December 29th, 2009
05:18 PM ET
10 months ago

Bristol Palin-Levi Johnston child custody fight goes public

An Alaska judge has denied Bristol Palin's request that her court fight with ex-boyfriend Levi Johnston over custody of their son be kept private to avoid a 'media circus.'
An Alaska judge has denied Bristol Palin's request that her court fight with ex-boyfriend Levi Johnston over custody of their son be kept private to avoid a 'media circus.'

(CNN) - An Alaska judge has denied Bristol Palin's request that her court fight with ex-boyfriend Levi Johnston over custody of their son be kept private to avoid a "media circus."

The daughter of former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin is seeking full custody of 1-year-old Tripp, contending that Johnston is too immature to be a responsible father and that his mother's felony drug conviction makes her a danger to the child.

Bristol Palin filed for full custody in November, but Johnston is seeking shared custody. Both parents are 19. Their teenage relationship fell under an intense public spotlight after Sen. John McCain picked Sarah Palin as his vice presidential running mate in August 2008.

Court documents, now unsealed, were published online Monday by the Anchorage Daily News.

Johnston joined the family at the Republican National Convention after the campaign confirmed that Bristol, then 17, was five months pregnant with his child. The couple broke off their engagement about two months after their son's birth in December 2008.

He has asked that the case conducted in public to protect him from Sarah Palin, whom he said was "powerful, politically ambitious and has a reputation for being extremely vindictive." But Bristol Palin's request that the case be sealed said public proceedings "will turn this custody case into a media circus which is not in Tripp's best interest."

"In this day and age of the Internet, media stories remain available for years, even decades, after they are first published, and anything printed in the media (whether it is true or not) will be available to Tripp when he is old enough to read," Palin said in a sworn affidavit.

She said Johnston wanted a public case so he could "continue to make a spectacle of this custody dispute for his own self-promotion." Johnston was set to take part in a reality show in Alaska, she said.

"I do not believe that it would be in Tripp's best interest for Levi's reality show to be filming this case as it unfolds, or for Levi Johnston to be capitalizing off of this custody case through his reality show," Palin said.

Johnston's sworn statement said he feared what Sarah Palin might do against him if the case were kept secret.

"I really think that closing the court could make this matter very uncivil and potentially open the door for poor influences on Bristol and her attorney that may be extremely inappropriate and potentially harmful to Tripp," he said.

While Johnston said his former girlfriend would never be malicious toward him, "her mother is powerful, politically ambitious and has a reputation for being extremely vindictive."

"So, I think a public case might go a long way in reducing Sarah Palin's instinct to attack and allow the real parties in this litigation, Bristol and I, to work things out a lot more peacefully than we could if there is any more meddling from Sarah Palin," Johnston said.

Bristol Palin's affidavit said her mother is not involved in the custody case, except as a grandmother. But Johnston's lawyer, Rex Butler, said in his own affidavit that his client does not trust closed proceedings because "Sarah Palin is known to deal forcefully with those she perceives as political enemies."

"He feels Sarah Palin, through her lawyer, under the guise of Bristol Palin's name, would run rough shod over his very bones," Butler said.

The judge's ruling, signed last week, concludes that Bristol Palin "failed to demonstrate that this case involves 'matters of a sensitive and highly personal nature' of such a magnitude that 'protection of the party's name outweighs the public's interest in disclosure.' "

Her filing for full custody argued that Levi was "not ready for the demands of parenthood and the sacrifices that would entail to a 19-year-old aspiring actor/model."

"Levi remains without a regular job or steady source of income," the petition states. While he's not enrolled in school "to learn a trade or earn a degree," he has made money by selling stories about his son and the Palins to news outlets and engaged in "risque modeling for Playgirl magazine," it states.

The photos published last month showed Johnston in semi-nude poses, not with the full frontal nudity that's Palin's filing cited.

The petition cited a series of messages posted on the online social network Twitter.com as evidence that Johnston "may have substance abuse issues, based on statements he has made about seeking 'weed.' "

Johnston's response said he does not have a Twitter account "and has made no such statements about the use of marijuana."

But Palin's harshest attack was on Levi's mother, Sherry Johnston, who pleaded guilty to a felony drug charge earlier this year.

Palin asked that the paternal grandmother be barred from having any unsupervised visitation with Tripp. Her petition said she "may re-offend, keep medications around the house which could be accessible to the baby, have illegal drug users come to the house (or she could take the baby in her car during a drug sale)."

Palin also said that since Sherry Johnston "could fall asleep or be too drowsy to appropriately monitor the baby."

"She is also a chronic pain patient and undergoes daily, regular and sustained narcotic infusions," Palin's petition said.

Johnston's response said his mother's "chronic pain condition is currently being managed in coordination with the Department of Corrections."

"Sherry Johnston will not be left to take care of the minor child alone, but will simply be there to assist to the best of her ability," Johnston's filing said.

She was released from an Alaska prison last week to serve the remainder of her three year sentence under house arrest at her Wasilla, Alaska home. She must wear an ankle bracelet for electronic monitoring, Corrections Department spokesman Richard Schmitz said.


Filed under: Bristol Palin • Levi Johnston
soundoff (64 Responses)
  1. Bob44

    Any child would be happier and thrive better with BOTH parents having equal custody - even an idiot like him and a ditz like her. I only hope HIS parents are a little less phony.

    December 29, 2009 08:37 pm at 8:37 pm |
  2. Proud American

    OK so the kid has a drug dealer and a Moron for Grandmother's. Boy I would sure hate to be the judge in this case. This is going to be difficult.

    December 29, 2009 08:37 pm at 8:37 pm |
  3. Dallas TX

    Good for you Levi. Silly Sarah always want to do things undercover away from the media unless it benefits her. From what I've read, Bristol and her brother were involved in drugs also. What makes Bristol think her white trash family is any better than Levi's family?

    December 29, 2009 08:54 pm at 8:54 pm |
  4. just saying

    Good for Levi. Sarah is at her most devious, vindictive, conniving, and cowardly back-stabbing self behind the scenes (i.e. twitter/facebook) and Johnston knows it! Now she will have to behave, or prove once and for all that she is indeed all of the above.

    December 29, 2009 08:59 pm at 8:59 pm |
  5. David in Indiana

    The Public is fascinated with train wrecks. S.P. is another reason to support term limits for every level of government.

    Give the people what they want!

    December 29, 2009 09:00 pm at 9:00 pm |
  6. Jenn, Philadelphia

    What exactly is CNN's obsession with all things Palin? This is not news. Unless CNN wants to be the new Enquirer.

    December 29, 2009 09:12 pm at 9:12 pm |
  7. Pragmatic

    Tripp is really much too young to mind the media circus ... he'll sleep right though it ... Palin didn't mind parading the young, unmarried mother and the boyfriend to her family values voters. Funny how "abstinence only" education works ... Not!

    December 29, 2009 09:20 pm at 9:20 pm |
  8. I saw this listed as entertainment on the CNN site

    leave it there, this has nothing to do with news

    December 29, 2009 09:27 pm at 9:27 pm |
  9. Richard in California

    I blame Senator McCain for all of this. Had he not been off his rocker when he chose Palin as his running mate, against all his advisors' recommendations, none of this would have ever come out, because no one would have cared. The collective intelligence of the American people would have not gone down by an IQ point or two.

    December 29, 2009 09:29 pm at 9:29 pm |
  10. darke812

    thankfully we have these wonderful people preaching to us above how to live our lives, to give ourselves to god and obey the bible. Great role models.

    December 29, 2009 09:54 pm at 9:54 pm |
  11. wag

    Of Course, the whole Palin outfit doesn"t want it made public.
    Wondering what they have to hide, as usual?

    December 29, 2009 09:57 pm at 9:57 pm |
  12. Indy

    This is the right thing as Palin is well known to be unethical and will abuse her celebrity status for an unjust ruling. Levi should have this done in public and it is not his fault that Palin has made it her mission to beome a "Celebrity Without a Cause" and the only fair way to handle this is in public court. It seems rathger weird that the Palins have paraded their kids around like royality and continue to do this on a recent book tour and now feel the spotlight would be bad for Levis son.The Father of this child has rights which ought not to be squashed by a well known celebrity that has been proven guilty of abuse of power while in office and as a very vindictive and mean person. Sarah Palin does not have the right to take the fathers rights away, just because she is used to abusing her power.

    December 29, 2009 09:59 pm at 9:59 pm |
  13. Debbie

    If Bristol was willing to be paraded around in the public campaign pregnant with Johnston's baby out of wedlock then its acceptable as to who will have custody of the child should be public.

    Palin said she and the father would get married...they did not. The child is legitimate as it is, the best they could do and should do is give the child duel custody.

    December 29, 2009 10:06 pm at 10:06 pm |
  14. ThinkAgain

    These two families are quite the train wreck! Can you imagine if they were somehow in the White House?

    YIKES!

    December 29, 2009 10:18 pm at 10:18 pm |
1 2 3