Well-choreographed Family Forum boasts several unscripted moments
November 20th, 2011
06:58 AM ET
3 years ago

Well-choreographed Family Forum boasts several unscripted moments

Des Moines, Iowa (CNN) - A gathering of six Republican presidential candidates and some 3,000 conservatives - most of them Christians - was marked as much by politeness and political posturing as by cheers, tears and jeers.

The "Thanksgiving Family Forum" in Des Moines, Iowa, was a friendly yet substantive discussion that centered on faith and family.

But the well-choreographed event could not prevent several unscripted moments: multiple GOP candidates choked with tears; protests from Occupy Wall Street sympathizers; an abrupt end to the conservative harmony after one candidate's political attack against another - and an absent Mitt Romney being accused of "lacking judgment."

The six candidates who attended the event were Michele Bachmann, Rick Perry, Herman Cain, Rick Santorum, Ron Paul and Newt Gingrich. The conservative group The Family Leader sponsored the event along with Focus on the Family affiliate Citizen Link and the National Organization for Marriage.

Conservative pollster Frank Luntz moderated the discussion.

As the event began, a small group of Occupy Des Moines protesters descended on the parking lot of the First Federated Church.

"We are the 99%," they shouted under the watchful eyes of police but within earshot of attendees.

The demonstrators were not allowed to enter but their influence was felt inside.

Moments after the event started, Luntz made an offer that caused some jaws to drop.

"Because there are about 3,000 people here, it is reasonably likely that several people in here are from Occupy Wall Street," Luntz told the crowd. "I want to do something different."

"I would ask that there not be any disruption. But I will make you a deal...if you've come here to protest, take two minutes now, take the time now, and speak to everyone here about what's on your mind."

"In return, allow the rest of us the two hours," Luntz added.

As the surprised crowd waited, a man took to the main floor from his balcony seat. He did not identify himself as an Occupy Wall Street protester. But he did raise an issue regarding the Federal Reserve.

"I think that we need to speak about this bank tonight," he said, claiming that the Fed is "not part of the United States."

Moments later, the event began with the candidates appearing together on stage.

One by one, they spoke about their values, ideas, sense of morality and the proper roles for religion and government in society.

Common themes were criticisms of government intrusion into family lives, an emphasis on individual liberties, a calling out of judicial "activism," and the need for greater economic freedoms.

At one point, Luntz asked the candidates to describe a personal or professional experience that helped shape their faith and spirituality.

"If ever there was a place to bare your soul...this is the place to do it," Luntz said.

One by one the candidates articulated stories rarely heard on the campaign trail with similar candor.

Cain described his diagnosis of stage four cancer. The Georgia businessman stopped multiple times - unable to hold back tears - especially when describing the moment he and his wife left a doctor's office after learning of the diagnosis.

"I will never forget, before my wife and I were about to get in the car, I said, 'I can do this.' She said: 'We can do this,'" Cain said, wiping tears from his eyes.

Other candidates' stories were equally moving.

Perry revealed how "lost" he felt during a period of his youth when he was "too busy for God."

"In every person's heart, in every person's soul, there is a hole that can only be filled by the Lord Jesus Christ," Perry said.

Paul talked about growing up during the Depression, making it through medical school, and "sharing new life" by delivering babies.

Bachmann talked about growing up poor, living through her parents' divorce and her father's leaving the home.

Gingrich talked about the child of a family friend born with a debilitating heart problem.

And Santorum stirred the crowd describing how his youngest daughter, Bella, struggled for life after she was born with the genetic disorder trisomy 18.

"They kept saying to us, 'You realize your child is going to die,'" Santorum said, referring to the girl's doctors. "You have to learn to let go," Santorum said a doctor advised he and his wife.

Choked up with tears, Santorum described how his daughter, now 3-and-a-half years old, survived but still suffers from the disorder.

After the event, one candidate quickly burst the bubble of harmony.

Bachmann's campaign distributed an email titled, "Newt Gingrich has failed to meet a consistently pro-life standard."

The email argued "Gingrich has positioned himself as open to watering down the Republican Party's commitment to the inalienable right to life and failed as the leader of the U.S. House of Representatives to stem the flow of taxpayer dollars to Planned Parenthood, the largest U.S. provider of abortions."

Reporters asked the former House Speaker about the timing of Bachmann's email and its merits.

"I'm not going to comment on emails I haven't read, issued at a point where we're all together here," Gingrich said.

Mitt Romney did not attend the event, instead choosing to hold a campaign event in New Hampshire during the same time.

His absence clearly angered the event's organizer.

Bob Vander Plaats, president and CEO of the Family Leader, also spoke to reporters after the event.

Saying Romney "dissed" Christian conservatives at this and previous similar events, Vander Plaats said: "If Gov. Romney were here, and if he could've displayed half the heart of these candidates around the table, it would've done his candidacy a world of good in Iowa and especially if he became the nominee. However, his choice to skip this event not only hurts him in the caucus process - if he ends up being the nominee, this base has to be inspired to go to work for him. We're still a swing state. And I think that's why he can't move his numbers."

Vander Plaats continued: "He wants to win the presidency. Which tells me he lacks judgment. And if he lacks judgment, I think people all across America have to say, 'Is he the right candidate?'"


Filed under: 2012 • Iowa • Religion
soundoff (10 Responses)
  1. Ziioon!

    Faith is everything!!

    November 20, 2011 07:04 am at 7:04 am |
  2. diridi

    like shipping jobs overseas, looting the nation with wars, eradicating Middle class, taking millions from corporate idiots...ha..

    November 20, 2011 07:28 am at 7:28 am |
  3. hsiabai

    Jefferson and company are rolling over in their graves at this Survivor Island - Christian Edition. Yes, the federal government should stay out of everyone's way - except when it has to do with imposing morality and bullets on the people.

    November 20, 2011 07:29 am at 7:29 am |
  4. diridi

    like shipping jobs overseas, looting the nation with wars, eradicating Middle class, taking millions from corporate idiots...ha.
    bribe from Freddie Mac of 2.8 million by Newt....ha...

    November 20, 2011 07:45 am at 7:45 am |
  5. Beth

    >Vander Plaats continued: "He (Romney) wants to win the presidency. Which tells me he lacks judgment. " (for not attending the event)

    Its funny because when I heard Romney chose not to attend this right-wing nut job event, I thought it demonstrated GREAT judgement. To win the presidency you have to appeal to the majority of voters in the US, and the majority of voters do not support this uber pro-life approach. Heck even Mississippi recently chose not to endorce the "life begins at conception" measure, and thats one of the most pro-life states in the nation.

    November 20, 2011 07:50 am at 7:50 am |
  6. ajax

    I saw what Ron Paul had to say for once without being interupted by a rude moderator that doesn't even care to listen to the man's response. It is worth a look on youtube search iowa family forum.

    November 20, 2011 07:52 am at 7:52 am |
  7. jboh

    Any more doubt that TEA? wants to make America a talibangelical theocracy.

    November 20, 2011 08:04 am at 8:04 am |
  8. beevee

    Among all these buffoons of GOP Romney and Huntsmen are the only one who merit consideration to be president representing the Republican party. The rest are trying to gain sympathy of the voters telling sob stories. That is pathetic.

    November 20, 2011 08:21 am at 8:21 am |
  9. Clwyd

    What a bunch of loony tunes. Even talking about being unfaithful! I cried too! Out of disgust as to the low level my former party has gone since the Goldwater era!

    November 20, 2011 08:33 am at 8:33 am |
  10. cigarman

    This forum is a joke, right? Every one up there claims to be christians, what a joke. Gingrich, one of the most unethical people on earth. Bachman, pray away the gay, deer in the headkights Santorum, touchy feely Cain, slick Rick,who believes Americans should pay for Illegals education, the old man who is a doctor and declares LETUM DIE, I dont want to be associated with any of these so called christians or the christian faith if this is what is represented. Mitt Romney is the best of the worst, although he doesnt stand a chance of being elected President. Remember, Separation of church and State. If any of these idiots get in they will try to make the United States like the arab countries,and have religious wars. Remember, Religion is the Root of all killings and hatred, and wars. If any of these people are running on there faith, they should be run out of town.

    November 20, 2011 08:53 am at 8:53 am |