Democrats eager to talk of government shutdown
February 3rd, 2011
03:02 PM ET
9 years ago

Democrats eager to talk of government shutdown


Washington (CNN) - Senate Democratic leaders held a news conference Thursday to warn about the dangers of a Republican-forced government shutdown.

But as one reporter aptly noted to the leaders, it is the Democrats talking most about shutting down the government.

The reason for the Democratic talking point is politically obvious. Republicans were punished by voters when they controlled Congress in 1995 and a spending fight with a Democratic president led to a government shutdown.

And Democrats are about to enter their first intense struggle with newly empowered Republicans over spending cuts – the issue the GOP believes it was elected to address.

A so-called continuing resolution that passed late last year to keep the government running expires on March 4, and GOP leaders have made clear they want to begin to slash spending then.

Sen. Chuck Schumer, D-New York, accused Republicans of "playing with fire" and making "the same exact mistake Newt Gingrich made years ago."

"Every week they keep upping the ante and proposing extreme cuts, and then they say if you don't do it our way we're going to shut the government down and hurt millions and millions of innocent people and at the same time, risk the credit rating of the United States," said Schumer.

The reality is that GOP leaders have in fact been careful not to take shutting the government down off the table, but none has said what Schumer and other leaders allege, that they are "going to shut the government down."

Still, Democratic senator after Democratic senator stood at the microphones and warned in dire terms of the catastrophic consequences of a government shutdown.

"When the government shut down last time, more than 400,000 veterans saw their pensions and disability claims delayed," said Sen. Patty Murray, D-Washington.

"Just at the time when we have a crisis in Egypt and tension in the Middle East, in Lebanon and other places, just at a time when our troops are on the ground in Afghanistan and Iraq and other places, a government shutdown, if anything, as it relates to our national security, would be a benefit to our enemies," raised Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pennsylvania.

Democrats insisted that even the notion of a potential government shutdown over a spending fight will rattle an already fragile economy.

A spokesman for Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell dismissed the news conference, led in part by Schumer, as a political stunt.

"It is our hope that he [Schumer] soon realizes the only person talking about a shutdown is Senator Schumer. Most Americans and even many in his own party have come to realize that the gravity of our current fiscal problems calls for constructive dialogue that will lead to serious cuts in spending and debt. That's what Republicans are focused on. We hope Senator Schumer joins that bipartisan effort so," said Don Stewart, spokesman for McConnell.

So, is there middle ground on the issue of spending cuts?

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid said Democrats realize there has to be some "long-term austerity here in the United States...we're not burying our heads on the sand, we realize we're going to have to do some things, but we're not willing to play Russian roulette."

But after the news conference ended and senators put away their talking points, Dick Durbin, the No. 2 Democrat in the Senate, admitted to reporters that Democrats do have to face the fact that spending cuts will be necessary.

"I think we're going to end this year with some spending cuts. Let's do it in a sensible fashion so we don't kill the recovery and we don't stop the basic services of government," said Durbin.

Filed under: Congress • Democrats
soundoff (28 Responses)
  1. DAVE

    the budget is not that hard to figure out. #1 raise taxes on the rich back to the level in the good old days of the 1990s. #2 take the cap of social sucerity so everyone pays the same 6% in taxes with now means testing in place (if you pay in you get something out no matter how much money you make. drop all tax breaks for the energy companies who have failed to try new sources of energy. change our health care to a single payer system so i can buy american made drugs here at home instead of buying american made drugs much cheaper in canada. in canada drug companies have to quote the lowest price to the buyer ( the goverment) thats the capitalist way. end both wars and bring everybody home. those wars have cost us our federal buget problems because the cost is almost $4trillion dollars right now. start minding our own business in world affairs. take care of us first like all other countries do at our exspense. job done!

    February 3, 2011 04:27 pm at 4:27 pm |
  2. SDvoter

    "I think we're going to end this year with some spending cuts. Let's do it in a sensible fashion so we don't kill the recovery and we don't stop the basic services of government," said Durbin

    This is a starting point. If both parties will work together, progress will take place.

    February 3, 2011 04:33 pm at 4:33 pm |
  3. New Age Independant

    It sounds more like Democrats are threatening the people rather than trying to find ways to get government spending under control. If they would put as much effort into working toward a solution as they do trying to bash Republicans, the possibility of a shutdown would never be a topic.

    February 3, 2011 04:33 pm at 4:33 pm |
1 2