(CNN) –On the anniversary of the September 11 attacks, presidential candidates John McCain and Barack Obama each take the stage to discuss service and civic engagement in a forum at Columbia University.
What do you think of their ideas? How does the role of service determine what kind of nation we live in? What does national service mean to you?
Along with CNN Senior Political Correspondent Candy Crowley, CNN Senior Political Analyst Bill Schneider, CNN Political Analyst Roland Martin, and Republican strategist Bay Buchanan, thousands of you weighed in.
Click "comments" below for a look at the entire conversation.
Good Point Laurie. They go in common men...come out multi millionaires.
I am an independent voter and have always been disgusted with the negative campaigning in previous elections. Unfortunately it's still present in the current campaigns, but I really feel that John McCain is providing a direction, optimism, and energy to help return the pride in America. Another important trait of McCain is to walk the talk, popular or not. When is the last time that happened in D.C.? As much as none of us want our troops at war, he was right about the surge, and in the long run this will benefit our troops. McCain's foreign and domestic policies are far ahead of his rivals.
Plain and simple, McCain has the experience, strength, and zeal to lead this nation.
Good question for Senator Obama:
You benefited from affirmative action in your younger years and look where you are today. But America has changed since your youth. Today, what are your feelings about affirmative action and do you think it has helped foster instances of reverse discrimination?
In reply to yessir – Obama inspires me to do more for my country and unfortunately he's not one of my choices in our election.
yessir, sign up for the military
Senator Obama will be our next President of the UNITED States of America.
Great, add "engage in war with Russia" for yet another reason why this amateur is not ready to be a heart beat away from the Oval Office.
Just because you can "see" Russia from your state does not make you an expert on Russian foreign policy or national defense.
Doesn't she have some minion to fire to occupy her time instead of sabre rattling with Russia?
Has anybody looked into the Gun Control Act of 1968 and the Lautenberg Amendment as it would apply to Trooper Wooten? I have read in the Alaska newspapers that while Trooper Wooten was under a protection order his badge and gun were taken from him at the end of his shift and returned to him at the beginning of his next shift. It is my understanding that military and police are not exempt from the Lautenberg Amendment. I believe it clearly states that it is a felony for anyone under a protection order to have guns or ammunition and it is a felony to furnish someone under a protection order with guns or ammunition. He and his supervisors may be guilty of a felony. Is it something that might be worth looking into?
I have always wanted to do more for my community. I feel Barack Obama knows how i feel.
Great job to the moderators. I love this forum. thanks CNN. Love ya Roland Martin.
All I have to say is that if McCain wins, this country is in big, big trouble. He has NO clue as the shape the economy is in, let alone any idea how to fix it. We are in big trouble, folks....And as for Palin, I'll just let her dig her own political grave, when she stops hiding behind McBush and begins to speak to the press. Give each of them enough rope and they'll do the work themselves....
I don't believe a word Obama says, it's double talk. I'm sick of
hearing the whining everytime someone has an opinion that
defers from his. Not ready for the big time.
I hope very much that Obama wins i must admit i'm terrified of McCain i believe he will bring great change.. but only to his own exclusive neighborhood i know Obama may have the experience but i dont get it how people say McCains military record shows his ability to lead. to me it shows his ability to get shot down and tortured and the whole staying for 5 extra years..yes very honorable.. but would he destroy america to save its honor too?
Can anyone here tell me McCains plan for the economy, oil prices, mortgage problems and education? I havent heard McCain mention any of these very serious issues.
MC Cain is still the same Maverick that left his wife in the time of need and voted with Bush over 90% of the time all you have to do is open you eyes and your minds to see Obama is the real deal and educated man who is also a great role model to all men and women that anyone that commits him or herself can be anything even President. MC Lame is and always will be the same clone of Bush.
i went to teach english as a foreign language in the czech republic for 4 years. this was my service to america. i did not receive even a thank you from the state department nor any other departments of the american government !!!!!!!!!!!!
I think Obama made a very good point about getting young people involved. When I was in high school the only opportunities a was informed of was military service, fast food, and school activities such as sports or stamp clubs etc. I never knew about any public service that was available such as Peace Corps etc.
I say Wonderful to Barack Obama. We need Barack for President. l00% plus agree with this guy. I could listen to him talk about the future of our country all day/night. Yes, We Can. Obama / Biden
Obama really expressed his point that service starts with the government's influence. He is the president that can inspire youth to participate in the well-being of our nation.
They stay in the senate for the health care plan of course :)
Why is everone making light of The Baracuda and her inexperience. 21 months 21 months this is crazy. John McCain has been yelling about Country First and clearly he was putting the country second when he picked the Baracuda. Here is a man who has had cancer four times, and is age 72 or 73 and he picks the most inexperience person to be his runnning make. Can you see the Baracuda in a show down with Russia in Nuclear talks. She is just a mess. I had respect for John McCain before he picked her. I always said that I would respect John McCain's campaign before any other Republican. That wa before this insult to the American people.
Loved the Forum....well only caught Sen Obama's part 'cause I was channel surfing between HGTV and ESPN.
Candy & Roland....You Guys ROCK!!! You too Bill
NO M L B, I watched McCain and laughed, 90% of his speech-sound as though "he was on another Planet", totally "Out Of Touch" !
And Palin, talking about going to War!
Where does McCain and Palin come from?
I thought both candidates were extremely civil and had interesting thoughts. McCain, however, definitely seemed to focus on service as something to do with national security, matters of war, defense, etc. Notice how his questions and answers led in the direction of Russia and Georgia, and he talked quite a bit about military service. Obama had a nuance about teachers here in the U.S. and civil servants, etc. although he definitely also discussed civil servants working in foreign countries.
The problem that I have with the whole campain this year is that people are loosing their houses to forclosure, loosing their jobs, no healthcare, economy is in the dumps, yet the candidates spend hundreds of millions of dollars on a campain. A recent article said that the demcrats want to raise 100 million dollars a month for three months. How many people could be bailed out of forclosure if all these rich donors would donated to those who were loosing their homes and loosing the jobs and not people who are already making hundres of thousands of dollars a year. If the candidats want to push for CHANGE, hold a dinner to raise money for the American people, not to spend 100 million a month on a political campaign.