Dems see House GOP struggles in Patriot Act vote
February 9th, 2011
01:26 PM ET
4 years ago

Dems see House GOP struggles in Patriot Act vote

Washington (CNN) – House Democratic leaders got a chance to gloat the morning after Republicans failed on Tuesday to pass a bill extending key provisions of the Patriot Act that are due to expire at the end of the month.

"I think our Republican colleagues are struggling with the burden of leadership and clearly they have not found their footing going forward," said Maryland Democratic Rep Chris Van Hollen.

Republicans seemed to be blindsided Tuesday night on the House floor when they came up seven votes short of passing a bill keeping three current measures used by law enforcement and intelligence officials from expiring at the end of February.

The bill was considered under a House rule requiring two thirds majority for passage and would have extended these provisions through December 8, 2011. Twenty six Republicans opposed the bill, eight of whom are freshmen. Some Republicans like Texas Republican Ron Paul, have previously opposed Patriot Act extensions because of concerns about civil liberties.

One GOP freshman, Rep Raul Labrador, R-Utah, also said concerns about privacy prompted his "no" vote.

"While I agree that law enforcement and national security agencies need the tools necessary to keep America safe from terrorism, when crafting policy we need to be sure we are not infringing upon the protections and freedoms guaranteed in the Constitution," Labrador said in a statement.

But one GOP leadership aide conceded that that many of those Republicans who opposed the measure did so because they felt they were not adequately briefed and were reluctant to support the extension before getting up to speed on the issue. Before Tuesday's vote a Republican Judiciary aide explained that time concerns about the law expiring at the end the month and the need for the Senate to vote on it caused leaders to move ahead with a vote without holding hearings. The extension through early December 2011, according to the aide, would give the committee the rest of the year to educate new members about the need for a longer term extension.

Speaker Boehner admitted that the vote could have been handled better, but blamed House Democrats for failing to support the bill.

"Listen, we've been in the majority four weeks. We are not going to be perfect everyday. If the Democrats who had voted for these same provisions last year had voted for them this year it would have passed," he said. 122 Democrats opposed the bill.

Boehner also declared that the Patriot Act provisions would be renewed. "We are going to get these extensions of the Patriot Act enacted because it is important to the safety and security of the American people."

But when he was pressed on why leaders scheduled the bill in way that mandated a supermajority to pass, Boehner curtly replied, "it was."

GOP leaders were also forced to pull a trade bill from a floor vote on Tuesday because they were concerned it could fail to muster the votes to pass. Ways and Means Committee leaders explained they were still working on the bill.

Democrats, still smarting from a stinging loss in November, wasted no time in rubbing it in that the new GOP leaders couldn't move their agenda forward on the House floor.

"They have the responsibility of governing and it seems right now they are coming apart at the seams," said Democratic Caucus Chair John Larson (D-CT). "From the outside looking in it seems as though they are in disarray."

House Democratic Whip Steny Hoyer (D-MD) said while the failure seemed to surprise party leaders, he maintained it was not a shock to anyone who watched last year's election.

"I think it means that they have divisions within their party," Hoyer said. "I think we all knew they had divisions in their party."


Filed under: Congress
soundoff (32 Responses)
  1. Poser

    When the Patriot Act was first passed I asked my Republican friends and family how they felt about their 4th Amendment rights being trampled upon. They acknowledged it (barely) and did not care. Maybe a few on the GOP side of the isle are finally realizing that to support and defend the Constitution means supporting and defending _all_ of it and not just the 1st and 2nd Amendments.

    February 9, 2011 02:47 pm at 2:47 pm |
  2. Ken

    Good riddance to the Patriot Act. But what were the provisions? CNN shouldn't you be elaborating on this so we know exactly what it is that will not be extended?

    February 9, 2011 02:48 pm at 2:48 pm |
  3. geecee

    What can all this possibly mean?? It could not be that the newly-elected Republicans that voters chose in November 2010 who were going to save our Country and take it back don't know what the h*** is going on and don't understand legislation, could it??

    February 9, 2011 02:50 pm at 2:50 pm |
  4. Me

    Be gracious, Democrats. The very freedoms the Patriot Act is supposed to protect are the very freedoms it, itself, attacks and abuses.

    February 9, 2011 02:51 pm at 2:51 pm |
  5. Joe from CT, not Lieberman

    I want to personally thank those 26 Republicans who remembered the 4th Amendment!

    February 9, 2011 02:56 pm at 2:56 pm |
  6. Mark

    GO CNN! GO! Keep beating up the Republicans so that you can get Obama elected President again!

    February 9, 2011 02:56 pm at 2:56 pm |
  7. Henry Miller, Libertarian

    Quit gloating, Dems, and quit making excuses, GOP!

    Americans are tired of being pushed around by government. It's that simple. The Dems try to cram socialised medicine down our throats and the GOP insists on spying on us and treating us all like criminals and we're tired of it! We're tired of being taxed into penury, we're tired of made-up wars and invented terrorist threats. We're tired of high-speed trains to nowhere and self-righteous would-be theocrats.

    Eighty-something percent of us have little but contempt for Congress or its members. About 40 percent of us think the President is a total screw-up; only about a quarter think he's doing a decent job. Two-thirds think government and business conspire to screw us bottom-of-the-economic-food-chain mere citizens and a similar percent think their own representatives in Congress would sell us out in order to keep their jobs.

    A plague o' both your houses! And your Senates too!

    February 9, 2011 02:59 pm at 2:59 pm |
1 2