Lugar's tax day attack
April 17th, 2012
11:36 AM ET
2 years ago

Lugar's tax day attack

(CNN) – Indiana Sen. Dick Lugar's campaign used Tax Day to release a negative ad reminding voters of a big tax error made by his GOP rival and state treasurer Richard Mourdock.

The 30-second TV spot, titled "Trust," questioned Mourdock's integrity by claiming the candidate received "$45,000 in illegal second homestead tax deductions" from 2008-2010.

– Follow the Ticker on Twitter: @PoliticalTicker

"Richard Mourdock: the more you know him, the less you trust him," the ad's narrator said.

The commercial also argued Mourdock "conveniently decided" to pay back the taxes once he decided to run for the Senate seat (although the word "candidate" was spelled incorrectly in the ad).

“Homestead fraud causes taxpayers who follow the law to pay more money to support local police and fire protection among other local services,” Lugar spokesman Andy Fisher said in a statement. “Voters have the right to question if the state treasurer didn’t care, was incompetent or a tax cheat.”

The two candidates are locked in a tight race ahead of the May 8 GOP primary, as Mourdock, with a heavy tea party backing, and other conservative groups attempt to oust Lugar from his six-term reign in the Senate.

News of the tax error made headlines last year, when Mourdock said he attempted to solve the problem earlier but his paperwork had been lost by the state. On Friday, campaign spokesman Christopher Conner provided documents showing the Marion County Auditor's Office had in fact taken responsibility for not removing the error when requested by Mourdock.

"Sensing that they are losing this race, Senator Lugar is now personally attacking Treasurer Mourdock with false claims," Conner said. "It is ironic that Lugar, who hasn't owned a home in Indiana since 1977, wants to discuss personal property issues."

Lugar opponents have tried to discredit the senator's re-election eligibility by highlighting the fact he hasn't lived in the state since he started working in the Senate 35 years ago. The Indiana Election Division, however, ruled in February that Lugar's situation was legal due to a loophole in the state's election law that states someone does not need to maintain residency in the state while serving in its capacity.

As for the homestead tax deduction, Mourdock addressed the issue in the summer of 2011. The candidate told local TV station WTHR that he had already paid "all the back taxes in excess of what they normally collect in this situation," adding that he was not trying to hide anything.

"The reality is I ran for re-election last year as state treasurer. If I had known before that election I would have gone in, I mean, if you want to take that line of thinking that I was trying to hide the fact, believe me it would have been just as damaging to me politically last year as this year," he said. "I fixed it at the first opportunity the exact day I found out about the problem. If I had found out about it in 2008, 2009 or 2010 I would have dealt with it the same day."

Also see:

House election committees add millions to coffers

Romney ready for November fight: 'It’s going to be fun'

Romney says he wouldn't transport dog on roof again


Filed under: 2012 • Indiana • Richard Lugar • Senate
soundoff (7 Responses)
  1. Rudy NYC

    Never thought I would be cheering for Dick Lugar to win an election contest, but here I am. Sic 'em. Dick.

    April 17, 2012 11:45 am at 11:45 am |
  2. Al-NY,NY

    the Brownshirts of the new Purity Party will make sure Lugar is replaced by a good "loyal party member" aka the new NSDAP (look it up)

    April 17, 2012 11:53 am at 11:53 am |
  3. SUBS 4 VOTES

    I'm no republican by far, but I respect Sen. Lugar. He's the last of a dying breed of moderates. It's pretty shameful to be treasurer and defraud the government. He should be in a orange jumpsuit, not running for office.

    April 17, 2012 12:05 pm at 12:05 pm |
  4. Fair is Fair

    "Never thought I would be cheering for Dick Lugar to win an election contest, but here I am."
    -------
    Can't understand why you wouldn't... I mean, after all, you're an "independent", and Lugar is a moderate. It would seem to me that you're made for each other.

    April 17, 2012 12:05 pm at 12:05 pm |
  5. Honest Abe

    Well, golly. Lugar has a lot to talk about... NOT! Mourdock and his wife bought a 2nd house in Indy area, his Treasure job was there. There was some confusion, so what. It was corrected and paid in FULL just as soon as possible. I think Lugar is getting desperate..... Since LUGAR IS A NOT RESIDENT! LUGAR PAYS NO HOUSE TAXES

    LUGAR PAYS NO HOUSE TAXES IN INDIDNA. He pays Virgina.

    Time to get rid of Lugar, he would be an 80 year old lame duck if elected.

    .

    April 17, 2012 12:08 pm at 12:08 pm |
  6. judy

    Obama 2012 get rid of all the republicans Move forward.

    April 17, 2012 12:12 pm at 12:12 pm |
  7. Rudy NYC

    The candidate told local TV station WTHR that he had already paid "all the back taxes in excess of what they normally collect in this situation," adding that he was not trying to hide anything.

    "I fixed it at the first opportunity the exact day I found out about the problem. If I had found out about it in 2008, 2009 or 2010 I would have dealt with it the same day."
    --------------
    When a Republican pays more in taxes than what was originally due, that not largesse. That's called a fine.

    Okay, Some clerical, correctable error was made in those years. But, why was the identical error made from year to year? How is it that was down properly in all of those previous years, but suddenly it is consistently down incorrectly? I have a saying about luck, good or bad. "Consistent luck isn't called being lucky. It's called skill."

    April 17, 2012 12:52 pm at 12:52 pm |