November 1, 2008
Posted: November 1st, 2008 01:09 PM ET
 Conyers called for an investigation into the leak over Obama’s aunt.
Conyers called for an investigation into the leak over Obama’s aunt.

WASHINGTON (CNN) – A Democratic lawmaker on Saturday asked Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff to investigate a leak to reporters regarding the immigration status of Democratic presidential candidate Barack Obama's aunt, suggesting the Bush administration may have been behind it.

"I was startled to read in today's Associated Press that a 'federal law enforcement official' has leaked information about an immigration case involving a relative of Senator Obama," said a letter sent to Chertoff by Rep. John Conyers, D-Michigan, who chairs the House Judiciary Committee.

"Even more troubling, the AP reports that it 'could not establish whether anyone at a political level in the Bush administration or in the McCain campaign had been involved,' a very disturbing (suggestion) indeed," the letter said.

"This leak is deplorable and I urge you to take immediate action to investigate and discipline those responsible."

The AP reported Saturday that Obama's Kenyan aunt, Zeituni Onyango, is living in the United States illegally, even though an immigration judge rejected her request for asylum four years ago. The story cites two sources, one of them a federal law enforcement official.

CNN has not been able to independently verify the aunt's immigration status. Immigration and Customs Enforcement spokeswoman Kelly Nantel declined comment, saying the agency "is prohibited from commenting on any individual's status."

Filed under: Barack Obama • John Conyers


kate (KS)   November 1st, 2008 5:11 pm ET

What does that have to do with the real issues...peoples job's, 401k's etc. And who really cares...the republicans are grasping for anything. I

American Joe   November 1st, 2008 5:11 pm ET

Have you noticed that half of all of obama's supporters cannot even spell correctly? If he does win, it will be won by ignorant, uninformed, and illiterate votes.

Paul   November 1st, 2008 5:10 pm ET

Obama would make a great used car salesman!

THE END OF AMERICA by OBAMA   November 1st, 2008 5:10 pm ET

Ok koolaide drinkers and fools, start your whinning now saying "who cares" or " let's talk about the issues". Yea, no one is suppose to say ANYTHING about the great fraud obama.
America is only suppose to believe the LIAR.

Paul H   November 1st, 2008 5:10 pm ET

shug

Joe the "Plumber" appeared on stage to campaign for McCain and was put front and center by the campaign as representing the average guy. That makes him a figure in the campaign and subject to being checked out. So we find out he is in fact not a licensed plumber, that he has a history of spousal abuse and non-payment of taxes and that he admittedly knows "enough about foreign policy to be dangerous" but still thinks he's qualified to say that Israel will be destroyed if Obama is elected. Sad, but the sign of a desperate campaign.

On the other hand, Obama's half aunt on his father's side of the family who he hasn't had much to do with is living quietly–if illegally–in the USA and has nothing to do with the campaign is apparently outed by a Federal public servant for political purposes. There's a way to deal with overstays, that isn't it.

Sorry, checking out Joe the "Plumber" is fair enough; going after non-campaigning distant relatives is desperate. We've heard nothing from McCain about how he's going to fix America's problems but more tax cuts for the rich and carrying on Bush's dumb war which has cost nearly 4500 coalition troops their lives and the taxpayer 10 BILLION a month. Compared to that I don't care if Obama has three half-aunts in Boston.

Lilly   November 1st, 2008 5:10 pm ET

One more time: Obama 08, yes we scam!

Larry   November 1st, 2008 5:08 pm ET

A sad day for any Republican when their party is willing to throw a fifty year old woman under a bus in an effort to win an election

But I guess they have killed so many people all over the world ... one more won't matter

A sad day for the American people indeed

American Joe   November 1st, 2008 5:06 pm ET

Obama is a liar. Period. He has lied from day one. America is losing it's sense of direction. Most all people who vote for obama is doing so just because of race and don't even know the issues or what he stands for. They are deaf, dumb & blind. With an emphasis on "dumb". All of you who get my money because I work for it and support you as it is, spend it wisely , please. That's of course if obama gets elected. God I hope and pray he don't, because those who vote for him now will be happy in 3 days and very regretful in 300 days.

Walmart Mom from Canada   November 1st, 2008 5:06 pm ET

....and is Sen Obama supposed to be responsible in some way??
My God people, pull your head up.
What a smoke screen!

osas   November 1st, 2008 5:05 pm ET

VOTE OBAMA FOR PRESIDENT !!!!

Silvestre   November 1st, 2008 5:05 pm ET

As a Hispanic male, I can tell you from speaking to many undecided Hispanic friends and relatives living in California, Arizona and Texas (for whom immigration reform is a top priority) that the sudden emergence of this "news story" has swayed them to Obama's column.

Thanks John McCain!

Treads from Austin, TX   November 1st, 2008 5:03 pm ET

Republican or Democrat...I have an Aunt that I don't keep tract of...what's the big whoop?

osas   November 1st, 2008 5:02 pm ET

THE NATIVE INDIANS WHERE THE FIRST PEOPLE IN THIS LAND AND OUR GREAT FOR FATHERS MIGRATED HERE ILLEGALLY FROM EUROPE, AND EVEN TAKE OVER THE LAND, SO WHAT IS THE BIG DEAL FOR A WOMAN ABIDING TO THE LAW AND CONTRIBUTING POSITIVELY TO THE SURVIVING AMERICA.

Tim   November 1st, 2008 5:02 pm ET

John the American is an American idiot. It's doesn't matter if Palin's daughter has a child out of wedlock, that is not against the law. Obama's Aunt being in the country is against the law.

We know democrat's don't like to follow the laws, just look at what happened during the 2000 election when they tried to change the laws after the fact.

Andrew From The Bronx   November 1st, 2008 5:00 pm ET

Maybe We Sould Check Obama'a Birth Certificate. He Wasn't Born In This Counrty.

Jerry   November 1st, 2008 5:00 pm ET

This is why we have to worry about identiy theft. People who have access to our information just past it out like we are bread to others who can eat it and not say a word. This is pathetic.

I hope Obama win by a huge margin just to show them that GOD DON
'T LIKE UGLY.

Tim   November 1st, 2008 4:59 pm ET

And I demand to know why she is in the country and what Obama would do about it. Now go ask him the question.

Brian   November 1st, 2008 4:59 pm ET

What did Obama know and when did he know it? The Attorney General needs to appoint a Special Prosecutor for possible impeachment charges against Obama for conspiracy to violate immigration laws and for being an accessory after the fact. IMPEACH OBAMA NOW! (That'll keep the fun of the campaign going for another year)

Lisa, MD   November 1st, 2008 4:59 pm ET

THIS IS CRAZY WHY ALL THE SUDDEN OBAMA'S AUNT LIVING IN THE US (BOSTON MA) AND MAYBE AND ILLEGAL IMMIGRANT A PROBLEM. I BELIEVE OBAMA REALLY DIDN'T KNOW AND MAYBE SHE DIDN'T WANT ANYONE TO KNOW. PLEASE QUIT JUDGING HIM BECAUSE OF HIS RACE, HIS AFFLIATIONS WITH PEOPLE AND NOW HIS FAMILY. DOES THAT REALLY MATTER NOW ESPECIALLY WITH ECONOMIC CRISIS WE ARE IN. SOME OF THE COMMENTS ON THIS BLOG SAYING HOW COME HE DIDN'T KNOW. TELL ME SOMETHING DO YOU KNOW EVERYTHING ABOUT YOUR FAMILY? HELL NO AND BELIEVE ME YOU PROBABLY DON'T WANT TO KNOW. I'M SORRY I'M JUST SO SICK OF PEOPLE CLAIM TO BE THIS AND THAT AND TALK A BUNCH OF BS!!!!!!!. IF YOU HAVE A PROBLEM WITH OBAMA FINDING OUT ABOUT HIS AUNT THEN YOU ARE NO BETTER THAN MCCAIN, PALIN AND BUSH THE WRECKIN CREW. IF YOU DON'T HAVE ANYTHING NICE OR POSITIVE TO SAY ABOUT OBAMA THEN PLEASE DO US ALL A FAVOR KEEP YOUR COMMENTS TO YOUR SELF. I USE TO LIKE PARTICIPATING ON CNN BLOG BUT AFTER READING SOME OF THE COMMENTS I JUST WON'T DO IT ANYMORE JUST BECAUSE SOME PEOPLE ON HERE HAVE SO MUCH HATRED IN THERE HEART AND IT'S IS SO SAD. SORRY BUT THAT'S JUST HOW FEEL :-(

Toby   November 1st, 2008 4:58 pm ET

Since she's trying to escape death at the hands of political hit squads, I'd say the republican attempt to make an issue of it just shows how christian they really are.

Bridg   November 1st, 2008 4:57 pm ET

HO HUM! THIS STORY IS SO DESPERATE AND PATHETIC!

vicky   November 1st, 2008 4:56 pm ET

I don't think Obama is going to let this story be talked about without finding out what is the truth quietly. Can you picture him sitting back and taking all this gaff. I can't see him ignoring it. I'll just bet he already has a lawyer looking into it. He knows how the Republicans operate and has invested too much of his precious time to let a thing like this ride. There has to be more to this story than meets the eye just as that hoax they tried to pull off with Todd.

Wilson   November 1st, 2008 4:56 pm ET

Do I smell Watergate?

Ruby S   November 1st, 2008 4:55 pm ET

Isn't the fact she was denied political asylum in US a bigger plus for Obama? He could have likely given favors, but didn't.

Leslie   November 1st, 2008 4:54 pm ET

Where was Senator Kerry and Duval Patrick when this was happening ?

mnyprinc44   November 1st, 2008 4:53 pm ET

This is RIDICOLOUS...immigration is a personal factor. Who Cares...Can you Please get on with the finally of this election ALREADY.

I'M TIRED OF THE LIARS IN THE REPUBLICAN CAMPAIGN/PARTY...They have stuped so low...that it is DEVILISH...not Christian – it's really RELIGIOUS HATRED.

FL Democrat supporting Obama   November 1st, 2008 4:53 pm ET

Glad I voted already for the Obama/Biden ticket. This is very senseless. As far folks commenting about Joe the Plumber, he's already been discredited as a phony. Him being behind on his taxes and child support, etc is public info. The fact that this is priviledged info supposedly protected by the INS and Dept of Homeland security makes criminal that this info was "leaked" by a federal law enforcement official. Smells fishy to me....Nonetheless, if this is the best you have then so be it. The writings on the wall the Rethugs! Theere are far more illegal people in this country and many are quite productive and are contributing to our economies on all levels even with their status being in limbo.....Let it Go! Or else you run the risk of alienating scores of other families who have members here illegally. Think about those votes YOU BIG SORE LOSERS!

Obama! Yes we can! Yes we will!

Mild Rubio   November 1st, 2008 4:53 pm ET

OBAMA NEVER DENIED INHALING FREQUENTLY MARIJUANA WHEN HE WAS A KID, HE WAS NOT EVEN ASHAME OF IT. NOW I WONDER WHY SOME PEOPLE HAVE A PROBLEM UNDERSTANDING HIM CAUSE HE CHANGES POSITIONS ON THINGS AND HE FORGET THINGS ABOUT HIS DIVERSIFIED RELATIVES, WITH REV. WRIGHT, HE SAID, HE NEVER HEARD HIS MENTOR BAD COMMENTS ABOUT AMERICA EVEN IF HE IS HIS PASTOR FOR MANY YEARS. MY CONCLUSION IS, I THINK THESE DRUGS HE HAS TAKEN HAVE DESTROYED HIS BRAIN CELLS LIKE THAT OF ALCOHOL PLUS MAYBE HIS SMOKING HABITS. HE IS SCARY FOR THE WHITE HOUSE. FOR THE PEOPLE WHO CHECKED ON HIS AUNT STATUS, IT IS PERFECTLY OK FOR THEM TO CHECK, HE LIKES TO STAY IN WHITE HOUSE. HE NEEDS TO EARN IT BY SHOWING HE IS ABLE AND NOT DISQUALIFIED, BUT FOR ME, I WILL NEVER SUPPORT HIM COZ I AM THINKING RIGHT. HE CLAIMS TOO BEING A CHRISTIAN BUT AT SAME TIME FOR MURDER OF INNOCENT BABIES. TO ME HE IS A FRAUD. VOTE MCCAIN/PALIN08 DRUGS CAN MAKE U INSANE AND IT DESTROYS YOUR BRAIN CELLS. VOTE MCCAIN, NOT GOING INSANE, VOTE PALIN, NOT "LACKIN"G IN BRAIN CELLS..

curtis   November 1st, 2008 4:52 pm ET

Palin wont release her medical records because she is pregnant again. You heard it here first.

Red Buoy Going Blue   November 1st, 2008 4:52 pm ET

Why is this a question?
It was strange for President Bush to go over to the RNC head office in D.C. the other day. And there has been much speculation as to why McCain and his staff seemed so upbeat for the past few days.
Now we see the RNNC stepping in with huge ad buys and the release of this private information about Barack's father's [who was only around till he was two] half sister whom Barack has seen in the U.S.

How responsible are you or anyone for what one of their parent's siblings does?
And don't you think the info was an INS file and to which Bush has ready access?

democrats /PA   November 1st, 2008 4:52 pm ET

OBAMA TOOK MONEY FROM HER
WHEN HE KNOW IT WAS WRONG TO TAKE MONEY FORM SOME ONE FROM A COUNTRY THEN ARES
AND HE STOLED TAX MONEY FROM US

rm   November 1st, 2008 4:51 pm ET

I really hope that no one does anything to the lady. If you can't win a campaign on your platform, sure throw an old helpless lady under the bus. Shame.

Ruby S   November 1st, 2008 4:51 pm ET

Good and Gracious Lord – remind us once again about what this nation is all about. Remind us what we lost these past eight years and remind us once again what it is we are searching for. Obama's Aunt?

Mcfatigue   November 1st, 2008 4:50 pm ET

The goal: MAKE OBAMA LOOK EXOTIC, UNAMERICAN!

virginia nielsen   November 1st, 2008 4:50 pm ET

Senator Obama is a very polite man, as he didn't talk about Sarah'Palin's affiliations with the Alaskan Independent Party !!! GO OBAMA !!!

Time to move on   November 1st, 2008 4:50 pm ET

Please people go out and vote the the peoples choice.
OBAMA/BIDEN 08

Scott MA.   November 1st, 2008 4:49 pm ET

The disturbing part of this is that she is donating money to a campaign when she is not suppose to have a pot to piss in. She should be booted out of the D street projects and sent back to Africa.

Jim Rousch   November 1st, 2008 4:49 pm ET

If I hear ONE MORE MORON say that there's no difference between the two parties EVER AGAIN, I'll kick 'em...can't say where-not on this board, anyway.

Know your History   November 1st, 2008 4:49 pm ET

Hey I want to know why I know more about Joe the Plumber that I do Barack Obama? Joes been investigated several times for asking nothing more than a hypothetical question. Obama is running for president and has years of missing time he does not account for.

sueb   November 1st, 2008 4:48 pm ET

Where were you when Joe the plumber was being investigated????? Not only that–he was a legal US citizen. You people wear blinders.

Berkeleyan   November 1st, 2008 4:48 pm ET

Obama owes nothing to his father's side, aunts, uncles, half brothers or sisters etc., who never supported him or saw him when he was growing up. Who cares about his aunt! If you think that a relative's action can affect you as an individual, you are truly a communist! It's so petty that the McCain campain cannot come up with any good ideas to get the country out of the worst crisis ever since the Great Depression. All they could do is to smear Obama, calling him with the worst and untruthful names....Pathetic.

Larry   November 1st, 2008 4:48 pm ET

The word LEAK implies that the Democrats knew about her ,and have been COVERING IT UP.

Why is it WE HAVE TO KEEP IGNORING EVERYTHING??LAWS DON'T SEEM TO MATTER when it comes to Obama–This is what Democrats want for their PRESIDENT???Constant LIES and COVER UPS !!

VOTE McCain and let's fix the country

Jay Anderson   November 1st, 2008 4:45 pm ET

Obama's aunt?? Don't let them distract you. I'm still waiting to see Holier Than Thou Palin's Medical records (did she get an abortion or what??? and why can't we see the medical records of someone who wants to be president??) Obama's aunt, my foot... and who "leaked" this from the Bush administration..and is it even true? and how long have they held this "information" back to use at the last minute??

And again Where are Palin's medical records and WHAT are the Republican's hiding???

McShame Fatigue   November 1st, 2008 4:44 pm ET

Looks like someone in the current administration leaked the information, with the goal of throwing a last-minute wrench into the people's campaign. And someone else confirmed it, with similar motives.

facts are facts   November 1st, 2008 4:43 pm ET

Well the GOP were guilty of treason in the Valarie Plame incident so what is another minor leak of something that absolutely no importance. The main thing is to get McCain elected so the rich can keep stealing and making more money at the expense of the American peasants.

GT   November 1st, 2008 4:43 pm ET

funny how the mccain/palin ticket is finding all these "issues". can they just deal with really issue plaguing the usa and find the right solutions? or will they continue to find everything under the rock to distract the voting people. i can't vote; i'm a proud canadian but wish you american look at the facts and not all these distraction. good luck. i hope you make the right choice....

Julie from LA   November 1st, 2008 4:41 pm ET

Well, she didn't talk to him about her immigration problem and he didn't help her with it.

So?

Conyers point, on the other hand, is VERY relevant.

HAS the Bush administration leaked private government records in order to damage a political opponent....AGAIN?

I hope the media doesn't let THAT part of it rest. I'm tired of the Bush administration's abuse of power and their lies.

44th President   November 1st, 2008 4:41 pm ET

To all you haters out there, Barack Obama will be the 44th President of the United States of America, so get used to it.

LL   November 1st, 2008 4:40 pm ET

The 4 1/2 hours of debates showed America that McCain is a lightweight. Relies on strut and bluster to cover his deficiencies. Doesn't know much about foreign affairs, and can't handle a "town hall" crowd.

This woman is the Republicans' last hope.

Michael F   November 1st, 2008 4:39 pm ET

Obama's HALF-aunt may be living in this country after being denied asylum. That is not a CRIME. It is an administrative violation. The details of a person's immigration status are private by law and disclosing them is a CRIME.

If the story is true, them the law should be followed in her case as in any other immigration case. The local housing officials should determine how she was able to live in public housing and get that loophole closed.

However, the real crime here is the leaking of private information to help a campaign. It is shameful and the perpetrator should go to jail. The government has a lot of information about all of us and we are protected by privacy laws. What if it was your private data being used to attack a political enemy?

ralph Mastrangelo   November 1st, 2008 4:39 pm ET

I was always brought up believig that America was a nation governed by laws, Yet ever this woman has broken the imigration laws by being here illegally, She has broken the by giving money to a politial compaign as an illegal alien. I would't be surprised that she has probably registered to vote in the election as well. When you do not follow the rule of law then the logical consequence is anarchy. I cannot believe that Senator Conyers has the chops to defend this woman by wanting an investigation into why we found out she was illegal. He should spend his time finding out how she got around the system that is meant to protect this country and not grandstand about
launching an investigation. He is supposedly here to represent the American Citizen not the illegal alien. He should be impeached and thrown out of the Congress.

Diane in Wis   November 1st, 2008 4:39 pm ET

No Hillary = No Obama November 1st, 2008 3:16 pm ET

THE WOMAN IS HERE ILLEGALLY. This isn't a leak. We, the taxpayers have a right to know whose living off our monies. Don't tell me Obama didn't know.

No Hillary=No Obama,
It is to a leak anything that is federal stays in the government... I see your a McCain voter, The tax money that McCain wants? What we need to do now instead of talking illigal or legal is start fixing our economy and reunite our country again, This country is full of immigrants being from all over the world and we should welcome our friends with open arms as Christians!! we are all Gods children!

Mike, Land O Lakes, FL   November 1st, 2008 4:39 pm ET

Why is anyone surprised that the Bush admininstration decided to leak this story in an attempt to help McCain???

Pat - San Antonio   November 1st, 2008 4:39 pm ET

Some more food for thought – Bush inherited the largest surplus in history as Alexandria quotes above – while Clinton turned an ignorant blind eye to a terrorist cell that took 6-7 years to execute it. Then Bush takes office and VOILA – 911. Millions of dollars was spent on creating Department of Homeland Security to keep our country safe – have we had any terrorist attacks on U.S. installations anywhere in the world since then? – I DON'T THINK SO. The man had an agenda, but was obviously never able to fulfill most of it because of the results of the Clinton Administration. Among the achievements on Clinton’s list were none other than “Modernizing for the New Economy through Technology and Consensus Deregulation.”, a Clinton White House document that credited part of the administration’s success to that now dreaded d-word, deregulation. Never mind the fact that our Democratic congress has a lower popularity that George W. Bush. Oh what a sad country we live in. I pray that we do not elect Obama – the Book of Revelation explains it all – he is the anti-Christ.

cb   November 1st, 2008 4:39 pm ET

Personally, I don't care about Obama's aunt. What I want to know is why the fact that it could not be "established" that Bush or McCain was behind the leak is "disturbing."

Cindy   November 1st, 2008 4:38 pm ET

There Obama goes again. throwing his poor aunt under the bus!! He threw his grandmother under the bus a few months ago and last time I checked his poor relation in Kenya is making a $1 a month. For someone who loves to talk about spreading the wealth he sure isn't taking very good care of his family. Does he really think that the average American believes he didn't know she was illegal?? What arrogance!! He sure knew her enough to take her $260 this past year...Soooo Michelle beware honey...the bus may be coming for you too. BTW/ watch the video just hitting the internet this morning on Youtube.Plot to overthrow. EVERYONE is watching it. The tide is turning fast!!!

Dave R. Pawleys Island, SC   November 1st, 2008 4:38 pm ET

The disdain for McCain. Obama & Biden have ben right all along. The RNC et.al. can no longer can discuss the issues. All they can do is cheat and lie.

lulu   November 1st, 2008 4:36 pm ET

This is sick. McSame knows that he is losing so they are pulling everything out. Good luck to America, they will need it!

Pee for Poultice   November 1st, 2008 4:36 pm ET

So is this strong Pro-McCain push from CNN a part of the Republican strategy?

But then again, CNN is comprised of mostly White men, aren't you...the very idea of an African American man presiding over the government of the United States of America...BUT look what you're offering in return...surely American deserves better than that!

Nayya   November 1st, 2008 4:36 pm ET

Who cares...........this will only enhance the votes for Obama. Every dumb move chalks up another vote for Obama, watch..........When will these folks ever learn that dirt begets a turn in the washing machine. Out with the old.....in with the new. Go Obama/Biden!!

Anonymous   November 1st, 2008 4:35 pm ET

I have to wonder how many of the "critics" here keep in close contact and know all that's going on with elderly relatives like a half-sister of a father they only knew for one month of their lives. It's phony and hypocritical to cast stones and accusations about things that you wouldn't be doing any differently.

Canadian   November 1st, 2008 4:33 pm ET

This is to all the McCain followers(not leaders). Just sit and listen to McCain and Palin (I mean listen with an open mind) then listen to Obama, and you still want to vote McCain then God help you all because if McCain and Palin represents America then America is in big trouble or maybe they're what Americans are truly all about. SAD!!!!

Orlando   November 1st, 2008 4:32 pm ET

Some one just lost their job over this little stunt. This type of information is not suppose to be leaked. Joe the Plumber's information was a matter of public record that was found out by reporters that went to get more information on him. Local reporters in his area. These are two completely different things that can't even be compared.

Leaking of information like this isn't suppose to happen and the person that most likely that did this has been found. Not because it's right but it makes that entire section of Homeland Security look bad.

This actually is a very stupid thing to do if the McCain camp and the Republicans had a hand in it. To do this and to use it would be a great way to drive the Hispanic vote Obama. He's already getting a huge share of them but this could cause almost all to go his way. This just adds to the stink of desperation that is already surrounding McCain and shows how vile he is.

Obama was worried about people being complacent. This was a great way of making sure that doesn't happen now. Thanks McCain. You just ignited a fire under Obama supporters that could have been possibly dying out.

v.ananthan   November 1st, 2008 4:32 pm ET

I do really feel sorry for aunt...

McCain / Palin 08

Anonymous   November 1st, 2008 4:32 pm ET

"Why is this news?," you ask? That is the question, isn't it... Why and how did a "federal law enforcement official" run to the press a few days before the election with this story. Obama is known as a brilliant man, even among those who don't agree with his political policies – and he would have been a moron not to have taken steps to get his aunt to clean up her act long ago if he'd known about her residence status problems – but someone is trying to make him look complicit right now when his hands are full with much more important campaign work. Very suspicious. More dirty politics in a really sleazy Republican campaign. Even Obama recently said in a nationally broadcast interview that his problem isn't with the Republican part itself, but with the right wing conservatives who have hijacked it. It used to be a party of dignity, and maybe it will be again some day, but not today.

Taxpayers Against Paying For Illegal Immigrants   November 1st, 2008 4:31 pm ET

Tax payers I hope you recognize that you have been paying for Obamas aunt to live in public housing even though she is an illegal immigrant.

Time to Wake up America
Go McCain

Laura   November 1st, 2008 4:31 pm ET

Pfft! I have nine Aunts and I don't know where half of them live.

lol   November 1st, 2008 4:30 pm ET

who cares who leaked this information. the woman is breaking the law for being in this country. deport her asap! it is disgusting that obama's aunt lives in the projects, and his brother lives in a hut. obama doesn't help out his own relatives. maybe he is generous with "spreading the wealth" of the taxpayers money, but not obama's own money. obama is a sham, media creation!

Dee, B.C. Canada   November 1st, 2008 4:29 pm ET

How sad, how desparate. Keep it up with all the negative crap. Countries are watching all over the world and are laughing at Americans who actually believe the negativity of McCain/Palin against Obama and laughing at anyone who believes that McCain would make a good president and OMG help us, Palin as VP. Countries have laughed at Bush/Cheney for 8 years, McCain/Palin are the same.

I am really tired of listening to McCain and Palin on CNN. What is it CNN, do you feel sorry for the old geezer so you are running him over and over and over. All he says is I this, I that, I have been tested, I , I, I. How can Americans be so sucked in? Open your eyes! Canada wants our soldiers to come home too! Obama will bring them home, Go Obama/Biden 08!!!!!

Anita of georgia   November 1st, 2008 4:29 pm ET

Obama, has enough to keep up with, Is there anyone, that goes to their relatives and question them about their personal business. I don't and neither do most of you. Keep searching John McCain, all you're going to do is nail your coffin shut. There nothing you can do or say now, that will derail Senate Obama campaign. Just give you enough rope, you'll hang yourself, it's just a matter of time. Your legacy has been destroyed by lies and deceit.

Roy - Chicago   November 1st, 2008 4:27 pm ET

When news articles are exposes of aunt's 'half-sisters', and other relatives FAR removed from the family tree…..it is obvious that the Republicans are desparate. Is Obama looking for Sarah Palin's extra-maritial lover? Is Obama looking for McCain's Annapolis stripper girlfriend? Is Obama continually mentioning Cindy McCain's drug abuse? It appears only ONE party is digging the dirt as deeply as the Republicans are….. funny how the party that portrays themselves as the more moral, actually feel more entitlement to use horrible campaign tactics. This is the hyprocrisy they have become.

Republican who voted for Obama/Biden on October 20th   November 1st, 2008 4:27 pm ET

What about the Black McCain's. I have a picture of them with McCain's brother Joe in the middle. They were slaves that the McCain's owned. Let's introduce them. They are wonderful people. They are also voting for Barack Obama.

JANE   November 1st, 2008 4:26 pm ET

I CAN'T IMAGINE HOW ANYONE CAN TURN THE FACTS AROUND AND BLAME EITHER BUSH OR McCAIN FOR TELLING THE TRUTH ABOUT OBAMA'S AUNT BREAKING THE LAW. IT IS NOT OK FOR ANYONE TO BREAK THE LAW. ONCE AGAIN AS ALWAYS OBAMA DIDN'T KNOW . THAT'S WHAT HE ALWAYS DOES BY CLAIMING HE DIDN'T KNOW. HE DIDN'T KNOW ABOUT AYERS, REZKO, REVERAND WRIGHT, ACCORN AND NOW HIS AUNT WITH SO MANY IN BETWEEN. HE IS EITHER SO STUPID THAT HE KNOWS NOITHING OR THE BIGGEST LIAR EVER, EITHER WAY HE DOESN'T BELONG IN THE WHITE HOUSE
McCAIN / PALIN 08 THEY CARE

Plumber washington   November 1st, 2008 4:26 pm ET

Desperation it is!! shame on the dirty republicans that are about to be booted out of the office.

FYI!
I still think the indians should have to decide on who's here illegally or legally. peace out!

George   November 1st, 2008 4:25 pm ET

Never underestimate the evil of the Republican party machine or the gullibility of the peasants with pitchforks who believe whatever Fox News and talk radio tell them to believe.

How can Sarah Palin continue to pose behind a "Country First" sign after having offered very visible and public support to the seccessionist Alaska Independence Party, whose founder claimed he wasn't even an American? When she can continue to pose like this-and be cheered, rather than laughed off the stage-we know just how dense and dishonest her supporters are.

Funny how rightwingers go postal over unsubstantiated rumors about the immigration status of some relative of Obama's-but blissfully ignore the well-documented fact that Palin's husband was a card-carrying member of the virulently anti-American AIP. Selective perception is an amazing thing to behold.

sandiek   November 1st, 2008 4:24 pm ET

I keep hearing how family is off limits. Why did Palin's daughter become headline news. Grow up Obama supporters, this is an election and your guy has so much trash in his trunk. You should be glad this is what came out, I am still waiting on a video tape to be released and really let the public know about the type of person your Obama is. So if anyboby leaked this info, it is probably Obama himself. I am sure he would rather throw his aunt under the train they have all his links to shady people continue to be in the headlines.
McCain/Palin 2008

MIKA   November 1st, 2008 4:24 pm ET

BUSH 2'S ADMIN IS RIGHT BACK INTO THEIR OLD SCHOOL DIRTY GAMES ***LOOSERS!!!*****
AMERICAN'S ARE TIRED OF EVERYTHING GOING UP BUT WAGES!

MORE AN MORE PEOPLE CAN RELATE TO OBAMA'S THINKING!

Gimmeabreak   November 1st, 2008 4:23 pm ET

THIS is the best they can do?

Pathetic. McCainites get all dewy eyed and indignant when Palin's pregnant daughter and drug-problem son are discussed, "no, no families are OFF LIMITS" you nasty liberal media you!"

But in the meantime they're digging around for this pathetic story. Let's see, a half-sister to the father who divorced Obama's mother when he was a baby, a father he only met once and who is now deceased...yep, I'm guessing that Obama knew all about that relative's situation (sarcasm).

Give it up. Please. For a change why don't you tell us why someone should vote for McCain/Palin, instead of these BS attacks on the other side.

I've never heard a opposing party give a candidate more free publicity. Thanks!

Renata Nicole   November 1st, 2008 4:22 pm ET

I hope who ever leaked this story gets in trouble. This story coming in the last 72 hours before election day is a desparate attempt. I also think it would be wise for McCain and his supporters to stay away from this story. McCain is already struggling with Hispanics and I don't think attacking this woman will help.

Tony   November 1st, 2008 4:22 pm ET

HEY ED!

DO YOU KNOW EVERYTHING YOUR REALATIVES ARE DOING?

NOT!

GET A LIFE MAN!

Eli   November 1st, 2008 4:22 pm ET

The immigration status of Obama's Kenyan aunt can be released, but Gov. Palin's medical records can't be?!?

Diane in Wis   November 1st, 2008 4:21 pm ET

Wow what a mess!!! Republican as myself and family became Democrat and already voted for Obama, I am ashamed to say i belonged to the republican party and I wish I hadn't voted for Bush, but whats done is done! I am now a democrat and have been out knocking on doors and calling for Obama! I see no gain for McCain in bringing the aunts status!! Another slander from McCain & Palin! I am a hispanic and ask all my Hispanic people to Vote for the right candidate Obama Si se puede!!!

Tony   November 1st, 2008 4:21 pm ET

IT'S THE REPUIBLICANS STUPID!

Obama-Biden 2008 and 2012   November 1st, 2008 4:20 pm ET

NO WORRIES, Rep. John Conyers. If this news is an attempt to put some kind of negative light on Sen. Obama, then I have some news to report also: IT WILL NOT PREVAIL !

You [ Barack Obama], are from God and have overcome them [the enemy's attacks, schemes, and plots ] , because the one [God] who is in you [ Barack Obama] is greater than the one [the enemy ] who is in the world. – 1 John 4:4

No weapon forged against you [ Barack Obama] will prevail, and you [ Barack Obama] will refute every tongue that accuses you [ Barack Obama] . This is the heritage of the servants [ Barack Obama] of the LORD, and this is their [ Barack Obama] vindication from me," declares the LORD. – Isaiah 54:17

" I [ God ] will send my terror ahead of you [ Barack Obama] and throw into confusion every nation you [ Barack Obama] encounter. I [ God ] will make all your [ Barack Obama] enemies turn their backs and run." – Exodus 23:27

They will fight against you [ Barack Obama] but will not overcome you, for I [God ] am with you [ Barack Obama] and will rescue you," declares the LORD. – Jeremiah 1:19
The Lord will rescue me [ Barack Obama] from every evil attack and will bring me [ Barack Obama] safely to his heavenly kingdom. – 2 Timothy 4:18

11 For he will command his angels concerning you [ Barack Obama] to guard you [ Barack Obama ] in all your ways; 12 they will lift you [ Barack Obama ] up in their hands, so that you [ Barack Obama ] will not strike your [his] foot against a stone. 13 You [ Barack Obama ] will tread upon the lion and the cobra; you [ Barack Obama ] will trample the great lion and the serpent. – Psalm 91:11-13

I have given you [ Barack Obama ] authority to trample on snakes and scorpions and to overcome all the power of the enemy; nothing will harm you [ Barack Obama ]. – Luke 10:19

It's time for the American people to get it right and NOT vote for McCain-Palin, instead vote for change. It's time for this country to turn the page and seek a new and better future for ourselves and our children.It's time for REAL change in Washington, it's time to elect Barack Obama for president !

Obama-Biden are the wiser and stronger team to solve the crucial challenges we have in this nation and abroad !

Amen.

Joe in Michigan   November 1st, 2008 4:19 pm ET

It might be intersting to see how much retribution comes down the pike when President Obama takes office in January. My bet is that all these repubijokers will hide like fleas. One always gets caught up with sooner or later and my bet is that these crooks and liars will get their just rewards. A campaign that rides on sleaze is like a bush in the Whitehouse. While talking about sleaze, why did the McStupid campaign accept millions from the gambling cartel in Vegas? When it comes to socialism, McStupid is one for spreading his wifes" wealth around like he's in Vegas. Isn't odd the he goes to Vegas so much?

Great   November 1st, 2008 4:19 pm ET

CNN dirty politics as usual:

Mc Cain keating 5, Pailin ethics violation who in their right mind would vote for them.

Stu-Florida   November 1st, 2008 4:16 pm ET

I am so ashamed of McCain and the Republican Party. I wonder just how many scouts are presently out there lifting every rock for something, anything on Obama. Their actions are deplorable, their tatics are offensive to all Americans. This has gone beyond disgusting.
Instead of using his resources to come up with concrete plans or ideas he just keeps trying to dig up dirt with all of his little shovels.

Think of it this way, America. On Wednesday Nov. 5th, think of it as Christmas. With Obama you'll get the new 12 speed bike you always wanted (Obama) and the coolest sweatshirt from Hollister (Biden)... with MCCain you get the old used, fat tires, rusted fenders, fat torn seat bike and with Palin you get a new pair of socks... ouuuu, Thanks

It sound and act like a Duck   November 1st, 2008 4:16 pm ET

Why is it that plain blank brained people, have to blame anyone, that is public information. I mean anyone who has homeland security should know, who is legal and who is not. This is a way to find out. It could of just been a neighbor, but no you demobrains, have to blame the current Administration, or Joe the plumber, for gosh sake, your taking this way to far. And not only that you liberal are getting a little to arrogant, please enjoy your posting on any site, when your choice of obama IF he win, will be monitored and told to get off the bus!!! He has the audacity and thinks he can walk on water. Lord help us!!
Obama is a socialist.simple.

mb   November 1st, 2008 4:16 pm ET

This definitely should be cleared up by Monday evening. Even if the United States Supreme Court is involved.

Jacques Rougier   November 1st, 2008 4:15 pm ET

I supose Obama was 8 years old at the time his aunt came to USA.

Rotten Minds   November 1st, 2008 4:15 pm ET

you decide..

being friends with radicals, dining & wining with them, sitting in same room for decades. Thats what Obama did all his life till recently.
He even likes Aiyers, who praise the killer of Robery Kennedy.

On other side, did McCain dine, sat in boards, went to Church with any of the guys his name is linked to ?

mark   November 1st, 2008 4:14 pm ET

wow this is ridiculous so what if obama aunt is here illegally does that affects the economy,education,health care give me a break mcain and pailin is very hungry for power and desperate.. you go desperate house wives obama all the way...

Tim from Texas   November 1st, 2008 4:13 pm ET

Joe the plumber not having a license is on the public record. As is his tax status. Immigration cases are not. One set of records is legal to look at. One set of records was illegally leaked. That is what is different. It's simple.

JDW   November 1st, 2008 4:13 pm ET

Hey ed. Nice try but no democrat would vote for McCain.

JIM HAWK   November 1st, 2008 4:12 pm ET

HERE COMES THE ROVE-BUSH CRAP...TO LATE YOU BONE HEADS.!!!!!!

Tony   November 1st, 2008 4:12 pm ET

CNN=McCain smear machine

I am sure the moderator will delete this.

wanda   November 1st, 2008 4:11 pm ET

OBAMA HALF-AUNT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH HIM.THE STORY IS A WAST OF TIME. WHAT ELSE DO YOU HAVE MCCAIN/PALIN? NOTHING YOU DO OR SAY CAN CHANGE MY MIND THAT OBAMA IS THE BETTER MAN TO TAKE THIS COUNTRY FOEWARD, AND HE WILL BE OUR NEXT COMMANDER AND CHIEF AND THATS FOR MOST OF YOU ANCHOR PERSONS AT CNN, ESPECIALLY WOLF.

Rashid Kalidi   November 1st, 2008 4:11 pm ET

Hold the Press..!

I'm still waiting for Sara Palen to get back to Katie Couric with an example of John McLame voting for increased regulation of banks & wall street.. :P

I also would love to hear more about John McCain as Chairman of the I.R.I. giving almost $500,000. to the P.L.O. c/o of Rashid Kalidi... :D

But he didn't ever meet him and doesn't know him...?

Hey John ! When can I pick up my Check :) ? LOL :P

Rotten Mind   November 1st, 2008 4:11 pm ET

ok, so this is the way Democrats want to hide the truth ?

Hang on Mr Right. Obama has mentioned about this Aunt in his book, and also said she lived in Boston, its so public.

Like Obama's Aunt, there are several thousands illegals who have given money to Obama campaign, and they all should be in Campaign records.

Emily   November 1st, 2008 4:11 pm ET

I think it's absolutely ridiculous that a candidate's family members are used as evidence against the candidate. Let's face it- unless that candidate had anything to do with it, which Obama did not in this situation, then why on earth does it matter?! If he had been harboring his aunt illegally, that might be something of contention, but he was not even aware of her living situation. He didn't intervene on her behalf to keep her here- bottom line.

Coherent1   November 1st, 2008 4:11 pm ET

I love it! The GOP is peeing all over itself with fear that Obama will become the 44th President of the United States of America. Thanks to the historical nature of Obama's bid for president and Bush's lack of leadership, American's have have been really listening and focusing on their choice of elected officials. America's eyes are opened and can now see the lies and deceit that's been used to keep us divided and in the dark. Thank you, GOP, for continuing with you foolishness during this campaign season! The people can finally see that the emporer has on no clothes. Your naked boodies have been exposed! I just have one more reques: Stop hiding behind the Christian title! You do no justice for true Christians. You've caused us to look foolish and to look like hypocrites. You shame the name of Jesus with your hypocrisy and the Pharisee is your idol. Nevertheless, much love to you and see you in the year 2024!

George   November 1st, 2008 4:09 pm ET

Don't really care about his aunt's citizenship status. Are you responsible for everything that all your relatives do?

Joan , Ontario   November 1st, 2008 4:09 pm ET

This is a half-sister to Obama's father who he saw once and was estranged from his whole life. He has seen her a few times in his life and they are documented. Obviously if he had known she had problems, he would have helped her. Maybe she thought she had solved the problem. The allegation is that she "may" be in the US illegally. Shouldn't this have been verified that she really was until it was published? Don't you find it disturbing that a law official gave this private information to a newspaper just three days before the election? Doesn't something smell a bit fishy here? They have to find and disclose who leaked this. Any American can have private information leaked if this is the case.

JJ   November 1st, 2008 4:08 pm ET

I hope that narrow minded people would realize that if Obama knew this he would have done everything possible to get it corrected. Now everything has been thrown at this man and yet nothing can stick. Vote for change not for hate. McCain is a really of hate and not change. Even the Republicans is bringing down their VP so now Go Figure. Republicans are a bunch of idiots.

Hopeful   November 1st, 2008 4:08 pm ET

Whats wrong with this title?

Obama's aunt MAY be Illegal immigrant

To No Hillary = No Obama
Get a life

This Joe the plumber stuff is a joke. Does anyone realize that the Joe the Plumber that McCain and Palin refer to is anyone that makes over $250,000 not your average plumber who makes about $60,000

God bless America, Lord knows we need it.

Joanna   November 1st, 2008 4:08 pm ET

Ok how is that Obama responsibility. I have no idea what my aunts and uncles, ect and what not are up too. As my three yr old said after watching the Obama info commercial" He going to change the world, but he isn't a prefect man". So cute.

Suspicious   November 1st, 2008 4:08 pm ET

I question the whole thing. This is either a full out lie, a half truth, or has been reported with with the most pertinent details that make it a total non-story missing. This sells papers, gets people readng stories, gives the media something else to drone on about, and sells advettising space, but it does nothing to effect the outcome of the election. What it has done is probably adversely effected the life of another innocent person with what is 99% likely to be as false a story as the story about the mentally disturbed lady the McCain campaign couldn't wait to promote. It's not going to work this time. Advice Republicans: read the story about the boy crying wolf and get a clue!

HouseDiva   November 1st, 2008 4:07 pm ET

i thought that the families were off limits?

well since they're not now...they should investigate wheather sarah palin gave birth to trigg, and bristol's medical records should be released...and why haven't palin released those medical records yet?

there's something shady about todd palin too...i think he should be investigated.

ken   November 1st, 2008 4:07 pm ET

if she is his real aunt ,then why is she haveing such that the area she came form has it's problems, but most off all it seems her hard time , we all know that since she is a blood relitive to a possoble president canidate, that it is very in portant to keep her in the u.s. now that her relation is possible for him to be the next leader of this country and a possible loss of his grand mother very soon, thay this woman may be the only family he has here and it would be a tragety to send her back now. ken

Sarah- ARIZONA   November 1st, 2008 4:07 pm ET

Republicans are so desperate. She is is estranged half aunt whom he barely has had any contact with.

this is a joke.

families are off limits

Jacob   November 1st, 2008 4:07 pm ET

If his aunt is an issue, Palin's pregnant daughter, her high school drop out son, her Alaska Independance Party husband, and John McCain's philandering on his disabled wife should be issues.

Trish   November 1st, 2008 4:06 pm ET

Oh for God's sake. It has been out there for a long time. Are some people just now learnign about it? Guess it depends where you go to find the info. If she is breaking the law Obama should know about it since it is his aunt and if he didn't know, it doesn't say much for his relationship with her. And futhermore, why do we not see any of his family members besides Michelle and daughters? What is he hiding??

Anonymous   November 1st, 2008 4:06 pm ET

i thought that the families were off limits?

well since they're not now...they should investigate wheather sarah palin gave birth to trigg, and bristol's medical records should be released...and why haven't palin released those medical records yet?

there's something shady about todd palin too...i think he should be investigated.

Jay   November 1st, 2008 4:05 pm ET

ed you wasn't going to vote for Obama anyway. Now look at how things come about. The Republicans are getting information and leaks from higher authority and yet even McCain campaign is not touching it because it will being it back to them. They are studpid but playing it safe. So if you want the sane old politics of four more years of George Bushhhhhhhhh then yes take your vote to McCain. You will be sorry sir.

David   November 1st, 2008 4:05 pm ET

The leak does not matter. If she is illegal, get her out of here.That's about right Demos, someone you like is doing wrong then blame it on Bush and McCain. Grow up.

Ruth   November 1st, 2008 4:05 pm ET

This is McCain, Bush and Palin at work again. CRY BABIES who will do anything to get elected. Not working this time.

roxyb   November 1st, 2008 4:05 pm ET

I'd like to know how many of you out there are accountable for their aunt's, uncles and other relations actions. Let them cast the first stone.

really?   November 1st, 2008 4:05 pm ET

Glen Combe, if this woman donated $260 to obama like you said, than Obama did do something illegal and this is significant. The campaigns are not allowed to accept money from foreign nationals, so right there Obama just failed.

Honestly, though representative, the fact that you're asking now who leaked the info but you didn't say anything after the media's lynching of joe the plumber. Hypocrites disgust me.

McCain 08/Romney 12

JACKED-UP-POLITICS, FLORIDA   November 1st, 2008 4:04 pm ET

Who gives a rats azzzzzzzzzzzzz. There are many illegals here. The GOP has not make a stink about them now so why start. If you are going to send one round them up and send them all out!!!!

Don't be selective

Andrew From The Bronx   November 1st, 2008 4:04 pm ET

I wonder if she peaks ENGLISH

MaryanneAZ formerly from Boston, MA   November 1st, 2008 4:04 pm ET

In the long history of this Country many have overstayed their Visas and green card expirations. I would wager that many of us third and fourth generation "Americans" are the progeny of illegals who arrived here from Ireland, Poland, Italy and other foreign countries seeking a better life. I certainly would not want anyone checking my old Irish ancestors for their official papers. The issue of an older aunt who overstayed her Visa and lives in public housing (have any of you seen Boston public housing?–its disgusting and unliveable for the most part–Boston police joking refer to the buildings as self-cleaning ovens) is completely irrelevant to Senator Obama's campaign and our vote. For those who argue that Obama should somehow finance all of his poor African relatives here and there, that notion is absurd. A lot of us have a hard time giving $5 to the Red Cross in this Country. Come on.

anotherview   November 1st, 2008 4:04 pm ET

Conyers thinks coverup is the way to go and yet another of Obama's crew that thinks news suppression is the law of Obamaland, and any violation must be paid for.

President George Hussien Washington   November 1st, 2008 4:04 pm ET

...and why has Palin not released her medical records, would it verify that there was no pregnancy???????????

sick n tired   November 1st, 2008 4:04 pm ET

Anyone with half a brain can clearly see whats going on! No confirmation needed! REPUBLICAN SCUM AT WORK!!!!!!!!

Steven   November 1st, 2008 4:04 pm ET

The Ugly Republican Party will try anything at this moment in history. I feel so sad for our children who are being brought up in a country divided and full of hatred as a result of these selfish and ignorant people. They are not Americans, they should all be shipped to some place that would welcome them, like the Sahara Desert.

JS   November 1st, 2008 4:04 pm ET

It is amazing to me that Americans can be so ignorant as to elect a president that does not even salute the American flag!!! A bunch of stupid lambs following each other to slaughter! All of the Islamic countries are laughing at our stupidity. They love him they want him and where do you think all of his money comes from?? Can you say Bin Ladin!!!! Better read your bible quick!! His name is all over it!! ]]

Andrew From The Bronx   November 1st, 2008 4:03 pm ET

Another Family That Barry Has Looked Over!!!!!!!!

Kate   November 1st, 2008 4:03 pm ET

This is about basic privacy that was invaded. And as the article notes, it is against the law for the agency to disclose an individual's status. Not Barack's but this distant relative. She didn't decide to run for public office. She wasn't trying to insert herself into the public eye (a la Joe the Plumber). Just as I don't think it was news that Joe McCain misused the 911 system and cursed at the operator, this is also not news. One can choose one's friends but not one's family. And, by the way, I'm a hardworking, Christian, mother of twins who believes strongly in personal responsibility and an ardent Obama supporter.

Betty, Virginia   November 1st, 2008 4:01 pm ET

I would like to know who leaked the information. I don't believe it makes a difference in the Obama campaign but I believe someone did think it would. I would like to know who is using immigration information for political gain. Wow, I'm thinking we need to rename my former party as rovepublicans... UGLY UGLY UGLY!

GOBAMA!!!!!

Diane   November 1st, 2008 4:01 pm ET

I guess it was ok to pry into Joe the Plummers record. A citizen who asked a question to St. Obama. Different story for Obama relative, huh Mr. Conyers?

ANA   November 1st, 2008 4:01 pm ET

who cares! Ditto

Ridgeway   November 1st, 2008 4:00 pm ET

Yeah, John help a brother out. Birds of a feather....

Independent in NC   November 1st, 2008 4:00 pm ET

I do not believe that people are responsible for the actions of other members of their families (ie the aunt living here illegally), but the fact is that in this election people have been using family members as ammunition against the character of candidates. Otherwise we would not have heard one word from anyone about Cindy McCain's former drug use or Bristol Palin's pregnancy being a reflection of mothering skills.

If anyone needs help in this country, it's the poor living in public housing – that's Obama's platform. So why is he ok with this woman living this way? She was important enough to mention in his book, is she not important enough to help with his multi-million dollar salary? Instead our lesser wealth is redistributed to take care of this woman. It just leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

james   November 1st, 2008 3:59 pm ET

Will there be an investigation on all the other illegals in this country. I guess since she has connections, her paper work will go to the top of the stack.

baleful   November 1st, 2008 3:59 pm ET

As a person with 36 first cousins and lots of aunt and uncles – I have no idea where the majority of they are living either.

Scooter? Scooter Libby? Are you back?

Carol, MD   November 1st, 2008 3:59 pm ET

How many people keep track of their relatives (or half-relatives) let alone give them money....Honestly? Obama has "half-relatives" all over the place. His father, who he last saw 37 years ago, was married 3 times in Kenya, in addition to Obama's mother.

This is so much a "non-story" I can't believe anybody broke the law (as a former govt employee, I know someone can get fired for this) to look it up and give it to the press.

Alastair   November 1st, 2008 3:59 pm ET

Mr Obama,
Does not need to get involved with his Aunt's case or situation, the man who will be the best for all Americans is showing his true faith and patriotism as an American by believing in the Constitution and the Law of the Land. The matter has been dealt again by the greedy and self indulgent aspects of society that do not have the intellect or capacity to understand. To find ones faith and true spirit of man comes from within and when that is found you will feel humble and not seek to take but give. It is for the State to demonstrate some wisdom and publicly acknowledge Barack's Aunt is a member of his family and therefore deemed to be protected under the State as a member of a political leader. She could never be returned to Africa, it's just another distraction of doubt. The only loosers if this sways in anyway will be all citizens of the USA and the rest of the World.

Lucy   November 1st, 2008 3:58 pm ET

Okay, guys... based on what we have learned from the Republicans over the last eight years who have embraced Dick Cheney and Carl Rowe as the political insiders they aspire to be..... do you think it was a Republican, Democrat or Independent? Talk about the Republicans losing credibility. The Republicans should be very worried that they might have to stand trial for criminal acts they have committed in the name of politics over the years. If I was a Republican and I would not want a jury trial. Congratulations for the Democrats in taking immediate action to stop the Republicans in their tracks. Good to see some strong backbone and clean fighting.... the Democrats have learned that you can't sink to their dirty political game level without drowning.

Andrew From The Bronx   November 1st, 2008 3:58 pm ET

Deport her ASAP. She has been milking us American's fo our TAX DOLLAR. I wonder how many other's of OBAMA's family has been doing the same

Maggie from Virginia   November 1st, 2008 3:57 pm ET

This is private information that should not be given to the public. This is the case for many reasons. One of them is for the safety and security of the individual. Another is to maintain law and order.

This is breaking the Privacy Right Act that protects citizens and non citizens. As a government employee, I would be fired and brought up on charges if I disclosed this sort of information to the public. This is wrong on many levels. Heads will roll; even if it's not publicized.

President George Hussien Washington   November 1st, 2008 3:56 pm ET

You better call Joe the Plumber, there's a leak at the whitehouse

Voter   November 1st, 2008 3:56 pm ET

So Palin likes Joe the Plumber. You know Joe the guy who has been divorced 2 times and has abuse charges filed against him. Isn't is funny that Joe is a great guy but Palin's brother-in-law is some kind of monster according to Palin, for divorcing her sister, so much so that she tried to get him fired. Will she try to get Joe fired for being the say kind of person as her brother-in-law, No, I didn't think so. What a joke, Palin is, she just uses people for her own gain. And now she is doing rallies without McCain's name even on the posters. McCain better watch his back around Palin she's pure evil.

JJW   November 1st, 2008 3:56 pm ET

First of all we have no idea if its true or not, so let's not jump to any conclusions. Here's the quote from the article.

CNN has not been able to independently verify the aunt's immigration status. Immigration and Customs Enforcement spokeswoman Kelly Nantel declined comment, saying the agency "is prohibited from commenting on any individual's status."

So it would appear that if this is confirmed, and is true, and as the quote said....the agency "is prohibited from commenting on any individual's status." ......who other than the agency was peeking into private files to get this information out??

I have relatives all over the world. USA, Canada, Australia and some in European countries and I have absolutely no clue as to what their immigration status is. What's the big deal anyway? What has this to do with the price of vegetables?

Misty   November 1st, 2008 3:55 pm ET

For people who may have a problem with Obama's aunt being here illegaly: How many of us are immigrants and have family and friends who are here from their native countries– do you go around asking them if they are here legally???

I do not think so!

I have a lot of friends are foreign born– I have never asked them their religion, their resident status and their affiliation with any parties in the past-

Republicans and conservative media are behinf this facade– and this is what they have come out with an October/November surprize - because Obama and Biden have a clean, just and honest record.

Obama/Biden 08' and '12

Michael   November 1st, 2008 3:55 pm ET

Hey JOE.

Two words: Spell Check.

Two more words: You moron.

Gobama   November 1st, 2008 3:54 pm ET

This discloser is IRRESPONSIBLE, and is a likely source of danger on so many levels.

Tom in Delaware   November 1st, 2008 3:54 pm ET

Since she's here illegally, that's means here four canpaign donations were also illegal, as POTUS canidates may not recieve foreign donations.

If the Obama Campaign can verify her four contributions, how come they can't account for the rest?

Tom   November 1st, 2008 3:53 pm ET

If it smells like a duck and it quacks like a duck it's a duck or in this case, another leak of the Bush/Cheney administration.

Regina Powell   November 1st, 2008 3:53 pm ET

The GOP is really desperate to dig this info. up, just like Shawn
Hannity on Fox News. If they knew about her, why didn't they follow
up and do their job. I have to say that this political campaign has
been one of the most nasty, corrupt and very bias, to say the least.
Now I know why that I'm voting for Senator Obama. It just shows you
the under-handed ways the GOP handle any situation or crisis.
People want to put "McShame & Numb Nuts" in the Whitehouse!
Voters are worried about Obama, they better worry about the two
GOP running mates. As I have stated earlier, I truly believe that
Senator McCain is having "delayed war syndrum"! I have friends
of mine who are still feeling the affects of the Viet Nam war and no
one can tell me he isn't. Here we go another (3rd war) and lets not
leave out all the young men and women who have died, when we
shouldn't have gone into that country, it will not bring back those
soldiers. Bush and McShame should pray every night for those
young people and their families!! May God Help Us All!!!!

R. Powell/Peoria, IL.

Lisa   November 1st, 2008 3:53 pm ET

Yes well that sounds very Bushish and McCainish, you know dirty anything to try and win the election. This is not a game changer!!!

Curt   November 1st, 2008 3:53 pm ET

Who really gives a rat's @ss??? The smell of Republican desperation is so sweet in the morning.

Joe   November 1st, 2008 3:52 pm ET

Leaked from Cheney's missing emails!

Palin's Medical Records ? – Monday SURPRISE

Something's rotten in Denmark !!!

tickerchill   November 1st, 2008 3:52 pm ET

Now I get it. Obama's aunt is here illegally, in violation of a 4-year old judge's ruling, living in public housing, making illegal donations to Obama's campaign, but what needs investigating is who's responsible for revealing this information to the public?

If this is the prevailing logic, an Obama victory Tuesday is inevitable.

james   November 1st, 2008 3:52 pm ET

Hmmm! Half Aunt? It's still Obama's family

spaniard (AL)   November 1st, 2008 3:52 pm ET

I applaud Obama for withstanding such brutal attacks form McCain-Palin time & again. Every possible denigrating thing has been said to Obama that can be, but he (Obama) still chooses not to comment on Palin's daughter's baby out of the wedlock & some such useless & completely meaningless crapp for the country's future. I wonder what would have McCain/Palin done if Obama/Biden had a daughter in a similar scenario. McCain/Palin are nothing but regulars like you & me (or politicians at best). Only a man such a stature as Obama is fit to lead this great country called America.

Anonymous   November 1st, 2008 3:52 pm ET

i thought that the families were off limits?

well since they're not now...they should investigate wheather sarah palin gave birth to trigg, bristol's medical records should be realeased...and why haven't palin released those medical records yet?

there's something shady about todd palin too...i think he should be investigated.

annette   November 1st, 2008 3:52 pm ET

CNN where is your "fair" reporting on this wonderful surprise, that Dick The Shooter endorced McSame today?????????????????? You remember you did not want to carry Mr. Obamas 1/2 hour the other night cuz you want to be fair, joke. get out of the bag, it is beginning to stink.

Obama 08: white, female, 60 yr old supporter   November 1st, 2008 3:52 pm ET

Why no blog on the Cheney endorsement of McCain and Palin??? The reasons for his endorsement are most telling of how they will continue the failed policies of Bush especially in foreign affairs and should be made known to voters.

Just because the man is down is no reason for the socalled "fair and balanced" CNN should not be reporting ALL the breaking news!!

American Expat   November 1st, 2008 3:52 pm ET

Truly despicable act! This means that 1st Amendment rights to privacy aren't honored in this country! I hope they find out who leaked this information and throw the book at them! I'm afraid that if McCain is elected- well maybe we should throw out the Constitution because they won't uphold the principles! Sad day! Obama's aunt should be compensated in some manner for her private affairs being exposed!

Slider   November 1st, 2008 3:51 pm ET

Yeah, right, Conyers.

Obama's auntie's status was so sekrit, that even he didn't know about it.

Yeah, right.

Blame McCain all you want, but McCain didn't put her in a book.

Make sure that factoid goes into one of your useless, voluminous investigations, Conyers.

Kathy   November 1st, 2008 3:51 pm ET

So, an old African woman prefers the high life in the squalor of a Boston slum over rape, torture and death in her own country.....Read about Kenya recently? She donates a huge portion of her meager wealth – She has values we all should admire. I hope her asylum claim is approved, and she gets invited to the White House.

latanya B (CA)   November 1st, 2008 3:51 pm ET

Just another nonsense to get the American people distracted!!!! who cares about whether or not Obama's aunt is legal? Get with it America our country is in dire distress economically. Let's stay focus on change and not the same Bush, Palin. and McCain's policies. Vote, vote, vote, vote, foe Change!!!!!!!!! I agreethat McCain is losing and he constantly smears Obama. If I were a republican i would be so ashamed of my party and vote Democrat for integrity, unity, and the american people.

Go Obama and the American people!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Joan   November 1st, 2008 3:50 pm ET

McCain and Palin have reached the bottom of the pit. Everyone knows that they will scrape at the dirt – anyone's dirt but their own – does Palin forget her past??? She has quite a few misdemeanours but seems to think that she is squeaky clean!!!

McCain and Palin start looking at yourselves instead of dishing up any liquid fertilizer you can find to allow you entrance into the Whitehouse.

Joe the Plumber (who McCain thinks is an American Hero) is not a plumber and also seems to owe back taxes. That is only a beginning!!! I am sure that there could be dirt to be dug up just there!!! Maybe look deeper into your own past McCain.

Why do you not concentrate on the important thins McCain – like economics – but, then, I forgot you do not know anything about economics!!!

Grow up Republicans – children have more common sense than you do.

EX REPUBLICAN   November 1st, 2008 3:49 pm ET

I wouldn't put anything past these cowardly republicans. They will do anything to deceive this nation.

Netty   November 1st, 2008 3:49 pm ET

Wow – they found an illegal half – aunt of Obama's. But noone nailed the illegals that took over THREE planes on 911 !!!!! Homeland security needs a roadmap. The most dangerous person invoved in this election is the one who has NEVER spoken – Todd Palin, – who believes in Alaska's independance from the US. Yeah – he belongs near the White House ! By the way, it's been months since I saw McCain wearing a flag lapel pin – guess he doesn't need to prove how patriotic he is.

1st time voter   November 1st, 2008 3:49 pm ET

Ed & Co – And you don't think McCain and Palin LIE!

Sad so many folks with a tunnel vision – that's why the country is in this state! Lost cause and hope....for this nation.

dave   November 1st, 2008 3:48 pm ET

FASCINATING; AND, QUITE TROUBLING. I READ FIRST ABOUT THIS
ON THE BBC WEBSITE. THIS FOREBODES TRUE SURPRESSION DURING AN OBAMA ADMINISTRATION. anyone WHO DARES ASK OR TELL ABOUT OBAMA IS QUICKLY RUN TO GROUND. HANG ON FOLKS; THIS WILL BE ONE SCARY RIDE....YOU NEED TO BE CAREFUL WHAT YOU ASK FOR.....

Kathy   November 1st, 2008 3:48 pm ET

You have got to be kidding me!!! Surely they are not going to defend this woman!! She has no business living off the backs of hard working tax payers. I don't know who leaked it, but I sure applaud them. Let's take our country back. NOBAMA

Jim in Asheville   November 1st, 2008 3:48 pm ET

It is entertaining and sad at the same time. So Mr. Conyers is troubled by a leak of private information during a hard-fought campaign. Big surprise. One is left to wonder why he wasn't the least bit concerned when Ohio officials went digging through Joe the Plumber's private records.

The two-party system has failed us for decades. Time for real change, not the phony stuff from the empty-suit socialist Obama and the past maverick of decades ago McCain. We need four or five viable parties and real (sound biteless) debate with coalition building results. Too bad the republicrats have locked out other parties.

Jose   November 1st, 2008 3:47 pm ET

Boo, hoo, hoo. Come on, we did not send you to Washington to complain about who said what, we sent you to do your jog. So Mr. Congressman....do your friking job. If she is here illegaly, then she needs to be deported.

MikeH   November 1st, 2008 3:47 pm ET

So why does this ticker remain open to comment, and the one about Palins campaign in Florida with no written reference to McCain gets closed after like 75 posts?

CNN, your moderators are showing their secret pro-Republican operative bias again.

lily   November 1st, 2008 3:46 pm ET

Yes, the question to be answered by the media and REAL journalists is WHO in the federal government broke the law and where does that leak lead from and to?

It is quite transparent 72 hours before the election that this is a political hit job and any credible journalist with intellectual curiosity should be interested in breaking open this story. Will we now see the REAL questions and hopefully answers reported? Will journalists present the other side to this story? We're waiting...

SnsforObama   November 1st, 2008 3:46 pm ET

I thought the family members were off limits to be used in this election. What does his Aunt have to do with his running for president. When did I log on to Fox News.

MARY, OLDER WHITE LADY OF NJ FOR PRES. OBAMA   November 1st, 2008 3:45 pm ET

WELL SAID JDM!!!

LOOK AT THE WAY THEY TRASHED JOHN KERRY'S MILITARY RECORD IN 2004!!!

JOHN MC CAIN DOES NOT SUPPORT FUNDING FOR OUR TROOPS OR AMERICA.

AMERICA I DON'T THINK THAT WE SHOULD SUPPORT MCCAIN/PALIN ON 11/04/2008!!!!

STAY FOCUSED AMERICA!!!!

OBAMA/BIDEN 08!!!

arlene, CA   November 1st, 2008 3:45 pm ET

another desperate attempt for distraction. Who cares ? We have millions of illegals here no one seems to care. Three more days, repubs will be trying everything. Obama said to expect it, but it will not work, not this time. Obama /Biden

Andrew   November 1st, 2008 3:45 pm ET

Nothing the Bush/Cheny White House does should surprise anyone. You want to talk about constitutional issues? These guys use that document like a hand towel.

Kim   November 1st, 2008 3:45 pm ET

CNN, I've been posting here for months. Every post I have is awaiting moderation–Why. Please tell us so we can avoid this happening all the time

CANADIAN CLUB   November 1st, 2008 3:45 pm ET

JOE McCAIN, THE BROTHER OF JOHN McCAIN, TELLS THE COPS ,AND A 911 OPERATOR TO " F.CK OFF', AND HE WAS PART OF THE CAMPAIGN. WHICH IS THE MORE SERIOUS TRANSGRESSION? WHAT BEARING DOES AN AUNT HAVE ON OBAMA'S PLATFORM. PALIN'S HUSBAND TODD, TOYED WITH AN ALASKAN SEPARATIST GROUP,.. NOW THAT'S A LOT MOE DANGEROUS.

Common Sense   November 1st, 2008 3:44 pm ET

I second Fix The Broken's comment-

Ed you indeed were never a democrat and if you could jump from Hilliary or Obama to someone like McCain you were always a republican.

Trevor   November 1st, 2008 3:44 pm ET

I suspect that one day we will find in the dictionary, under fascism that the Republican party of this era will be given as a prime example!

SAT   November 1st, 2008 3:44 pm ET

According to Senator Obama, he had very little contact with his father growing up. I've read his father had several wives and children while living in Kenya. Since his father's side of the family didn't raise him, it is understandable that Senator Obama might not be close to them. Therefore, he might not keep in touch on a regular basis like he would his mother's family.

This story does sound desperate to me. Many illegal immigrants are here in this country. Go through the proper channels to correct the situation.

Linda32   November 1st, 2008 3:44 pm ET

Funny thing that people expect Obama to know about his Aunt's status, but McCain didn't even know about his own wife's drug addiction.

Kim   November 1st, 2008 3:44 pm ET

So much for the Republicans and keep government privacy laws in check. First Valerie Plame- which I have to ask- why in the world would you give anyone's name in the CIA if they are undercover or not. This is national security. Then breaking privacy law as to further your party . No wonder we have lost faith in out government. How can the Republicans justify any of this?

UNKNOWN123ABC   November 1st, 2008 3:43 pm ET

The Bush administration is doing all this against Obama because they know he will investigate how they have brought this great country that we all love too close to rock bottom and global shame.

Pete   November 1st, 2008 3:43 pm ET

Desperate republicans are getting dirty

Josh   November 1st, 2008 3:43 pm ET

Backed by a administration that trampled on citizens rights, this is just a token gift for McCain. There are much more distressing issues raised by McCain/Palin campaign than this matter. Can the truth police get Palin and stop her poisoning this country!!

Peg   November 1st, 2008 3:42 pm ET

Gee, and hear I thought the October surprise would be the capture of Bin Laden but nope it's the *capture* of Obama's aunt. Such desperation from the McCain camp.

Independent in Portland   November 1st, 2008 3:41 pm ET

McCain stopped being a 'maverick' some time ago, and just became another slave to the Repub political machine. His competitive ego and desire to win overtook good judgement. Palin's selection was the first glaring sign; this is just the most recent. It is this trend, more than anything else, that has changing my original intention to vote for McCain.

Arlene, Illinois   November 1st, 2008 3:40 pm ET

I want to know more about John McCain's "Joe the Plumber" record
1) Covictions of Domestic Violence
2) 2 Divorces involving Domestic Abuse

sue   November 1st, 2008 3:40 pm ET

Why are they saying that she "MAY" be in the country illegally? Why "MAY"?
Will it come out 5 days from now that they were wrong?

Wendy   November 1st, 2008 3:40 pm ET

Right...Obama's immigration status is a question, but Palin's medical records are not?

annnddd...Joe the deadbeat dad/tax owing buffoon in an American Hero and John McCain's role model? No wonder he's losing.

Esther   November 1st, 2008 3:39 pm ET

Why would this matter? If she is in fact an illegal I am sure Obama will know what to do to work it out. Not like this isn't a common occurrence in the US.

KLEE   November 1st, 2008 3:39 pm ET

remember this "You don't need to "BOO" you just need to "VOTE" – thank you Obama for that wisdom.. No matter which side we are on we need to vote – and we need to vote with honesty in our hearts that it is the best for this country and this countries standing in the world – because "we are the leader" lets not go down fighting among ourselves.

Dee   November 1st, 2008 3:39 pm ET

Obama met this aunt briefly. He was not raised by his father so of course he would not have as strong a bond with that side of his family. It is really funny how most criticize yet I seriously doubt that you would financially support all the extended members of your family if you had the resources to do it. This election and the comments posted by many on these blogs, who constantly attack Obama's character (when they have never met him) really show that we still have a long way to go as a country. Both Obama and McCain are politicians- we will never truly know either one of them.

Theresa   November 1st, 2008 3:39 pm ET

This is not important at all! Just more fear-mongering tactics in deperation from McSame and campaign... targeted at the low-information, ignorant and racist people out there.

Tom in Delaware   November 1st, 2008 3:39 pm ET

While you're at it, why don't you look into why MSM knows more about Joe the Plumber in 21 days than we do about Barack Obama in 21 months.

conservative   November 1st, 2008 3:38 pm ET

Shocking isn't it how much the left has tried to cover all of Obamas secrets and how much we don't know about this man who would be president !! Talk about lunacy in this quest for power !

billmel8er   November 1st, 2008 3:38 pm ET

I guess we are going to hear from now until Tuesday how he pals around with illegal immigrants! For crying out loud enough is enough.

Michael, Los Angeles CA   November 1st, 2008 3:37 pm ET

This is beyond disgusting, the press should be unbelievably ashamed of itself. Unbelievably ashamed.

Including CNN.

Iowa Obama   November 1st, 2008 3:36 pm ET

CNN, Why don't you just say openly that you are endorsing McCain?
Other Media houses have openly stated their feelings and endorsements.I hope that Americans will see through this and vote for the candidate who will make the Economy much better than right now- Obama/Biden.
The timing of reporting of this news(last saturday before Elections)? I smell something not right here CNN!!

what?   November 1st, 2008 3:35 pm ET

wow this is so sad......im embarrased for the department of homeland security

Koilor Kimba   November 1st, 2008 3:35 pm ET

The information about Senator Obama's Aunt illegal stay is definately from the Republic Party as part of their campaign tactics. Obviously for the republicans especially Senator Mccain for his age it is a last chance fight in his political career for the highest office. Because of this they are exploring every unethical and criminal means to get to official office. It is totally a shame of people who use a needed situation like Obama's Aunt to advance political gains. As you may know Kenya where she came from have had savage unrest causing many lives. Cann't these people who are persueing read newspapers or are they so heartless because of political gain.

We hope that the Departmjent of Homeland Security will not be left to rest till the doer of this act is brought to justice. These individuals could also sell important information or setup false alarm or scandalize an innocent person – this is a worst terrorist and felony crime to the state.

May God Bless USA.

Koilor Kimba

erika in seattle   November 1st, 2008 3:35 pm ET

Why is this non story a story three days before the election. I saw an article on fox news earlier this week detailing a half aunt living in public housing. Hannity was whining about why an accomplished politician would have an aunt living in poverty. Now that she may or may not be illegal CNN wants to jump on the bandwagon? Did I miss something?

Te   November 1st, 2008 3:35 pm ET

Mrs. Palin calling from a cellular phone is still insisting that the signs in the sun, the moon, the stars should be imminent.

Hopefully, McCain,73, will retire now.

Dave   November 1st, 2008 3:35 pm ET

Mr. Obama "takes care" of his aunt by hiding her in a slum in Boston living as an illiegal immigrant, and the Dems and the Obamanation are disgusted by how the truth was "leaked".

If Mr. Obama wins the election, will this he the way he will "take care" of all Americans?

ED CROSS   November 1st, 2008 3:34 pm ET

WHO CARES???

ghost   November 1st, 2008 3:34 pm ET

With 12 million undocumented workers in the USA who cares that one is related to a candidate?

Kate   November 1st, 2008 3:34 pm ET

WHERE ARE SARAH PALIN'S MEDICAL RECORDS? .. CNN YOU ARE COWARDS FOR NOT ASKING SERIOUS QUESTIONS INSTEAD GOING AFTER A POOR OLD WOMAN WHO IS HALF-SISTER OF A MAN THAT ABANDONED SEN. OBAMA .. NO WONDER CHINA IS TAKING OVER, WE,VE BECOME A NATION OF LITTLE BRAINS!!!

Former PUMA   November 1st, 2008 3:34 pm ET

I had an aunt here illegally from Ireland. I had no idea she was an illegal until she died. I grew up going to her home for years, went shopping with her, was babysat by her, and didn't have a clue she was here illegally. She even owned her own home. Am I a worse person because of her? I don't think so. She was here illegally, ok, so????? Treat her like every other illegal. When the ICE people find illegals, do they then go after their LEGAL family members? I really don't see how this affects Obama. He didn't help get her here, he doesn't pay her bills, he didn't protect her from immigration, so what's the point of this?

Jean 2   November 1st, 2008 3:34 pm ET

This is very troubling. How secure are all of us, if our files or confidential information can be leaked for any reason. I could understand if this was the result of an investigation.
I believe in laws and the enforcement of them, but when something like this happens we are all at risk.

It is larger than any donation to the poor.

A sick commentary on the democratic process.

IS THIS COUNTRY FIRST???

jacq   November 1st, 2008 3:33 pm ET

I think the Navy needs to release the details on McShameful's involvement in a car accident that led to either the death or injury of an individual in the car with DRUNK DRIVING McCain, we need to know the whole truth about his screw ups. What about the 120 navy personnel killed aboard ship ship, the 5 air planes wrecked due to carelessness on McCains part? LET'S GET ALL OF THE TRUTH OUT.

LindainSD   November 1st, 2008 3:31 pm ET

Homeland Security...now there's the biggest OXYMORON to come out of the Bushes.

Homeland Security...while this dept kept a close watch at airports and took away our shampoo, the financial stability and economy of the USA went down the drain. Faster than the confiscated toiletries at an airport security check

blkkbbeauty   November 1st, 2008 3:31 pm ET

I cant believe the GOP spread this ladys business around and also with the help of the media who did not even verify the story... Mccain AND Palin are a sad bunch that will stoop to any level to win this election, but mark my words once they get in they wont know what the HELL to do !! , then the will start attacking each other ....

Lisa   November 1st, 2008 3:31 pm ET

The GOP is so low. I am sorry to say I grew up a Republican. I loved Ronald Reagan and the 1st Bush. I can't tolerate the direction of the party, John McCain or Sara Palin.

If they think this will change my mind they are dead wrong. It makes me dig in even more. I have relatives on my Dad's side I have met over the years, but know nothing about them. They could be drug dealers for all I know. Give me a break. McCain is vile.

No McCain   November 1st, 2008 3:30 pm ET

AND WHY IS THIS NEWS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Hilary   November 1st, 2008 3:30 pm ET

Well, considering the Bush Administration doesn't mind leaking names of people in the CIA, I don't think this would be above their pay grade.

Fix The Broken   November 1st, 2008 3:29 pm ET

ed,

You were never a democrat and you were always going to vote for McCain.

You do not have any integrity.

GARY   November 1st, 2008 3:29 pm ET

BLAME IT ALL ON THE REPUBLICANS. YOU STINKEN DEM'S CANT TAKE RESPONSIBILITIES FOR THEIR OWN ACTIONS. OBAMA IS GOOD AT BRAIN WASHING HIS MORON NAIVE PUPPETS THAT SUPPORT HIM ,AND TURN EVERYTHING AGAINST THE OTHERSIDE.OBAMA DONT TAKE RESPONSIBILTIES OF HIS ACTIONS .HE WANTS EVERYONE TO THINK HE IS RIGHT ALL THE TIME. THIS COUNTRY IS HEADED FOR A VERY BAD SCENE ,IF HE IS ELECTED.

JOE   November 1st, 2008 3:28 pm ET

IF OBAMA GETS ELECTED AND THATS A BIG MAYBE MAYBE NOT, THEN ALL THE AFFERMATIVE ACTION QUOTA'S SHOULD BE ELEMINATED, THAT SEEMS ONLY THE RIGHT THING, BUT THAT WOULD MEAN THAT EVEN THE CANDIDATE WITH THE LEAST EXPERIENCE SHOULD BE LOOKED AT BUT THE JOB GOES TO THE MOST EXPERIENCED CANDIDATE SHOULDN'T IT?

ed   November 1st, 2008 3:28 pm ET

Why did Obama not know about his aunt situation? I find that fishy! This democrat will vote for McCain. I can not take it – Obama always lies when confroted with the truth...

john, american   November 1st, 2008 3:28 pm ET

If Obama's aunt is an issue then Palin's daughter having a baby out of wedlock is surely an issue. It is obvious that Obama is not as close to the Kenyan side of his family while Palin's daughter is right under her nose.

KLEE   November 1st, 2008 3:28 pm ET

Jesus was for the poor for the rich getting to heaven was like a camel going through the eye of a needle – get it!! I wonder if Jesus had "socialist" leanings......ok Religious "Right" – your turn.

Joe Green   November 1st, 2008 3:28 pm ET

Hey, maybe next we all get to look at her tax returns.

Anything's is possible with Bush in the White House.

Ask Vaierie Plame....

Not sicnce Nixon has the power of government been so abused to "get" political opponents.

Remember what happened to Nixon?

Oh, right, he is the hero of the Republicans even still!

RoRo   November 1st, 2008 3:28 pm ET

Obama did not even use his influence to help his aunt, unlike the republicans.
He shd be commended for that!!
If republicans play this illegal aunt immigration card they will more than the gurantee the hispanic vote goes to Obama, I dare them to try it it!!

Bre Kiessling   November 1st, 2008 3:28 pm ET

No Hillary=No Obama how many illegal immigrants do we have in th US and we care about this one? Wow republicans really will stoop to anything just to make voting for Mccain justifiable. How about if Obama threatens to blow up some buildings then we report about it. An Aunt that might be illegal give me a break!!!! Give me some real news.

steven   November 1st, 2008 3:27 pm ET

sad...GO OBAMA 08

Hopeful Democrat   November 1st, 2008 3:27 pm ET

These McRepugs keep blaming Obama for other peoples shortcomings: Ayers, Wright, Kalidi and now Onyango. Remember that both McCain and Palin have been found guilty by constituted authorities of some wrong doing. Keating 5 and abuse of office. They should be ashamed of themselves.

john, Missouri   November 1st, 2008 3:27 pm ET

All imigrants beware! All hispanics this will befall you if you vote for McCain. Bush , McCain and Palin say they see Ammerica differently from the way other immigrants see it. One more reason to vote for Obama, so he can give everyone a chance to survive. If Mccain wins ever arnold the Swineger with his biceps will have to leave!!
Vote wisely, Vote Obama, vote for a clean and well respected image of America abroad and a restructured economy at home.

Shyla Swamy   November 1st, 2008 3:27 pm ET

So, now are we at fault for the actions of our relatives?

Christian   November 1st, 2008 3:26 pm ET

So What, You make a big deal out of this but you don't want to show what is on that tape that the La Times has, Why? is it because it shows what Obama truly thinks of Israel or how he laughed when that poem was read, or how he doesn't like the Jewish people. yep another thing that Obama says I wasn't aware, right like his frineds of Ayers, Dohrn, Rezko, Auchi his cousin Raili Odinga and what he done. Khaldi, You cover this up but want to know who told this. Why did his Aunt say I can't talk til the day after the election,. What are they afraid of. So she would have voted and her vote wouldn't have been legal. What he gets away with.

Shannon   November 1st, 2008 3:26 pm ET

This Bush Administration is a joke. Their sneaky and devilish. IF the Mccain camp did leak this than alot of people will be upset, Because family is OFF LIMITS!!!! OBTW, I haven't heard anything from Mccain Palin today reguarding this.. Hummm smells....

KLEE   November 1st, 2008 3:26 pm ET

Joe the Plumber leaked on himself – he wanted the attention and by golly he got it! It was John McCain that kept, time after time, bringing him up during the debate -– Joe has all this stuff going on now, gonna write a book, get a record label, etc. etc. – the guy may look like a fool – but he's playing for all its worth and so it the Republican Party...big sham!!

Paige in Dallas, TX   November 1st, 2008 3:25 pm ET

Beautifully said, Sue in Vienna, Va. I've been a Republican my entire life (now age 37) and I am so proud to have cast my vote for Obama. Sadly, I have lost much respect for Mr. McCain simply because of the way he has run his campaign and because of his poor choice of a running mate. There is not one doubt in my mind that Barack Obama is the right man for this job.

Jeremiah   November 1st, 2008 3:25 pm ET

so $265 and an illegal aunt.... this is the best that the McCain / Palin can come up with? C-mon Johnny boy I'm still waiting on answers about the Keaton 5 or your relationship with libby, or Palin's husband being part of an organization that wants to deunionize Alaska.... sounds like McCain knows he's beat

gail   November 1st, 2008 3:25 pm ET

would not surprise me, but what does this have to do with Obama for president just another jab. geez only 2 days and then we will see what the papers and journalist will print. voted early in texas obama 08

Dave   November 1st, 2008 3:25 pm ET

Yep... looks like somebody's in trouble having violated confidentiality standards of the Immigration and Nationality Act (probably § 245a.21). I won't be surprised if it's some member of the RNC or McCain campaign. If you've had enough of the politics of personal destruction like I have please vote for Obama.

Hilary   November 1st, 2008 3:25 pm ET

Let's vote already!!!!

Hilary   November 1st, 2008 3:24 pm ET

I thought families were off limits.

Let's vote already!!!!

mbg   November 1st, 2008 3:24 pm ET

I find this very disturbing that an employee of our Federal Government would leak information to the press about anyones family. They knew what they were doing to this man and his family. This is curruption at his finest. I cant believe in this day and age someone would stoop to this level. I hope and pray that McCains campain or the Bush administration doesnt have there hand in this. However it looks like a deplorable late minute mudslinging tactic by the GOP. I hope for America's sake I am wrong, but with the name calling and bashing Sen. Obama has endured thru this it would shock me in the least. I am sure Sarah the witch will be bashing this soon. I commend Obama campain for not attacking anyone's family in this campain. Thats is one of the reason among many he got my vote.

Catholic-mom-4-OBAMA   November 1st, 2008 3:23 pm ET

TO SUE IN VIENA VA: THANK YOU TO YOU AND YOUR HUSBAND FOR VOTING FOR SEN. OBAMA!

You are right. We, AMERICANS REJECT THE VILE POLITICS OF THE REPUBLICAN-LIES-HATE-FEAR-AND-DIVISION MACHINE!

Ayo   November 1st, 2008 3:23 pm ET

TOO ..............LATE.............FOR............... MCCAIN
THAT...........WAS.........AN..............ADVICE............FROM..............W BUSH.

john wilson,Pa   November 1st, 2008 3:22 pm ET

They are millions illegal imigrant in us so what is here a big deal.The status of any imigrant is secret between the person and immigration.The law maker took the right decision.This need to be investigate immediatly.

gumps   November 1st, 2008 3:22 pm ET

It's a shame what American (and especially republican) politics has become. I don't ever want to hear Christian Conservative in the same sentence with deragotory remarks. Evidently they are not Christ like at all, just dumb people looking for a cause that excuses them from being hypocrits of the wost kind. Don't besmirch my religion, you people are pathetic. You don't care about how many people are killed as a result of wars, famine, tragedy of natural sources, just as long as you have Roe V Wade overturned. How about instead of that, you adopt all the unwanted babies from unwanted pregnancies. Stand up, be proud of what you preach and if you don't want to do that, shut up.
Remember, Christ himself said he hated hipocrits...think about it. And as for politics, it should only be about the running of the country's
business....and that does not include religious leanings. Follow the consitution people...separation of church and state...do not mix the two, or it will destroy us all.

VinceP1974   November 1st, 2008 3:22 pm ET

So let me get this straight.. Multi-Millionaire Obama has an aunt living in the country illegally and in poverty and public housing... and he has the nerve to call people who dont want their taxes jacked up "selfish"?

What an arrogant jerk.

I would be interested to know how many more related foreign nationals are here in the country.. but that would require a "reporter" to ask him.

shug   November 1st, 2008 3:21 pm ET

Hum, lawmakers want to know who leaked info on Obama's aunt , but no inquiry on who leaked info on Joe Wurzulbacher, the plumber, and all his personal information. All that personal info leaked to the Obama campaign and worse yet made public. Conyers needs to be fair and seek answers for both sides and then maybe I would take his complaints seriously and not partisan! Definetly a one sided ploy again. How do we actually know anything about anyone anymore. Things have gotten so ridiculous that I wouldn't doubt that the Democrats released the info themselves to blame McCain and his campaign. The public can't even get the LA Times to release a tape showing Senator Obama at a dinner engagement with another one of his extreme "friends". Funny, when his aunt was first interviewed by a reporter she told them she could only talk to them after the election and not before!!!!! Huh, perhaps Senator Obama and his campaign did know where she was?
Go figure this one sided nonsense.

JB   November 1st, 2008 3:20 pm ET

oooh. is this the scary "October Surprise"????

surprise! doesn't matter, GOP!

(1) Why would he push into the legal status of extended family (God knows I'm not pressing into all the arrests, rehabs, or family problems of all my extended relatives!); (2) yeah–bringing up his Aunt, who doesn't want to go back to a country riddled with violence and murder and lives the lavish lifestyle that public housing in Boston affords is REALLY going to short up Arizona and New Mexico for you. The liberals and moderates are already voting for Obama; this shores up the conservative vote, which McCain (or Palin, really) already has. Just what demographic is this supposed to push into McCain's column at this point?

MLH   November 1st, 2008 3:20 pm ET

Senator Obama is no more responsible for his aunt than Senator McCain is for a brother that called 911 because he was in a snit over having to wait in a traffic jam. This is yet another sordid, nasty and small minded way to attempt to deny the reality that most of us out here prefer Senator Obama to Senator McCain when it comes to Commander in Chief.

Judith   November 1st, 2008 3:20 pm ET

Why is this "news?" Was Obama notified that she was her illegally? Should he have been? Is he her keeper? I don't think so. Obama hasn't seen her in over a year according to reports. Who "leaked" this ... most likely, not someone from the Obama camp–they were probably blindsided. Most likely, someone affiliated with Bush, Rove or McCain. Is this supposed to be the October Surprise a la a Willie Horton "aha."

I've got a wild and jerky brother who I'm sure is involved in all kinds of conspiracy issues. I'm not responsible for anything that he does illegally, and I bet there are plenty. End of story.

The question is why? And why just a few days before the final vote? Obama has reported today that if she is here illegally, then she needs to be handled via the proper channels and immigration authories. Show her the plane or start the process for a green card. They've ID that a few hundred dollars was donated to the campaign and have started the process to return the money, per campaign laws. End of story.

A Citizen   November 1st, 2008 3:19 pm ET

This is disgusting, point blanc! I'm an independant but I'm starting to see what the republicans are capable of. I will still wait until the very last day until I make my decision.

Bre Kiessling   November 1st, 2008 3:19 pm ET

Are you kidding me...anything to win. Kind of convenient that this comes out 4 days till voting. Well my vote is in stone Obama/Biden all the way. Mccain needs some new tactics. Maybe talking about what he is going to do fo our country and how we are going to fix our big problem the economy and job loses. Hey theres an idea!!! I will be glad when this is all over. I am so tired of the Mccain/Palin attacks enough it enough shut it Mccain!!!

JAHOOH   November 1st, 2008 3:19 pm ET

I dont think that McCain would go that low... although with this election I am begining to wonder..... but this close to election day???? c-mon there is with out a doubt someone from either the Bush administration, or McCain's goon squad doing this. But that is ok, Obama has taken every hit the mccain campaign has thrown his way and Obama still stands tall smiling.

OBAMA / BIDEN 2008 AND 2012

oh please !!!   November 1st, 2008 3:18 pm ET

they are just trying to find thing on Obama that would penalize him . this is ridiculous ... maybe he didn't even have contact with her ...he hasn't seen is father for years ....what tell you he was in contact with her ? if so we would have found out months ago . America please do the right thing. your decision on Tuesday will impact the world . think twice ...if your unsure ...just look at the mess your in!!! that should shine your light .

Lucy   November 1st, 2008 3:18 pm ET

I'd start with Karl Rove, maybe Dick Cheney. But we know they will never answer a subpoena, just like McMoosie and troopergate. She figured she already had "Executive Priveledge". SURPRISE!

Marie   November 1st, 2008 3:18 pm ET

Where is the line drawn and legal action taken against this administration? Cheney should have been before an investigative committee by now...not to mention Bush's lies in gettings us into Iraq. There is no doubt in my mind that the McCain camp has enough clout to get this information and "accidently" leak it to the media. McCain/Palin are losing desperately and will go deeper in the mud if necessary. I should hope on Nov. 5th, McCain slinks back to Arizona and goes into hiding and send Palin packing to Alaska, to deal with all the problems she has made there.

Kathy from MD   November 1st, 2008 3:17 pm ET

dirty tricks from the republicans – anyway what does this have to do with how great a president Obama will be?

Ronnie   November 1st, 2008 3:17 pm ET

Was this the "October/November" surprise? This is sad indeed. When the ICE can't confirm Obama's aunt's status, this is just speculation. While I do hope it's not true, I am genuinely disturbed by the increasingly nasty turn of events. I cannot wait for November 5th to be here!

Obama/Biden 08/12

Daryl in Seattle   November 1st, 2008 3:17 pm ET

I'm absolutely convinced that the highest ranking Republicans are pure evil. They will do anything and say anything to win. This is such a dirty attack and then to leak it to the press. Again, an attempt to blame Obama for any and everyone he's ever come into contact with for their decisions. What was he supposed to do? Escort her out of the country himself? That isn't Obama's job. That's whoever didn't follow up and make sure she left's responsibility.

Glen Combe   November 1st, 2008 3:17 pm ET

3 days to go in one of the most heated, negtative elections in the history of the United States and this begs the question of being politically motivated? How ignorant does CNN or the GOP percieve the American people to be? I was on the fence on who to vote for. But after seeing the picture of this 56 year old woman who lives in public housing and donates whopping 260 to Obama. It guarantees that I will vote for anyone but McCain\Palin. So I guess that agreement both parties had to not attack each others wives does not apply to extended family? Let alone breaking the law and disclosing private information? I hope who ever did break the law \ (multiple laws) is punished to the full extent of the law. What is, right is right. And what is wrong is wrong. There is no grey area in this matter. The law was broke and this person should be removed and punished. Its a sad day in America when a guy like "Joe" the plumber can be celebrity, when really a fraud and an old lady living in public housing can be used to bring a canidate down. What ever it takes to win right? There is no honor in American Politics this year.

North Dallas Thirty   November 1st, 2008 3:16 pm ET

Sort of like how Conyers supported and endorsed Ohio state officials abusing their power to look up Joe the Plumber's tax records and child suppport status.

Paul R   November 1st, 2008 3:16 pm ET

Note too that the story first got leaked to the Times of London, a Murdoch paper with a history of taking planted stories from Republicans for siphoning back into the US media.

No McCain   November 1st, 2008 3:16 pm ET

Who cares that we may or may not have one more illegal immigrant in USA.... Columbus did not have a visa for America either. None of our grandfathers/mothers had a visa as they immigrated to America (originally Native-Indian Land). PLZ PLZ PLZ stop this non-sense.

Hopeful Democrat   November 1st, 2008 3:16 pm ET

Lou Dobbs, take it away!

No Hillary = No Obama   November 1st, 2008 3:16 pm ET

THE WOMAN IS HERE ILLEGALLY. This isn't a leak. We, the taxpayers have a right to know whose living off our monies. Don't tell me Obama didn't know.

Scoti   November 1st, 2008 3:16 pm ET

Since there wasn't an October Surprise against Obama, someone high up came up with one. It shouldn't take long to figure out who leaked the story. If President Bush is smart, he will cooperate and so will Homeland Security.

Soccer mom from Canada   November 1st, 2008 3:15 pm ET

Very irresponsible for the safety of that woman.

Mr. Paul   November 1st, 2008 3:15 pm ET

It is more than a shame. This is reflective of the kinds of content of character with the Republican Party and John McCain. As if they have not done enough harm to America by misleading us to go to war for political gains, they have resorted to this lowest road to the highest office ever in the world. Soon they will preach to us about values, honor and integrity when they are valueless and dishonorable. We cannot keep on listening to these falsehoods and evil folks. It further poisons our society and it is not who we should be. John McCain has totally lost respect with the American people and he will not realize it until after this election. There is no grace in these folks. The amount of names they have called Obama is disgraceful and yet the are not succeeding in tripping him. History has a mind of its own. If history has written its notes with Obama as the president noone can stop it.

Helki   November 1st, 2008 3:14 pm ET

Who cares about his aunt this is another ploy of the republicans trying to find something on Obama because they are losing. At this point in the election no one cares whoever is going to vote for Obama has already voted for him or still are going to vote for him on November 4th. The undecided voters are not going to make a difference. I already voted for OBAMA

Hillary   November 1st, 2008 3:14 pm ET

She's Obama's half- aunt. The half sister of an estranged father. If you don't know whether or not she's really an illegal immigrant, because you can't verify this story, why run it?

H.Nelson An American living In Maastricht Holland   November 1st, 2008 3:14 pm ET

Wow!!!!! The the Mcpalin and G.W.Bush gang will do anything to get eclected...How low can you go....Sad day for American politics and this election..Sad,sad,sad.......

Jdm   November 1st, 2008 3:13 pm ET

Good luck! They outed a CIA OP and got away with it. Do you really think your going to find anything about a illegal immigrat outed 3 days before an election. Yeah right! The kicthen sink approach in full swing!

SICKandTIRED!   November 1st, 2008 3:12 pm ET

Whether this is politically motivated or not, the bottom line is if she is here illegally, then it is wrong. There are 12 million illegal immigrants in the U.S.A. So, I hope nobody stoops so low to tie Obama or take it against him.

Sue, Vienna, VA   November 1st, 2008 3:12 pm ET

This country has become mired in the worst political vitriol I have encountered in my 41 years of voting. From false accusations, innuendos, and outright lies, we have watched the 2008 campaign sink lower and lower. I began the campaign season thinking I would vote for John McCain, since I am a registered Republican, I have voted Rep. the majority of the time, and I thought Senator MCain was an honorable man. I no longer feel that way. My husband and I cast our votes for Obama-Biden last Tuesday and couldn't be more proud. The differences between Obama and McCain were MUCH too stark to ignore – Obama being an intelligent, introspective, and resolute man ready to lead this nation back to the respected country it used to be, and McCain being an angry, cantankerous, divisive old man.

g terry   November 1st, 2008 3:12 pm ET

I HOPE SHE CONTINUE THE EFFORT TO BECOME A CITIZEN OF THIS WONDERFUL COUNTRY AS MANY BEFORE HER HAS, AND MY GOD BLESS HER EFFORT.

ALEXANDER SMITH SR   November 1st, 2008 3:12 pm ET

please let her live here and in peace.she is a woman and have going through two much know. please leave her in peace in Jesus name. God be with her always.

victor, NC   November 1st, 2008 3:12 pm ET

Barack Obama: 'It's gonna get nasty' in final days before election. "War Hero", "Not Country First", "No Honor" McCain & Co would rather win an election than helps his volk.

Mike   November 1st, 2008 3:11 pm ET

"Leak"??? A "leak" would imply that the shared information was not to be released publicly, or was confidential. Freudian, perhaps, Mr. Conyers?

Arielle Yanaba   November 1st, 2008 3:11 pm ET

This must be the republican party's idea of an "October Surprise". To bad they just don't get the fact this is not the same electorate of 2000 or even 2004! Seriously, leaking info about his Aunt? Are you kidding me?

Diana Ewing NJ   November 1st, 2008 3:11 pm ET

Don't bother spending money on this..... it was Bush/Chaney/McCain/Rove Bush Chaney /McCain/ Rove.... sorry for repeating myself.....

Brenda in Evansville, Indiana   November 1st, 2008 3:11 pm ET

If Valerie Plame taught us nothing else, it's that this par for the course from the Bush-Cheney administration.

Does anybody care that the Dept. of Homeland Security has leaks?

Rod in nc   November 1st, 2008 3:11 pm ET

This should not be a shock or surprise to anyone. Pres. Bush used terror alerts to to create fear to redirect views and attention from his policies. Tricks are used to gain an advantage, like a lot of this homeowners under water! Instead of protecting us, they blamed us, and then said- we should have read the fine print. Sounds alot like the patroit act to me

Kina, A Veteran in NYC   November 1st, 2008 3:10 pm ET

i'm with u on this one Rep. Conyers...and that's why we can't vote for another republican...it's very sad, though...really!!!...but it's hardly surprising, if u ask me...i mean, we've been waiting for an "October Surprise" and here we have it...BTW, pls go out and vote, good ppl...we don't need to tolerate this anymore...

Pls don't shut me up, MODERATOR...

Obama/Biden 08.

Kina.

Beth, NY   November 1st, 2008 3:09 pm ET

Where was this guy when Joe the Plumbers' tax records were looked into and leaked? These Obama supporters are becoming Nazis-suppressing everyone who does not agree with them-like they did by kicking certain news reporters off the plane.

cheryl   November 1st, 2008 3:09 pm ET

One more thing. Out of millions of campaign donations from all the people ing this country, this was the only womans name they came up with? And I have swamp land to sell you in FL!

Alex ednie   November 1st, 2008 3:09 pm ET

Are Americans really going to re-elect Bush and company ?
Isn't anyone thinking back there ?
Bush inherited the largest budget surplus in the history of the country and is leaving with the largest deficet in the history of the country.
If America re-elects Bush/Mcbush
You deserve it.
The only real terrorists are Americans
That country is going to implode.
God bless America

IF, Portugal   November 1st, 2008 3:08 pm ET

Guess this is the best the McCain campaign or one of its supporters could come up with as a late October surprise. Lame... and even if true how on earth does this reflect on Obama? Obviosuly if it's true and he had been aware of it, he'd have dispatched his aunt for a long vacation somewhere. Grow up...

California Gold   November 1st, 2008 3:08 pm ET

She may also not be Obama's aunt.

Catholic-mom-4-OBAMA   November 1st, 2008 3:08 pm ET

That's IS a good question! By the way, IF his aunt IS here illegally, wouldn't INS pick her up?

The far-right-hate-lies-fear-and-division mongers of the Republican party, will do and say anything!

What a SHAME that the media did not investigate the story before it appeared in the headlines. What about the "federal law enforcement official" who was one of the AP "sources" who is this guy? And IF this "federal enforcement law official" knows that Sen. Obama's aunt is here illegally WHY hasn't she been deported???????????????????

JUST LIKE THAT WOMAN WHOM ACCUSED A BLACK MAN OF ATTACKING HER AND CARVING HER FACE..........WAS A .....LIE, AND SMELLED BAD FROM THE START........SO DOES THIS STORY!

Voting anything but Republocrat   November 1st, 2008 3:07 pm ET

I have been coming to America ever since 1975. I always come and go," – from the CNN article expressing Obama's ignorance on her immigration status. So she can afford to travel back and forth across the Atlantic but needs my tax dollars to afford housing? Gee... I'm so glad I could help the poor woman out after she overstayed her welcome.

Even if Obama doesn't know anything about all these people he hangs out with and even is related to, doesn't that ignorance scare the crap out of anyone else? How can he know how to help people he doesn't know when he doesn't seem to notice anything about the live, feelings, and motivations of the people he DOES know?

Oh yeah, I remember. He's going to give you money you didn't earn by raising taxes on people who already pay 5-20% higher tax rates than you. What a freakin hero.

Jacklyn, NC   November 1st, 2008 3:07 pm ET

People and this is the America that we are suppose to love so dearly. I don't think so. Why should we have any allegiance and pledges of a one-of-a-kind nation which is WHITE people are the chosen ones, well if this is the case, NO THANKS AMERICA!

David   November 1st, 2008 3:07 pm ET

It's half-aunt, not aunt. I know CNN doesn't care about details.

Bebe   November 1st, 2008 3:07 pm ET

I pray they find out who is responsible for this leak. I hope the aunt is in a safe place because they showed pictures of where she lives. That's terrifying knowing how some people feel about OB.

cheryl   November 1st, 2008 3:06 pm ET

Glad to know that somebody has some brains! Whoever leaked this information for the Retrash party should be fired on the spot! As I stated before, if you do the crime you should do the time!

Obama & Biden all the way!

Steven Albretsen   November 1st, 2008 3:05 pm ET

This is political sleaze at its worse! any media company that
shows this should be ashamed.

nelley   November 1st, 2008 3:05 pm ET

on nov 4,2008. Amercia please choose "HOPE over FEAR".........

d   November 1st, 2008 3:05 pm ET

Bush again! Man they will do anything to win.

N V Shipman   November 1st, 2008 3:04 pm ET

I can't understand why the Govenor of California would support the Bush/McCain policies after putting his state employees on minimum wages. Instead of worrying about Obama's skinny legs, he should be concerned about the forced economic genocide he has placeed upon his state workers. Based on his actions he really deserves the name of terminator 08.

rob   November 1st, 2008 3:04 pm ET

good luck in finding out. If the bushies leaked it, you think they'd admit it. Me thinks not. Fascism reigns supreme in the republican party.

KansasGirl   November 1st, 2008 3:04 pm ET

Why is this leak deplorable? The only deplorable thing here is, why am I supporting an illegal? Send her back home.

Chris in PA   November 1st, 2008 3:04 pm ET

The lowest of low.

How low can they go?

How can anyone consider voting for McCain/Palin?

Absurd.

Joel Parkes   November 1st, 2008 3:04 pm ET

Anything the Bush/McCain/McCarthy team does won't surprise anyone anymore. that's why they are getting the boot.

The Tax Payer Revolution begins Nov 4 (Producers vs. Moochers and Looters)   November 1st, 2008 3:04 pm ET

Let's demand to know who may have leaked info on Obama's aunt's immigration status, but actually requiring Barack Obama to produce physical proof (ie an actual paper birth certificate) that he is even Constitutionally-eligible to RUN for the office of POTUS, let alone hold the office, why that's simple racism!

A constitutional crisis is brewing over this man and it may very well split this country in two. Granted, the media that is ignoring and pooh-poohing this issue is the very same media that said, "John Edwards is NOT messing around on his cancer stricken wife and it's shameful that anyone is even alleging it." Nothing to see here... move along... these aren't the droids you're looking for...

BBB   November 1st, 2008 3:03 pm ET

And they sink lower and lower....

Karen - Missouri   November 1st, 2008 3:03 pm ET

Oh you can bet it was McCain or Bush! That's what's so disgusting about the Republican politicians of late. Bush couldn't control leaks while dealing with Iraq and now McCain can't control his own campaign.

and the press is just as guilty. They KNOW about the confidentiality so why didn't they check this out first? I say go after the media person and the AP for even considering airing the info.

Besides, why was she denied political asylum?

Anonymous   November 1st, 2008 3:03 pm ET

How low will John McCain and Sarah Palin stup? It's very sad that they can't address the issues, their whole platform is bash Barrack and find something negative so they can get a vote, HOW SAD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
How can John McCain consider himself a maverick with this kind of performance. The respect I had for Senator McCain is now gone, I even gave him the benefit of the doubt when he picked his running mate Sarah Palin, but his campaign since that has been horrible!!!!!!!
When he looses this race he can only blame himself and Sarah Palin.

robtr   November 1st, 2008 3:02 pm ET

we sure wouldn't want the American people finding out about lawbreakers in our own country now would we Mr. Conyers? The Obama thuggery continues on.

Christine   November 1st, 2008 3:02 pm ET

Also, why doesn't it disturb Conyers that Obama's aunt is living here illegally period? And that Obama claims to not have known. How is that even possible? Obama should spread his wealth around to his own family before lecturing the rest of us. And his illegal immigrant aunt shouldn't be living off taxpayer's dollars. This is completely ridiculous.

Peter (CA)   November 1st, 2008 3:02 pm ET

Ignore it.

This is Republican desperation politics. If you give it attention, it grows more than it should.

jon,philadelphia   November 1st, 2008 3:02 pm ET

These people don't know how to not leak. I am still waiting for someone to go to jail for treason for the Valerie Plame affair.

Christian Democrat in Florida   November 1st, 2008 3:02 pm ET

The Repubs will stop at nothing...
In Broward County, Florida: Robo calls circulating from a person pretending to be Brenda Snipes (Supervisor of Elections) telling people they can vote Tuesday by phone. I hope no one will actually believe the caller...

Steve Bender   November 1st, 2008 3:01 pm ET

Here is another example of hypocrisy from the republican base, whoever released this information(coward) is trying to say that the Obama camp is committing an illegal act, when they committed an illegal act to release this garbage. Sara Palin is allowed to spew the Anti-American vile when she herself commended the AIP in 2006 for doing a great job to be removed from the United States. I myself had my father the abandon me when I was a child, there are relatives I have that I do not know anything about. Even the ones I have only met once. SAD.........

common sense   November 1st, 2008 3:01 pm ET

Where are Palin's medical records? She said she would release them, but she has not. Palin Lie #1,827.

annie - never again a dem.   November 1st, 2008 3:01 pm ET

Possibility that obama is an illegal!

Karen   November 1st, 2008 3:00 pm ET

Disgusting. The federal law enforcement official should be fired if the identity is ever discovered. This would appear to be another attempt to cast doubt on Sen. Obama. I am sick of the tactics of the past eight years. Wake up America and make the "Change We Need"!

Obamma Camp Going Nazi.   November 1st, 2008 3:00 pm ET

It's starting already-first Obama threw reporters off the plane whose newspapers supported McCain-now they are trying to suppress info on Obama's aunt who is an illegal immigrant–then Obama insisted that his replacement in the Senate be black-

If you are white, you best move to Canada.

i.s   November 1st, 2008 3:00 pm ET

what does Obama's aunt's immigration status have to do with the election and the issues? I think Conyers has a valid point they should investigate the source of this report. The Republicans have noooo shame, sooo disgusting, they keep avoiding the issues, simply because they know they have nothing to offer the American people.

Teena in Denver   November 1st, 2008 3:00 pm ET

Remember what Barack Obama said–Power does not concede easily. After 8 years of under-handed governing this report by a law-official is NOT Suprising!

"Anything to win" is the Republican motto.

Terrence   November 1st, 2008 3:00 pm ET

John Conyers should be more concerned with the disgrace his wife is as a Detroit city councilwoman than the source of this leak.

shahid   November 1st, 2008 3:00 pm ET

Why not investigate the immigration violation and Obama's knowledge of his aunt and not doing anything about it instead of investigating the leak? Media bias again?

Christine   November 1st, 2008 2:59 pm ET

Who leaked Joe McCain's 911 call a couple of weeks ago? Did Conyers demand an investigation? Was it political? Of course no one in the media cares. Conyers is a well-known lunatic fringe liberal hack.

finally   November 1st, 2008 2:59 pm ET

someone need to be fired for this ,how would feel if somebody's situation you know is parade like that on national tv because some relative is running for president? Please stop the mud ,McCain supporter think they are helping him....not that if he want to loose FL,Co,Nevada New mexico and make 20% in California

Tena   November 1st, 2008 2:59 pm ET

I, too, was stunned as well as questioned how Senator Obama's aunt's unlawful U.S. residency status was obtained by the media. As a federal government employee whose work entails close and direct Homeland Security and Immigration Services' contact for status verification of aliens' lawful/unlawful U.S. presence, I know the leak had to involve governmental insider release of secured information that is prohibted by law! Totally unacceptable! Investigation for identifying person(s) is appropriate and once discovered, disciplinary actions should be exercised to the fullest!

Olivia   November 1st, 2008 2:59 pm ET

Or maybe someone from the obama campaign?
For whatever obscure reason...it's a toss up.
Besides.....I'm sure Michael Chertoff will add this to his list of things to look into pertaining to this presidential race, especially if it affects security.

B. Washington   November 1st, 2008 2:59 pm ET

I am really tired of this election. I feel that people who would do any to win an election does not deserve to be in office. McCain and Palin have said and done everything about Obama. The Republican party is such narrow minded and the people in it for most part are hateful and prejudice. I do not know how they can call themself Christians.

The Tax Payer Revolution begins Nov 4 (Producers vs. Moochers and Looters)   November 1st, 2008 2:58 pm ET

Yes, let us get the bottom of who leaked the immigration status of Obama aunt, but that major newspaper (NYT) that leaked national security secrets, that's not important. Nothing to see here... move along... these aren't the droids you've been looking for...

Reality   November 1st, 2008 2:58 pm ET

More attempts at censorship from the Obamabots. Disgusting. This is America.

Truth to the People   November 1st, 2008 2:58 pm ET

Its ok to investigate

investigate Bush, Cheney for high crimes

investigate all these 30 year Republicans that have been robbing us with one hand and pointing to accuse decent Americans of "not being "real" Americans" with the other.

Republicans have pilfered our nation, with a brilliant clean white smile and convinced us that its or own best interests.....Republicans turned our government into a tool for capitalists, the reason the Republicans want to destroy organized labor is because slavery is illegal.

May God grant the courage to the decent men and women of the Justice Dept to bring these people to trial.

Our national character hangs in the balance of our will to vigilantly pursue justice......and condemn criminals.....all the way to the top

ARREST BUSH and CHENEY, ALL MEMBERS of the TORTURE TEAM
Investigate, indict, bring to trial.

The truth shall set you free........still

Lynne   November 1st, 2008 2:58 pm ET

It's laughable that Conyers is more concerned with the idea that someone might have leaked the fact that Obama's aunt is an illegal alien than he is with the fact that 1. she is an illegal alien, residing in the United States illegally, 2. she is living in public housing in Boston, once again against the law, 3. she has broken campaign finance laws by contributing to her nephew's campaign, 4. that she was ordered to leave the country four years ago by an immigration judge and didn't leave and 5. that Obama and his campaign knew that she was in Boston.

Once again, teflon O will get away with something unsavory as the press whistles its way past the graveyard. I dread the next four years.

The Krazed Kanadian   November 1st, 2008 2:58 pm ET

Like President Obama said, it' about to get nasty these next couple days!

Dr. Lecter, Baltimore MD   November 1st, 2008 2:57 pm ET

After the whole Valerie Plame fiasco, is anyone really surprised at this?

Susan MO   November 1st, 2008 2:56 pm ET

Now he says he knew nothing about this. We find that very hard to believe.

tishoogle   November 1st, 2008 2:56 pm ET

Dirty pool is going on! An investigation should be conducted! McCain
will do whatever it takes to win this election!

Obama will win! Honest Man!!!!

dave   November 1st, 2008 2:54 pm ET

it is really sad for our country!
weather it is republican or dems.
that our politics has gone to the lowest low
ever seen before , an having federal officials
leak out information, with know regaurd
of what our country stands for.
its a sad sad day for the people that have to live with this
so call government

i thought there were protections for everyone in america
even immigration status, if that not the case why dont
we leak out eveyone businees, social sec. numbers, bank acounts
make our voting records public, .. etc.. etc.

we preach PROUD TO BE AMERICAN, as long as it fits
for what you want out of it , an dont care about your fellow man

next president fix this please
if you can take your head out of our countrys butts long enough

eddy   November 1st, 2008 2:54 pm ET

You can bet that BUUUUUUSH,McCain & AILIN PALIN ARE BEHIND THIS.

Obama is for UNITING of the PEOPLE   November 1st, 2008 2:54 pm ET

So Obama has a relative who WANTS to be an American........And McCain Picked a VP and her first dude WHOM want to DIVIDE Alaska FROM the UNITED STATES........CNN. YOu would report this, WHat happen toe the leader ofAIP who stated if he had an AMERICAN flag he would stump all over it? Why haven't you listed Alaskan Independence Party that Todd and Palin were obsess with?: Keep up the good work," Sarah Palin told members of the Alaskan Independence Party in a videotaped speech to their convention six months ago in Fairbanks. She wished the party luck on what she called its "inspiring convention." The Alaskan Independence Party, founded in 1978, initially promoted "the Alaskan independence movement." But now, according to its website, "its primary goal is merely a vote on secession." The Alaskan Independence Party has HATE US for YEARS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The leader of the Alaskan Independence Party said HE would NEVER hang an American FLAG on a pole in ALaska...WHERE IS HIS INTERVEIW????????????????

Billy   November 1st, 2008 2:53 pm ET

Standard low road, republican tactis.

Power never concedes.

Robert   November 1st, 2008 2:52 pm ET

Who cares about any of this? The Boston Housing supposedly checked her status and didnt find anything wrong. Shes been here for at least 4 years, and she is one of 10million. The campaign returned her money, Obama even said she should follow the law and that he didnt know about it, none of us know everyone in our family and what they are doing and if its such a big deal, deport her. This type of "news" coming out so close to the just shows you how low the republicans are. Who cares?! Stop wasting our time with stupid things like this. Stories like this dont fix the economy, they dont get us health care. They dont do anything to unite us. CNN and others, stop wasting our time with this nonsense!

Mike H.   November 1st, 2008 2:52 pm ET

The real focus of any investligation should be whether Obama was in touch with his aunt and knew of her illegal status and the deportation order against her. The authorities should also look into the violations of law in the form of Obama's aunt living in public housing and donating to his campaign.

Linda32   November 1st, 2008 2:48 pm ET

I would like to know that also.

Kim   November 1st, 2008 2:47 pm ET

I think we all know where this came from in the 11th hour of the election race. The campaign who's running scared and now will do anything, at any cost to win. I guess they couldn't find Bin Laden to provide an October surprise...

Pathetic.

barbara miller   November 1st, 2008 2:47 pm ET

Thank you Mr. Chertoff for taking right and just action. It must have taken a lot of digging by someone out there to find this information about a woman who is a half-sister to Obama's Father. And then, it took a incredible lack of character and judgment to divulge this private information to the 'diggers'.

BM   November 1st, 2008 2:46 pm ET

While you were at it, Bush you should have revealed to CNN your arrest record and how you avoided the military.

Paul - Seattle   November 1st, 2008 2:46 pm ET

Once again the American people are supposed to be distracted from the issues. We won't be fooled this time. The consequences are too serious. We have real problems that need real solutions. Divisiveness is not a solution...it just adds to the problem.

Obama/Biden '08
Hope...Solutions...Our Future!

Steve in WY   November 1st, 2008 2:46 pm ET

Typical Republican law breaking.

Toole   November 1st, 2008 2:46 pm ET

Republican fingerprints all over this one.

JOL   November 1st, 2008 2:46 pm ET

I certainly hope that no one ever expects me to be held accountable for all of my relatives actions.

Independent white female patriotic voter   November 1st, 2008 2:46 pm ET

Who cares???? I don't! just give me someone who will fix the economy, fix healthcare and fix education...someone who will once and for all put the people of America before their hunger for power and their own political gain. Mccain has been lying through his teeth and I am sick of Joe the plumber"who by the way would get a beter tax break under Obama" and I am sick of air head, Palin, and tired of all the finger pointing. They have spent the last few weeks throwing all kinds of bull at Obama trying to see what sticks. I think Obama has been a great campaigner, a great politician who has respect for others and a very tough and disciplined way of doing business. Just what we need today in this economy. I have lost so much respect for Mccain, I never disliked him, but now I do.

Matt, Manchester, CT   November 1st, 2008 2:46 pm ET

Sure thing, Congressman Conyers – let's spend our money wisely in that manner. I'm certain there's nothing else in the country that you folks in Congress should be analyzing.

LaVelle from Atlanta,GA   November 1st, 2008 2:45 pm ET

hmmmm CNN knows that it was the republicans who leaked this out, but who cares about his aunt, wait a second, arent there millions of illegal immigrants that are here in this country that we know for a FACT are illegal, and we havent talked on them this whole campaign season and now CNN wants to talk about Barack's aunt who we do not even know all about the facts in her case. CNN you are suppose to report the truth, not playing a guess game. More Fear Tactics. And people who are not going to read into this and just read the headlines are going to think something bad of this, when they shouldnt! Shame on you CNN...This is what I have been saying all along, including reporters like Campbell Brown who will do anything to criticize Barack and never Mccain. I have said she as well as many need to take her shirt off to reveal a big Superman "R" underneath. I give her as well as CNN, "A Pat on the Back for the republicans."

The Manchurian candidate   November 1st, 2008 2:44 pm ET

Faux News perhaps? Desperate, whoever's fault it was

McHoover Would Destroy What's Left of America   November 1st, 2008 2:43 pm ET

This is a perfect example of why the Republicans need more than their hands slapped this election.

The hypocrisy is outrageous. I recall Mr McHypocrite stating earlier that families were off limits.

Our country has become a dictatorship under Bush/Cheney/Rove/McCain/Palin.

Tony   November 1st, 2008 2:43 pm ET

It is a last, deseprate by McCain and the republicans.

WON'T WORK JOHNNY BOY!

A moderate independent in Illinois   November 1st, 2008 2:43 pm ET

Of course somebody in the Bush administration is involved! I guess the nasty Republicans will soon be calling this Aunti-Gate.
What did Obama know and when did he know it. This is just more gutter-level politics from the "honorable" John McCain. HAH!
John McCain and Sarah Palin should absolutely be ashamed of themselves. I hope the voters across America repudiate this type of politics once and for all.

BM   November 1st, 2008 2:43 pm ET

This is one of the kinds of sneaky,stealing that Bush did to win his presidency.He should not want another term with the kind of mess he has put this country in. McCain will be worse.

Mike in Texas   November 1st, 2008 2:43 pm ET

Wouldn't surprise me if Bush or McCain was behind this. I am sure they knew along time ago but wanted to put it out right before the election. Shouldn't be a big deal anyways except for neo-cons like Rush and Sean.

Susan   November 1st, 2008 2:42 pm ET

We are concerned that Obama has known this from the beginning. This concerns us as Democrat voters.

MaryJane   November 1st, 2008 2:42 pm ET

I have no clue and have no responsibility over what happens to my extended family. I can only control who lives under my roof.

This leak shows that there's a hole in the US Dept of Homeland Security process. Tells much about how they track people with visas. After denying her application for asylum, why wouldn't they follow up to ensure she had left the country?

I'm still voting for Obama and if the GOP thinks this is going to change people's mind, they have another thing coming. No more stealing of the White House, sorry!!

Virginia Voter   November 1st, 2008 2:42 pm ET

I voted early for Obama/Biden. I'm sick of this gutter politics from the GOP.

j   November 1st, 2008 2:42 pm ET

Just get her legal status if she qualifies or send her back to Africa. Geez!

Alexander   November 1st, 2008 2:42 pm ET

Maybe there should be laws against reporters using information that they know can only be given illegally – and when the intention behind leaking it is so obvious. Or maybe it should just be in the reporters moral DNA?

Memarme   November 1st, 2008 2:40 pm ET

GO MCCAIN AND PALIN!!!!!! NO OBAMA!!!!!!!!!!

3D   November 1st, 2008 2:40 pm ET

Here we go and here they come . . . trying to stop the Obama freight train. Keep trying!

DB25   November 1st, 2008 2:40 pm ET

Gee, could it be a Bush political appointee from Homeland Security? Duh.

weneedstrongleadership   November 1st, 2008 2:40 pm ET

First the tip off of the Ashley Todd information to try and smear Obama, now this. McCain you sir are a disgrace to not only yourself but to the american people. McCain you and Palin aren't even wearing your flag pins anymore, just another sign that you have turned your back on the American People.

Jo-Ann   November 1st, 2008 2:39 pm ET

Wow....anything to make Obama look bad...We the peopel are sick of this kind of stories....It's not going to stop people from voting for Obama....

OBAMA WILL BE OUR NEXT PRESIDENT OF THESE UNITED STATES!!!

Cathy   November 1st, 2008 2:39 pm ET

Everyone knows that the Bush administration would do anything to try to help his sidekick, John McCain, win this election. Not this time Bush and McBush! Enough is Enough! Eight years is Enough! It is time for a positive change and the American people will speak on Nov. 4. Enough Said!

Obama/Biden 2008!

Obama for President!!!   November 1st, 2008 2:39 pm ET

This is more Rethuglican tactics that will BLOW UP in there face!!!!!!!!!!

LT for Obama   November 1st, 2008 2:39 pm ET

I have read some interesting comments on this subject of the illegal aunt on a different blog.

First of all, there is not evidence that Obama knew this woman was here on an expired visa nor is there any of his knowledge of her financial situation, yet so many who want to lay blame put this all at his feet. You all have to keep in mind that he has only met her a few times in his 47 years on this earth. His Kenya family is quite large.

One comment that really pisses me off is that people keep talking about him giving his Kenyan family money to help out. Two things here, he does not really know these people and there are far too many of them for him to be helping out everyone. Secondly, where is the OUTRAGE about Cindy McCain who let her sister on her father's side get completely cut off without a look over her shoulder when their father died. She claims to be an only child but has two sisters she grew up knowing and acts like they don't exist. Talk about hypocrisy.

Dave   November 1st, 2008 2:39 pm ET

Republicans are desperate to distract attention from the real issues.

Alissa in Kansas   November 1st, 2008 2:39 pm ET

I think we all know this has got Bush/McCain written all over it.

A Well Educated Woman   November 1st, 2008 2:38 pm ET

Figures, what will it be tomorrow?

California Voter   November 1st, 2008 2:37 pm ET

What about the "leaks" on Joe the plummer?

votenow   November 1st, 2008 2:36 pm ET

these sort of tactics are to be expcted from the repubs campaign. the should concentrate on the real issues, better yet start to repair the damage they have done, and that will become apparent after they loose the elections.

spread the wealth   November 1st, 2008 2:36 pm ET

cnn-virginia obama 51 mccain 44 undecided 7 hu??? 51+ 44=95,will that not make it 5% undecided cnn??? stop tryin to make it seem tight cnn!!

Tom, KS   November 1st, 2008 2:36 pm ET

It's funny though how the Government waited until this weekend to release this info. Clearly Bush is trying to make waves for Obama in hopes of knocking him off stride so close to the election. By keeping it under the radar until now, the story won't develop enough to be anything but an outlandish headline. I hope we aren't fooled again!

Jadie   November 1st, 2008 2:36 pm ET

We don't have to look too far. What a mess the Republican party has become. I doubt I'll ever trust any of them again....not even for local dog-catcher.
OBAMA?BIDEN

AmericadowntheDrainMcCain   November 1st, 2008 2:35 pm ET

GOP tactic. Is the public supposed to be outraged at his aunts presence here in the USA to the point where we don't want to vote for Obama? It amazes me at the level of narrow minded attacks on Obama. any informed person can see right through this rubbish but the sad fact of the matter is that most of America refuses to even get informed.

Gary   November 1st, 2008 2:35 pm ET

Todd Palin running free around the WhiteHouse scares me a whole lot more than Obama's Aunt.
Het Trig, who's your Mommy?

Nate Hussein   November 1st, 2008 2:33 pm ET

How low will the repugnants go? Hopefully after tuesday, they'll go away!
Obama/Biden '08

Bas   November 1st, 2008 2:33 pm ET

Of course it was leaked for political reasons.

Jen, CA   November 1st, 2008 2:33 pm ET

Well, of course, Conyers - it's an "inconvenient" truth, isn't it?

And since it's about Obama, the "untouchable" one - we don't like "inconvenient" truths - so we MUST HAVE AN INVESTIGATION - and Obama has plenty of dough to pay for it!

Ed Gmerek   November 1st, 2008 2:33 pm ET

This is typical of the biased News Media, unable to verify justifiable areas requiring information, problems where Obama's 'skeletons' should be exposed.

Vic   November 1st, 2008 2:33 pm ET

Registered Republican "voted" Obama/Biden 08.

Go Democrats!

Robert Bushman   November 1st, 2008 2:33 pm ET

Considering BO's immigration status has been challenged I believe it significant but not determinate that he has famility in the same position

OLD MAN SHOUTS AT CLOUDS   November 1st, 2008 2:32 pm ET

Of course someone on the rethug side leaked this – how low they are & should be thoroughly investigated for this – let's see if CNN & other msm outlets run the story about who leaked it since CNN seems to be afraid to give any more negative news to the rethugs or the McSame/Pain-lin campaign -

Sue/PA   November 1st, 2008 2:32 pm ET

So what if she is here illegally..................just goes to show that being Obama's relative gave her no special treatment....keep that fact in mind.

McCain is going to lose this race without honor........just sad.

Make sure you vote counts...check and recheck your electronic voting machine before fully completing your vote.

Every Vote Counts...........So VOTE!!!!

Barry In Las Vegas   November 1st, 2008 2:32 pm ET

Why isn't this lawmaker insist on finind out the source of the person doing the background check using govenment computers on Joe The Plumber?

Oops – Joe isn't aDemocrat and isn't African American.

KLEE   November 1st, 2008 2:32 pm ET

Here John & Sarah – try throwing this at Obama! Whats up when the agency is "prohibited from commenting on any individual's status" as per the Immigration and Customs – well just break the rules because we need "something" to throw in the road to see if we can make Obama stumble.....cheap shots are just that cheap shots......I live in the South – beautiful down here – but some of the stuff that comes out of the mouths of some people will just curdle your stomach.....I couldn't understand how I would live – if I weren't a white person......I would be very angry at the injustice because I already am! Martin Luther King was so right.......you've come along way baby – keep up the good work – one day – we will all live in the sun and come out of our caves!

Obama-Biden 08   November 1st, 2008 2:32 pm ET

Thank you John Conyers. Americans are tired of this kind of politics and we need to put an end to the Bush/Rove tactics.

MY FRIENDS - REPUBLI-KLANS JOA$$HN McINSANE/PAIN-LIN ARE SPREADING HATE & BIGOTRY IN AMERICA   November 1st, 2008 2:32 pm ET

not suprised this is coming from the BUSH/MCSAME white house that have fundamentally trampled on the human and civic rights of everyone living in the united states.

they are trying to stir up an "october surprise" to shift the momentum of this election to John McSame.

NOT THIS TIME –

IMMIGRANTS – LEGAL OR ILLEGAL HAVE RIGHTS TOO TO LIVE IN AMERICA.

NO ONE HAS AN EXCLUSIVE RIGHT -WHITES/BLACK/HISPANICS/ASIANS TO CLAIM THAT THEY ARE CITIZENS OF THE UNITED STATES – WE ARE ALL IMMIGRANTS!!!!!!!!!!

LET THE WOMAN LIVE IN PEACE...DONT HATE ON IMMIGRANTS, YOUR FATHERS WERE ONCE IMMIGRANTS AND YOU'RE PROUD OF THEM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

lost   November 1st, 2008 2:31 pm ET

if it is the truth, why it is important who leaked this out?
the fact is the fact no matter who found it. That person should not be persecuted for finding the truth. If it is the truth.
This is what we have right to know.

Joe Regis   November 1st, 2008 2:31 pm ET

The hard time and the economic crisis left by the repubs are going to determine the outcome of this election on Tuesday and not the vicious and vile attacks of the repubs.

THe people are paying attention this time around. The repubs are doomed on Tuesday.

I can see a landslide Obama/Biden 08/12.

SEIG OBAMA   November 1st, 2008 2:31 pm ET

Well if anyone is old enough remember NO ONE WILL QUESTION HEIR OBAMA, any questions and you will be LABELED DISLOYAL TO DER FUER, HEIR OBAMA."the one, the billiant and all knowing one. This is all to familiar it starts out so innocent and slowly grinds to changing the Constituion and loyalty oaths and taking people away at 3am.

Kimberly from Houston, TX   November 1st, 2008 2:27 pm ET

How about an investigation into why PALIN hasn't released her medical records?

rosangel..change that im waiting for   November 1st, 2008 2:27 pm ET

yes stop them why nobody talks about palin abuse of power with troopergate and using the money that do not belong to her for her kids travel........this is so wrong God will speak.

dittohead with forty names   November 1st, 2008 2:27 pm ET

You dont think an upstanding christian Republican would do such a thing do you mr.Conyers?

JAY N.H.   November 1st, 2008 2:27 pm ET

Republicans= ABUSE OF POWER

Bruce   November 1st, 2008 2:26 pm ET

While I am disturbed about this story as it is a fly in the ointment of Obama’s excellent closing campaign and a distraction from the profound challenges that face this country there are significan specifics to be recognized.

Mexico is a country which is economically disadvantaged. Illegal aliens come to the US seeking a better standard of living and financial advancement. Kenya is a country experiencing serious political violence and this woman came to the US seeking political asylum. This is a profoundly different issue from the current immigration debate. I do hope that once he is elected, Obama will address this situation promptly and legally.

David in San Diego   November 1st, 2008 2:25 pm ET

Gee–

A leak of legally confidential information from a politically motivated Repubican source ?

Tell me it isn't so....

No surprise in these Last Days for the Republicans.

worriedmom   November 1st, 2008 2:22 pm ET

hey maybe it was the same people that investigated Joe the Plumber!

spread the wealth   November 1st, 2008 2:22 pm ET

GOP it's easy""

McCain- A patriot   November 1st, 2008 2:21 pm ET

Of couse he did.. I'm sure he would have asked the same for some video the LA Times has, or why Joe the plumber was investigated.

cheryl   November 1st, 2008 2:20 pm ET

McCain's campaign will stop at nothing to try to smear Senator Obama. It's going to work.

Rogue Palin   November 1st, 2008 2:17 pm ET

Uh, it's of course Bush and Bush II (aka mcCain). No one doubts this.

Lee from FL   November 1st, 2008 2:16 pm ET

call george bush, im sure he knows

Comments have been closed for this article

subscribe RSS Icon
About The Ticker

The latest political news from CNN's Best Political Team, with campaign coverage, 24-7. Sign up for our twice daily Ticker emails. Got a news tip or feedback? For complete political coverage, bookmark CNNPolitics.com.

CNN=Politics Screensaver

CNN=Politics ScreensaverTap into the power of The Situation Room. Download this powerful new tool that keeps you posted on the latest political news from the campaign trail.
Download (4.1 MB, PC only)

twitter
@PrestonCNN: #FF @brianstelter, @NYT_JenPreston, @mediaite, @MysteryPollster
Updated: Fri, 27 Nov 2009 20:53:30 -0800
@wolfblitzercnn: Wizards beat Heat. That's two in a row. We need more. Earl Boykins is a real spark. Also glad Mike Dunleavy is back playing for Pacers.
Updated: Fri, 27 Nov 2009 18:45:40 -0800
@wolfblitzercnn: These White House State Dinner crashers ensure that security for thousands at upcoming holiday receptions at White House will be intense.
Updated: Fri, 27 Nov 2009 13:53:42 -0800
@CNNPolitics: Christmas season kicks off at the White House. http://bit.ly/5BLWNG
Updated: Fri, 27 Nov 2009 13:48:23 -0800
@PrestonCNN: RT @cnnbrk Dow falls 193 points in early trading. Wall Street shaken by Dubai woes. http://bit.ly/92VGAo
Updated: Fri, 27 Nov 2009 07:19:45 -0800
Categories
Powered by WordPress.com VIP