Carnegie, Pennsylvania (CNN) – Paul Ryan revisited some of President Barack Obama's most controversial comments from the 2008 campaign to rally a crowd behind the Republican ticket Tuesday.
"You know, every now and then President Obama sort of drops his veil. He's less coy about his philosophy. He sort of reveals his true governing policy, what he really believes," Ryan said at a steel factory near Pittsburgh.
– Follow the Ticker on Twitter: @PoliticalTicker
– Follow Shawna Shepherd on Twitter: @ShepherdCNN
The new vice presidential candidate brought up unscripted moments from 2008 that dogged Obama's first presidential run.
"Remember this other time where he was caught on video saying, 'People like to cling to their guns and their religion,'" said Paul, referring to a comment Obama made during a San Francisco fund-raiser in April 2008. The remark was quickly jumped on by Republicans as an example of Obama being derisive toward conservative voters.
"Hey, I'm a Catholic deer-hunter. I am happy to be clinging to my guns and my religion," he said.
The seven-term congressman and House Budget Committee chairman from Wisconsin, who joined the ticket on August 11, reminded his audience of another time when Obama was confronted by a man in Ohio who became known as Joe the Plumber.
"Remember back in 2008, remember the guy Joe the Plumber? Remember when he said, you know, 'We wanna spread the wealth around.' It's this belief that the economy is some fixed pie, that there's only just so much money in America, it's fixed, and that the job of the government is to redistribute the slices of the pie."
Paul continued, "That's not true. The job of the government is to set the conditions for economic growth so we can grow the pie and everybody can get a bigger slice of the American pie through economic growth, through opportunity, through achievement, upward mobility. That's where prosperity comes from."
The old anecdotes fed into a larger narrative about the economy that the Romney-Ryan team has been trying to drive home for months. The campaign continues to take out of context a comment Obama made in Roanoke about business.
Their message was reinforced by the backdrop at Beaver Steel with the words "We did build it!" displayed behind Ryan on a flat-bed truck.
"Or how about the latest doozy in Roanoke, VA? Tony and Tony, father and son, we're here in your business. You have 50 employees in your business. You created jobs. You worked hard. You sacrificed. You rolled up your sleeves, you took risks. You had good days, you had bad days. Tony, you built this business. The government didn't build it for you. It's your business, your achievement, and we all benefit from that. That's what this country is built upon. You see, it's this belief that we need a government-centered society driven by a government-driven economy. It doesn't work," he said.
Danny Kanner, an Obama campaign spokesperson, said in response to Ryan's Tuesday event, "In Pennsylvania today, Paul Ryan chose to launch recycled attacks rather than debate the devastating impact that the Romney-Ryan agenda would have on middle class families. But that makes sense – their plan includes middle class tax increases, turning Medicare into a voucher program, and slashing critical investments in education, all to pay for massive tax cuts for millionaires and billionaires.
"It's an agenda Romney's own advisers have said would be suicidal for their campaign to discuss, which is why Mitt Romney and Paul Ryan have completely abandoned the 'substantive' campaign they promised to run," Kanner continued.
Ryan bounded on stage waving a Pittsburgh Steelers Terrible Towel and he let it hang from his back pocket throughout the entire rally.
– Check out the CNN Electoral Map and Calculator and game out your own strategy for November.
Ryan voted for the $700 billion bank bailout, the auto bailout, Bush's wars, Bush tax cuts, the biggest Medicare expansion in U.S. history, a massive highway bill that included the “Bridge to Nowhere.” Enough said.
YOU DID VOTE ON THAT!!!
"The government didn't build it for you. It's your business, your achievement, and we all benefit from that."
Did Tony build the road that leads to his business??? That was the President's point. R&R taking the President's comments out of context oonce more. PATHETIC!!!
This dude is so pathetic idiot.
Paul does not understand the role of government. Since he is a disciple of Ayn Rand, he know relatively little of the works of a democracy.
"Hey, I'm a Catholic deer-hunter. I am happy to be clinging to my guns and my religion,"
You're a Catholic pathological liar!! I'm sure you've molested a boy or two in your day.
The Romney/Ryan "Pants on Fire" campaign continues.
Ryan is going to end up with higher negatives than positives.
Ryan is talking about creating jobs Oblunders response always the same it was taken out of blah, blah, blah, I cant wait for the debates put up or shut up time. 3 to 1 Biden doesnt show!!!!
Niall Ferguson: Obama’s Gotta Go
Aug 19, 2012 1:00 AM EDT
Why does Paul Ryan scare the president so much? Because Obama has broken his promises, and it’s clear that the GOP ticket’s path to prosperity is our only hope.
Obama is the Manchurian candidate. Nobody knows who he truly is. His books are lies. He hides his past.
Paula Rand said "You know, every now and then President Obama sort of drops his veil. He's less coy about his philosophy. He sort of reveals his true governing policy, what he really believes"
Careful, Paula. You seem to be developing that GOP disease called projection. As in your lies on medicare and your hypocritical pushing Akin out. Might as well drop the veil, trixie, because we're getting a better look at your policies and they don't pass the smell test. Your unfavorables will be hitting Willard territory in a very short matter of time. Looking forward to the end of your stint in politics going down with the sinking Romney campaign.
Just wonder why Paula didn't hold this lie-fest at GS Steel....oops, nevermind.
Ryan got riching buillding "that" because the government ordered it. She's pathetic.
You know, it's extremely funny that the "IT" in their stupid little backdrop sign is italicized like that in order to make it stand out from the rest of the words, because that "IT" and what it refers to is precisely what Mittens and Lapdog are lying about:
When Obama said it, he was referring to business-owners not having built the infrastructure that made their business possible. Obama wasn't saying that you didn't build your business. "IT" does not refer to your business. "IT," in the context of what Obama said and in terms of his intent in saying it, refers to the country's infrastructure...the roads, bridge, railways, airways, economic laws, education system, etc. Mittens and Lapdog are running their entire campaign...100% of it...on the basis of straw man arguments.
R&R broke Wisconsin state law earlier this year when they were handing out sandwiches in exchange for votes. IOKIYAR
"Obama is the Manchurian candidate. Nobody knows who he truly is. His books are lies. He hides his past."
You're going to have to do better than that if you really want to scare everyone. Maybe remind us that he's brown too?
Like the POTUS said: You Can't Just Make Stuff Up! Soon the GOP will understand...
Knowone here but a bunch of libtards. Move on...
The two qualities for VP in the pube party, is being catholic and a deer hunter. That is quite a glowing resume, Paul.
If you win Ryan stay the hell out of California you backwards moron.
was romney checking out this companies bank account-health care and pension funds-for future bain investment
bb – Biden will show, and he'll mop the floor with Ryan. Biden has more political knowledge and instincts in his pinkie finger than Ryan has in his whole body. It will be fun watching Ryan trying to explain all those budget busting votes he made during the Bush years. And watch him run and hide when the subject of abortion comes up........after the Akin thing, he is quickly adjusting his thoughts about exceptions. He will come across as a complete phony.
Right..............Ryan.....................keep in mind your understanding of the 'role of government' is def NOT mine. So whatever and STOP trying to make me live your stupid pipe dream.
OBAMA HAS PREVIOUSLY SAID OTHER THINGS WHICH BOLSTER THE COMMENT "YOU DIDN'T BUILD THAT".
IN 2008, HE SAID "SPREAD THE WEALTH AROUND".
OBAMA CLEARLY IS A SOCIALIST WHICH DOESN'T MAKE HIM A BAD PERSON BUT HIS POLICIES ARE NOT WHAT THE VAST MAJORITY OF AMERICANS WANT FOR OUR FUTURE .
My dad was an enterpreneur and worked so hard building his business. We also pay for the roads surrounding his business with "our" tax dollars. If my dad was around, he would not appreciate Mr. Obama's comments.
bb, the path the prosperity is the Bush plan, period. Look where that got us last time. I for one don't want to go back to that – we're still trying to recover from the Republican's last attempt at "fixing" things.
What's really pathetic is how those without a legitimate argument typically resort to name-calling and simpley talking louder while repeating their lies, as if that makes things more true. RMoney & RyAyn are repeating lies at every campaign stop – stuff that ALL researchers and fact-checkers have mark "pants on fire" for their sheer BS. Want to check out some of these doozies?
PROMISES MADE AND BROKEN: http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/promises/gop-pledge-o-meter/
WELFARE: Romney’s ad says, "Under Obama’s plan (for welfare), you wouldn’t have to work and wouldn’t have to train for a job. They just send you your welfare check."
That's a drastic distortion of the planned changes to Temporary Assistance to Needy Families. By granting waivers to states, the Obama administration is seeking to make welfare-to-work efforts more successful, not end them. What’s more, the waivers would apply to individually evaluated pilot programs - HHS is not proposing a blanket, national change to welfare law.
The ad tries to connect the dots to reach this zinger: "They just send you your welfare check." The HHS memo in no way advocates that practice. In fact, it says the new policy is "designed to improve employment outcomes for needy families."
The ad’s claim is not accurate, and it inflames old resentments about able-bodied adults sitting around collecting public assistance. Pants on Fire!
RMoney on the free market: "We're only inches away from no longer being a free economy." BS! http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2012/jan/08/mitt-romney/mitt-romney-once-again-says-us-inches-away-no-long/
It’s true that the government’s footprint on spending has grown over the past few years, due in large part to the recession. But while the statistics show that the government continues to have a large influence on the economy, there is little indication that the government’s role has risen dramatically enough over the past few years to threaten the kind of free market that the U.S. has operated under in recent decades. And international comparisons show that the U.S. ranks low in both total tax burden and high in economic freedom - at least as measured by a prominent conservative think tank. Last June and August, we found this claim to merit a Pants on Fire. Nothing has changed our view. We rate Romney's statement Pants on Fire.
I could go on, but won't... how hard is it to find the truth? Not very... but you have to WANT to FIND it.