McCain might have given smooth answers, but he has put the country in a very dangerous position by selecting such an unseasoned individual for his running mate. There is no way this woman can EFFECTIVELY take over on January 1. The reason I voted against George the First was because he selected Dan Quayle in an attempt to woo female voters. We're smarter than that! I'll vote against McCain because Palin is such an irresponsible choice.

mike   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

gee BK, you think we can afford 350 million / day for a war?

Tera   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

I'm concerned about why Bay is being so very negative. Please stop being so cynical. Can't we just have a conversation? Roland stop messing with Bay!!! LOL!!!!

Brian Green   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Roland, u have definitely got the 'no government handouts' chant from the GOP and the rich right, as we all know as far as they are concerned, it only applies to non republicans and the poor, and isn't it strange how the 'no government handout' crowd in the WhiteHouse (that includes McCain) always gives the biggest handouts to the richest in the country.

One thing I can say that this is an attitude with most 'conservative/republican' governments, because the same applies to the the conservative government and their rich cronies in Canada.

Blackknight   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Roland, as a former member of the U.S. Army, I would agree with that type of tax but I think it should only go to soldiers that are in harms way. It can also be given to soldiers returning from the battlefield that have special needs.

DZ   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

There appears to be some common themes to comments from liberal Obama mania supporters....emotional frustration, victimization, anger, resentment, and a conviction that the solution to all problems is comes from government, not individuals and business.... all reflecting their negative moods about our country. Are you proud of anything?

Wanda Valdosta Ga   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

I think this topic is definitely who Obama is in reality which is why he looks so comfortable. He believes in community service not just military service. Service to our country must be met with support when they come home. That is the only way to build trust.

marta   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

I would support a specific tax that would go only to the members of the miltary, cause I beliveve that they are the most under pay people in the government.

Tianna   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Why I am voting for Obama.
1. He is Extremely Intelligent.
2. I love his willingness to help fund education in return for service(this will make our country better in many facets).
3. I believe in his Energy Corp plan. We need to mobilize in order to make America truly green. The Europeans are beating us with this.
4. He understands that our children are falling behind in Math and Science. We cannot compete with India and China. Mccain has no education plan.

Patricia, Philadelphia, PA   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Bay, can you say anything about Obama that is not dismissive? I mean even some Obama supporters here gave McCain credit. Its the same as Obama telling everyone Palin's family was off limits, but then they turn around and say he wants to teach kindergarten student about sex. Unbelievable sometimes.

Ohio Girl   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

And regarding "shopping".....Have people forgotten so soon the stock market crash and the impact to the airline industry, hotels, travel, and SHOPPING in general aft 911? Of course President Bush had to encourage people to shop again.....our economy went into the tank due to a lack of consumer confidence! How little of him to bash Bush on that issue!

Steve K   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Obama heard the course of questioning before he came out. He should be more at ease.

thad   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

OBAMA MIGHT AS WELL BE IN HIS LIVING ROOM. IT WAS AN UNFAIR INTERVIEW. THIS WAS A HOME COURT ADVANTAGE.
IF THIS HAD BEEN HELD AT MCCAINS COLLEGE THEY WOULD HAVE WENT CRAZY. TYPICAL JUNK BY CNN

Sierra   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

I lover Mrs. Palins interview. She hit me as a a strong woman with great ideas. Watched her with a group of friends and we are all excited. We can't wait to hear more tomorrow night.

Laura   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Obama is doing better than he did at Saddleback. I do feel however that much of what he is saying I have heard during all his various speeches.

I also think that service (the act of helping your fellow man) can be found in all types of activities. Military, community, school, etc.

Laura

namit   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

I think we have another war waiting with McCain Palin.. They jump to conclusions without facts. Diplomacy should always be first option rather war .. I was so disappointed mentioning another option of war from.. We have 8 years of war.. half trillion dollar debt.. 1/3rd of america is owned by others.... We are scared of chinese companies e.g unical and chevron. deal..

AL   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

why does Barack stutter and say ah, ah, uh, ah so much he has to over think his answers he is burying himself in clumsy over rhetoric...

Earnie   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

What about McCain's call for the DRAFT! WHY WON't ANYONE TALK ABOUT THAT?

Christine   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

No, Roland, her pregnancy will NOT be paid for by her mother's health insurance.

First, If you know anything about Health Insurance...the Grandmother's health insurance does not cover Grandchildren or
married childrens' pregancies and births. Once she marries, she is off the her mother's health insurance plan.

She is getting married. Married children can not be covered under their parents plans.

As usually, the left wing media has not done it's homework.

Tired of the media   September 11th, 2008 9:32 pm ET

Whoa!!!!! Roland, where did you come from.....how dare you blast someone who has volunteered to protect our country...not just a city where people have made a mess out of their neighborhood..... this man volunteered to protect our country. Risk life and limb for you....well, I guess being a cnn political analyst is a real ego trip for you.
In the future I will make sure I change channels when I see your face. Your mama sure did miss out on teaching you respect and you sure missed out on any manners.....SHAME ON YOU!!!

Franco Russo   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

I agree this forum is mundane and is not pushing the issues like Saddleback

dusty   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

how is obama going to pay for all of these government funded groups and all the money he is proposing to spend tonight. Seems to me his answer for everything is to spend hard earned tax dollars.

Minpres   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Just because you are a POW does not make you qualified to be president of the united states, if anything it scares me because it is all mccain seems to care about is war, he is not concerned with the economy,education, the employment rate etc, the man is simply out of touch and if i hear that i will make them famous line again i dont know what i will do

Loyal American123   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

What is taking so long for Levi to marry Bristol?

Jason   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Is there a reason why Palin is not campaigning on her own? If the Republicans don't trust her to act on her own how can the American people?

Nathan Hale   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

McCain= war hero
Obama= friend of terrorists

Karen Whittemore   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Yhe military should always have the very best medical benefits, America has to offer, always! Physically and mentally! If they are willing to give their lives...or have their legs blown off...or have Tramatic Stress Syndrome...they deserve the best medical benefits!
Obama voted for this!

JAD   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Then why wouldn't he want to apply everything he just said to the military people who served or are serving our country at this moment.
Why wait !!!! clean up the problems we have with the VA now around the country. Why should this only apply to teachers they have a union that should be supporting them.

Dee   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Roland, I nominate you to be one of President Obama's advisors. You are so wise and he is too. The perfect match.

Rick in Minnesota   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Roland, well stated!

Texico From Mexico   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Someone please tell me what has McCain done for veterans like me in his 26 years? I will tell you....NOTHING! All we have is a joke of a G.I. Bill that will not even cover costs for 1 year at a state univeristy, never mind getting into a private school.

Veterans for Obama

LISA   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

So it's okay for Sara to kill animals. But Michael Vick goes to prison for fighting and killing Dogs. Wow American people Wake the Ump Up!

Where is PETA now People! Hmm

Liz   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

If Obama can't keep the streets of his state safe, how will he keep America safe?

CHANGE our mindset   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

The reason for the military being so unattractive is that not everyone wakes up and decides that "today I'm ready to join the military and go fight someone".

Obama made a great point by pointing out the many different responsiblities or opportunities for joining the military.

He made it very attractive from those points alone.

Don T.   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Bill @ 9:13,

Are you so naive to think that if service became a national issue that neither Obama and McCain would compromise? Though they may "appear" to be different based on the statements, we all know in the end, both sides will compromise where government will be involved somehow – that's why government is getting out of hand. Proof is in Bush's Faith-based program – gov't is still involved and it got just a little bit larger.

j.williams, san diego   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

i now see that this man –is not someone i would trust the future of my children with...It's only words and speeches–nothing more...

mike   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

why is mccain's service legendary? were not there thousands of pow's??

Ron   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

where did sen. Obama work before he went to college he must have done something to help pay his way

Lisa   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Is it just me or is Obama starting to steal McCain's most famous lines? Serve a cause greater than you...that sounds way too familiar!

Fatma Yossip   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Mr. Mccain,

It is very disappointing to see you complaining about a lipstick and pig expression and accusing obama as sexist when you used it against Hillary Rodham Clinton. Talk about change and honor and serving a cause above your self. What a shame.

deloresbell   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Obama segment is so inspirational and forward thinking. We really need someone to move us into the future.
All McCain talked about was war war war. He thinks of nothing else!!!!!

jamie22   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Obama got to hear McCains questions, what a joke! Moderators go after McCain and leave Obama go on... and on....and on with NO tough questions. I thought this was to be about service to country, Not a one sided obamathon! If Obama says uh uh uh uh one more time before each sentence I will puke.

ZYEDCO D   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Hey Bill, Roland,Bay and Candy,,,,What about school principals, and the folks that maintain schools they may get paid but not enough isn't that national service. Like to hear your comments.

jackie   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

ROTC doesn't have to be on campus for people to know its an option..I agree with Roland....service is service...I wn't want my kids to be in the service is McCain/Palin was in charge...they will take us into another war!

elio   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Obama cannot answer a question directley. As far as i'm concerned he is finished, he just does not have what it takes to be President.

Barbara   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Candy – Obama thinks in paragraphs. Not just sound bites. ; )

Jake Diliberto   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Wow.... Senator Obama has really made some ground here with this commentary on community service and military interpolation. I think Gov. Palin and John Mccain would not be as inclusive as Sen. Obama. He really pushes on domestic and international work being equally important. If the GOP doesnt pick up on this this could be a big voter attraction. WHat do you think??

kat   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

I am sorry, Nathan, you cannot tell me that a social worker who goes into a drug infested neighborhood to get a child out is somehow not putting thier life on the line for a greater good. There is no higher purpose then service, whatever form one chooses, in my opinion.

winningside   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Obama! is not real or Honest, he is evading and avoiding most of the questions him, with alot of wording, and he is not getting right to the point, he is at arms length, and he has nerver served in our Military so he would not be a good commander and Cheif, like McCain, Obama remember he was present even while he was in his the building, so he really never took part in the politcal responsiblity, of really voting on the issues, so that should tell you alot, He is always pointing the finger on the president, well he should look at the Clintons, they had this information of 9/11 for the last four years of there stance of the presidency! while the Bush had it only for a couple of months, We are pointing the fingers at the wrong persons, it should be the clintons, but the press and the Democrats have this wrong, and Congress had had this information for many years as well and we still blame the Bush people, We say thank you for one sided infor

Charles L. Shaw   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

I see the voice of freedom is censored again.

Russ   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Im not sure everyone is keeping track of all the promises of aid that Obama is promising- $4000 for every child for school- yes that would be great as I have 3 of my own- but How will he pay for it??? TAXES!! Why take it one month and give it back in taxes the next??

Pete   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

You are wrong Roland
How many people volunteer to a service they know they may not come back home. Only the brave and courageos do. Dying for someone is the ultimate sacrifice. I would say military service trumps all, in my opinion.

Kujo   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Sergeant Wag

who did you vote for 4 years ago?

EJ (USA)   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Overall Obama is presenting more thoughtful, detailed, and innovative ways of service.

Indeed!

dennise   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

My take on a doctor who provides service in a rural area vs a hospital is they might be inclinded to take paycuts vs a hospital...Which goes back to Obama's well noted time as a community organizer. He wasn't paid well, but yet he chose his community over a better paying job.

Mary   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

I personally think that Obama has a hidden agenda. The man scares me and I am an African American. I would love for this election to be about the issues and not race or gender. All of the smart remarks and taking things out of context are rediculous. I will vote for McCain for the simple reason – he is the lessor of two evils. I simply can not vote for Obama because he is dishonest and I don't trust the man.
I know that I am one of few and others disagree with me every day. I think McCain and Palin need to walk the walk when they are elected.

Boone , NC   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

You're exactly right Clay. The media needs to do their part to get things on the right track.

Grace Brewer   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

I was surprised that the forum tonight, second presidential candidate was allowed to listen to the first presidential candidate, and then be in the position to comment on the first speaker.

David   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Obama makes me proud to be an American once again!

Tom from WI   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Roland

You speak of working in a rural locatin is somehow doing a service as if its like working in the third world.

Us your own advise and don't talk on what you don't know anything about.

You sound as if crime and gangs and murders only take place in cities and I have news for you rural areas have it to and more than fair share.

lynn   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Concerned: I agree with you; CNN would do a great service if they would publish both candidates policy papers on national service. They are both on Mark Halperin's The blog and are revealing to voters who want to educate themselves beyong 30 or 60 second answer,

Mike, Syracuse NY   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Read 'Band of Brothers' and tell me community service stacks up.

Becky S.   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

I don't believe a word Mr. B. Hussein Obama is saying. He is a little too arrogant and sure of himself. He talks in lofty terms for a man who has very little applicable experience. I am sorry, I've tried but I just don't get the hero worship that the media has for him.

Roger   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Why does Judy W. have to keep giving McCain's answers to Obama, when he's already been allowed to watch/listen and formulate his answers from McCains???

AMY RARICK   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

Why doesn't anyone ask who the candidates will choose for cabinet members? The vp waits for a crisis so they can step in. We are at war...doesn't anyone want to to know who the Joint Chiefs of Staff would be, or the Secretary of State? This is what matters!!

Loyal American123   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

The Bushies plan to give Georgia over $2B this year.
Who is the lobbyist for Georgia?

AD   September 11th, 2008 9:31 pm ET

McCain says we don't need governement. Then what they hell is he running for office for?

Onyeka   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Must agree to giving our men and women of the military specific tax so that pay will raise.

Andrew   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Roland, I think you missed something. No government and Freddie and Fannie never exist.

Julius - Shreveport   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Roland,
Would the special tax for the military include retirees.

BK   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

I don't think we can afford Obama and all his programs.

US Citizen living abroad   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Bee Explain What Way Roland is talking – and are you really meaning that there are only whites allowed in the "White House"

SEA   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Khyati Desai–your so right. If more importance was put on community service-world wide-then maybe, just maybe there would not be a need for military service.

jopat   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

The main difference between McCain and Obama is McCain is straight to the point and Obama is so wishy washy. His answers are long and winding . I think Obama is not too confident anymore on winning this election. The Democrats were so cocky before that it will bea cake walk beating any Republican nominee. But they never anticipated the resilience of McCain and the discovery of the superstar Sarah Palin.

gerri   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Hey Bay,good idea about the teachers and while we are at it,lets get rid of some political hacks like yourself that divide our country rather than try to unite it?

cg-msp   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Maybe if we put as much emphasis on finding the best and brightest to serve in diplomacy and valued it we would not need to send as many men and women into harm's way in war.

Joec87   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

He is very calm

CSpann   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Regarding Peace Corp...I am member of Americorp. This organization provides services here in the US. We are in schools and communities around the country. Members provide a variety of services from tutoring to medical services to rebuilding after storms.

roberto   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

no disrespect to mcain and our military. but being a pow and serving in our military does not mean that u can help our economy and better our health plan. i see alot of vets living on the street. let me ask u what did there military experence do for them.

Martin Tease   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Roland you are right. We need to stop putting one level of activism for this country over another. If the military people here want to ask questions. then ask McCain why he has voted against or has not been for most bills or legislation to help veterans on education, services, healthcare, etc.

Secondly how can you encourage people to join the military now, when we have an obvious view that is skewed by a mismanaged war, troops being push beyond their limits, ill equipped resources, etc.

FGP   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Obama is considerably more specific on issues than the wishy-washy McCain who tends to dance around the issues.

Christian, Tampa FL   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Let's keep in mind that firefighters and police officers put their lives in harm's way. 9/11 proved that.

Matt.G   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Barack Obama won this Forem tonight hands down! Palin doesnt know squat about foregien policy, just talking points from McSames Campaign.

Jennifer   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Concerned....RIGHT on the money!

abdul   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

i side with katiec in what she says
although cnn is an excellent channel (one of tthe best news channels actually)

but i still feel that they are more republican
they seem to side with mccain in ALMOST everything
and they they cover up all his and palins blunders and mistakes.

Vishal   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

uh gee, after spending 100's of thousands on a college education, do I really want to join the army and fight in a war I don't believe in?

If Iraq was the reason 9/11 happened you would see more people joining. Truth is most young people don't believe in the war, and if they don't believe in the war, why in heck would they ever want to join?

sjprugh   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

As long as Senator Obame continues to attack the critical issues in this campaign... he should beat McCaint in November. No substance in the republican campaign, more of the same, as usual.

Common Sense   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Can we all agree that 'Country First' is a vague, cynical platitude aimed at raising questions about your opponents patriotism. The whole theme of 'Country First' inherently downgrades community service to be inferior to military service.

Monica, Texas   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Obama makes a great point that if the gov't cuts the red tape and as a leader there is a call for action many more folks would volunteer their time and service....

Roland Martin,
CNN Political Analyst
  September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Here is the grand solution to the service issue for those who are compelled to do something:

Right now, write down ONE THING you want to see changed in your community, and commit yourself to finding out how to make it happen.

Then commit yourself to doing that for the next year. Just the next year.

And on Sept. 11, 2009, determine what progress you have made.

That's the starting point.

Patti Zimmerman   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Barach is right to ask for civilian and military service. How exciting to be part of a new movement, to rebuild the honor of selfless service. Just like being asked to go green, we need to be asked to pay it forward for the next generation.

OBAMA   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Obama's answers are soo much more specific than McCains. When McCain got asked about goverment role in our nation, he just replied that we have to be cautious about how much of a role it plays. Obama totally owned that when he explained specifically that the government is needed and that more government doesnt always mean more taxes. So all those people who say Obama isnt specific, there you have it!

Bay Buchanan,
Republican Strategist
  September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

this forum is not going to change a vote.

Carla   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Watch the body language on the Time mag interviewer. Was on the edge of his chair, leaning in, hand movements – really engaged, hanging on every word of mccain. (also asking softball questions that favor him)

Notice the change now that Obama's been on. He's sitting way back in his chair, telegraphing disinterest. Much tougher questions. Good for Obama, though – he's doing great!!!

Carla

Gail from Fl   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

I am surprised and disappointed to hear that Candy feels Obama should do well because he is on home turf.... this is not a football game. I think he sounds better because he is the better candidate, with more ideas for the American public.

Paul   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

What Schneider and the commentators fail to share with everyone is that ROTC is homophobic and the universities have a non-discrimination policy. When the military/ROTC gets rid of their divisive Don't Ask, Don't Tell, then it will no longer be an issue. Obama will get rid of DADT, McCain will not.

Sherry   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Yes I agree with an above comment- McCain does seen to have two personalities- and I just don't trust him because he waffles between too often on issues- and in the past EVEn between parties. He's a War vet – and I appreciate that. But he's 72 and out of touch with the innovative ideas and progressiveness I hope to see achieved in the nations government.

Tommy   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

I can't believe Barack didn't how 9/11 was being used politically by the Republican party.

This is a appalling and should be brought to the public's attention, and we as Americans should demand it be stopped.

American   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Roland,

How about a specific tax to support National Service?

Joni Jones   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Bill Schneider – I love you!

Sandra   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Why do we have to read Candy, Bill and Roland? Don't we hear and see enough of them everyday. I thought this forum was suppose to be about service and not political. Judy asked a few political questions for McCain which I thought was unfair . I don't know about Obama because after the first question and his lingering answer (I didn't wait to hear the end) I turned the TV OFF. Same ole, same ole.

Johnny   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Roland this setting would be better if both candidates were together but this is a nice repreive/setting from the the divisive partisan politics that consistently gets displayed throughout this campaign by both sides and enflamed by the media.

This general focus area is one where it seems Obama and McCain share commonality. As Americans (Republicans and Democrats) we spend more time pointing fingers at the other party for what they said or what they have or haven't done than trying to find the areas where we have common ground and working from there.

Being an American isn't a zero sum game however both parties and candidates have forgotten some of the basic constructs and principles that our forefathers fought so hard for many years ago.

Kaydee   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

As a child advocate and parent I am extremely concerned that Sarah Palin's "appearance" as an "Evangelical Christian" is merely all talk. Anyone can go to church and be anti-abortion. Where were mom and dad when teenage daughter needed attention? Do the research. Teen pregnancies usually occur because the parents are somehow unavailable and disconnected from the family. The Palins were attending to political business instead of raising and CARING FOR (being involved) with their family. I see Sarah Palin as power hungry, and egoCENTRIC. Extremely self-serving. She does NOT represent my Christian beliefs because my beliefs embrace FAMILY FIRST. Look at George W. Karl Rove had him painted as a devout, Bible toting, spiritually filled Christian man and all of us Christians were fooled by him. I no more believe Sarah Palin is the "upright Christian" she portrays herself to be than do I believe George W. Bush to be. Anyone can say they are anti-abortion and ultra-conservative. But do their actions truly SUPPORT those ideologies? Are "true Christians" underhanded, deceitful, self-serving, manipulative, mud-slingers who lie to their friends, colleagues (American public) and settle things by strong-arming others? Or are they diplomatic and peace-making? (And I don't mean weak and spineless) Come on people this is PURE DECEPTION, once again. It's the same story with a pair of high heels. We bought it with George W. and now look at the opinion polls! I'm not saying either of these people are "bad people" but I do NOT believe either of them are honest about who they really are and what they really stand for because I believe they stand only for themselves, not the American people or CHRISTIAN VALUES! At least not mine! Don't be deceived by Palin like we were by Bush!

Steve   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Hey Roland, quick question: Are your arms getting tired carrying Obama's water!

You need to go suck on a Zoloft and even out a bit!

Joe Boggs   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Can someone please tell me how Obama is supposedly for "hope" when he voted to end the life of a child who survived an abortion. This is truly baffling. Please vote for McCain, at least he has dignity for human life.

Louise   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

McCain is full of it. He has been running a nasty campaign, and to blame Obama for the the tone of his campaign is ridiculous.

And to Bill, just because Obama is at ease does not mean he heard the questions. I definitely believe McCain had the questions beforehand when he appeared with Rick Warren. Obama was in hostile territory, and he did well. The media never said anything about the possiblity of McCain having the questions. Now, who is the media supporting? I think it is obvious.

Obama looks Presidential tonight.

kp   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

it's easy for OBAMA to ride the coat tails of McCain's answers. This is the glaring difference between the two. McCain is a true leader and Obama is a follower.

The flipped a coin McCain went first. I get that. However, they should have sequestered Obama. If not, then as McCain pointed in his segment, why didn't they just have all four of them together on the stage tonight and engage in what is supposed to be a bipartisan discussion on service.

Aubrey   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

I dont understand where they get the serving in the military is the only way to serve your country, how about teaching, so that we all wont be dumb and lacking behind the world, how about medical practice, so that we wont all die out early, how about Police, so that we can be protected in America from the people that live in America. We have this notion that America is perfect and we can do no wrong.....well WRONG!!!

Steve K   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Military pay could be increased with the money saved in cutting out the pork. And still not have to increase taxes.

Glen Shouse Jr.   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

I think the whole military service, community service thing is petty. The key word here is service. If this country could get more people to serve in any positive way we would be better off, and I would encourage my kids to admire any of them.

Texico From Mexico   September 11th, 2008 9:30 pm ET

Hey Bill, Cops and Fireman put it on the line also....

gc   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

The trickle down Republicans need to demand National Service of the corporations they pour our tax $ into, before they take the national stage and pander to the military they have put into harm's way to continue pouring $ into the coffers of a corupt military-industrial complex that Dwight D Eisenhower warned the US about.

His daughter sees the truth; obreviously the rest of the republicans who claim to be patriotic do not.

GC in West TX

Jake   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

I'm with everything Obama just said in that last segment. Politically and factually brilliant!

EJ (USA)   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

I'll say this, a doctor who chooses to provide medical care in rural towns where they live too far from a hospital is just as honorable as someone in the military.

We should respect anyone who makes this decision. Not try to say one is better than the other.

Amen to that.

A canadian watching   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Just wanted to say that after watching all those news and debates since the begining of this campaing. This one is the most inspiring and civilized.

Gilles from Montreal

zcaveman   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

What would really change America is if we nationalized ALL insurance, mortage companys, healthcare, utility services, and VOTED on EVERY law !

Cheryl   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

One of the military-type benefits that should be offered to American citizens engaged in service overseas is access to the PX, commissary and on-base medical facilities. They should also receive the 5 point preference when applying for federal jobs.

Teddy   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Roland, you're right....absolutely right

Joec87   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

True

Donald Stuckey   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Let's just be honest most people do want to help others, but many people need a little encouragement to do so. I think this is where Obama is coming from, helping students pay for school in exchange for doing National Service is a good way to get that of all in their communities.

Kevin   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

The military card only goes so far. I have done both I am a vet and manage HUD properties where community service programs are required for the residents. Both are challenging but the military is a world all of it's own and outside of it you deal with every day people with no on post housing and a mess hall for chow. They have bills etc militray get housing allowances when they live off post and extra pay for dependents. As for BIG Government why doesn't Obama state the fact that the Democrats are more fiscally conservative by all economic standards?

Ken   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

I agree that all of Palin's credentials make her a great Republican, but what makes her a great Vice-Predsidential Pick?

It appears that the media is giving her a free ride....if she is so ready to lead then why such limited access...she's one heart beat away....Obama and Clinton were both racked over the coals for the history...but Palin is being treated like her past mistakes and record is not of importance.

Jessica Mattison   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Senator sounds evasive regarding military service....is he intending or is is considering " re instituting a mandatory military draft ?"

Plain and simple question that I think he is being dishonest about by being evasive on this issue.

Is Obama speaking of drafting Americans into forced military service ???

Jessica.

Candy Crowley, CNN Sr. Political Correspondent   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

I sat through Saddleback too - Obama seems much more at ease here. More direct, less meandering.

Joyce   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Randy Smythe, I somewhat agree. However, idoon't you think that f goverment created the problem, then government needs to fix the problem??

Reagan   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

I am still waiting for Obama to answer a question directly rather than ignore it and talk about his naive fantasies.

Tammy   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

I wonder what Mr. Obama knows about the military. One of the career areas in the US Army is Civil Affairs. My nephew spent 11 mos in Iraq facilitating agricultural development and economic development. The civil affairs soldiers are taught to work with the local community to find qualified experts. That way there is continuity after the military pull out. This is the way democracy is developed. My other nephew is currently serving in a Civil Affairs unit in Wasit province in Iraq. His unit has worked to establish a court system in that province as well as many economic development projects. He is due home in 2 mos.

David F   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

They should ask him about government oversight of those Blackwater contractors etc.

Daniel   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Roland:
I would support such a tax and I'm a Republican. I would view it as a way for me to contribute.

Bill Schneider,
CNN Sr. Political Analyst
  September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Overall Obama is presenting more thoughtful, detailed, and innovative ways of service.

Dr. No   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

CNN rarely posts my comments.

For once, I hope they do.

I'm a Navy vet. I was a nuclear engineer. I had friends that I grew up with and we all joined the service together. I went to the Navy, my other two close buddies went to the Army. One of those friends died in Iraq in 2007.

I still can't comprehend it in some ways. I know he died with valor but for all the wrong reasons. I know this because he told me this. He was a good person who loved his country.

Everyone has a story, but why should mine be different? It probably isn't different to many, but to those who have been affected by the war, and the economy, we want answers to those problems.

McCain, Obama, CNN...why can't we get answers to our problems? All we get is lipstick junk stories and who smeared who but nothing that is going to bring my other friend home.

I have followed CNN for some time, quite some time, and they have been leaning toward the right. And I do feel that Obama tries quite hard to talk about the issues. McCain is more involved with the smear tactics and negative ads.

Is there anyone out there? And if there is, are you listening? Are you listening to us? Do you see that we need help?

-Shayne

Freda   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Do you plan on making cancer a national priority, if so how will you execute it

Larry Hines   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

What steps are being taken about hate crime laws in indiana, since there isnt none....

Liz   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

More people died on the the streets of Chicago last year then on the battlefield in Iraq last year.

Curtis   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

What I've heard tonight is John McCain telling me that military service is the only true way to serve your country while Obama is saying that making the lives of your fellow Americans better and/or safer in any way is service.

I agree with Obama's platform.

lizzy   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

I can not believe that for the most part I have stumbled upon a forum with intelligent and thoughtful comments.....how great is this?!

trudy   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Why is there a Republican Strategist in here but no Democratic Strategist?

Kimberly   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Does Obama come across Angry and Fake? Just my observation!

Loyal American123   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

ask if the 2 candidates w9ill be willingf to denounce any and every Plum Book applicant who cheated, ever, on Social Security taxes.

Tom from NJ   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Why is Obama being asked these cushy, feel good questions, with inserted negativity by the commentators; one of which said an article of Obama's plan is in this week's Time magazine? These are stupid questions that defeat the purpose of this so called discussion.

Also, this isn't a litmus test to determine his qualifications and abilities to lead OUR country but a good old down home type gab fest that America does not need to hear for this very important election!

This is a complete waste of America's time!

RAY PADGETT   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

LOL ... A wonderful idea Roland .... Wonderful

Jessy King   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

that is what I have been saying this whole time

David Anderson   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

It is clear to me from his choice for Vice-President that John McCain is under pressure from the advisers to George Bush who have run this country into the ground with their Darwinian economics. The task for Barack Obama is to convince the undecided voters that he is not a socialist who believes that the government should run the country, that he is for strong national defense, that he is for energy independence, that he is for reform of the health system, that he is for immigration reform, and that he is not indebted to the traditional supporters of the Democratic party, like the teacher's union, trial lawyers, and other similar groups. If he can do this, he will be elected because America is fed up with Karl Rove and his kind.

Richard Foy   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

I have been amazed at how people can believe that a person, regardles of race or gender, can lead the most powerfull country in the history of mankind with vertually no experience and didn't even grow up in America. I firmly believe that if you have not had any military experience or a family history of military experiece, you do not have any concept of how to defend freedom or what that takes. If you have not witnessed the horrows of not having freedom; i.e., Russia, China, Vietnam, Iraq, Africa, Korea, Germany you can not understand at what lengths we must go to maintain our freedom. You can not defend freedom with ships, airplanes, bombs. It takes, people. Look at Iraq. All the might of the US can not eliminate a huge number of casualties until the people take charge.

twila   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

what happened to objectivity in the media. The media especially CNN runs the same tired speech that Paln gave at the GOP convention, she is lying this has been proven by many different sources including CNN and she is still seen lying over and over again, I thought that the media was supposed to be the watch dogs, Not the Lapdogs!!

DJB   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Roland, how disrespectful and rude! To the Lt. Col.! Would you have said that if he had been a supporter of the other candidate?

EqualBranchesofGovernment   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Excellent point Nick......just ask Paris Hilton .......didn't she promise to use her celebrity to do some good in Africa after she had "do time" for her D.U.I.?

Misha   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Roland, please you need to listen to what Sarah Palin said on Charlie Gibson's interview.Oh my goodness.You will be shocked. Tell your cnn team there they need to scrutinize all irrelevant replies she gave to Charlie Gibson. This will be news tomorrow.

ncgma   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Mr. McCain sounded great this evening, right on with all the questions, I was very impressed.

Kathie   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Thank you Senator Obama for recognizing the Foreign Service, and USAID. As the mom of a Foreign Service Officer the validation is appreciated.

A. Bellak   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

What's Bay Buchanan doing there ? Why didn't you also invite a democrat strategist, like Carville or Mrs Brazile ? Mrs Buchanan seems to watch a different forum than we are.

John   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Even do Obama heard the questions before coming out here its very clear here someone is more thoughtful before answering a question.

FrancescaY   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Senator John McCain talk about how he is going to extend military, get more fund for the Peace corp., America corp, and possible created new programs that has to do with service. Those ideas are great, but McCain campaign is about lowing taxes. What I want to know? Is why didn’t your correspondent asks a follow up question? Such as, How you are going to pay for these programs without raising taxes?

lostinthemadness   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

How can we expect our young people to serve when they are being place in situations such as wars that are predicated on blatant lies. Shouldn't those that served be told the truth about why they will be sacrificing their lives. Most of the young folks out there defending this great country of ours are poor why the rich folks are making the rules. Few of the rich military members are actually doing the grunt work instead they are busy hiding the truth. Again, one who is so cynical at this point. What is the purpose of this forum?

Jessy King   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Roland that is a great question

Colt   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

I am just getting in on this but..

If Obama and McCain reference each other and ideas that they agree with... I don't think that is a good thing for either campaigns.

DREW79   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Another great Idea Scholarship for teachers willing to teach in failing schools

James Cox   September 11th, 2008 9:29 pm ET

Obama is blowing McCain away. I can't wait for them to debate and I know that the better candidate is on stage right now.

jack strong   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Mary im disappointed in you...you are starting to make Glen Iffel look conservative.

pam   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

now she's quoting lincoln to cover up her quote that she made to her church about "god's task", this is going to be fun to watch her
evaporate slowly over the next week or so. why obama didn't pick hillary i will never understand, hopefully he'll come to his senses and start campaigning with her and announce that she'll be our next
secretary of state! that should bring the poll numbers back up as well as make a great team to run the country.

Rick in Minnesota   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Are we discussing what is more honorable or what is important to each individual and how that person can best make a difference

Ohio voter   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Nick from CA

I don't blame younger people for not signing up for the military right now. I wouldn't sign up for anything run by an incompetent CEO (Bush)

valerie   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Good point concerned.

hicktick   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

If we would mind or own business, we wouldnt need so much military, chairty begins at home

mike   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

obama is right on point about all issues very engaged ..

Vicki of NJ   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Senator Obama just said that we are the wealthiest country on earth; however, given our current deficit which is only continuing to grow, I don't know that we are the wealthiest anymore. And, how can young students volunteer for service, whether it be community or otherwise, when they will be busy trying to pay back their loans for schooling. I come from a family of 10 and their was not enough government back then to help pay for college for me and my siblings, so we didn't go to college. As it is, my father worked 2 jobs all of his life to support us and we are all honorable American Citizens and help our neighbors whenever we see the need. The government can't afford to pay for students to go to college. We are already spending above our means now and that is not a lesson we should be teaching our children. When we were growing up, we were a one car family and we made it by walking or sharing rides, etc. Now, every child at driving age has to have and usually gets their own car. So are we spoiled perhaps in thinking we absolutely need it to survive along with our 2 & 3 cellphones each?

Chad Stephenson   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

How can he say what he is saying ? How can Obama talk of the military as he does when he has yet to serve in any shape himself ? How can his short days he has spent in the government allow him to feel competent to serve this country in the highest office ? In my opinion, he is trying to skip to the front of the line without waiting through what everyone else who has the proper dedication to get to the front has done by patiently waiting !! If I wanted to ride any roller coaster growing up, I had to wait in line for the proper time !! I could NOT move straight from the end of the line to the ride without going through the line !! What makes Obama think he is qualified to do what no man or woman that has ever walked this earth could do ?

Blair for Illinois   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

I feel if you don't want to serve your government (local or federal) then you shouldn't expect them to help you. If you serve, they should pay for college.

Darren   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Why does nobody mention that the current administration has been the ANTITHESIS to this concept of service across the board. They totally stuck this thing straight to military and their families, and from us they hid it with tax cuts on borrowed money, sticking it to our kids. Shameful! They wouldn't even let it touch us in the form of coffins on our TVs. The current administration is getting undeserved cover from this campaign. I would like to see the Obama campaign take the lid off of this when they reveal to the nation over the next eight weeks that McCain is 'w's Siamese twin.

Sherry, Atlanta   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

NOW PLEASE, why would anyone vote for McCain? When Obama's ON MESSAGE. . .

OB SUPPORTER   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

What If, What If , after 911 the most horrific act probably inflicted
on the US in the US since Pearl Harbor. The president used this
to embrace the need to get away from the dependency on foreign
oil. What impact would this have had on the American people, the
Auto indusrty, the oil companies.

msdx   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

More than anything else I am finding that Obama and McCain agree more than they disagree. The difference? Karl Rove politics directly contradict McCain Peace and cooperation message. I find it very hard to believe he is sincere, but Obama is far more genuine and believable even with the same message. Its like McCain is a kid that steals from the cookie jar all the time telling you he doesn't care about cookies and Obama is the good kid that never takes any. Which one do you believe the guy with his hand in the cookie jar or the guy that always seems to do the right thing? There are beginning to be real reasons, with McCain's campaign style, to stop trusting him.

CLA   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Right on, RM! Thanks for the comment, I agree totally. Does military service immediately qualify someone for office? Does having been a POW necessarily qualify someone to be President? No! Bill Clinton didn;t serve & he presided over the eight most peaceful & prosperous years in our history. Conversely, Bush didn;t really serve either & look what's happened on his watch. Military service is not the litmus test for any position...

Chanel   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Bay, when was the last time the McCain campaign even talked about improving the schools. You are working really hard for McCain tonight..

Juan G.   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Nick form CA

I disagree, it is not that young people are not compelled to serve, its that young people need to choose between paying for student loans or serving their country.

I WANT THE TRUTH   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Sargent Wag wake up. Many of our soldiers today have no intent on going to war. Many want a education and a steady payckeck. Although giving your life is physically is selfless there are many who give all the days of their lives and get nothing in return either. MILITARY is not better than anyone. Although it is greatly appreciated it is not the only slefless act of community and country.

FLARTIST   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

They talk the talk but never ask for a sacrifice...just keep shopping!

DHolmesNC   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Roland you took the Doctor comment right out of my head!

Turn VA blue   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Military service is NOT necessary to be president or even be a great president – FDR did not have any military experience!

Blackknight   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Did anyone from CNN view the interview that McCain had today with a news anchor in Maine? It was very revealing in terms of their approach to answering questions related to Palin's foreign policy experience.

AL   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Barack where was your wife on 9/11 memorial...Cindy was with John McCain, or was your wife more proud of the terrorists and not America....

Matt90   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

In the end we will all realize that a 72-year, 3-time cancer survivor cannot be trusted in the Oval Office if the next in line is a 44 year, 2-year governor from one of the nation's least populated states.

Experience? Well Obama has none either!

Very well, but the American people think he deserved to get FIRST BILLING on his party's ticket. Voters actually went out and made a choice. People made a judgment on his background and decided he deserves a shot.

Nobody did that with Sarah Palin. As a matter of fact, she wasn't even good enough to get into the primary. She is all style, no substance. The Republicans are gearing up to lose it all.

Daniel   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Ron: I too am ashamed that I never served in the military. I'm 38 so, from what I gather, I could still go in but with a whole mess of young kids...it just doesn't seem right. Frankly, I support compulsary national service. My father still keeps in touch with people he served with and it is a very diverse group. Mandatory service would strengthen our country.

tony   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Senator Obama speaks eloquently about his plans to fix public educaton yet during his tenure in Illinois and national politics his real actions have been to send his children to the most exclusive private school in Chicago. It speaks volumes about his oportunistic politics

Michael   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Fabian, you argument is rediculous. you imply that by not being in the military, I am the hundreds of million of other americans are not patriotic, are not diciplined, do not honor our country.
That sir is offensive!

Shawnna   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Fabian- how can you suggest that every man and women should be forced to do 2 yrs service to the military? In what world would that make any sense? Contrary to what you may have been told, you can learn Honor, respect and discipline at home with the right parents. How dare you question non military cititzen's patriotism! What a shmuck!

Larry   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Roland you are correct about DOCTORS ...I think that is a smart idea and I would support it...

jack strong   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

its obvious this forum was staged to cater to Obama's community service
FFS.....its being held at his alma mater university how biased is that!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Justin Gagnon   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Concerned, great thinking, elections have become a media circus, its time to get back to the issues

Mo   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

Wheres McCain seemed to focus on a few good men for service, Obama appears to solicit all to service.

Tera   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

I think Obama is being very substantive and you can tell that he knows of what he speaks. I'm supporting Sen. Obama but I think Sen. McCain did well too. I did find it interesting that he really didn't address the fact that more kids that are not well off are in the military. they should have pressed harder there. Sen McCain said offer them more incentives to become officers. If they are well off, what's the incentive that you use?

Woman of Feathers   September 11th, 2008 9:28 pm ET

It is so refreshing to hear someone actually answer the questions instead of skirting around them with the same pat answers we have heard over and over.

April in Texas   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

my husband was turned down for the army so to try and draft him now would be a contradiction imo. I just hope we get steady jobs back where you work for a company forever till you retire and thats that ... Man i need health care too but cant afford it due to contract work currently.. So far I have always been disappointed in my presidential picks or they didnt win.. Hope its not that way this year as I may give up voting..

Janice Il   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

The national Guard should be just as the name applies NATIONAL in the United States. Our soldiers are needed here at times of difficulty and could serve OUR country in many ways that are not being utilized by the goverment for the good of our nation alone.

natasha in tally   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

ALL AMERICAN SERVICE IS VITAL NOT JUST MILITARY BUT COMMUNITY SERVICE AS WELL.

OBAMA 08

Nathan   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

I hate hearing how there's a "government program" that can heal all of our wounds and fix everything when there isn't. I don't want to be reliant on the government to move on with my life! A big part as to why people are stuck where they are is poor personal choices, and a government that gets in our way too often. No matter how many programs are started, there will always be people that have a hard go at life!!!

Maryellen   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

I am beginning to think that people are not listening and thinking this through but making choices to vote based on who is more charming on the camera. I personally would like women to remember if the repubs win what we stand to lose is our right of choice. Why does that NEVER seem to come up when we are talking about Palin and McCain? I personally think this is THE most important issue at stake since they are BOTH declared to do what they can to reverse Roe v Wade. With that being said, I do not believe everyone that liked Hillary is going to Palin, the media saying women are doing that are saying women are stupid and I simply do not buy it.

patti   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

On the Lipstick on a pig comment. That is an old saying and even one of the republican's Tory something wrote a book entitled "Lipstick on a Pig." why is it that when John McCain said it twice and others mentioned it, it wasn't a big deal. But just because Palin mentioned the word Lipstick, it became a big deal. Why is it that people are so sensitive for this woman, when they lambasted Hillary Clinton?

Ohio Girl   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

Why wasn't Obama in the secluded cone during the time McCain was interviewed? He keeps saying he listened to John McCain's interview. He had a huge advantage in knowing the questions in advance and also John McCain's answers!

Bill Schneider,
CNN Sr. Political Analyst
  September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

Obama was careful to put the military in a special category of service, because its people who put their lives on the line.

That's important for him to do.

Joec87   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

(Roland Martin) What do you think of rich neighborhoods not allowing military recruiters to come to there schools?

Joni Jones   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

CNN: How many bloggers are on now? I know you don't post every comment but it'd be nice to know how many people are reading this.

connie   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

Concerned: Most thought inspiring comment of the evening. I'm in accord with you and your thinking. I hope everyone participating on this blog will make their list and ponder it. Thank you.

Krissy-pooh   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

I think obama is doing well tonight.

jeanie   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

Dan

well said!

Teddy   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

I see Obama as not there to entertain, but to make the lines of difference more visible to the public eye between him and McCain...and he's doing a fantastic job.

Nathan Hale   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

the military

Anonymous   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

Roland,
I'll let you tell that to the guy that spent years in a POW camp. He's one of the reasons people like you are allowed to ponder the world's problems, write about, but do nothing tangible to solve it.

Just Plain Tired - St. Louis   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

I'm bothered that the candidates speak in terms of ideals. Let's face it, they make promises in terms of absolutes that they can't guarantee. Then, they do a ballet around questions that they are either unprepared to answer, afraid divulge their true feelings about, or simply don't have a clue as to how to respond because they didn't expect the question. I don't like this. I just want to here some honest responses even if they do have to choose their words carefully. Anyone who is really interested in the issues could care less about the personality appeal, gender appeal, or the insane attempts to manipulate and distract people from the obvious.

Yes, I am a democratic voter, but I am unimpressed with the rhetoric on both sides. I think we all basically gamble when we vote because even though we may not like to admit it, like our religious leaders, politicians are human, and we mistakenly put faith and hope in them that is akin to that which we put in God. They are nowhere close, but we have to make choices that we believe are better or at least the lesser of evils, so to speak for the country. "Change" and "Country First" are great mantras, but give me a break! V.P.s aside, they both need to man up. McCain also needs to stand on his own and let Palin be a real V.P. and campaign like one on her own. If she needs protecting, then why did he pick her?

Karen Whittemore   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

I would make absolutly sure that the military had the chance to at least a 4 year degree. If they willing to give their lives, they should have help to go to school to better their lives!!! Obama shares this idea, MCCain does not...McCain voted against it!!!

grizz   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

Great idea on the veteran corp. spacific plans how refreshing.

Douglas FReeman   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

I,think if Mccain is serious about our security and Troops, he should discuss bringing back the draft , let's not be protected by a few,lets all protect our country . So before their children go to college they should protect the interest of America and serve,let's see how much they really support sending more troops . When Mccain served there was a draft in place, so since he loves to mention ,his service time he should'nt have a problem with the draft.

BK   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

Obama talks and talks and says nothing.

sjprugh   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

I agree with Dan!

Max Winters   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

If Palin doesn't know the Bush doctrine, what does she know about the established doctrines and practices of American foreign policy?
She is obviously less equipped to be president than Charlie Gibson. How acn McCain get away with springing someone so inept on the country at the last minute, just because she makes women identify with er as amother?

Roland Martin,
CNN Political Analyst
  September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

How about this to all of my anti-tax friends (yea, you, Grover Norquist):

If we care about the military so much, would you support a specific tax that would go only to the members of the military that would significantly raise their pay and benefits?

Silene Young   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

There has been a huge difference in these two candidates so far during this forum. Obama is giving very specific answers, programs and ideas and we didn't get any of that from McCain. As usual, he was very general in all his comments.

Richard   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

Man, Ms. Sarah sure sounded like she didn't understand the "Bush Doctrine." Tim Russert would have made mence meat out of her.

Jessica   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

Roland, what is your take on Obama not doing town halls with McCain? I attended one with McCain and I think everyone could learn more about both candidates rather than having to be put through such a fine line with one or two moderators...why not let the people ask the questions, not the media?

Steve K   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

Roland ....as a DR. I not putting my life on the line...unless I'm doing it in a combat zone.

carrie   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

Tom,
If call yourself a Democrat, please switch parties so that your channeling of Fox News Hillary hate is consistent with your party affiliation . Hillary's committment to the Democratic party can not be seriously questioned. Hillary will campaign more for Obama and to greater effect than any other of the other contenders. She will do that because she wants a President in the White House who will support her work in Congress to advance the Democratic philosophy and agenda that she and Obama both support.

If Obama wins, he'll have a superb legislator to work with,in Hillary. If he loses, than Obama and Hillary will have their work cut out them. They will work together regardless and we need too as well.

Jamie   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

People put themselves at great harm to do lots of jobs in the US – not just military (and my sister and her husband are in the military) – but I dont think they deserve any more attention than fire fighters, police offices in gang task forces etc. We all work and risk our lives and we dont get anything special.

Karl Rove sucks   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

How can you not elect this man!!!!

K   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

Fabian- I am trully offended by this PATRIOTISM, HONOR COUNTRY, RESPECT, DISCIPLINE, only in the military is ignorant. The everyday citizen who fights to protect their neighborhoods from violence, helping those less fortunate and teaching children in a tutoring effort is just as honrable to country, discipline and patriotic. Where do you live in Beverly Hills because while the military is fighting in other countries we citizens are fighting on the front lines for our future generations to have a better life just like you are fighting for our freedoms. Volunteering in the military is honorable but not supreme to the community volunteering they are equal.

jim   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

Free Trade,

McCain is saying the same bull the Bush said about retooling Americans who lost jobs over seas – 3+ million jobs! The campain promise that Bush made in 04 never happened. Why should I trust McCain when he is all for giving tax breaks to corporations, who in turn ship US jobs over seas and take in record profits and big bonus for the top dogs. I don't trust you McCain! I have been through enough over the last few years because of free trade! Top down job growth doesn't happen in the US any more, only the top.

I think Obama will help me much more than you when my job is lost because of unfair free trade. Lastly – why doesn't the US push India to relax the restrictions to allow Walmart to set up shops in India? They sure took plenty of our jobs, why don't they allow Walmart to operate?

This is fair free trade?

Loyal American123   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

Everybody in the BM is asking about lipstick. Why not ask if Palin paid all the Social Security taxes she owes/owed on wages paid to household employees. Ask Biden, Obama and McCain too.
then ask if the 2 candidates w9ill be willingf to denounce any and every Plum Book applicant who cheated, ever, on Social Security taxes.

Reg   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

I think these guys are letting Obama get away w/o directly answering questions. I like his answers when he actually answers the question, but he takes a little too long to get to the answer.

Carolina 4 Obama   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

What is Joe Biden doing? Are the Repulicans paying this guy or what? Is he trying to ruin this ticket?

Obama needs to pull his card he's either with us (Dem) or against us. I wasn't to big on a Obama/Clinton ticket cause Bill was trippn and Hillary was a childish loser but now . I'll swallow my pride to get the Dem's in the office.

Advice to the Obama camp: take the gloves off, I know you want to take the high road but some americans aren't smart enough to see past the politics of the old that the McCain camp is pulling and the McCain camp knows it and are preying on the ignorant.

Obama 08-2012

Nathan Hale   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

my father served in the military, and those who go out there and put EVERYTHING on the line are just on a different level, yes those who go into the inner city are great, i applaud them however they are NOT

Bill Hodges   September 11th, 2008 9:27 pm ET

I'll say this, a doctor who chooses to provide medical care in rural towns where they live too far from a hospital is just as honorable as someone in the military.

Roland, I will agree whole heartedly with that statement.

OBAMA GET'S IT!   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

OBAMA SAID SOMETHING THAT REALLY TOUCHED ME, JUST THE TRUTH OF HIS WORDS."IT'S GOING TO HAVE TO TAKE SOMEONE THAT CAN INSPIRE PEOPLE TO GET OUT THERE AND TAKE AN ACTIVE ROLE' THAT IS SO VERY TRUE, SO VERY TRUE, THEN HE SAID THAT HE AS PRESIDENT CAN DO THAT. NOW THAT IS A TRUTH THAT I CAN ATTEST TO. MY 27 YEAR OLD SON WHO HAS LIVED HIS LIVE AFRAID TO STEP OUT THERE AND TAKE A CHANCE, SURE HE WOULD LATCH ON TO JOBS THAT GOT HIM BY, BUT TOO AFRAID TO REACH FARTHER AND LORD KNOWS HE NEVER GOT INVOLVED WITH ANYTHING IN POLITICS, BUT NOW! SINCE HE WATCHED WITH ME OBAMA GIVING A SPEECH THE ONE ON RACE WITH TEARS IN HIS EYES ( MY SON) HE LOOKED AT ME AND DECLARED ABOUT OBAMA "THIS MAN HAS CHANGED MY LIFE!" I LOOKED AT HIM AND KNEW SOMETHING WAS DIFFERENT, NOW HE IS STILL IN MIMINUM WAGE JOBS, BUT GUESS WHAT HE IS NOT STILL IN MY HOUSE AFRAID, HE IS IN ANOTHER STATE GOING TO SCHOOL GETTING HIS GED AND NOT AFRAID TO TRY. AND AS FOR AS POLITICS IS CONCERNED HE IS WORKING FOR THE OBAMA CAMPAIGN.

I THOUGHT I WOULD HAVE TO TAKE CARE OF HIM THE REST OF HIS LIFE!

YES!!! OBAMA INSPIRES US!

VA voter   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Watching the ongoing forum:
Judy W's references to McCains comments is creating a one sided debate. Also it appears Obama was able to listen to McCains answers to the question... tell me this wasn't the case!!! If so then that is plain wrong

Laurie Carroll   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Obama is not all about government created service in absence of service from the private sector. He has a service plain and was just explaining it. Please don't make your comment a sound bite, Bill. Just read his position on Obama's web site to get a grasp of his position.

Omgoodness!

Rick in Minnesota   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Service is a focus perspective; if we focus on what we want and what the government can do for me, then we are less apt to be looking to serve others. If however we are focused on our country, state,county,city,neighborhood, etc then we will make choices and actions that are focused on giving and serving...

Carl   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Complete Government control over a citizens service to the country will hinder Community involvement. Corporations should be afforded tax breaks to support Service to Country and Community...If the Government controls this Service this is a pure form of Federalism..

Khyati Desai   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

I apologize for posting again but service is something we get fired up about. Roland, you're so right. I'm not undermining military service in any way but it's really frustrating to hear military service getting so much more respect and admiration than nonprofit service. Like you said, peple who have worked with inner city children who are struggling or people who are risking their lives rescuing women in domestic violence situations or children being trafficked, who themselves are struggling to make ends meet know the meaning of sacrifice. And what they are doing is equally as life saving and freedom fighting.

Matt   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

"Obama's answers appear to be far more specific than McCain's."
Bill Schneider wrote that not five minutes into Obama's speech (9:02). How can anyone make a judgement so soon. This entire process is useless, all the CNN "analysts" have planned out all their talking points regardless of what the candidate says. Stop pretending you are completely objective, come out and be honest. Admit your political bias. CNN should focus on reporting the news and quit this ridiculous partisan spin you all seem to have adopted.

kathy   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

I was not in the military, but adopted 2 older children to give them a chance and teach my 2 other children, that is type of community service is just as important!

Hollis   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

I like Obama very much, but he is stumbling a bit on the question of military service. Wartime or not, it is a brave choice.

Just heard the question about service benefits - good one!

I know what he is trying to say, but to some it might come across as turning the entire country into federal servants.

J. McKinon   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

I can’t understand the American people on how they think. Is there something in the water? Many of them don’t realize it was the Republicans who have basically ruin this great country. In the past eight years all I’ve seen from the Republicans who had control of the three branches of government is tell one lie after another and made life miserable for everyone. The Republican Party intimidated the media, no one had the guts to stand up to them and say you wrong. Al Gore tried to tell the American people what was going to happen under a Bush government and no one listen. Four year later John Kerry tried to once again tell the American people that Bush is leading the country in the wrong direction. Now it is Obama’s turn. He too is trying to tell the American people we can not afford to have these corrupt people in power. I hope some day the American people would wake up, they must be sleeping through the lies McCain is telling to get elected.

Joel in CA   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Bob,

Why not? McCain heard most of the questions Obama got at Rick Warren's forum. The "cone of silence" references we've heard about that interview were especially apt because, as anyone who's seen even one episode of 'Get Smart' could've told you, the Cone of Silence never worked!

FLARTIST   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

This is our next President..no more
"Smoke em Out"..."Bomb Bomb Bomb Iran"..."100 yrs in Iraq"

We need a leader....with brains!!!!

zcaveman   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Government: 1/2 the nations mortages already down the tubes
Government: If I don't wear my seatbelt I must pay the rich
Government: If i choose to smoke, I must pay the rich
Government: SUCKS

from ohio   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

well ..we would n't have needed miltary service first place if we aren't that dumb to go to losing wars again and again sacrifing for WHAT??...

ruth   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

I agree with jdfc, the media now, 60 days to election, is been very subtle, shrewd.... they really know how to show people the door with a smile and leave you very, very calm !!!

Beverly   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Roland, do you think Obama is doing a better job engaging the audience than he did at the Saddleback forum? I think so.

Martin Tease   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

I think Obama was given better questions and had the opportunity to define himself in a way that McCain was not able to. McCain was good but I think by going second Obama has done very well.

Dale in Louisa, KY   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Good point, concerned. One way we can serve right now is to become informed about these two men and their positions on the issues, and vote our consciences. What else is more important?

Heather   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Concerned -you hit the nail on the head totlaly.

grace carr   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

How can people think any Hillary supporter will go over to the Republican ticket? We women are not "plug compatible"...Palin is different from Hillary in almost every way except biology.
As a stanch Hillary supporter, I will do whatever I can to make sure that Obama is elected...and, any true Hillary supporter, aware of the issues, must do the same. We are in the middle of an evil war, which McCain thinks he can win...we have deplorable health care for many Americans, and McCain has no answers...we are in a serious economic state, and he wants to continue to spend billions on the war. He is lying about Obama's position on education, lying about Palin's position on earmarks (I believe she kept all or most of the "Bridge to Nowhere money", so much for thanks but no thanks) and he and she will continue to move the Supreme Court to the right, resulting in a rescinding of Roe v Wade...Wake up, America!

Girlpower   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Let's quit on which one is greater-EVERY JOB that a person does is important. You forget the real issue here-these candidates are trying to prove themselves for the presidency. Let's not look at the jobs they did, but what they have accomplished with those jobs.

Matt   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Interesting Fabian.....Read about that somewhere before.....Mandatory military, discipline, patriotism, country......can't quite remember what it was called though.......oh yeah, FASCISM

Paul Gillham   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Should we offer military benefits to non-military personnel?

Victor   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Roland,

Your parents' community activities are commendable (as is being mayor of a small town). The problem is, that it doesn't contribute much to a razor thin Presidential resume'. Either Obama in 2008 or Palin in 2010 will be the least qualified president in the lifetime of anyone alive today – by a wide margin.

- Victor

Danielle   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

JMe: temple – I have an idea about how to help this. If you had the opportunity to be part of an organization where you got to work for the government in the area of you degree but be willing to relocate to an area for a year that is need of the skills you graduated with and in return the government paid your student loan and gave you a modest salary, would you consider doing this?

What I propose is that, like Americorp, we ask college graduates to give up a year or two to move to New Orleans, or other depressed areas to help rebuild, provide their newly required medical skills, teaching skills, engineering skills, etc in return for the student loans getting wiped clean. Don't put an age limit on this either – I am 30 and I would do it.

Young individuals living for a year or two in these areas may actually choose to live there for good which increases the level of professionals in the areas and supports the communities.

Lanre Akinola   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

If I have almost $70K from undergraduate and graduate degree. Why in the world would I want to go and join the military when this nation is producing the Forbes richest folks on Wall St. Don't get me wrong, I love this nation, but I found it hard to balance this mental conflict. How do I justify CEO pay package and someone is preaching to me about military or public service. I don't get it.

Saad, NJ   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Both cadidates are speaking very nicely regarding our military... but I wish they would for once slip in some text about making teh world rather more peaceful and in hope to reduce teh size of the military versus the need to increase it.

I know that's wishful thinking but hey... I am asking to slip that only once... afterall, we are the country rest of the looks up to and listens to.... or used to!!!

bane   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

the entire world hates us roland.

Quit   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Roland, im thinking about joing the military how hypocritical is it to be against the iraq war but still willing to serve in the military?

Bikul Koirala   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Obama's answers are very inspiring. I like his idea of including the community in everything from energy to military service. The idea of weighing benefits to service is great.

DREW79   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

a cop in the innercity is = to military

thomas coe   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

JOHN MCCAIN HAS NO HONOR

John McCain's latest ad insinuates Obama is a pedophile!!! John McCain has no honor. He left his honor in 'nam. Every major event in his life since 'nam indicates he lacks honor. Left his first wife for another, Keating 5, now new Rovian lows in his so-called 'honorable campaign.' He calls this business a tough business – a tough business John, or a dishonorable business

JOHN MCCAIN HAS NO HONOR

Bev   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Sorry, had to take a break, and I'm just getting caught up.

Wonderful on service and why and HOW. I love specifics :-)
Strong on military AND other ways of serving. Sly way of getting in how the McCain-Bush regime has treated the vets; Obama's got a sneaky side to him that I adore.

Linear090   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

I agree, Roland.

Samurai Jack   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Do we really want to offer Walter Reed type benefits to civilians lol

Mike, Syracuse NY   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Obama's answer on why he didn't join is bad. When a war breaks out you can't start from scratch to build a military. You need it trained and ready to go. Hence the need for people to join during peace.

Frank   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

I truly feel after watching these two men speak that Obama does offer the fresh perspective. McCain to me comes across as the old guard no matter how hard he tries to convince us otherwise.

MLB   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Brian Carlson,

I believe it is true that ideally it would be that way. However, with the economy the way it is and the wars happening in our world, many more people would be motivated to serve if the knew that sometime a favor would be returned (ex: veterans returning to the US homeless).

vic   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

i think only mccain stands for the true change..in fact if you see in the past year, in the primaries debating against romney, he constantly and consistently tried to show himself to be a true conservative, and not a mavrick, he showed th ability to CHANGE and is trying to show himself to be a true mavrick.. this is what change is all about people..mccain = change every week

Danielle   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

That would be a lot to think about and study to recall in such a short time. Can the really be done effectively. I know I can't. They sequestered Palin for nearly a month before letting her answer one question.

Penny in NC   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

These forums are rediculous unless the questions are asked by the people. This is very evasive, practiced and boring. I would like to see a good old fashioned debate.

Nick from CA   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Roland, you touch on an important point. The problem is not that young people do not feel compelled serve in the military. The problem is that many young people compelled to serve their country at all.

sue   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Agree...
example...drs without boarders-are you saying that individuals who go out in the world to save lives are worth less than the individuals who are send out to take lives?
I think it is ridicules to make such a sweeping response to military as the ultimate.

Taylor   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

My question is directed towards John McCain. Don't you find it little bit hypocritical that for all these months, during all the libel and banter that has been discussed, the rapport that you distinguished yourself for the American Public, even your campaign slogan, that your campaign revolves around experience.

My question is don't you find it hypocritical that you've been condemning Obama for a lack of experience, and you go and select a governor that has only been in office for months? Obama has clearly had more experience.

But yet, experience doesn't matter to you, does it?

Maverick Democrat !!!   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Obama was A Community Organizer (ACORN ) , thur Wight's Church . Google It !!!!

James Cox   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

I can't wait for the first debate.

lynn   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

The approach is the same aas at Saddleback and shows their difference styles; Obama is having a conversation while with McCain it is all about politics.

I like the conversation style.

I also think that many people seem to think that military service should be a requirement for being president. One needs to remember there were no wars when Obama finished his first degree. There certainly was need in urban communities and that was his choice and it shows in his belief in community.

cj   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

Again he gives specifics!

Clay   September 11th, 2008 9:26 pm ET

I'm ashamed by the media coverage of the general election. Major Finacial institutions and seasoned Blue Chip companies are on the verge of calapse and the media's focus is "lipstick on a pig"? Discusting. There's real news that happens every day that effects all Americans, stop reporting crap!!!

Joec87   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

You should have the oppertunity to go into the military where ever you are.

Todd Heap   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

I am so glad to see us talking about the issues and not "lipstick". I'm very glad to see McCain, Obama, and the "MEDIA" getting back on track.

This should be a GREAT election, not another reality show!

Jennifer   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Roland, you are the best!! Listen to this man, he knows what he's talking about!!

I am a special education teacher here in DC, I have never walked away from the kids, their families, their hard situations. I also am a returned Peace Corps volunteer. I've served and continue to serve my country in many ways. Although I have never served in the military, I honor and respect everyone who does serve in that capacity, which is a valuable and different kind of service.

Cam   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

concerned: I second that idea for sure!

al   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Barack just said he would support the military in a conflict....didn't he go against funding the troops in Iraq during the war....

Brenda - WI   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Bob R –
How is today's forum any different than the DNC having their convention first, and the RNC being able to watch and prepare their convention speeches appropriately? I think it's perfectly acceptable and fair for Obama to see McCain's comments, before his portion of the forum.

Jeff DuShane   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Wow, taking care of our veterans? That is such an excellent idea.

John   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Why wont CNN post my comments?

How is Obama going to "inspire" military service? Once again, all talk, but not specifics.

Bryan B.   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Military service is not the only kind of service. It is a great way to serve, but so is serving in Ameri corp or the Peace corp. Not wanting to serve in the military makes me a wimp? Sorry but I cannot agree with that. If I had no other choice but to defend my country and my home, of course I would. People should not be forced to serve.

My example is Israel, they have compulsory Military service. I am very pro-Israel, but I don't support that.

student   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

I have complete respect for people who serve in the military. But if everyone is doing 2 years of required military service, then who is working on educating the American people about the dangers of tobacco, which is ranked as the #1 actual cause of death (in the US for 2000) and has been shown to be directly correlated with education. Or how about lifestyle modification since diet and activity patterns resulted in 15% of the deaths in 2000? There are many opportunities for service, and we need to create paths for people, in addition to the military, to serve in the way in which they are best qualified. Students who are leaving with debt are going to be motivated to find a job to pay off that debt. Why is there there only talk of vouchers, why is no one talking about limiting tuition increases?

BK   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Obama is stubbling like crazy over saying he thought about joining the military, but there was no war.

James, TX   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Regardless of your political stripe, i think everyone can agree that these two are strikingly different in their personalities and world view. It's stack bare in the answers they are giving and i agree with candy that these kind of forums don't have winners or losers, they're just eye-openers on "who" they really are.

Mississippi Man   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Roland, my vote is for you to do the next debate. As a big fan of the late Tim Russert, I think that says a lot.

David   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Obama is an "empty suit." Macro-level speak with very little detail or content. When asked the difficult questions his confidence drops and his polish wears off.

Liz   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Still never answered the the question.

Kujo   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Yes Bill S. (Obama's emphasis on energy her eis very smart)

but by this time tomorrow, the news will not be reporting on insight like this, it will be talking about what one candidate said about the other.

Tom   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Not that it is a big thing, but who the heck let McCain wear a blue shirt on TV!!! Never looks good on TV

Wayne M   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Gee I'm sorry I didnt serve in the military my 20 years of working with juvenile offenders and abused kids just doesnt matter and I guess working with gang members doesnt take fortitude- just a wimp job is was

Shannon   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Kiddos Roland!

Larry   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Glad to see Obama say RECRUITERS should be on College sites...I think that is a plus for him....

DeeinNC   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

FINALLY! It's so refreshing to hear Obama say what McCain won't – that militarhy service is not the ONLY way to serve one's country and distinguish yourself as a leader.

mike   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

the republicans were singing a different tune about service during their convention.

Matt Poynter   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Bay,

No offense but atleast Obama is offering a innovative plan and recognizes the problems in education.

Senator McCain has been talking about pig and lipstick. Have seen nothing on the issues.

Shawn in Iowa City   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

How can McCain and the right even consider the idea of goodwill overseas given the unprecedented strong-arm policy of the administration of the last 8 years?

An analogy for consideration:
Take three people from a poor, underdeveloped and low education nation. The first one punch in the face. The second one hand some textbooks, a couple of meals, clothing, and medicine. The third one first punch in the face and then give everything the second one received. Now ask yourself the result:

#1) Wants revenge and will likely extract it in some way.

#2) Accepts the gifts and betters themselves financially, physically and mentally thus effecting themselves, their families, their friends and their progeny.

#3) You get someone who wants revenge AND get accused of aiding and comforting the enemy, which causes you to be sent to Guantanamo Bay where you will be charged as an enemy combatant, not see the light of day for 5-6 years and probably be waterboarded and forced to endure 'kinder, gentler' forms of non-torture.

Sorry, John, you can't have #1 for 8 years and suddenly expect the results of #2 for being a humanitarian. A very nice, if misguided, pipe dream.

judy in PA   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Patriotism is Love of One's Own Country, Not hatred of another.

Nicole   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

I think Obama has a heart, which is what our country needs especially now. I pray, we as a country, see that as well. "Change" may have been a word many haven't liked, but I do think he's stepping up to the plate by giving us more insight oh his plan. With Biden on his ticket, he will guide Sen. Obama. Hillary would have been my pick, but I'll take any "change" to the mess our country is in now.
Thank you for your time.

FL

Ali Y   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Roland, your comments rock !!

mike   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

sounds like big, big government if obama is elected??

Bill Hodges   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Scoring points with a comment that is long over due is shameful. Every Senator should have been standing up and demanding this from the beginning of the banning at these Universities.

joel maggio   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

both canada (my country) and america are going to the polls in the next 2 months. we both want change. Jack Layton, the leader of the new democratic party admitted that his campaign has been inspired by Obama's campaign. I wish the best of luck to these leaders as only they will bring change to a prosperous North America.

EqualBranchesofGovernment   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

I'm Ok with R.O.T.C. on campuses.......but again when Senator McCain was serving in Vietnam there was a draft.......Senator Kerry graduated from Yale and "ENLISTED" yet his service was denigrated in the 2004 Presidential campaign by Karl Rove and the Republicans while President Bush went into the Air National Guard so he wouln't have to see "COMBAT" during Vietnam.

Tammy In GA   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

I believe there is a shortage of Military personal is directly due to our leadership and the war in Iraq

When our leader sends our military to a war that our country and allies do not support – they should not expect people lining up to join the Armed Forces as they did in WW2

Samurai Jack   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Basically he's saying keep the ROTC away from underpriviliged neighborhoods let's see how many students of elite educational institutions take the military up on their offers. 50k plus a year for school uhhh whose gonna join ROTC lol

MM   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Dear concerned - I think you are absolutely right.

Russ   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Sounds like there are alot of Democrats on the blog whining because they were out performed on the VP selection. I think MCcain will make a great President and he has skillfully picked a VP who is far more talented than both Obama and Biden. As I see it the election has been won by the enduring service John has gven and his ability to recognize talent in a VP candidate. This alone is a fine example of how well he will do as our President. Come on Republicans- step up to the plate and lets get this over with so we can get on with a prosperrous 4 years. Let Obama keep playing high school games of invstigating his oponents and trying to find another loop hole to get elected.

RAY PADGETT   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

True Roland ... Very True

Mary   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

I agree with you Lt Col – Sorry Roland. Who's fault is it that the inner cities are bad? I feel sorry for folks who might live there.

But there is no way you can compare it to military service (in a war zone, in a POW camp) and personally if for no other reason, McCain deserves to be President.

Barbara   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

ron – I agree with you – if asked to help, I will. I don't like being enlisted to volunteer (so the speak). My family has to come first.

Lew   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Judy just said the magic word-Draft! How do you relive the beleaguered troops that have served two and three tours in Iraq or Afganistan?

Christian, Tampa FL   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Obama is right about us needing civilian workers. My father worked as a civilian for the Department of Defense Dependent Schools, and that was a valuable service to military and civilian families alike. Now he's going to Iraq with the Red Cross. We need a lot more American civilians to go overseas!

Capt. Carl   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Risky move by Obama to support ROTC in campus. Good point Bill.

trudy   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Let's get clear on why this campaign is in the gutter.

McCain took it there. He's the one who brought in Rove and his cohorts.

They're the ones who are spending time on lipstick, pigs, etc. instead of concrete issues like health care, because they know they can't win if people look at the issues.

They're the ones lying their heads off, for example, saying that Obama wants to raise taxes, when the truth is everyone but the wealthy will have lower taxes with Obama than McCain.

And the media follows right along with the crap stuff instead of issues, and rarely calls them on their lies. Nice job, guys. Didn't learn anything from your rah-rah leading up to the Iraq war, did you?

Well, Obama managed to win even though Hillary got desperate and went for the gutter. Let's hope when the dust settles he'll win in November and McCain will be left in the gutter.

Fred   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Why hasn't anyone focused on the simple fact that Obama has about as much time in major office as Palin?

Half-term senator (and half of that campaigning for pres) and a half-term governor.

Guess elitists like Obama cannot stand that she went to IDAHO, not HARVARD and – my gosh – doesn't even have a law degree!

Brion   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

Concerned: I couldn't have said it better myself!!! That's exactly what we need to do.

-=*THC*=- Leather Face   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

I don't think people have a problem serving their Counrty, I think the problem is staying in one place for seven years and seeing no way out.

Dan   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

I agree Peace Corp. is a great organization providing excellent service to the world. I think both candidates need to address the issues at home (U.S.) frist. We need the same services that both candidates mentioned. Should be providing other countries these services first?

Gene Venable   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

"Some people think the government should give them everything."

Oh, like big banks, you mean?

Vicki Stein, MI   September 11th, 2008 9:25 pm ET

I think his ideas on a well-rounded service plan, including actual civic troops for rebuilding Iraq (and you could apply that to the infrastructure here in the States, as well), is an excellent idea.

DC   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Oh,Bay!Come on,you talk about unity and all your statements are so very partisan.Come on!

Permanently Confused   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Why is it that McCain adopted the "change" platform long after Obama had already made that part of his forefront? I am guessing because McCain saw that it was working, and that change is what people want. Though I applaud him for holding his ground on many issues, does this not show that McCain is just another bandwagon politician?

Dave   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

I am insulted on so many levels at the arrogance of Obama to suggest that compulsory military service is an obligation Americans are ready for. If he felt that way why in the hell didn't he serve in the armed forces when he had a chance? But listening to him claim you or your children need to serve is beyond elitism, it is communism.

McCain rightly pointed out that as government programs displace formerly volunteer programs people quit participating because they are now paying for those services to be rendered through taxes. Worse still, those benefiting from what was formerly a volunteer program start to feel "entitled" to these programs because the taxpayer is providing it to them for "free". That is the real cancer of socialism, apathy. Why should I volunteer, when someone else will do it.

saftgek   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Determing who gets our votes in November should be simple, but it is not. How any voter with their mind on the process, and our recent history, can consider voting for Senator McCain is way beyond my comprehension. He struck a deal in 2004 with the RNC, selling out the very people he purports to "put first," with the promise of getting "his turn." To transfer the lease on our White House from George Bush (after fumigation) to John McCain will tell the world U.S. voters just don't care – about themselves, their country, or the world. I am beyond fearful that John McCain will win Election '08, and perpetuate the destruction of our country according to the Bush Plan. God help us all!

Tom O'Brien   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

YIKES Aubrey, you are the problem!

CSpann   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Obama is arguing for a smarter use of our military.–I love it!!!

David in Illinois   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Somebody should ask McCain that is campaign is all about "character," why all the lies about Obama's legilative accomplishments, why the sneering about his community organizing days, why the horrible tone of the Paris Hilton ads and the spots about Obama being "The One." That has never sounded like character to me, at least not the right kind.

I WANT THE TRUTH   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Rp13 yes you are on welfare to. Where did you think the money came from? The government money fairy LOL come on. Just because you don't go to DFCS offices to get your check you are no better than any f them. The only difference between you financial situation and public welfare recipients is it is not always their choice of how they got in that welfare line. Everyone who is on welfare is not some poor person. Look into the eyes of the mothers who husbands were taken by violence in communities. Look into the eyes of the daughter trying to take care of her mother with cancer. Look into the eyes of the father who is trying to do better than his father did. Those are all people who need help, adn our government should be just as obliged to take care of them without prejudice as we take care of others.

RAY PADGETT   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Community Service is wonderful and we need it so badly in the country.... so many issues here that need our help to volunteer

Sydney   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Barack Obama is showing the world one thing:

He is ready to lead this country.

Obama/Biden 08

Steve K   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Military service is one of the greater services you can do for your country. You put your life on the line.

John   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Obama lied about him joining the military. He never mentioned that in any of his books. How is he going to "inspire" service? thats such a baloney answer

Early Flowers   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Correct me if i am wrong but didn't Obama say that he was going to stop the war in Iraq so why is he saying that we need more student in the war. It seem like McCain has persuade Obama about the war should keep going.

FLARTIST   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Military experience?

Cheney, Rumsfeld, Romney, Guliani, Rove, Bush.......

Hummmmmm

Skip   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Bill, ROTC programs are a great way to pay for college. Just another perk.

Gretchen   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

I think this male moderator is clearly a McCain fan. Was it necessary to call Columbia "elite" given all the Republican attacks trying to paint Obama as such?

Texico From Mexico   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Wow Palin just said we might have to go to war with Russia over Georgia....now what a stupid thing to say! OMG she just blew it there! You are not even VP yet you are already out to start WWIII? yes we will go to war over georgia killing 150 million Americans and 200 Million Russians and god knows how many others over Georgia! Jebus if this person gets in office or her warmonger grandfather we are all toast! Thats not the way you stand up to the Russians without even discussions first. I dont think you people hear me 150 million dead when the nukes fly over

thad   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

All of the media keeps saying that Obama didnt mean anything by his pig and lipstick statement. Well if this is true, then where was his since of discretion in not using such a statement. He knew that it would be taken that way and he knew that he could defend it.
It was a shot and he knew it.
But McCain still leads in the polls. VOTE- MCCAIN/PALIN

Roland Martin,
CNN Political Analyst
  September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

I'll say this, a doctor who chooses to provide medical care in rural towns where they live too far from a hospital is just as honorable as someone in the military.

We should respect anyone who makes this decision. Not try to say one is better than the other.

ALOHA TITA   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

I've overheard people saying that Obama's comment
about "lipstick" is not really meant for Palin but rather it is his compliment to his wife, Michelle.

Patricia, Philadelphia, PA   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Thank you Obama for making the point that those who love this country are not just the people in those uniforms. I think some of McCain supporters forget that. The Military is incredibly noble but to disregard or demean the work of others here at home is unfair.

heather4Obama   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Obama is BACK...yes he is explaining it clearer and clearer...Roland I am sure you are kicking back and enjoying this one...Bay darling...McCain did well for his age.

Common Sense   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Whooa....it's great to see the best political team on TV blog . Roland, thanks for cutting through the fog of spin, as always. I think Obama does better in forums like this unlike some saddleback bait forum.

ww-New York   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Ron,
Isn't that what are leaders should do? "Inspire us to help our fellowman and community". I hope you do as you say... try to make a difference. GOOD LUCK!!!

Darryl Schmitz   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Both of the major parties are spending us toward a catastrophic economic collapse and have been gradually whittling away at civil liberties. It makes me sick to know that we're expected to settle for More of the Same #1 or More of the Same #2. The presidential debates – regardless of what we feel the independant and third-party candidates' chances are – need to have all of the ballot candidates' voices included. To keep these voices far in the background closes the "arena of ideas" to only the two Establishment parties in perpetuity.

Charles   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Bay, what's McCain's message? Help me because all I hear from Mccain and CNN is Sarah Palin.

Some of us who are your friends north of the boarder are quite frankly bemused at how you conduct your politics.

Regards,
Charles, Victoria, BC

Guidy Mamann   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

How can Americans not be cynical about Mcains presidential run when it is so obvious that he picked a running mate who is more likely to help him win the election more than she is experienced to help him run the country?

SEA   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Obama just said the key words in regards to inspiring the youth to become volunteers–INSPIRATIONS! For too many years, those that volunteer see no rewards just as those who work see no rewards. For too long we have lived under a benefits for the few environment.

Erik   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

obama is doing a good job dosent matter if McCain talked before him, he is making good points

Teddy   September 11th, 2008 9:24 pm ET

Fabian, that was very close minded comment. I'm sorry, but there are more ways than one to serve this country. As Obama just said the military is not the only option to help this country, there are plenty of other jobs that equal opportunity and greatness, just not as glorified on tv as the military.

jps   September 11th, 2008 9:23 pm ET

Why is it that 90% of the people I know that have entered military service in recent years have done so only because they had no other options? They were in trouble in school, with their parents or the law and they went in. They became great men and women, but at the time they entered their lives were falling apart.

Cheryl   September 11th, 2008 9:23 pm ET

Obama is talking about the importance of the GI bill. He seems to be a fierce proponent of military service. That is supposed to be McCain's forte. He agrees with McCain that ROTC programs should be on campuses such as Columbia. I think that should be left up to the institutions.

Sarah- ARIZONA   September 11th, 2008 9:23 pm ET

he is not missing the opportunity at all. He is connecting the dots.

JAD   September 11th, 2008 9:23 pm ET

OK with that said why has he not served or where has he helped the Peace core in any way. Someone please ask him that.....

susie   September 11th, 2008 9:23 pm ET

Obama's answers sound a lot like McCains!!!! Did Obama listen back stage to the questions?

Gabriel   September 11th, 2008 9:23 pm ET

It's every humans responsibility to care for each other. Especially if it's a family member in need. Just think if we all helped one other person. If we all did one thing for someone in real need (not the lazy who don't try) the government would save alot of money that could be used for education, medical insurance, cure cancer and the list is very long of what we could do with the money. Teach a human to fish......... u know the deal. Also the 7 houses McCain owns, are they rental property? Is he so rich he doesn't know how much bread and milk cost? We've heard it over and over again, the same, political candidate song, yet, as a nation, we are not improving. Maybe we need a real change.

Please don't publish my e-mail address. thank u.

voter   September 11th, 2008 9:23 pm ET

J-me: Temple

actually that is not true. As Obama indicated, there are many service jobs available that will pay up tp 50% of your college and graduate school loans in return to serving in rual and urban areas. For example, the national instituite of mental health will pay up to 50% of your loans if you are in the medical and allied health fields. Nurses will have their college education paid for if they work for an urban hosptial after school. Teachers can have their masters paid for if they work for an inner city school. It is hard to find this information, but it if out there.

Jean   September 11th, 2008 9:23 pm ET

Candy, are you referring to how some believe that McCain hit it out of the park at Saddleback when he had the home field advangage?

judy in PA   September 11th, 2008 9:23 pm ET

I tried to serbe in the military, they told me to go to college first, I couldn't afford that, no loans or grants. Because I couldn't supply all info required for those due to absent parents and didn't have their info.
Because of that I do not allow my sons to join the military.

Samantha Smith   September 11th, 2008 9:23 pm ET

I as well feel that Palin got off with extremely easy answers. If your ready, your ready and she obviously is not ready. She is being prepped and filled in on all she needs to know about what McCain stands for... she is obviously NOT READY.

Ali Y   September 11th, 2008 9:23 pm ET

Right on Roland !! Yeah how come the argument works for those other bail outs?

Samurai Jack   September 11th, 2008 9:23 pm ET

Excellent safe answer by Barack, regarding ROTC, sure let them come to Columbia. The students are to bright to actually take the ROTC up on the offer. If anything they might present arguments to change the mindsets of the recruiters LOL.

anonymousONE   September 11th, 2008 9:23 pm ET

By the way, Jesus was not a community organizer, he flew in the face of the organizational tradition of his community, arriving instead to overturn tradition, abolish the old law, and sacrifice