(CNN) - President Barack Obama may have one less problem to worry about.
A federal judge on Thursday dismissed a lawsuit that claimed Obama is ineligible to be president because he isn't a bona fide U.S. citizen.
The lawsuit represented the claim by the so-called "birthers" movement that Obama was not born in Hawaii - despite a birth certificate to the contrary - or that if he was, his citizenship was invalidated by living overseas as a child.
In a 30-page ruling, U.S. District Judge David O. Carter of California said his court lacked the jurisdiction to rule on a case intended to unseat a sitting president.
Carter's ruling said the plaintiffs were trying to persuade him to "disregard the constitutional procedures in place for the removal of a sitting president."
"The process for removal of a sitting president - removal for any reason - is within the province of Congress, not the courts," the ruling said.
Carter's ruling also noted that the plaintiffs "have attacked the judiciary, including every prior court that has dismissed their claim, as unpatriotic and even treasonous for refusing to grant their requests and for adhering to the terms of the Constitution."
"Respecting the constitutional role and jurisdiction of this court is not unpatriotic," the ruling said. "Quite the contrary, this court considers commitment to that constitutional role to be the ultimate reflection of patriotism."
Where were the birthers when Bush was starting frivolous wars in the middle east and running up our national debt. They are 2 terms 2 late!
A more appropriate response from the judge would have been to throw this idiotic 'birther' in a mental institution.
Of couse no judge will rule on this because they are all afraid of losing the job and the good pay. OBAMA SHOULD NOT BE PRESIDENT.--–if he was born in the USA then why doesn,t he publish or show his real birth certificate. Not the laser printed one or a birth anouncement from the paper laser printers were not around in 1961
It's people like this that make me question democracy. But alas, even idiots deserve their opinion.
I would suggest that some of these "birthers" are so uneducated, that they probably don't recognize Hawaii is one of the 50 states. They are an entirely irrational and totally emotional herd, content with following the pin headed pied pipers of political talk radio quacks.
I did not vote for Obama, but this is abuse of our judiciary system.
It is ridiculous that any foreign visitor can fly in as a tourist or walk across the boarder and give birth to a baby, who immediately becomes a US citizen, while President Obama's citizenship is being ridiculed.
Can these birthers be tried for treason?
So only the congress can unseat him for not being a US citizen? Thats ok, we will take this up first thing when we take back control of congress in 2010. FIRST THING. There are reasons for not having a resident alien as president. The proof is obamas sympathy for islam and his interest in seeing islamic insurgents defeat our military. That is the reason for his delay in deploying more troops. A photo-op saluting the caskets of returning heros killed by obamas people does not fool us. Tick tick tick
Gee the birthers where not following the constitution? Wow arent they the ones that make such a big deal out of it to begin with. They should take all these nut jobs and lock them in the looney bid so they won't hurt themselves or others. What a waste of the court system.
Obama HAS produced a birth certificate, but these nuts don't care. To the ignoramus above, "socialist" healthcare is not "against the constitution". It was GW Bush who was illegally GIVEN the Presidency, Obama won fair and square. Finally, he has nothing to hide, it only looks that way because all these racist nuts are throwing everything at him that they can drag up. Just part of the GOP tantrum.
It's about time that this childish, birthers, crap be laid to rest, its long overdue in my opinion! Maybe the judge should bring charges against all of these halfwits for wasting the courts time with these farce,and fact free, frivilous, lawsuits!!!!
Some people just will not let this go. One comment said it would be simple for Obama to just settle this by showing us his birth certificate LOL! Do these people even read the articles they are commenting on? HE HAS SHOWN US HIS BIRTH CERTIFICATE!!!!!!!!! Good grief.
It is just unbelievable that people can be so racist and hateful. So much for being "pro-life" when all these conservative birthers do is hate on everybody.
Please, birthers, get over yourselves.
Better yet, why don't you people leave this country, and go start your own racist nation somewheres else. Far away, where the rest of us don't have to deal with you.
The Court should file a suit against these idiots for wasting the Courts time. I hope they had to pay some serious Court fees!
What a WASTE of time and money! And the same birthers criticize Obama for needless spending?? I am ashamed these birthers call themselves American!
What is next? Your lawsuits about the earth being flat and we are not children of evolution?
Quite clearly anyone who plays THAT much golf is by definition a US citizen whether or not he can produce a birth certificate. Check the constitution, it's in the fine print.
But don't you see? President Obama is guilty of "presidenting while black." That's what the birthers are really upset about?
The Republican party has a long and proud tradition, but it is allowing itself to be completely dragged through the mud by the assortment of morons that are taking center stage. Time to purge the party and regain some decency and common sense. This kind of stuff, Palin, Evangelical Christian right wing conservatives are destroying the party.
Why won't the court rule if the birth certificate is valid? That is the question nothing else.
Gosh when is all this crop going to stop!
All those loney bins A.K.A as rethuglicansits about time they get a life
They are burning up with jealousy.Lol
R U 4 Real?
What a waste of time and money! This is why the Republicans have not credibility for me....whether I agree or disagree with Obama, Republican hypocrites are the worst.
Will the morons who still believe that the birth certificate hasn't been made public LEAVE the country? We don't need any more of you idiots in the U.S.
The valid (or *legal*) Hawaiian birth certificate for Pres. Obama HAS been released to the public AND independently verified as such by state officials in HI and the Annenberg Public Policy Center in PA.
as one who has followed the issue for a long time, I'd like to inform the 'people' that Obama's COLB posted on the internet are forgeries.
The media has lied to you. Obama has not shown his B.C. The one they hold up has a major flaw as a copy of the real deal.. The Hawaii emboss seal. The one item that CAN'T be duplicated. Go to Factcheck and get a look at the seal.
Can you read Department of Health State of Hawaii?
The current inhabitants in the WH thinks you are all dupe's, are you?
Obama has produced his birth certificate..........and the Governor of Hawaii has certified it ...WHAT MORE DO YOU Idoits want !!!!! Let's see the leader of the pack has a foreign accent....maybe they 're not a U.S. citizen.
Glad the judge realizes his constitutional limits – he's right, the constitution lays out how to remove a president – impeachment. I would that all judges would be constrained and let our representatives represent.