December 16th, 2007
06:06 AM ET
12 years ago

Key newspaper nods go to McCain, Obama, Clinton

Sen. John McCain campaigning in Dover, New Hampshire.

(CNN) - The editorial boards of the Des Moines Register and the Boston Globe - two of the most influential papers for voters in Iowa and New Hampshire, the first two states to weigh in at the polls - both gave their endorsement to John McCain in the Republican presidential race, but parted ways over their choice in the Democratic contest.

The Register backed Hillary Clinton, while the Globe picked Barack Obama, in excerpts of Sunday's editorials posted on their papers' Web sites Saturday night. The Iowa caucuses are January 3, and New Hampshire's primary follows five days later.

The Globe's board dismissed concerns over the Illinois senator’s relative lack of Washington experience. "It is true that all the other Democratic contenders have more conventional resumes, and have spent more time in Washington," the board wrote. "But that exposure has tended to give them a sense of government’s constraints. Obama is more open to its possibilities."

But the Register's board, which noted that Obama "demonstrates the potential to be a fine president," still gave the edge to the New York senator, saying it made the nods in both parties' primaries based on competence and readiness to lead.

“When Obama speaks before a crowd, he can be more inspirational than Clinton," the board wrote. "Yet, with his relative inexperience, it’s hard to feel as confident he could accomplish the daunting agenda that lies ahead.”

The Iowa paper's endorsement is widely viewed as a major boost for Clinton, and a blow to the campaign of former North Carolina Sen. John Edwards, whose Register endorsement during the 2004 race was followed by a surprisingly strong showing in the state's Democratic caucuses.

Obama spokesman Robert Gibbs told CNN's Mike Roselli Saturday that the campaign was “not surprised" by the Register’s decision, adding "that it was a bigger surprise to get the Globe’s," and noting that the Des Moines paper "said good things about us.”

Later, Obama told CNN's Roselli, "I think we are doing pretty good. We split it today between the Globe and the Register."

The Clinton campaign immediately sent out a news release containing the full text of the paper's endorsement which took Edwards to task for recent campaign trail rhetoric, writing that "We too seldom saw the 'positive, optimistic' campaign we found appealing in 2004."

"Obama, her chief rival, inspired our imaginations," the Register board wrote. "But it was Clinton who inspired our confidence."

Edwards spokesman Dan Leistikow told CNN's Rebecca Sinderbrand that the candidate had "great respect for the Register, but has a different view." He added that Edwards "remains as optimistic about America and the future as he’s ever been. He’s also more seasoned, he has more ideas, and he's ready to take on the entrenched special interests and fight for average Americans."

Clinton spokesman Mark Daley told CNN's Suzanne Malveaux that "We are incredibly pleased and honored, but we know we have a few weeks left to go before the caucuses and a lot of work to do," adding that after Clinton's Thursday debate performance, her Friday endorsement by Iowa's Democratic Rep. Leonard Boswell, and Saturday's Register nod, "we feel good about our campaign heading into the final weeks."

The three Democrats are battling for the lead in Iowa, placing within just a few points of each other in most recent state polls.

On the Republican side, the Register's board wrote the endorsement went to the Arizona senator because “Time after time, McCain has stuck to his beliefs in the face of opposition from other elected leaders and the public.

“The force of John McCain’s moral authority could go a long way toward restoring Americans’ trust in government and inspiring new generations to believe in the goodness and greatness of America,” they wrote.

Meanwhile, the Globe's board passed over former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, saying that McCain’s views might differ from theirs, his “honesty has served him well…" the board wrote. "As a lawmaker and as a candidate, he has done more than his share to transcend partisanship and promote an honest discussion of the problems facing the United States.”

In 2004, the board stuck with the native son on the ballot, giving the nod in New Hampshire's Democratic primary to Massachusetts Sen. John Kerry, who went on to win that race.

The Boston Globe’s endorsements are influential in neighboring New Hampshire, especially the southern part of the state, where many residents make the daily weekday commute to work in Boston. And the endorsement weighs even greater with Democratic voters there, since the state's main newspaper, the New Hampshire Union Leader, has a conservative editorial board and only makes one primary endorsement, which is almost always a Republican.

McCain’s Globe endorsement follows a recent nod from the New Hampshire Union Leader. Political pundits nearly left McCain for dead this summer, after his campaign nearly ran out of cash and hemorrhaged staff, and the candidate sank in the polls. Now the senator is second place, or tied for second, in the most recent Granite State polls.

McCain won New Hampshire's Republican primary during his 2000 presidential run.

–CNN's Rebecca Sinderbrand and Paul Steinhauser

soundoff (79 Responses)
  1. Lily

    Obama rocks! Hillary never answers any of the questions full on, but Obama will lead our country! Hillary will say anything to get peoples votes.

    February 1, 2008 10:59 am at 10:59 am |
  2. Cindy

    I was listening to the Democractic debate again on Sunday evening Feb 03. Every time I hear Barack Obama say the war was a mistake I want to scream. That is the worst insult to the families of those who have lost their lives and who are putting their lives on the line everday in the Iraq war. Can you imagine how you would feel hearing that your loved one died because of a mistake. Those who have the couage to go to the front lines deserve only praise. I understand that the time has come to make some changes but please Barack Obama do not suggest that the war was just a mistake. That is just WRONG. The real heroes are the ones who take risks to make our world better, not the politicians who strut around in the comfort and security of their boardrooms forgetting that hindsight is always 2020. President Hillary. Sounds good to me!

    February 3, 2008 10:13 pm at 10:13 pm |
  3. Pamela/ florida

    America wants CHANGE! Then why are the Republicians running? Quote(Birds of a feather, flock together) another republician will be another Bush, just a different face.And the childess bicking in debates only shows the republicians will fight with the rest of the world leaders. Our country needs Help not inmature men.
    Hillary has already been in the house, and knows how it works. And to her advange, she is a strong woman and we all know what women can do-MULTITASKING- on a daily basics. So, maybe we can get something done in the next 4 yrs. We have seen what men can do, maybe its time to put a woman in office. Her track record should speak for its self. Hillary, I believe will turn this country around and restore some true teamwork in our goverment. That will only result in a stronger, richer, and healthier America. key word MULTITASKING. getting more than 1 thing done.
    Obama may be concidered in the future, with more experience and knowledge of our laws, Rewarding law breakers with drivers licsences, what is Obama thinking,? just about the votes. illegal aliens broke our laws. They get our tax dollars for health care, what about Americans FIRST for health care and the rest stand in line to be citizens.

    February 5, 2008 04:07 pm at 4:07 pm |
  4. rbracher

    I don`t understand why no one is talking about JOHN McCAIN`S crocked dealings with the savings and loan scandels as A MEMBER OF THE kEATING FIVE ALONG WITH JOHN GLEN.This man says he is so experance because he has been A member of congress 23 years or so,then why didn`t he see it comming sence it is almost the same exact thing that happened with the failed S & L`s that he was Apart OF.
    .IM TALKING ABOUT THE MORTGAGE CRISES WERE HAVING NOW.Asmuch as I HATE Bush I would rather see him stay in the white house then this paid for crock get in there.HE WAS BROKE AND NOW HE HAS ALL THIS MONEY TO SPEND,HES JUST LIKE bush hes being bought.

    February 5, 2008 10:16 pm at 10:16 pm |
1 2 3 4