WASHINGTON (CNN) - A Republican House member shouted "you lie" during President Barack Obama's health-care speech to Congress on Wednesday, and members of both parties condemned the heckling.
When Obama denied that proposed health-care legislation would provide free health coverage for illegal immigrants, South Carolina Republican Rep. Joe Wilson shouted, "You lie!"
Obama paused and looked toward the Republican side of the chamber before
continuing his speech.
After the speech, Republican Sen. John McCain, the Republican presidential candidate defeated by Obama last year, called Wilson's outburst "totally disrespectful" and said he should apologize.
McCain said there was "no place for it in that setting or any other and he should apologize immediately."
Other Republicans also criticized Wilson, along with the expected Democratic condemnation.
"It was crude and disrespectful," said Sen. Dick Durbin of Illinois, a top Senate Democrat. "I think the person who said it will pay a price."
Updated: 10:00 p.m.
From CNN Politics
© 2011 Cable News Network. Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
| Advertising practices | Advertise with us | About us | Contact us | Work for us | Help
way to show how stupid and uneducated you are
I suspected it was a southern republican.
I love it. The president had the haters so flustered until they could not hide it.
Can you expect any better from the GOP?
Obama will likely invite him to the white house to see what he has to say to his face one on one without anyone else around. Doubtful that he will accept the invite.
Oh my god, someone dares disagree publicly with the messiah. Should he be shot, castrated, or exiled to Canada?
Shows class! yeah that's right, go ahead Rep. Joe Wilson show where you come from.... trailer trash?
This behavior is disgusting. I don't care what party you are from, you don't show this kind of disrespect to the President, especially as a member of congress during the Presidents Congressional address. Its bad behavior, pure and simple.
Well, well, for some reason I can't get on his website to learn about him. Perhaps the server crashed due to heavy traffic?
I'm not surprised. Just like my parents taught me in 2nd grade. When someone tries to shout you down its because they have ground to stand on to talk you down.
A white POTUS has never to my knowledge been disrespected like President Obama has. The republicans are despicable with their lies.
A public insult to my president requires a PUBLIC apology. Mr. Wilson should be ashamed of himself as his actions are not worthy of a man in his position!
There always has to be one jerk in the room, and with a room that size, several. Way to be classy Joe.
Whether or not you agree with someone, you should always do so respectfully. Rep Wilson should be ashamed of himself.
Such awful behavior. Whether one agrees with him or not, Obama was addressing Congress and the nation and deserved all respect. How many times you you think Democrats believed Bush was lying but refused to play the childish game as Rep. Wilson did?
I am a resident of South Carolina and I am a shame of this man totally respect towards the President, this is worst then a spoiled brat who has no home training. He needs to be removed from his duty. This was not the place for that kind of behavior,,,
I would like to say that Wilson was the most disrespectful Congressman I have every seen. He not only owes an apology to President Obama he also needs to apologize to the American People. He should be reprimand for his unprofessional behavior.
I would like to ask all South Carolina voters to rally together to get this jerk out of office.
Woops. i mean no ground to stand on!
Mr. Wilson has just proved his unfitness to serve in Congress, or in any public office.
If Obama wants a Canadian style health care system then opponents should be aloud to grieve opposition out load during public political discussion like we do here in Canada.
How mature. That's a great way to get your ideas heard. Really.
And that is one of the elected people who makes decisions that impact our lives. Outrageous!
Sadly, typical of the GOP. Classless.
He needs to go back to grade school , this was not the place or time to put on this rude behavior, send him to china where he would have been beheaded for such run comment to a president.
Way to go...
Stand up against this dictator...
Call it like you see it...
You're 100% correct...
HE LIED!!!
Of course he was lying, he's a politician, his lips were moving.
I just moved away from South Carolina. I am now glad that I did. Joe Wilson showed total disrespect for the President. They were not at some out of control town hall meeting. He should be ashamed!
Not surprising from a GOP Rep. Joe Wilson, set a new low water mark for the House. He has no class and should be barred from Congress.
Joseph Ricciuti
Way To Go Mr. Wilson
So the Grand Old Party can't muster basic logic and debate, so they resort to nana-nana-boo-boo? Their lack of respect for the Office of President, let alone for the man currently holding it, at least matches their level of respect for The Constitution.
How low class can you get? Someone elected this fool who does not have the common decency to disagree with someone with some kind of decorum. I think that his behavior is representative of "republican" behavior.
This is more of the disrespectful, rude, unhelpful behavior that we can expect from the Republicans. This type of behavior has become all to common in America, it's just really sad to see it in our Congress. We can't diagree without name calling and other disgraceful acts. I guess rude and shameful acts will be the norm from this group from now on. What happened to being gentleman and gentlewomen. What a Disgrace!
Rep. Wilson is an Idiot, and a disgrace .......
Very immature and highly disrespectful to the POTUS.
What a shameful thing to do. I don't care who the President is, or whether you agree with his policies, it's just absolutely tasteless to scream at him while he is addressing Congress and the nation.
I am so saddened by the idiotic behavior of the people who oppose health car e reform, but to have a member of Congress shout out like a common heckler during a speech by a sitting President is shameful. Sen Joe Wilson needs to publicly apologize to President Obama.. Congress should lead, not engage in riduculous and disrespectful behavior, but oh, he's a Republican.
This guy is from S.C. no wonder he is an idot to say out loud the President is lying. This is not what we need in this Country right now.....This guy is an idiot.
This man has no business holding any office for this country........you can disagree with the President but there are other more intelligent ways than this man exhibited in this Chamber on Tv........he should have to make a full apology as soon as possible........this in not Parliment like over in Great Britian.....this man's future in politics has just come to an end........we expect more respect from our elected officials........But take a look at the State he is from ...... the Great State of SC where the Govenor right now is being asked to step down from his office
Joe Wilson, should have some better respect. How did he get elected. Good speech, I give the President a B.
This is all part of the repubs strategy to dehumanize and make his presidency look illegitimate. Why do you think fox won't show his speeches? it's because if they dehumanize him, it makes it easier for people to hate him or be scared of him. Repubs think the american people are fools but the ones who hang on every word fox news tells them are the fools.
I think this his last term
We have to respect our president
absolutely classless!
Is this the way people in congress act? Where was your outrage when Bush lead us in to a war under false scare tactics. You should be thrown out on your ear.
Typical Republican. Downright rude. If you don't agree with the President that's fine, but respect him!
That's okay, apparently he was yelling the same thing at Cheney and Bush when they were making their case for the Iraq war.... Right.
Seriously, what's up with these guys? Is it they just cannot handle a man of color telling them how it's done?
Rep. Wilson: A true representative of the republican party. Obama gave a truly great speech. The republican response, by contrast, was lame and irrelevant, just like the republican party and it's representatives like Joe Wilson, Sarah Palin, and Rush Limbaugh.
how come he didnt call bush out on his many lies where do republicans find these people i know now why reagan quit funding mental illness there would be know republican party left
Rep. Wilson is REALLY doing a GREAT JOB himself – isn't he???
S. Carolina is the WORST in EVERY category except golf courses – and he has the nerve to disrespect the President of the United States????
What a MORON!!!!
Remember: Republicans = Incompetence
This man should be removed from office. He is a disgrace, all the childish tempertantrum throwing repugs in tonights speach. Its beyong pathtic.
Obama needs to get some Bush balls and make it clear that HE is the descider now. There is a new Sherrif in town.... A BLACK Sheriff.
What a total idiot!
He may disagree, but show some respect. South Carolina, I would be ashamed.
This will do alot to dispell the Republicans are angry, white men myth.
Shame and disgraceful .He can be sent to argentina as well.
DISRESPECT TO OUR AMERICA! He should be expelled we have become a laugh for rest of civil world
This congressman disrespected the President Of The United States it just goes to show that obama was right, Mr.Wilson is now a marked man the media is going to expose the hell out of him. lol
Totally disgraceful! His constituents should be ashamed to have a representative that would heckle the President of the United States. Moreover, he's perpetuating the "whomever screams loudest wins" behavior that has been dominating the health care discussion. I hope the good people of South Carolina kick this bozo to the curb!
Sad to see that republicans have to drop to such a low-class stunt. Funny all through Bush administration, throughout the theft and lies, no one screamed out those words during a Presidential speech. I guess when your only left wit the lowest of the scum, you get responses like Joe Wilson.
Everyone in Washington Metropolitan area needs to be at the Capital in tomorrow morning and protest his disrespectful behavior and he needs to get out of Washington, DC.
Joe Wilson ...
What a disrespectful jerk
The man does not deserve the seat he sits in
What have you done for this country in the past year Joe????
We The People say YOUR FIRED !!!
And using the word jerk is generous, compared to my real thoughts
Bravo to Joe Wilson, we need more people with his courage to speak out. Let that creep (obama) know we are on to him.
Funny ,he didn't listen nor understand the healthcare plan addressed. How disrespectful of him to shout at the presdient of the united states of america,. Bush didn't get that, and when will the NO sayers ever grow up?
What kind of people are we sending to congress? It makes me sick to see the rude, common behavior of those who should be examples of civility for our youth
Is this really a big suprise? These dumb republicans after supporting a retarded monkey the last 8 years cant stand that we actually have a smart president, oh and get this an African American. That is actually trying to do some good for this country.
If we dont get health care reform now, we will never get it and the US will no longer remain a super power. Just look at China and the rest of the world on how they are passing us on pretty much everything.
God help us
This moron Republican is the real liar ... Congrat to President Obama for call Republicans what they truely are – liars and fear mongers
For shame
That was very rude! Grow up.
that's a no-no!!! i couldn't believe my ears when i heard that! seeing nancy pelosi's face said it all! you do NOT disrespect the president in that arena under those circumstances like that no matter what political affiliation! just seeing the republican 30 second rebuttal with lies thrown in, lies the president had just debunked said it ALL to me! They are truly the party of NO. no ideas, no concrete thinking and now no on education of our young people... maybe they should all be in Canada?!
I'm a Republican and found this behaviour quite revolting and damaging. I crinched in embarassment when this blowhard uttered those words. Terrible mistake.
The poster child for the 'class' actions of the GOP.
Wow. Seriously? No respect wahatsoever. What an arrogant jerk. Tell me again why anyone votes republican
What an IDIOT!!!
Absolutely unforgivable behaviour. If you vote for the moron, you should be ashamed!
Rep. Wilson's rude outburst & lie confirm why I left the GOP and the fringe element too prevalent amongst its ranks. His fellow colleagues and the American people deserve better than the disgraceful behavior he showed in the Chamber tonight. Shame on you, Wilson!
I wonder if he realized he would get Identified so quickly, or maybe he expected more outbursts from his congressional fellows.
joe wilson totaly out of touch with his enviroment ..........totally not called for and he must be punished for his actions.
What is the matter with the people from the southern part of our united states. Are they all illiterate and rude? I am beginning to think so! Whether you agree or disagree with Pres. Obama's speech context, it is definitely rude to yell something like this out. After all, this person is our president. And for those that are going to respond with the standard "freedom of speech" routine. Freedom of speech does not excuse rudeness.
As a side note, if there were term limits for these people, they would not be worrying about being re-elected and would concentrate on doing what is best for our country during their time in office. Jpw sad that our country is being run by a group of people that are more worried about their own jobs than the plight of the american people. They have all obviously forgotten why they were voted in or why they even have a job.
This man should not just apologize he should step down. There is no place for people like him in what is supposed to be a civilized, dignified place like the Capital. You should be ashamed Wilson(you don't deserve to be called Mr.) and anyone who votes for you in the future should be ashamed. Hats off to John McCain who denounced him immediately. There is the McCain that many of us admired before he hooked himself to the Lunatic Fringe of the Republican Party.
Congratulations, Wilson (no, you don't deserve a title): you just outed yourself on national TV as a boorish pig.
"Biggest disappointment of evening, the total lack of respect shown by one member for the President.Never acceptable to behave like a jerk." – Claire McCaskill via Twitter
Wilson sir i don't see why you should shoute at the president,why take
it personel immagrant just human like sir,
Despicable.
In our society, to call someone a liar is the height of insulting. GOP Rep. Joe Wilson, who obviously doesn't understand the word "dignified", sinks to a new low. Contrast his behavior to President Obama whose bipartisan speech brought class and dignity to the chamber tonight. When I think of Mr. Obama, I think of Jackie Robinson and the manner in which he changed minds into accepting that a man of his race could be one of the greatest sportmen of his time. So too, Mr. Obama is changing minds. With his speech tonight, he hit the proverbial ball out of the ballpark!
How ignorant and disrespectful can you get? This kind of behavior only reinforces most Americans' feelings about the republican party...disgusting!!!! The people of South Carolina must be mortified.
This is shameful,and disrespectful individual
It's Tool Time with Joe Wilson
Way to represent yourself, and your state, on National TV!
Welcome to Dirty South Carolina
And the man who makes it dirty!
To do what Congressman Wilson did is disgusting. There should be some respect shown in the Halls of Congress for the President of the United States. Is this the way Republicans want to be seen by the American people?
how childish, but considering he is from the south, it is to be expected. good ole boy sydrome is strong and well in the south. dumb dumber and dumbest politicans live there. not too many from the south , can see above their own selfish gains. they do not care about the people they serve. i have lived in the south and did not like it! they need to grow up and join the rest of the country!
Barack Obama is a liar. This is true.
What an embarrassment. He should be publicly proven wrong. The bill clearly states that no illegal immigrants are to receive benefits.
Joe Wilson is a confederate piece of garbage
Typical of these far fringe republican crazies.
"The time for bickering is over"
What do you expect? He's a Republican from South Carolina.
Wow, no class whatsoever. I hope you enjoy your final term in office.
Joe Wilson-what a low life
I hope he plans to apologize to the President for his rude outburst.
Ricardo Enriquez
What an incredibly rude thing to do. Having said that, it's nothing compared to what you see in the House of Commons in Great Britain. Many's the time, I'd wager, that Tony Blair or Gordon Brown wished they'd had it that easy.
Total lack of decorum. He should be ashamed of his actions and owes the President, is party, and the nation an apology. Even John McCain said this was out of line!
How embarrassing to be from South Carolina. What an idiot! Way to represent South Carolina!
I'm not surprised that it came from a White Rich Man from S. Carolina?
He's a fool and he demonstrates just another clown from South Carolina. I don't know who should secede first, Texas (my home state) or South Carolina. They both produce some reall classless folks.
I have never seen such disrepect for a President than I have seen from the Republicans tonight.Joe Wilson needs to be fired from his job... what a disgrace he is!! South Carolina should be ashamed of him!!
Totally disrespectful and totally out of line. I thought Obama accepted it well, knowing full well that the Republicans are idiots. I thought Pelosi and Biden were going to come out of their seats!!!
Yeah to McCain who also called Wilson disrespectful and recommended that he apologize!!!
Rep. Wilson, was completely out of line-disrespectful. He must have some financial interest or ties with the private insurance companies. I support Obama 100%
If he had heckled anywhere else.....he would have been thrown out. He was an embarrassment to this country before the entire world. His constituents should all get an immediate apology. Who does he think he is representing..... his children his in-laws, his wife, who?????
Congressman Joe Wilson should take John McCain's advice and apologize. And be happy he doesn't get disappeared like he would in other countries.
wilson should be kicked out of congress. This country has no place for scum.
I am not suprised. A GOP Rep calling the presdient a liar. I knew something like that could happen. I thought this was the president's chance to explain how he is planning to help the American people, but has usual the GOP finds a way to dirty the process. The President has a good heart, but he his powerful enemies within the GOP.
Tackless! Just as bad as the people shouting at townhalls.
Did anyone teach this heathen knave any manners? I am getting real tired of the rudeness of the neo-cons. If they can't get their way, they resort to bullying tactics and using "Mein Kampf" by Adolf Hitler as their playbook.
Boys and girls, Adolf Hitler, Benito Mussolini and Francisco Franco represent what the right-wing are all about. Do yourselves a favor and read history so that people like them don't get into power.
For once I agree with a Republican!!
And this tells you everything we need to know about Republicans and their willingness to engage in any type of credible dialogue. He should be censored for his total lack of respect to the President and the office,
I am listening to responses from various Republicans who are basically calling the President a liar. My understandingis that these bills are still being written, nothing has been passed. Republicans don't seem willing to negotiate unless they have it their way. The Republican way seems to be no health care reform period. I believe they went in determined to nit pick everything President Obama said and were determined not to agree with him and to remain negative. Rep. Wilson sealed their fate.
I'm not sure, but the heckler may be wrong, at least on that one issue. No illegals get health care from Medicare or Medicaid, but they do get basic emergency care through the Hill-Burton Act, requiring hospitals to provide uncompensated in emergencies. Is this the case?
Rude and Juvenile.
I am ashamed, as a proud citizen of South Carolina, to have that un-American man representing me. As a Republican, that is saying something.
what a jerk!
Joe Wilson, is very disrespectful a disgrace to his state and a loser.
Disgraceful. Another reason for not voting republican. They respect no one. The world is watching and a public figure disrespects the president of the United States.
he's an idiot
What a disgrace. This so called Congressman has no respect. Is this the person SC wants representing their state?
Classless idiot.
No wonder the health care debate has reached such disgusting lows.
Go Joe, keep Obama's feet to the fire. We need to read the final bill and call him out when what he said tonight is not in the bill.
disrespect
Is anyone surprised that a middle aged white guy from the south thinks its okay to yell and call the first AA POTUS a liar during a world wide televised address to Congress? Why do people continue to suggest that there is no element of racism at the base of the criticisms and opposition of Pres. Obama? Wilson's hate so overwhelmed him that he could not contain himself. So sad.
What a classless display of ignorance from an elected member of government during a formal address from the President of the United States. Unbelievable.
Yet another vivid and disturbing illustration of exactly how Republicans get "their job done"
Wilson, and the GOP as a whole embarrased themselves tonight. I have never seen a President treated with such disrespect ever. I hope the GOP enjoys the hole they dug for themselves tonight. They're gonna be in it for a long time to come.
Wilson is a disgrace to his constituents, the state of South Carolina and to the Congress. He should be ashamed of himself.
Good old South Carolina. Hey, how is your governor?
What an embarrassment for the GOP. Such a childish, immature outburst during a speech to a joint session of Congress. Is this what the GOP offers to America?
This is disgraceful. This idiot owes the President a VERY PUBLIC apology, NOW... When has any member of congress yelled out at THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES during a public address...
More proof that people think they can say anything to and about President Obama. I give everybody 3 guess as to why that is, and the first 2 don't count...
This needs to STOP RIGHT NOW...
Joe Wilson is an embarrassment to his party, congress and to all Americans...
It strikes me that if Wilson had done the same during a bush speech, he would've been dragged out in handcuffs.
Rep. Joe Wilson is an un-American, low class piece of garbage and the Republican party is clearly attempting to destroy civil discourse in this great country. They are a shameful group of sore losers who have obviously lost sight of how a DEMOCRACY should function for the greater good of the nation. He should be censured.
What happened to common courtesy? This man does not have the character to represent the American people if he can call the President of the United States a lier during a Joint Session of Congress. He can respectfully disagree with the President. He obviously doesn't feel he can debate on the merits if he stoops to such tactics.
A Huge part of Racism is lack of respect for someone of a different race!
This is clear that this PUNK is a blatant racist that needs to be stopped!!
Totally disrespectful! He should have been ejected from the assembly by Secret Service.
I hope Joe Wilson gets treatment for his Tourette's Syndrome using his insurance.
To God be the glory who knew the end even before the beginning that in those difficult times like this a leader will emerge to regain prestige and respect to every single Americain now all over the planet earth thanks to president Barack Obama.
Joe Wilson was very rude. you have no respect and is showing no good example to the younger generation.. This is your president you have shown the world how uneducated you are. respect yourself and control your tongue. we have have come along way from where you are. GROW UP.
You go Joe!!!!
It was disrespectful. But sometimes you have to call a Spade a Spade.
Yet another reason to be an embarrassed South Carolinian. What's worse, they'll take pride in it. For those that do, they are disrespectful idiots.
Stay classy GOP
The audacity of Rep. Wilson to inturrupt the State of the Union Speech!
How disrespectful to the Presidency. Not only has Wilson crowned himself as the "congressional heckler", yet shown that the republican party is filled with anger and fear of change with the hope that it can aid this country for the better. As stated by President Obama, "Time for bickering is over", therein Wilson has shown that he is not ready to stop bickering and work things out with logic, in a peaceful manner, with overall common sense.
Yet more proof that Class is priceless! You can take the boy out of the wild but you can't take the wild out of the boy. Joe, this is not some barnyard hoe-down...it's Congress for pete's sakes
A classless ignorant display of disrespect. I would expect such behavior from a child not a politician. South Carolianians should be embarrased to have such a representative.
Hopefully his constituents will be wise enough to recall him.
I suppose that the Republicans think it's good politics to shout insults at the President. Not only was Wilson childish and rude, but that level of disrespect aimed at a speaking President provides a model for those who would have us fail at democracy. The lesson: It's OK to disrespect the President, the Office of President, the Congress of the United States, the citizens viewing the speech, and the processes of democratic governance. Or, it's a Republican version of bi-partisan collaboration.
Shame on you. Rep. Wilson should be kicked out of the party. If the Republican Party does not do what is right and that is remove him as a member, then that party will never ever see my vote!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
What an IDIOT! Typical Republican for sure.
The fact that no one in Congress ever disrespected Bush (2nd) whilst in the middle of an Address to Congress despite their disagreement, shows restraint and respect for the Office of the Presidency. It was only when Bush went to Iraq where a shoe was tossed at him. We in the States found that to be a serious offense. To yell "You Lie" whilst the President is speaking is just as offensive as having a shoe tossed at your face! Joe Wilson needs to be REMOVED from office!
Did we ever hear anyone cry out "LIAR" during one of GW's speeches? We all know he lied to our faces! Very disrespectful and let's see if the Reeeps will denounce such behavior and separate themselves from Wilson.....after all...if so much as a weatherman says its gonna rain and it doesn't...Pres. Obama gets called to the carpet!
Such a sad display of hated from an elected official!
It's no time to soon to start the "calling out!"
Good old Joe must have been attending many of the town hall meetings on Health Care, or he is looking for a job at FOX News. GOP keeps disrespecting the office of the President.
Very disrepectful...he owes the President a public apology.
Joe Wilson of South Carolina is an embarrassment to our country and himself. As my father always told me, there is a weak cow in every herd.
Congressman Joe Wilson from South Carolina showed the world tonight how IGNORANT he is!!!!!
I have never seen a Congressman or Senator Democrat or Republican Ever disrespect the President of the US in chamber.
The people of South Carolina should be embarrassed.
Instead of participating in the health care debate he needs to take ETIQUETTE classes immediately.
No respect for the president! It appears he get treated like the dirt we walk on, is it because he's black? and a black president?
You are the most dishonest person in America that I have ever seen. I just want you to know with that disrespectful unAmerican remark yelled out during a speach from the highest leader in the world. I will be heading down to your state to fight against you during your re-election.
Between this and the crazy claims about President Obama's speech to kids about hard work, the Republicans have not covered themselves with glory. What an embarassment.
Classy. Very, Very classy. There are no words.
You know in this life time, whenever someone wants to try and help everybody we have a hot head from of course South Carolina to call the President of the United States a LIAR.
Senator, if ypu were to look back in your pass and probably now , how many lies has you told to get ahead. A least we know Obama is looking out for the best of all the people. He does not care if you are black, white, jewish, spanish, greek, indian, scotish, african, you name the nationality he just want as much healthcare for everyone. Senator you need to help us clean South Carolina, we have a governor ( Mark Sandford) who has lied to us and left us. What do you have to say to him. You see you must clean your own front door before you can clean another person back door, Mr. Wilson we will make sure you are re-elected.
Wilson- You should be ashamed of yourself. Honest debate is one thing. Absolute disrespect is another.
Tell Joe Wilson to start looking for a new Job. Americans don't need a disrespectful fool like him in Washington.
1930s - Republicans oppose Social Security... "will lead this country into communism". Not a single yes vote. 1960s - Republicans oppose Medicare ... "will kill private insurance" ... "government takeover".
Not a single yes vote. Neither allegations were true or became true. Which program does your grandparents want to get rid of? How about the Socialist/Marxist PUBLIC school you went to? or the Socialist/Marxist Public Fire Dept? Socialist/Marxist Public Library? Police Dept? Armed Services? All Government run. None of them have run any private enterprise "out of business".
The Public Option is just that, AN OPTION.
Dow we want to fall for the same scare tactics and bogus claims from the people who wanted to kill and still want to kill Social Security or Medicare?
Not appropriate. People of South Carolina, what do you say of this?
I'm glad I don't live in South Carolina, especially in his district. If I did, I would move. I agree with Senator McCain.
I agreed with John McCain
Joe Wilson was totally disrespectful and that won't do their party any good.
Joe should be ashamed of himself and does not deserve the right to be called Senator anything. A true American Idiot!!
Rep. Wilson, ironically, outlines exactly what Obama mentioned he is fighting against. Is responding "you lie" to debunking rumors all that the Republicans will ever think of?
He is an idiot
Wow, a new low even for Republicans. He needs to apologize or always be known as the disrespectful loser in The House of Representatives.
Just more proof that Republicans don't deserve a seat at the adult table in this debate and legislation.
Not only should he apologize but should do so very publically. I am sure his mother would be ashamed as should his entire constituentancy. Pathetic.
Whether you agree with the POTUS or not, it is extremely disrespectful to shout out "Liar". Even if you dont like him, you still respect the office. Too bad he wont be disciplined.
Rep. Wilson should be ashamed.
President Barack Obama has just expressed in his message, to the Members of Congress,what the conscients of America yearns to say to her political leaders in reference to health care for her citizens.
Once again, this young and brilliant American leader has spoken for his people pleaded with the politicians and the cooperation to be their brothers and sisters' keepers.
I hope and pray that the persons to whom he was speaking and pleading were listening with the ears of God.
UmValli
If Obama wants a Canadian style health care system then opponents should be allowed to grieve opposition out loud during public political discussion just like we do here in Canada.
Shame beyond words!
This is a vile human being. There is no excuse for this behavior. He should represent no one!!!
What an embarrassment to the nation! South Carolina should be ashamed of their representation. I don't care if he apologizes, he has shown his character and been found wanting. If there is justice in this nation, his career will fizzle and he will be unceremoniously tossed out of office next year.
Breaking news,Breaking news. Where was this "news". For Sure it wasn't on Cnn. I never saw Rep. Wilso's face or name,yet all I get ON Cnn is breaking news, breaking news.
I think the republicans lost more than they gained tonight. The total disrepect shown towards the man and the office demonstrates just how disfunctional and low they have become. Makes me sick to think they were actually elected.
This is totally uncalled for. People need to get a grip. Anger stiffles debate.
This is what the great party of Lincoln has stooped to. They are nothing more than playground bullies and foul mouthed dimwits blinded by their overpowering hate.
Wilson can kiss his you know what good bye. Ignorance and arrogance will not support a wanna be who thinks it was cute but quickly find out from his own, not so cute. You are out of here.
I hope he does not get re-elected...our state is FOREVER in the news for some IGNORANCE...but what do you expect when you are in one of the most racist states in the nation.
That was DISRESPECTFUL Im glad the President didnt stoop to his level. even CNN said that the plan will not cover illegal imigrants but they have to be seen in the EMERGENCY ROOM.
Wilson should apologize on his way to the airport to pick up his 1 way ticket to the most distant point planes fly-Iran, N. Korea, might be good choices!! As a S. Carolinian I would gladly contribute to his plane fare. Wilson, you just outdid our "esteemed Gov." in your idiocy.
Wilson is the first punk President Obama should call out. IDIOT!!!
republicans everywhere should be embarrased with their leader's behavior tonight! Grow up!
YES! Is all I can say. Someone has COURAGE to tell the TRUTH!
How can anyone sit there and listen to Obama Lying and not do what this courageous man did. Our Founding Fathers would be so proud!
Look at the face of the little boy on the left. Did these guy's every get out of middle school?
He's right. Obama is a liar.
This response simply shows how little respect some have for our President. How Sad...
Hey Mr. Congressional heckler, you should go work for FOX NEWS. You don't belong here. Here it's only for grown ups. Shame on you Sir!!! Shameeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
Shame on this guy! Disrespectful to his president, his congress, and his country. This is not democracy. Don't abuse your right.
MH from Canada
Well this is what republicans have come to...we know that they are callous and low class and this jerk proves it...he is seeing his health care and drug money slip away....if someone had done that to bush they would have had the Sgt of Arms pick them up and throw them in jail...
So if he shows no respect...let us show HIM NO RESPECT. Lets flood him with emails, letters and phone calls and write letters to the papers in his state.
this man should apologize on live TV and directly to the president. Regardless of your beliefs, he is the president, and deserves the upmost respect!
As crass, mean and ugly as Rep. Joe Wilson (R of SC) was tonight, he accurately portrayed the soul of the republican party. He is what they are.
Completely uncalled for, ignorant and disrespectful. This was not the place for his ranting. Idiotic move on his part.
Shouting...the next best thing to being right.
It seems that at every turn representatives from my State seek to embarrass themselves and their co-residents. I am ashamed this man represents anyone from South Carolina.
Has the line now, finally, been crossed? Okay media... Now call this out for what it is.
What a moron. That was really acting responsible and adult like.
cong.wilson 's outburst,is the worse thing i have heard in the congress to a president. SHAME ON YOU ,SIR .you do not deserve to to be allowed in the sacred hall of congress, democrat or republican
What a mess the Republican party has become.
Obama really truly "scared" us. But, let's examine similar policies in Canada, England and Australis, and listen to their citizens.
Disrepsectful Jerk!
Disgusting! The proper protocol and title for Members of Congress is: "Honorable".
Joe Wilson (R-SC) does NOT deserve to be called "Honorable" by anyone! He showed no honor tonight; even if he disagreed, he should have done as all other Republicans in the chamber did – keep quiet!
Seriously? How old are you to be heckling in the middle of a speech? You consider yourself a congressman? I thought that required maturity but apparently not. You just proved the President's point and made yourself and your state look bad.
So a Democrat has never done that before. The President is still in a dream world and still doesn't know how to do his job.
Unfortunately, a lot of these Republicans are idiots and liars themselves.
This was the most disrespectable act to a President by an elected official I have ever witnessed and SHOULD NOT BE TOLERATED! It is this type of behavior that has brought us to this state in our nation. Sen. Wilson should be reprimanded for his action and made an example of a no tolerance of this type of behavior especially during a NATIONAL ADDRESS .!
Joe Wilson is a redneck and his constituents are rednecks. What else do you expect other than Wal-Mart behavior?
Totally disrepectful. It's one thing to disagree with the President's position on an issue, but an outburst such as this shows disrespect toward the Office of the President, sends a bad signal to the youth of our country, and is completely unprofessional. Representative Wilson should be sanctioned for his outburst.
Oh my how some people will do to get recognized. Ramble rousing behavior at a dignified assembly of lawmakeers is totally unaccepetabe.
wow that is just disrespectful!
What an idiot! And you have the gall to call yourself a congressman. Shame on you. Shame on you!
That's the one part where I wish Obama would've turned and said "show me where in the bill that I say illegal immigrants are covered"
I guess this was the wrong forum to do that in.. but that's what should've been said. I read the bill, and it specifically says that it only covers legal residents. I'm sure some will fall through the cracks.. Doctors won't turn away an illegal immigrant if he's in the emergency room on the verge of death.. but in general.. the bill does not cover illegal immigrants.
What is wrong with the Republicans of South Carolina??....first Sanford and now this idiot!!
This guy is pathetic.
shame on Joe Wilson. Some role model! (not) If he is re-elected it will be a statement about the people of South Carolina.
How proud the Palmetto State must be tonight of its goober Congressman.
I'm one South Carolinian who now wishes to hide from the rest of my nation for the leaders who can somehow still make the news. As a concerned citizen I ask my representatives one thing and one thing only, please stop embarrassing me!!
Rep. Joe Wilson is a total discrace.After 8 years of Repulbican control with nothing achieved and their support of a divided nation..what else can you expect. They left the country in a complete mess and take no responsibility for all our problems. At least this President has tackeled tough issues and seems to care about its citizens. I think a nation should be judged on how it treats the lesser among us, not the ones on top. We have money for war but not for the things that would life easier for most of us. At least this man seems to care about the people that need the most help.
A complete moron if there ever was one.
why are the republicans so filled with hate
are they sore losers?
or just losers
I agree that is was disrespectful, but I also felt like it was disrespectful for the dems to act the way they did toward President Bush. Once again it seems a double standard is in place.
I'm a Republican but this is totally wrong.
I think it's very disrespectful for an elected member of congress to heckle the president of the united state while speaking in front of a joint session of congress. I wonder if the president's skin had anything to do with that.
Rep Wilson should be Impeached if there is such a thing.
Joe - Shame on you!!!
Funny how this guy never yelled anything while Bush and Cheney were lying through their teeth about the supposed wmd of Iraq. He just sat quietly while approving billions of dollars for that budget busting war!
But now we have a president who is actually working for the common citizens of this country and he just can't stand it!!! What a joke on the hardworking citizens of SC. I for one will NEVER be a Republican again!!!
Real class act that Joe Wilson.
Clearly Obama has caused more division than President Bush ever did. No one has respect for this President anymore. He has angered people to a point where they can't even stay quiet in a stump speech to congress.
How immature. There's a time and a place. I hope he loses all credibility if he had any to begin with.
If the Dems booed and heckled Bush during a speech he was giving to a full chamber like that, they would have been demonized by every media outlet. It was disrespectful. We don't have to agree, but you don't have to be so disrespectful.
It is unfortunate to see a man elected as a repub. rep. behave in a reprehensible manner in the chamber. He sounded like a terrorist to us, w/ seething fury in his eyes, as depicted in the photo.
The security should have bundled him out, and he should be forced to attend anger managemant classes and see a shrink at the same time or sooner than later, if he wants to stay in public business.
This man Wilson is a disgrace to the office he holds. If he is unable to have civil discourse without resorting to the chants of an uneducated child then he has no place in public office. How childish and how unamerican!
That tacky Republican should be removed from office and never be allowed in the chamber again.
This man needs to be censured NOW. This scum has no place in politics. He needs to be run out on a rail.
At best, he's a bigot. I don't mean to slur all white males from the south, but if someone's going to do what he did tonight, they would have his bio.
Republican Joe Wilson is a big, fat, digruntled Republican who thinks he's got a right to heckle....what a jerk!!
Joe Wislon is a fool.... Racist....
Highly disrespectful, and he should not only apologize but step down.
What a clown this Joe Wilson is. He should be ashamed of himself, but my guess is that a guy who would do that is incapable of feeling shame.
He should be ashamed of himself. You don't have to like Obama's policies – you don't even have to like the man. But he IS the president of the United States and deserves our respect. It's the American way.
Congressman Wilson's web site is currently unaccessable! I wonder how that happened? Just goes to show you that those who are elected officials, by their actions, have no right to be making such important decions for this country.
What nerve does Joe Wilson have to call the President a "Lier"...What happened to respect of the President weather you agree with him or not. He has shown nothing but disrespect....When former Presidents have said things that people did not agree or did not make any sence, no one ever call the President a "Lier"....What a great way to show kids in America how to show respect for the office of the President.
I almost bet if the president was either White or a Republican, those words would have never been said.....
Joe Wilson is one of the most disrespectful people I have ever set my eyes on. I hope his state never vote for him again, he doesnt deserve to be where he's at.....Oh but he's a white republican man, I guess that will never happen....Get over the prejudice, it's 2009.
Wilson should be at a MINIMUM be censured. Thugs like him do not belong in the US House of Representatives. His behaviour tonight, regardless of politics was a disgrace to the Congress and to the United States.
Does freedom of speech end with speeches to congress? No apology necessary! McCain should apologize to Joe Wilson for him (McCain) adding his 2 cents! I believe in a town hall not too long ago that he (McCain) was not that enthusiastic about the Obama bill either! McCain seems to change his spots whenever the situation demands. Mr. Wilson represents that Republicans are leaders not followers! Way to go, SC! Joe Wilson is a keeper! We need someone in government who is not intimitated and is not afraid to speak up and out. God Bless South Carolina Republicans and God Bless the Red, White and Blue!
Apparently respect for the Office of the President only applies to white Republicans. Joe Wilson is a thug. Here's hoping the voters in his district have the good sense to send him packing in next year's midterm elections.
This man is an embarrassment to the United States. He obviously does not understand democracy, decency or civility. Like in sports, he should be banned for a period of time from Congress.
Sen. Durbin,
I think Joe will be just fine!
As a former marine who served uder several presidents , Republicans and democrats. I Never made my thoughts clear about any, and Never disrespected any President whom I served under so tonight hearing the the disrespect during a national address was appalling to me.
What is being made of our country?
The country needs to get back its moral compass and start treating
each with respect.
Shame on the representative from South Carolina!!! How utterly disrespectful and un-American! What lesson he is teaching the next generation by yelling at the President of the United States of America. Have we come to this that we can't respect our leader - whether we agree with his policies, ideologies, and beliefs. It is an egregious outrage. He should apologize immediately!!
Absolutely ridiculous behavior, the likes of which I've never seen before.
South Carolina will probably overtake Louisiana as the "sespool" of the south after tonight. WOW!!!!!
What else can you expect from a fear monger? His nonprofessional shouting and ignorance are a clear view of his party leadership. When are they going to get it? Many Americans like myself are watching and listening.
a complete douche this guy just lost his job another one bites the dust nice would republicans keep up the good work
Senator McCain is correct, that is completly disrespectful. There were many times former President Bush made false allegations, and lies in front of the Congress, and the American people. Never did a Congress Person scream "Liar!" That was the worst example of disrespect I have ever seen.
Rep. Wilson,
Millions of Americans watching their Commander-in-Chief speak to them tonight were abruptly interrupted by your rude and disrespectful comment when you called our President a liar. May I remind you sir, you work for us. We pay your salary. By disrespecting our President, you disrespected me and the American people who have elected our President. Above all, you disrespected the body of government who you are a member of and serve. I have serious reservations that you have any bit of respect for this great institution but if you do, you owe me, the President, and every American an apology- immediately! In the words of Senator McCain, “"totally disrespectful - [there's] no place for it in that setting or any other and he should apologize immediately." Yes Sir, that is your party’s Presidential nominee calling you out! Shame on you for bringing shame to SC!
I would like to see Joe Wilson come up with a better plan for health care. I bet you he couldn't. I am just happy that President Obama is actually trying to better the United States of America and it's citizens.
Truly disgusting. This man Wilson is no leader, but an embarrassment to himself and his constituency.
Wilson is an idiot and is living proof of the results of electing rednecks to public office.
I see why SC doesn't get any of my money...I don't even want to visit this backwood hillbilly town. No respect..what do you expect from a State that has a philandering Governor....and now a disrespectful Senator...GA, MS, LA, AL....same fate. If I lived in his State I would be knocking on doors right now to remove the likes of him out of government. AND If SC isn't embarassed for him....I'm EMBARASSED FOR HIM AND THEM! IGNORANT! I bet he would be the first person to scream about RIGHTS.
Actually it's funny that he is8 years too late to the party...His remarks would have been quite beneficial for the Bush Administration when they went exploring for WMDs. Get real..Get him out of office NOW!
Sometimes too much freedom of speech is disrespectfu.It is ashame to see a rep. to behave like somebody with no manners. It is America
New Poll:
66% Approval.
21% Aginni.
(and we know who THEY are). tee hee
Just when I thought I knew the names of most of the more tactless, bigotted Republicans, along comes this clown. I'm embarrassed for the good people of S. Carolina
Shame on you congressman. Shame on you! Apologize and go sit in the corner.
South Carolina ... typical.
Joe Wilson was just the most egregious of the Republicans... Far too many of them were just sitting on their hands during the address. The Republican party is giving a whole new meaning to mean-spirited.
I agree with Rep. Wilson's sentiment, but I believe he was totally out of line in his conduct.
As far as Durbin's comment? That's the same guy who said on the Senate floor that US Marines were like Nazis, and Durbin didn't pay any price, so his opinion is meaningless to me.
In 8 years of George W Bush, as much as he was loathed as leader of our nation for his choices, democrats NEVER heckled him during a speech. There was still a level of professionalism that was upheld. You don't have to agree or like the President, but the fact remains they are still the President of the United States. Perhaps Wilson thought he was at a comedy club and Chris Rock was up there.
Why should this guy be punished? Freedom of speech. Why is it any different from Dems booing Bush during his speechs? Obama is lying, illegal imigrants already get free health care in the US. I applaud Joe Wilson and I'm not even a Republican, I'm one of those guys wishing I could get my vote back from last year. Nothing but LIES!
Even at the height of George Bush's unpopularity, he was never NEVER heckled by the Democrats during a speech. For Congressmen to act so childish, so disrespectful, so...evil says something about the Country in which we live today. Basically it was a speech about how we should all work together for the benefit of the Country, and the Republicans wouldn't even applaud for that. Very, very callous. Very, very sad.
Rep. Wilson should be censored by the house for his behavior tonight.
Speaker Pelosi is too kind.
The South Carolina redneck, knuckle-dragging Wilson should be sanctioned.
What a complete idiot. It is precisely this type of petulence displayed by the republican party that makes them despised.
desperate and without useful ideas, all they could do is name-call in the most immature and embarrassing way. Republicans know their goose is cooked on this issue.
I cannot believe that Rep.Joe Wilson would be so disrespectful to shout and call "Our President" a lie during his speech! Who the hell does he think he is? Why don't folks like him just open up and be honest. I don't believe he would have said that if he were disagreeing with George Bush during a speech. His comment was inappropriate and especially in that setting. People like Joe Wilson should just admit, he said it because he felt it was ok, because our President is a black man, someone he has been taught he does not have to respect!
He represents my district...I'm ashamed. (Then again, SC hasn't had much to be proud of lately...)
Can we get that loon censured? Since when is it appropriate for a member of the Congress to heckle the President by calling him a liar during a joint address? If this had been a Democrat doing that to W, they would have been exiled, hung upside down ...on a cross, and set on fire. Where is the outrage? What happened to all of the "You have to respect the POTUS?" bull? Guess it doesn't count for a black Democrat, right?
The heckler is an embarassment to his district. He should resign in favor of someone who knows how to disagree without sounding like a zoo animal.
I've never seen such behavior during a presidential address to congress.
Sen. Dick Durbin is wrong, Rep. Joe Wilson will not pay a price for his crude, disrespectful outburst during the president's address. He will be hailed by all the media wing-nuts like Glenn Beck and Sean Hannity as a great "patriot" for having the "courage to speak his convictions".
I am glad there are still some decent Republican members like McCain and Snowe who will try to show some decency and can still work as the LOYAL opposition. However, the villification of President Obama by so many of the Republican members of Congress is a disgrace. They are paid to serve as members of Congress and I would hope they would do more to earn their pay then just saying "no" to everything the president proposes.
i was appalled by this elected official who i feel very strongly was unprofessional and disrespectful. it was totally inappropriate. i grew up in sc and the people of sc should be outraged and embarrassed of this individual's behavior.
A new hero for Rush and Glenn, and another pathetic excuse for a human being. The vile behavior of the right makes it clear that they no longer have any core principles. They cannot argue without screaming because once voices are lowered and mob tactics are suspended, they have nothing at all to say.
Grow up Rep. Wilson, you are in Capitol Hill for Christ sake! It will be an ugly thing to watch you get grilled in the coming days and weeks. You will ultimately have to apologize and say what kind of moron you are, don't worry we already know.
Wilson is in TRUE REPUBLICAN PATHETIC FORM.
Utterly shameful! Beyond rude. How can one of our lawmakers act in such a despicable manner? I am thoroughly disgusted!
How low class and disrespectful this outburst was! The hatred from the right is starting to boil over and these people are getting desperate.
As bad as Bush was, no Democrat ever shouted out he was a liar.
Another rageful Nopubulican LOSER!!!
I was shouting "you're a liar" at the exact same time and thought it went right through the tv. Scared me for a minute!
This disrespect is becoming the "norm" for the New Republican Party.
Look at what is going on in the town meetings! It is a sad that opposing opinions cannot be exchanged in a dignified manner
What is it with South Carolina? Normal rules of behavior don't apply?
Even under Bush I would think that anything like that during a presidential speech to Congress would be out of line and completely disrespectful. I would like the Representative to point out the line that would guarantee benefits for illegals; oh wait! It specifically prohibits illegal aliens from participating in the program! Too bad they never taught the representative how to read in South Carolina...
Agree to disagree but how dare he disrespect our President.. Public apology is in order.
Joe Wilson
are you serious? Grow up!
My God! How low can we go? During a joint Session, shouting at our Commander in Chief "You are a LIAR"??? During wartime???
This Congressperson should be investigated as a terrorist!!
Representative Wilson's outburst on the floor of Congress tonight was nothing short of an outrage. Regardless of ones' political affiliation or opinion regarding the President's health care proposal, there is no place for such conduct. I am stunned that a representative of our state would call our President a "liar" on the hallowed floor of Congress under any circumstance. This cavalier attack was a humiliating embarassment to the citizens of South Carolina and compromises the integrity of each and every citizen that Mr. Wilson represents. For a state already embroiled in scandal, the timing could not have been worse.
An unequivical apology is in certain order, and should be issued immediately. There is absolutely no question that this incident will weigh heavy on the minds of voters in South Carolina. We should not tolerate such reckless unprofessionalism.