July 13, 2009
Posted: July 13th, 2009 10:56 AM ET

WASHINGTON (CNN) - The Supreme Court confirmation hearings for Judge Sonia Sotomayor began Monday with leading Democrats and Republicans signaling a fierce ideological debate over her qualifications to become the nation's first Hispanic justice on the high court.

The Judiciary Committee is considering whether Sotomayor, a federal appellate judge, should be the 111th person to sit on the nation's highest court. If confirmed by both the committee and the full Senate, she would be the third woman justice.

"Judge Sotomayor's journey to this hearing room is a truly American story," committee Chairman Patrick Leahy, D-Vermont, said after gaveling the first session to order. "Hers is a success story in which all Americans can take pride. ... Let no one demean this extraordinary woman."

Leahy also ripped conservative "ideological pressure groups" for "distorting" Sotomayor's record and opposing a woman who "will be a justice for all Americans."

However, Sen. Jeff Sessions of Alabama, the committee's ranking Republican, said Sotomayor represents the kind of activist judge that threatens the traditional foundation of the U.S. legal system.

Sessions, a former prosecutor and attorney general in his home state, challenged the attribute of empathy cited by President Barack Obama in nominating Sotomayor.

"Call it empathy, call it prejudice, call it sympathy - whatever it is, it is not law," Sessions said.

In particular, Sessions quoted Sotomayor from past speeches in which she said a wise Latina woman should be able to reach a better ruling than a white man, saying it showed an inherent bias.

"I want to be clear: I will not vote for and no senator should vote for an individual nominated by any president who is not fully committed to fairness and impartiality toward every person who appears before them," Sessions said.

A smiling Sotomayor arrived on Capitol Hill still wearing a cast for a broken ankle she suffered a week after Obama nominated her.

The 55-year-old Sotomayor received a good-luck telephone call Sunday from Obama, according to a White House statement.

Democrats who hold a majority in both the Judiciary Committee and the full Senate have predicted she will easily win approval from both.

If history is a guide, Sotomayor appears certain to get Senate approval with mostly Democratic support. When she won Senate confirmation for the federal appellate court in 1998, there were 29 "no" votes - all cast by Republicans.

Filed under: Sonia Sotomayor • Supreme Court


Mark of Saint Louis   July 13th, 2009 12:27 pm ET

The libs love her as she is possible racist, definitely biased. She will be ready to "legislate from the bench" and who cares if she doesn't think white guys can make a fair judge, only Latina women. She doesn't care about aborting babies either. Outstanding morals! You libs found another real winner.

Lakita Wright   July 13th, 2009 12:26 pm ET

Senator Grahams' remarks are very heartfelt and sincere, however, he like many of his GOP colleagues have a huge blind spot which limits their insight. It's called hindsight or history. He said, "if he had made the same comment she had made about a wise Latina . . . his career would be over." He lives in a world where he believes freedom and justice has always applied to everyone at all times and all things are equal. If this were the case he would be correct! However, he is not. In this country even a wise Latina can contribute wisdom, and she would be the first Latina in this nations history to actually have a prominent voice. My elderly Black aunts and uncles were called "boy" and "missy" by white children and it was perfectly fine, because traditionally only white males were the dispensers of wisdom. The fact that of the 111 Supreme Court Justices, 109 have been white males is a testament to this. Graham doesn't understand that if he had made the comment it would have been a reinforcement or reintroduction of the "Old Order," Sonja's statement was an interjection of something that has never entered their psyche. Until they come to terms with history they will never be able to positively impact it for the future.

GOP = Party of Hypocrisy   July 13th, 2009 12:24 pm ET

Bush appointed 2 far-right white men. These are the only type of justices the GOP wants on the Court. Despite the racists who oppose her because they are pandering to the far-right that controls the GOP, Sotomayor will obviously be confirmed because she is intelligent and extremely well qualified. Her service on the Court will benefit all Americans. By these disgusting personal attacks on Sotomayor, the GOP is saying they don't want any Hispanic votes in 2010 and 2012.

Doug, New Jersey   July 13th, 2009 12:23 pm ET

"How foolish is this statement? Sotomayor is a law honor student. I'm pretty sure she has never and would never think that race is a factor in applying the law…unlike David Duke that would support the lynching of any minority.

You sir no absolutely nada with your uninformed comparisons"

So what you feel trumps my facts that are based solely on her own words, how lib is that!

Her own words show that race is a factor in applying the law with her, she feels she will make a better decision than a white male because she is a female latina. Racism is the belief that one race is superior to another. Both David Duke and Sonia Sotomayor believe that is true. I love the "your iniformed comarisons", you as an Obama-bot are unable to respond to my facts since you don't have any Moore-on.org regurgitation for it. My issue with people like you is not that you are a blind partisan lib who functions soley on hate and lies, it is that you don't think for yourself and are told what to say and think from your libeal mind masters. Read the facts and draw your own conclusions, is that really too much to ask?

Zion   July 13th, 2009 12:20 pm ET

When we learn to get past ideology and focus on interests...boy America will then be a better place. This isn't about Sotomayor. This hearing is about posturing from the right and the left. It's also about prostituting themselves for votes. It's not about the good of the country. Wake up America.

Zion's famous quote
You were poor under Democrats, and you were poor under Republicans. Pick your poison.

dominican mama 4 Obama   July 13th, 2009 12:19 pm ET

@ Fair is Fair:
"I suggest you take a look at donations made by businesses and PACs to the democratic party as well. '

It is no secret that big businessess have made contributions to both parties, historically. The difference this time around,however, is that Obama did not accept contributions from the PACs, and has made AIG toe the line in regards to bonuses and other perks. Had Johnny been in the White House, it would've been business as usual with the Republicans, once again, looking the other way while big business got bigger and the average American got crushed. This is yet another reason why some of you are up in arms about Obama: it is NOT business as usual.

ella   July 13th, 2009 12:12 pm ET

Make no mistake – The GOP is the one under the microscope here. They can either choose to be people of character, or go the bigot route. Does not look so good for them right now.

Lakita Wright   July 13th, 2009 12:09 pm ET

Does a persons race, sex, and background have an influence on how they govern? Not if you're a white male, because the Republicans believe they are the only persons who can govern objectively (last I checked nearly 90% of the registered Reps are white males). With regards to Sonja, the Supreme Court Nominee, her race and sex will influence how she'll judge from the bench, just like the 109 out of the 111 past Supreme Court judges who were white males. If there had been more women on the bench, would it have taken 150 years for women to get the vote? If there had been more Blacks & Native Americans, would slavery and genocide been codified and carried out over centuries? Republicans refuse to acknowledge what is obvious to the rest of the world and therefore they will continue to have a credibility issue as the masses stay away in droves. I see it clearly, and I am considered a Black conservative. When will they ever get it?

Andrew, Buffalo NY   July 13th, 2009 12:05 pm ET

So why is it that the liberal left loves telling personal stories for their own, but discount everyone else's personal story?

LEFTIES=Hypocrates!

Republicans are the American Taliban   July 13th, 2009 12:03 pm ET

I want to hear the committee Republicans slander her to her face instead of hiding behind shock jocks and the other hate mongers....

awaitingliberalizationbyCNN   July 13th, 2009 11:57 am ET

Echoing a familiar refrain, lets just hope she gets the same treatement from the republicans as those nice liberal democrats gave to all of Bush's nominees over the last 8 years. But wait, if they did that, it would unfair, biased, personally and professionally destructive and partisan. Once again the libs have blazed the trail, hit her so hard her head spins.

Ken   July 13th, 2009 11:56 am ET

I agree, let's just have the vote and let these gentlemen get back to trying to get us out of this mess the last administration left us in. And for the gentleman who criticized the stimulus package, let's not forget the first $700 billion which "W" and the Boys wanted with no strings attached and to this day can not say where it went. Oh how I wished just one "real" news agency would just "Follow The Money" and report the Truth.

Dutch/Bad Newz, VA   July 13th, 2009 11:53 am ET

According to a judicial study on Judge Sotomayor, it showed that 98% of the time she sides with the unaminous decision. It's hard to ignore that. So if they disagree with her rulings, that's like saying they disagree with every judge.

dominican mama 4 Obama   July 13th, 2009 11:51 am ET

Put on a good show for your constituents, gentlemen, the whole country is watching....but no one is holding their breath, this is a done deal.

Fair is Fair   July 13th, 2009 11:51 am ET

tedious898 said,

"I am not saying the democrats are perfect but they're concern is for the average american. The GOP's main concern is the wallets of big business. I think big business can look out for themselves. The average american needs someone to look out for them".
_______________________

BOTH parties are looking out for one thing and one thing only – THEMSELVES. If you believe that big business supports only the GOP, I suggest you take a look at donations made by businesses and PACs to the democratic party as well. And when you do – take a good hard look at where companies such as AIG made the lion's share of their donations. You may be surprised.

Kevin in Ohio   July 13th, 2009 11:48 am ET

Leahy: ""Hers is a success story in which all Americans can take pride. … Let no one demean this extraordinary woman."
_____

You mean its was OK for YOU to demean the extraordinary people nominated by Republicans, bur not the other way around? True hypocrisy for the Party Of Hate. The TRUE Party of No.

Mississippi Mike   July 13th, 2009 11:47 am ET

Either she is a racist and sexist or she isn't. That's what we need to figure out.

Fla.   July 13th, 2009 11:47 am ET

Racism seems to be a sad part of Republican "ideology" these days. Just look at the deplorably racist CD distributed at the RNC against the black & Hispanic communities.

& TCM,

You can assume whatever you want–I could not care less. Your assertion of Rush Limbaugh's nonsense as so-called "truth" is hilarious and only continues to remind me why I left the GOP. No gracias.

ella   July 13th, 2009 11:45 am ET

The Republicans are choosing to travel down a path that NOBODY wants to follow. I can't get over how bigoted they are looking in these hearings.

Bob of Lompoc   July 13th, 2009 11:42 am ET

Keep it up Republicans. The picture of a group of angry, fat (some), white, rich, Republican males, thumping on Justice Sotomayor, should be shown to the melody "Hello Mary Lou", but the words will be, "Hello Libertarians and Ron Paul, goodbye Republicans and Sarah Palin". Sorry Sarah, I know you are not fat, rich (yet) nor male, but you are hitched to the Republican wagon, and you are all heading directly over the political cliff. Appeal to Ron Paul and Libertarians: Please, please save the two party system. Get out front, take the lead, replace the Republicans and permanently end their misery. Push them into the "Third Party" parking space, where they belong.

tom   July 13th, 2009 11:41 am ET

Eric:
I suggest you quit posting until you learn the difference between a liberal and a conservative. Until then I don't think you even understand what is at stake!!!

Trade Freedom for Security, Lose Both   July 13th, 2009 11:40 am ET

The gloves always come off for SCOTUS confirmations – as well they should. Given the long-term impact a SCOTUS Justice has, it is vitally important that the Senate duke it out as ugly as it may be.

Luke Brown   July 13th, 2009 11:40 am ET

I hope the Republicans really go after her. Unless you are white, wealthy, attend private schools, and belong to the right clubs you will never really fit into the Republican party. A lot of Americans - including Hispanics – don;t get thatt. These hearings will be a stark reminder of just how exclusive the Republican view of our country really is.

These GOP senators have gleefully approved people like Alito, Roberts, & Scalia, who have happily imposed their own right wing prejudices on this country. Suddenly now, we got this Puerto Rican lady and they are freaking out because she might do the same thing.

Wolves 4 Palin Charlotte, NC   July 13th, 2009 11:39 am ET

....nothing new here; so why bother to watch?

Terry from Texas   July 13th, 2009 11:39 am ET

The Conservative strategy is simply this: prevent government from solving any of the nations problems. When the country is in much worse shape in 4 years, they will have a better chance in the elections.

Conservative tactics: Block, stall, prevent, attack, exaggerate, minimize, divert, confuse, obscure, distract, attack, attack, attack.

Their thinking: if the middle class is in much worse shape in four years, they will reject Obama and we are the only alternative.

Al-NY,NY   July 13th, 2009 11:39 am ET

The GOP senators know their is nothing they can do to stop her appointment but they want to draw as much blood as they can. When the first decision they disagree with comes up it will be a "see I told you so" moment. Too bad GOP, you lose. Activist judges come from both sides so your constant whining and use of "buzz words" will not work

Jim   July 13th, 2009 11:37 am ET

They keep emphasizing that she is a "True American". They protest too much !!!

Ken   July 13th, 2009 11:37 am ET

I have never seen such mean spirited people as the Republicans. It really shows here. It sounds just pure evil. What is wrong with these people.

tedious898   July 13th, 2009 11:36 am ET

I am so looking forward to the GOP imploding. These sorry wastes of political space and air need to find themselves a reason to exist....other than greed and hypocracy.

I am not saying the democrats are perfect but they're concern is for the average american. The GOP's main concern is the wallets of big business. I think big business can look out for themselves. The average american needs someone to look out for them

Independent thinker   July 13th, 2009 11:35 am ET

I hope she gets the same "fair" treatment given to all the republican-nominated judges in the past......

Hypocrisy stinks.

southerncousin   July 13th, 2009 11:35 am ET

Hey libs you are right she will be confirmed and she will be as successul as the economic stimulus plan you took from our wallets to pay for . The Unions, ACORN, George Soros and the dope smokers fooled the Americans and won the election.

Fair is Fair   July 13th, 2009 11:32 am ET

She looks like she's about to cry already.

John from California   July 13th, 2009 11:26 am ET

As the great Senator McConnell once said during the Bush supreme court nomination hearings – Let's have an "Up or down vote".

Senator McConnell even threatened to suspend the filibuster rule in the Senate if he couldn't get his conservative judges confirmed.

Let's have a vote and forget all this "political theater".

If the republicans can get 51 votes against her, then lets see with a quick vote.

fierce ideological debate   July 13th, 2009 11:25 am ET

the GOP side would be:

did you lie? no

did you spy? no

did you cause someone to die? no

did you cheat on your spouse? no

did you cause a recession? no

did you start multiple wars? no

well how do you think you are qualified? you fail the GOP test

tedious898   July 13th, 2009 11:25 am ET

This going to be ALL About Race for the GOP. I believe they feel this is their last chance to destroy a perfectly qualified Latina Woman ...simply because of her ethnicity? I'm glad the President nominated her. She's qualified and will force the GOP to destroy themselves while displaying the obvious racism of this political party dinosaur.

I can't wait until the GOP is exstinct

GI Joe   July 13th, 2009 11:25 am ET

A true statement from Gaham: It's political.

Melissa   July 13th, 2009 11:24 am ET

Amazing how people like Mary love to ignore the fact that she wasn't the only judge to make the same determination as Sotomayer. Republicans use ignoring inconvenient truths to justify their own bad behavior.

eric   July 13th, 2009 11:24 am ET

First what the hell is the difference between a conservative or liberal? I mean if you disagree with a republican then you are labled this wild liberal . What in the hell is that? I mean if republicans disagree then why arent they called liberal. I would think that evryone whom is an American want the best for there families and communities,and yes there will be disagreements,but to put this label of too liberal !! get real. Wish we could do away with these assinine descriptions of folk just because we all don't agrre on how somethings are done. This woman is most highly qualified to be a Supreme court justice and those assine folk who would want to reject her because she is supposedly to liberal you all need to go back to your caves and crawl away!!

Brian Eisold   July 13th, 2009 11:21 am ET

Empathy is not a legal term, and those who argue it is not a defined part of the legal system are correct. However, unless justice is to be dispenced FAIRLY, law must be tempered with justice. And justice is law with mercy and fairness. To reach justice requires empathy.

I'm not sure why we'd want someone on the bench who didn't draw upon their life experiences, their understanding of history, and have a desire to right injustice. Otherwise, why not construst robots to dispence with untempered law?

citizenjane   July 13th, 2009 11:21 am ET

@Maria-Proud Democrat asked about the protesters.

It was something to do with "what about the unborn".

notfooledtx   July 13th, 2009 11:21 am ET

Of course the republicans are putting up a fight – I doubt that Jesus himself would be approved by the american taliban.

This is all just a sideshow for the gop – she has the credentials, but the obvious bigotry of those on the right will fight this tooth and nail. Too bad the good old white boys club lead by the wannabe kkk'er jeff sessions – who was embarrassed by his own bigotry years ago – aren't portraying themselves in a good light to the majority of the country.

maria   July 13th, 2009 11:20 am ET

The GOP is setting themselves up in a big way for their own train wreck.

GI Joe   July 13th, 2009 11:20 am ET

To Scott, Tucson July 13th, 2009 11:09 am ET

Fair as in the same treatment the Dems gave to Clarence Thomas and Robert Bork?
******************************************************
So, this is not really a fair hearing? It's about perceived "paybacks" for voting against a man that put "hair" on a woman's soda can? Or talked about "Long Dong ..................."?

Get REAL !!!!!

ANGIE   July 13th, 2009 11:18 am ET

repugs=haters!

tedious898   July 13th, 2009 11:18 am ET

Doug, New Jersey July 13th, 2009 11:07 am ET

"Hers is a success story in which all Americans can take pride. … Let no one demean this extraordinary woman."

Sorry, I don't find David Duke to be a success story either. There is no difference between these two, they both believe that thier race makes them superior to people of other races.

===============================

How foolish is this statement? Sotomayor is a law honor student. I'm pretty sure she has never and would never think that race is a factor in applying the law...unlike David Duke that would support the lynching of any minority.

You sir no absolutely nada with your uninformed comparisons

Mary   July 13th, 2009 11:16 am ET

Oh please Mr. Leahy, it was she who used reversed discrimination with the fire fighters. What is so admirable about that. The problem we have in this nation is the Mr. Leahy's who have one standard for the other guy and another for he and 'his' chosen. NO - the constitution did not allow for that. What's right is right, what's wrong is wrong - she was WRONG to use reverse discrimination. Period.

Peoples Voice   July 13th, 2009 11:16 am ET

The GOP's argument is simply, "She's not a white man."

Esther massillon ohio   July 13th, 2009 11:15 am ET

what is the debate really all about? they don't like the fact she is a woman or a latino enough said those old white men are clinging to there bias. they know better than you so shut up and do as i say not as i do.

Ed, Santa Fe, NM   July 13th, 2009 11:14 am ET

GOP right-wingers can't stop her confirmation, so why be so small-minded and hypocritical? Look at the ideologic duds the Bush boys put on the bench.

w.l. jones   July 13th, 2009 11:13 am ET

Sen. Patrick Leahy is a true American heroe for saying "hers is a success story" we all can be pride of. WHAT A PEOPLE WE ARE!

DH Mid MI   July 13th, 2009 11:11 am ET

I hope the Republicans give her the same treatment and attitude as Leahy gave Roberts and Alito.

Leahy and most of Congress are baffoons!

jim ohare   July 13th, 2009 11:10 am ET

I really think think she is racist. she always portrays herselfe as a latino . she was born in new york that makes her an american . not a latino. why is she so afraid to call herselfe a american woman.both my grandparents on both sids were born in Ireland.I dont go arround saying iam Irish. iam an american & proud of it.

Crazy Cat Lady   July 13th, 2009 11:09 am ET

Does Senator Sessions not know that the defining trait of a psychopath is a total lack of empathy?

Or is that a defining trait of the radical right wing of the GOP?

tedious898   July 13th, 2009 11:09 am ET

The Gee OH Fleas are going to be all over Sonya.

Does anyone see the racism and intellectual jealousy from especially the rather ignorant, racist, Jeff Sessions?

Scott, Tucson   July 13th, 2009 11:09 am ET

Fair as in the same treatment the Dems gave to Clarence Thomas and Robert Bork?

S.B. Stein E.B. NJ   July 13th, 2009 11:09 am ET

Where in her record is it clear that she ruled against the law in favor of a specific group. If that is found, then she should go back to where she is from. I am more inclind to believe that she followed the law.

Drumming Up Some Drama for Your Viewing Pleasure? | DEEP BRAIN DIARY   July 13th, 2009 11:08 am ET

[...] let's not waste them TV cameras, eh, fellas!  The fact that this nomination is a DONE DEAL doesn't mean you can't [...]

Alex   July 13th, 2009 11:08 am ET

Since this is a lost cause for the GOP, why are they wasting they time posturing? Why not construct some new ideas to help this country recover?

Maria - Proud Democrat   July 13th, 2009 11:08 am ET

Good let the debates begin.....that's what Democracy is about.

By the way did any one get what the protesters said in the back ground?

CNN censored the protests .....

Melissa   July 13th, 2009 11:08 am ET

No, whats really signalled is that the Republicans don't like her and will try everything they can think of to block her appointment.

Doug, New Jersey   July 13th, 2009 11:07 am ET

"Hers is a success story in which all Americans can take pride. … Let no one demean this extraordinary woman."

Sorry, I don't find David Duke to be a success story either. There is no difference between these two, they both believe that thier race makes them superior to people of other races. Every fair minded, decent, good hearted American takes issue with these racists and dreams of a society where we are judged by the content of our charecter, not our race. It is serious, our nation will take a major step backward if we allow a racist to be a supreme court judge, however you do have to laugh at the liberals who call people racists for not wanting a judge who thinks race makes one superior, yet acts as if she is not a racist. Maybe lib should pick up a dictonary and look up the term racist.

Rick CT   July 13th, 2009 11:06 am ET

She'll be confirmed – that's not the issue.

Funny how Leahy's standards have changed from the las t couple of SCOTUS nominations. Just another scummy politician who has way overstayed his welcome.

VB Lincoln Park NJ   July 13th, 2009 11:04 am ET

When Judge Sotomayor becomes Justice Sotomayor, will the vitriol and lies from the party of NO stop.

I doubt it, since when you can't win on issues, what else do you have but tactics like that of Mr. Limboob.

GI Joe   July 13th, 2009 11:04 am ET

We're watching. They may be judging her now, but we get the chance to judge a lot of them next year.

Pay attention, people. "NO" isn't always the correct answer. Sometimes it is, but not ALWAYS (like we've seen the last 4 or 5 months).

B.H.   July 13th, 2009 11:04 am ET

The GOP will naturally try to impose their racist bend to everything they say which is so transparent to most rational listeners.

maria   July 13th, 2009 11:02 am ET

The Republican senators are setting themselves up a very bigoted argument against Sotomayor. Hispanics, females, and people of all colors and descents are seeing straight through this. If these Republican senators continue down this path, the GOP will not survive the Sotomayor hearings.

Comments have been closed for this article

subscribe RSS Icon
About The Ticker

The latest political news from CNN's Best Political Team, with campaign coverage, 24-7. Sign up for our twice daily Ticker emails. Got a news tip or feedback? For complete political coverage, bookmark CNNPolitics.com.

CNN=Politics Screensaver

CNN=Politics ScreensaverTap into the power of The Situation Room. Download this powerful new tool that keeps you posted on the latest political news from the campaign trail.
Download (4.1 MB, PC only)

twitter
Categories
Powered by WordPress.com VIP